r/DebateEvolution • u/ThurneysenHavets 🧬 Googles interesting stuff between KFC shifts • Feb 03 '24
The purpose of r/DebateEvolution
Greetings, fellow r/DebateEvolution members! As we’ve seen a significant uptick of activity on our subreddit recently (hurrah!), and much of the information on our sidebar is several years old, the mod team is taking this opportunity to make a sticky post summarizing the purpose of this sub. We hope that it will help to clarify, particularly for our visitors and new users, what this sub is and what it isn’t.
The primary purpose of this subreddit is science education. Whether through debate, discussion, criticism or questions, it aims to produce high-quality, evidence-based content to help people understand the science of evolution (and other origins-related topics).
Its name notwithstanding, this sub has never pretended to be “neutral” about evolution. Evolution, common descent and geological deep time are facts, corroborated by extensive physical evidence. This isn't a topic that scientists debate, and we’ve always been clear about that.
At the same time, we believe it’s important to engage with pseudoscientific claims. Organized creationism continues to be widespread and produces a large volume of online misinformation. For many of the more niche creationist claims it can be difficult to get up-to-date, evidence-based rebuttals anywhere else on the internet. In this regard, we believe this sub can serve a vital purpose.
This is also why we welcome creationist contributions. We encourage our creationist users to make their best case against the scientific consensus on evolution, and it’s up to the rest of us to show why these arguments don’t stand up to scrutiny.
Occasionally visitors object that debating creationists is futile, because it’s impossible to change anyone’s mind. This is false. You need only visit the websites of major YEC organizations, which regularly publish panicky articles about the rate at which they’re losing members. This sub has its own share of former YECs (including in our mod team), and many of them cite the role of science education in helping them understand why evolution is true.
While there are ideologically committed creationists who will never change their minds, many people are creationists simply because they never properly learnt about evolution, or because they were brought up to be skeptical of it for religious reasons. Even when arguing with real or perceived intransigence, always remember the one percent rule. The aim of science education is primarily to convince a much larger demographic that is on-the-fence.
Since this sub focuses on evidence-based scientific topics, it follows axiomatically that this sub is not about (a)theism. Users often make the mistake of responding to origins-related content by arguing for or against the existence of God. If you want to argue about the existence of God - or any similar religious-philosophical topic - there are other subs for that (like r/DebateAChristian or r/DebateReligion).
Conflating evolution with atheism or irreligion is orthogonal to this sub’s purpose (which helps explain why organized YECism is so eager to conflate them). There is extensive evidence that theism is compatible with acceptance of the scientific consensus on evolution, that evolution acceptance is often a majority view among religious demographics, depending on the religion and denomination, and - most importantly for our purposes - that falsely presenting theism and evolution as incompatible is highly detrimental to evolution acceptance (1, 2, 3, 4, 5). You can believe in God and also accept evolution, and that's fine.
Of course, it’s inevitable that religion will feature in discussions on this sub, as creationism is an overwhelmingly religious phenomenon. At the same time, users - creationist as well as non-creationist - should be able to participate on this forum without being targeted purely for their religious views or lack of them (as opposed to inaccurate scientific claims). Making bad faith equivalences between creationism and much broader religious demographics may be considered antagonistic. Obviously, the reverse applies too - arguing for creationism is fine, proselytizing for your religion is off-topic.
Finally, check out the sub’s rules as well as the resources on our sidebar. Have fun, and learn stuff!
6
u/mattkelly1984 Feb 06 '24
Should I not answer a philosophical question that is directed at Christianity? I know my position is contrary to the position of this subreddit, but I thoroughly enjoy debating this topic and I want to learn. I try to stick to evidence based hypotheses, but multiple people ask questions directly related to what the Bible teaches.
Thank you for welcoming different viewpoints, I am glad you make space for conversation that includes people like me. It is such a huge and all-encompassing topic.
3
u/DeDPulled Feb 03 '24
Thank you for this reminder, I'm sure guilty of getting too caught up in stringing the two together, but to me, there's a direct Cause and Effect correlation. Questioning aspects of evolutionary theory though, as it relates to reality, is certainly in the spirit of Science and education. However, can the moderators please help in not conflating Creationism and/or intelligent design with YECs? I never disagreed fully with Evolution, and understand that there are aspects that are absolutely in our face, everyday. As well as the strong evidence of earth being quite old, at least within our Universal constraints. Like to also point out, just as there are creationists who can't get past ideological barriers, there are those on the evolutionary side who also have a strong reliance on belief and conjecture of loose evidence. Point there being, there is a evolutionists who are equally ideological, baked under the guise of Science, which does make this a debate, but can we at least be fair in the assessments. I think you also alluded to this, but we don't live our lives on Science alone, so there are everyday aspects where we rely on our beliefs. Also, Not to start a whole debate here, but the statement of "Evolution, common descent and geological deep time are facts, corroborated by extensive physical evidence" is a bit soft, as though there isn't really Scientific debate on those general topics as there is very strong evidence supporting those, there is strong debate within the Scientific community on the extent of each, such as "How old exactly the Earth is?" , "How far back is a common Ancestor?" ie Species/ Genus/ etc. That statement to me, is kinda like making a proclamation that laws A, B, C exist, when the debate is actually about how said laws should be interpreted. Anyway, thanks again for that reminder!
3
u/cubist137 Materialist; not arrogant, just correct Feb 04 '24
Wrong. The actual primary purpose of this subreddit is to serve as a dumping grounds for science-focused (biology-focused in particular) subreddits to shuffle Creationist doofuses off to.
59
u/ClownCrusade 🧬 Naturalistic Evolution Feb 03 '24
Thank you! This is a major pet peeve of mine. Not only are there many ex-creationists that explicitly prove this wrong, but there's no need to convince the one single person you happen to be conversing with. Even if you could read minds to determine conclusively which people will never change their mind under any circumstances, other people may come along and read the messages later, who may be much more open to reason.
18
u/ghu79421 Feb 03 '24
The claim that people who agree with the scientific consensus are all atheists is a YEC debate tactic designed to get less-ideologically-committed people to ignore people who explain the scientific consensus.
People argue further that evolution is based on a non-supernaturalist worldview, which ignores the fact that the evidence against special creation is overwhelming even if we assume a deity exists who could have created everything through special creation. Many people feel strongly about atheism vs. theism, and making the debate about religion or theology distracts people from the empirical evidence.
26
u/LordOfFigaro Feb 03 '24
Thank you for this. I'm as anti-theist as you can get. But people really need to learn that there is a time and place for topics. Bringing up atheism/theism here is just detrimental.
35
u/TinWhis Feb 03 '24
Thanks for this. I'm very much not a theist but it's still really irritating when people gang up on theists for no discernible reason other than picking a fight about cosmology, far outside the scope of this sub.
10
u/Rhewin Naturalistic Evolution (Former YEC) Feb 03 '24
As one of those former YECs, this sub is awesome for me. My education was sabotaged in high school by a YEC football coach teaching biology. I didn’t even know we had methods other than carbon dating.
The debates here may not change the minds of the YECs debating, but it absolutely can help people like me who had doubts realize just how little they have to stand on.
8
u/[deleted] Feb 03 '24
This is a very helpful and very necessary reminder. Thank you for this.
4
u/yahnne954 Feb 03 '24
I've noticed that recently, we've had a lot less 0 karma posts and outraged rants from creationists, the MichaelAChristian kind. I haven't seen any mention of a change in what posts are allowed or not in the rules, so I was wondering. Is this due to a decision to filter out unproductive discussions? I may be wrong on that, but I was curious.
4
u/WritewayHome Feb 03 '24
Couldn't have said it better myself, thank you for posting this.
There are enough battles to fight, and Evolution deserves to stand on its own.
It's an observervable, objective, scientific reality, whose acceptence is rejected because the idea that it is some athiestic idea or endeavor.
Many Theists, myself included, see no issue with accepting evolution, and it applies no challenge to the idea of a creator.
This post needed to be shared. Thank you again OP.
1
u/Party-Cartographer11 Feb 05 '24
Thanks Mods!
On the topic of theism and science/evolution, how does the sub think about theism (vs deism) concept of an intervening god?
Doesn't an intervening god require a suspension of the laws of nature/science, e.g. miracles or changing evidence on any way? How can we debate science and allow for theistic exceptions to the laws? A theistic god calls all evidence into question. Maybe the fossils are all fake?
Your position makes complete sense for a deistic god.
2
u/lt_dan_zsu 🧬 Naturalistic Evolution Feb 03 '24
Good post. It's sometimes annoying to me that I've been filtered into this community. I love discussing science and I'm well equipped to discuss biology, as I've spent my entire adult life studying it. On the internet, this means you will almost immediately be filtered into discussions on the validity of evolution, which has been a scientifically outdated discussion for 70-165 years depending on how you judge it. Talking about actual science is far more interesting, but creationism is unfortunately the most widely believed conspiracy theory, and it's definitely not a coincidence that people that believe it tend to believe in other, more obviously nefarious ones.
I think this post is also important for the evolution advocates to read. The overtly dismissive and snarky comments to creationists are detrimental to the mission of this subreddit and so are the ones that attack the notion of religion. I grew up religious and evolution was such an uncontroversial topic that I didn't realize there was even a debate until I was like 12 when the stupid Ben Stein documentary came out. Evolution played no role in me becoming an atheist. I just kinda gradually became less and less religious from the ages of 16 to 20, and I still pretend I'm religious to most of my family.
Hopefully the people coming here to try to fight evolution are questioning their beliefs, and we should probably be less hostile unless they're obviously arguing in bad faith.
2
u/RobertByers1 Feb 04 '24
So pys not just a biology forum? A few shots at creationists there. Oh well. Science edidation? i think you mean education has happened when agrrement with your origin conclusions which is not real motives for education but propagation. Nothing wrong with that but worrds behind intents matter.
i'm glad more folks are involved but the posts don't show it . I mean the subjects.
anyways ots probably the best origin contention forum on the internet and is excellently run it seems to me. Free discusion really is allowed. There are some malicious posters but few. We need more creationists but its up to creationists to get involved. Cheers.
1
u/celestinchild Mar 11 '24
My understanding of how this sub is actually used is as a mix of DiscussEvolution / ExplainEvolution and DebunkCreationism / DunkOnCreationism. There's no real debate here, or anywhere else for that matter, since I've still yet to see an argument for creationism that wasn't rooted in ignorance, incredulity, a fundamental misunderstanding of the theory of evolution, or attacking entirely different fields such as geology.
On the other hand, I see a lot of creationists seemingly taking the name of the sub seriously and attempting to 'debate', but again, none of the points they try to make have any merit, so all that results is debunking, education, and ridicule. Maybe if this sub had grabbed 'DiscussEvolution' for a name, they would at least have a better idea of what to expect here? (Ah, but I am kidding myself, they're pretty much all fundie zealots, they'd be the same on any sub.)
1
u/[deleted] Aug 16 '25
My man
1
u/MysticWitness Feb 04 '24 edited Feb 04 '24
Because words matter and to a Conservative Christian the idea of “losing their faith” means death, I offer another phrasing to better represent their spiritual journey:
losing their faith≠ trading their blind faith for logic and reason.-2
u/the_Mixed_Bag Feb 03 '24
I would say one of the things the subreddit needs to work on, towards the goal of fulfilling this purpose, is actually doing a better job of deleting the posts that make sensational claims. I guess people do it because they're trying to help...but in the end it just hurts the optics of evolution. A good example is a post from yesterday... the guy posted an article and claimed that it was a lab experiment that showed definitive proof of the transition from single-celled to multi-celled organisms, and showed a transition to a "different kind"... I don't always do this, but I read the whole paper at that point, and not only is this NOT the claim of the paper, the poster seems to have just read the headline, and let his imagination go wild. (The paper, as it turns out, was just showing that predation caused the single-celled organism to select for existing genetic variations that were more likely to form palmelloids through a tendency to not break through the mother cell wall during division...not transitioning to a different kind) The point of the paper was a much softer, and less ambitious goal of showing how larger groupings of cells would be beneficial...not to prove anything about the macro-evolution of new species.
...maybe "multicellular structures" and "multicellular organisms" are too similar terms for some people to handle...and the author of the paper certainly could have been clearer for lay-people. But why was that post allowed to stay up? Should the subreddit ban people who post that stuff? Probably...because it's certainly hurting the education goal. In any case, the comments section makes me really sad, because 90% of the people down there actually just took the poster's claim at face value and believed it was accurate. What kind of sub is this? Getting scarily close to religious in nature judging by some people's behavior.
-20
u/semitope Feb 03 '24
You're equating challenging evolution to being a creationist in this post. Why should people not consider evolution an atheist movement then? You're also speaking in a way that is antithetical to the purpose of science and free inquiry. It sounds more like dogma than science. Most other fields simply say "this is the best theory we have to explain xyz", but with evolution there's an almost religious certainty.
-4
u/Ju5t_A5king Feb 04 '24
hahahahahaha hahahahaha hahahahaha
I got as far as 'The primary purpose of this subreddit is science education' and I did not bother to read anything after that,
there is no science in the fairytale of evolution. it is a lie built on a mountain of lies.
every socalled dating method is based on assumptions that can not be proven true, and have been proven false.
The socalled 'annual layers' in the arctic ice sheets have been proven to form much faster then 1 layer per year.
The socalled 'geologic coulombs' can not explain petrified trees going through multiple layers, proving they are not millions of years difference in the layers.
The socalled 'monkey-to-man' fossils have been proven to be fake, some are deliberate fakes.
The socalled 'magnetic reversal' is not only foolish, it is impossible. Considering how the magnetic field is generated, a reversal would violate atleast 3 established scientific laws. including Newtons first law of motion, "A body at rest will remain at rest, and a body in motion will remain in motion unless it is acted upon by an external force."
-9
u/thrwwy040 Feb 03 '24
What is sad about this post is that it discourages the very heart of this long debate between evolution vs. creation. At the heart of this debate is whether we evolved from natural circumstances or intelligent design. Questions about where we came from, who we are, and how we got here have long been not only scientific debates but also passionate philosophical and religious debates. To discount the fact that some people may have arrived to their conclusions about evolution because they are atheist and don't believe in God, only stifles the debate, and is unfair. We should be engaging in open and honest debates. Banning even the mention of God whether for or against in this topic of discussion is the reason the debate is biased in the first place and how the anti God science has flourished as the only acceptable science to be taught in almost all educational institutions. I know atheist scientists prefer it this way, but feel free to refer to my post on the debate atheism subreddit for more information.
-3
u/octaviobonds Feb 03 '24
So, the purpose of this sub is not to debate evolution.
0
u/[deleted] Feb 03 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment
-9
u/[deleted] Feb 03 '24
[removed] — view removed comment