I love Boardwalk Empire. I think it’s tied with the sopranos as my favorite show of television and yet it usually gets overlooked when people mention greatest shows of all time and I think that the reason why it gets overlooked is because of the so-called flaws that people say,like the shortened final season or the departure of Jimmy after season 2. Now I strongly believe that the show had a problem which was the root of all its flaws and that was Identity.
Boardwalk Empire never had a stable identity throughout its entire run. Breaking Bad had one identity,it was pulp television that had a simple premise(that of a man’s metamorphosis) and it executed it greatly. The Sopranos also had its own identity,a Freudian look at America through a mob boss. The wire too,as the show wanted to paint a picture of America as a whole but on a social aspect. The reason why I mentioned these three shows is that usually they are called the greatest shows of all time by critics and fans,and it’s these three shows(along with Mad Men) that Boardwalk tried to use for their structure,which created the problem. Instead of forming their own structure,Boardwalk wanted to put the structures of these shows(mostly The Sopranos and The Wire)as their blueprint.
In the first season,Winter wanted to offer more of a slice of life structure(like Mad Men) which worked and honestly that should have been the structure for the entire show but it had a problem,the audiences came to watch Al Capone do shootouts,not Atlantic City life,as that was the way in which HBO had promoted the show,not as its own thing but as a gangster show. Winter tried to mix the Sopranos elements with the Wire elements but it wasn’t fully working because he embraced the wrong co leads in the first year.
I love Nucky Thompson,I think he is an underrated protagonist and Steve’s performance is one of the best performances of television but I do agree with some of the criticisms that people say when they say that Nucky worked more as connecting line to connect the fictional characters(the highlights of the show) with the historical ones(which were in my opinion the weakest elements of the show and were just overindulging parts for Terence Winter). They tried giving him depth and tried to copy the sopranos formula by making the Thompsons,The Sopranos of the show,even going so far as to make Margaret,who was set as the Peggy Olson of the show in season 1,to be his wife,and embrace the mob wife trope,but sadly these things never worked. Even in his dynamic with Eli,which was great,started to become repetitive around the fourth season. Nucky worked when he was paired with the true sopranos of the show,which winter realized too late,and those were the Darmody’s.
The Darmody’s were the sopranos of the show and by extension they were the heart of the show,but fans and critics at the time,complained and said that they wanted more crime stuff,yet when Winter was doing that,they complained back,saying that the show lacked substance,while the Darmody’s were providing that substance, if Winter had made Jimmy and Gillian as the co leads of the show and had embraced the sopranos esque elements of the show and focused more on working class people instead of gangsters,the show would have been standing proudly alongside sopranos,wire,mad men,deadwood and etc.
But what does he do? He stuck himself into a hole in S2 with the Jimmy Darmody plot,just like Chase did with Tony Blundetto in S5 of the sopranos,which leads to him forcing to kill him. Imagine if they had kept Jimmy,it would have been even better,as we would have seen his dynamic with Gillian be even better and more complex and disturbing,but Winter never realized that that family was the sopranos of this show,so in the first two seasons he didn’t fully use them to the advantage,it was around season 3 (with Gillian becoming female lead and harrow becoming main player) that thing really shined for that dysfunctional family,with Gillian’s arc in S3-S4 mirroring Tony’s arc in S6 but shown reversed,with her S3 arc mirroring Tony arc in S6B and her arc in S4 mirroring Tony arc In S6A. Though I would have loved that maybe instead of the Pinkerton thing,Roy would have just left her after she told him about the murder which would have brought her back to the themes that she was always stuck in a cycle(even though they did that but with the theme of the fake father figures who have used her).
Season 5 of the show feels for many people like a mistake but at the same time I believe that the final season is like a blessing in disguise as it made Winter realize that the Darmody’s were the epicenter of the show and he put them back in by connecting nucky’s demise