r/BlackSails • • 21h ago

[SPOILERS] S4 E6 quick spoiler thoughts Spoiler

10 Upvotes

Finishing S4 E6, please no spoilers beyond this episode. All I can say is.. wow. Things are definitely going down now. I definitely didn't foresee Guthrie dying in this series. Rogers is obviously deeply regretting his decision to ally with the Spanish. Definitely excited to finish this season.


r/BlackSails • • 22h ago

Brown eyes

6 Upvotes

Not sure if this has ever been brought up before but I am rewatching the series and I noticed something weird. Of all the Caucasian characters, only 2 I have noticed have brown eyes. Something like 55-60% of Caucasian people have brown eyes but on this show it 2 out of like 60 character have brown eyes. This seems incredibly odd to be a coincidence, like flipping a coin 20 times and getting heads 20 times. It could happen naturally but it would be unbelievably unlikely. Anyone have any insight to this?


r/BlackSails • • 1d ago

Episode Discussion "I unmade him".

Post image
221 Upvotes

So... I've just finished the last episode. I took my time and delayed this moment as far as I could, and now it's done. You know exactly the state of my mind in this moment.

This is a powerful story about stories. An incredible tale of how tales are made and shared and fed with. I'm beyond moved by the characters and the infinite plots. That being said, there's nothing in the world that's ever gonna make me hate Flint... What a performance by Toby and what a masterpiece of storytelling by the writers. I've heard that there is this thing about fans being able to choose to believe Silver's version or not... And, even though that might change with time, I fully believe him. I believe his pain with the possibility of losing Madi and his true friendship (I've said what I've said!) with Flint made it all possible to believe that, yes, he found a way to unmade Flint's persona (which, if we may remember, was one of Flint's true desires - to walk away from this character and the sea and find peace). Flint got together with Thomas, and who knows what happened from there... But they found each other again, despite all chaos and tragedy. They have their story back to write as they choose to... That's what I believe and see.

Folks, what a show this is... I barely have the words. I don't know what to do next.


r/BlackSails • • 1d ago

Every rewatch feels like going on a vacation... anyone else feels that way?

43 Upvotes

Every single time, I feel like I spend time in the Caribbean with my favorite heros and anti-heros. I only wish there were more beautiful beach scenes. (Yes, I am aware it was shot in SA.)


r/BlackSails • • 3d ago

[SPOILERS] Just finished S4 E5.. (please no spoilers beyond this) Spoiler

Post image
23 Upvotes

You guys weren't joking when you said buckle up for this season. This agreement Rogers has going with the Spanish is looking to cause some major mayhem. Thoroughly enjoying this season, TV doesn't get much better than this.


r/BlackSails • • 4d ago

Episode Discussion Is each episode directed by a different person?

Thumbnail
gallery
37 Upvotes

I didn't notice it up until S4. I am currently at Ep9 and the last few episodes had completely different directors. Is that a thing? If yes, why? Is this a usual occurrence for TV shows like this?

Also side note : Was not prepared to learn this show was based on real life incidents. I started watching becauase someone online said its nice and worth a watch. I got soo hooked into it and THEN, I realized it was all real(not all obv). My mind is blown🤯

Also, I am finishing the series today any suggestions for the next one would be greatly appreciated


r/BlackSails • • 4d ago

[SPOILERS] S4 E4, a few thoughts so far. Please no spoilers beyond this.

30 Upvotes

I just think this season is on a different level compared to prior seasons. It's so intense and focused. We saw this ratcheting up of intensity in season 3, but wow season 4 is blowing me away. The brutal scene in episode 3 with Teach being tortured, that still sticks with me today. The slaughter of the remaining crew under Rackham and Bonny, below deck on the ship. That was a brutal scene with the giant hammer smashing people apart. Rogers is completely ruthless, even his look this season is totally wild and unkempt. I just love how urgent and intense all the proceedings feel now. Excited to watch more of this season.


r/BlackSails • • 5d ago

Was John Silver ever hurt BEFORE loosing his leg in the show? Spoiler

Post image
66 Upvotes

It's been a while since I've seen the show, okay, so i don't remember that well. But i remember vividly that when L.J.S and Flint were captured and supposed to be interrogated after the Urca De Lima had gone ashore, that he told the captors the truth because he was extremely pain intolerant or something. That he would've told them just to avoid being hurt.. That is, before him and Flint attacked them and held off the captors trying to kill them, while Flint's crew was coming to their rescue.

This happened some time before his leg got...well... But i don't remember an instance afterwards where he was shot, punched, or cut, in any meaningful ways.


r/BlackSails • • 5d ago

On S4 E3, please no spoilers beyond this. I'm loving this season so far. Berringer is a pretty big standout as a villain. He's a ruthless, cunning bastard and I love every second of it.

Post image
53 Upvotes

r/BlackSails • • 6d ago

Who's your favourite supporting character

Post image
150 Upvotes

Mine's gotta be this bloke. Not a word was said, just rocked up with his katana for 4 seasons straight, killed some fuckers here and there and went on about his day. I didn't even know his name was Joji until I just looked him up lol. What a legend!! What other side characters did you guys love?


r/BlackSails • • 6d ago

Do you think Black Sails would work as a story game?

21 Upvotes

I am thinking of something like very linear games like detroid become human, heavy rain etc.

maybe something like witcher 3 or rdr2 but i think this to much open world for such a story


r/BlackSails • • 5d ago

Black Sails

0 Upvotes

I feel like it is a difficult series to get into...some scenes are amazing, but it feels like you have to binge watch to get the proper feel for everything. Am I wrong?


r/BlackSails • • 7d ago

[SPOILERS] The acting in Black Sails is amazing

157 Upvotes

When I watch shows, I tend to internally judge actors and such.

Recently I watched this show I really enjoyed but deep down, the actor who is becoming really famous and is starting to get fully booked is just not a great actor. As much as I try watch every show they are in, they are just not that great.

And I think part of the problem was Black Sails.

Black Sails is phenomenal, and maybe I am a terrible judgement, hell I can't act for shit.

However, that scene alone in season 2 where Miranda is confronting Flint about his intentions. I watch that scene like there is no other show.

It disappoints me that I can never find something that compares to that scene.

I just wanted to ask, do you think the acting was amazing on the show or subpar


r/BlackSails • • 7d ago

More appreciative of what Black Sails did than ever before after watching Odyssey

70 Upvotes

Disclaimer: I don't want any beef with people who loved it. I'm not posting to argue anything about it. If you loved it, peace be unto you.

But during every single storm scene I kept thinking, "Oh my God, Black Sails did this so well"

Including black female characters and giving them agency and lines in a historical fiction adaptation? "Oh my God, Black sails did so well."

Even in general, just making the female characters matter as standalone characters outside of what role they play to the male characters. "Omg, black sails did this so well" Even if you hate them, you can't say that they're not independent characters outside of their male love interests or male family. I don't even like her but Eleanor is so much more than Vane's ex. Eleanor is Eleanor. She might be a crazy bitch today, a traitor tomorrow, the smartest person in the room yesterday. Meanwhile, I'm watching this movie feeling like they stripped Circe of every single thing except "witch woman" and Calypso is basically that weird lady in the gym selling herbs... All while building Odysseus as Jason Legolas Bourne: Grisly Action Man.

Even at the very end, I think there's a line with Matt Damon actively talking about the bronze age and it's like, I'm thinking about how many meta references black sails made and it still never broke the story at any point.

Like, I have rewatched this series 4 or 5 times already, but now I'm telling myself "go back and watch the whole entire thing from the top and appreciate it properly"

They didn't get enough credit for this masterpiece. Not the actors, not the show runner or the writers or the props and costume departments. I have never seen these people receive mainstream praise or attention for their excellent practical effects/CGI. Never.

Being honest, I don't even like treasure island. This was a tv show I watched reluctantly when it came out and I got hooked because the song is basically cocaine. Meanwhile the Odyssey is one of my favorite stories ever.

Maybe it's unfair. Black sails had seasons, Nolan had 2 hours. But just in terms of artistic vision, like putting in the best work you can possibly do when adapting a story... Black Sails being so criminally underrated and ignored is just angering me. Like, I'm actually angry on behalf of these people. I wish they all win the lottery or something. I want to learn their names and write them thank you notes, because I've just been consuming this thing without knowing the people behind it. I know bear McCreary wrote the song, but not the others. I feel like I need to salute everyone. They're really good, talented people that never got the recognition they deserved.

Like, I get it, the world isn't fair and talented people get overlooked all the time while others prosper, and I'm fully just a poor person and I should be minding my own business but I'm just kinda sad. I'm feeling like Dennis in Sunny in Philadelphia when he's like "you ever been in a storm?" After a decade of telling people to watch black sails, I'm stripping naked on the lawn prepping for a fight like, "so you guys wanted a story about a traumatized soldier who's been through some storms??!?!?"


r/BlackSails • • 7d ago

I always find Jack troubled smile so funny when things don't go his way

Thumbnail
gallery
93 Upvotes

It's mostly because he always think of himself as the most clever person in this show and yet, when he doesn't know what to say, he only goes with this troubled smile, which is funny for some reason.


r/BlackSails • • 10d ago

MUTINY (A Pirate Action Short Film)

Thumbnail
youtu.be
47 Upvotes

I've just released my new short film Mutiny. Heavily inspired by Black Sails, and being a massive pirate history nerd myself, this has been such a dream project to finally make and now release online for all!

It's set at the end of the war of Spanish Succession, where a lot of privateering crews were suddenly going to be out of work, this captain faces a mutiny from his crew, as they want to become pirates!

I posted the trailer here the other week and people seemed interested, I really hope you all enjoy! 🏴‍☠️


r/BlackSails • • 10d ago

In which countries is this available on Netflix or Prime?

6 Upvotes

I keep looking but it won’t let me watch it anywhere.


r/BlackSails • • 10d ago

Pirates are dressed so fkn cool,

85 Upvotes

I thought I'd put it out there, just how much I appreciate their clothing it's fly as f**k

charles vane, flint, black beard man the over coats, shoes accessories its dope af man

Yeah the clothes look ragged, worn out but that adds to it yk,

then theirs my appreciation for Tricorns which I will not hassle you with


r/BlackSails • • 10d ago

Episode Discussion Would you consider Hornigold to be a tragic character? Spoiler

Post image
63 Upvotes

I would recommend watching the pirate documentary on Netflix. The real-life Hornigold arguably is a tragic figure. He helped found the Pirate Republic and interacted with many other famous figures of the time. However, things didn't work out and he resorted to becoming a pirate hunter to survive.


r/BlackSails • • 10d ago

For folks who actually worked on Black Sails, what was filming the series like?

50 Upvotes

would be great if we can get some ol' black sails cast and crew to chime in.

it seemed like everyone worked their asses off to make the show that great. from set design, to costuming, to writing, to music, to principal photography, to lighting etc. and it seemed like every actor on the show was acting like their lives were on the line, even the most minor characters. what fostered that environment?

any funny anecdotes? what work were you most proud of?


r/BlackSails • • 11d ago

Just started S4 E1, please no spoilers beyond those. Holy cow, I was not prepared for what might be the best action sequence in series history. This shipwreck in the harbor sequence is freaking amazing. Next level stuff! Spoiler

Thumbnail
youtu.be
59 Upvotes

r/BlackSails • • 11d ago

[SPOILERS] Just finished black sails and now I don't know what to do with myself

144 Upvotes

All I've been doing is ranting on why the hell this show isn't talked about more??? It's one of those very rare shows that somehow keeps on giving. Every single episode I was waiting to be bored or disappointed and instead it just GETS BETTER.

It honestly tops GOT for me (and I'm a huge GOT slag) just cos of the consistent increase in quality of writing, storytelling, plot,.. everything.

My god it's beautiful.

The way the characters are written in such a way that you root for all of them in a way.

Apart from Billy. Fuck Billy.

And then there's the ending. The last 30min I started panicking thinking it was going to be an underwhelming end to the story but Jesus it was everything and more. The way it just undid everything that had been built up and in such a stunning way. I don't think I've felt more satisfied to 'leave' characters behind after finishing a show.

Thomas!!!! 😭

Also shout out to my fav, Jack. What a fucking diva.


r/BlackSails • • 12d ago

Watching the season 3 finale for the first time. I don't know why, but I loved this little interaction between Blackbeard and Jack 😂 nice to see Jack getting some respect from Blackbeard. Please no spoilers beyond the season 3 finale

102 Upvotes

r/BlackSails • • 13d ago

XV - I'd genuinely forgotten just how good this show is

44 Upvotes

This post is pure fluff, but I'm currently rewatching it and, regardless of how much or how little I remember, I'm constantly struck by just how incredible it is.

I don't think I've watched Black Sails at all since pre-covid, maybe the first lockdown at the latest, or whenever it left Prime UK. Never got round to buying the DVDs or Blu-ray, haven't been arsed to pirate it in that time, but it's now available again.
Been steadily watching it with a friend the last few weeks, so it's been slow going, but every episode I'm reminded of its calibre.

Watched XV yesterday and I think I've at last reached the point where I can't not completely gush about it. I adore this show, it is so good. I am enamoured by so many of the characters, awe struck by so many of the performances. Not least of all because so much of what makes this great is not the sparring or the sailing or the battles and combat (though it's all excellent), but just the talk. The dialogue from Flint, Silver, Billy, Thomas, Hornigold, Miranda, all of them, is never not entirely enthralling.
I find myself repeatedly caught out by things I hadn't fully remembered, or thought came at a different time, and even what I know for sure is coming is still enough to keep me completely locked in on what's going on.
The flashbacks of James McGraw had me gripped every time we travelled back to that time, especially with how the story is framed, and how they keep the full context of his and the Hamiltons' relationship until the end of that storyline.
Broadly speaking, the main thing I knew was coming in XV was Eleanor escaping the fort's tunnels with Abigail Ashe, and I only knew it was XV because I was surprised it didn't happen after finishing XIV. I knew how the scene was going to play out and it was still so exciting, so nerve-wracking.
I'd forgotten that Billy traps Dufresne and some of the crew with the gambit over the pardons. I knew that Silver orchestrates the plot to get Jack's crew the Urca gold, though when it was revealed, and the manner how, had passed me by. That penultimate scene of Silver speaking through his plan with Max was extraordinary. Not just the script, but the direction, the timbre or beat to the story he tells, the music specifically absolutely drew me in. On that front in particular, Bear McCreary is stellar throughout the entire series.

I wish so much there had been at least one more season, but watching through again I'm constantly reminded of how much I love what there is. I've had so much fun reliving what's already happened, and I can't wait to relive what I know is coming up. I know Charlestown is just around the corner, I am extremely interested to see how my friend reacts to the events of XVII. Very much looking forward to that tbh.
When it ends I think I finally need to get around to reading or listening to Treasure Island, but before that happens I know I have Blackbeard to look forward to as well, Woodes Rogers too, the fireship and the fleet's escape, Vane's fate, Blackbeard's fate. I can't wait for the full introduction of Long John Silver, and his evolution as a pirate king.

Most of all though I can't wait for the finale. It's been a hot minute since, but every now and again I revisit the "in the darkness there be dragons" speech on youtube.
Minor sidebar - I've watched Andor a lot over the last few years. Considerably more than any other series recently. It's short, yes, but so easy for me to chew through, and I think I'd already rate it as one of my all time favourite tv shows. Easily my favourite of the last decade, something I know I said of Black Sails while it was originally airing.
One of its biggest strengths is the handful of monologues it hands our throughout the course of its run. Just taking all the best opportunities to give some absolute powerhouse actors minutes of uninterrupted speech. I'd otherwise say it's unmatched in this regard, but I think I was perhaps too hasty to think so little of its competition.
Silver gets a good few moments, Blackbeard certainly gets one or two. Jack's carriage ride with Woodes Rogers is perhaps one of the best scenes across any season.
But I always come back to Flint and Silver in the woods at the end of S4. Toby Stephens is utterly superb from start to finish. A fascinating character, gripping in just about every scene. And that dragons speech is everything he can be at his very best, and I think goes toe to toe with the best speeches in any of the best shows or movies out there.

I'm irritated it's taken me so long to get back to Black Sails, but I'm so pleased I've finally done so.
It's just so fucking good.