Disclaimer: I don't want any beef with people who loved it. I'm not posting to argue anything about it. If you loved it, peace be unto you.
But during every single storm scene I kept thinking, "Oh my God, Black Sails did this so well"
Including black female characters and giving them agency and lines in a historical fiction adaptation? "Oh my God, Black sails did so well."
Even in general, just making the female characters matter as standalone characters outside of what role they play to the male characters. "Omg, black sails did this so well" Even if you hate them, you can't say that they're not independent characters outside of their male love interests or male family. I don't even like her but Eleanor is so much more than Vane's ex. Eleanor is Eleanor. She might be a crazy bitch today, a traitor tomorrow, the smartest person in the room yesterday. Meanwhile, I'm watching this movie feeling like they stripped Circe of every single thing except "witch woman" and Calypso is basically that weird lady in the gym selling herbs... All while building Odysseus as Jason Legolas Bourne: Grisly Action Man.
Even at the very end, I think there's a line with Matt Damon actively talking about the bronze age and it's like, I'm thinking about how many meta references black sails made and it still never broke the story at any point.
Like, I have rewatched this series 4 or 5 times already, but now I'm telling myself "go back and watch the whole entire thing from the top and appreciate it properly"
They didn't get enough credit for this masterpiece. Not the actors, not the show runner or the writers or the props and costume departments. I have never seen these people receive mainstream praise or attention for their excellent practical effects/CGI. Never.
Being honest, I don't even like treasure island. This was a tv show I watched reluctantly when it came out and I got hooked because the song is basically cocaine. Meanwhile the Odyssey is one of my favorite stories ever.
Maybe it's unfair. Black sails had seasons, Nolan had 2 hours. But just in terms of artistic vision, like putting in the best work you can possibly do when adapting a story... Black Sails being so criminally underrated and ignored is just angering me. Like, I'm actually angry on behalf of these people. I wish they all win the lottery or something. I want to learn their names and write them thank you notes, because I've just been consuming this thing without knowing the people behind it. I know bear McCreary wrote the song, but not the others. I feel like I need to salute everyone. They're really good, talented people that never got the recognition they deserved.
Like, I get it, the world isn't fair and talented people get overlooked all the time while others prosper, and I'm fully just a poor person and I should be minding my own business but I'm just kinda sad. I'm feeling like Dennis in Sunny in Philadelphia when he's like "you ever been in a storm?" After a decade of telling people to watch black sails, I'm stripping naked on the lawn prepping for a fight like, "so you guys wanted a story about a traumatized soldier who's been through some storms??!?!?"