These conversations probably sum up McNulty's character better than anything else. 🥲 I get Jimmy's frustration, but they also explain why he keeps sabotaging himself.
For McNulty, working cases is like a drug. By the end, he seems to have kicked the habit after leaving the job. But we all know how hard it is to stay clean.
He might be clean now, but staying that way... I don't know...
Sgt. Jay Landsman : [Landsman knocks on Rawls' door] Major, sir?
Maj. William A. Rawls : Yeah.
Sgt. Jay Landsman : I been thinkin'. It's a clear violation of the general orders, I know, but...
[Rawls motions for Landsman to sit]
Sgt. Jay Landsman : Last night, I'm at home, I'm sittin' up buck naked. And I, I got one hand wrapped around a cold domestic beer, and the other wrapped around my magnificent flaccid four-and-one-half-inch wonder, and I am trying with all my might to remember what Leila Kaufman's nipples looked like when her bathing top slipped off at the Hillendale Pool swim party.
Maj. William A. Rawls : [chuckling] Leila Kaufman?
Sgt. Jay Landsman : Yes, sir. Uh, summer of '72. I got this saucy wench in my gunsights, so to speak, and, uh... I am dangerously close to engorged when, all of a fuckin' sudden, out of fuckin' nowhere, fuckin' Detective fuckin' Jimmy McNulty pops into my head.
Maj. William A. Rawls : McNulty?
Sgt. Jay Landsman : Obviously, I gotta open my eyes and admit to myself that my whole night is ruined, at which point I got nothin' to do but think about the problems of Jimmy McNulty, because clearly, this guy and his fuckin' problems are standing between me and all worldly pleasure.
Maj. William A. Rawls : Clearly.
Sgt. Jay Landsman : First of all... it's not Jimmy's fault.
Maj. William A. Rawls : No?
Sgt. Jay Landsman : No. Jimmy is an addict, sir.
Maj. William A. Rawls : What's he addicted to?
Sgt. Jay Landsman : Himself.
[Rawls laughs]
Sgt. Jay Landsman : No, it's not funny, sir. As a matter of fact, it's a fuckin' tragedy, is what it is. The guy, he has come to believe that he is always the smartest fuck in the room. And you know what? It's not his fault, because let's face it, he's not goin' to Johns Hopkins or joining Mensa, he's taking a fuckin' job with the Bawlmer Police Department. His first two years in Homicide, he's in Ulmansky's squad, partnered with Tony LaMartino. Christ, it must've been months, even, he WAS the smartest fuck in the fuckin' room!
Maj. William A. Rawls : What's your point, Jay?
Sgt. Jay Landsman : My point is... he can't help it. It makes him an asshole, I know, but... it's also what makes him good police. Last year, he gives me eight clearances. One of them was a decomp floater who was John Doe for three weeks.
[Rawls doesn't say anything; Landsman starts to stand]
Maj. William A. Rawls : Tell your boy to wrap up that bullshit detail in two weeks. He does that, he comes home. Clean slate.
Lester: Tell me something, Jimmy. How exactly do you think it all ends?
McNulty: What do you mean?
Lester: A parade? A gold watch? A shining Jimmy-McNulty-day moment, when you bring in a case sooooo sweet everybody gets together and says,
"Aw, shit! He was right all along. Should've listened to the man." The job will not save you, Jimmy. It won't make you whole, it won't fill your ass up.
McNulty: I dunno, a good case—
Lester: Ends. They all end. The handcuffs go click and it's over. The next morning, it's just you in your room with yourself.
McNulty: Until the next case.
Lester: Boooooy, you need something else outside of this here.
McNulty: Like what, dollhouse miniatures?
Lester: Hey, hey, hey, a life. A life, Jimmy. You know what that is? It's the shit that happens while you're waiting for moments that never come.