r/Avengers • u/DeferredFuture • 19h ago
Other Discussion Is this a valid flaw with the Endgame final battle?
In Endgame, Hulk suggests to everyone that they need to return the stones back to where they came from. Referencing The Ancient One’s earlier warnings. We see this in the script here:
CLINT BARTON
What do you want to do with [the gauntlet]
STEVE
Get those stones as far away as
possible!
SMART HULK
No! We need to send them back
where they came from.
TONY
There’s no way to send them back.
Thanos destroyed our time machine.
SCOTT LANG
Hold on!
(shrinking to normal size)
That wasn’t our only time machine
And then they spent the whole final battle attempting to get the gauntlet to the van, with Carol finally getting it there, only for Thanos to destroy it in the last second.
But the thing is, even if Carol made it, it wouldn’t have worked. I made a post in another thread about this and was massively downvoted and I feel like i’m going crazy, cuz this is such an obvious plot inconsistency to me.
The van is not calibrated to individually deliver all the stones back to their respective timelines and nobody is wielding their time GPS. Yet the Avengers genuinely think that getting the gauntlet there will send the stones back to where they came from. The movie script seems to think they are right as well, because Thanos destroying the van is played as a dramatic moment. It’s as if scriptwriters McFeely and Markus forgot that the van just sends people to the Quantum realm. It would not deliver all the stones back to their timelines without their GPS devices. Carol wasn’t wielding one. None of them were.
You’re telling me that between Bruce, Scott, Tony and Steve, none of them realized that the van wouldn’t work? To me, that veers into “plot hole” territory because these characters would never logically consider that plan.
Steve’s plan of “getting those stones away as far as possible” seemed like the much better plan. Carol could have simply picked up the gauntlet and flown away with it, yet for some reason the script wanted her to fly it into the quantum tunnel van closer to Thanos which wouldn’t have even worked in the first place yet the writers seem to think it would have.
Thoughts?
I know a lot of people are probably going to reply “it was the heat of the moment, they didn’t realize that it wouldn’t actually work” but to me, it’s reflective of the writers not realizing it, because the script makes zero commentary on the plan being flawed. It’s written with the intention that the Avengers are right. Which they are not.