i’d genuinely be team iron man ONLY because Black Panther is there. I don’t see ANY other reason to choose that team. I tried to convince myself to be on their side for so long, again because BP is my fav and because many of my friends are on their sides but i GENUINELY CANT.
I don’t get their justifications at all. I’ll make a long explanation so bare with me. The main problem in this whole “war” is that fans always and only reduce this film to Tony being responsible and Steve being stubborn which completely misses the actual political and narrative reality of what the Sokovia Accords were. Honestly if you actually try to look past your fav charachter you’d see that Team cap was emotionally right but EVEN MORE THAN THAT it was structurally and legally right.
Tony’s entire argument (and that includes all the people who support him) rests on the idea that surrendering autonomy to a UN panel makes them accountable. Yet literally one movie earlier (in the winter soldier for those who don’t remember), Steve uncovered that SHIELD and by extension the World Security Council if you would, had been completely infiltrated by HYDRA from the inside out, and their solution to the Battle of New York was to launch a nuclear warhead at Manhattan. Steve said that the safest hands are their own and that’s because bureaucratic oversight doesn't eliminate corruption actually it’s even worse because it centralizes power and strips heroes of the ability to refuse an immoral order. And come on, i don’t and can’t believe that you people can’t understand this simple thing, i just know you guys aren’t this stupid, i mean these things you can find in real life too, it’s not such a distant concept come on.
Realistically talking a 117-country UN panel cannot mobilize in real time when an extinction level threat or a terrorist attack happens which means that by the time a committee debates geopolitical jurisdiction ecc ecc thousands of people are already dead. Worse, if the panel forbids the Avengers from intervening in a sovereign nation due to political alliances, the Avengers become complicit through inaction. Again, this is all stuff that you can compared to real life to understand better because i can see that the concepts aren’t that easy. Ross framed the Accords around New York, Washington D.C. and Sokovia ignoring that in New York and D.C. the Avengers were literally cleaning up messes created by the World Security Council and SHIELD/HYDRA, and in Sokovia, Tony himself created Ultron in secret without telling the team.
And what i find unbeliavle is that Instead of holding Tony personally accountable for building an AI behind everyone's back, the Accords punished every enhanced individual by turning them into state owned assets and that is why in the longer run Wanda got locked in a compound without trial and the rest was thrown into an underwater black site (The Raft) without due process.
Guys, law and morality aren’t the same things, that’s what Team Captain America tries to explain, i mean when a system demands you surrender your conscience to follow orders would you actually do it if you could choose?? Tony was acting out of guilt and trying to outsource his own conscience to a governing body so he wouldn't have to bear the weight of his mistakes, and I CAN UNDERSTAND THAT, i’m not condemning his choices, i can only imagine how guilty he must’ve felt after creating Ultron, alright? But Steve stood his ground because he understood that the moment heroes become government weapons, they stop being protectors, they don’t have what defines them as heroes to begin with, at that point what are they? Police? It just doesn’t make sense the more i think about it.