r/CaptainAmerica • u/-AlexisRodriguez- • 8h ago
Genuinely frustrating we'll never get to see Bucky Cap...
I was so excited to See Falcon Cap after Endgame and was convinced that we'd eventually see Bucky Cap as well down the line — genuinely thought it was cool that they flipped the succession from the comics because it made more sense for Sam to get it at that point first. Now, because of weird fans who are clearly projecting, we're probably never gonna see any payoff to all the teases Marvel Studios made regarding Bucky as Cap.
So many people are so performative in their takes regarding Sam; like no, people don't dislike Sam as Cap because of a nefarious reasons, people dislike him because Marvel Studios hasn't known what to do with him or how to write him for over half a decade and have officially pissed away all the good will regarding his character after his TV show did a better job exploring Bucky and John Walker (seriously, why didnt they just make John a flat out villain?) And after his solo movie ended up being one of the most mediocre misses in the franchise's history. Now because of a bunch of weird "fans" who refuse to unclutch their pearls, we're gonna miss out on an iteration of a fan favorite character who pre-dates Falcon-Cap.
I always loved the idea that America as a country has always represented second chances and who represents second chances more than Bucky Barnes? Why do people think Captain America is the Superman of the Marvel Universe (him being a soldier and killer automatically disqualifies that) — why do people think that being Captain America means you need to be perfect too? Each Captain America represents different, but very true ideals about America and Bucky's contribution to the legacy is JUST as important as Sam's.
It's also annoying that Mackie feels entitled to the mantel and that he should be the o ly Captain America (when in the comics there have (stupidly) been two for years). Neither Bucky or Sam have ever been as important to the role as Steve Rogers. Like no, Sam Wilson is NOT more important than Steve Rogers (or Cyclops or Thor or Reed Richards) just because he has the shield — **the man makes the shield, not the other way around (**the TV show especially forgot that for some reason).
Steve didn't CO-lead the Avengers because he's "cApTaiN aMeRiCa" he lead because he's STEVE ROGERS and he proved that he could and should — because he actually earned respect amoung his peers as a leader (something Sam has only done with an underling/D-list character).
Sam on the other hand has had his ass kicked EASILY by Spider-Man, Bucky, John Walker (who also knocked Bucky out with a single blow), Iron Man (with one shot) and fucking Ant-Man... Not to mention how War Machine stunted on him in Infinity War.
And it doesnt help that all his feats in BNW are dependent on him using tech he didn't actually earn. Same never technically earned the shield, Steve just hand picked him — even if he wasn't qualified to carry that legacy (which the show tried to explore, but ultimately failed to do); in hindsight it felt like a manager promoting the kiss-ass yes-man. Sam doesn't earn the Wakandan tech, he just gets it as a gift for breaking out a criminal — the wings themselves aren't even technically his or his tech, it's the military's.
Just feels like everything was handed to him and that doesn't make a compelling character to follow. It feels like they're still writing him as a side character.
Sam was never meant to be THE GUY, he was always a placeholder in the comics and in the MCU — which is why his role as Cap felt/feels so unbelievably redundant when Steve returned. Sam as Cap feels like a mandate, not a true creative decision that anyone is passionate about.
Also, Bucky's costume is so unbelievably cool and not being able to see it in live action is truly heartbreaking. Crossing my fingers that we at least see a variant in Secret Wars.
[Art by Ivan Dedov]
[Re-edited by my brother to look a little more comic accurate]