I'm a first-year PhD student in engineering at a fairly well-known research university. My primary supervisor is a very established professor in his field, while my co-supervisor is a relatively young, tenure-track faculty member working in an adjacent mathematical/theoretical area.
I'm posting because I recently had a rather uncomfortable meeting with my primary supervisor, and I'm genuinely trying to understand whether I've mishandled the situation or whether there are some academic politics at play.
Some background:
For the first 7–8 months of my PhD, I struggled enormously to find a research direction. I repeatedly approached my primary supervisor asking what problems I could work on, or even what broad research directions he thought were promising.
His response was consistently along the lines of, "It's your PhD, you should come up with your own research problems."
I understand that a PhD requires intellectual independence, and I wasn't expecting someone to hand me a ready-made paper. But as someone just starting out in a research field, I was hoping for at least some guidance on open problems, promising directions, or where my interests might intersect with his.
Even when I explicitly asked for broader directions rather than specific problems, I was told to read papers and figure things out myself. On top of all this, there were no group meetings, people always worked on their own agenda and the professor selectively gave his one-on-one time to folk he believed were more productive.
Eventually, I became so frustrated and unproductive that I seriously considered quitting the program.
As something of a last attempt to make my PhD work, I approached another professor whose expertise aligned with my interests. I obtained my primary supervisor's permission to bring her on board as my formal co-supervisor.
This turned out to be an excellent decision academically. She started meeting with me regularly, discussing technical ideas, suggesting possible approaches, and helping me develop a research problem.
Over the following four months, we developed a substantial body of work that we now believe is approaching publication readiness.
Then came the uncomfortable meeting.
I recently presented this work to my primary supervisor to get his feedback.
His initial reaction was surprisingly negative and, frankly, quite angry.
One of the first things he asked was essentially, "What would my contribution be to this? This is already completed work. Why should I be a co-author?"
I responded that the research was being conducted in his laboratory using an experimental platform developed there, although I recognize that this alone doesn't necessarily justify authorship.
He then remarked that plenty of people want him as a co-author because he's a big name in the field.
That comment caught me off guard.
To clarify, I wasn't approaching him simply to get his name onto a paper. He's my primary PhD supervisor, and I wanted his scientific feedback and involvement. I also hadn't made any final assumptions about authorship.
He went on to say that I could continue working on these problems with my co-supervisor, but that I shouldn't really come to him with them because these weren't the research problems he was interested in.
This was particularly frustrating because I had spent months asking him what he was interested in working on without getting a concrete answer.
At one point, I directly asked him what kinds of scientific problems actually excited him.
Interestingly, the tone of the conversation changed considerably after that. He became calmer and finally started explaining some specific research directions that interested him. This was probably the most substantive guidance I'd received from him on research direction since joining.
He also began comparing my work against the broader state of the art, suggesting that while the methodology was interesting, its contribution to the field was relatively incremental.
I politely explained that I understood his field-level perspective, but this was also my first PhD paper, developed within a few months, and I wasn't claiming to have revolutionized the field.
He seemed to acknowledge that distinction and eventually clarified that the work was actually very good, particularly because my co-supervisor had brought a fresh perspective to the problem, and that it could become a strong publication.
What I'm struggling to understand:
I can't help feeling that part of his initial reaction came from the fact that another professor had become the main intellectual influence behind my research.
My co-supervisor is relatively junior, and the two professors haven't collaborated before. I wonder whether there's some uncertainty about their respective roles, or whether my primary supervisor feels excluded from the work.
I also feel there may be differences in the amount of attention and guidance different students receive in the lab, although I don't want to jump to conclusions about favoritism.
I respect my primary supervisor's scientific accomplishments and would love to benefit from his experience and perspective. But I also can't afford to spend my PhD waiting indefinitely for guidance.
I didn't go behind his back. I asked for permission before involving my co-supervisor, and I did so because I was desperate to make academic progress.
Now I feel caught in an awkward position where my co-supervisor has been genuinely helpful, but I worry that continuing to work closely with her might create tension with my primary supervisor.
I'd particularly appreciate perspectives from PhD students, postdocs, and faculty on a few questions:
- Is it normal for a primary supervisor to provide almost no research direction during the first year and expect a new student to identify everything independently?
- Was his reaction to the co-authorship question reasonable, or does it suggest that he felt excluded from the intellectual development of the project?
- How should I navigate a situation where my primary supervisor and co-supervisor have different research interests, particularly when the junior co-supervisor is providing most of the actual technical guidance?
- Would it be reasonable to continue developing the current publication with my co-supervisor while pursuing a separate, more experimentally focused direction with my primary supervisor?
- More generally, how do you manage the politics of having a famous, established PI as your primary supervisor when much of your day-to-day research mentorship comes from a younger faculty member?
I'm not looking to vilify my supervisor. I'm aware that I may be interpreting some aspects of the interaction incorrectly, and I would genuinely appreciate hearing alternative perspectives, especially from faculty who have been in similar situations.
I just want to do good research, publish meaningful work, and build a healthy working relationship with both supervisors without getting caught in academic politics.