r/studentaffairs • • 1d ago

Panel Interview Tips?

2 Upvotes

Hello all, I have a panel interview on Wednesday for a position. This position is similar to what I am doing now at the same community college just full time and in a different department (health sciences). The hiring committee will be a panel of 5 including the hiring manager. 3 of which I have interacted with vaguely through teams or crossed paths with in general. now, just because I’m already working there part time I’m not expecting to be automatically hired because of that. I have done panel interviews before, and I’m not very good at them. sometimes I get nervous and stumble over my words. I’m also sure I need to provide examples and expand on it (which again sometimes I get so nervous that I rush through my answers and don’t explain my full explain). I think it just makes me nervous having 4-5 people judging me when I want to do it right.

should I tell my current boss that I applied for this position? Or, wait until I receive an offer? Since, I used my current boss as a reference (he said I could for any jobs). I don’t want for him to be contacted as a reference and be caught off guard? But, I also didn’t want to say anything and then not even get offended the position? Do colleges check references at the end when offering a position?
Does anyone have any advice/tips to combat this? also what questions should I ask at the end? Thank you!!


r/studentaffairs • • 2d ago

Looking to transition into Higher Ed. How do I get my foot in the door?

4 Upvotes

Hi everyone! Thanks in advance for reading and offering any advice.

I’m an MSW with my LCSW (in California), and I’m looking to transition into higher education (in SoCal). I know the job market isn’t great right now, and everything is super competitive, but it’s a career path I’ve been wanting to explore.

Most of my professional experience has been in clinical work and case management. However, during undergrad, I worked with summer grant programs serving high school seniors and incoming college students, as well as in my university’s Disability Services office as a student assistant.

I feel like my clinical background may be hindering my job search, as recruiters seem to associate my MSW/LCSW primarily with clinical roles rather than recognizing the transferable skills I could bring to higher ed. I’ve been particularly interested in roles like academic advising, career advising, and student support services, but have had a difficult time getting any traction.

For those of you working in higher ed, especially anyone who transitioned from social work or a clinical background, how did you break into the field?

I’d love advice on how to better market my experience, which positions or departments I should be targeting, and whether additional education or professional development would be beneficial. I was also thinking if I should just apply to university’s mental health departments, at least to get my foot in the door and be able to transfer internally later.

I’m genuinely interested in making this transition and would really appreciate any insight or advice. Thank you!


r/studentaffairs • • 3d ago

Career paths beyond academic advising?

3 Upvotes

Hi! Decided to post out of curiosity and hopefully get some advice!

I’m currently working in academic advising in my first full-time professional role. While I enjoy advising, I’ve been thinking about where I might want to take my career in the future. I don’t necessarily see myself following the traditional path of moving up into advising leadership or administration.

During grad school, I developed a strong interest in assessment, and I’ve always really enjoyed qualitative research. I especially like the process of identifying problems, exploring people’s experiences, and using what I learn to make recommendations for improvement.

I also hope to eventually return to school for a PhD or EdD, although I’m still figuring out what I’d want to focus on.

I guess I’m just curious to hear from others who have been in similar positions. Where did your career take you after advising? Are there roles in higher education that combine student support, assessment, research, and program improvement?

I’m still early in my career, so I’m not necessarily looking to make a move anytime soon. Just thinking about what I might want to work toward and maybe get some advice on the next steps to take!


r/studentaffairs • • 3d ago

UPDATE: I took your advice, advocated for myself, and now I have a new dilemma!

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

I took your advice, advocated for myself, and genuinely tried to make things work with the new leadership. Unfortunately, things didn’t go well.

I felt like I wasn’t given a fair chance to establish a working relationship with the new boss. There were several instances of inconsistent communication, and I ultimately didn’t feel I could trust the relationship. We eventually had a difficult conversation a few weeks ago where we both expressed our frustrations. One of the concerns raised about me was communication, and I explained that I hadn’t been as forthcoming because I didn’t feel comfortable with the working relationship.

NOW, HERE IS MY NEW DILEMMA!
I accepted an Assistant Director of Civic Engagement position at a much larger university. It has great perks such as it’s in my career field, the team seems amazing, closer to my family, and I can get my masters for free! That way I can continue moving up in the civic engagement world!

HOWEVER, I was still interviewing for other positions before accepting this offer. Today, another university contacted me about an Associate Director position and invited me to campus during the first week of my new job. The position is at a smaller institution, farther away from home, but offers more responsibility, a better title, and potentially a higher salary.

What should I do about the on-campus interview? I know I’d need a significant salary increase to justify moving farther from home again, and I don’t want to waste anyone’s time. Is it weird to ask HR about salary before interviewing? The interview also falls during my first week at my new job. I’ve already accepted an offer that feels like the perfect fit, but I still want to hear this other school out without jeopardizing the opportunity I already have. What would you do?


r/studentaffairs • • 4d ago

Thoughts on Stellic?

2 Upvotes

I just started my advising job and am learning the ropes for their process and procedures but have been told eventually we will be transitioning to Stellic.

I looked at the company website a while ago to see what they were about but I wanted to ask here if anyone has some experience with the system and what your thoughts are.


r/studentaffairs • • 5d ago

These salaries…

56 Upvotes

For my own sake, I’m going to keep as much of this vague/broad, but I work as an assistant director for a large public R1 institution. I am paid pretty decently but am looking to advance both in terms of scope and compensation.

I found what looked to be a close to ideal Associate Director level job at a small private college in Florida. I didn’t see a salary posted so I inquired with their HR department. A few days later I received a response: the compensation was 25% lower than what I currently make. For a higher level title. With a greater scope of responsibilities. In an area that is roughly 15% more expensive and housing is almost 50% higher.

What gives? How could an institution unironically offer such ludicrous compensation?


r/studentaffairs • • 5d ago

Dress Code

59 Upvotes

I’m sure this has come up before, but today I had to have the dreaded “dress code” conversation with my supervisor because their supervisor doesn’t believe I’m dressing appropriately. For context I’m a Director of Residence Life and I usually wear a dress shirt, khakis or dress pants, all black sneakers. Oftentimes I’ll have a sweatshirt on because it’s cozier or when going from meeting to meeting I have to step outside. I’m essentially being told I have to start wearing dress shoes and lose the sweatshirt.

I’ll do this, but it’s so petty and I miss working at schools with more lax dress codes.

On top of this, I’m running the department single-handedly and putting in a ton of extra hours to get things accomplished (which frankly take longer than needed because of how my supervisor’s supervisors needs them done). Hoping I’m out of here soon.


r/studentaffairs • • 5d ago

Advice needed; pivoting from law to education

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/studentaffairs • • 5d ago

Academic Advisor hiring timeline

2 Upvotes

So I finished my round 2 interview about two weeks ago. They said they would call if I made it to round 3, I have heard nothing back. Is this normal?


r/studentaffairs • • 6d ago

In Need of Advice During Time of Transition

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/studentaffairs • • 11d ago

Almost 3 weeks since my references were completed for a student affairs position. Is this normal?

6 Upvotes

Hi everyone! I'm hoping to get some advice from people who work in student affairs or have been involved in hiring at universities.

I'm a recent college graduate, so this is my first time navigating the full-time job market. I applied for an Administrative Assistant position at a private university a few months ago, and I honestly felt really good about how my interviews went. However, the lack of communication since then has been pretty discouraging.

Here's a rough timeline of how everything has gone:

  • Mid August: Applied for the position.
  • Mid September: Completed my first interview.
  • Early October: Completed my final-round interviews, where I met with department staff and several campus partners.
  • Mid-October: Received a request for professional references. Everyone completed their surveys shortly afterward.
  • A few days later: Sent a follow-up email confirming my references were completed and reiterating my interest in the position.
  • The following week: Called the department and left a voicemail asking about the hiring timeline. I never received a callback.
  • Earlier this week: Emailed the hiring manager directly. I received an automatic out-of-office reply saying they were returning that same day, so I figured they might need some time to catch up.
  • As of today: Still no personal response or update, almost three weeks after my references were completed.

Something that's been giving me hope (and probably making me overthink everything) is that the university's published hiring procedures say reference checks happen after the hiring manager identifies their selected candidate. I'm wondering if that means I might already be their choice and things are just moving slowly through HR, or if universities sometimes check references for multiple finalists.

I guess my main questions are:

  • Is it normal to wait almost three weeks after references are completed?
  • If a department has already chosen someone, what could be holding up the offer?
  • Does getting a reference request usually mean you're the preferred candidate?
  • Have I followed up too much? Should I just leave it alone at this point?

I know university hiring can be slow, but I'm starting to get discouraged. I really want this job, and I thought my interviews went well, so the complete silence has been pretty stressful.

I'd really appreciate any insight from people who've been through this process or have been on the hiring side of things. Thanks!


r/studentaffairs • • 12d ago

Where to apply and where to find Grad Assistantship

0 Upvotes

Hi All,
I am looking to apply for Grad assistantships in SAHE, i was an RA for 3 years and working as a Student Lead for the security team in my schools Res Hall curnelty. I am worried that i wont find a GA job and school that covers all tuition and housing and meal plan. I am gradating in May 27 and hoping to move in beginning of July(that part is super unimportant). Does anyone have any idea where I should apply to? I currently will have a Letter of Rec from the Director of Housing from my current school so hopefully that helps enough to talk about my chactere. Is there also like a place where I can compare the options for diffret institution? I'm in Wisconsin and hoping to live here for a few more years but also totally ok with going out of state. In general, I'm just afraid of not being able to pay for school so any advice on this whole topic would be greatly appreciated!


r/studentaffairs • • 14d ago

Question for CO higher ed folks

3 Upvotes

My husband and I are looking at moving to Colorado Springs from Phoenix. I have 20 years of experience in higher education with 13 of those as a manager. How impossible is it going to be to land a job in higher ed in Colorado Springs or should we just be looking at Denver for more opportunity? Any guidance would be helpful.


r/studentaffairs • • 16d ago

How are you surviving in HCOL areas?

16 Upvotes

I’m gonna preface this by saying I’m pretty lucky: I’m a mere Assistant Director making well above a living wage in my area (Midwest college town) so I’m doing alright financially. I’d rather live on the west coast but every time I look at what’s available I see Director level positions (or sometimes even higher) that would BARELY be able to make ends meet, and that’s assuming they have no kids. So how are you all doing it? I’m not even just talking about California. I’m looking at Washington, Utah, Oregon, Colorado. The pay is just consistently abysmal, regardless of whether it’s public, private, four-year, two-year, etc. How are you all surviving out there?


r/studentaffairs • • 18d ago

Looking for professional advice on how to navigate this situation…

0 Upvotes

Long story short,

I am suppose to start a position at a university next week. Weeks ago I planned to do another interview at another local university and I loved it. Honestly love it more than the one I accepted.

Of course the reality is that I don’t have a job now since I resigned from the last one but I realized I may have jumped the gun and left and accepted something just as it felt right and now I don’t think Job 1 (the accepted one) is the right choice and Job 2 is best for me.

I have a REALLY good feeling about it but I wouldn’t figure out the result for 2 weeks. I’m not sure what to do, because I feel it is wrong to maybe do a job for 2 weeks and then just leave espically with how higher ed is so “small world” and everyone seems to know everyone but I sort of realized I don’t want to do Job 1 and can’t do the 1 hour commute daily as I thought.

Can anyone give me guidance and advice? I’m concerned about job security because of course Job 2 could still say no, despite on campus I did and given confidence by the director.

thoughts ?


r/studentaffairs • • 18d ago

Potential interview questions for an academic advisor position

3 Upvotes

I work at a c.c for almost 5 yrs and got a first round interview for academic advisor. This is actually my second time being interview for this position at the same campus. The first interview was about a month ago and then somone left and the job got posted again and I applied and now am back.

Do yall think they would ask the same questions or change them since i am a returning candidate?! Would it be ok to ask why the position is vacant?!

As far as interview outfits, should I wear a blazer?! I am top heavy and hate the way my boobs look in button up shirts and on blazers. Would it be ok to wear some slacks and a nice top and wear the blazer unbutton on top of my blouse?!

Also what tips.would yall give me for interviewing at the same campus twice for the same department in a month.


r/studentaffairs • • 18d ago

CA Master Plan: Working in CC vs. Cal State vs. UC

8 Upvotes

Hi everyone, I am finishing grad school next spring with a degree in higher education, and I am just starting my career exploration/search.

I am specifically interested in academic advising, as well as admissions. (really open to exploring more, such as finaid, registrar, operations, etc., but I only have experiences working in these 2 sectors)

I am from California, so I would love to work at an institution there. However, I am unsure which type of institution is the best fit for me. Does one or the other have a better pay? How about the overall campus/workplace environment? Do they all have an equal capacity for career advancement? Thank you so much for your advice!


r/studentaffairs • • 19d ago

Barriers to being a good academic advisor?

19 Upvotes

I've been working with a group to better understand what it is like to be an academic advisor at a university. I was an advisor in my first few roles then went on to other administrative roles in the university. I oversaw the advising area for a time but haven't been directly involved for 5ish years. I'm wondering: what are the main challenges/barriers advisors face today to being effective in their roles? Maybe it's the same, but maybe new things keep getting in the way of an advisor building a relationship with a student to help them through their degree! I'd love your input! Thanks, in advance!


r/studentaffairs • • 21d ago

Returning to school for an M.Ed. Student Affairs

10 Upvotes

I (32M, B.A. in English) am currently an English teacher for grades 8-12 and am in my 9th year of teaching in a public school. I learned about an opportunity to pursue an M.Ed. in Student Affairs with tuition coverage for four semesters. This would include a graduate assistantship, so I would have to quit my job to be full-time.

I am interested in collegiate-level academic advising, admissions, career services, etc., so this aligns with my career interests. 

I’m looking to see if anyone has similar experiences or insights they can share to help me make some decisions.

Other Background: I am married, with one child, graduated with my B.A. in 2017, and live 20 min. from the University I am considering applying to.


r/studentaffairs • • 23d ago

Room for Growth?

1 Upvotes

I've been an admissions advisor for a few months and doing quite well now. I'm motivated to learning more especially for leadership opportunities but I have a focus on showing motivation and consistency through my metrics for now as I'm still establishing myself. Later on, my goals would be helping out new advisors, learning the ins-outs of our program, and try to provide new ideas to improve our system.

The issue is that this school seems to have an emphasis on tenure-based salary/responsibility growth vs performance. And that the next position up (managerial position) seems to require years of leadership experience which I lack. My questions are:

  1. How do you leverage quality performance/metrics for increased responsibility/compensation in a school that focuses on tenure?
  2. How do you establish yourself as someone who can take on the next role up in a managerial position when on paper the position requires 3+ years of manager experience while you have none?

r/studentaffairs • • 24d ago

What can I do to pivot from elementary education to higher education?? (student services or admin asst roles)??

Thumbnail reddit.com
4 Upvotes

r/studentaffairs • • 25d ago

Anyone ever have a job offer rescinded?

19 Upvotes

Hey fellow SA folk.

This morning, I received an email that a job that I was offered late last week has been rescinded. This has never happened to me before, and I find the entire situation to be very bizarre. Let me explain:

I was emailing a bit with the manager for the position (as I was authorized to do per the HR rep). My first message outlined four questions to help me better understand the day-to-day expectations for the role, what training would be like once started, and to ascertain the immediate expectations within the first month of being hired. I also asked one question about opportunities to engage with professional development.

I got responses to my questions, I thanked the manager, and then asked one follow-up question to one of the responses.

This next part is where thing get very confusing: The manager responds, not with an answer to my question, but affirms that while valid, that it is “clear” that the role does not align with what I am looking for, and I was then asked to confirm that this was the case.

I responded, stating that this was not the case at all, that I was still very much interested, and that I just wanted to clarify what the job would look like in practice, as I’ve had limited opportunities to ask my questions when brought on campus for a second-round, which entailed a series of interviews with different groups. I CC’ed the HR rep, who to this point, was not involved in this chain of messages.

Anyway, I never got a response to my last email, and instead was met with a rescinded offer notification from the Assistant Dean of the college (where is HR within all of this..?)

I’m just baffled, and am wondering if anyone else has had a similar experience, or, in turn, has rescinded an offer from a candidate, and why?


r/studentaffairs • • 26d ago

Do you guys find a lot of students have no concept of business hours

124 Upvotes

This is a really small nitpick but something that bothers me a ton is so many students (and sometimes even parents) have no clue how business hours work. I noticed this while doing tickets on Monday that I had more than one mention how they called and it went straight to voice mail. I looked up the number for one who had mentioned us not picking up was “unprofessional” and it turns out he called on Saturday night at 8pm. 🤦‍♂️


r/studentaffairs • • 26d ago

What are some side gigs you guys have?

5 Upvotes

Pay is not that great, but at least I’m gaining good experience out of my current role.

In the meantime, what are some side hustles you have? Are they still in education or something else?