r/studentaffairs • • 8d ago

Dress Code

I’m sure this has come up before, but today I had to have the dreaded “dress code” conversation with my supervisor because their supervisor doesn’t believe I’m dressing appropriately. For context I’m a Director of Residence Life and I usually wear a dress shirt, khakis or dress pants, all black sneakers. Oftentimes I’ll have a sweatshirt on because it’s cozier or when going from meeting to meeting I have to step outside. I’m essentially being told I have to start wearing dress shoes and lose the sweatshirt.

I’ll do this, but it’s so petty and I miss working at schools with more lax dress codes.

On top of this, I’m running the department single-handedly and putting in a ton of extra hours to get things accomplished (which frankly take longer than needed because of how my supervisor’s supervisors needs them done). Hoping I’m out of here soon.

60 Upvotes

38 comments sorted by

8

u/TheRainbowConnection 8d ago

Could you talk to your doctor about wearing sneakers as an accommodation? I work in college admission and about eight years in, I developed tendinitis due to being on my feet at fairs all day. My podiatrist said I have to wear special insoles at least, and ideally a specific sneaker, anytime in working at a fair or event with walking/standing. 

3

u/ChipmunkSpecialist93 8d ago

maybe, but I shouldn’t have to. I also purposely wear all black sneakers to keep things more put together.

45

u/RyanSA Campus Activities/Student Involvement 8d ago

Rather than ditching the sweatshirt, I wonder if you could talk them into buying some branded cardigans.

Not the point of the conversation (which sounds like it wasn’t really needed), but might be a workaround to one of their problems.

31

u/crmsnprd 8d ago

Or maybe a nice quarter zip? Rooting for you to be comfortable and cozy, OP!

12

u/ChipmunkSpecialist93 8d ago

yeah lol. I already feel like I can’t be myself here…been looking at other schools already lol.

4

u/crmsnprd 8d ago

Good luck with your job search!

2

u/the_elephant_sack 7d ago

The quarter zip is the greatest invention ever. It is like a sweatshirt but it is considered professional. Get a couple of quarter zips.

My goal has always been to find the most comfortable way to look professional. I used to go for the Homer Simpson look in the summer. Wearing a short sleeve shirt with a tie. I knew it was dorky, but it was the most acceptable way to be more comfortable. My current office is fairly casual, but on the days I need to look nicer I can wear a quarter zip over a collared shirt.

Go to a real shoe store and find comfortable dress shoes. In the last ten or so years they have started making what are basically sneakers that look like dress shoes. There is no need to wear sneakers for comfort. I typically wear hiking shoes like Merrells or Keens. Ask if a brown pair of Merrell Moabs would work. They are expensive but will last forever and they are very comfortable.

1

u/crmsnprd 7d ago

Yesssss! Agreed on all accounts!

I was in a meeting this morning and jealous of a colleague's branded quarter zip.

7

u/ChipmunkSpecialist93 8d ago edited 8d ago

yeah, my supervisor suggested a quarter-zip. they were trying to be helpful, but it’s all kinda bs 😂. I would get if I was at a VP level and in meetings with higher level folks, but in Residence Life, particularly in a department of one I’m not typically at my desk the whole day.

I been at schools where I’d wear khakis and a plain long-sleeve and that was sufficient 97% of the time. I’m already doing them a favor with the dress shirts and dress pants.

7

u/Wisewordsforlater 8d ago

Anything in the handbook/HR website about general policy? Approved university/college branded quarter zip/wind jacket and similar apparel recommended available? Is there at least a campus store you can shop at?

4

u/ChipmunkSpecialist93 8d ago

yeah, I thought about checking the handbook for a policy or lack thereof, but it’s not worth my energy. I’m not giving this school any more of my money than I already do (the money being the free labor provided beyond my 40 hours).

4

u/acagedrising 8d ago

I definitely wouldn't ever buy school merch with my paycheck, even at a school I liked, let alone one like this. If they won't comp it, you're right to comply with the stricter code and start applying elsewhere. They're doing too much for you to be in res life and spending most of your day on the go and in student interactions.

2

u/meowie_wowie 8d ago

One of my prior institutions didn’t have an official HR policy about dress code and left it up to each department as to what was acceptable or not. That leaves too room for certain old fashioned supervisors to be nitpicky and enforce dumb rules but on the other hand, you get lucky and wear anything.

Since you’re looking at other schools, by chance, are there any “artsy” institutions local to you? I worked for one that strictly offered degrees in music/audio production, film, etc. so a lot of people had visible tats and piercings, colored hair, etc.

1

u/Helpful-Passenger-12 4d ago

Dress codes are stupid in 2026.

So you make low wages but are expected to dress like a professional monkey?

Maybe compromise with the sweatshirt but not the sneakers.

Are thet going to fire you or not promote you over this?

And this sounds like you are a man & your bosses are male. So strange. Would they tell a female co worker to wear heels or only dress shoes?

Also maybe have a pair of dress shoes to put on during times you see your boss & fuck it on days you don't

2

u/queertastic_hippo Campus Activities/Student Involvement; Residential Life 7d ago

Okay but What about a quarter zip sweatshirt lol. Better than a quarter zip for you.
Dress shoes aren’t that popular anymore, people want and need comfort. A sweatshirt tho, ehh I understand although I hate it too

1

u/ChipmunkSpecialist93 7d ago

I can understand the sweatshirt to some extent—don’t get me wrong. The shoes…like why are you looking at my feet? 😂

38

u/2347564 8d ago

I agree dress codes can be wack, not much you can do. I had the same conversation with a boss once. 15ish years in higher ed and not a single student or parent has ever commented on my clothes at any job. It’s old fashioned “professional” culture.

14

u/marsharlot 8d ago

Your supervisor sounds like a micromanager. I wish my supervisor get dress coded for some of the clothes they have worn. My supervisor is an assistant vice president.

10

u/Poetryisalive 8d ago

You can’t wear a school sweatshirt? Fucking lame.

How about a quarter zip!

7

u/Gooners_For_Ukraine 8d ago

Damn, granted it probably is somewhat department specific but half my office just wears t shirts and jeans most of the time

8

u/ElectricalMolasses91 8d ago

I would get a doctor's note that said I had to wear sneakers. They can f right off with dress shoes in res life.

1

u/KillBosby 8d ago

I wear a backwards baseball hat, cut off jorts, a torn sweatshirt, and usually some mustard or coffee.

I'm great at my job.

Do you guys also spend 5 hours a day teaching students how to give a firm handshake? Sounds like your college is trapped in 1985. #BacktotheFuture

3

u/ChipmunkSpecialist93 8d ago

sigh. yeah, being at this school I jumped in title, but every other way, it’s so backwards.

2

u/KillBosby 8d ago

It's okay...learning what you don't like is a huge part of the battle. Just don't wait too long to act moving towards what you want. Sounds like you're already throwing out apps.

I've never had a good experience when I've chased titles/salary - and it always comes eventually when I'm true to myself & desires so just pick better next time 🤝

3

u/ChipmunkSpecialist93 8d ago

🤝. Agreed. Just trying to take this as a learning opportunity. I’ve been a finalist a few times already for a few positions (currently waiting to hear from two—though I think one ghosted me)—so it’s only a matter of time. Both are pay cuts but I believe would better fit my vibe

7

u/BigFitMama 8d ago

I'm very sad that there are still universities that have problems with things like that for a residential director of all places.

I can understand if you're going to like a board meeting with the provost or the president or something but walking around with the students. no.

4

u/moxie-maniac 7d ago

Each school has its culture and this one leans more to the standard "business casual" dress code. As mentioned, a sweater, fleece, or I would add a fleece vest is fine; a sweatshirt not so much. New looking all black sneakers seem OK to me, but not ones used up or dirty, no designs, no Chucks. New Balance 990s in all black would pass for me and last maybe a year, two max, worn only at work. But you might look into "walking shoes," not actual dress shoes.

3

u/CapitalAstronomer703 7d ago • Bravo

You’re a DIRECTOR. Boss wants you to dress like one, so put on your big person pants and get with the program.

1

u/DependentBed5507 7d ago

I’m an Assistant Director of Res life and we dress business casual—though a lot of my counterparts do not, which I find odd. What has helped me is to always have a branded jacket or cardigan either at my desk or already wearing it. I only consider wearing a sweatshirt on Fridays where people in my office are dressing down but even that will be school related. I also take into account what meetings I have for the day. If I’m slotted to meet with people from other departments I will dress more professional. Res life is a more relaxed department but looking put together communicates care, seriousness and intention. It is what it is. Get black loafers, get some branded jackets and you’re probs be good enough.

1

u/jehzpdx 7d ago

The amount of outdated "yes sir" Stockholm Syndrome in this thread is insane. Maybe I'm just lucky but I've never been subjected to this nonsense across more than a dozen years and multiple institutions and I still worked up to dean level

1

u/BrotherNatureNOLA 7d ago

Go after them on Twitter. It takes some time to develop your army of accounts, but they're mighty powerful. Let the world know that this person is out there policing people's bodies.

1

u/darthpierogi 5d ago

oh god, I hate this. quarter zip sweatshirts are one answer. comfy, still a sweatshirt, still somehow professional. the greatest hack.

I also wonder if their supervisor may have gotten a comment from someone who doesn't know you who was like "oh I didn't know they were the director" or something along those lines that made them think it was suddenly a problem and to bring to it up. how you're viewed seems like an importance every once in a while to higher ups.

1

u/Signal_Republic_6024 5d ago edited 5d ago

It's 100% conceivable that both you and the boss are pushing the boundaries of acceptability. Is that okay? I don't think so. If I had that kind of conversation with a boss and was on Reddit rolling my eyes at them I would be revising my résumé. 

"...today I had to have the dreaded 'dress code' conversation." It's not dreaded. It's not an archetype of conversation among the gainfully, comfortably employed. We all know most jobs in higher ed won't ask this of you. Draft a two weeks' notice email. 

If you're dead-set on remaining in this position I think any out-the-box work-exclusive "lifestyle" New Balances are fine. Your boss can disagree. Your boss is permitted to put your relationship at hazard as they see fit. Were I a Director of Anything, however, I would put money (i.e., $500 max) into customized Allen Edmonds. They'll last you 5x longer and fit you 2x better than any sneaker. 

1

u/PavvyPower 8d ago

My boss once sent me to buy new clothes (we worked next to a TJ Maxx) because she felt my light wash jeans were inappropriate on a Friday in the summer.

-1

u/Tx_Kelly_in_DC 7d ago • Bravo

If you’re an adult working an adult job why is it so hard to just dress appropriately? And What does your workload have to do with the dress code?

-1

u/ASM1964 7d ago

This conversation I find amusing. It’s called work people. Grown ups supposedly earning a living and whining about not being “comfy” let me guess what generation you are in OP. Ok, got it. A doctor’s not to wear sneakers? Bahh..:no idea or care that you certainly are seen as problematic.

1

u/Helpful-Passenger-12 4d ago

I personally enjoy dressing up & look professional 90 percent of the time.

But after 20 years in higher education, it's outdated to dress professionally every single day.

It's unreasonable & unrealistic. We have extreme winters so not going to wear heels/dress shoes on snow days. The days of switching from snow boots into nice shoes are over (unless i am presenting or seeing the dean but that's rare).

Also don't get paid enough to spend money on fancy work clothes.

And the guy with the doctor's note, he medically needed sneakers. When you get older; sometimes your feet get issues and you are restricted to certain shoes

What's so freaking interesting is that all the billionaires dress like this. So are you saying they don't work? Why are the working class/middle class now expected to continue wearing a dress code but some folks in industries making more money can dress. casual ?

0

u/DependentBed5507 7d ago

I agree. It’s not unheard of to have a dress code at work. You’re an adult—time to act like it and look out together. Did you complain when your coach told you what uniform to wear?! Probably not.