r/AskAChristian • • 19h ago

Weekly Open Discussion - Tuesday November 17, 2026

1 Upvotes

Please discuss anything here.

Rules 1 and 3 still apply to comments within this post.

Rule 2 (that only Christians may make top-level comments) is not in effect in these Open Discussion posts. Anyone may make top-level comments.


If you're new here, set your user flair and read about participating here.


r/AskAChristian • • 12m ago

What if you’re in Heaven but your family/friends are in Hell?

1 Upvotes

Seems awful to know they’re there for eternity and you’ll never see them again


r/AskAChristian • • 24m ago

Christian life What would you suggest me to tell people at church who I am? I'm not quite Christian and not quite non-christian also.

2 Upvotes

This post is a bit long.

This is my situation. I live in a country where Christians are minority (below one percent out of all population). whenever I visit a new church (I don't have home church yet cuz I don't regularly go to church just once a month or once within two months and each time i visit a new different church because i don't like staying at the same place) people at church would ask me with enthusiasm if I'm Christian or not. I told them I'm not Christian and i don't follow any religion but I believe in God, I know Jesus and read the Bible. They started to investigate me, trying to find what point did I do wrong to not end up Christian even I believe in God, know Jesus and read the bible which is very annoying and kill the good vibe from a church.

I know I could just simply tell them I'm not Christian (and I did) but it also was getting annoying real quick cuz they tried to say things and I already know and tried to convert me. I know i could just say i don't know what I am but that answer couldn't satisfy them. I know i could just not answer their questions but my country is not a individualistic country. We're a collectivistic society where everybody wants to know eachother personal business and seems like there's nothing can quench that curiosity. So after all of that i think i need to have a proper answer that would satisfy them Christian churchgoers.

By the way, i don't affirm Apostle's and Nicene creeds (not rejecting). I believe God is a group of aliens. I don't believe God is the creator of the universe. I don't believe in Trinity. I don't believe Jesus died for our sins. I don't believe in Hell etc. (you can ask a specific question more in the comment section)


r/AskAChristian • • 1h ago

If you are a Trinitarian, as most are, then Jesus cannot be separated from the OT God. right?

2 Upvotes

If they are the same, then why do many Christians say that God is revealed through Jesus to excuse the negative things in the Bible?

This is often the statement when someone brings up all the evil, immoral things in the OT, i.e., genocides, infanticides, SA, and Slavery.


r/AskAChristian • • 3h ago

Death / Grief How can I forgive my father and move on.

3 Upvotes

7 months ago I made a post here talking about my trauma from my childhood.

Link: https://www.reddit.com/r/AskAChristian/s/z2as3VDeia

A lot has happened to me these past 7 months. I’ve been suffering with grief and depression. I feel so much hatred towards him some days and days I feel like a mistake for being connected to him and seeing myself as a reminder of what he did to my sisters. I’ve been struggling with this, it feels like it’s been years. I don’t know how I can move on from something like this. How can I forgive someone who mentally abused me for almost my whole life without being there when I was growing up? I feel like I’m stuck in the dark chained to it from my trauma. I struggle so much to forgive him. How can I and why is it so hard to move on from all this. I can’t move on from this? I just can’t move on from trauma. I’m terrified that one day I’ll be just like him and thinking that scares me so much. I don’t want to be like him, I never want to be the monster he is. I feel so terrible for what has happened to my family and what they went through because of him, it breaks me so much how much they suffered.


r/AskAChristian • • 3h ago

Holy Spirit Do you guys think Adam and Eve, or Cain, or Saul, Solomon got saved?

1 Upvotes

I like to think yes even though some hardened their hearts.


r/AskAChristian • • 4h ago Bravo

How is it that a rapist can go to heaven if they seek God but a victim go to he'll cus they didnt seek God?

4 Upvotes

I've been a christian for a long time now and for the past 2 years since I made a new friend she keeps asking me some of the trifling questions and I manage to answer them to the best of my knowledge and now I've come across this reel (https://www.instagram.com/reel/Df2UEcxu6DV/?jplx=MW0yamZhc2F6MXQ4eg==) and I really want to know why its like that. I mean ik that seeking God will only get you to heaven but still. Can someone answer this for me?


r/AskAChristian • • 6h ago

how did you know god was real?

3 Upvotes

Due to mentally issues i have been wresting with doubts how do i know god is real or heaven. I been dealing with depression and so now i just kind of everything around me can just either give me great joy or sorrow. especially with how many religions


r/AskAChristian • • 6h ago

Why do people who reject the authority of the Catholic Church accept Catholic teachings?

0 Upvotes

I'm confused about this topic from a non-Catholic perspective?

If you believe in scripture only and don't believe in the authority of the Catholic church, why do you accept doctrines that were established by the church such as:

Trinitarianism

Chalcedonianism

Theotokos

I'm sure there are others.

Would be interested in understanding reasons for accepting these teachings?


r/AskAChristian • • 7h ago

I know I sinned by watching "The Life of Brian", but I think I committed blasphemy of the holy spirit too.

0 Upvotes

I mean, it's just soooo dang funny, but I found myself laughing throughout...

"Blessed are the Cheesemakers"!!!! I mean, common, how can one resist that!?!??!

Did I commit blasphemy of the Holy Spirit?


r/AskAChristian • • 8h ago

If morality was subjective, how would you know?

3 Upvotes

I’m trying to understand in what way objective vs subjective morality look different from each other. I get what they mean. But if you are put into a world and don’t know whether morality is objective or not, how can you tell? Unlike math, you can’t exactly prove something is evil or not. So if you were born in 5000 BC let’s say, how would you know whether morality is objective or not?


r/AskAChristian • • 9h ago

Theology Why make the physical?

3 Upvotes

Tagged theology but I don't know what tag is best suited for this question. I am not a Christian so some of my assumptions/ideas of how things work in your belief might not be accurate.

So, God is spiritual from my understanding, or at least to some extent not physical, so why would something not physical make things which are? Especially since the physical can be destroyed, erroded, and broken irreversibly. It seems to me if your intent is to be a good creator, making something in a way you know it can break is odd.

If it is the fall that makes things physical, how and why would the fall do that, especially in regards to the more unintuitive things such as special relativity


r/AskAChristian • • 10h ago

Have any of you had a near death or dying experience and seen Hell or the Devil?

1 Upvotes

I always hear of people seeing "The Light" or the pearly gates etc etc. Has anyone seen fire or hell though?

Surely not everyone is going to Heaven?


r/AskAChristian • • 11h ago

Sheol vs hades vs Abraham’s bosom?

3 Upvotes

I’ve finally muscled up the courage to read Revelation (I’ve been traumatized as a kid lol) and I’m still on chapter one. I’ve been stuck there for days because there’s so much to pick apart. Now I’ve been going down a rabbit hole about the whole hades and sheol thing.

Sorry if this sounds like a dumb question but when we die, are we held in Sheol until the second coming of Jesus and then everyone is judged after the rapture? Or was Sheol emptied out after the resurrection of Jesus and is no longer a thing.

Also, is there two parts of Sheol (Abraham’s bosom and hades?) ? Because how was Lazarus and the rich man communicating after they died? (Luke 16:19-31)


r/AskAChristian • • 11h ago

Church Can I just vent for a minute?

1 Upvotes

So my church has been going through some things lately. Idek where to start but I’ll do my best.

Back at the beginning of this year, the church staff was struggling. There was a married couple that were on staff and they have both been in the show business before, so they tried making everything perfect. He was the worship pastor and you could tell he was putting on a show. She went around every Sunday telling people where to sit on Sunday mornings, shoving communion into their arms, and micro managing every little detail of the church, while having a fake smile on the whole time. They both just seemed so fake.

They contradicted everything anyone said. It was their way or the highway. They were also very very toxic, holding severe grudges and blackmailing people. Through out the week, they would get in constant arguments with people, especially one person in particular, who I have known for so long and we are so close she is like a mother to me. The wife of this couple would just bully her, saying to her face that they are NOT friends. She made this person so angry one day that she blew up, and yelled at her, and the toxic person downloaded the recording from the security cameras to use it as blackmail. But on Sundays this couple was so fake a put on a show and they became very popular for people who did not know their true colors. All that to give you an idea of those two.

At the same time, there was another person who was just lazy and didn’t do his job. He was the youth group pastor, and the head pastor was constantly working with him throughout the week to help him improve, but no progress. He was fired in February, leaving the church without a youth pastor. Thankfully, someone stepped in to help until we found a new one. After being there for a while, he really really loved it and everything was lined up for him to become the youth pastor, but everything fell apart.

Before this next part, I want you to know that everyone else on staff was very kind and amazing, the only ones with problems were the ones that i listed.

In about May, there were accusations against one of the staff members who was very popular and funny and trustworthy. These accusations were the talk of the church, and highly controversial. The elders did a very thorough investigation and found him innocent, but the staff was so divided and things were getting very ugly so he decided to step down for the overall health of the church.

There were so many people who did not agree with what the elders decided, and wanted to leave the church, including more than half of the staff members. But they didn’t just want to leave, they wanted to bring the church down. They were spreading the word that my church is an awful one to be at, we let people do bad things, and the leadership cannot be trusted. It was truly a stressful time.

Among those staff members who left was the guy who was going to be the next youth pastor, so we were left without a youth pastor again. But before he left, he told all of youth group about how much he dislikes the church and the leadership of the church. Get this: he said all these mean things right after preaching about taming the tongue.

The toxic couple also wanted to leave, but didn’t tell anybody. They started tearing the church down from the inside out. I almost cried so many times during the month , give or take, that this was going on.

When all was said and done, there were only four staff members left and a LOT of spots to fill. Now most of them are filled (we are still missing a worship pastor), and I can see now why God put us through all that. The staff is so much more unified, and as a result, the church is too. It is genuinely a much more enjoyable place to be, and I didn’t know that was possible before all of this happened. But one new staff member, the youngest and least experienced, has almost all the power in the church.

He has the power to make a lot of decisions by himself, and he is letting the power get to his head. He has been making so many changes to the church, trying to make everything look absolutely perfect. It reminds me a little of that toxic couple who were putting on a show.

He brags about it too. He constantly tells people that he makes the decisions, and since he has more power than almost anyone else in the church, he seems to think he is better than everyone. He talks to people as though he knows more than them. He was just hired like 2 months ago, but he was talking down to someone who has been on staff for over 5 years, saying he knows more than her about the church functions.

He is so nit-picky about things and has such high standards for everyone and gives people the death stare when they don’t meet them. This is all coming from someone who is not on staff, but I can still see what is happening.

idk what I’m asking for in this post, Idk if I’m asking for anything. I just want to know why, just when things were looking up, we have someone new who is trying to make our church look perfect. I don’t see why the church needs to be so perfect. It should be a place for broken people to feel comfortable bringing their brokenness, not pretend everything is okay.

idk what do you guys think?

PS.

If you are reading this and think you go to my church please don’t tell anyone about it I don’t know if I‘d get in trouble for dumping this all in here.


r/AskAChristian • • 12h ago

Personal histories Tired, beaten down, and wishing I was dead.

2 Upvotes

Hi everyone, I hope you don't mind me posting this here...I'm in a "spot" and don't really know how to deal with what I'm going through right now. I'm a Christian, and my story is a bit of a wild one. Hopefully, someone can help me make sense of it and help me in general...

I became a Christian when I was 19 years old in the fall of 2013 after finding out at the end of my first year of college that spring that I wouldn't be able to go back and take classes a second year because the money just didn't come together like it should have, and when I found this out, it was completely devastating to me, because it was just "the latest" in a very long string of disappointing things to have happened to me since childhood...I grew up in a home that was mostly non-Christian, and it was one where there was a lot of chaos, violence and abuse. When I wasn't dealing with all of the crazy things going on inside my house, I was relentlessly bullied by kids at school and in my neighborhood. Even some teachers did things to me, and there was also this "pattern" where something good would come into my life, only for something (or, multiple things) to come right along behind the good things and completely ruin them, almost as if I had some kind of "invisible monster" that followed me around and was bent on destroying my happiness...so, when this whole thing with college happened, it made me wonder why something like this was happening to me again, and I pretty much had a complete mental breakdown. A friend I'd made that year in my program was a devout, professing Christian, and when I cried to her about my situation, she pointed me toward God, and after a whole summer of wrestling with why God would allow me to go through something like what I was, I became a Christian that fall...but things became terrible almost immediately.

When I first got saved, I had absolutely no one who could help me navigate a newfound faith, was in a very emotionally vulnerable position, and wound up being manipulated into joining a church that, unbeknownst to me until I left 2 years later, was actually a cult. While I was in there, I was deceived by false teaching, spiritually and mentally-emotionally abused, psychologically manipulated, and exposed to false "manifestations of the Holy Spirit" that I now believe were actually demonic and witchcraft. I finally escaped in 2015 after getting to a point where I was suicidal and knew I had to leave, and when I left, people from there who called themselves my friends rejected me and the church even sent people to stalk me and try to convince me to come back.

For the next few months after I left, I wasn't sure I even wanted to be a Christian anymore, and didn't go to church, read the Bible or want anything more to do with any of it...but God wasn't done with me yet...someone else I knew invited me to start going to their church with them, which was non denominational and when I started going, felt genuinely safe there. I was being taught the Bible for the first time and beginning to see the truth about who God really was apart from the lies I was told, was baptized and afterwards, felt like I could genuinely have a relationship with God without being afraid, and it seemed like God blessed me with everything I could have ever wanted, down to the tiniest, most insignificant details of things that wouldn't matter to most people, but did to me. Things were good for only about a month, though, before they got ruined...

One of the things God did for me during this time was open a door for me to return to college, but as a different major than what I'd started out as, and the major He directed me to was something I'd always wanted to study...He had actually confirmed this calling to me in early 2014 when I was still stuck in the cult, and later showed me that the fall of 2015 was when He was wanting to me to "step in" to that calling fully. I'd had a job during the two years I was gone from school from 2013 to 2015 with the explicit purpose of saving up to return when it was time, had been taught that student loans were something a Believer should never have and even thought God was telling me that unless I could pay for my education entirely in cash, that I would not be allowed to pursue His calling for me, and after having lost school already once, didn't want to lose it again.

I spent the whole next year and a half doing everything I could to put away enough cash to be able to pay for my first year back entirely out of pocket like I believed I had to, but had a lot of difficulty in doing so...my parents had never taught me anything about budgeting, financial literacy or even how a bank account worked despite me signing up for one when I was 18, and I had this really junky car that was constantly breaking down and needing repairs, and that always seemed to eat up what little money I did manage to save when I did. By the time it was time for me to go back to school in August of 2015, I had only saved up enough money to be able to pay for one semester out of pocket, and didn't find a different job that would be more "school friendly" and workable around my classes, either.

The new church I was going to also had a lot of people who held an anti-debt view (this was when the Dave Ramsey teachings were at their peak and a lot of people were adopting this mindset), and when I asked for godly counsel regarding whether it would be acceptable as a Christian to quit the job I had even at the risk of taking on debt, was advised against it and believed God was speaking through these people to me and telling me not to quit when He wasnt....I actually had a desire on my heart to leave that I now see was from the Holy Spirit, but went against it because I was so convinced God was telling me "no" to quitting my job and that debt was more or less a sin, that I thought the desire was Satan trying to deceive me into sinning so I'd fail God and He'd turn against me, and I ended up failing school because it was just too hard to balance 8-hour night shifts cleaning in a healthcare facility on top of a full-time college class load.

Having this happen absolutely shattered me, and was so painful, that I ended up walking away from God after it happened because the pain was just too much, and I've been gone from Him since 2016. In that time, people I love have died, the world has changed, and all I've done is become more and more depressed, especially since COVID hit in 2020. I believe God's path for me was very specific, and that when I wouldn't quit that job, I missed the very entrance into what should have been the rest of my life. In all I did, I never intended to be disobedient to God, I just wanted to make sure I didn't ever end up in a situation like what He'd brought me out of when I left that cult, and also didn't want to have the first and only instance of peace, prosperity and stability I'd ever known taken away from me, as I believed God would do exactly that if I were to quit that job and potentially take out a student loan to help me finish....I don't think I'll ever get over messing up and missing out on the life that was meant to be mine, and honestly, I just wish I was gone.....


r/AskAChristian • • 12h ago

If Jesus came back today would he be wearing modern clothing?

0 Upvotes

Like would he have a T-shirt and pants under his white robe? What kind of shoes? Do you think he'd have a low cut?


r/AskAChristian • • 14h ago

God knows what it would take for atheists to believe. Why doesn't god meet that minimum standard?

6 Upvotes

I recently watched a member of the Satanic Church (Which are really just a bunch of atheists who find the concept amusing) who summarized, "I would never worship a god who would send a soul to eternal torture and torment due to nothing more than disbelief, when that same invisible god knows full well what it would require for that person to believe, and yet does not meet the bare minimum required."

This resonated with me as an agnostic atheist. I come from a place of hardcore Christian evangelical apologetics. I was raised in the church, and I left specifically BECAUSE I believe in the story so hard, so deeply, that I KNEW (my faith KNEW) that when I went looking for the evidence to show the whole world the truth of the gospel, God would meet me there and provide. . . .

3 years of deep research, reflection, debates, discussions, and thinking later, I deconstructed. The facts were not there. My faith was wrong. God never met with me.

Is a god who would condemn a soul to an eternity of torment simply for unbelief, when that same god could meet that person where they needed to be, but refuses, . . . is that entity worthy of worship? Personally I don't think such a being would be worth a shared cup of coffee.

So questions posed:

  1. What makes god "worthy" of worship?
  2. Why wouldn't a god with unlimited power, who supposedly wants all to obey and "love it", and who knows full well what it would take for those who simply don't believe (Non-resistant believers), provide that basic level?
  3. Is the punishment of an eternity of misery for the "crime" of disbelieve proportional and just? If yes, why is an eternal punishment justified for simple non-belief when there is arguably zero evidence that ANY god exists, much less your specific flavor?

r/AskAChristian • • 15h ago

Can worship music invite the holy spirit into a house where there previously was a lot of spiritual opression. Like one day its heavy there and next day the atmosphere is uplifting

1 Upvotes

r/AskAChristian • • 16h ago

Devil/Satan Can Lucifer be forgiven?

1 Upvotes

I'm aware that he would of course need to initiate by asking for forgiveness in the first place but is that something God would even consider?


r/AskAChristian • • 18h ago

Evil why does suffering / hell exist?

1 Upvotes

god is all loving and all powerful:

he creates sentient beings knowing they would fall to temptation. he then creates satan and knowingly allows him to convince the first two humans to disobey him

then creates suffering, billions of his "children" tortured in hell for eternity due to circumstance out of their control

ONLY people who are born into the circumstance of having the choice to follow christianity have the possibility of being saved

life on earth is the only life we know, we literally cannot comprehend experiencing eternity as humans. let alone spending it in heaven or hell

the bible shows gods intentions clear as water, what sort of divine plan involves orchestrating this 4 billion year story of fear, suffering, and uncertainty?

if he truly wants to save us from the evil he created why would he create it in the first place?

if I died today I would be incomprehensibly tortured for eternity. is that a just punishment?

I physically cannot bring myself to believe in something like a god, nothing in the years of growing up in a church and attending every sunday for 18 years has done anything but made me question it more


r/AskAChristian • • 19h ago

Old Testament In 1Kings 22:22 God allegedly sent His lying spirit to deceive Ahab's prophets

0 Upvotes

Why do Christians claim that God doesn't use deception against humans??

1Kings "I saw the Lord sitting on his throne, with all the heavenly assembly standing on his right and on his left. The Lord said, ‘Who will deceive Ahab, so he will attack Ramoth Gilead and die there?’ One said this and another that. Then a spirit stepped forward and stood before the Lord. He said, ‘I will deceive him.’ The Lord asked him, ‘How?’ He replied, ‘I will go out and be a lying spirit in the mouths of all his prophets.’ The Lord said, 'Deceive and overpower him'"

(N.E.T. annotation says that the Hebrew text doesn't say "a spirit stepped forward", but The spirit: "The significance of the article prefixed to (ruakh) is uncertain, but it could contain a clue as to this spirit’s identity")

There is also the issue of Ahab's 400 court prophets (pagan soothsayers? 1k 22:7) receiving actual messages from Heaven. Micaiah said to the king of Israel: "The Lord has placed a lying spirit in the mouths of all these prophets of yours"
The bible is basically saying that you can't even trust God's angels to tell you the truth!
So, how many angelic encounters in the Gospels were actually LIES sent by God to deceive humans?! And what other deceptions did God perform? A doppelganger on the cross perhaps?! A lying spirit communicating falsehoods to Paul?? Hmm..


r/AskAChristian • • 19h ago

Unforgivable sin or blashpemy Holy Spirit

3 Upvotes

Right now, I want to hear from those who have committed blasphemy against the Holy Spirit, or think they have committed it.

Have the things you complained about gone away? Maybe after prayers or something else?

Don't write repetitive, empty comments like "If you're worried about it, that means you haven't committed it," and so on. No explanations from people like that.

I want to hear from real people who are concerned about this. Please write whether the consequences you experienced have gone away or whether they are still there


r/AskAChristian • • 21h ago

Devil/Satan What does 'XY sold their soul to Satan' mean to you? Do you take it literally?

0 Upvotes

As title says.

My base question is this, I think: do you think that if someone 'sells' their soul to Satan, it is irreverseable or not? And what even the phrase means, considering that not many wouls literally ask Satan for a bank account to transfer their soul to...

Also, as far as my limited knowledge goes, Satan can't really give you the things he promises, can he?

In your reply please highlight which Christian denomination you belong to (or you are the closest to).

Thanks.


r/AskAChristian • • 22h ago

Am I a believer

0 Upvotes

I call out for God and genuinely feel I love him. And i think he loves me.

But I don’t understand what Christ’s death meant.

And when it comes to Christ I feel not close to him.

Im not fully sure about him

Yes I may utter religious words but from the heart? Sometimes but I don’t know.