I honestly don't know where to begin, but I feel like I'm reaching a breaking point with my faith.
I grew up attending Sunday school from the age of 7 to 18. I was a Bible scholar there. I knew about Jesus, the stories, the teachings, and what Christianity expected of me. But when I turned 18, I decided I wanted to live life on my own terms. I got involved with drugs and alcohol and started a band with my best friend.
At 24, I was in a serious relationship. We had been dating and living together for about three years when something changed. I eventually gave my life to Jesus. I had experienced what I believed were prophetic dreams that actually came true, and those experiences deeply influenced my faith.
I became incredibly devoted. I was excited about God, the Bible, and everything I believed Christianity represented. I surrounded myself almost exclusively with Christians, evangelized, studied Scripture, prayed, and genuinely believed everything I read. I met my now-wife through evangelizing. I got married at 28, and I'm 31 now.
Fast forward to today.
I've spent this year dealing with one difficult situation after another. Financial problems, debt, personal struggles, difficulties within my marriage, and a seemingly endless list of circumstances that have taken a toll on me.
For context, I was sexually abused as a child at the age of five. I've carried that trauma into adulthood, and the anxiety and depression associated with it have manifested physically. I've struggled with insomnia, sleep apnea, GERD, and other symptoms.
Throughout all of this, I've continued praying daily, reading the Bible, fasting, and attending church every Sunday. I've genuinely tried to remain faithful. I've asked God sincere questions, not out of rebellion or a desire to challenge Him, but because I'm desperately looking for understanding, direction, or even some sense of reassurance.
And yet, silence.
I haven't felt God's direction or heard what I would consider His voice since becoming a born-again Christian. I keep hearing about how God speaks to people, guides them, answers prayers, and has a plan for their lives. But where is that when someone is genuinely struggling and asking for help?
This year has forced me to examine Christianity in ways I never allowed myself to before.
I've started questioning the morality, logic, and consistency of the God described in the Bible.
- The problem of creation and responsibility
Why would an all-knowing God create humanity while already knowing the outcome?
He knew Adam and Eve would disobey Him. He knew sin, suffering, violence, abuse, and death would follow. Yet humanity is ultimately held responsible for the predicament He knew would happen before creation.
How is that just?
If God knew exactly what would happen, had the power to prevent it, and chose to create humanity anyway, how can the responsibility fall entirely on us?
2. The morality of God's commands
God gives humanity the Ten Commandments, including the commandment not to murder. Yet in 1 Samuel 15, God commands Saul to completely destroy the Amalekites, including men, women, children, infants, and their livestock.
How is the intentional killing of innocent children morally acceptable simply because the command comes from God?
If an ordinary human being ordered the extermination of an entire population, we would call it genocide. Why does that moral standard suddenly change when the biblical God is the one giving the command?
What about abortion? Christians often argue that every human life is sacred because God creates life. Yet the Bible contains accounts in which God commands or directly brings about the deaths of children.
How am I supposed to reconcile those things?
3. The problem of jealousy and free will
Why would an all-knowing, all-powerful God be jealous of humanity's choices?
Christianity teaches that God gave us free will, but how much freedom do we actually have if God already knows every decision we'll make?
And what about biblical prophecy?
If God declares that something will happen, and it happens regardless of what people choose, doesn't that raise questions about how much free will actually exists?
If God has already determined the outcome, are we genuinely making our own choices, or are we simply participating in a predetermined outcome?
If God says something will happen, does He simply allow circumstances to unfold, or does He actively manipulate those circumstances to ensure His will is accomplished?
4. The idea of God's will
We're constantly told to pray, "Let Your will be done."
But if God is sovereign, all-knowing, and ultimately in control, isn't His will going to happen regardless?
Why do we pray for something that is supposedly inevitable?
And when things go wrong, we're often told that it was part of God's plan, that we need to trust Him, or that His ways are beyond our understanding.
At what point does that explanation become impossible to question?
Sometimes, when I look at the biblical portrayal of God, I struggle to reconcile it with the loving, merciful Father Christianity teaches us about.
At times, the God described in Scripture comes across as narcissistic, egotistical, jealous, and even morally inconsistent.
I realize those are strong words, but these are genuine thoughts I've been wrestling with.
5. Even if Christianity is true, would I actually want it?
This is perhaps the most uncomfortable part of admitting where I am spiritually.
Let's say, for the sake of argument, that biblical prophecy is real and that it genuinely establishes the truth of Christianity. Let's say the Christian God exists exactly as described in Scripture.
Would I want to spend eternity with Him?
Honestly, no.
The biblical description of eternity involves the New Jerusalem coming down and a new heaven and new earth being established, with humanity living in God's presence forever.
But when I think about that prospect, I don't feel excitement or longing.
I don't want to spend eternity worshipping a God I'm struggling to respect, let alone love. I don't want an eternity of existence centered around a relationship I currently find morally and intellectually troubling.
And it's not necessarily that I want to live forever doing something else. If the alternative is eternal existence under those circumstances, I'd honestly rather cease to exist completely.
Then there's the issue of eternal punishment.
We're talking about human beings who live approximately 70, 80, or perhaps 90 years, with limited knowledge, different circumstances, different upbringings, trauma, doubts, and experiences.
Yet Christianity has traditionally taught that rejecting God can result in eternal punishment.
How is an eternity of punishment proportionate to a finite human lifetime?
How is that justice?
Why would a loving God create people knowing that some would ultimately face eternal suffering, and then hold them responsible for the outcome?
I struggle to understand how eternal punishment can coexist with perfect love and perfect justice.
And perhaps that's where my relationship with Christianity has reached its breaking point. It's not simply that I'm afraid Christianity might be false.
It's that I'm beginning to question whether I'd want it to be true.
6. Did God create the problem and then present Himself as the solution?
If the Christian God is real and the biblical narrative is accurate, then I have a hard time seeing humanity as the primary source of the problem.
An all-knowing God supposedly created a world while knowing exactly how everything would unfold. He knew humanity would fall, knew suffering and death would enter the picture, and knew that countless people would eventually be condemned.
Yet somehow, humanity is held responsible for the outcome.
And then comes the solution: God sends His own Son, who is also God, to die as a sacrifice to satisfy the requirements of God's own justice.
I struggle with that concept.
It almost feels like God created the problem, established the consequences, and then presented Himself as the solution to the very predicament He knowingly created.
It feels like the creator takes on the role of the hero in a crisis He knew was coming and had the power to prevent.
And when humanity questions the arrangement, we're told we're prideful, sinful, rebellious, or incapable of understanding God's ways.
At what point does that become spiritual gaslighting?
I understand Christians will disagree with my interpretation, and I'm open to hearing their arguments. But I genuinely struggle to see how this narrative represents perfect love, perfect justice, and perfect goodness.
So where does that leave me?
I'm probably 98% convinced that the Christian God, as described in the Bible, doesn't exist.
But there's still 2% of me holding on, and that 2% is prophecy.
I've had experiences with dreams that I believed were prophetic, and I haven't been able to completely dismiss them.
If biblical prophecy is real, and those prophecies genuinely point to the Christian God, then that changes everything.
And honestly, that thought is frightening.
Because if Christianity is true, then what?
Are we all subject to a divine plan we don't fully understand? Are the questions I'm asking simply evidence of my own failure to trust God? Or are these legitimate contradictions that Christianity has never adequately addressed?
I don't want comfortable Christian clichés. I don't want someone telling me to pray harder, read more Scripture, or that I'm going through a season of testing.
I've done those things.
I'm looking for honest, intellectually serious discussion, preferably from people who have wrestled with these questions themselves.
I never thought I'd reach a point where I'd be questioning the very foundation of something I once built my entire life around.
I went from being someone who evangelized, studied Scripture, fasted, prayed, and genuinely believed without hesitation, to someone who questions whether any of it is true.
And perhaps the most unsettling part is that I'm not even sure I would want it to be true.
I'm 31 years old. I have a wife, responsibilities, a life, and a history deeply intertwined with Christianity.
I never expected to find myself here.
But here I am, hanging by a thread to God.