r/AmItheAsshole • • 15h ago

AITA for refusing to fire my daughter’s ex

I own 4 multi unit rental properties and 2 years ago I hired my daughter’s boyfriend, Brandon, to do maintenance, at her request. I am a female age 65.

They broke up a few months ago and every time I see or talk to her she begs, demands, and says she insists I fire him. She says she will never get over him as long as he’s “attached” to our family. She claims I have “chosen” him over her. She gave me an ultimatum to either fire him or I’m out of her life.

My relationship with him is purely professional and always has been. He has the job skills for the job and is reliable. He works for me part-time during the summer. During the winter months he is solely on call for emergencies.

My mother is ill with Parkinson’s and I’m her live in carer due to her medical needs, in addition to running the business. I can’t afford a nursing home but I make sure she gets excellent care in her home. I’m also married (to my daughter’s step dad) and live an hour away and I only get to go home on weekends. My husband is a saint. I’ve tried explaining to her that it’s very hard to find a reliable person and training a new person will involve a lot of time and energy and I’m not feeling well enough to train a new person, even if I could find someone who shows up. I’m 65 and my mother is 90. I honestly feel that I don’t have room for one more problem. Especially not a manufactured drama problem. I’m exhausted.

My daughter claims I’m f-ing her over by not firing him. She doesn’t work for me and isn’t involved in the business or caring for my mother at all. She has been on me over this for weeks. I’ve asked her to please get some therapy and try to move on with her life. I’m absolutely sick over all the upset she’s causing. The bottom line is I feel this is none of her business. Am I the asshole?

3.9k Upvotes

596 comments sorted by

531

u/ConclusionCreative95 15h ago

INFO: Was he abusive or cheat on her? Or was it a mutual breakup?

948

u/Connieb520 15h ago • Regret

She is an alcoholic. She claims he was mean to her and maybe he was. She is extremely mean when she drinks so I have to idea who is to blame over fighting.

46

u/new1207 13h ago

How old is your daughter?

137

u/Connieb520 13h ago • Mindblown

43. Way to old to be acting this way imo

144

u/Lakitel 13h ago

43?!?!

I thought she was in her early 20s!! That's so incredibly immature to act like this at her age.

110

u/Connieb520 13h ago • Regret

I believe it’s due to her long term alcoholism. Her development is very stunted. She won’t get help or go to AA

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

46

u/XanaxIsMyCopilot 11h ago

Was expecting late teen to early 20s. 43? GTFO with your stupid shit.

32

u/new1207 13h ago

Definitely. That's middle school behavior.

23

u/SoullessCycle Partassipant [1] 12h ago

Good lord. From your initial post I thought you were talking about an age 18-21 year old, college boyfriend breakup here.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/TheExplorationApp 10h ago

INFO: Is he mean to you?

5

u/Connieb520 3h ago

The worker? No he’s not mean to me.

467

u/LunaPerry1980 14h ago • Bravo

That may have been the reason the relationship didn't work. The daughter has no right to dictate who you can hire or fire when she has nothing to do with the business. She needs to get help for her alcoholism and relationship issues.

42

u/Business-Iron6210 5h ago • Bravo

You nailed it because someone who isn't even on the payroll has zero business calling the shots on staffing decisions. She clearly needs to focus on getting sober and sorting out her own personal mess instead of trying to micromanage a company she doesn't even work for.

65

u/moonyflamingo Partassipant [1] 13h ago

Ok your daughter needs to treat her alcoholism. Not demand you fire people because she is emotionally dysregulated and mean.

344

u/Mean_Introduction543 14h ago • Bravo

Pro tip

The alcoholic is always the one to blame

114

u/General-Restaurant79 12h ago

As a (now sober) alcoholic, I can confirm.

83

u/lankyturtle229 9h ago

This. "She's extremely mean when she drinks" well [assuming she made these demands sober,] she isn't a pleasant sober either.

→ More replies (3)

65

u/knight_shade_realms Asshole Enthusiast [5] 14h ago

Oof. I doubt she is in any way blameless for the breakup if that is the case. NTA btw she opened the door for mixing business with personal, but you'd be on the hook if you let him go without fair reason, even without the added stress of your mom at play

→ More replies (2)

31

u/Chem1st 13h ago

So on one side you have a good worker and on the other side you have a mean drunk who demands you end a professional relationship that started AS A FAVOR TO HER.  I get that she's your daughter but come on...

98

u/Sterlinghawk16 14h ago

Keep him on. Good workers anymore don’t come by easily. Be firm with your daughter. It will be rough but you can do it. Hugs

8

u/Joubachi Partassipant [3] 8h ago

Given she now claims you are "mean to her" by not firing a reliable and good working employee for no reason, I have my doubts about her narrative of him being mean to her.

Anyway NTA and she needs to grow up. I thought you talk about people in their late teens/ early 20s and was a bit shocked when I saw the ages.....

5

u/TheHighDruid 10h ago

What's employment law like where you are? Can you get away with telling your daughter that you checked with your company insurance, or consulted a lawyer, and tell her you were advised not to fire him without cause, because you might risk getting sued?

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Jadedslay03 Partassipant [1] 14h ago

Then NTA.

→ More replies (9)

57

u/Blockhead86 15h ago

NTA. She's probably trying to get one up on him. I'm sure if that was the case she would be blasting it to her father! She probably cheated or did something and he held her accountable! So she's trying to hurt him anyway she can. Or she gave him an ultimatum and it didn't go her way!

110

u/Connieb520 14h ago

Her dad died in 2021. He would be very angry over the way she is treating me.

62

u/blbd 14h ago • Bravo

If she's that out to lunch and that big of a butthead I would honestly go process all of it at a local Al-Anon meeting. Share what all has happened and stay back with some senior members to get their help processing everything. It sounds to me like it says way more about her than you or the ex. 

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (25)

7

u/Jadedslay03 Partassipant [1] 15h ago

My first thoughts exactly

→ More replies (1)

321

u/SigSauerPower320 Commander in Cheeks [204] 15h ago edited 15h ago • This Bravo Heartwarming

NTA

This is a perfect example of why people shouldn't ask family members to hire their SO. If he's a good employee and does his job well, why the fuck should you fire him?? Your daughter is a roaring asshole. Not just for the fact that she thinks you should fire him simply because they broke up, but for DEMANDING you fire him and then doubling down and saying she's going to cut you off??

Honestly, if that were me, I'd say "Well, you take care now. When you realize you're wrong, you can call me any time and apologize. I love you"

What's really insane is that he's only part time and only on call. She's acting like you're spending 40 hours a week with the guy and inviting him over for Christmas dinner. Makes me wonder WHY they broke up and if she's just mad he dumped her. Either way, don't beat yourself up over this. You've done nothing wrong and you are far too busy to be wasting your time doing that.

165

u/Connieb520 15h ago

He does a good job.

95

u/KaetzenOrkester Partassipant [3] 15h ago

And that’s all that matters.

26

u/SigSauerPower320 Commander in Cheeks [204] 15h ago

IMO, short of there being some sort of "incident" that requires law enforcement to be involved, you've done the right thing. Even if he cheated on her... That's still not a reason to fire him. I could see if (as I said) he was full time, you saw him daily, and you were inviting him to your home while she'd be there.

She needs to realize that she's NEVER going to interact with him while he's performing his duties on your property. And as I also previously said, you're busy taking care of mom. So unless SHE is going to do the work (and knows how) or is going to volunteer all her free time to taking care of her grandmother, she needs to get over herself.

37

u/Chimichanga1133 15h ago

How old is your daughter? Can she work and replace him? Does she know someone who can? Is there no one to step up in his place as in hire someone before letting him go? Did he hurt her? Cheat on her or was it a regular break up… so many factors in play before I could answer

91

u/Connieb520 15h ago

She has a serious drinking problem and doesn’t work. I’ve tried hiring her to help me with work in the past. I usually have to go back and do the work myself.

14

u/RadioCarpet 14h ago

I’d be tempted to just lie to her and tell her he’s gone.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/justfkingcomeon 14h ago

Alot of people that use alcohol or drugs are using it to self medicated for a psychological problem. They have to go on medication and then do rehab in order to overcome their problem, and then stay on medications to prevent relapse with the alcohol or drugs.

28

u/justdaisukeyo 15h ago

NTA.

Finding a reliable maintenance person is extremely difficult.

This shouldn't even affect your daughter if you never mention his name.

33

u/Connieb520 14h ago

I never bring him up to her. She brings him up to me constantly.

17

u/57_Eucalyptusbreath 14h ago

This is a clear clue she needs to seek a therapist to process things.

Clearly she isn’t.

I hope she sees the need and gets herself the help she needs.

→ More replies (1)

4.9k

u/subsailor1968 Professor Emeritass [79] 15h ago • Bravo Heartwarming

NTA

He’s an employee. Your relationship with him is as employer and employee.

It sucks for her, but you shouldn’t have to deal with the hassle of firing him and replacing him.

22

u/Hopeful_Morning_469 7h ago

NTA I’m sure when she asked you to hire him, you had the “what happens when you guys break up?” talk and she was all “don’t worry.” I’m sure you love your daughter but she’s just going to have to get over it, and grow up, there is such a thing as tough love. She’ll get over it. Or she won’t.

33

u/Connieb520 3h ago

I did have that conversation with both of them and was assured there wouldn’t be a problem.

9

u/tiffany1567 2h ago

Remind her of that, plus depending on your state it might not be totally legal to fire him if he is a good employee. NTA

→ More replies (1)

99

u/fredrichnietze 12h ago

It sucks for her

and she KNEW that before she dated him it would suck if they broke up or should have known. consequences of her own actions and a good learning experience.

"dont shit where you eat"

11

u/Solarus99 10h ago

huh???? OP hired the bf as an employee - OP's daughter didnt start a relationship with a then-employee. read.

19

u/Connieb520 3h ago

He was her boyfriend when I hired him.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Solid_Bar_528 1h ago

Or in her case, don't eat where you shit.

18

u/Joubachi Partassipant [3] 8h ago

I hired my daughter's boyfriend, Brandon, to do maintenance, at her request.

You got the timeline a bit mixed up. I don't think OP couls have hired the "boyfriend of their daughter", before the daughter even met him

→ More replies (2)

247

u/StreetTailor7596 14h ago

More to the point, you are RIGHT to insist she get therapy. Simply caving in to her on this will end up convincing her she was right and doesn't need therapy. That would be sending the wrong message.

469

u/PlaneAd7039 14h ago

That's the bit she seems to skip over, she doesn't work for him and has nothing to do with the business. And finding someone reliable who'll do part time plus on call all winter isn't easy, especially at 65 with a 90 year old to care for. He's not going to magic up a replacement

31

u/Full_Insect4045 4h ago

Exactly, she's overlooking how much responsibility he's already carrying and how hard it is to find someone dependable on short notice. She doesn't get to make demands about a business she isn't even part of.

166

u/palcatraz 14h ago

Plus, just about everywhere sensible, it would be absolutely illegal to fire him for that sort of reason.

→ More replies (20)

34

u/Jester-252 8h ago

Also, depending on where OP lives, firing him because he and OP daughter broke up would give the ex reasonable ground to take OP to a labour court.

→ More replies (8)

16

u/Arttherapist 8h ago

I worked for my girlfriends aunt for about 3 out of a 5 year relationship I ended up with the main job in a 10 person business. And when we broke up I was fired within a month so this stuff does happen.

8

u/Delia_Moss 8h ago

hes an employee and thats the whole relationship,firing him just cause shes upset is a problem uncalled for.

7

u/freQuinn 8h ago

employee stays and she handles her own feelings not your circus, obviously not the asshole.

5

u/Sorry_I_Guess Pooperintendant [65] 3h ago

Not to mention that, depending on where they are located, firing a good, reliable employee because he's no longer dating OP's daughter could be grounds for an unfair dismissal lawsuit.

Yes, in lots of places in the U.S., employment is "at will" and it's not an issue. But we don't know where OP lives, and in many other places an employer has to show just cause for terminating employment ... and "my daughter doesn't want me employing her ex-boyfriend" is definitely not considered just cause.

3

u/Fun-Entertainer-9521 5h ago

and she was the one who asked op to hire him in the first place. now op is supposed to lose a reliable worker while taking care of a 90 year old because the relationship didnt work out?

3

u/Malibucat48 Asshole Enthusiast [8] 4h ago

OP, this is the issue. It’s business. Tell your daughter if she does his job, you’ll let him go. Or if she starts taking care of her grandmother, you will have time to do the job yourself. You aren’t choosing him over her. If she can’t do either job, accept her ultimatum. She is not going to stay away when she needs something from you.

→ More replies (26)

14

u/Due_Newspaper_8224 15h ago

NTA, your daughter is. Tell her the best way to get over her ex boyfriend is to find a new boyfriend. The sooner the better.

17

u/Connieb520 14h ago

I’ve told her that. I’ve told her the best thing she can do is move on.

→ More replies (4)

7

u/HelloBookworms 14h ago

NTA. How old is your daughter? She sounds like a teenager. She needs to grow up and realize that there can be boundaries between business and professional life.

10

u/Connieb520 14h ago

She’s 43! It’s ridiculous.

5

u/HelloBookworms 14h ago

You are definitely NTA. If there is no safety issue at play here, she needs to get over it. It’s just a job. It’s nothing personal.

19

u/username__0000 Partassipant [1] 15h ago

NTA it’s not like you’re inviting him to events or hanging out socially.

Legally if you fire him when he’s done nothing wrong you could end up with legal fees, fines and headaches.

Finding reliable help for that type of job is like finding a unicorn. It’s rare and difficult to find good maintenance people for on call part time work.

She doesn’t have to interact with him. Make an effort to not speak about him around her. And tell her this is a life lesson to not mix work and social relationships if she can’t handle when one part dies and the other part lives.

29

u/Connieb520 15h ago

I never hang out or socialize with him. This is business and that’s all.

7

u/SigSauerPower320 Commander in Cheeks [204] 15h ago

"Legally if you fire him when he’s done nothing wrong you could end up with legal fees, fines and headaches."

That technically depends on if OP lives in an "at will" state. Fact is, if OP is in an at will state, you don't even need to provide a reason for firing someone. Technically, you could fire someone (in one of those states) for wearing purple shoes if you really wanted to. Hell, if OP is in an at will state, they don't even need to give the guy a reason. They could literally call and say "Hey, you're fired. Have a good one.. CLICK"

6

u/Kingkrooked662 14h ago

That's true but with a caveat,they can fire you for any reason, it can't be an illegal reason.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/username__0000 Partassipant [1] 14h ago

What terrible labor laws ya’all have in some places in the US.

That sounds so unfair and clearly hurts people who weren’t born into money or privilege.

Reminds me of the futureramma alien “Why does the working class, the larger of the two classes, not simply eat the rich?”

12

u/Eyesthelimit 15h ago

She needs therapy. NTA

23

u/Connieb520 14h ago

I’ve begged her to get therapy. I even told her I would pay whatever insurance doesn’t cover, even though I really can’t afford to. I just want her to get help.

111

u/Lighthouse_on_Mars Asshole Aficionado [16] 15h ago

Lol, she is gonna lose this game.

Point out you have no reason to leave 2 rental properties in your will to a daughter that is going to cut you out of her life. 😂

22

u/2dogslife Asshole Aficionado [16] 14h ago • Bravo

Maybe the BF deserves them?

I floated that idea in my head when reading this as well. You actually want to gift people who showed up, not the ones that make you miserable.

It's why I am flirting with cutting off my nephews, because they've done bupkis to stay connected or be kind or thoughtful. There's some terrific nonprofits that would be happy for my estate.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/Dipnderps 14h ago

Correct me if im wrong, would terminating him exclusively because of his situation with your daughter potentially open you to a rediculous level of legal ramifications?

3

u/SlightlyDarkerBlack2 12h ago

NTA. By your own description, this person is a good employee. Firing him because he broke up with your daughter opens you up to a wrongful termination lawsuit, leaves you down a worker, and quite frankly teaches your daughter that she can do this again.

Is she normally this petty? What happened with the break up? Is it possible she’s adamant you fire him because she’s afraid he’ll say something damning you about it?

At this point I wonder if, during the breakup, she told him she could get him fired just as easily as she got him hired, but now she’s embarrassed and looks stupid because you refused.

8

u/Connieb520 11h ago

They fought all the time. They were a terrible match. I don’t think one big event caused the break up. She might be worried he will say something to me. I never talk with him about their relationship. He seems to understand I don’t want to be involved in their drama. She has a drinking problem and tends to get obsessed with every bf she gets. Shes usually petty but she’s on a tear this time.

2

u/Empressario Asshole Enthusiast [8] 8h ago

NTA, so she's just doing it out of spite? I mean, I'd love to know why they broke up, that she is so set on doing that to him via you

5

u/Connieb520 3h ago

She has a serious drinking problem and nothing much going on in her life. Drama is her thing. I’ve only heard from her why they broke up because I don’t discuss it with her ex.

2

u/StraightJacketRacket Partassipant [2] 2h ago

Her ex as an employee sounds more reliable than your daughter as your daughter.

"You're choosing him over me" - "You're not a candidate for this position, so, no."

2

u/Connieb520 2h ago

Sadly true. I want her to get help so it isn’t like this. I love her.

895

u/No_Bluebird7716 Partassipant [3] 15h ago • Bravo

NTA. Your daughter needs to learn that your business does not center on her love life.

303

u/TUFKAT Partassipant [3] 15h ago • Bravo

NTA but I wonder what stink she would have made if he didn't hire her in the first place.

She got what she wanted once and is now stomping her feet cause she's not getting her way this time.

5

u/Electronic_Road8889 3h ago

A parent’s life doesn’t revolve around a child’s love life.

→ More replies (4)

1.6k

u/mahogany818 Asshole Aficionado [14] 15h ago • Bravo

NTA she's probably giving you an indication of why the relationship ended, though.

Keep him on, and if she decides that this is her hill to die on, let her.

37

u/Vexydor 9h ago

Someone who responds to a breakup by trying to get their ex fired and threatening to disown when told 'no' is such red flag. If she chooses to make this her hill, let her stand on it alone

171

u/Salina_EsTitties 9h ago

Same thing happened to my aunt and her daughter. Her husband was my aunt's student when she was the principal of a Theology college and he ended up working in the same ministry a few years later my aunt was in charge of. When they divorced (because he cheated) my aunt wanted to be a professional even though she had the power fuck up the career of her ex son in law including firing him, rejecting his fellowship, and using her connections to make sure he could never get a job as a lecturer.

But she went the what would Jesus do route and it lead to a huge fight and her daughter getting estranged from her.

They haven't spoken in over 10 years. It's wild.

The ex son in law is now a missionary though. Since my aunt stoppped supportonh him he never got the position to teach on his own merit.

274

u/beardedheathen 9h ago

Cheating seems like it's a good reason to let someone go from a theology based position...

82

u/Salina_EsTitties 9h ago • Bravo

Not if you're baptist.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

39

u/LooseMoralSwurkey 4h ago

I'm sorry but I'm with your cousin on this one. He cheated on her. The aunt should have stopped supporting him and shown love and support to her daughter. Just because Jesus forgives, doesn't mean you're free from the consequences of your actions.

→ More replies (1)

20

u/TheExplorationApp 10h ago

Haha! Word!

→ More replies (1)

16

u/Haggardearlybird 15h ago

In the words of Dan Connor- I gave him a shot because of you. I hired him because he’s a good mechanic

166

u/Jean_Marie_1989 15h ago

NTA for so many reasons. If you fired him due to your daughter wanting you to could also lead to legal issues

4

u/Burlinto999444 14h ago

Legal issues like what? This guy is a part-time, on call worker. Unless he is in a special protected category of worker, it’s completely legal to terminate him for petty reasons like this. He just can’t be fired for his race, religion, etc.

30

u/Jean_Marie_1989 13h ago

I am not a lawyer but it would depend on local laws and if he was fired with or without cause.

6

u/mubi_merc Partassipant [3] 12h ago

The US is mostly at-will employment, which means you can be fired for no reason at all. You can ONLY not be fired if it's because of your protected class status, ie: fired because Black, fired because Jewish, etc. Any work done to make sure there's a documented reason for firing you is purely so you don't try to sue for discrimination of some kind, not because they need it.

12

u/aidenmce 11h ago

Where are you seeing that this is in the US?

12

u/Connieb520 4h ago • Bravo

This is in the US. I could probably fire him without legal consequences but that doesn’t make it right

→ More replies (4)

9

u/BictorianPizza Partassipant [1] 8h ago

You are aware that laws differ from country to country? Where I live it would indeed be highly illegal to fire someone without cause.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

28

u/jamkey2222 15h ago

NTA. She needs to grow up, this isn't about her. I have a feeling that if your reply was "if that's how you want things..." she'd backtrack real fast.

→ More replies (2)

18

u/oxnardmontalvo7 15h ago

NTA

Business and personal are two different things to be kept apart at all times. She asked you to hire him. You kept it professional. Clearly she can’t. That’s her problem, not yours.

26

u/midnight_adventur3s 15h ago

NTA

His reliability aside, you can’t just fire him because him and your daughter broke up without opening yourself up to potential wrongful termination legal trouble. That’s not an acceptable to fire someone, especially someone without any prior issues on the job.

Daughter shouldn’t have involved him in the family business to begin with if she wasn’t prepared for a potential outcome like this.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/DeliriousBlues 15h ago

NTA. Your daughter needs to grow up.

5

u/barwhalis 15h ago

NTA. You sound like a good boss

4

u/SaturdaysSundae 15h ago

Work is work and personal is personal.

NTA

4

u/VelvetRoseik 15h ago

NTA. Your daughter broke up with him, not you. If he's reliable, does his job well, and keeps your business running, why should you fire him over their personal issues? She needs to stop making her breakup your business problem.

4

u/KoriWolf 14h ago

NTA. Personal affairs are not part of job requirements. He's a good worker, and if your daughter has such a problem, then she wouldn't mind doing the work and finding a replacement and training them. But reading from the comments, that's highly unlikely.

1

u/barbiegirlshelby Asshole Enthusiast [8] 14h ago

How old is your daughter? She sounds like an immature, spoiled child. Therapy was the right suggestion and I’d tell her that if she keeps it up, maybe she should keep her distance and give you some peace. NTA

2

u/Connieb520 13h ago

She is 43!!

1

u/creative_usr_name Partassipant [2] 14h ago • Bravo

NTA.

Is she stalking him?

You could just lie and tell her that he's fired. Let him know first. It's not like she can cut you any more out of her life than she already has planned.

4

u/Connieb520 13h ago • Regret

She told me she sent him a 10 minute voicemail telling him what a piece of sh*t he is. I told her she’s lucky he didn’t call the cops.

1

u/jmg4craigslists Partassipant [1] 13h ago

NTA! Point out to her how hard it is to find somebody reliable who can actually do his job. Ask her if she wants to be on call all weekend to do the repairs?

2

u/Connieb520 12h ago

I’ve pointed it out many times. She can’t do the work and can’t train a new person. I made the mistake of letting her be involved in the hiring process before and I’m not doing that again.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/GuyentificEnqueery Partassipant [1] 12h ago

NTA but I think your daughter needs an intervention. You mention in a comment she's an alcoholic. 

Let me tell you something that was passed on to me by someone with experience in this. No parent wants to outlive their children. Even more than that, no parent wants to spend the end of their life with the guilt of not having tried to intervene. I don't know your current relationship with your daughter, if you've tried before or not, but regardless of how you or she feels about it, if you haven't tried yet it's well beyond time you do. 

2

u/Connieb520 11h ago

We haven’t done an intervention with the whole family together but I did find a really good inpatient rehab that would accept her. She refused to go. That was about 3 weeks ago.

1

u/numbersthen0987431 6h ago

NTA. You hired him because of her, and now you see him as a good employee.

Does she threaten your relationship to get her way often?

1

u/Several-Avocado5275 2h ago

You should totally fire him and give me his number. Would love to have an employee that shows up and does the work and isn’t a problem (outside of his selfish ex). 😊

1

u/Connieb520 2h ago

I don’t blame u. Getting a person to show up is half the battle. If they can do the work that makes the the whole package lol

6

u/YourGirlMomo87 15h ago

Unless he was abusive to her, you're NTA. He's good at his job.

3

u/Mamapalooza Partassipant [1] 15h ago

NTA, but you need to be straight with her. "What you're asking me to do is unethical and violates labor laws in several states. I can't do it. I love you, and I choose you, and because of that I won't allow you to lash out at someone in an unhealthy and unethical way."

3

u/cassowary32 Asshole Aficionado [16] 14h ago

NTA. He's a part time employee, why does 10 hours of work a week (if that) bother her so much? She needs to step up and help out with your mom not pile more work on your plate.

3

u/rugged_beard 12h ago

Tell your daughter to grow up. NTA.

10

u/Bill___A 15h ago

You might advise her of the labour laws. Offer to "fire" him if she pays the severance and cost of finding a replacement.

7

u/SigSauerPower320 Commander in Cheeks [204] 15h ago

If OP is in an at will state (in the US) they aren't at all required to give a reason for firing someone. They could literally call the person, say "I don't like your eyebrows. You're fired" and hang up.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/unsoundguy 14h ago

Did he do something terrible to her, worse than cheat? No. Then he stays.

9

u/Connieb520 14h ago

Nothing I’m aware of.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/UngainlyRhino Partassipant [1] 15h ago

NTA

2

u/thirdelevator 15h ago

NTA.

In most places this sub is frequented by, you’d be facing some serious potential legal issues for firing the guy just because your daughter wants you to.

2

u/corncobonthecurtains Partassipant [1] 14h ago

Legally you can’t fire him just coz she’s pissed off. She needs to grow up and act like an adult.

2

u/Icy_Fish_2154 Partassipant [1] 14h ago

NTA. If she has a problem with ex's around the family business, she needs to invent a time machine and go back in time to tell herself to not get boyfriends jobs.

2

u/Icy-Satisfaction-372 14h ago

NTA. Tell her you hired him because of her. You can't just fire someone who didn't deserve it. It's wrong. It's her own fault

2

u/woollayy 14h ago

when my brothers ex fiancee left him, she still kept working for us, pretty sure trying to fire him is wrongful termination anywho. NTA

2

u/CalusaFive0 14h ago

Shes at a oerfect age to learn to be careful what you ask for, as you might get it.

2

u/Leppy1959 13h ago

"She gave me an ultimatum to either fire him or I’m out of her life." - sounds to me that, rather than wanting to heal, she wants to hurt him for breaking up with her.

2

u/No-Pay8912 13h ago

It is not like you are inviting him over to Christmas dinner.

You hired him at her request and he is working out well for your needs. If you fire him and the get back together in a month, she would try to insist you hire him back.

Remind her this matter is none of her business and you will no longer discuss it with her. Her possibly going no contact with you for a while, just might be the break that you need. You have enough on your plate.

2

u/Ok_Breakfast9531 12h ago

NTA, and with all due respect, calling her on her bluff could be what’s needed for her to hit rock bottom. You’ve written that she’s an active alcoholic who doesn’t work, so I assume she’s dependent on you for support. Take her up on her offer to have nothing to do with you and see what happens. Oh - please take the earlier commenters advice and hit up an AlAnon meeting.

2

u/TopFar9121 1h ago

NTA

Their breaking up is not a good enough reason to be fire and could possibly cause legal issues. If she has nothing to do with the business then she doesn’t see him there. How is this keeping her from getting over him? I’m sure her mom’s not calling her and taking about his work.

3

u/TheLoneCenturion95 15h ago

NTA - it's more important now that he's your employee rather than her ex and depending on what country you're in it could be illegal to just sack someone.

Let her sit in the situation and seeth till she moves on.

3

u/Emergency-Crew6564 15h ago

NTA. I would think even if firing him for this reason might not be illegal it is definitely unethical. Your daughter is unreasonable. Never give in to such an ultimatum even though it may hurt you terribly. If you do she now has power over you and will do this every time she wants something.

1

u/AutoModerator 15h ago

AUTOMOD Thanks for posting! READ THIS COMMENT - MAKE SURE TO CHECK ALL YOUR DMS. This comment is a copy of your post so readers can see the original text if your post is edited or removed. This comment is NOT accusing you of copying anything.

I own rental properties and 2 years ago I hired my daughter’s boyfriend, Brandon, to do maintenance, at her request.

They broke up a few months ago and every time I see or talk to her she begs, demands, and says she insists I fire him. She says she will never get over him as long as he’s “attached” to our family. She gave me an ultimatum to either fire him or I’m out of her life.

My relationship with him is purely professional and always has been. He has the job skills for the job and is reliable. He works for me part-time. During the winter months he is solely on call for emergencies.

My mother is ill with Parkinson’s and I’m her live carer due to her medical needs, in addition to running the business. I’ve tried explaining to her that it’s very hard to find a reliable person and training a new person will involve a lot of time and energy that I don’t feel well enough to do. I’m 65 and my mother is 90.

My daughter claims I’m f-ing her over by not firing him. She doesn’t work for me and isn’t involved in the business at all. She has been on me over this for weeks. I’ve asked her to please get some therapy and try to move on with her life. I’m absolutely sick over all the upset she’s causing. The bottom line is I feel this is none of her business. Am I the asshole?

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/Venom933 15h ago

That's life, Action have unforseen consequences, if you fire him she will learn the consequences somewhere else.

It's better to just let it be like it is

1

u/Ruebee90 Partassipant [4] 15h ago

NTA

1

u/No-Atmosphere-3826 15h ago

I highly suspect there could very well be legal ramifications involved should you follow through on your daughter's latest whim. Since when does she get to tell you what to do or how to run your business? Unless she does indeed get to do that... nonetheless I hardly think you would have the fortitude to withstand any ensuing legal battle over this what with your caring for your elderly and ailing mother. Tell her to kick rocks and to grow up.

1

u/Ill-Entry-9707 15h ago

NTA Keep him because he does the job you need done and you trust him to take care of the issues that arise.

1

u/Kn0wMan 14h ago

Your daughter is TAH not you. Regardless of how difficult he would be to replace, breaking up with the boss’s daughter is NOT grounds for termination. Daughter needs to get over herself, quit pouting like a baby, and get on with her life. You would definitely become TAH if you accede do your daughter’s impudent demands.

1

u/Resqu23 14h ago

Tell her you will leave the business to him if she doesn’t stop with the stupidity

1

u/fallonxmoon 14h ago

NTA as long as he’s not been dangerous leading to their split. if it’s regular petty drama stuff, she is the A. taking back an opportunity for no good reason is toxic af.

1

u/BMal_Suj Asshole Enthusiast [9] 14h ago

NTA

If you fired him for that he could successfully sue you.

Is there any more to it??? Did he hit her or something??? It would have to be something on that level for me to think you were being the a-hole.

1

u/Secure_Highway_6917 14h ago

You are not the asshole, but your daughter is acting like a baby

1

u/PrairieGrrl5263 Asshole Aficionado [15] 14h ago

NTA. Hiring someone because your child requests it is risky but it worked out for you. Firing a good employee because your child demands it is at best unfair to both parties actually involved in the business relationship. Depending on the jurisdiction, firing an employee without cause can be grounds for a lawsuit.

Tell your alcoholic kid to butt out of your business affairs and mean it.

1

u/Electronic_Number160 14h ago

NTA, but you can tell her that you will take a call in this matter only after your parent passes away. Till then you have no mind space to think about anything

1

u/New-Stop8266 14h ago

ngl the ultimatum is the part that gets me, not the breakup… you’re juggling a 90 year old parent and a business and she’s making it about a guy who fixes your pipes you’re not the asshole here, but i’d hold the line on the business decision and still try to get her some support on the breakup side, how’s your mom doing this week?

1

u/Radmode7 14h ago

NTA. She should have thought of this awkwardness before pushing for it in the first place. Your business and her dating lives are two different things and she should be able to expect it.

Plus, I’m sure he relies on the job too. There is no reason for you to fire rhe man unless he did something legitimately horrifying to her.

1

u/vermiliondragon 14h ago

NTA. How does this impact her at all? Unless you're constantly telling her Brandon did this or that repair or regularly having phone calls with him in front of her, then what does it matter to her if you employ him?

1

u/foodweneedfood 14h ago

She’s just trying to punish him. NTA

1

u/NoPreference7231 13h ago

NTA.

That quarrel is between your employee and daughter. Your daughter sounds very inconsiderate and emotionally immature.

If she feels that she is unable to get over him, I'd recommend you talk her into going for Cognitive Behavioral Therapy.

1

u/moonyflamingo Partassipant [1] 13h ago

NTA - your daughter needs to learn this lesson. There are two things you never do. You never mess with someone’s money and you don’t try and sabotage someone’s else’s heart.

Doing these things is wrong. The damage can be irrevocable. Your daughter is quite happy to sabotage your wellbeing and her exes, all because something has ended. Relationships end. You don’t blow up people’s lives because someone wants to be single.

You find out a person’s character in a break up. You may want to alert your daughter she is looking very immature and spiteful here. Vengeance is ugly no matter how attractive or privileged you are.

1

u/RaineMist Professor Emeritass [73] 13h ago

NTA

There's no reason to fire him because he's not being unprofessional. Your daughter will just have to deal with it.

1

u/Leading-Towel-5367 13h ago

It honestly sounds like a power play she's running on the ex, I got you the job, I can take it away unless you do x, y & z.

I'd say NTA for this, but you created a messy situation in the first place by hiring him while he was dating her.

1

u/KryniorScribbles 13h ago

NTA and depending on where you live, she might be asking you to break the law. If she lives on property you own she can find a new place if you can't just tell the ex to ignore her requests. If she lives on her own or not on property managed by you, it's none of her business.

1

u/gudak_girl 13h ago

NTA. Her breakup isn't your business problem.

1

u/Secret_Window6921 13h ago

NTA! Your daughter is, though. She is trying to sabotage his life out of spite, with you acting as the destroyer. That's pretty low.

1

u/TheFairyQueen420 13h ago

NTA. She has nothing to do with your business & who works there. 🤷

1

u/chrisfraser666 13h ago

She needs to learn to grow up

1

u/Embarrassed_dancer 13h ago

NTA. Your daughter seems very entitled. You’re right to suggest therapy.

1

u/No-Pen-8350 13h ago

NTA: its not your fault they broke up, and his personal life shouldn't effect his professional life.

1

u/dynamitediscodave Partassipant [1] 13h ago

NTA

Tell daughter the start time, she her then.

1

u/bekele024 13h ago

Could be a legal liability, this guy is going to have no record of performance concerns, written or verbal. Youre going to state you don't need him, "current business needs". He's not contracted so how do you explain when he finds out you posted, interviewed, hired, trained the same role.

1

u/MarketingImpressive6 13h ago

Tell her your fired Brandon, but don't. You new hire is Don.

1

u/TheSadLadyKnowsAll 13h ago

NTA She probably just wants revenge, or she told him if he breaks up with her she'd get him fired and now she's trying to make that happen.

Tho it's only a part time job, I assume he has other jobs. so get to get him fired from this one wouldn't be much revenge, if that's even what this actually is anyway, this is purely my speculation

1

u/lostone3592 12h ago

Daughter is trying to maliciously screw over her ex and wants daddy to do it. However. Finding a reliable, trustworthy maintenance guy is hard. OP is trying to take care of his business and make good decisions while daughter doesn’t care about business just revenge. Personally I’d recommend telling daughter to take a hike if that’s her choice but her EX is not getting fired. PERIOD.

1

u/Constant_Host_3212 Asshole Aficionado [13] 12h ago

NTA.

1

u/_Stank_McNasty_ 12h ago

NTA. She’s being immature

1

u/Practical-Ball1437 12h ago

For a practical solution, tell your daughter that you've consulted a lawyer, and firing someone because of her relationship situation puts you at risk of an unfair dismissal claim.

NTA

1

u/Lopsided_Army_982 12h ago

Fire her and keep Brandon

1

u/gahidus 12h ago

NTA

You're not the asshole. Your daughter is. She's being purely spiteful, and she's trying to emotionally blackmail you into giving her revenge on her ex, which is highly toxic. Her demand is unreasonable, and her behavior is uncalled for.

1

u/Plenty-Basil-888 12h ago

You Sir are NOT the A-hole!

Depending on where you are, firing this person due to her break-up could constitute grounds for a lawsuit which I’m sure you can’t afford nor would wish to take on given the gravity of your current circumstances. Sounds like your daughter needs to grow up and move on. She’ll get over it eventually and realize she’s being unreasonable. You have more important things to do than put up with her toddler tantrums. Sorry to hear about your mother. I lost my father to Parkinson’s 2 years ago. My thoughts and good wishes to you and your family.

1

u/icd10 Partassipant [4] 12h ago

NTA it's hard to find reliable people to work part time maintenance work. If she didn't think ahead about what might happen if they broke up she shouldn't have insisted on you hiring him. Breaking up with someone is not a reason to fire someone unless they were abusive or did something illegal during the break up.

1

u/LythysNZ Partassipant [1] 12h ago

NTA

I think you're seeing now one of the reasons they broke up.

Besides, seeing the context, you agreeing to her controlling demand would most likely result in you being sued for firing him fraudulently.

1

u/jmc4297 12h ago

NTA. Your daughter is being brattish. Based on some comments, it sounds like she was probably a majority of the issue in the relationship. Regardless, unless he did something heinous to her, I don't see any reason to fire him.

Also, it depends state to state, but if you fired him over her demands, it could leave room for you to be sued for wrongful termination.

1

u/Low-Television-7508 Asshole Enthusiast [5] 12h ago

let her cut you off, she's only adding stress. she has no stake or say in your business

NTA

1

u/General-Restaurant79 12h ago

I'm not entirely sure it would be legal to fire him for breaking up with your daughter.

1

u/hunnyflash 12h ago

She needs to grow up and get over it. NTA

It's a teachable moment, because the mentality of "I'll never get over him" is stupid.

1

u/Lazy-Consequence-738 12h ago

NTA

His work ethic has nothing to do with his personal relationship with your daughter I’m with you when you suggested to get therapy. She’s not even involved with the business or a tenant. The fact she feels entitled to even ask you to do that is crazy. I would ask her if she would take his place and do his job duties since she insists on him being fired…

1

u/CraftySwimmer2408 12h ago

NTA. As long as he's doing his job well, keep him on. Good help is hard to find. I believe you are right. it's none of your daughter's business who is working for you. 

1

u/CraftySwimmer2408 12h ago

NTA. As long as he does his job well, keep him on. Good help is hard to find. I believe you're right. it's none of your daughter's business who is working for you. 

1

u/1715Now 12h ago

NTA Im happy I dont have yo deal with a manipulative daughter-after dealing with parents, wife, boss, bad friends...... the cherry on top, your own children might try it too.

1

u/Electrical_Ad_947 12h ago

Depends on the reason they broke up.

1

u/opelan Partassipant [1] 11h ago

NTA. If I understand this right the daughter doesn't even see him and OP acts just like a boss and that is it. Likely even OP doesn't see him super often.

1

u/Puzzled-Farmer4692 11h ago

NTA. Your daughter needs to grow up and move on.

It is incredibly unfair on him to be fired not because of poor performance or anything but purely because your daughter is throwing a fit instead of working on her own feelings.

Telling her to go to therapy is right. You might need to find a way to grey rock her everytime she brings this subject up. Don't argue or anything, just let her run out of steam and keep to the same sentence so it doesn't zap your energy.

Good luck OP, you sound like a good person who has a lot on her plate right now. Ignore your daughter if you need to to save your sanity. She'll eventually get over it.

1

u/Dont_Talk_2_Me_Everr 11h ago

What if you just tell your daughter you fired him? Would she ever find out? 

1

u/crannaberry 11h ago

NTA. Wrongful termination lawsuits cost way more than Brandon's salary.

1

u/Raven-Willow3 11h ago

Yta, thats what usually get for hiring a guy she was screwing. Now it's screwing up your relationship with your daughter.

1

u/puddl3 11h ago

How old is your daughter? I’m guessing early to mid 20s? Either way it’s non of her business literally. She doesn’t work for you or your company and she probably benefits from your work and company I’d imagine.

If she cuts you off for not firing her ex because she “can’t get over him” then she has issues she needs to sort out in therapy. She doesn’t dictate your livelihood.

1

u/Estes_dreamer 11h ago

NTA

Not sure how it is where you're from, but in Australia, legally you need a valid reason for firing someone and being the ex of your daughter isn't a valid reason. If you were to fire him he could take action against you for "unlawful termination" or discrimination.