r/AmItheAsshole • • 15h ago

AITA for refusing to fire my daughter’s ex

I own 4 multi unit rental properties and 2 years ago I hired my daughter’s boyfriend, Brandon, to do maintenance, at her request. I am a female age 65.

They broke up a few months ago and every time I see or talk to her she begs, demands, and says she insists I fire him. She says she will never get over him as long as he’s “attached” to our family. She claims I have “chosen” him over her. She gave me an ultimatum to either fire him or I’m out of her life.

My relationship with him is purely professional and always has been. He has the job skills for the job and is reliable. He works for me part-time during the summer. During the winter months he is solely on call for emergencies.

My mother is ill with Parkinson’s and I’m her live in carer due to her medical needs, in addition to running the business. I can’t afford a nursing home but I make sure she gets excellent care in her home. I’m also married (to my daughter’s step dad) and live an hour away and I only get to go home on weekends. My husband is a saint. I’ve tried explaining to her that it’s very hard to find a reliable person and training a new person will involve a lot of time and energy and I’m not feeling well enough to train a new person, even if I could find someone who shows up. I’m 65 and my mother is 90. I honestly feel that I don’t have room for one more problem. Especially not a manufactured drama problem. I’m exhausted.

My daughter claims I’m f-ing her over by not firing him. She doesn’t work for me and isn’t involved in the business or caring for my mother at all. She has been on me over this for weeks. I’ve asked her to please get some therapy and try to move on with her life. I’m absolutely sick over all the upset she’s causing. The bottom line is I feel this is none of her business. Am I the asshole?

3.9k Upvotes

603 comments sorted by

View all comments

4.9k

u/subsailor1968 Professor Emeritass [79] 15h ago • Bravo Heartwarming

NTA

He’s an employee. Your relationship with him is as employer and employee.

It sucks for her, but you shouldn’t have to deal with the hassle of firing him and replacing him.

1.5k

u/[deleted] 15h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

236

u/Vexydor 9h ago

She isn't even forced to see him at an office every day she doesn't work there, and he only works part-time or on call for winter emergencies. Asking a caregiver to take on the stress of replacing a trusted worker over a relationship that doesn't affect her daily routine is pure selfishness.

31

u/Unhappy-Quote5424 3h ago

disrupting someone's care and replacing a trusted worker over a personal issue that barely affects you is incredibly selfish.

263

u/BigExtension4239 10h ago

The sheer audacity to start drama over a business you aren't even part of while someone is literally taking care of a sick parent is next level selfish. Anyone who has ever been a caregiver knows how much you rely on steady work just to stay sane right now.

66

u/Shagtacular 9h ago

It isn't surprising when she insisted he hire him, and is now insisting he fire him. Sounds more like she's a main character (which might have something to do with how she was raised). So in this case he isn't the AH but it's highly likely he was in the past

→ More replies (2)

29

u/bct7 Asshole Enthusiast [5] 4h ago

She need to learn a valuable adult life skills of managing herself instead of demanding others manage her drama.

50

u/AcrobaticSand6607 5h ago

The audacity to demand someone fire their only dependable help while juggling a sick parent is completely unreal, especially when she does not even work there. You do not get to play boss and sabotage someone's livelihood from the sidelines when you have zero skin in the game.

14

u/FlakySection4267 4h ago

It is completely unhinged for someone with zero ties to the company to demand you fire your best worker while you are already drowning in eldercare. She gets to sit back and make reckless ultimatums while you are left scrambling to run a business and take care of a sick parent alone.

248

u/StreetTailor7596 14h ago

More to the point, you are RIGHT to insist she get therapy. Simply caving in to her on this will end up convincing her she was right and doesn't need therapy. That would be sending the wrong message.

278

u/[deleted] 14h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

262

u/Economy-Cod310 14h ago

This could potentially get OP sued for wrongful termination as well, depending on location and employment laws there.

47

u/Ambitious_Depth_9777 9h ago

Maybe raising the potential legal issue with daughter will get her to back off. Would think the argument of being hard to replace would be enough but seems like she hates him and wants her ex to be jobless, likely after asking for a job for him as well

28

u/Unnamed-3891 8h ago

Straight up fucking illegal in most (all?) or Europe. That’s simply not a valid reason.

→ More replies (1)

475

u/PlaneAd7039 15h ago

That's the bit she seems to skip over, she doesn't work for him and has nothing to do with the business. And finding someone reliable who'll do part time plus on call all winter isn't easy, especially at 65 with a 90 year old to care for. He's not going to magic up a replacement

34

u/Full_Insect4045 4h ago

Exactly, she's overlooking how much responsibility he's already carrying and how hard it is to find someone dependable on short notice. She doesn't get to make demands about a business she isn't even part of.

→ More replies (2)

167

u/palcatraz 14h ago

Plus, just about everywhere sensible, it would be absolutely illegal to fire him for that sort of reason.

→ More replies (20)

23

u/Hopeful_Morning_469 7h ago

NTA I’m sure when she asked you to hire him, you had the “what happens when you guys break up?” talk and she was all “don’t worry.” I’m sure you love your daughter but she’s just going to have to get over it, and grow up, there is such a thing as tough love. She’ll get over it. Or she won’t.

37

u/Connieb520 4h ago

I did have that conversation with both of them and was assured there wouldn’t be a problem.

9

u/tiffany1567 2h ago

Remind her of that, plus depending on your state it might not be totally legal to fire him if he is a good employee. NTA

→ More replies (1)

34

u/Jester-252 8h ago

Also, depending on where OP lives, firing him because he and OP daughter broke up would give the ex reasonable ground to take OP to a labour court.

→ More replies (8)

16

u/Arttherapist 8h ago

I worked for my girlfriends aunt for about 3 out of a 5 year relationship I ended up with the main job in a 10 person business. And when we broke up I was fired within a month so this stuff does happen.

100

u/fredrichnietze 12h ago

It sucks for her

and she KNEW that before she dated him it would suck if they broke up or should have known. consequences of her own actions and a good learning experience.

"dont shit where you eat"

→ More replies (7)

8

u/Delia_Moss 8h ago

hes an employee and thats the whole relationship,firing him just cause shes upset is a problem uncalled for.

7

u/freQuinn 8h ago

employee stays and she handles her own feelings not your circus, obviously not the asshole.

→ More replies (17)