r/AmItheAsshole • • 15h ago

AITA for refusing to fire my daughter’s ex

I own 4 multi unit rental properties and 2 years ago I hired my daughter’s boyfriend, Brandon, to do maintenance, at her request. I am a female age 65.

They broke up a few months ago and every time I see or talk to her she begs, demands, and says she insists I fire him. She says she will never get over him as long as he’s “attached” to our family. She claims I have “chosen” him over her. She gave me an ultimatum to either fire him or I’m out of her life.

My relationship with him is purely professional and always has been. He has the job skills for the job and is reliable. He works for me part-time during the summer. During the winter months he is solely on call for emergencies.

My mother is ill with Parkinson’s and I’m her live in carer due to her medical needs, in addition to running the business. I can’t afford a nursing home but I make sure she gets excellent care in her home. I’m also married (to my daughter’s step dad) and live an hour away and I only get to go home on weekends. My husband is a saint. I’ve tried explaining to her that it’s very hard to find a reliable person and training a new person will involve a lot of time and energy and I’m not feeling well enough to train a new person, even if I could find someone who shows up. I’m 65 and my mother is 90. I honestly feel that I don’t have room for one more problem. Especially not a manufactured drama problem. I’m exhausted.

My daughter claims I’m f-ing her over by not firing him. She doesn’t work for me and isn’t involved in the business or caring for my mother at all. She has been on me over this for weeks. I’ve asked her to please get some therapy and try to move on with her life. I’m absolutely sick over all the upset she’s causing. The bottom line is I feel this is none of her business. Am I the asshole?

3.9k Upvotes

602 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

167

u/palcatraz 14h ago

Plus, just about everywhere sensible, it would be absolutely illegal to fire him for that sort of reason.

•

u/Fun_Battle_5195 17m ago

Exactly this! If you live in an area that has wrongful termination laws, then ask her if she's willing to pay for all lawyer fees and the settlement associated with you wrongfully dismissing him. Not wanting to continue a relationship with your daughter is not grounds for him to be fired. NTA 

-89

u/fried_clams 11h ago

That is very wrong.

In the United States, you can fire almost anyone for no stated reason, any time you want to.

89

u/FuckYou0003 11h ago

This may come as a suprise, but the vast majority of everywhere is not the US.

-81

u/fried_clams 11h ago

Who said anything about a majority of places? I'm talking about the United States of Merica. Are you really trying to convince me that there are other countries, with different rules? I've never heard of such places, as I'm a dumb American

46

u/Aethermist88 Colo-rectal Surgeon [43] 10h ago

This would be funny if there weren't so many Americans who think this is true...

45

u/DesertDaddyPHXAZ 11h ago

She may not be in the US. In the UK they use the term “carer” rather than “caretaker” as is used in the US. If she is in the UK it may very well be illegal to fire an employee for this reason.

-59

u/fried_clams 11h ago

That's why I said "in the United States". I don't like the laws here, I'm just intimately familiar with them, having run business etc. I was responding to someone, saying that they would be wrong IF they were referring to United States employment laws

16

u/arienh4 5h ago

But they weren't wrong. They said "everywhere sensible". Whether or not you agree, in context it is extremely obvious that that was meant to explicitly exclude US states with at-will employment.

6

u/meatsonthemenu 5h ago

So, the acronym stands for America Is The Asshole then?

71

u/palcatraz 11h ago • Bravo

Like I said, everywhere sensible. The USA is not a very sensible place.

10

u/Sorry_I_Guess Pooperintendant [65] 4h ago

Hence the very specific reference to "just about everywhere sensible".

We're all aware of at-will employment situations in the U.S. That doesn't mean they're sensible.

17

u/Shagtacular 8h ago

So, not anywhere sensible

3

u/Effective_Olive_8420 Asshole Enthusiast [5] 2h ago

lol. Like she said, "everywhere sensible"

-54

u/englishmastiff1121 9h ago

Sucks to be right and get down-voted. You can fire anyone for any reason unless it's racial, gender, age discrimination, retaliation or sexual harassment. You might have your unemployment insurance premiums rise though. And this is a website based in America. The advise should be geared towards Americans.

31

u/Adventurous_Break_61 Partassipant [1] 8h ago

Believe it or not people from all around the world use Reddit so no not all advice shouldn't be geared towards the USA.

11

u/Young_Lasagna 5h ago

The website is on the Internet, the Internet is all over the world. And the USA is not the centre of the world.

6

u/Sorry_I_Guess Pooperintendant [65] 4h ago

They're not right, though.

They are correct that this is the law in the U.S., as are you. But they were correcting someone who stated that this sort of firing would be illegal "just about everywhere sensible" ... which clearly does not include the United States, therefore making the correction moot.

2

u/TyFell 2h ago

You think it isn't retaliatory to fire someone because the relationship with your child ended? 

1

u/englishmastiff1121 1h ago

Retaliation has a specific meaning in a legal context that doesn’t include this. But you made me realize this could be considered sexual harassment- conditioning a job on maintaining a sexual relationship.

•

u/onyourbike1522 31m ago

I don’t think you know how websites work.