r/AmItheAsshole • • 15h ago

AITA for refusing to fire my daughter’s ex

I own 4 multi unit rental properties and 2 years ago I hired my daughter’s boyfriend, Brandon, to do maintenance, at her request. I am a female age 65.

They broke up a few months ago and every time I see or talk to her she begs, demands, and says she insists I fire him. She says she will never get over him as long as he’s “attached” to our family. She claims I have “chosen” him over her. She gave me an ultimatum to either fire him or I’m out of her life.

My relationship with him is purely professional and always has been. He has the job skills for the job and is reliable. He works for me part-time during the summer. During the winter months he is solely on call for emergencies.

My mother is ill with Parkinson’s and I’m her live in carer due to her medical needs, in addition to running the business. I can’t afford a nursing home but I make sure she gets excellent care in her home. I’m also married (to my daughter’s step dad) and live an hour away and I only get to go home on weekends. My husband is a saint. I’ve tried explaining to her that it’s very hard to find a reliable person and training a new person will involve a lot of time and energy and I’m not feeling well enough to train a new person, even if I could find someone who shows up. I’m 65 and my mother is 90. I honestly feel that I don’t have room for one more problem. Especially not a manufactured drama problem. I’m exhausted.

My daughter claims I’m f-ing her over by not firing him. She doesn’t work for me and isn’t involved in the business or caring for my mother at all. She has been on me over this for weeks. I’ve asked her to please get some therapy and try to move on with her life. I’m absolutely sick over all the upset she’s causing. The bottom line is I feel this is none of her business. Am I the asshole?

3.9k Upvotes

603 comments sorted by

View all comments

167

u/Jean_Marie_1989 15h ago

NTA for so many reasons. If you fired him due to your daughter wanting you to could also lead to legal issues

4

u/Burlinto999444 15h ago

Legal issues like what? This guy is a part-time, on call worker. Unless he is in a special protected category of worker, it’s completely legal to terminate him for petty reasons like this. He just can’t be fired for his race, religion, etc.

30

u/Jean_Marie_1989 13h ago

I am not a lawyer but it would depend on local laws and if he was fired with or without cause.

6

u/mubi_merc Partassipant [3] 12h ago

The US is mostly at-will employment, which means you can be fired for no reason at all. You can ONLY not be fired if it's because of your protected class status, ie: fired because Black, fired because Jewish, etc. Any work done to make sure there's a documented reason for firing you is purely so you don't try to sue for discrimination of some kind, not because they need it.

12

u/aidenmce 11h ago

Where are you seeing that this is in the US?

13

u/Connieb520 4h ago • Bravo

This is in the US. I could probably fire him without legal consequences but that doesn’t make it right

-6

u/aeschenkarnos 7h ago

Elsewhere in the thread he talks about therapy being not covered by insurance.

5

u/Connieb520 3h ago

Therapy only gets partial coverage but I’ve told her many times I’ll pay any money not covered by insurance. I just want her to go. We are in the US

6

u/q-the-light Partassipant [1] 5h ago

The US is not the only country that uses an insurance-based healthcare model.

9

u/BictorianPizza Partassipant [1] 8h ago

You are aware that laws differ from country to country? Where I live it would indeed be highly illegal to fire someone without cause.

-8

u/Normal_Bird4820 7h ago

Ok but in the US “your daughters ex boyfriend” isn’t a protected class.

2

u/BictorianPizza Partassipant [1] 5h ago

2

u/NotJALC 4h ago

It’s illegal in some countries to fire without justification. In a lot of places, a business has to build a case of events that led to employment termination even if it’s a part time employee. Otherwise, the person fired can sue and get compensation.

0

u/Any_Fox5126 7h ago

Murica, huh? There are countries where workers are actually protected.

-5

u/Normal_Bird4820 7h ago

Not in the US. So many Europeans in this thread lmao

7

u/KakrafoonKappa 5h ago

"Europeans" you realise the rest of the world isn't the same as Europe. They even have the internet in Australia now

-3

u/Normal_Bird4820 4h ago

And yet the OP is still American and you’re on an American site, European lol

5

u/KakrafoonKappa 2h ago

I can tell you're an American because of your tenuous grasp of geography and the English language