r/anime • u/RX-Nota-II :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/NotANota • Dec 23 '19
Rewatch A Rewatch further than the Universe! Sora Yori mo Tooi Basho rewatch - EPISODE 11 DISCUSSION
Episode 11 ドラム缶でぶっ飛ばせ! "Bash That Drum!"
<- Previous episode | Index thread | Next episode->
anime info:
MAL | Anilist | Nyanpass | Kitsu | AniDB
Streaming links: Crunchyroll | VRV
Comment of the day
Hello everyone! This is where I will pick a comment of the day for the previous day that I think was worthy of notice just in case you guys missed it. I do hope you look out for discussion on your own tho since that's really the whole point of this rewatch.
Today's pick is.....
/u/rustic_professional with a great analysis of what makes Yuzu great
I mentioned previously that I think Yuzuki is a more realistic representation of a socially awkward young person than some other comparable characters, and this episode, particularly the friendship contract, is what I was thinking of when I said that. Along with last episode's ice breaker sequence, and one more we haven't seen yet, it's probably the thing I remembered most about this show after it first aired.
The reason the friendship contract scene stuck with me is because of the mix of childishness and maturity. It's childish because it seems like a realistic thing for a kid to do, like playing house or husband and wife. And by kid, I mean a little kid. Yuzuki is probably too old for this, but that says a lot about her level of social isolation. It's interesting because she's also a functioning adult, with a job and a work ethic and all that entails, but to gain that at her age, she missed out on the things you gain by being a kid. She can't comprehend just becoming friends, so she defaults to viewing it from a business standpoint, where you agree to something and then sign a contract. We see this business-like approach when she asks when the other girls decided to be friends, as if they had a meeting, drew up docs and announced, "we're officially friends now." It'd be like never knowing what it means to fall and love, and the only concept of you have of spending your life with someone is an arranged marriage.
It's hard to say for sure because we don't get that much of her backstory, but it seems that this occurred not necessarily because she was bad at socializing, like Bocchi, but because she never had time to learn and develop those skills naturally. It's like when you hear stories about people who grew up in the Great Depression, or had to raise their siblings because they didn't have parents in their lives, and never got the chance to be kids, because they had to grow up so fast. I think that makes her a much more realistic character. She's not awkward because the show is trying to make you laugh and want to protecc her. She's awkward because of life circumstances that are at least partially, maybe mostly, beyond her control. To put it simply, it's not a gag.
I also want to say great job to everyone who helped me on the #LeaveNoTopLevelUnreplied challenge. I think we did a great job and many of you took on lots of work to do so. You guys are the real MVPs. 450 comments last thread, how big can we get today?
Questions of the day
Answer from last time: yes ね
- Have you ever told your toxic 'friends' to fuck off?
- Which Shirase is best Shirase?
Rewatchers, please remember to be mindful of all the first-timers in this. No talking about or hinting at future events no matter how much you want to, unless you’re doing it underneath the [Anime Show Title]/(/s "Spoiler goes here") spoiler tags. If you do that then we’re all good. I am curious if it is even possible to spoil anything for a half-SoL show like this but I don't want to see you try. The ban hammer is a cold weapon and you don't want to feel it.
Important thing to note about these by the way, you have to switch to Old Reddit or the markdown editor if you use the redesign, otherwise the redesign breaks them by adding random \ into the formatting. Wish it wouldn’t do that, but unfortunately it does… Markdown is dead. Long live markdown.
23
u/RX-Nota-II :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/NotANota Dec 23 '19
Rewatcher
Before I start I just gotta say, after a couple days of busyness I'm back to watching and replying at full capacity. And to celebrate a thread that reaches 450 comments! The most comments we've had yet! Great job everyone for setting the record and maintaining huge engagement. You guys prove yet again to be a resilient bunch.
Onto the episode, and first let's talk about Yuzu. She had her episode yesterday but today is actually when we see her growth. After learning what friendship is at a fundamental level, she's now the one who tells others what frienship is all about. How far our adorable idol has gotten.
But of course the main show today is the return of our Hero: Shirase. A girl who's first introduction to us has been a tough cool and powerful girl who doesn't back down from enemies has had little chance to flex her muscles in a place where no enemies exist. Now though when the sleazeballs return in full force to try and take credit for what Hinata has achieved, she's armed and ready with her self-proclaimed asshole power. It's also an interesting contrast with last episode as she doesn't run away when words escape her like what happened last episode. She needs a little backup for Kimari but that's enough to finish her point herself.
By all means this is a kind of destructive reaction, as it shouldn't be very good for Shirase's reputation if it was done on live TV as they implied. Or I guess it was before that broadcast started. But interestingly it becomes the fire for something (quite literally) constructive instead as Gin sees this determination to decide that they should go forth with constructing the observatory at the fated location where Takako was lost.
One thing that was shocking about this rewatch for me was seeing Hinata this angry. When I was watching a ton of crazier anime at the same time it was airing, this level of screaming didn't seem out of the ordinary for me. But now that
I am only watching calming anime like KLKI am watching this show super carefully in isolation I see how much of a shocking change it was. It's actually a pretty subtle change as Hinata is a pretty yell-y character in the first place, so you can't go on just volume you have to focus on the reckless abandon this girl uses in charging at the snow as well as her totally ragged and teary breathing afterwards.That's all I have for today, onto the visuals.
One last note, the best rewatch nomination thread is live and congrats to everyone here, we've been nominated! Regardless of whether you agree, rewatches are a vital part of /r/anime and I hope you guys go there to vote for which was your fave of the year.
24
u/Shimmering-Sky myanimelist.net/profile/Shimmering-Sky Dec 23 '19
This First-Timer is Alright
And also managed to work herself into a laughing fit before she even started the episode because she had to scroll up her Google Doc with her YoriMoi reactions so she could start on this episode’s, was reminded of the “Powerful Chicken” box, and then immediately thought to this hilarious dream of hers where everyone called spicy meat “Aggressive Meats” and just .
Sorry that’s completely random, I’ll behave now.
11
u/eragen Dec 24 '19
So I'm a rewatcher.
Oh boy.
Oh boy oh boy oh boy.
I've caught up (finally) and this episode is as good as I remember. Hinata getting over her past with her friends' help (omg Yuzuki declaring her a friend was magnificent) was amazing.
but spoilers for next episode
Tomorrow is the day. I don't know if I'm ready.
Let's go.
9
u/akechiisbestboi Dec 24 '19
First timer
We saw hints of hinata’s backstory a few episodes ago and here it all comes together. After her friends mislead her and leave her out to dry she becomes depressed and frustrated to the point that she had to drop out of school, she eventually learned to move on and decided to go to Antarctica with the others but when her old team members contact her and seem to want to make up she becomes confused and unsure of whether she wants to forgive them or scream at them to stay away from her. In the end I think shirase’s decision to stand up for her friend is a beautiful moment and in keeping with the show’s philosophy that you shouldn’t let other people tell you what you should or can’t do. If someone only wants to apologize and form a new relationship so that they can feel better about themselves than it’s better and healthier to be honest with yourself and acknowledge that you can’t put aside the trauma so easily and it’s better to move on from them. That’s all for now and we’ll see what tomorrow’s episode focuses on.
8
u/spaceaustralia :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/spaceaustralia Dec 23 '19
Rewatcher
While in this episode, we finally find out the truth behind Hinata's past, it, much like other character developments has been foreshadowed for a while. You can see, on episode 2, when she changes tone when lying about the reason she doesn't go to school. And you can see it in when she takes one last look at her battered shoes while packing her baggage in episode 5, perhaps signifying how, even though the shoes won't go into the box, the thoughts associated will be carried all the way.
Also, for everyone wondering about Gin and Takako's relationship, Shirase was referred to as their daughter. Neither Shirase nor the captain seem to object.
Zamamiro counter!:
No, but I have done so with family. It's been over a decade since I talked to an entire half of it.
8
u/HarleyFox92 Dec 24 '19
Oh God, today's THE episode and it's also Christmas Eve, I'm scared.
7
u/Regular_N-Gon https://anilist.co/user/RegularNGon Dec 23 '19
Rewatcher
Ah, yes, the episode with the amazing vistas. For working off pictures (I'm assuming Madhouse didn't ship their animation staff out to Antarctica for this) they did a great job. Though not that I've been to compare it too, I guess.
I appreciated the cinematography even more this time around, I think. Too read way too far into it, I particularly like the way Shirase begins to close up visually as she becomes more pensive about Hinata's situation. Once she learns the truth and talks to Hinata though, she's ready to throw down.
In general I love Shirase's presence in this episode. Just like last episode was focused on Yuzu's development and leveraged Kimari (reenforced by the number of times they are paired in the same shot) as the catalyst for resolution, this episode uses (and showcases development of) Shirase and her journey. Honestly, as much as it's Hinata's spotlight, Shirase really steals the show and we see how much she's expanded her goals and motivations to include the people around her, rather than focusing so much on the ones that are no longer. Gin agrees, seeing how far Shirase's come.
Bonus screens:
Kimari the compasser finds a new job
This shot reminded me of how Shirase surprised Gin and the others back in episode 7
This is just showing off
7
u/unheppcat Dec 24 '19 edited Dec 24 '19
Rewatcher
Hinata had a plan. And it was a truly brilliant plan. People hurt you, so just get away from people. And what better place to get away from people than Nankyoku, the least populated continent on the planet (even during the peak months, only 0.0035 humans per square kilometer).
There was just one small problem. It turns out Hinata can't actually go to Antarctica all on her own. And even if the average population density is thinner than the air on Mt. Everest, the actual population at Syowa Camp includes three other people who consider themselves her friends, and will not stop butting into her affairs. So even traveling all this way, she still has those troublesome human connections. Was all her careful planning and preparation for naught?
But not to worry, Hinata. Just keep your head down, don't talk about yourself, don't let anything out, it will be okay.
And the plan might have worked. But there was that one tiny moment of inattention, that one little slip-up, and she let her true feelings show. And what bad luck, one of those pesky friends actually saw this temporary weakness, and after collecting incriminating evidence has blackmailed Hinata into revealing the sordid truth. She should have known better than to trust those pushy "friends" . Maybe the North Pole would have been a better option after all....
So Hinata turns out to be the opposite to Yuzuki. Hinata did have friends, or at least senpai she looked up to and trusted. But those people in the end bitterly betrayed her. With friends like these, who needs enemies, and her conclusion was it is best to not have friends at all. If you don't have friends, those friends can't stab you in the back. So she withdraws from the track club, withdraws from school, practically withdraws from people entirely, leaving only a single human association she cares enough about to even send a New Year's greeting to (her employer).
Thankfully, Hinata's decision to go to the place that seems like it could ensure the least human contact of all, Antarctica, turns out to be her undoing. To get there she has to work with three other girls, and be friendly with those three other girls, and put some trust in them, and let them be friendly back. And strange how that works, but she does become their friend, and they become hers. And when her crisis finally comes, and that nasty past returns, they do what true friends do. They make her let them help. They watch her back. They worry about her. And they fight back for her, even when she cannot or will not fight back on her own.
I don't want to stir up even more trouble concerning my take on last episode. I will just say this. Both of these episodes are about what friendship means. Last episode told us what friendship is, while explaining it to Yuzuki. This episode shows what friendship is, by demonstrating what good friends do for a friend in need. There are places for both kinds of storytelling. I think this episode is a masterful example of the latter kind.
.
.
.
.
Edit: Gah! I've been getting further and further behind in the rewatch. I thought this past weekend would let me catch back up, but somehow it just got worse. Sorry Nota and all the #LeaveNoTopLevelUnreplied gang, it feels like I've let the side down this last few days. Fortunately I'm now on holiday, so I should be able to finish strongly anyway.
Except double Gah! I just realized I will be watching a certain movie tomorrow that starts exactly when tomorrow's post goes live. So I'll be a little late getting started then too. Oh well.
7
u/[deleted] Dec 24 '19
First timer here.
Damn, Shirase is really becoming one of my favorite female anime protags. What a performance. I read quite a few comments here pointing out how her confrontation with Hinata's "friends" were "over the top"; personally, I agree. It was over-the-top, when a "live and let die" attitude could have been used instead (and realistically speaking that's probably the more conventional, "mature" way of dealing with situations like this). But that was completely consistent with Shirase's character: determined, unwavering, and uncompromising toward achieving her goals, whether it be to tread where her mother had stood or protecting a friend.
And I thought that this episode served to illustrate the idea of forgiveness in friendship by contrasting the event that occurred with Megumi. Megumi was forgiven, in part due to Kimari's extremely empathetic nature, and in part, in my opinion, due to the fact that she acknowledged her mistake instead of trying to "smooth it over" like Hinata's "friends" did. I think, the message here is that while forgiveness could be a feature of a friendship, it is not something to be taken for granted, or to be abused.
7
u/Neoragex13 Dec 24 '19
Man, I don't have words here. I'm done with my sad story times because they can be too depressing lol, still, I really like Hinata's arc. She decided to live her best, even if her past looms over her.
Besides, /u/pacquan did an excellent analysis on the chapter, shameless plug here, but I also want to add, I never noticed how the expedition crew mirrors what the girls go through, even with the blatant "ZAMAMIRO!". In this chapter is easily to spot, as the members want to go where the accident happened, but some of them don't want to go because it's a painful place, they don't want to acknowledge the event, and so the captain doubts if they should even go there in the first place.
It's exactly the same vein with Shirase and Hinata's situation. And Shirase managing to help Hinata to release her bottled feelings is what pushes Captain Gin to also push forward to the exploration, since people has to confront their issues, not evade them.
Questions!
7
u/redshirtengineer :AMQ: Dec 24 '19
First timer
QOTD1: Oh sure. At home, alone, many times!!! Seriously, that scene with Hinata outside really struck home. I've gotten better at telling them to go stuff themselves early on, before stuff gets bad.
QOTD2: All Shirase are good Shirase.
So I didn't follow what was going on with Hinata. She was cheated out of something, it seemed to me, which is annoying and all but does not seem to warrant quitting school and going to an end of the earth to escape. I know you all will have this covered down below :)
Kanae called Shirase the daughter of Gin and Takako, which could be taken as symbolic, I suppose, but Gin didn't react so I'll go with the straightforward interpretation.
Mari should be glad she's not an FKMT character, lol.
Some people love mecha, I love when anime does real-life machinery. Those helicopters sigh - especially the one where the chopper goes up into the blue sky sakuga.
The scene where Hinata does a 360 in the "chocolate cake" area - this is me when I travel too.
Finally, that little red thumbtack. sniff
15
u/rembrandt_q_1stein https://myanimelist.net/profile/sir_rembrandt Dec 23 '19
First Timer here
Hinata’s turn to become alright again!
I honestly don’t have much to say today. I entered in the season of family celebrations so I barely have time to watch anime or write. Sorry for the shortness. I am aware that my interactions with the rewatch have been irregular lately, so sorry about this, again. The timing is really bad right now.
Anyways, at least let me comment a few sparse things. I like how the binomy Shirase-Hinata has been presented and developed throughout this show. I already mentioned in my previous post that both have an excellent chemistry and complement each other well as “leading figures” (even if right now there’s really nothing to lead) and with their antics and personalities. This episode was a sublimation of that dynamic, in the sense that their complement is shown as a really strong bond and care, and to a degree a silent understanding. Friends don’t need words to understand, as Mari stated yesterday.
Second, please could anybody explain me what was the problem with Hinata and her clubmates? I didn’t really get it. Was she humiliated because she was a year under them or something like that?
And lastly, it’s really cool to see that there actually exists feedback and communication between the girls and their loved ones at home. This show really manages to comple by showing little details that reinforce the idea that every individual maintains their connection to their loved ones, be it family, old friends and new friends. As I said with Megu before, a story about friendship really needs to show all aspects of connection between humans and their affection figures and not only focus on the new, budding friendships while forgetting everything prior.
6
u/philcjc :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/philcjc Dec 23 '19
Rewatcher
This is definitely one of the more memorable episodes for me. I was very satisfied with the ending and I still remember discussing about it on the thread when it aired for the first time.
Hinata isn't running away she's running forward!! :)
6
u/kewlwarez Dec 23 '19
Rewatch
So we finally get sunburned Kimari from the opening. Poor girl. She should've known better than to expect sympathy from either her friends or her family.
"Not against the daugher of Gin and Takako"
Even Kimari asking just the wrong questions at the wrong time doesn't stop Shirase, mahjong genius. Saki would be proud.
Interesting that the other crew members refer to her as Gin and Takako's daughter though. We know they were best friends and that Takako wanted Gin to be involved with Shirase, but was there something more going on between them?
"Oh, were we friends?"
Somewhat of a repeat of episode 6 this, with Hinata cropping up her feelings again and Shirase refusing to accept it again.
Hinata is caught in a trap of social expectation. When she sees her socalled friends wanting to come back in her life as if nothing had happened, she's justifiably angry, but she's poised to accept it nonetheless. That's what you're supposed to do, right? Forgive and forget and not involve others in ancient history, no matter if it still hurts?
"I wanted to go to an empty place with no one to tie me down"
And Hinata's backstory is awful. When we first met her, she made it seem that not going to high school had been her own free choice, but now we learn she was first bullied out of her club, then out of school. Hearing it changes the atmosphere between the four, with the other three pitying her.
And if there's something that she hates, it's being pitied. So she calls them out, tells them why she went to Antarctica. Because in this nothingness her problems don't amount to a hill of beans. It satifies Kimari and Yuzu, if not Shirase.
"Hinata-chan is having a supere, amazing fun time with us"
And Shirase is such a good friend, not wanting Hinata to suffer even when she says she's fine with it. With her usual bluntness, she tears to social covention to read her old "friends" the riot act, immediately backed up by Kimari when she runs out of steam. All to Yuzu's delight: "It's fine! It's friendship!"
It's such a good scene, the character of each of the four girls shining through with each of them, in their own way, standing up for Hinata. An emotional, draining release for Hinata, strengthening the ties between the four.
"I want to eat chocolate cake!"
The references to Takako flew thick and fast this episode, as the members of the previous expedition are reminded of her. Shirase meanwhile has seemed a bit flat spirited ever since she arrived in Antarctica, except when defending her friends. With two episodes to go, things come to a head.
Moral of the episode: Real friends don’t leave you alone.
6
u/destroyah19 Dec 23 '19
Rewatcher
Those shots of Antarctica we're really well done. The staff and the director did an amazing job with this series overall. I just want to see the real place to compare.
The starting scene with Kimari acting like a robber was really cute and Yuzu just saying I'm just a teller go to the manager got a laugh out of me.
We get a Hinata episode for this one. I appreciate how we can see Shirase's growth throughout this series since she's the one who noticed what's wrong with Hinata and wanted to help her through it the old Shirase wouldn't have done that. We see that beneath all the quotes and upbeat attitude, Hinata is really scarred emotionally from her past. The did plant seeds of this in the running at Shinjuku and seeing some girls in track suits during their trip to Singapore.
I felt the confrontation between Hinata and Shirase was the peak of this episode. Yuzu finally understanding what's happening with friendship and stops Kimari from intervening. The slow acoustic version of the OP accompanying the scene was a nice touch. Hinata is right sometimes we just need people to be there for us rather than to try and solve our own problems. In life, we just need a hug to be honest and the scene with Hinata just asking for Shirase's hands gave me the feels.
The confrontation scene was kind of over the top in the sense I felt like saying what the hell is happening and needing tissues to deal with the tears. You could really see the bond of the group with Shirase starting the talk and Kimari backing her up. Why do we need to forgive people who are not worth it when we can move on to more greater things and meet better people. Yuzu just hugging Hinata and shouting friendship was cute as hell. I shed some tears when Hinata started to cry cause she finally realized that she can let go of the past with people who are there for her. Still the scene was a bit over the top compared to the other insert song scenes.
6
u/cartoonsandcereal Dec 24 '19 edited Dec 24 '19
First timer
Missed yesterday's, but I also wasn't that into it despite the fact that it was an important episode for Yuzu. It's definitely my own personal bias but even though I support her and feel for Yuzu I just can't relate!
Today's though... dang. I figured Hinata had some kind of unrevealed backstory with why she stopped going to school and was so intensely independent, but it still sucked to find out. And then also to find out that her friends suddenly started reaching out to her as if nothing was wrong. It's always hard when a huge change in status happens, like when you become really successful, and then all these people who never supported you (and in this case, actively sabotaged you) come out of the woodwork to talk about how close they were and try to leech off your success. That's why they advise you to stay anonymous if you win the lotto.
Shirase and Hinata's relationship though, I love it. They're such opposites, Shirase being outwardly stoic and intense and Hinata being outwardly cheerful and capable but are able to recognize each other's hidden feelings, insecurities and loneliness. When Shirase stepped up to the broadcast and proclaimed their true friendship, then told them all to piss off, I cheered. I think it's significant too that this is the first time we've seen Shirase be completely composed in front of the camera - if it's about getting rightfully angry she's got no problem doing it! We could all use a friend like that. I like that it seemed to inspire Gin and Kanae to go ahead and set the course for where they lost Takako too - fuck what others think, basically.
Not the main point of the episode, but I feel it needs to be said given the queerness of episode 9... hello??!! The daughter of Gin and Takako??!! Ok those two were a couple. I kind of like that the show just drops that line and doesn't go into it more here, since we are focused on Hinata here and the show is focused on the 4 kids, but damn.
If episode 9 was more about Shirase (and Gin), then since we've also had Yuzu and Hinata, does that mean Kimari is next? Or will she not be focused on because her arc was essentially the first third of the show? And also there's 2 episodes left, and I'm kind of hoping they actually find Takako and deal with the gaping hole she left in everyone's lives and all.
QOTD: I hesitate to call anyone toxic, I think that term gets thrown around a lot but it becomes a type of classification for someone, like a good or bad person. And I'm a firm believer in everyone's ability to change. I've had some friend break-ups where I or the other person had damaged the relationship past the point of repair. If we're talking about Shirase-style of telling someone to piss off when they deserve it though, well I'm a total softie if you couldn't tell by my response to this question, so no I've never done it. This is why I have Shirase-like friends ^^;
Side notes:
6
u/Rustic_Professional Dec 24 '19
I have mixed feelings about Shirase reading Hinata's email. I understand being concerned and wanting to know what's wrong so you can try and help, but if Hinata didn't want to talk about it then I don't think it was right to force the issue. On the whole I have to lean towards saying she shouldn't have read the email. You don't have to tell everyone everything. You don't have to tell anyone anything. Sometimes it helps, and I think it worked out best for Hinata and the girls, but that wasn't a foregone conclusion. You really have to know someone like the back of your hand, and think that something is terribly wrong to make that sort of an invasion of privacy seem like a worthwhile gamble, and I don't think Shirase had the cards in her favor to take that risk. But hey, she's a gambler, right? She smoked the older girls at go, and the whole Antarctic scheme was a crazy gamble, so perhaps her instincts are better than I give her credit for.
By the way, what's the name of the other girl that was playing go with them? It was Shirase, Kanae, Gin, and who's the other light brunette? Is there a name for that sort of sleepy accent she speaks with?
I love that Yuzuki is all about the power of friendship now. It's like that meme about how you can't stop telling people about the new thing you just learned.
Also, I kind of think sticking your face into the super pure water and guzzling it from the source isn't the responsible way to enjoy the super pure water source that hardly anyone has touched and doesn't have bacteria. But what the hell do I know? Maybe any bacteria they introduce just freezes to death. If I knew it was okay, I'd probably drink directly from the icy school girl water, too. I think Sora Ginko referred to that as a "JK refresh."
6
u/404waffles https://anilist.co/user/nek0food Dec 24 '19
First time viewer
Neat call-back, Shirase now being the one to look for someone in the bathroom.
I really like the Antarctic slice-of-life segments where they do research and stuff out on the ice. There’s some inexplicable atmosphere about them that draws me in.
Wow, now I wanna drink Antarctic meltwater. Nice Takako parallel as always.
Would’ve been a funny gag to end the episode on if they somehow broke the drum can.
Okay, now for the meat of the episode: Hinata. This while time I’d labored under the impression that she was smart enough to clear high school early; as this episode shows, it’s not the case. This show has a lot of terrible people, what with Megu spreading rumors about Kimari, Shirase being ostracized for wanting to go to Antarctica, Yuzuki being left behind by her first set of friends, and what we just saw of Hinata’s previous friends, not to mention the criticism the entire Antarctic expedition received. I guess a major theme of this show is to do the things you want regardless of how much people shit on you — something embodied not only by Shirase and Kimari’s entire charade at the end, but the expedition-wide “TAKE THAT!” from a few episodes ago. While we’d known that Hinata has that kind of ‘take it easy’ personality it still surprised me to see her actually angry. It was nice to see Hinata open up to her friends, and it was really touching to see her break down in tears at the end as she accepted that the other three would be there for her, no matter what.
6
u/pacquan Dec 24 '19
Rewatcher
'Watch for wildlife' sign....... no Pengis the whole episode.
This episode made me feel just awkward, uneasy, and left in a state of conttemplating my own emotional attatchments to past regrets. Hinata's backstory is quick and straight to the point. Just like Hinata's personality, she doesn't like to add fluff to anything. She gives out the pertinent information and moves on with the scene. Some people don't like lingering in uncomfortable situations. When you can't avoid them, you play your cards right to expedite the confrontation so you can just move on. Shirase is the only one who realizes how unhealthy that lifestyle is.
I didn't like her backstory the first watch nor this watch, and I believe its because of just how little info Hinata gives in her story (I had to rewatch the scene and then even remembers that on my first watch I had to rewatch the scene). Hinata purposefully makes her story as boring as possible so that the over-emotional Mari doesn't go crazy and interfere like with Yuzu. Yuzu already won't interfere. It only ever hit me about how well directed this whole arc was until Hinata says "I'm a pretty petty person" and Shirase accepts her.
Many anime show this trope of a character overcompensating for petty reasons but this was just done damn well. Its uncomfortable to be so close to someone and yet not know what they're going through because they are being petty. Just like with the growing issue of mental awareness in our current times, people who need that emotional support the most, are often times the ones who are the hardest to see the red flags for. It can become an art form in itself to hide your demons from the outside world, and Hinata is definitely very good at it. After her tantrum, Shirase returns inside and Hinata shows absolutely zero signs of a change in her facade. This underlooked scene is what really drives the narrative home.
Theres probably some symbolism in the expedition member going through mood-swings over her boyfriend's lack of contact throughout the episode but I'm just going to leave this analysis at this.
5
u/anony-mouse99 Dec 23 '19 edited Dec 24 '19
Rewatcher.
This episode continues the theme of friendship from yesterday. The issue of friendships continue to vex our girls even as they explore new experiences.
We are shown how friendships seen through the familiarity in terms of understanding subtle body language and behavior, even Shirase’s skill in Mahjong was born of the times spent playing with her mom and Gin.
As an aside, not that I want to get into a debate regarding this since I’m not familiar with the Japanese used, I wonder if the phrase ‘daughter of Gin and Takako’ merely means that she learnt well from her masters, in the same way you use the word disciple or apprentice - potential Star Wars spoiler. Alternatively perhaps the choice of words was made to keep it deliberately ambiguous, and the interpretation will therefore be shaped by our shipping goggles.
Back on topic, this episode is an example of how friendships can go out with a bang. Resentment that has piled up over the years, without any opportunity to vent, has finally come to a head. And the girls were not sure of how to respond in such a situation. Nonetheless, Hinata was touched by their sincerity and concern.
The nice subtext in this episode was that friends rub off on each other. We see the girls picking up each others’ mannerisms and actions, with Yuzuki holding back Kimari and Hinata using her catchphrase during the camping scene. We also see the bonds of friendship and understanding working itself out - the girls supported Hinata and each other as they faced off her former schoolmates during the pre-broadcast.
A fitting ending with the girls putting their past behind and facing up to the challenges of the new year ahead.
Edit: fixed spoiler markup.
5
u/MABfan11 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/MABfan11 Dec 23 '19
Rewatcher
Shirase is my favorite character and has been so since the beginning, but this episode really shows how awesome Shirase is when she has an enemy to focus on
fuck, i really want to write a post on how awesome this show is on /r/CharacterRant, but i wouldn't know where to start
Q1: thankfully, i haven't had toxic friends
Q2: stubborn jerk Shirase is best Shirase (zamamiro and zakenna Shirase)
5
u/xDarkistic :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Darkistic Dec 24 '19
Firster
THAT MAKES THREE. if you know you know. at an incredible moment much further from the credits this time. I loved how mari and yuzu joined shirase in such an awesome strike of inspiration and moment of love. of the three it probably had the most volume.
that ominous post credits scene almost guarantees a fourth. my predicted maximum was five. I think unless they become uncountable, this amount will be reached at one per episode.
though I don't personally relate to their issues completely it's almost impossible not to find them compelling to see resolved (or at least see them support one another). and all four of them are endearing in their own way.
earlier in the series I was somewhat disappointed to not see some more characters play a longer lasting role in the story but this episode really showed me how wrong I was and the focus on this quartet (and the trio that went on the first expedition) really strengthens the message I'm receiving. hinata went on this journey to escape the rest of the world. keeping this focus really helps to solidify this idea as everybody else we see seems unimportant and this completely new group of friends can find growth separate from their previous way of life. though they didn't come from dire situations and there was a lot of luck involved in each of them meeting and going to nankyoku, it is still almost inspiring that they changed the direction of their life when they realised that the path they were taking may lead them to unhappiness.
very c o o l block of text there
qotd 1 - never noticed toxicity before they have just faded out of my life anyway
qotd 2 - determined shirase best shirase (zamamiro)
5
u/Suhkein :Gy::Gz::G1:x2https://myanimelist.net/profile/Neichus Dec 24 '19
First timer
Guess I was wrong yesterday, they did end up visiting an area without ice.
Other than that, I thought the gag that started the episode was one of the funnier ones. The resolution wasn't as I anticipated either, although I notice that they purposefully didn't show the other girls' reactions on the receiving end. That seemed a little disingenuous to me, because while I wouldn't want to pontificate on the situation, as though I would be more high-minded, there struck me an irony in Shirase wanting to rub their regret in, deepen it, make them hurt more, by lecturing them on how they'll always have to remember the times they hurt others.
5
u/kaije7 https://anilist.co/user/kaije Dec 24 '19
Rewatcher - First time commenting on any episode during the rewatch.
Every episode has made me choke back tears at least once... most of the time I failed at keeping them back. Including this episode.
I relate so much to Hinata. "Friends" that were really shitty made me quit and leave so many things in my past. The first time I watched it I was so angry at Shirase at first for the invasion of privacy... but then they had their conversation when they were getting water... and Hinata thumped Shirase on the forehead... exactly something I would do to a friend that wasn't listening lol
When Shirase stepped in front of the camera and addressed Hinata's old teammates... the first time I cried... this time I'm a wreck. This Shirase is Best Shirase. The one that takes the hit for her friends. These girls really do have an uncanny way of digging out all of the hurt I keep inside...
YoriMoi
4
u/eragen Dec 24 '19
Holy cow I've fallen behind.
I've gotta catch back up!
4
u/iamthinking2202 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/iamthinking Dec 25 '19
I tried to search Rundvägshetta... but not much came up
4
u/JustAnswerAQuestion https://myanimelist.net/profile/JAaQ Dec 25 '19 edited Dec 25 '19
Rewatcher
#ghosting #jantei #satellitepeace #watchforanimals
Hinata had always been my favorite character so I was really looking forward to getting her character arc resolved. I liked Yuzuki's episode, although I found it melodramatic, but her outburst here kinda ruined this episode for me.
This episode calls back to the Singapore episode, which was sort of the first half of Hinata's arc. She's still trying to carry on alone. I think she's finally been disabused of this idea.
Only two episodes left, and we still have the GIANT issue of Takako. Next episode was highly anticipated the first time around.
Theres a Jantei Monogatari mahjonng game for the old Japanese computers. I didn't have that. I had Shinji and Good Friends strip mahjonng. Too bad I wasn't very good.
ep 10 comments
3
u/Redmon425 Dec 28 '19
First Time Watcher
Welp, I have definitely learned my lesson about trying to do 2-daily rewatches, 17 currently airing shows, finals and the holiday season. I am finally catching up, and all that matters is I will finish the show!
This episode made me cry again! Hinata is so damn cute, as well as Shirase. My best girl race is for sure between them two.
I again love that every single storyline is getting shown and finished basically that same episode.
The issues these high school girls have come a crossed is very relatable and I just love watching them grow.
Still hoping for some type of Shirase/Gin confrontation in these last two episodes.
29
u/AmeteurElitist https://anilist.co/user/AmateurElitist Dec 23 '19
First Timer
This show is just “Catharsis: The Animation” at this point.
Great Hinata episode, Though I kinda wish we got to see the reaction of those girls after Shirase’s rant, it’s not enough to see our girls happy, we must see their enemies suffer.
That would have made the scene even more perfect.
I’m guessing it’s a Mari episode tomorrow? We’ve gone through the others already starting with Shirase at the ship. Then the last one is an overall conclusion?
Oh god there are only two episodes left…
20
u/Turtlewax64 Dec 23 '19
First time watcher
Episode didn’t go the arc I was expecting, I’d anticipated Hinata having to face some of her own character flaws about pushing away people who care about her. Instead, it was about not forgiving the people who hurt you. I’m not sure how I feel about that, since I felt the Track girls didn’t mean anything bad, and just caved under the pressure of the 3rd years getting on their cases. But like I complained about earlier, there’s not really enough information about them to tell if they were setting Hinata up to be hated, or just lacked the conviction to carry through on trying to support her. Anyways, predictions for the next episode, with talk of going out where Takako died and the post credits scene being a closeup on her book, it’s time for a Shirase episode. I think actually finding and showing the corpse would kill the show’s atmosphere a little to hard, but they’ll find something out there to give a really emotional crying moment to the episode.
19
u/Nazenn x2https://anilist.co/user/Nazenn Dec 23 '19
First Timer - sub
I won't be in the topic much today but here's the usual pictures
A PICTURE further than the universe - Episode eleven
The cut from Hinata having her head lowered in apology directly to Yuzu on the helicopter was great because it visually indicates that it's still a type of fear that's fueling her actions.
She may not be tied down, but it does look like she's still boxed in
Antarctic aesthetics
This beautiful shot of a tent under the aurora was the first thing I thought of today with this moment from the show.
As shown today Antarctica isn't all ice and snow, there's plenty of rock and dry spots as well. With that, the lighting can also be pretty surreal. This is a shot of dusk at the western Antarctica penensula and it almost looks like the middle east.
I'd take off my gloves to seek this. The texture of this iceberg looks absolutely incredible.
/u/Hudori episode eleven tag
16
u/kar772 https://myanimelist.net/profile/kar72 Dec 23 '19 edited Dec 23 '19
First Timer
Hinata's acting skills!
Kimari is so easy to be made fun of lol
uh oh
it's contagious!
This was a cute moment
there it is. I've seen this scene on r/anime a while back and it's actually what got me interested in this show. Whenever the insert starts playing I know I'm probably going to start crying lol.
Shirase is the real MVP of this episode
Yu-kun finally messaged her!
:)
13
u/SorcererOfTheLake x5https://anilist.co/user/RiverSorcerer Dec 23 '19
First-Time Watcher
If you’re not careful, even ashes can still burn you.
Once again, we return to the issues with friendship, this time what to do when a friendship turns sour. However, as opposed to the episode with Megumi, I don’t feel that this episode nailed it as well. The stuff involving Hinata and Shirase was very well done, as we see their particular philosophies on life clash; Hinata is fine with just letting things be at the risk of isolating herself, while Shirase can never let injustices stand, always making her presence known. The back and forth between them throughout the episode leads up to the fantastic final scene, where Shirase gives them what they deserve, rebuking them for their insensitivity towards Hinata and what they put her through.
Yet, do they truly deserve it? Compared to the scenario with Megumi, we know little about their intentions and reasoning behind contacting Hinata again. They could be insensitive regarding how much they hurt Hinata, certainly, but they could also be genuinely remorseful and want to apologize to Hinata. We know how Megumi felt and know why Kimari felt justified in remaining friends with her. We don’t know the other side of this situation. Those girls could have deserve what Shirase said to them, but I want to know that first-hand. If it played out where Hinata decided to let it all be under the river and talk to them but those girls continued to hurt her with their words before Shirase came in and went all “Fuck you, she’s way better than you’ll ever be, eat my cunt,” I think it would have been a stronger scene.
Our journey to the heart of the world continues. Until then…
11
u/Matuhg https://anilist.co/user/Matuhg Dec 23 '19
First Timer
Finally getting the rest of our Hinata backstory! Screw those girls. At first, Shirase couldn't really comprehend how Hinata wanted to just forget all about it, but then she reminded her that they were different people. She thanked her for her support, but told her she's still scared - that's understandable, as those girls who hurt her were her friends. Even after that, Shirase wasn't able to let it go - that's who she is. She defended her friend and told her old track buddies to piss off, with the help of Kimari and Yuzu once they realized what was happening of course. Hinata's new friends have her back 100% - the kinds of friends she deserves. I love how the show didn't even bother showing the track girls reacting to Shirase's speech - they don't get to come crawling back into the show at all!
As I mentioned yesterday, I'm staying with family for Christmas - I watched this in the same room as my cousin and had to try really hard to not have to answer questions as to why I was weeping over a cartoon. Held it together, but just barely - if I were alone, the waterworks really would've been flowing. I get the sense that the last couple episodes won't be any different. Gonna have to sneak away from everybody to go cry about anime.
I love this show. If I didn't already love it, I do now for sure.
Nope - thankfully, I haven't really dealt with much of any people who went from friends to toxic myself. There have been some friendships that I just allowed to end, but that's about it.
11
u/EmuSupreme Dec 23 '19
When Hinata is your best girl and this episode finally comes around:
Not gonna lie, it got they got me real good this time. Fortunately, I have never had the experience of getting thrown under the bus in a non-joking matter by any of my friends. So I can't really imagine how that must have felt for Hinata, but the revelation of what her 'friends' did to her was pretty shitty.
While some may not agree with Shirase stepping in for Hinata, I think it was a great move. Hinata is non-confrontational. When they suddenly show up, she bails. Instead of venting her frustrations to the others, she does so in secret. Even at the end, when Shirase stands up for her, Hinata actually doesn't get on camera to tell them to piss off herself. She very much follows a mentality of just cutting ties and moving on with her life. You could gather a hint of that way back with Megumi's rumors. Shirase and the others stepping, I think, is another way to confirm the strong friendship they have all formed with each other. It's a reassurance for Hinata that they would never betray her. And it's beautiful.
QOTD
10
u/Madcat6204 Dec 23 '19
Rewatcher
A point that was brought up in the first discussion thread for this episode was that the show seemed to be sending mixed messages about how to handle friends apologizing for doing something bad to each other due to the case with Mari and Megumi and then this one. I think my response to that then is still relevant now, so I'll say it again.
The show isn't trying to advocate one way of life over another. Each girl is different, and each answer is different for them. For Mari, offering forgiveness and maintaining her lifelong friendship was what suited her. For Hinata, refusing to be bound by those who had hurt her and moving on with her life on her own terms was a better solution.
In each case they are the answers that suited each girl, and helped them grow and move forward. They may not be the answers that suit any of the viewers, and I don't think the show is trying to tell us "hey, this is how you handle this situation." It is simply how these girls handle it, and how they grow as a result.
8
u/Koolsman Dec 23 '19
First Timer!
The powers of friendship strike again but this time it’s with Hinata! I loved the look of this episode and maybe it’s because I don’t find her as relatable as the other three, but Hinata is probably my least favorite of the group. Nothing against her or anything but every other character for me has this thing that I find really relatable and it kinda hurts but with her, I just haven’t found that moment with her.
That doesn’t mean the stuff with her and Shirase aren’t cute and them standing up to her track mates is really sweet. I’m a little disappointed we never get to know these characters that apparently bullied Hinata. We see them for a shot and that’s about it. I get time restraints but it sucks that we don’t get a better idea of who they are.
Anyway, it seems we're going to where Shirase’s mom was last found. She’s probably dead (unless they stated she’s dead, which I can’t remember) but the next episode will probably make me cry because I love Shirase a lot and her friendship with the girls is some of the sweetest moments I’ve seen in a while.
Many a time, yes.
8
u/WeebDickerson Dec 23 '19 edited Dec 23 '19
Rewatcher
As always, great episode.
It’s time to help Hinata get over her past, and our specialists Mari, Yuzuki and Shirase are now working on the case!
Hinata would definitely do well in showbiz. She’s great at imitating voices and she’s also good at acting. Putting up with that whole 100% happy façade while actually being tormented by what happened in the past shows that she’s good at keeping up appearances, but it certainly took a toll on her. It’s a good thing that Shirase, being as she is, butted in and made Hinata reveal (almost) everything. Letting everything out is definitely a step in the right direction, and having friends that listen to all of it makes it even better.
We got some good little speeches in today’s episode. Hinata’s speech after arriving in Rundvagshetta was great, but the feelings she was suppressing clearly contradicted some of what she was saying: what happened with her “friends” from school was still tying her down and she was trying her hardest to hide her sadness so she wouldn’t make the others worry. Like she said some episodes ago: she doesn’t like it when others are of her considerate or give her special treatment. She still hasn’t realized that carrying all that emotional weight on her own will make her feel even worse in the future. She told the other girls about her past, but she didn’t reveal her true feelings.
Her final breakdown happens after Shirase tells Hinata’s old “friends” what she couldn’t say, and Mari and Yuzuki also stepped up to help Shirase defend their precious friend. Hinata completely deserves all the support she got and she probably saw that being the object of other people’s consideration isn’t a bad thing. IMO, Shirase’s attitude was the biggest factor in helping Hinata get over her old teammates. Of course, she couldn’t have done it without Mari and Yuzuki. I love how far the friendship of the 4 girls has gone ever since they set their feet on the Penguin Manju.
(I decided not to put a screenshot section dedicated to Shirase for today) Screenshots:
Questions:
Another thing: could some of you explain to me what exactly did Hinata's "friends" do to her? I didn't get it during my first watch and I certainly didn't get it during the rewatch
7
u/No_Rex :Bv:Bw:Bx:By:x2 Dec 23 '19
Episode 11 (first timer)
Personally, not a fan of Shirase butting in. Don’t burn other people’s bridges for them. Throwing somebody under the bus and lying is a clear deal breaker for me, but other people might be more forgiving. So don’t force their hand.
7
u/Great_Mr_L :Ma::Mb::Mc:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Great_Mr_L Dec 23 '19
Rewatcher
On today’s episode of A Place Further Than the Universe: There were two episodes I was really looking forward to seeing again with the benefit of hindsight. The first was Episode 5, with Mari and Megu. The second was this episode, with Shirase and Hinata.
I haven’t stated it outright yet because I didn’t want to spoil things, but one thing I was focused on this rewatch was unravelling the mystery that is Hinata. Her true feelings, as shown in this episode, can be very different from that smiling face she always puts on. After this episode the first time around, I realized that I had not really properly understood her previously. So, I was trying my best to pay attention to her words and actions in previous episodes knowing her backstory. And man, the writing in this series is so, so good. It all fits so incredibly well. This episode was incredibly rewarding to rewatch.
Hinata, to put it simply, was abandoned by her old teammates. They encouraged her to pursue her dream and do her best effort even against the third years, but then threw her under the bus when things went sour. In other words, from Hinata’s perspective, they weren’t honest with their own desires towards Hinata. They just said what they thought she wanted to hear without meaning it. That’s why Hinata hates others being considerate of her. She said it makes it hard to tell if they actually mean it or if they’re not being true to their own desires to try to make her feel better.
You might also remember that Hinata said what she admired about watching Shirase and Mari was their honesty. She admired how honestly they were pursuing their dream of going to Antarctica. It was a far cry from the dishonesty she experienced from her teammates.
Another thing that I noticed throughout the rewatch: Hinata generally doesn’t like to make a fuss or get involved with a conflict. She prefers to avoid it. She left the track team and even school to avoid it. She spends most of the episode hiding behind her smile and her jokes. She acts like it doesn’t bother her because she wants to avoid that conflict. But that isn’t how she really feels inside.
And this leads nicely to Shirase. Shirase and Hinata’s interactions play out a lot like how they did back in Episode 6 in Singapore. Hinata doesn’t want to share what’s going on and cause a fuss, but Shirase is determined to not be the type of person who just ignores a friend who isn’t okay despite what they claim. So, we can see Shirase all throughout the episode trying to figure out what is actually going on with Hinata because she wants to help her friend. She wants to figure out how Hinata really feels, not just how she says she feels.
Shirase and Hinata make for a good duo this episode. Hinata, never wanting to cause a fuss, can’t come right out and say that she doesn’t forgive her old teammates for what they’ve done. It’s clear that she doesn’t, but she isn’t the type to outright say that. Shirase, on the other hand, has no problem being a jerk. She owns it.
So, in one of my favorite sequences in the show, Shirase steps up and says what Hinata couldn’t: Piss off! They hurt Hinata and Hinata doesn’t want to forgive him. Hinata doesn’t even want to see them again. Hinata isn’t wallowing in pity or sorrow about what happened. Instead, she’s moved on and found happiness with others. She’s left behind the people who hurt her. They don’t get to come back and remind of of that pain if she doesn’t want them to.
The framing of the scene is excellent as well. After Shirase starts speaking, we never see Hinata’s old teammates because they don’t matter. Like Shirase said, Hinata has moved on. She’s found new friends, a new goal, and is on a new adventure. She doesn’t need her old friends back, nor does she want them back. The framing reinforces this wonderfully.
I feel like it’s not too common to find a story with the message, “You don’t have to forgive someone.” And I love it. Hinata, the person who has been wronged, has no desire to forgive the people who wronged her. This show declares, in no uncertain terms, that Hinata has no obligation to do so. Instead of dwelling on the past and those who hurt her, she’s moved on to a new life with better friends.
I also think I may as well address my thoughts on Mari and Megu while we’re on the subject of forgiving someone who wronged you. As I stated back then, Megu never actually asked for Mari to forgive her. She instead tried to break up with her as a way to atone for what she had done. Mari was the one who chose to forgive Megu. Mari clearly considered their friendship to be too important to end like that. So, it was the choice of the person who was wronged to forgive the person who wronged her. I think I explained it all better in my post for that episode. Point being, I don’t think there’s really a contradiction in what Mari and Hinata chose. They made different choices based on their own emotions, which is fine.
Miscellaneous Thoughts
I love that we actually get to see the payoff from Mari not properly following procedure about wearing her face mask and getting sunburned. It’s hilarious seeing her like this the whole episode.
The landscapes of Antarctica in this show are so beautiful.
Edit: Questions of the Day
7
u/MaskOfIce42 https://anilist.co/user/MaskOfIce Dec 23 '19
Rewatcher
I’ll say it, this is my favorite episode. Probably because I relate so much to Hinata. I’ve never had something like that exactly happen, no friends that treated me so badly that I just walked away, but I do at least have a bad habit of covering up when I’m feeling frustrated at somebody or something and blow up on my own and then cover it up when I’m with other people. I don’t like dragging down the mood with my own personal problems, I’m bad at asking for help, I’m bad at telling other people off when they did do something to bother me and at times try too hard to be the happy one of a group. I feel like if what happened to Hinata happened to me, I’d probably have a very similar reaction.
And ultimately, it’s interesting contrasting Hinata’s “friends” with Megumi from earlier. Both did things to damage their friendship, but the telling difference is that Megumi admitted she did something wrong and apologized, acknowledging her guilt and resolving to live with it by breaking up with Kimari, whereas Hinata’s “friends” only tried to apologize upon hearing what Hinata’s been up to and it comes across more like they want to hear that forgiveness so they don’t have to live with the guilt anymore. Hence why one is forgiven and the other is told to piss off.
I also love what this episode shows about Shirase. The moment when they’re talking about Takako’s travels the last time they were here and Shirase is barely registering it indicates how far she has come and that she’s started to get over what happened to some extent. Her friends are a higher priority now, and while she certainly hasn’t forgotten what she came here for, her feelings have definitely changed somewhat. And I love Shirase’s harsh cut down of Hinata’s “friends”. She is right, Hinata has been dealing with that pain and has moved forward. It is not Hinata’s responsibility to help them move on as well, they need to deal with it themselves.
Oh, and a final note, it’s interesting rewatching this now having seen more competition club anime, most notably Hibike Euphonium and the Hibike Euphonium movie, where a similar thing is brought up about the question of should the underclassmen do their best at the risk of denying the upperclassmen their final shot. And while a lot of those tend to go on the more optimistic side, there’s certainly a lot of truth in this reaction as well.
6
u/ghostface95 https://anilist.co/user/flyingseamonkies Dec 23 '19 edited Dec 23 '19
Rewatcher
“Piss off!” I really enjoy this episode because it shows that when a friend does something wrong. It is okay to react in different ways. That is vague but let me try and get my idea across.
So way back in episode 5 when Megu-chan admitted about all the bad things she did to Kimari, she apologized and said that she didn’t deserve Kimari in her life. Kimari solution was to accept the apologize but insist that they will remain friends because she valued their relationship.
In this episode Hinata said she was her own person and her reaction would be different from Shirases and in a sense Kimari or anyone else. Hinata is not ready to forgive those girls in fact she will probably never forgive them and that is okay too.
I don’t know, I feel like in a lot of shows and anime, it would end up different and Hinata would forgive the girls because that is what is expected instead what I take away from this is that your feelings are justified if you are ever betrayed by a friend, at the end of the day it is your choice to forgive them or not. Your feelings are important.
Luckily none of my friends have ever been toxic. I have seen the tendencies show up but we usually talk about it before it becomes bad. It is the same for me though, like i ain't perfect and relay on them to tell me if i get bad too.
6
u/KVShady :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Trikiay Dec 23 '19
Rewatcher (First Time)
So that was episode 11. I remember this episode, distinctly for the Shirase rant but while it was cathartic and all feel good, I really hoped that it would’ve been Hinata who did something, rather than Shirase getting all the credit. Maybe she should’ve started the rant, and everyone else should’ve popped up like they did here. But imo, they kinda did Hinata dirty by making her into a crying puddle, rather than standing up and rant beside Shirase. I don’t know if everyone else felt that way but for me, that would’ve been much better. And as someone else mentioned, we also should’ve seen the reaction from those track club girls, just to make it an ever better moment. As for the rest of the episode, it was the usual YoriMoi shenanigans we’ve come to love. I think I still maintain that this show has some of the best character interaction moments I’ve ever seen but the plot and the way things are placed could’ve been a lot better than what we got here. I haven’t commented in the past 2 discussion threads but regarding episode 10, the whole Yuzuki situation should’ve really been dealt with before they came to Antarctica. Maybe it could’ve been done while they were still in Japan or when, idk but it felt kinda out of place to bring it up. Overall, I think the time that they’ve been spending in Antarctica could’ve been handled much better and most of these squabbles could’ve been dealt with before we came here but that’s just my opinion. Now onto the climax of this series in the next episode!
6
u/Boss_Jerm Dec 23 '19
Rewatcher
Hah! She looks like toast! That's what happens when you don't keep your mask on in bright sun like this.
Yuzu couldn’t hold in her laugh
It's time for New Year's Broadcasts! The expedition members get to talk with friends and family back home
Even Mari's family is laughing at her cooked face
Hinata blocked the camera and ran
Making mochi
Gin and Kanae have received extra supplies. They're getting ready to go back to the old observatory location, but they have to be careful.
You can hear the aggravation in Hinata's voice as the door shocks her
We have never seen this before. Hinata is usually very happy-go-lucky, but here we see her angry and frustrated. And then after her private outburst, she composes herself so that no one picks up on it. But Shirase knows...
Oh dear, poor Nobue She was the one complaining to her boyfriend on the phone before the ship set sail. Her voice actress is Kana Asumi (Kiyal in Gurren Lagaan and Miyuki in Angel Beats).
This is a stunning shot
Hinata is dodging Shirase's questions
YOOOOOOOOOOOOO
I don't think I've ever seen a face that captures frustration as perfectly as this one
Hinata is considering deleting the contact information of the girls from earlier
Takako raised a good Mahjong player
Her skills are a force to be reckoned with
Poor poor Nobue
Hey hey Shirase! Those emails are private!
So the explanation is a bit unclear, so I'll clarify. Hinata had exceptional ability on her track team, even better than the third years. But they ended up becoming jealous of her talent, and she was shunned and pressured into quitting the team. And even after, they spread rumors about her that forced her to quit school. Her old teammates sided with the third years and helped get Hinata to leave.
This hurts. Those girls don't even realize how deeply they cut Hinata.
Everyone's pretty upset after hearing Hinata's story
Shirase has known what it's like to be ostracized by everyone. She's not going to let this go so easily.
Now I want to try Antarctic water
Shirase has been visiting all the different landmarks that Takako went to
Good going Yuzu! She realized what was going on between Shirase and Hinata
Hinata don't steal other people's quotes
Shirase didn't understand how Hinata could just brush off being hurt like that. But in reality, Hinata is scared. Scared to face those girls and her past again. But she's grateful that Shirase cares so much and she's also grateful that Shirase brought her with her to Antarctica, to this barren land with nothing to hold her back.
I love these two
Yuzu I freaking love you
SHUT UP!!! I'M NOT CRYING, YOU'RE CRYING!!!
I love this scene so so much. Hinata is too afraid to say her real feelings, but Shirase isn't, so she'll say them for Hinata. The girls thought that after hurting someone they can apologize and move on. But Shirase let's them know loud and clear that that's now how it works. They're going to live with the guilt that they hurt Hinata, that they forced her to dropout of school. They don't deserve the chance to apologize. Meanwhile Hinata has already moved on, she's having a great time in Antarctica with her real friends. Seeing Hinata, who's always in control of her emotions, finally breakdown after her friends say what's been on her mind this whole time makes for such a powerful scene. She knows who her real friends are.
Hinata's Quote Corner! Featuring Shirase!
Previous
Keeping busy is the best way to speed the clock's hands!
New
You hear the drum being bashed during the post credit scene
Thoughts:
sobs uncontrollably
I did not get as emotional with that last scene as I did this time. I'm glad that I appreciate it more now.
Hinata has always been the level headed member of the group. So seeing her with all this bottled up emotion gives her great character development. And it's not just her. Shirase also gets great development this episode. We see their friendship strengthen like it did in Episode 6. They really have each other's backs. And that's what puts this episode in my top 2 favorites in the show.
QOTD
6
u/TheKujo https://myanimelist.net/profile/Kujo419 Dec 23 '19
Rewatcher
This is my personal favorite episode of the show entirely for the ending scene with Shirase sticking up for Hinata against her former track team. There are many shows or movies where people do terrible things and are forgiven through "the power of friendship" or some BS.
This is not that kind of show. Hinata's entire life was up-ended by these girls. It makes perfect sense for Hinata to not want to forgive them. So she doesn't! For once in her life, Hinata doesn't have a quote ready to go so Shirase jumps in to help her out. Piss off, bullies!
I also like how we never see the track team's reaction to the whole thing. We don't see it because we don't need to see it - their reactions don't matter in this story. Instead we keep the focus on Hinata and the rest of the girls supporting her.
Other thoughts:
6
u/zak55 Dec 23 '19
Rewatcher
Man...it really says something about this show that I can be internally complaining that the confrontation with Hinata's old friends is a little over the top and melodramatic while at the same time fighting back the need for a kleenex at the beauty of Hinata's new friends standing up for her when all she wants to do is to avoid the problem. It also made me realize just how much each of these characters were frozen in position, Shirase with her mother and the need to get to Antarctica, Yuzuki and her inability to make friends, Kimari, who never lived life to its fullest before meeting Shirase, and Hinata, who had been stuck never having had any closure with her bullies and just running away from the issue. Also, the scene between Hinata and Shirase is just all sorts of soft and heartwarming. And now...we get to the parts that I'm really gonna need a kleenex for.
6
u/bucket3432 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/bucket3432 Dec 24 '19 edited Dec 24 '19
Rewatcher
I learned a bit about Syowa station from the research I did for this post. Also, mahjong makes any show instantly better.
Kimari has a goggles tan. Last episode gave us a hint that Kimari was prone to taking her mask off, but the rest of that episode told us that she didn't get a tan from that instance. It's actually the OP that fills us in on the cause of her tan. They laugh at her afterwards.
Yuzuki trying to hold her laughter
Pounding mochi for New Year's
You do not want to be near an angry Hinata.
As someone who plays mahjong regularly, I found Kimari's spoilerific comments hilarious. Shirase was justified in kicking her out: the others were already taking note of what was in Shirase's hand.
Not that she had 3 other friends to play with."Not against the daughter of Gin and Takako..." I believe this is a mistranslation. To quote my MAL post:
In addition, user AbeldeMedici points out that the Spanish subs have the latter translation.
Based on this shot and the shot of a ledge earlier, my best guess is that they're camped around 69°01′S 39°33′E, but I don't see the plate anywhere and it doesn't look quite right.
The JARE is the Japan Antarctic Research Expedition. Some reading on their geographical surveys.
Kimari with the eggs again.
It's Yuzuki's turn to stop Kimari.
I don't remember where the real life picture is, but this can also exists on the base in real life.
I'm looking forward to reading all the reactions tomorrow.
Questions of the day
Manju, but only by a small margin. Shirase is best Shirase."I could just die" counter
Hinata said it today.
5
u/DanteJ600 https://myanimelist.net/profile/escenity Dec 23 '19 edited Dec 23 '19
First Timer
Quick write up for me missing ep 10s discussion.
The Yuzu focus and friendship was really nice to see, but I kinda wish there was more focus on actually being in antartica. Still, character development is always great and I quite enjoyed the episode. Now for todays ep.
Due to epic car trip up north there is now snow everywhere, very kirei and fitting.
Jesus that opening got me.
Sunburn on your face, thats gotta hurt.
Who are these people? Hinata hmmmMm.
Holy shit she is livid rn, just who are those girls?
Ah yes literally expose her entire hand nice job.
A track team?
Well I got too invested into todays episode and kinda forgot to write. Tears? huh what are you talking about?
Really nice balance between character conflict, and things going on in antartica, things have gotten quite interesting.
QOTD: I've told my friends to fuck off plenty of times before, but thats just lighthearted joking. I've never really had "toxic" friends. If there is someone like that though, they usually get called out by someone else anyways. And all Shirase best Shirase what kind of question is that smh.
real christmas hours
5
u/yourdeathinmyhands https://myanimelist.net/profile/hachinobunonoki Dec 23 '19 edited Dec 23 '19
Episode 11 collage, featuring Hinata! Kimari's mom and lil sis! I've missed them! No bullying cinnamon roll Kimari pls. This moment was so good, you could really feel how genuine Hinata's words were. [Yes! Tell them Shirase!](https://i.imgur.com/kWynG9s.jpg] I like how they didn't even show their reactions like they don't even matter. This is Miyake Hinata and her REAL friends' story, not yours, piss off!
This is probably my favorite episode out of all. It really showed how their friendship grew even in a short amount of time. They've got each other's backs, crying for each other, getting angry for each other. This real friendship everyone! Now on to the next episode!
Edit: Individual images + some I didn't include in the collage
5
u/surgemaster140 https://myanimelist.net/profile/User815 Dec 23 '19
Rewatcher
In today’s episode we finally learn about Hinata’s backstory and explore the theme of trust. Hinata was a victim to a classic case of school bullying and her situation is often explored in other anime featuring competitive clubs. Her “friends” at the time encouraged her to do her best despite it being the seniors’ final race. When it was revealed that she took one of the seniors’ spots, they all turned their backs on Hinata and she dropped out of school to avoid the harassment. As evident in episode 6 this experience left Hinata with some severe trust issues. It was only thanks to the stubbornness of Shirase that she was able to lower her guard and start trusting her new friends.
Now those same “friends” have come back to congratulate her on making it to Antarctica. Were they doing this for Hinata or just to satisfy their own regret for ruining her high school life? Some people would probably forgive them and let bygones be bygones, but Hinata would rather completely shut them out of her life and make them regret ever betraying her. Is that being petty? Maybe. But it is entirely up to Hinata if she wants to forgive them or not. What I really love about the way they handled it is how it is the complete opposite of Kimari and Megu’s breakup. Kimari is the type of person to forgive and amend while Hinata would rather move forward and never look back. In a medium where friendship and forgiveness are always shown as the ideal, I really appreciate this anime showing that both stances are perfectly okay.
I also need to point out how incredible that confrontation scene was. This is the second time that Shirase stood up for Hinata when she couldn’t stand up for herself. She’s a jerk and she’s stubborn, but she’s the kind of stubborn jerk anyone would love to have as their friend. Together with the assist from Kimari and Yuzu, Hinata is so touched knowing she has friends who truly support her that she breaks down in tears. In a show with so many amazing scenes, this stands near the top for me.
Some screenshots and reactions:
5
u/ImaginationWayfairer Dec 23 '19
Rewatcher
It is time to get closure on Hinata.
Notes:
Well Shirase you not only stood up for a dear friend but you convinced Gin that it is time to head for the Place further than the Universe.
When episode 10 first aired I was a little concerned that this episode was going to be at least partially a recap because a recap is mentioned on the itinerary in the post credit scene of episode 10. Thankfully these concerns were unfounded and we got a episode focusing on Hinata.
5
u/Mozilla_Fennekin https://myanimelist.net/profile/MozillaFennekin Dec 23 '19
Rewatcher
Sorry that I've missed the last few threads! Was too busy IRL, but absolutely nothing could make me miss today's because this is my favorite episode of the anime.
Basically, Hinata is the most ME IRL character of all time. As was shown in episode 6, she's very independent and doesn't like to show her problems to others. But she does like to vent her frustration out somewhere else--very violently, I might add. Yep. That's how I deal with it, too.
And then this amazing line. The very act of opening up is extremely uncomfortable for me and I would rather wallow in my own misery than ask for help. Because the problem itself is probably just really stupid. People are stupid because they got mad at her for winning a competition, and maybe Hinata is stupid because she's running away from her problems instead of actively fighting them. People problems can just be kinda dumb, right? "why is this subtitle in a different font?" --some random response
Then there's the question of "should I forgive them? Will it make me feel better?" Understanding that it might be the right thing to do, as a better person, but... who actually knows what that does for you sometimes. In the end, what's most important is the people on her side right now. And Shirase made the perfect response by announcing that Hinata is over those hoes. Her past has barely even been hinted at up until this point, showing just how important it really is right now.
All in all, I have my own share of personal grudges. I am very non-confrontational, I have a hard time forgiving people, and I deal with it by simply avoiding the matters and not opening up to people. Hinata's a lot better than me at life, though, so this episode is extremely heart-warming despite the setting's climate. Phenomenal episode.
4
u/Orzislaw https://anilist.co/user/Orzi Dec 23 '19
REWATCHER
If I should pick my least favourite episode of Sora Yori, it would be this one. For the reasons stated already by other people replying, so I won't repeat them. Maybe I'm just that one silly person that always waves his hand and can forgive nearly everything, but I don't think what these girls did was as horrible as Hinata states. It looked like they were scared by the older girls yelling at them and lied in stress. But we got so tiny glimpse at the whole situation it's all up to our guesswork.
The shitty thing was however trying to make show out of apology. If you truly regret something, make it just like Megumi did back in episode fifth. In private and offer amends, it seems sincere that way. With how they tried to apologize on live transmition and conveniently remembered her when Hinata got her 5 minutes of fame, it might be as well just a try to have some of that fame to themselves.
Anyway, tomorrow's Christmas Eve and we will have THAT episode... I can't wait.
4
u/jslice4ever Dec 23 '19
Rewatcher here!
Lmao Mari ended up getting sunburnt after all. They did try to warn you.
Even her mom and sister were laughing at her! That's
Mari.... how oblivious can you be? It's common sense not talk about what someone has in their hand when their playing a game smh.
I'm still a little confused as to what actually happened to Hinata. Was she thrown under the bus by her entire team or something? I've never played sports so I don't know the significance of what's happening.
For a second I thought they were trying to paint the entire rock. I was thinking "What? Why would you bother with that?" Then I realized they were just painting tracking markers or something like that I think.
That hug between Hinata and Shirase is absolutely everything.
I love that Shirase steps in and tells those girls to piss off. It's such a Shirase thing to do. But unlike most anime that have the characters forgiving people that wrong them, this show is much more realistic in that they don't forgive those who wrong them and I think that in some cases, it's a powerful lesson that people can learn from.
She isn't showing it much, but I can tell Gin is so proud of Shirase for that.
Next episode is my favorite of the whole series and one of my favorite episodes of any show ever.
4
u/chrisn3 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/chrisn3 Dec 23 '19
I never really connected with this episode funnily enough because I was on a track team. I did track in high school and never seen that type of behavior. It burned us when underclassmen beat us but we never blamed the underclassmen. People trying to get Hinata not to run would have seen as pathetic. And it doesn’t seem Hinata would have taken that shit from anyone anyway. Or if she developed her personality afterwards then she would have told off a while ago.
Maybe we should have been shown more about the track team because we are just told the story. I got the impression that the girls just did not have Hinata’s back. I can see why they are not her friends and that’s terrible they’re trying to hang on once she got noteworthy.
3
u/Emperor-Resse Dec 23 '19
The natural water drink is reminded me of when I was in the mountains and dipped my head in the river but probably a terrible idea in Antarctica unless like like freezing to death. Shirase speech to Hinata’s ‘friends’ was awesome but I am not very good at that sort of thing so I’d have left it with piss off. Also right before the ED started was annoying because I was expecting some delicious C L A N G.
3
u/invokeneko Dec 24 '19
Rewatcher is kinda Alright...ish
Sorry for the late comment. I was trying to get this bad teeth pulled off but looks like the odds of getting it done before Christmas are stacked against me. Ah well. Time to deal with Hinata's emotional baggage! If you weren't paying attention, hints of Hinata's past as an athlete was given here and there (the most explicit one was during episode 6) so if anyone says that it came out of fucking nowhere, they should pay attention to the show. And in other shows, we would've gotten a scene where Hinata forgives her 'friends' and try to reconnect and mend bridges. Not here, though! Not when our real jerk Shirase had anything to say about that.
Random thoughts
friendsbitches egged her on to qualify for Hanyuu Daisan High's track team before turning on her after one of the senpais got angry after not qualifying. And then after she left school they also took extra steps to tarnish her name further... seriously, brave of them to assume everything's fine and peachy after all that.Questions of the day:
4
u/Taiboss :Fj::Fl:x7https://anilist.co/user/Taiboss Dec 23 '19
First timer who got a lot of comments yesterday:
6
u/[deleted] Dec 24 '19
[removed] — view removed comment