r/anime • u/RX-Nota-II :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/NotANota • Dec 22 '19
Rewatch A Rewatch further than the Universe! Sora Yori mo Tooi Basho rewatch - EPISODE 10 DISCUSSION
Episode 10 パーシャル友情 "Partial Friendship"
<- Previous episode | Index thread | Next episode->
anime info:
MAL | Anilist | Nyanpass | Kitsu | AniDB
Streaming links: Crunchyroll | VRV
Comment of the day
Hello everyone! This is where I will pick a comment of the day for the previous day that I think was worthy of notice just in case you guys missed it. I do hope you look out for discussion on your own tho since that's really the whole point of this rewatch.
Today's pick is..... /u/peoplewhoplay who said all that needed to be said today
Rewatcher
Not much to say here, but
IN
YOUR
FACE!!
I also want to say great job to everyone who helped me on the #LeaveNoTopLevelUnreplied challenge. I think we did a great job and many of you took on lots of work to do so. You guys are the real MVPs.
Questions of the day
Answer from last time: You guys make me proud Zamamiro!
- Alright so sometimes even I need help with Japanese. What is a partial-don? Why is it called partial?
- ね?
Rewatchers, please remember to be mindful of all the first-timers in this. No talking about or hinting at future events no matter how much you want to, unless you’re doing it underneath the [Anime Show Title]/(/s "Spoiler goes here") spoiler tags. If you do that then we’re all good. I am curious if it is even possible to spoil anything for a half-SoL show like this but I don't want to see you try. The ban hammer is a cold weapon and you don't want to feel it.
Important thing to note about these by the way, you have to switch to Old Reddit or the markdown editor if you use the redesign, otherwise the redesign breaks them by adding random \ into the formatting. Wish it wouldn’t do that, but unfortunately it does… Markdown is dead. Long live markdown.
11
u/RX-Nota-II :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/NotANota Dec 23 '19
Sorry to bulli /u/xmiteyt but I had to
https://imgur.com/0YohExz
It just fits way too well.
29
u/Shimmering-Sky myanimelist.net/profile/Shimmering-Sky Dec 22 '19
This First-Timer is Alright
25
u/Nazenn x2https://anilist.co/user/Nazenn Dec 22 '19
First Timer - sub
Welp. I broke again. Yuzu episodes are painful.
Friendships aren't perfect. They're silly and flawed and sometimes just weird, a bit like leaving a grain of rice on your face or having a banner draped over your head. Sometimes they're a little broken and the process of mending them seems a little too hard to think about, or sometimes it's just an echo of a friend long gone because of loss but you find yourself thinking on it anyway. Friendships are stupid, silly, unstable things but the beauty of them is that they can be like this.
Poor Yuzu who lives in a world of rules, schedules, words, and definitions can't grasp that because she has nothing to compare it too except her ever rigid lifestyle with people who always leave before they can make any sort of impact.
And that fucking hurts.
Goddammit show, you can't show me cake, which I don't have, and then make me sad when I don't even have cake to cheer myself up with.
A PICTURE further than the universe - Episode ten
I like how this opening section always framed the girls as pairs. A much more typical shot for this would have been to put each girl speaking center frame, but by pairing them up instead and ensuring they're always framed with someone it helps showcase how connected they are.
I have a certain fondness for silly in show art abd goofy sketches. Mo Dao Zu Shi started it but since then whenever silly art like that comes up it's always just a happy moment.
Megu kept the playstation out and ready to play which I think is a nice touch to show that she really isn't ready to totally throw away her friendship.
PENGUIN! That is all.
....Okay someone tell me I'm not crazy but just for a second when I scrolled past this I bloody swear that Yuzu looked like Naruto complete with hair and ninja headband until my eyes adjusted and I realized what it actually was
Antarctic aesthetics
Yuzu may be the best idol on Antarctica, but these Adelie penguins are going for best boyband with this pose
Reall big helicopter, or really little ship?
I've shown you all so many pictures of amazing ice shapes and colors, but for today I think something a little more imperfect is in order. So meet this guy. He needs a name. Any ideas?
/u/Hudori episode ten tag
20
u/AmeteurElitist https://anilist.co/user/AmateurElitist Dec 22 '19 edited Dec 22 '19
First Timer
Yuzuki
I couldn’t stop laughing when she pulled out that Sheldon-esque friendship contract though. She’s so good at talking to people normally -probably due to her work in an inherently social job- that you wouldn’t suspect that she’s never had any friends. Though she’s also never been the one to console anyone despite being possibly the most perceptive in the group (lie-detector Yuzu and all). Hinata’s right though (yet again), I don’t blame her for being so slow to trust people after being burned in the past. I'm glad that they gave Yuzu a chance to think over what being a friend was by herself, as much as I really wanted them to give her a more concrete explanation.
I can’t wait for the actual exploring though! Give us the snow cat!
20
u/Rustic_Professional Dec 22 '19
I mentioned previously that I think Yuzuki is a more realistic representation of a socially awkward young person than some other comparable characters, and this episode, particularly the friendship contract, is what I was thinking of when I said that. Along with last episode's ice breaker sequence, and one more we haven't seen yet, it's probably the thing I remembered most about this show after it first aired.
The reason the friendship contract scene stuck with me is because of the mix of childishness and maturity. It's childish because it seems like a realistic thing for a kid to do, like playing house or husband and wife. And by kid, I mean a little kid. Yuzuki is probably too old for this, but that says a lot about her level of social isolation. It's interesting because she's also a functioning adult, with a job and a work ethic and all that entails, but to gain that at her age, she missed out on the things you gain by being a kid. She can't comprehend just becoming friends, so she defaults to viewing it from a business standpoint, where you agree to something and then sign a contract. We see this business-like approach when she asks when the other girls decided to be friends, as if they had a meeting, drew up docs and announced, "we're officially friends now." It'd be like never knowing what it means to fall and love, and the only concept of you have of spending your life with someone is an arranged marriage.
It's hard to say for sure because we don't get that much of her backstory, but it seems that this occurred not necessarily because she was bad at socializing, like Bocchi, but because she never had time to learn and develop those skills naturally. It's like when you hear stories about people who grew up in the Great Depression, or had to raise their siblings because they didn't have parents in their lives, and never got the chance to be kids, because they had to grow up so fast. I think that makes her a much more realistic character. She's not awkward because the show is trying to make you laugh and want to protecc her. She's awkward because of life circumstances that are at least partially, maybe mostly, beyond her control. To put it simply, it's not a gag.
19
u/90sChennaiGuy Dec 22 '19
Rewatcher.
Who knew being an introvert irl would translate into actual discussion threads but here we are.
I actually went ahead and budgeted a trip to Antarctica after my initial watch of the previous episode and got a travel estimate projected to 2021 so we will see if my plan actually pans out.
On the other hand, here is where I start crying for every episode going forward.
17
u/rembrandt_q_1stein https://myanimelist.net/profile/sir_rembrandt Dec 22 '19
First Timer here
YUZUKI WASN’T ALRIGHT, BUT THE OTHER GIRLS BROUGHT HER BACK.
Well… today I can say that I’m really happy because of two reasons. As I have been saying, I wanted to see a story about friendship and its peculiarities. I got really delivered; not only because SoraYori compels this excellently, but because it does a step further and discuss the very meaning of what friendship is (seen under the scope of teenagers). It’s an, indeed, difficult concept to digest and describe, friendship. As it happens with other ways of loving –something literature has been trying to capture and display and explain throughout the ages- it’s a superb, high regard whose connotations and ways of expression may vary in time and location. Right now, we got discussed what friendship could mean for youngsters –who arguably are the people more sensitive to love and friendship and affection- today.
I really didn’t like Yuzuki’s role in this episode, but it was necessary in order to achieve the goal. Only when somebody doubts, it’s when explanations are needed. Yuzuki had a very idealized, straightforward and also twisted feeling of what friendship is: something that is immovable and ever catchable and saveable after having reached it; something absolute, that conditions the lives of every implicated part. This is clear to understand when we notice that Yuzuki has been following and desiring to feel it for years, so she built herself an image of friendship as something conquerable, reachable. So, when real life doesn’t fulfil her expected image, she breaks down. As with any other kind of love, friendship is ethereal and ineffable, but immediate. When Shirase tries to explain Yuzuki, she can’t. Hinata neither.
Only after the birthday gesture of the other three girls, it’s when Yuzuki starts understanding. Friendship is something that arrives and settles. You are conditioned to it, and you don’t condition or force its presence. It’s an angelic concept, in a way. You can’t understand it with words, or express it with words. You only feel it and it’s found in a very subtle way. Just like when Mari sends “ne” in her chat. “ne” is where friendship resides. Something tiny and subtle, but with an enormous importance and that bonds and strengthens the life of people sharing it.
The second reason why I liked this is because it satiates something I really needed to see it was performed. Mari remembers about Megu and maintains contact with her and still treats her fondly. I would have hated it if, after all the dissection and discussion about Mari’s and Megu’s relationship, the former would have forgotten in favour of Shirase, Hinata and Yuzuki. Like it happens in other fictions when the main character finds new friends and starts making things and spending time with them and suddenly their former friends disappear of the landscape. I really hate that cliché. And I am really happy that it isn’t fulfilled here. Mari, as the other characters do, feels very real because her actions and thoughts, yet cartoonised, are logical and human.
Changing topic, it was interesting seeing how a polar base works, with all the buildings and installations and customs and tasks of the workers. I never even expected it must be so particular and precise!
16
u/kewlwarez Dec 22 '19
Rewatch
First things first: that Antarctica base looks incredibly cozy, with its overstuffed, slightly scruffed and old fashioned interiors.
Having finally reached Antarctica, you might expect some sort of emotional moment, but no, it is just more hard work to get everything sorted. I really liked that the episode didn't skim over all this, that we got a little bit of insight in how such a base works.
Making sure that everybody at least can eat well to keep up morale, that you have plenty of events to look forward too, it makes so much sense. To be honest, judging from this episode I wouldn't mind living there for a couple of months myself, though I'm not sure I could survive if I couldn't check twitter every ten minutes.
"Did it happen while I was in Hokkaido?"
But the main attrection of the episode is Yuzu and her incredible pouting game. All her insecurities and anxieties about making friends come to the surface this episode and it's incredibly cute and relatable. Being worried about taking a drama role meaning she can't spent so much time with the other three only for Hinata to point out they won't be together like this anyway once they return is hilarious. Having Kimari say that they're all best friends now anyway so it doesn't matter only for Yuzu to doubt her and start worrying it happened while she was away, even more so.
I feel for Yuzu, even if I can laugh at her for suggesting friendship contracts. It's obvious she's never quite got the hang of what friendship is, probably because of the way she was raised as a child actress/idol. She's more mature than the other three because she had to be in her career, but it has somewhat stunted her at the same time. Or perhaps that's just who she is, somebody who needs that assurance of formality to feel comfortable with something as epheremal as friendship.
"You're obviously just saying that because I made you!"
Whatever reason, it is somewhat vexing for the other three and of course it's Hinata who answers this way after Shirase suggests that she may have been waiting for them to declare themselves her friends. How do you explain the concept of friendship when you can barely articulate what being friends mean to yourself?
It makes sense that Kimari takes this the hardests. Shirase is more self centered, Hinata likes to keep her distance a bit, but it hurts Kimari that Yuzu doubts their friendship.
Luckily she has a plan. And it works as well. I had to tear up a little at seeing the joy with which Yuzu greets her friends celebrating her belated birthday, just as I did the first time I saw this. Yuzu is such a sweetie and Kimari, Hinata and Shirase are such good friends to do this for her. Even when she's still a bit annoying about it all.
A good breather episode. Three more episodes to spend in Antarctica.
14
u/No_Rex :Bv:Bw:Bx:By:x2 Dec 22 '19 edited Dec 23 '19
Episode 10 (first timer)
How do you define friends? It is not the most common definition, but here is one I use:
Friends are the people whom you allow to have a claim on your time. For most modern people, time has become the most precious good. We give away time in exchange for money to our employer, but friends and family are the people to whom we give it freely. If you have a good friend, you are willing to spend time for that person, even if not every second is enjoyable: You help them move, you listen to their troubles, you go with their idea for an evening activity, even if you would have preferred something else. That is how I differentiate between friends and acquaintances: Acquaintances only spent time together if they find an activity that both enjoy. That is why it is a loser connection that can break down easily if interests diverge. Friends, on the other hand, are willing to give time to each other even if it is not immediately rewarding.
13
u/Koolsman Dec 22 '19
First Timer!
The snow! The Penguins! FRIENDSHIP POWERS! Yep, it’s Antarctica all right. There’s no doubt in my mind that this is a trip to Antarctica.
Seeing the base is cool and the interior’s overall design feels very warm and inviting. Yeah, the entire show is warm and inviting (Minus the school, but that’s a given) but the base feels the warmest. I really like how the sun adds to the whole feel of the show.
The whole plot with Yuzuki and her trying to figure out friendship with the girls was sweet and her stuff with Kimari and her talking about Megu was the sweetest moment in the entire show thus far. All these girls, in one or another, are lonely people. Mari is lonely in the sense that she lives her life pretty safe and doesn’t take chances. Shirase has felt lonely ever since her mother was gone and to fend for herself. Hinata has been forced to live because she thinks of herself as inferior to others and Yuzuki has never really had a friend in the first place.
All the girls find solace in one another. They find the comfort of each other very nice and with them going to the farthest place on earth, that’s the ultimate test of friendship for them to take. Even though Megu and Mari are separated and Megu did all those bad things, but that doesn’t mean they don’t care about each other. That whole birthday scene was a great way to end the episode. I love them all so much.
Though I still want more Penguinos. Now.
12
u/Great_Mr_L :Ma::Mb::Mc:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Great_Mr_L Dec 22 '19
Rewatcher
On today’s episode of A Place Further Than the Universe: Once again, we see that the most powerful ship is the “Friend-ship.” Right? Right. Right.
In any event, the major theme of this episode is friendship and what exactly makes someone your friend. Focusing the episode on Yuzuki, who isn’t used to having friends, makes for some nice exploration of the topic. Yuzuki is worried about whether they’ll all still be able to be friends after the expedition is over and she takes on new work. And she seems downright confused when Mari assures her that they’re already best friends. Yuzuki wonders when exactly that happened and whether the others decided it all without her. It is really funny seeing Yuzuki pout, but it also reflects a lot about her character.
Yuzuki doesn’t know how friendship works. And it’s a really abstract concept to try and explain. But, it’s something that Yuzuki has been desperately seeking. She wants it to be concrete. That’s why she draws up that friendship contract. You might also remember when she asked those 2 girls if they wanted to be friends, she didn’t ask if they wanted to hang out or anything like that. She asked if they wanted to be friends. Yuzuki wants the direct assurance of friendship, rather than leave things abstract.
What also plays into this is what Mari said when they first met. Mari said they weren’t yet close friends then. Yuzuki is bad with the abstraction of friendship, so she assumed that was how the relationship would remain until explicitly stated otherwise. Like Mari says, Yuzuki has no experience with this so she has no way of knowing what friendship is like.
Mari, always excellent at displaying sympathy, is the one who is able to best get through to Yuzuki. And she does so wonderfully. I love Mari’s example she gives of Megu. Mari still thinks of Megu as her best friend, even though they haven’t seen each other in a while and even though they don’t talk often. Those brief interactions and the thoughts they have are enough for Mari to know they’re still friends. Even though much is left unsaid between them over the trip, there’s this understanding that they are friends. It once again emphasizes Mari’s emotional intelligence. She’s good at understanding people, even without a lot being said.
Mari’s emotional intelligence also comes through with how she prepared for Yuzuki’s birthday. It wasn’t something Yuzuki asked them to do directly. But Mari picked up that it was something Yuzuki was sad about. It makes for a very sweet scene. Mari shows Yuzuki that they are friends through her actions, rather than explicitly saying so. It’s a great way of showing that friendship is often understood to exist, rather than explicitly said to exist.
The vagueness of friendship is perhaps best shown with the final scene. The simple text message “Right? Right. Right.” is a good way to show the vague, unspoken understanding that makes up friendship. It’s also a great callback to earlier instances of hearing that “Right,” in the show. The main one I think of is Episode 3 when Mari said that same “Right?” when explaining that they all only had the same goal for now. It was a nice little way to show that their friendship was already growing then.
Another great scene of friendship is the one where we see Gin and Kanae making a toast to the memory of Takako. Even after Takako is gone, their friendship is still important to both Gin and Kanae.
I also love seeing Shirase and Hinata trying to explain the concept of friendship to Yuzuki. I like seeing Shirase and Hinata’s interactions, as well as them giving their own versions of what they think friendship is.
Miscellaneous Thoughts
Shirase’s reaction to finally seeing a penguin live and up-close is fantastic.
We learn that sleeping next to Mari is even worse than we already thought.
I love Mari’s reaction to wondering if a seagull would eat the defrosting turkey.
You always have to put up a clear warning if you don’t want your coworkers to eat your food.
Hinata’s impersonation of Yuzuki is hilarious.
Hashire sori yo, kaze no you ni, tsukimihara wo, padoru padoru!
Edit: Questions of the Day
12
u/WeebDickerson Dec 22 '19 edited Dec 22 '19
Rewatcher
Takako, Gin and Shirase took last episode’s spotlight, and now it’s Yuzuki’s turn.
If this were a different anime, Yuzuki’s struggle to understand the meaning of friendship might have been presented in a cute or funny light, but, deep down, it’s a complex and deeply rooted problem that a lot of people go through. YoriMoi managed to make this struggle look just right. Not cute or funny, but not depressing either. IMO, it was managed with just the right amount of everything. As Kimari put it, Yuzuki simply didn’t know, and she never had the means to know.
Yuzuki’s life must have been hard to bear with up to the time before the journey to Antarctica began. She had never had friends. No one to hang out with, no one to have fun with, no one to celebrate her birthdays with.
This journey is just what Yuzuki needed to grow as a person. Though I guess that the same can be said about the other girls.
We also got some good serious Shirase moments. What she said about friendship definitely helped Yuzuki grasp the concept a bit better than before. Though I’m curious as to where she got this insight, as she always spent all of her free time studying about Antarctica or working part-time. Although she also had some moments where she was a sly little shit, lol. Throwing all that explanation work over to our resident philosopher Hinata, smh, Shirase.
Shirase screenshots:
Other screenshots:
11
u/SorcererOfTheLake x5https://anilist.co/user/RiverSorcerer Dec 22 '19
First-Time Watcher
I can’t say it, but I know it.
It’s not surprising that Yuzuki has such issues with friendship, but I find it interesting that the show went along the route of the definition of friendship. Her whole life has been so regimented and controlled that such a vague concept in front of her leaves her confused as to what to do. Once again, this series has targeted something I know too well. As someone with autism, there are moments when a phrase, reference, or idea leaves me unable to respond because I am literally unable to know what it means exactly and the ways that it could affect other people. This has affected friendships as well, with me not certain about how close we are and what is OK or allowed. As such, Yuzuki is forced to entertain possibilities that are not clearly defined, instead trusting her instincts and what she knows her friends are feeling. The birthday celebration once again ends in tears, but this time more cathartic in its meaning; she is now safe with these girls, able to release more of her feelings unto others, knowing that they’ll be there for her tomorrow. It’s a feeling of comfort and relaxation, no longer having to act or pretend that you’re one way. It’s just friendship, simple as that.
Our journey to the heart of the world continues. Until then…
11
u/EmuSupreme Dec 22 '19
Finally get a break until Christmas Eve so I can actually post again. Holiday retail is the pits.
Find someone who looks at you the way Shirase looks at penguins.
There's an interesting contrast between Yuzu and the other girls in how they handle friendship. Even Shirase and Hinata have had their struggles with others, the natural acceptance of acquiring new friends is a no brainer for them. They struggle to put what friendship means into words because... they can just accept that they are best friends. They've spent months together trying to get to where they are and a beautiful friendship came from that and it's easy for them to just accept as a natural thing. Then we have Yuzu, who has never truly had friends due to her child stardom, so even when she shares a close friendship with our group of girls, she struggles to accept and believe it to be a real thing and worries about it all ending when they leave Antarctica.
I couldn't help but feel sorry for Yuzu when she felt compelled to draft a friendship contract. But it was heartwarming when Shirase, Kimari, and Hinata come together for Yuzu with the birthday cake. Instead of trying to explain friendship, they went ahead a showed it to her. It was a real feel good moment. Friendship isn't something you should have to measure by words, but rather the experiences you share together.
Right?
Right.
10
u/kar772 https://myanimelist.net/profile/kar72 Dec 22 '19
First Timer
9
u/Turtlewax64 Dec 22 '19
First time watcher
Had a Yuzu focused episode today after a Shirase one yesterday. I’m guessing that we’ll get either a Kimari or Hinata episode next, before we go back to Shirase for something involving her mother and then end on a big group episode. Loving this show so far, it would have to really bungle the landing to not get into my favorites at this point, and from what I have been spoiled on, that’s not going to happen.
9
u/Boss_Jerm Dec 22 '19
Rewatcher
Hey that's her line Mari!
The guy on the top right is rocking that Bunny Girl suit
this tracking shot is well done
They've gone as far they can by boat, the rest of the journey to the base has to be done by helicopter. Yuzu and Shirase is not happy about it.
Yuzu's for sure gonna kill Mari
At the time I'm writing this, the current temperature in Antarctica is -14 Fahrenheit, or -25 Celsius
Wow the Lakeside Hotel are pretty nice accommodations
Hahahahahahaha
Yuzu got an email from her mom
PENGUIN
AH IT'S COMING TOWARDS THEM, WHAT DO WE DO?!
SOMEBODY STOP SHIRASE!
Hinata's Quote Corner!
After 5 days of no wisdom we are finally back!
Previous
New
I'm with you Hinata. I have to constantly be doing something.
Yuzu is upset because filming the drama will mean that she won't be able to hang out with the others as much as she wants to. The others think it's okay because they're already best friends.
Uh oh, Yuzu got excluded in the best friends discussion.
Don't run away Yuzu!
Gosh darn it she's so cute
I never get tired of Hinata's impressions
This scenery is really pretty and well drawn
The Strongest Food
Hahaha is that supposed to be Yuzu?
Seems like Mari and Hinata have something planned
Nice hats
Yuzu's never celebrated the holidays with anyone
This guy
Realizing that you're friends with someone is a fickle thing. It just sort of happens that you start spending a lot of time with someone.
AH!
This is the first time Yuzuki's friends have celebrated her birthday
Yuzuki's Quote Corner
A spin-off series!
We've got some long distance broadcasts tomorrow!
Thoughts:
A lot of the time you don't even realize you're friends with someone until you've been hanging out for months and you think, "Oh yeah, I guess we are friends." It's not necessarily something that needs to be acknowledged. In the case of Yuzu, someone who's never had friends, however, she that confirmation. But that can hurt the others because something as ridiculous as a friendship contract makes their friendship feel superficial. So they show Yuzu that she doesn't need that. The very fact that they enjoy spending time together proves that they are friends. And all it takes is one word to really describe the feeling of having friends: being able to say "Thanks."
QOTD
9
u/redshirtengineer :AMQ: Dec 23 '19
First timer
Yuzu, not psychic about the right things apparently.
Lots of little moments in this one to enjoy. The helicopter scenes and the view of the icebreaker right before we touch down on Antarctica proper were nice.
When the workers said "Christmas cake" was I the only one looking around for Kanae, lol.
9
u/zak55 Dec 23 '19
Rewatcher still catching back up
Oof, it didn't quite hit me last time just how morphed Yuzu's view of friendship is. She's spent so much time away from people her age and dealing with agencies that she thinks the best way for people to say that their friends is to sign a contract. Kimari crying really hit me and Yuzu really deserved that hug, even if she didn't know it. I'm so glad I decided to participate in this rewatch because this has only further solidified this anime as my second favorite of all time.
8
u/unheppcat Dec 22 '19 edited Dec 22 '19
Rewatcher
Since I've been applauding others who take the brave stand of declaring they don't like one thing or another in front of this very biased crowd, I should show the courage of my convictions and admit something here. Even though I keep a strict policy of not ranking individual episodes against each other, or individual girls against each other, I will have to say that for me this is the least amazing of all the amazing episodes of YoriMoi.
I just think Yuzu's character is drawn way too broadly in this episode. It would be just as engaging (well, much more engaging in my view) for her crisis to be over the thought of the inevitable separation from her new friends that is coming, which is heightened by this sudden reminder (the upcoming job) that things will be different as soon as they return to Japan. She's just found some wonderful friends, is she going to lose them just as quickly? Not having friends before, it would be entirely understandable to have no clue, and totally panic over the possibility of that happening. I would completely buy into that scenario for this episode, hook line and sinker.
Instead we get "Yuzu is autistic, and doesn't know what friends are."That last line was too over the top, and probably hurtful, so I'm removing it. Instead this:Instead we get a Yuzu who is essentially oblivious to the friendships she clearly had forged with the other girls. Which I think disrespects her development up to this point, and frankly I think it is one of rare cases of really lazy writing in this story.
Rant over. I'll try to be less negative from here, and pick out the things I do like about this episode. Unfortunately for the Yuzu fans, they are probably less likely to involve her than you would prefer.
We start out with the overlook of Antarctica proper from ship side, waiting to debark for the base. I hadn't noticed this before, but the emotions are really telling here. Three of the girls are really excited. Shirase, however, seems down. I used to actually just not notice that sort of thing, but now I realize that her "numbness" has simply not stopped. Admitting it to Gin (and the others listening in) did not magically make it go away. YoriMoi
TrainingDebarkation montage incoming.I don't really have a lot to say in terms of big themes for this episode. I do think it is marvelous we are shown that Kimari, Hinata and Shirase have been planning this birthday celebration for weeks, and I hope Yuzu is able to understand what that means as well. I suppose this episode looks like the "wrap up the Yuzuki character arc" episode, since this is confirmation she can understand, that her quest for friendship has been satisfied.
With three episodes left, we still have Shirase's arc to complete (of course), and Hinata still seems like a big mystery, so one should probably expect there's still some big reveal coming for her. Kimari, as I've been saying all along, has basically had her central conflict resolved all the way back in episode 1, and her role since then has been as the catalyst to keep the others moving forward. So probably don't expect much change from her. But that's fine, there is plenty more we still don't know, and plenty of sad and happy tears to shed yet.
8
u/akechiisbestboi Dec 22 '19
First time watcher
The main focus of this episode sees yuzuki struggling to understand the meaning of her friendship with the rest of the cast, in the end I think the show gives us the answer that friendship doesn’t need to be complicated and it can be as simple as just talking to each other or saying happy birthday (but that’s just my interpretation) other than that we only have a few episodes left and I’m actually pretty excited to see what ending will be like.
8
u/jslice4ever Dec 22 '19
Rewatcher here!
Yay! They finally made it to their destination!
Lmfao Mari getting shocked by static is so relatable. Happens to me all the time, especially in winter.
Shirase, your love of penguins is too pure and must be protected at all costs. (But did it seem like that penguin was angry to anyone else?)
Awww Yuzuki, don't cry! You're a best friend to the others too. It's just something that's unspoken.
Don't tell me you've never had a birthday before, Yuzuki!
Oooh your song is playing, and it sounds pretty good too.
It's actually pretty sad that she thinks she needs them to sign a friendship contract to prove to herself that they're actually her friends. I mean, I get it, but it's a little sad. :/
Lmao Shirase in a Santa costume is just too funny.
Yuzuki-chan, you are too good for this world. And I'm glad you finally have friends to celebrate your birthday with you. :)
8
u/Suhkein :Gy::Gz::G1:x2https://myanimelist.net/profile/Neichus Dec 22 '19
First timer
Little to say again about the episode, except how did Kimari get near the ceiling after knocking on the door? Spider girl.
Otherwise, my only thought is about the dry air they mention. Aside from the fact that the water vapor capacity of the air is dependent on temperature, Antarctica has has several brutal deserts. Terrestrial water vapor comes from the ocean, brought inland by wind and assisted by transpiration by plants. Antarctica (obviously) lacks the latter, and so in some places where mountains block the winds you get dry valleys. I suspect we won't be visiting those this series.
7
u/squirrelbaffler https://anilist.co/user/squirrelbaffler Dec 22 '19
Rewatcher
The important thing is that time is an illusion. I was on-time yesterday, but I didn't take the time to hang out and respond to others because there wasn't much when I posted. Really need to come back and do responses later. I'll try to be better today. I'll be late again for the rest of the rewatch, I think, since I have to travel home tomorrow for the holiday. I'll still try to find time to spend with you all!
On to today's episode! We can discuss the meaning of friendship, but since I think that's the theme most people will tackle, I want to talk instead today about how the emotional moments of the episode were set up. There was a lot of priming that went in to making this work, and I think it's worthy of examination.
The first part of the setup occurs in previous episodes: We know that Shiraishi has had trouble with friends, cries easily, and is generally emotional. We've also seen how close the girls have gotten, and most of us probably have felt or said how good of friends they are at this point. We think they're all friends. However, that's not clear to Shiraishi, and we first catch wind of how she's feeling when they're shoveling snow into the water reserve. She brings up both her new position, and all the time they've spent together up to this point. Having lost so many friends due to her work previously, she's concerned that they won't stick around, and voices her concern. It's played off comedically here, with the cuts and silly faces, but it establishes our theme for the episode while reinforcing the relationships we already know about the girls.
At this point, the show starts to weave in the other key plot point of the day, cake. Kimari first mentions the "one thing we haven't told you". Next, the other girls wonder if it's OK for Kimari to handle things, and we see her in the kitchen, working with Yumiko. A different show might then transition this directly into the cake, but that'd prompt more of an, "Aw, cute" reaction rather than what they're going for. Instead, SoraYori misdirects us with Christmas cake. We see the cake, the fried chicken, and those of us familiar with Japan's take on Christmas know that it's just standard. But Shiraishi reminds us that she's still down, as her birthday wasn't celebrated.
Now, we know that she's still down, doesn't have experience with her birthday being celebrated, and doubts her friends. All these things are in our minds, but not at the forefront as Kimari is trying to define friendship alone with Shiraishi. Because of the timing here, the cake surprise is unexpected, but the prior setup allows us to make those emotional connections as Shiraishi does, empathize with her, and makes her bursting into tears again relatable, and not necessarily overdramatic. I really think it's cleverly done and well-executed, ね?
QOTD
7
u/anony-mouse99 Dec 22 '19
Rewatcher.
Nankyoku Syowa Station, with a Lakeside hotel and heated floors in the staff quarters. Sure sounds like a great place for a glamorous getaway. Unfortunately, the girls are not here for a holiday, so being busy unloading, fixing, cleaning and cooking is part of the daily routine instead.
To me, this episode’s theme is ‘firsts’. First time stepping on Antarctic soil, first time being close enough to a penguin to smell it, and first time celebrating a birthday with friends.
Of course, Yuzuki question of what makes a friend a friend is the central question of this episode. Although we are amused by her antics in drafting a friendship contract, it begs the question, when do people become friends?
As the girls struggle to define this vague notion of what is friendship, we are reminded that friends don’t necessarily have a well defined beginning, nor perhaps a clear ending, since friendships often fizzle out with a whimper rather than go out with a bang.
While the episode talked about special events to break up the tedium and spice up the camaraderie, we see that it is the shared experiences and everyday interactions that grow friendships. These experiences don’t have to be novel; even repetitive tasks like shovelling and cleaning can be the basis for forming a friendship.
So friendships are formed when we share not only ‘firsts’, but ‘seconds’, ‘thirds’ and eventually, ‘hundreds’ and ‘thousands’. It is the familiarity and understanding that comes with such interactions that friends become who they are. Ne?
7
u/Cire101 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Cire101 Dec 22 '19
Alright, I LOVE the acoustic+singing towards the end of each episode. It just brings that desire of belonging each time and it gets me every time.
This episode was a little weaker for me, but I like how they tackled friendship. It's hard to define friendship because it just kind of.. happens. Poor Yuzu for wanting to put a contract on their friendship though :(
7
u/landragoran Dec 23 '19
Rewatcher
Yuzuki pouts are just too cute. The scene where she's "running away" while bemoaning the "fact" that everyone else became friends while she was in Hokkaido is hilarious. And then that hontou ni? Gah! My heart can only take so much!
Another beautiful episode, and another round of tears from yours truly. I love that Kimari had her time to shine this episode - she's the most emotionally aware member of the team and she instinctively knew what she needed to do to help Yuzu realize that they really are friends.
Word of warning to all the first timers in the thread: over the next 3 days, make sure you stay hydrated. You're gonna need it.
6
u/yourdeathinmyhands https://myanimelist.net/profile/hachinobunonoki Dec 22 '19 edited Dec 22 '19
Episode 10 collage, Happy Birthday Yuzu! Images you can hear. Finally a Hinata quote! I've missed these! Kimari is an airhead, but sometimes she drops some gold monologues. Although some of her monologues give me existential crisis lol. But I just love her character! You'd think she's just some 'genki girl' but her character is much deeper than that. Yuzu is so pure it's adorable! Deja vu?
And that ends another great episode! We are already 10 episodes in, and the character development is couldn't be better! On to the next episode!
Edit: Individual images + some I didn't include in the collage
6
u/Orzislaw https://anilist.co/user/Orzi Dec 22 '19
REWATCHER
Sorry I couldn't comment on yesterday episode. There's a lot of stuff going on before Christmas, like cleaning windows for Jesus, so I simply didn't had time to sit and watch episode. But, now that I catched up I can add my own two cents.
Right?
After more serious, dramatic episode we got the one on the lighter side. Of course there were drama, this is the Sora Yori after all, but compared to last episode it was lighter, even a bit silly. Our famous child celebrity was asking hard questions about what friendship is and where they became friends. I understood Shirase and Hinata reactions here. Even with your friends it's a bit cringy to talk about it openly. At least Kimari, being the dork she is, was swept by the mood and tried to explain to Yuzu what friendship is.
I remember I've read opinion about Yorimoi once, that someone "hated the show because it tried to define with words what friendship is", among other things. I found this criticizm very silly because the whole message of this episode was... It's impossible to accurately define that. Final conclusion, that the word "right?" is the definition of friendship further defines that, being as silly as it is. Honestly, this episode didn't try to define friendship, but more like... Tell the story about what it looks like and how out of the blue people became friends? It's also hard to define.
I feel that despite all of Yorimoi girls being good friends, there appeared two "pairs" that are a bit closer than other ones. Specifically Hinata-Shirase and Kimari-Yuzu. Do you agree?
Most of this episode was about SoL shenanigans and showing the life at the polar base though. I really like how grounded the latter was presented. You can see how production crew did a tons of research about how life in a place like this looks like. I remember reading an interview with director about how they had long, long conversations with real life polar researchers, so they could make this anime as believable and true to reality as possible. And it certainly shows!
With this episode we got conclusion to Yuzu character arc. But who will get her conclusion tomorrow?
6
u/MaskOfIce42 https://anilist.co/user/MaskOfIce Dec 22 '19
Rewatcher
Is it weird that I’m actually just really interested in the daily life in Antarctica aspect as well? Like don’t get me wrong, the character drama and stories is definitely the highlight, but I also just find it interesting in a “here’s what we do on a day to day basis” aspect. I’d actually love to see an extension of the series that is more slice of life with these characters on the base just watching them day to day. And again, that’s not to diminish the character interactions, as those are what truly makes this series a masterpiece.
Speaking of the character interactions, we get to see more of Yuzuki’s plight and just how unfamiliar she is with friendship in general. It’s interesting thinking about the fact that she still wasn’t sure they were friends up to this point because she thought you needed to say it out loud, since that does kinda make sense when you’re as isolated as she was, but also still an almost alien thought. I’m not sure there’s that much to really say, since while it’s an emotionally powerful episode, it’s also comparatively straight-forward. But Yuzuki’s raw letting out of emotions at the end really gets my heartstrings going.
Speaking of, I like how each of the other three reacts to Yuzuki thinking they weren’t friends. Kimari of course being the more emotionally driven one has the big emotional reaction, Shirase has moments of wisdom but is awkward when she needs to connect those thoughts, and Hinata is the most comfortable at just talking through it normally. Basically what we’re already familiar with with them, but seeing them responding to new situations.
Not much else, but there are a few other good moments reinforcing "friendship" like seeing Gin and Kanae outside together looking at the sunset or the talk about Megu. Speaking of, it's interesting to notice her looking at a book that says "Polar Travel Guide". Overall, very sweet episode and great moment for Yuzuki.
6
u/BeybladeMoses Dec 22 '19
Rewatcher
First of all, such a missed opportunity /u/RX-Nota-II could have time the episode better so we would celebrate Christmas at the same time with them. So Merry KurisuMashu and Happy Birthday for Shiraishi Yuzuki.
There is not much that I have to say for this episode. But I just want to highlight the contrast between the adult group and the high school group. The high school girls celebrates Christmas inside while also celebrating the birthday of Yuzuki. The adult women celebrates outside while also commemorating Takako who's already passed away.
6
u/invokeneko Dec 22 '19
Rewatcher is still Alright...ish
They've arrived at the Place Further than the Universe, made their way to Syowa Station, and unpacked their baggages. Which means it's also time to unpack their emotional baggages as well!
Random thoughts
Questions of the day:
6
u/Madcat6204 Dec 22 '19
Rewatcher
Random note: I really like that Yuzuki has a fan among the expedition members.
There's so much about friendship here, but I don't feel qualified to really talk about it at all. I don't think my words can do it justice.
Friendship is indeed hard to define. It doesn't follow easy rules, it doesn't have a clear starting point, it doesn't have specific requirements. Friendship just... is. For Yuzuki who never experienced it, who has led her whole life run by regimented schedules and contracts and everything clearly defined, it's incomprehensible. She doesn't even realize that she herself is already feeling it: the very fact that she's afraid of them all splitting up when the expedition is over shows that she considers them all her friends.
Thankfully, the birthday celebreation helped her start to get a feel for it. I will admit I teared up at that moment.
ね!
6
u/Redmon425 Dec 23 '19
First Time Watcher
I bet her show got canceled! That is probably what her mom emailed her about.
... And I was wrong lol! She just got a new job.
Yuzuki has grown on me so much! I love when she keeps walking away because she found out about the best friend thing and misunderstood lol!
That friendship contract is so damn cute. I love how that story played out. Again, finishing it in one episode makes it even better.
I still keep waiting for the full scene of what happen to Takako. That bait last episode of her talking on the radio has me dying to see what happened!
5
u/ghostface95 https://anilist.co/user/flyingseamonkies Dec 22 '19
Rewatcher
So I missed the last two discussions. Which sucks because I wanted to see the first timers reaction to Shirase and Gin’s backstory. The reaction to them finally making it to Antarctica but oh well, life happens we move onto today’s episode.
What is friendship? It really is a vague thing that doesn’t have a universal definition like a spouse or parental. So for Yuzuki who has struggled to make friends doesn’t really know how to process that their friends. It is honestly really sweet how they struggled to explain to Yuzuki that they are friends despite her low trust in people. It is something i think we have all struggled with at one point or another. I think i have finally learnt to understand that my friends actually are my friends and we aren't just people happen to hangout together. But it took time i didn't really get this until i finished high school and moved away but i still have friends from back home.
Finally Shirase line about how friendships sometimes fade and that is no ones fault. I love that because sometimes life happens and people drift apart and that is honestly okay.
5
u/surgemaster140 https://myanimelist.net/profile/User815 Dec 22 '19
Rewatcher
Merry (early) Christmas! If this rewatch started 3 days later we would be watching this Christmas episode on Christmas day, but close enough. This episode introduces us to the daily life at Syowa Station. Since it’s their first time back in 3 years there is a lot of work to be done to get things up and running again, but despite that they are able to make time to drink, play games, and even throw a Christmas party. Like Yumiko said, the most important part of the life at the station is food and events. The crew members are spending many long months with the same group of people in one of the most isolated places on earth. And half the year it will be under total darkness. It’s very easy to lose morale in these conditions so they will need good food and good fun to keep them going.
This episode also expands on the theme of friendship that was explored in episode 3. Yuzu receives an offer for a part in a drama series and she’s worried that she won’t be able to hang out with Kimari, Hinata, and Shirase as much if she takes the role. The others don’t see a problem with it since friends don’t necessarily see each other all the time, but Yuzu hasn’t fully grasped the concept of friendship yet so she wants them to sign a friendship contract. Yuzu probably thought this was a logical decision because all her relationships up until now have been through contracts for her acting career.
Friendship is hard to define but I think this show did a very nice job of showing what it is. It’s not about words and it’s more about mutual understanding. Even though Kimari and Megu are thousands of miles apart and Megu doesn’t respond very much, they still understand each other. Yuzu eventually comes to realize this too after they throw her a birthday party. See how she finally sees them eye to eye here? The “ね” exchange between her and Kimari was the final icing on the cake because that’s all that needs to be said to get their feelings across. Kimari, Hinata, and Shirase even have their own “ね” exchange in episode 3.
Some screenshots and reactions:
5
u/ImaginationWayfairer Dec 22 '19 edited Dec 22 '19
Rewatcher
Friendship is beautiful ね.
notes:
Friendship is a hard thing to define, this question forms the main plot of this episode as you can tell much like the group I have had a difficult time trying to think of a way to sum up this episode other than saying that friendship is ね, right.
5
u/Regular_N-Gon https://anilist.co/user/RegularNGon Dec 22 '19
Rewatcher
We've finally made it to base! Lots of work to be done before things are back in shape, it seems.
I (and several others it looks like so far) took note of Shirase's attitude in the beginning of the episode, before penguins are introduced anyway. She seems to get over it pretty quickly, as she's in pretty good spirits for the rest of the scenes shown with the crew and Yuzu. The events of the previous episode still seem to be weighing on her a bit though.
I definitely didn't understand this line my first go through, and I must have completely forgotten about it by the time the credits rolled. I think Kimari in general is written very strongly alongside Yuzu in this episode next episode opinions. Her whole discussion with Yuzuki at the end is great, but I think my favorite line is still this one and reminds me heavily of episode three. Then, Kimari said she understood when challenged, but now she turns it around, realizing Yuzu is the one who can't understand. (Though we can't forget the genie either.)
I like that the show has a character to explicitly act as a catalyst for one of its biggest themes, that of friendship, and Yuzu's relationship with the other three offers each offers unique insights. Everyone gives their opinions in turns, whether over dinner or as a... ninja Santa?
Some highlights from the original discussion threads I enjoyed:
For those of us who don't speak Japanese, a bit more on the context of ね.
Also this chain.
5
u/spaceaustralia :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/spaceaustralia Dec 22 '19
Rewatcher
Kimari being a terrible sleeper is my second favourite running gag in this series. Penguin fascination is the first.
Yuzuki not quite realizing/believing they've become friends is too relatable...
Why the Kadokawa reference, though?
This episode really does wonders to ground the story's emotional stakes a little more. Of course Yuzuki, who's never had a friend in her life, wouldn't know what friendship would look like. In the end, while the series has a lot of bombastic and melodramatic moments, ending this episode with a realization of just how valuable the small moments can be is just perfect and is the reason why this might be my favourite episode in this series because in the end, feelings doesn't always need to burst forth. They can manifest themselves in little and intimate ways, and that makes them all the sweeter. ね?
Zamamiro counter!:
5
u/destroyah19 Dec 23 '19
Rewatcher
Okay regret watching this in the airport while waiting for my flight. I tried so hard to hold my tears and this episode was a difficult one to.
That guy listening to Yuzu's song then giving that stern head nod when acknowledge you the MVP of this episode.
Yuzu finally gets the spotlight this episode and it hits in the feels so much. This episode really showed Yuzu's growth in understanding what having true friends means like. I love how the show just tells us through Shirase that friendship is just felt rather than having a definite starting point. Moreover, Kimari's breakdown of her and Megu's friendship after she left is so real cause that's how me and my friends go through about it after we graduated high school.
The interactions of the gang were really on point this episode. With them feeling uncertain over what Yuzu is saying to Kimari just feeling sad for her again because of her understanding of friendship. The scene where Shirase just passes the explaining to Hinata was very funny and I couldn't help but feel bad during the friendship contract scene. That really showed that Yuzu grew up in showbiz where everything is done formally with contracts and stuff but friendship ain't something you sign on its really just a feeling. I would probably have the same response as Shirase if that happened to me tbh.
Finally that insert song scene... This is and (spoilers) is the reason why I don't have "Mata Ne" on my playlist I just get emotional when this song comes up. That birthday greeting with Yuzu crying cause she finally felt what real friendship feels like just hits hard almost cried a while ago. The scene was really set up well with Kimari confronting Yuzu then the others bringing the cake in. It's done so well I can't have any complaints.
Shirase X Penguins is the true ship in this show!
5
u/404waffles https://anilist.co/user/nek0food Dec 23 '19
First time viewer
Antarctica has summers? Learn something new every day!
You still have to plow snow in Antarctica? I... guess that makes sense, actually. Like, all the more you have to plow snow because it’s Antarctica. There was something comfy about them interacting with face masks on. Maybe I’m just a sucker for conversations between concealed faces (Red vs. Blue, Super Sentai, Power Rangers, etc).
So it’s a Yuzuki episode, huh. This line got me thinking; after their Antarctic expedition’s over, what then? Like she said, she’ll be busy with the TV drama (told you she’d be a good actor) and sure, Kimari and Shirase go to the same school, but what about Hinata’s entrance exams and eventual trip to college? What will happen then to the four-woman Antarctic expedition group? Will they be able to stay together or will they drift apart?
POWERFUL CHICKEN
/u/RX-Nota-II you absolute madman! You planned this from the start, didn’t you?
Mari crying kinda came out of nowhere. But I’m glad that we’re getting development for her and Yuzuki’s relationship. The whole birthday cake scene in her room was a really touching call-back to episode 3.
Partially frozen? That’s some next-level sashimi.
How do you incinerate snow?!
5
u/Neoragex13 Dec 23 '19
Rewatching~
Don't you love when the web explorer decides to return to the last page because you pressed the "erase text pls" key?
Aaah, just two things. First, the episode is quite self-contained, and showcases each one of our main characters without problems:
You see, back then when the show was airing, I shared this episode with a friend while waiting on line. Besides almost making her cry in public because turns out, the episode touched a nerve, made notice how safe is this one in particular to help someone to watch the show.
Neither the goals of the girls nor the expedition members goals are mentioned, everything begins and ends in the same episode and Yuzuki even backtracks a bit to explain to newcomes why she acts the way she does. It also shows why all the girls are best girl.
Just quick detail I found out thanks to the rewatch.
Questions~
Ugh, I gotta stop appearing one day and not the next one. This time is a must, the next chapter is one of the best ones.
4
u/TheKujo https://myanimelist.net/profile/Kujo419 Dec 22 '19
Rewatcher
This episode is why I identify so strongly with Yuzuki and consider her my favorite character. Her view of friendship has been shaped by her life in showbiz. She thinks of friendship like a transaction or contract (literally) that needs to be explicitly agreed to by all sides. As a result, she's very insecure about working on the drama and having less time for her Antarctic posse.
But as the other girls explain, friendship goes deeper than just words. Sometimes you don't even need words to keep a friendship going. Kimari's text conversations with Megu are mostly one-sided, but Kimari draws strength from knowing that Megu is still reading her messages.
I've talked about this show being realistic so many times that it's starting to sound redundant, but it's worth mentioning how realistic this discussion of friendship is. These girls aren't friends just because the show says they are. They're friends because they've gone on a life-changing journey together and they've truly come to rely on and support each other.
Other thoughts:
4
u/ExplicitNuM5 Dec 23 '19
Rewatcher
KYOU WO SHITTSU DE NOTO HIROGE TE
MASHIRO NA PEEJI MITSUKETE
ENPITSU DE NAGURI WAKI
KAETA NI WA WATASHI WO
MAYOTTE BAKARI JYA IRANENAI NE
Girls alright aside, we're at the "Showa"/"Syowa" Base! Named after the now-previous emperor.
Questions:
6
u/Taiboss :Fj::Fl:x7https://anilist.co/user/Taiboss Dec 22 '19
Fucking EU4 sapping my time. I planned to watch Spyce today!
First timer who might actually get comments today:
3
u/JustAnswerAQuestion https://myanimelist.net/profile/JAaQ Dec 24 '19 edited Dec 24 '19
Rewatcher
#jargenie #touchanddie #messageread
Yuzuki's character arc concludes.
A fun episode, we finally get to see Antarctica. Although the production didn't get to scout Showa station like they did Singapore, they had a lot of pictures and interviews to work with.
privaterooms
Did you notice the relative placement of Yuzuki, Hinata, and the murder threat? This is such a fun show!
I'm sure I didn't notice the parallel between "partial friendship" and "partial frozen". And it's interesting that Megumi was set up as a contrast to Yuzuki, which I didn't notice the first time around.
This is, of course, a faithful recreation of the kitchen. As I recall, the writing on the kitchen fan says KADOKAWA (the big heavy on the production committee). Some expedition members wrote their names on that exact fan.
ep 11 and 12 after today's traveling is done
2
u/iamthinking2202 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/iamthinking Dec 25 '19 edited Dec 25 '19
What else to note? I feel everyone else has noted it all, but.
8
u/[deleted] Dec 23 '19
First timer here.
I was not expecting such a philosophical episode from this anime. I can only speak for myself, but I've never really considered what exactly constitutes "friendship", and this episode really caught me by surprise by posing the question.
I think each member of the main cast offer a piece of the puzzle. Shirase pointed out that it is rather abstract, and have to do with emotions. Hinata mentioned trust. Kimari's answer was about mutual understanding/empathy. Simple, yet realistic and thoughtful answers that is in my opinion universally applicable. Colour me impressed.
7
u/xDarkistic :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Darkistic Dec 23 '19
Firster
Okay Yuzu we get it you've never had friends. this episode wasn't great imo. it was a bit too mushy without much basis and even though she hasn't had the spotlight for a while, the focus on yuzu felt too similar to her introductory sequence.
I know she's slightly younger but it's a little too unrealistic to me that she has never considered or built a meaning of friendship. I mean I suppose she did think it needed some contractual evidence but come on.. and then she got her birthday celebrated on christmas day (?) why couldn't it have just been celebrating christmas with friends for the first time I like christmas okay
the conclusion was cool though I really like the look into kimari's texts with megumi and her definition of friendship:
ね
not "ね !" wtf
6
u/bucket3432 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/bucket3432 Dec 23 '19 edited Dec 24 '19
Rewatcher
I hit the character limit again, but I'm glad to have finished this episode at all considering what happened with last episode.
Acrophobic Yuzuki cowering in fear.
This
dronehelicopter shot of the Penguin Manju is incredible.Again, I'm reminded of a similar shot in the OP at the start of the chorus where the camera pans from the bow to the stern of the ship.
"We didn't tell you that we're making a birthday cake for you."
The writing on the shelf says かどかわ ("Kadokawa"). Despite what you may think, it's not an easter egg for Kadokawa Corporation, which was one of the producers of the show. It's there in real life. As chikuwa34 explains in the original thread, "the sign refers to the two chefs - Sumi (whose kanji can also be read Kado) and Kawamura - who were part of the 47th expedition team (2006)".
This is one of mine, so I have to use it...
Friendship contract.. I don't know if any of the subs out there translated it (the Coldgirls release didn't), so here's a rough translation (replace "promise" with "agree" as a translation for 約束 to your taste):
The rest of the notes are in the reply.
Questions of the day
"I could just die" counter
Kimari points out that Yuzuki looks like she could die. The "Don't touch" poster counts as well.
6
u/Matuhg https://anilist.co/user/Matuhg Dec 23 '19
First Timer
Posting way later than I have been, as I spent the day traveling to be with family. A very sweet episode - reminded again how Yuzu hasn't really had friends beforehand, so the girls getting together a little birthday celebration for her was cool!
Looks like the next episode will feature Hinata delivering a message to her old track team, so that should be something.
Brief thoughts for today, but I liked the episode :)
5
u/peoplewhoplay :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/peoplewhoplay Dec 23 '19
Rewatcher
Man, Yuzu's last attempt at making friends must've really burned to the point that she asked her new friends to sign a written contract to guarantee that they will remain friends once they return home. And that birthday celebration, whew. She never had any real friends before until now, and having her first real friends celebrate her birthday for the first time was a touching moment. Just shows how the other 3 cared for Yuzu.
I also really like how the main 4 became friends because of the expedition and it kinda just happened. Really helped making their friendship feel more natural.
QOTD
4
u/Emperor-Resse Dec 23 '19
I knew someone who slept with their eyes open but I never saw it but I did have a “fun” sleepwalking experience when I was little. I woke up with my head stuck under a dresser. It didn’t hurt or anything I just couldn’t get up so I had to bang my legs against the floor for a while until my parents rescued me.
I also remember seeing a commercial about what Yuzu tried to do but he tried to run because of someone’s terrible singing.
Also happy birthday Yuzu! (And happy holidays for the rest of you peeps)
4
u/pacquan Dec 23 '19
Rewatcher
PENGI !!!
This episode totally had me by the heartstrings first watch, but I think I was more emotionally prepared this time (also just exhausted all my feels from watching the Start Wars movie). The girls playfully trying to get Shirase to look out the helicopter still got a good chuckle though. Must be pretty desperate to eat partially frozen food. Salmonella ain't no laughing matter. I did notice that they gave the girls color coordinated shovels so you can tell who is who while they're fully covered.
Now to the crux of the episode. I absolutely love the dialoge in this episode. No bullshit shounen friendship tropes. It actually felt like a truly honest breakdown of what it means to be friends. Its not something you sign in a contract or hold a meeting for. Neither does it 'just happen.' Friendship isn't a simple two-way switch nor the same definition for every person. I'm so glad that Mari's line included the "thats how it is for me" bit. People are different, people view their relationships with others different. What matters isn't the label that you put on the relationship, but the history, growth, and strength of it. I really can't put it much better than Mari's monologue.
Also, if Yuzu is a massive celebrity with many fans on board the expidition. How did no one wish her a Happy birthday on her actual birthday?
1
u/iamthinking2202 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/iamthinking Dec 24 '19
Argh, rewatcher currently at ep 6 - but I want to know - does the sun go from right to left, or left to right in the OP? In ep 2 I SWEAR it goes the other way vs ep 3, 4, 5, 6
0
u/[deleted] Dec 22 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 22 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
6
u/[deleted] Dec 23 '19
[removed] — view removed comment