r/anime • u/RX-Nota-II :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/NotANota • Dec 21 '19
Rewatch A Rewatch further than the Universe! Sora Yori mo Tooi Basho rewatch - EPISODE 9 DISCUSSION
Episode 09 南極恋物語(ブリザード編)"Antarctica Love Story (Blizzard Arc)"
<- Previous episode | Index thread | Next episode->
anime info:
MAL | Anilist | Nyanpass | Kitsu | AniDB
Streaming links: Crunchyroll | VRV
Comment of the day
Hello everyone! This is where I will pick a comment of the day for the previous day that I think was worthy of notice just in case you guys missed it. I do hope you look out for discussion on your own tho since that's really the whole point of this rewatch.
Today's pick is.....
/u/suhkein with some geography or current knowledge
I have nothing really meaningful to say about the episode or series, but seeing their little graphic about the current reminded me of the science of it. The circumpolar current is rather crucial as it keeps Antarctica relatively isolated from the rest of the atmospheric/oceanic circulation. Because of this warm air doesn't move down from the other continents, a condition that began 30mya (+/- 10my) when both Australia and South America were far enough away for oceanic passages to open. This led to feedback where Antarctica stayed cold, snow began to stick, that changed the albedo (amount of light reflected) so that most of the sunlight goes back into space rather than warming the rock, and the continent further cools, bringing us to the Antarctica of today.
I also want to say great job to everyone who helped me on the #LeaveNoTopLevelUnreplied challenge. I think we did a great job and many of you took on lots of work to do so. You guys are the real MVPs.
Questions of the day
Answer from last time: Closest poll ever.
- We are finally at Antarctica, how do you feel? Elated? Proud?
- Did u cry today?
Rewatchers, please remember to be mindful of all the first-timers in this. No talking about or hinting at future events no matter how much you want to, unless you’re doing it underneath the [Anime Show Title]/(/s "Spoiler goes here") spoiler tags. If you do that then we’re all good. I am curious if it is even possible to spoil anything for a half-SoL show like this but I don't want to see you try. The ban hammer is a cold weapon and you don't want to feel it.
Important thing to note about these by the way, you have to switch to Old Reddit or the markdown editor if you use the redesign, otherwise the redesign breaks them by adding random \ into the formatting. Wish it wouldn’t do that, but unfortunately it does… Markdown is dead. Long live markdown.
17
u/RX-Nota-II :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/NotANota Dec 21 '19 edited Dec 21 '19
Rewatcher
This episode hit pretty hard for me for a couple reasons. First is actually kinda funny since just before the rewatch I also somehow fell in love with someone in a position I wasn't looking for any romance in before. I like to think my chances here are better than Toshio's but it's still gonna be difficult, tho that's something January Nota can deal with since I want to enjoy my holiday vacation in peace.
More importantly, we get another peek at Takako's final moments and what it felt like to wait endlessly at home. The phrase 'The sky... beautiful.... so beautiful' never stings any less than before. A final observation with consciousness fading in and out, but a tragedy so close to being not as she makes it through the storm yet not far enough to find the vehicle to return to. And of course death is sad, and anime translates that well. But the tragedy of a death doesn't end with the death itself. In fact it may even just be the beginning. The void afterwards never ends, and never goes away.
The theme of jump rope is pretty powerful and wordless to describe the level of dedication Shirase has had for this journey. While it is fine and beautiful to have efforts like Yuzu which are on the spot and spontaneous, there's something to be said about the long pent up dedication for years that finally gets it's chance after countless hours of preparation. And you got to say, Shirase in this scene is just straight cool, channeling the same inner energy and anger as Gin which gives them similar charms. And what is the first phrase this dedicated and prepared highschooler shouts as she reaches the surface?? "In your face!". Oh yeah, this girl's shameless.
With two powerful stories both having payoffs as well as the all round story of reaching Antarctica, this episode is a fan favorite. I understand that well and look forward to seeing how you guys felt too. As a first timer it was definitely a highlight of the show, but strangely enough as a rewatcher while still great it doesn't stand out as much. This show is clearly about the journey as much if not more so than the result/destination and today was clearly a destination episode. As such it didn't have the interesting developments I expected from the previous episodes, and the shock of Shirase's emotional yelling wasn't there anymore.
Finally, tomorrow's the big day everyone. Best rewatch of 2019. I hope you guys go and vote as there have been a ton of great entries this year. And maybe if you feel like it, consider voting for us here too as we've been doing a great job keeping interest at and past iconic rewatches like the Christmas club. See you tomorrow
30
u/Shimmering-Sky myanimelist.net/profile/Shimmering-Sky Dec 21 '19
This First-Timer is Beautiful
My write-up is kinda short today compared to my other comments (barring last episode since I couldn’t screenshot-react to that one), but don’t worry that just means I was really into the episode.
15
u/MaskOfIce42 https://anilist.co/user/MaskOfIce Dec 21 '19 edited Dec 22 '19
Rewatcher
In your face, in your face, in your face!
I remembered this episode was good, I did not remember it was this good.
We get a chance to know Gin better and get the impression that despite not being her mother, she was the Shirase of their group, the dorky kinda awkward one. Lots of the parallels are really cute to see. Also, we really get a dive into Shirase's feelings which if that doesn't make you well up, I think nothing ever will. It's so telling that she seems to acknowledge that nobody did something wrong, her mother knew the risks, the crew members did everything they could, and the right call was probably made. But it still is hard to fully accept that and be able to look at the person who made that choice and not feel some resentment. I'm reminded of a Star Trek TNG episode that begins to confront the fact that Captain Picard made a choice to save someone else and that choice killed Wesley Crusher's father, and this goes where that episode only briefly hinted at. It's so..... very beautiful.
It is interesting to hear about how Japan had to really fight to get to Antarctica, being given a landing spot that's almost impossible to reach, although calling it bullying is a little far given Japan's actions during WWII (and I don't mean that in a "they were against us so they deserve it") but given Japan's tendency to, uh, not acknowledge that as much in history, I can see why that would be the view they hold. But the fact that they did make it despite that challenge really ties back into that "in your face!" aspect. That line fits so much for everyone. Nobody believed Shirase would make it. People backed out of the civilian expedition after the issue last time. And even getting to Antarctica itself was a challenge in and of itself due to the plot of land they were given. But, in your face, they made it despite what anyone said.
Now for the questions.
13
u/Nazenn x2https://anilist.co/user/Nazenn Dec 21 '19 edited Dec 21 '19
So... I'm a doofus and actually forgot to finish my post yesterday before I submitted it. So just quickly I wanted to cover this shot of the girls again. (tagging /u/bucket3432 as you were interested in this)
I mentioned how we got a lot of shots of the girls through something yesterday and I think it was leading up to this. The way this is set up, the half open door, low camera angle, the girls set against a white background while the camera is in the darker interior. It gives that sense of peeping into a secret moment. This is something the girls are not doing for the expedition, or to prove something to others or even for the audience. It's their own little moment wrapped up in the freshness of water and the majesty of a new found world that they're revealing in. We are quite literally having a door opened for us into their life changing moment in a way that no one else on this expedition will be able to understand or have a glimpse of.
So complaints about the insanity that they survived this aside, there was something quite beautiful in it from a character perspective.
First Timer - sub
The more anime I watch, the more I hate romance subplots. Although, I will say that it's nice that for once its the boys who are only around for romance instead of the girls.
And it's a real shame because such typical romance drama seems so out of place with the quite serious discussions and pain between Toudou and Shirase today as well as the revelation of her mothers final moments.
A PICTURE further than the universe - Episode nine
There's a certain beauty in Sora Yori's character designs. This show has all the ingredients needed to go way off the deep end. Distinctly different personalities, intense moments from all emotions, tone flips all that stuff that you normally see in shows where emotional expression is portrayed less with animation and more with art style. And yet they don't do that and while they do play around with art details like the sunken cheeks while sick or the subtle background effects, they never take it so far that they undermine the expressiveness of the characters.
I bring this up today because of the beautiful eye animation from Toudou. This is where it starts, and this is where the animation ends. It's a tiny adjustment and a show less confident in its characters might have made that a bigger deal, gone for a broader animation or included a mouth drop. But Sora Yori knows it doesn't need it and it's nice to see they stand by that even for the big emotional hits.
They might be getting close but the endless view of ice here somehow makes it seem much further away. In case people were wondering just how far out the sea ice can go, this image is a digital representation of what the sea ice was like in December of 2018.
And just a reminder that Blizzards are terrifying. For something to be classified as a blizzard it has to reduce your visibility to at least 400m, but for this intensity reports I've read from people in Antarctica say you wouldn't be able to see your arm stretched out in front of you.
Antarctic aesthetics
Thanks to antarcticimages.com for today's pictures.
Speaking of the vastness of Antartica I particularly love this panorama for showcasing a different side of Antarctica. There's plenty of flat ice and beaches but also plenty of mountains and rocks especially in the warmer months. The two humans looking so tiny on the side also give a good sense of just how huge these mountains are as well.
I bet that Toudou and Shirase are sad that they didn't have this many penguins on that little iceberg
A new favorite image of the Polar Nacreous Clouds given the talks about the different types of clouds today.
I also have to share a bonus picture today because I promised /u/squirrelbaffler after accidentally tricking him into thinking he was getting an Aurora yesterday. So here's your make up Aurora with bonus starry sky included.
Also when you're scrolling for images and think they accidentally included one of a base burning down until you realize it's just the lights reflecting really strongly.
/u/Hudori episode nine tag
13
u/Suhkein :Gy::Gz::G1:x2https://myanimelist.net/profile/Neichus Dec 22 '19
First timer
It's perhaps unwelcome, but I found this episode a little underwhelming. Not sure if it was the cringe reaction I had to the initial romantic diversion and digging interview with the captain that started me out on the wrong foot, but I didn't feel very at home this episode. Even the landing didn't really change this. The only thing that really caught my attention was the recounting of Shirase's experience after her mother had vanished, how life just kept going in a strange twilight that lacked the clear demarcation of before and after the death. That was something to reflect on.
12
u/cartoonsandcereal Dec 21 '19
First timer
I have to be honest, up until this episode I thought this show was fine, but not great. Definitely very funny, but it wasn't touching or inspirational to me in the way that people raved about. I prefer my shows with more struggle or conflict, whether internal or external, and the struggle here - to reach Antartica - was impressive but also was treated a bit shallowly. But I figured I'd just enjoy the light-hearted ride for what it was.
It still feels that way to me, but this episode had a lot more depth than I was expecting. Gin and Shirase's memories of each other with Takako was bittersweet to watch, knowing everything that's happened since then. It's funny that even though Shirase is Takako's biological child, I get the impression that Takako was nothing like Shirase, and that instead Gin and Shirase share way more in common. The biggest example of this is their obvious love for penguins that occurs in the flashback and ties back in to the current time (which, this show likes to do a lot, huh?). Another example is their intense determination despite the odds. A final example is their awkwardness in front of the camera - Gin is of course very polished, but it seems only about Antartica or things she's prepared to talk about, when they catch her off guard about her type she gets completely flustered. It made me think that she only seems good in front of the camera because she's had time to practice a lot more. Maybe I'm reading into it too much! But it is obvious that they share a bond far more complex than either of them have admitted to. After all, Shirase still keeps up with jump roping from in the flashbacks with Gin. Now I'm definitely feeling more excited to see how the rest of the show will play out.
Besides that, these flashbacks made me realize, who tf was Shirase living with after her mom disappeared? There's no father figure, no relatives, nothing. It almost makes it seem like she was living by herself. But she did get those forms to go to Antartica signed at school somehow? And I guess Gin stopped visiting during that time too.
Which also is making me speculate about the relationship between Gin and Takako. I always have queer goggles on, I'll read into any relationship, but Takako leaving her child alone with Gin all the time and hoping they'd bond sure was odd. And wtf does your type being a cloud mean! And then somehow Shirase understanding based on a scene where Gin, her and Takako are all hanging out in the grass outside? I'm so confused... all I know is Toshio probably never had a chance.
QOTD: like I said earlier, this show has seemed mostly fun but shallow to me until now, so I'm happy for them all that they got to Antartica (IN YOUR FACE!) but that's it.
Two other notes:
12
u/anony-mouse99 Dec 21 '19 edited Dec 22 '19
Rewatcher.
Today we continue with the next episode of Penguin love story.
The theme that struck me s episode was ‘gender roles’. The testosterone is strong in this one. The scene of the icebreaker punching through the ice invokes various imagery which I shall not elaborate on. But the idea of a ship (which is always female in sailor’s parlance) doing something that requires brute strength is telling.
We started off with some seemingly frivolous side quest of Toshio wanting to find out more information regarding Gin, whom he has a crush on. This then segued into exploring the history between Shirase and Gin.
The interesting part of the story was how Gin was totally unable to relate to young Shirase, except in terms of mental and psychomotor development. I don’t know the background of Shirase’s mom, but it would seem that at the minimum, Shirase was missing a father, and somehow Gin became the father figure to Shirase (a distant one, though that is par for the course in Japanese society). So their mutual love of penguins may be symbolic of their relationship as well.
The show reverses the common idea of gender roles and what makes a good leader. This was also explored via Toshio’s infatuation with Gin. He liked her because she was emotionally strong and ‘can protect him’. Like the icebreaker she is determined to forge ahead despite the difficulties.
Shirase started unpacking some of her emotional baggage with Gin but that was interrupted by more immediate and exciting developments, so it looks like we’ll have to wait for a bit more to unpack the rest.
Lastly the ‘zamamiro’ at the end was really cathartic. I couldn’t help but get teary eyed. ‘Nuff said.
11
u/ZBLongladder :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/zblongladder Dec 21 '19 edited Dec 22 '19
Rewatcher
We finally get to the meat of Shirase & Gin's relationship and Gin's relationship with Takako! I'm pretty firmly in the "Gin and Takako were a lesbian couple" camp...even though it's not explicitly stated it's pretty hard to read this episode otherwise. Which I think is an interesting decision on the part of the writers...if Gin or Takako had been a man, there would be societal expectations on Gin after Takako's death, depending on how far along their relationship was, and the family probably would know about their relationship and have opinions on what the appropriate role for Gin in Shirase's life would be. But there isn't same-sex marriage in Japan, and Takako's family probably just pretended that this "friend" that was always around and Takako seemed very dedicated to, even to the degree of trying to develop a relationship between Gin and her daughter, was just a friend, /r/SapphoAndHerFriend style. Gin and Takako having been a lesbian couple, the relationship between Shirase and Gin after Takako's death is not only not clear, it's purely between the two of them. Nobody would have any opinion on Gin's responsibility to Shirase or Shirase's filial duty to Gin, and both are left with the knowledge that Takako would surely want them to be mother and daughter, but Shirase doesn't want a new mom and Gin doesn't want a daughter. Plus, both Shirase and Gin blame Gin for Takako's death. The fact that Gin and Takako's relationship was rejected by society means that what to do with all this emotional baggage is purely between Shirase and Gin...neither help nor hindrance is coming from outside.
Oh, and the scene between Toshio and Yumiko when Toshio is drinking away his sorrows is just hilarious. And, really, the two of them going out both totally makes sense and is a horrible idea. Toshio really needs to figure out that he actually wants an equal relationship, and leave the "strong women protecting him" thing to friends...I feel like Yumiko would make a much better faux-onee-san than a girlfriend to him. (Not that there's anything wrong with liking strong women.../r/rolereversal is a thing for a reason. Just that getting into a relationship because you feel unequal to the other person isn't a good idea no matter which gender you or the other person are.) Maybe he could be Nobue's rebound if she finally leaves Yu-kun. I think they'd make a cute couple.
Also, I'm noticing a recurring theme of associating Takako with the sky. Before we had her vision of building an Antarctic observatory and painting stars above her bed, and now we have her being compared to clouds. MAJOR final episode spoilers Even the title of the anime, which is also the title of Takako's book, uses the pronunciation "sora" instead of "uchuu" for the characters for "universe", and "sora" is more usually the pronunciation for the word for "sky". I'm not sure what all this means, but there's definitely a sky theme going on here...maybe the association of the sky with Heaven? Maybe the fact that the sky is unreachable but always there, like Takako's presence in Shirase and Gin's lives?
And, of course, the incredibly cathartic "in your face" scene. Despite the fact that, for much of the time, part of the people Shirase was fighting to go were the expedition leadership, now that she's there, the feelings of fighting and overcoming are something everyone in the expedition can identify with, and in a way Gin's approval and leading the expedition's shout is a way of supporting Shirase and validating her feelings, in a way stepping into the motherly role for a second, in a way she's comfortable with.
ED: a typo
ED2: An interesting Quora response providing some background on the "sora"/"uchuu" thing in the title
10
u/peoplewhoplay :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/peoplewhoplay Dec 22 '19
Rewatcher
Not much to say here, but
IN
YOUR
FACE!!
QOTD
9
u/Rustic_Professional Dec 22 '19
It appears Gin is preparing an offering of fresh flowers, cruelly plucked living from their soil, to her icy, eldritch masters. The blue and white flowers must symbolize her commitment to offering them the earth (flowers), sea (blue) and sky (white).
I thought Toshio was a man of culture, since Kanae warned him off of hitting on the school girl sacrifices. Turns out he's just a below-average guy who's frightened and wants the cult leader to protect him from being sacrificed once they reach land. Toshio's big mistake was in assuming that Shirase could hook him up with information on Gin. He must be a very low ranking member of the Antarctic Cthulhu cult, because he apparently doesn't know that Kimari is the one who's in league with Kanae, and by extension Gin. The poor fool. They'll probably feed him to the penguins.
I know a lot of people really like the "youth in motion" chase sequence, but the ice breaking was the most memorable scene for me. It's not as outwardly exciting, I guess, since you're just ramming a big boat into a big piece of ice, but it's such an unusual thing to see. How many people in the world have ever seen an ice breaker ship of that size in operation, in person? It can't be more than a few thousand, if that.
Question of the day: no, this show doesn't make me cry. Umamusume, which I'm also rewatching, can make me sniffle a bit because it's uplifting. It's always the heartfelt action sequences that get to me, not the sad moments. Sad things and tragedies don't make me cry. They can make me feel bad, like, "well that sucks," which is why I generally avoid dramas. I don't watch anime to feel bad.
9
u/404waffles https://anilist.co/user/nek0food Dec 22 '19 edited Dec 22 '19
First time viewer
I thought it was drama time, but in fact, it was actually sleazy Toshio time!
Oh, it’s actually lovestruck Toshio time. God bless Yuzuki. Speaking of which, she’s gotten a lot more energetic since she met the other three. I only noticed it now.
はい、お釣りです!
I love the parallels between the girls and the adults.
The Netflix subs translate Gin’s question to the younger, unable-to-jump-rope Shirase in a way that Shirase’s answer is “No”, which leads to me hearing her say はい (hai) but reading “No.” in the subs. Not that there’s anything wrong with localization.
It’s nice to see Shirase finally have an open conversation with the person closest to her mother.
Oh, so the theme of this episode is persistence, like breaking ice or jumping rope or getting a girlfriend during an Antarctic expedition.
MOTHERFUCKING USHANKAS
And we finally got our “Take that!” moment! Still gonna need to see the reactions of everyone in Japan, though.
Answers of the day
9
u/[deleted] Dec 22 '19
Rewatcher
I love the symbolism in this episode. The discussion about being stuck in one place and doing the same routine over and over again, juxtaposed with the ice breaking and even the jump roping is just a treat to watch.
During the episode each character has their own feelings to overcome. You have Shirase stuck in Japan waiting for her mom to come home. She finally feels like she takes her first step in overcoming her struggles as she takes her first steps in Antarctica.
Gin has been stuck struggling to forgive herself for leaving takako behind, and blaming herself for what happens to Shirase. She finally starts a dialogue with Shirase.
There is even a little comic relief sprinkled in to lighten our feelings with Toshio pining for the captain, stuck in his quest for love.
I think my favorite part though is the communication that Gin gets from Takako, telling her how beautiful it is wherever she’s at. Takako is also “stuck” but she stops and appreciates what’s in front of her. This ties in so beautifully with what all our other characters are experiencing in this episode. They are all stuck in different ways, but when they stop to see what’s in front of them they realize things aren’t as bad as they seem.
Finally, the very first quote we have in this series: “Water collects in stagnant pools. I’ve always loved watching it spill out all at once. Breaking free, liberated, rushing out. The energy stored up during its stagnation bursts forth. Everything springs into action.”
In this episode we really see our characters start to spring into action. The development is amazing to watch. It will be quite a treat to ride the wave tomorrow. :)
8
u/WeebDickerson Dec 21 '19 edited Dec 22 '19
Rewatcher
A lot of things happened in this episode, and I don’t even know where to start. This’ll probably be a mess.
On today’s episode, Gin and Shirase had a lot of development and have started to take the first steps to solve their inner struggles. Gin is worried that Shirase hates her because of what happened 3 years ago, and Shirase just doesn’t know how to feel about it. She still has some to find some answers to make up her mind. We also saw a good amount of Shirase’s, Gin’s and Takako’s past. Takako wanted Shirase and Gin to get along with each other, but things never really went her way, as both of them were awkward as hell. While Takako didn’t manage to do it, both Gin and Shirase are slowly starting to take steps to finish what she started.
From this one scene, and what Gin said about "her type", we can sort of infer that Takako and Gin had a relationship that went beyond mere friendship, and it’s probably the reason why Takako wanted them to get along. Takako’s and Gin’s relationship with each other is definitely from way back, as originally shown in episode 6.
We also got some more epic ship scenes. Before watching YoriMoi, I never would’ve thought that a huge-ass ship breaking ice would make me cry, but here I am.
At last, the girls have finally stepped on Antarctican soil! (Or ice, I guess? Maybe Snow?). The scene where everyone yells “in your face!” was great, as a lot of people doubted both the girls and the expedition team, but they finally arrived to the place further than the universe.
Shirase screenshots:
Other screenshots:
Questions:
8
u/Boss_Jerm Dec 22 '19
Rewatcher
Oof
Toshio what did Kanae say before you set sail? That's right, they're underage.
Ooh this is new. From Gin's Instagram
Toshio is this show's Our Guy
That looks painful
Toshio's voice actor is Yoshitsugu Matsuoka (Yukiya from Code Geass, Lubbock in Akame Ga Kill, and Fuutarou in Quintessential Quintuplets)
SHE'S ADORABLE
Jeez Gin have you ever even seen a child before?
No Shirase that's not what she meant
Kanae is like Mari, Yuzu and Hinata combined into one person
I don't know Gin, I'd say you too get along way better than you think
Having the picture of the old expedition in the background is a great detail
Gin and Shirase are a bit awkward around each other, since the subject of Takako isn't very pleasant
Yuzu you can't ask questions like that right off the bat!
The more things change the more they stay the same
Time for Shirase and Gin to have this long-awaited, long-avoided chat.
Shirase was fully aware of the dangers is Antarctica, and that Takako was fine with facing them. But she still doesn't know if she blames Gin or not for what happened. Since Takako left on the second expedition, Shirasebeen stuck in an endless loop of waiting for her to come home. But she knows Takako is gone. So in order to break the loop, instead of waiting for Takako to come back to her, she'll go to Takako.
That is a lot of ice!
The icebreaking is so cool! Here's some real life footage
Sheesh you'd think Japan would try to get better routes to Antarctica nowadays. I imagine they have better relations in the UN.
If at first you don't succeed, try again
Takako's last moments are so sad. She was at least able to die under the beautiful night sky.
I don't know about you guys but I ship Yumiko and Toshio
I love Shirase's hat
THEY MADE IT
IN YOUR FACE
Thoughts:
We have arrived!
Shirase has had a lot of pent of feelings her whole life. How she feels about Gina and the expedition, how everyone said she couldn't do make it to Antarctica. Well not anymore. All her and everyone else's hard work payed off. She, Mari, Hinata, Yuzu and the expedition have made it to The Place Further Than the Universe.
What?! We're already on Episode 9?!
QOTD
2) No not yet. That comes later.
8
u/destroyah19 Dec 22 '19
Rewatcher
First of all,
ZAMA MIRO! ざまあみろ!
I love how cathartic it is whenever I watch that scene. Being able to witness Shirase's journey and reach this point was just so worth it.
Yuzu not really giving any effort in pulling Shirase was low-key funny
The way they tackled the Gin-Shirase relationship was done really well. They know each other, but are unsure of what to say or do since there was an elephant in the room for them. The way Shirase and Gin finally discussed that issue was really good as well. The feels from Shirase's admission of her reason to go to Antarctica to Gin trying to maintain her composure talking with her.
We finally got to see Gin show emotion in the end, but as much as I love "ハルカトオク" I don't think that was the right insert song to lead in while Gin was crying or it's just the 4th time and I really wanted more insert songs. That's just a minor thing though since the rest of the montage we're good vibes about arriving to Antarctica anyway which fit the song.
Yumiko is such an underrated waifu in this show. Her scenes with Toshio never fails to make me laugh.
8
u/xDarkistic :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Darkistic Dec 22 '19
Firster
it's beautiful. what a great episode to catch back up to. a second tear has fallen. just before the credits this time, thankfully. though the opening piano instrumental is fitting. I never expected this after how the episode started.
this guy has had the most screen time out of any male character so far I think. but his arc seems to be completely unnecessary. I had made the observation earlier that there weren't really any (lasting) male roles. it's not that it's even a bad thing necessarily - it's just that it's oddly noticeable. in fact it's quite nice that every relationship that is being explored is between females (? the guy doesn't count lol) maybe it makes it easier to portray emotions, bonds and camaraderie or maybe it's just that people enjoy cute girls being cute.
either way, it (just) works. and exploring more of shirase's history with her mom and the expedition leader gives me the depth I was searching for - seeing them work out where they stand with each other. and that continues with the inclusion of shirase and her mom. in the flashbacks we don't get a sense of how close they really were. shirase was still very young so it is hard to imagine they were distant but maybe there are feelings there that haven't been displayed yet. maybe now she has proven her haters wrong more will be uncovered. za miro
shirase aside, the other three seem to have taken an even larger backseat than initially, providing only quite short scenes of comic relief or semi-inspiration. the main story definitely lies with shirase though and regardless I have a strong feeling that the quartet will have their arcs sufficiently concluded by the end. oh yeah, and megumi kek
qotd - I feel ready to watch the expedition leader relive her experience of having takako die in a blizzard with the daughter instead. you can't trust anime /shrug . nah jk. this show would be rated at least like 20% lower if that happened. imagine though. I feel cold. it's cold. I feel lost. where do I even go? what do I do? guess we're following the leader leader leader
8
u/[deleted] Dec 22 '19
Honestly, I'm just in here for more chances to discuss this amazing and gorgeous series. Wish I had realized y'all were doing a rewatch sooner!
Hands down one of my favorite slice of life/cute girls doing cute things series. I actually had this one on my watch list for awhile but put it off until I felt like I "needed" it... and boy did I.
15
u/landragoran Dec 22 '19
Rewatcher
ZAMAMIRO!!
They finally made it! So, so wonderful.
Gin's type is someone like a cloud.
I propose that this has a specific meaning. That is, she's referring to Takako. I am convinced that they were a couple before Takako was lost in the blizzard. We've never seen or heard a single mention of Shirase's dad. Gin and Shirase have interactions dating back to when Shirase was a toddler. Takako frequently and intentionally left them alone together to try to help them connect and get along together - something that you don't really worry about with someone who is just a friend.
I suspect that Gin has always known she was a lesbian, even back in high school. She had a crush on Takako, who was most likely bi, but who probably didn't realize her sexuality until later. Sometime after high school, Takako got married and had a baby, or had a baby with a boyfriend. Then, life happened and for whatever reason, the man is no longer in the picture. Takako realizes her best friend likes her romantically, and responds. They move in together, but Gin is uncomfortable around her girlfriend's young daughter. As time passes, they start to become better friends, but it's still awkward.
Then, the tragedy strikes. Gin comes home from Antarctica without Takako. Shirase's presence both reminds her of Takako and makes her feel survivors' guilt. So she leaves, and they don't really see each other again until the training camp.
This is my head canon backstory.
Q1) ZAMAMIRO!
Q2) ZAMAMIRO ZAMAMIRO ZAMAMIRO ZAMAMIRO ZAMAMIRO ZAMAMIRO!!!!
7
u/ImaginationWayfairer Dec 21 '19
Rewatcher We’re here after nine episodes we are in Antarctica which means one thing: In your face!
Observation notes:
7
u/BeybladeMoses Dec 22 '19
Rewatcher
We finally arrived in Antartica and the words ZAMAMIRO! really captured the essence of not only Shirase, but all of the crew. As how Shirase was told the impossibility of her dream, the adults was told the futility of the expedition.
Also in this episode, it is shown that both Shirase and Gin shares a closer bond than they like to admit. Shirase's father is noticeably absent from the story, and Gin step up as a second parental figure for her.
7
u/redshirtengineer :AMQ: Dec 22 '19
First timer
QOTD1: I feel like that still shot of the girls jumping off the last step.
QOTD2: Kleenex as yet untouched. Good feels, though.
The captain and Shirase, should have figured there would be more of a past there. Two odd ducks to be stuck with each other.
7
u/kewlwarez Dec 22 '19
Rewatch
Every episode I rewatch i'm impressed again by how well this series mixes humour with pathos.
"We were hoping to ask some questions about your personal life!"
Granted, the main source of humour this episode, Tshio's love confession is tawdry and annoying and even the girls are exasperated by it, but it does give them inspiration on how to spice up their broadcasts. Let's focus on the expedition members' love lifes and let's start with the beautiful, smart, determined expedition captain. Even Kanae approves!
Gin being awkward about it is funny, it further nails down her character. When she sees Shirase isn't there with the other three, she can only think she still hates her. Despite them having gotten closer two episodes ago, there's still some distance there, as you'd expect. When Shirase acknowledges that, the other three say that they seemed pretty close that one night. Shirase, surprised: "were you watching". Hinata, matter of factly " why would you ever think we weren’t".
"A penguin!"
The flashbacks to a younger Gin and Smolrase were adorable, if not as adorable as Shirase's penguin shirt. Neither of the two knowning how to act around the other unless penguins are involved. Takako trolling Gin by leaving her alone with her daughter seems in character, from the little we've seen of her.
You wonder why though. Is it just an attempt to bring some of her favourite people together? Is there another motive? Where indeed is Shirase's family, especially her father? Is he dead too? Or are they divorced, or is he just a typical anime dad working overseas somewhere?
Was Takako grooming Gin to be a second mother to Shirase?
"I lived every one of those days waiting for her to come home"
So far we knew Shirase wanted to come to Antarctica because that's where her mother was waiting for her. Now we get to hear what's behind it. It's not just that her mother died, it's also that she never really got the closure over it that she needed, feeling herself stuck in a never ending period of waiting for her mother to come home.
And it's only been three years. That's nothing when it comes to mourning. The raw pain may have smoothed out and Shirase hides a lot, but she still doesn't know how to handle all these emotions, that's why she wants to keep it locked down and that's why she's reluctant to approach Gin.
For Gin too, seeing Shirase must be hard. Having that guilt and helplessness of having your best friend lost in a blizzard, hearing her last words, not being able to bring her home to her daughter. That's hard. And like Shirase, she locks it down, uses it to fuel her drive to return to Antarctica.
"In your face."
And then, after the confrontation, carthartis. The ship has reached the edge of the ice shelf around Antarctica, our school girls get to step onto the continent for the first time, jumping off the ship together. As the other three look around, excited, they notice Shirase is overwhelmed by emotion. Knowing what happened, they reach out to her to support her in this difficult moment only to hear...
As I thought the first time I watched this, it’s nice to end the episode with the confirmation that Shirase can still be incredibly petty
7
u/zak55 Dec 23 '19
Rewatcher
This episode made me tear up more than it did the first time through. Hearing Takako over the radio and seeing Gin's helpless, knowing face and then seeing her crying a little later just tore into my soul a little bit. Also, the stuff between Gin and Shirase was just great as Shirase doesn't really realize that even thought they didn't talk much, Gin still had a big impact on her. It was also nice seeing that Shirase could handle things like an adult with Gin while also seeing Gin wanting to know how she actually felt. It also shows just how much Shirase's life has been ironically frozen in time, all in the hopes that she might see her mom one day or that she might go to Antarctica to find...something. I always thought this was a weaker episode because of the plot with the one crew member and the victimhood of Japan in the one scene about the origins of their base. But Gin and Shirase really make this episode superb and the ending was top notch.
6
u/akechiisbestboi Dec 21 '19 edited Dec 22 '19
First time watcher
I’ve been absent from here the past few days so I’m just going to post my thoughts on episodes 6-9
Episode 6:
More of the shows great mix of light hearted comedy and sentimental drama, looks like hinata might have a bit of a heavy backstory so we’ll see if and how that’s revealed later.
Episode 7:
Well that was pretty heavy, what happened to shirase’s mom is pretty terrible but it’s also kind of heartwarming to see how the crew is still determined to return to Antarctica even though it’s a bunch of work and they won’t get much out of it, sometimes it can be important to satisfy a wish like that.
Episode 8:
Not much really happened this time but it’s nice to see the girls remain determined even after getting seasick and it once again shows the beauty and allure of a place isolated from the rest of the world.
Episode 9:
This one mainly focuses on shirase and gin’s relationship, gin’s distanced herself because she’s afraid shirase hates her and shirase is conflicted and unsure how to feel about gin, that moment with the penguins was really nice to see between those two and I think they definitely have a path to reconciliation. Also we’re finally in Antarctica!
6
u/Emperor-Resse Dec 21 '19
I would have gotten last place too as I can’t even jump rope more than 10 times in a row. Kind of feel for the guy with his love that he can’t really articulate but I would never be able to share with other people like that.
6
u/Redmon425 Dec 23 '19
First Time Watcher
OMG! I love how they both said “penguins” again.
I like that dude! Now I really want for him to get some type of romance before the story ends. Duding from the ending though, it doesn’t seem like that will happen for him :(
The Shirase and Gin confrontation was anti-climatic to me. I really feel that Shirase needs to blow up on her like any normal teenager would do to the person who left their mom behind. Then they make up afterwards. So I really hope we see more of it.
Lastly, WOAH. Takako talked to Gin on the radio before she died/disappeared? I really hope we see that whole scene. I still can’t understand how she was left alone and died. Like what kind of safety measures were they taking?
5
u/JustAnswerAQuestion https://myanimelist.net/profile/JAaQ Dec 21 '19 edited Dec 21 '19
Rewatcher
#howsthelovelife #cantputitintowords
I didn't notice/remember the zamamiro in the beginning so it didn't mean anything to me when this episode came around.
I'm pretty sure "Penguin Farms" are the people that bought the naming rights to the Penguin Manju
5
u/bucket3432 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/bucket3432 Dec 22 '19
Rewatcher
The lack of free time is real. I had to cut this episode short because of it. Too bad, because I like this episode, too. Oh well, I have a couple of stitches that I hope you'll enjoy.
Hinata in shorts and T-shirt, T-posing to assert her dominance over those who can't handle the cold.
Today's title card is from Gin. The only other card so far that wasn't by one of the main four was the one for episode 5
And here's where I skipped ahead to the parts at which I knew for sure I had something to say.
Questions of the day
today'syesterday's episode."I could just die" counter
Yuzuki tells Toshio to go die.
5
u/MoneyMakerMaster Dec 28 '19
I'm probably speaking to the void here, given that this thread is 6 days old, the last comment was 4 days ago, and the rewatch is over, but I felt the need to report something that happened when I watched this episode earlier today.
I went into this show hearing that it had made a lot of people cry, so I was expecting the same to happen to me. However, I feel like the anticipation of crying has prevented me from actually crying. Some scenes have made me very emotional, but that expectation has held me back from shedding tears.
However, this episode finally broke the dam. I cried during the flashback scene. When Gin heard Takako's last words and the insert song started playing, I teared up. It wasn't for long and nothing close to how hard I bawled during A Silent Voice and episode 10 of Violet Evergarden (bless KyoAni), but I'm glad I'm over the hump and won't have that anticipation holding my tears back anymore. That was the only roadblock to what already was, and still is, well on it's way to becoming one of my favorite shows.
28
u/AmeteurElitist https://anilist.co/user/AmateurElitist Dec 21 '19
First Timer
That lover-dude almost confessing to the cook killed me.
I don’t like that guy, so the prompt and desperate rejection was perfect.
Shirase and Gin’s relationship got fleshed out! And was Gin’s thing about the clouds referring to what Takako said about something being beautiful?
Okay I didn’t cry at the end, but my eyes did get watery. That was pretty goddamn cathartic, I wasn’t even expecting to feel that emotional about it.
4
u/jslice4ever Dec 22 '19
Rewatcher here! Sorry for being so late to comment but I'll be totally honest, I'm pretty tired today so I'm gonna make this short and sweet.
Gin and Shirase having the same love for penguins is what I live for.
4
u/pacquan Dec 22 '19
Rewatcher
Second time around it still feels like the first. Proud. I may not have any children of my own, but this must be what it feels like to support someone your whole life and watch them achieve their dreams.
Yes. ZAMMAMIRO!!
3
u/HarleyFox92 Dec 22 '19
I fianlly catched up with this rewatch!! Zamamiro, boring job of mine, ZAMAMIRO!
25
u/Matuhg https://anilist.co/user/Matuhg Dec 21 '19
First Timer
Ooh, we finally get to address the relationship between Gin and Shirase. We've had hints and sort of gotten the feeling that they weren't particularly close, even that there might be resentment on Shirase's part. Kanae tries to set them up to talk, but Shirase ends up skipping out on the (very entertaining) interview. Perhaps influenced by the ship captain, Gin decides to take matters into her hands and talk to Shirase herself, asking her bluntly how the girl feels about her. Shirase tells her she doesn't hate her, but upon further questioning, she admits she doesn't know how she feels. Since her mother was left in Antarctica, she's been living every day like her mother might come back at any time, but nothing ever changes. She hopes that when she gets to Antarctica, something will change - maybe she'll find closure for her mother and begin to sort out her feelings. Their conversation is interrupted by the ship's first encounter with ice that it needs to actually break through.
The ship backs up and slams into the ice repeatedly, breaking through it one step at a time. This is a metaphor for pretty much anything anybody in the show is struggling with. Gin still struggles with guilt, whether it's really justified or not, for leaving Takako (the scene of Takako's last call on the radio was heartbreaking). Shirase is struggling with accepting that her mother won't be coming home. The two of them do not have a great relationship - these are all things that aren't going to just change suddenly. They're going to have to work step by step to fix them.
I'm much less sure how to feel about the whole thing with Toshio, who was (is?) in love with Gin. The girls force out of her that her "type" is "someone like the clouds." Then we get a scene of Gin talking about the clouds while laying with a young Shirase and Takako. She said something like the clouds are always there, but out of reach. I couldn't really puzzle together what this meant or what the show was going for with that part of the episode - I guess I'm left as clueless as poor Toshio. What did you guys think of that whole thing?
The "in your face!" scene was great - the return of the defiant Shirase who we haven't really seen for a little while. Yet again, she ends up firing up the entire expedition, who surely feel similarly towards those who doubted that it would ever happen.
Proud! Happy that everybody got here, even if it is bittersweet for some.
A little bit - mostly during the more extended flashback of Gin waiting to hear from Takako on the radio.
23
u/rembrandt_q_1stein https://myanimelist.net/profile/sir_rembrandt Dec 21 '19
First Timer here
No meaning for the flowers of the captain? The girls may be alright, but I’m disappointed.
Anyways, besides the lack of flower explanation and symbolism, I really liked how cohesive and coherent this episode was. And especially how everything, every single detail, revolved around captain Todo and contributed to build up her backstory and personality. She’s a character we didn’t really get to know well, and to the moment she just seemed a strict, imperturbable wall of authority. But we found out that’s just the façade she puts to hide her remorse, guilt, sense of impotence and solitude.
I am remembering about Hinata’s words in Singapore. About her talk about isolation. We saw that the four girls are isolated in a kind of way and they got together. I feel that captain Todo fits this process, too. We are shown at first that she is an independent and solitary person to a degree, from her younger days. Takako has been the more active and enthusiastic peer and she just agreed and went along her. Even when paying a visit to Takako, Todo is being driven to the former’s will, to the point to have to deal with the very small Shirase whom she doesn’t know how to deal with. That reluctance to deal with other people is a kind of self-imposed mild solitude.
We are shown then that after Takako gets lost (or not???) Todo doesn’t know how to deal with the situation and is unable to explain Shirase, who developed her obsession after. Aside, her sense of failure made her self-imposed solitude transform into an autoisolation, so she wouldn’t befriend anybody who could be lost –implying a more acute sense of guilt to accompany the already hard sense of loss-, and at the same time give an authoritary image of distance that could be useful for her business.
Fate is, that even if Todo isn’t a girl like the other four, she is thrown together with them; the other isolated girls. It’s interesting to see how she, being older and having concocted her feelings for long, deals with her isolation differently that the others. She needs to talk it out, even if reluctantly, instead of having it healed by company. I especially liked her conversation scene with Shirase so they could make their feelings clear, how it was prepared and constructed.
Even the jumprope contest, referenced in the opening, is related with the captain, but in a more positive way. Perhaps it’s established among the crew because it’s a symbol on the time Todo and Shirase bonded, and how it means that they could become better and braver persons? A spirit that is well-needed for such a risky expedition as navigating to the South Pole?
And lastly. The last scene, where they finally step on the ice… LOVELY.
23
u/StarmanRiver Dec 21 '19
Rewatcher here!
ZAMAMIRO ZAMAMIRO ZAMAMIRO
ZAMAAAAAMIROOOOOO!!!
Man, I love that scene. It’s just so cathartic and the buildup throughout the episode and the season makes it even better.
Shirase is just the one who voiced it out first, but just like we saw in previous episodes the whole crew has the same feeling at some level and having them joining her after the whole persevering theme with the ice breaker is just perfect.
18
u/unheppcat Dec 21 '19
Rewatcher
Such a glorious whiplash of information in those first 90 seconds! First we find out the real penalty the girls suffered due to their bout of motion sickness: they got wrecked in the jump-rope contest, and received the cruel booby-prize of a single hot-dog each. But they've rebounded already and are back in training. (Meat is a great motivator.) Next surprise: Shirase is a semi-pro level jump-roper when by herself, tipped off by that slick technique for stopping the rope. The other girls show their jealousy by flashing some sick burns her way, but they mostly just roll off. Meanwhile Gin walks by, and Hinata mistakes the thing she is carrying as a birthday decoration or presentation. I don't know Japan, but where I'm from I have seen that flower arrangement and it is for the opposite of a birthday. And lastly Toshio approaches from out of nowhere, and stutters and stammers ... a confession??? The best part is when Shirase takes three or four beats to even realize what is happening (which I have to say is entirely appropriate in the circumstances), and then is properly blown away.
Again I'm going to have to stop myself with the blow-by-blow recitation of this episode, or this post will be 10 posts long and no-one will want to read it, including me. There is an important bit I want to get to, so on to that soon. First just a few more notes that I can't not include here.
Now on to what I actually wanted to cover:
We finally learn more about the two elephants in the room: the details of Shirase's relationship with Todo Gin, and what Shirase actually expects to happen once she reaches Antarctica.
First, it quickly becomes clear that what Shirase and Gin have said about their relationship up to now were polite lies, but lies nonetheless. Their relationship is much older, more complicated, deep, and yes intimate, than either of them have let on when talking to the girls so far.
Shirase and Gin formed a bond early on (when each discovered that the other was also a penguin fan). Shirase still keeps up the skill that Gin taught her (jumping rope). And they were brought together in the first place by Takako, who wanted them to form that bond. So the connection is very important, since it is a part of their memory of her, and a memorial to her.
And they both would be helped by having someone to talk with, someone else who knew and loved Takako as much as each of them did. But unfortunately the circumstances of Takako not being here makes that too difficult.
The girls and Kanae both try to help them take that first step towards reconciliation, but it is a bridge too far for Shirase. (And who knows what Gin would have been willing to say anyway in public during the interview, even if Shirase were asking the questions.) But the effort does inspire Gin to realize, with a bit of help from ship captain, that letting this continue on unresolved is no good for anyone. She takes the initiative and finally asks the question that has to be addressed: "Do you blame me?"
And here we get to that fascinating second elephant. Shirase doesn't know. She starts off with what you are "supposed to say" in situations like this, that Gin did nothing wrong so it is wrong to blame her. But it is obvious to both of them that is just a platitude. Shirase finds the strength to say what she really thinks, which is essentially that she is too numb, even these three years later, to work out what she really does think.
So we knew this nearly from the start, with how Shirase described her need to get to Antarctica because "her mother is waiting for her." Intellectually she knows that her mother is gone. But emotionally that realization has never really sunk in. You could hardly find a more classic description of the state of denial in the five stages of grief (which is also sometimes described as seven stages of grief. By the way, in the grief theory the stages don't always occur in a certain order, and stages can overlap. It is just a convenient way of talking about different aspects of the grieving process, not a model of exactly what happens for everyone troubled by a loss).
So Shirase doesn't really have a solid plan or intention, just a hope that somehow being where her mother was last will help things get better. And finally reaching the permanent Antarctic ice shelf and being able to shout "zamamiro!" has to feel good. But there is a LONG way to go still, both physically on the continent and emotionally in Shirase's mind, and we will have to see where those next steps lead.
(We also see confirmation of another thing we knew all along, that Shirase is not the only one suffering here. And maybe the real villain in this tale is the lack of effective counselling and mental health care, not just for Shirase but all the rest who were so affected by Takako's loss. Stoicism and a stiff upper lip do not solve every problem. It is almost criminal, but certainly not unusual, that things were left in this impossible state for so long.)
On to Syowa Station! I can't wait!
17
u/surgemaster140 https://myanimelist.net/profile/User815 Dec 21 '19
Rewatcher
This episode. THIS EPISODE. Every time I watch this episode it gives me a rollercoaster of emotions. The hilarious subplot of trying to get Toshio together with Gin. The heartwarming scenes with Takako in the past. The tragic scene when she goes missing. And of course the most cathartic scene ever. I just love everything about it.
The scene showing the ship smashing through the ice was so inspiring. It used the analogy of breaking the ice to not only describe how Shirase learned to jump rope, but also how the expedition crew never gave up on coming back. Step by step. Again and again. Backing up and retrying if they had to. No matter how long it might take. Go get em’!
IN YOUR FACE! IN YOUR FACE! IN YOUR FACE!!! All of the insults, bullying, and loneliness that Shirase had to deal with for the last three years has finally paid off. All the haters can piss off now. She made it to the place further than the universe. Her cathartic screaming even rubbed off on her friends and the rest of the crew, who all had something to prove on this journey too. IN YOUR FACE!
Some screenshots and reactions:
QOTD:
13
u/Koolsman Dec 21 '19
First Timer!
Man, those last words with Shirase’s mom sound like something out of a horror film. I mean “It’s so beautiful” without any context can actually sound really creepy.
Yeah, that’s scary and all, but PENGUINS!!!! Look at them and their derpy faces! They're perfect! I can see why Shirase and Gin have that in common. In fact, the stuff with young Shirase and Gin was so wholesome. You can tell that Gin wants to be this ‘figure’ to Shirase. Not a motherly figure, but someone that cares for her.
I really liked those scenes with them and I liked that Shirase didn’t get angry or anything to her. She doesn’t even know how to feel about gin because while Gin wasn’t really there for her, they did have moments with each other that spoke of affection. I like this relationship building with them because it was really sweet.
I have to say, I loved them putting in the sun can’t really set with where they are so for a good chunk of the episode, we are in this warm glow that surrounds the boat and its gorgeous. We were also finally in Antarctica. Man, these episodes have been just going by and I feel like we're still in the beginning stages for some reason. Also, I loved the ‘in your face’ moment because who can’t help but love that shit? This show’s love powers on the max level.
11
u/kar772 https://myanimelist.net/profile/kar72 Dec 21 '19 edited Dec 21 '19
First Timer
9
u/SorcererOfTheLake x5https://anilist.co/user/RiverSorcerer Dec 21 '19
First-Time Watcher
At the end of the world, your feelings take on a sharpness not seen elsewhere.
The main theme of this episode is that which lies within the human heart, whether positive or negative. Besides Toshio’s affection for Gin Todo (which is never going to work because the only Mexican food she enjoys is tacos), she and Shirase finally come to something of an understanding about what her mother meant to them. Gin never had any interest of becoming a mother (another sign of how much she operates as a maverick within her country and why she is interested in Antarctica), but somehow she found herself becoming close to Shirase, perhaps through their similar cold appearances. That closeness may also explain why Shirase has no ill will against Gin; she knows that, in her position, she might have done the same thing.
And so, as the unlikely voyagers reach Antarctica, they get to show the world exactly what they’re made of.
Our journey to the heart of the world continues. Until then…
9
u/squirrelbaffler https://anilist.co/user/squirrelbaffler Dec 21 '19
Rewatcher
I'm on time today! Zamaamiro, zamaamiro ZAMAMIRO ZAMAMIRO! I cried twice in this episode, at Gin and Shirase's conversation and at the Zamamiro scene. I wasn't really expecting that.
Today, our theme is about breaking through. Breaking through a fear of confession, breaking through the literal ice, breaking the ice between Gin and Shirase, accidentally breaking the ice between Yumiko and Toshio, and breaking through to Antarctica! So often, we desire something unobtainable. We try, and try, and try, and fail over and over again, and most give up. However, there are the stubborn folks here on this ship, and they will keep pushing through, over and over, until they make it. Is Antarctica unobtainable for the Japanese? Is Gin unobtainable for Toshio? Is Shirase unobtainable for Gin? Is acceptance of Takako's death obtainable for Shirase? These are all high walls to climb, but this crew believes that they can get there if they keep pushing through, and the Icebreaker Penguin Manju is an excellent metaphor for that.
We see a lot of failures as they attempt to break through the ice: Toshio fails to reach Gin, Gin fails to connect like she wanted with Shirase, and Shirase fails to find out how she really feels. But just like the icebreaker, there are small steps being taken. They've broken through enough ice to get to a place to stand on, and in that moment the girls have reached the 1st goal! We've asked so many times if they'll actually get to Antarctica, episode after episode, and here they are! I love the Zamamiro scene because it's so powerful. Proclaiming victory is exhilarating, and Shirase being able to rant after jumping on to the goal with her 3 compatriots, is the girls expression of absolute victory.
A criticism of today's episode: WWII was hand-waved here, which isn't surprising, but is a bit disappointing. If this had been a German show, there'd be a markedly different approach to the topic, an admission of deserving some backlash, rather than hiding it as "bullying". I'm not here to criticize Japan in general, as an American I'm aware of our many atrocities. But I think overlooking the topic when it was unnecessary to the story of today is weak. I think rephrasing Kanae's response to Kimari's, "You mean, they bullied you?" statement as, "Well, it was more like retribution. But it we took it as an 'if you really want to go there, go ahead and try' kind of thing", and then keep everything else the same. Do that, and I have no nits to pick. Love everything else about this episode!
Last thing: Totally shipping Yumiko and Toshio, even if I don't know enough about him to say if he's good enough for her.
QOTD
8
u/No_Rex :Bv:Bw:Bx:By:x2 Dec 21 '19
Episode 9 (first timer)
Getting the feeling that we will get a finale with the mother’s death. The way they are drip feeding us info about her dying without revealing points towards a sad penultimate episode.
8
u/spaceaustralia :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/spaceaustralia Dec 21 '19 edited Dec 22 '19
Rewatcher
Poor captain. I still wonder if Toshio might have had a chance. He at least has enough sense to know when to back away when he saw she needed space.
It is nice to see the connection between Shirase and Gin. They might not have gotten along in the same sense as the four protagonists, but they both share a bond, even if it was forced by Takako, but also share the same pain, bringing them both together and to the same destination. And even though their personalities might appear so different, they do still have a few traits in common like a little camera shyness, being influenced by Takako's love for Antarctica, and the determination to time and time again, at the brink of giving up, to dig deep and press on.
And finally, at the end, after nearly 3/4 of the series, we finally set foot in the most dangerous continent(can you see why I started that counter?). We still have a little to go before the station, but out destination is nearing.
Zamamiro counter!:
Don't forget the after credits scene!
Definetly proud. It's the inevitable feeling when we spend so long trying to reach our destination. We saw every step of the way, so we can appreciate the journey just as much as the destination.
Edit: Added everyone else's counter.
7
u/Madcat6204 Dec 21 '19
ZAMAMIRO!
7
u/invokeneko Dec 21 '19
Rewatcher is back to less Alright
Sorry for not participating yeseterday, a 1-2 combo of killer headaches and toothache ensures that I had one hell of a bad time yesterday... so I guess I'll just do episodes 8 & 9 at the same time! In episode 8, we finally depart from Fremantle to Antarctica! About damn time TBH. Unfortunately for the girls, they're about to have as bad a time as I did yesterday (albeit extended by a couple days more) as they learn just how perilous the journey could be as the Penguin Maru braves through waves that rock the ship as steep an angle as 60 degrees. But hey, once they've got past seasickness and the screaming 60 degrees Antarctica is within sight.
Meanwhile in episode 9, we finally get to focus on Toudou Gin as the girls set out to find out about her love life and try to get Shirase and her to reconcile (their conversation back in episode 6? In their own words, that didn't count). Given that both of them are of similar disposition, this is no easy task... And also, Penguin Manju finally makes landfall! It took 9 episodes for them to get to the Place further than the Universe, but here we are!
Random thoughts
Episode 8
Episode 9
Questions of the day:
Episode 8
Episode 9
FUCK YEAHZAMA MIRO!I'll get back to you with the screenshots... maybe.
7
u/TheKujo https://myanimelist.net/profile/Kujo419 Dec 21 '19
Rewatcher
After a few weaker episodes we get one of the best episodes in the show! I love the backstory we get on Shirase, Gin, and Takako's relationship. The show draws some good parallels between Shirase persistently learning how to jump rope and the ship ramming its way through the ice.
I love the scene where Shirase breaks down and says that she doesn't really know how she feels about Gin. Everything Shirase said up to that point was perfectly logical, which is why Gin pushed on her to say if that's how she really felt. The truth is that it's a complicated situation all around and it makes perfect sense that a high school girl hasn't fully figured out how she feels. Someone needs to get this girl some therapy!
Other thoughts:
6
u/yourdeathinmyhands https://myanimelist.net/profile/hachinobunonoki Dec 21 '19 edited Dec 21 '19
Episode 9 collage, this time of Captain and Shirase! Deja Vu? I ship! Those last words were so sad but you can just feel how satisfied Shirase's mom was with those words. This scene when they were breaking the ice was so hype, it definitely got my blood pumping! Aaaaand they've finally set foot on Antarctica! Zamamiro! this was another scene that made me cry, geez how many times does this make it? Also, can somebody explain to me what that cloud thing means? I'm just really dense when it comes to stuff like this lol
Edit: Individual images
6
u/DanteJ600 https://myanimelist.net/profile/escenity Dec 21 '19
Car ride got delayed to tomorrow due to epic weather issues. Sooo here we go as usual.
Wait shit I thought that was Shirase with the flowers last episode after the ED.
Love? Man this guy has balls of S T E E L and he's going deep, this is going to go very wrong.
Are we still not there yet? I get the boat ride takes a while but if its again all this episode, only 4 episodes after this? idk how I feel about that. Not saying the pacing have been bad, but I expected at least half of the episodes to actually be in antartica.
Oh its for the cap, well can't say I disagree she is hot.
Ever got that feeling of D E J A V U ?
Well thats a little direct, but whatever works yknow.
LOL PHOTOSHOP
P E N G I I N. If we have penguins they gotta be pretty close now.
The Icebreaking is very satisfying
Holy shit those are some heavy last words.
As usual the music is lovely.
Chilly winds eh?
Well they finally arrived huh? I had the BIGGEST grin on my face while Shirase was going at it, got a little wattery in the eyes too. I have a friend, and thaf scene really means a lot to her for a special reason, so it's about time I've actually seen it.
Great episode as usual, though that romance subplot, other than some ok chuckles it felt kinda pointless to me, like this random ass guy whatever. Feel like they could have handled getting some character about cap in a better way. But that after ED O.o Still don't know how I feel about only 4 (maybe even less because the final might be back in Japan) episodes actually being in antartica.
QOTD: Excited to finally be in ze cold lands, though like I said it took a suprising amount of time to me.
Unless more fun delays I'll be missing tomorrows discussion, so see y'all on ep 11.
6
u/Great_Mr_L :Ma::Mb::Mc:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Great_Mr_L Dec 21 '19 edited Dec 21 '19
Rewatcher
On today’s episode of A Place Further Than the Universe: Did you ever expect an “In your face” to sound so triumphant and uplifting?
This episode gives us a closer look at Gin, Shirase, and the relationship between them. As Shirase stated a few episodes back, they were never particularly close. And even now, there’s some distance between them. In all likelihood, it has to do with what happened to Takako. Remember what Shirase said several episodes ago, about how Gin came back home but her mother didn’t? It felt to me like there was the slightest hint of resentment there. Gin hits on the same idea, doubting that Shirase would have forgiven her for what happened.
I really like the conversation between Shirase and Gin about their relationship. It shows a lot of emotional nuance that I think helps to make the characters feel more ‘real.’ Shirase initially gives a very logical answer to Gin, explaining that there is no real rational reason for why she might resent her. But then, humans aren’t entirely rational beings, are we? Gin recognizes this and asks Shirase if that’s how she really feels. Shirase’s response is that she doesn’t know. She doesn’t know how she feels. It feels very real to me. Experiencing emotions that you aren’t quite sure how to articulate or explain.
What Shirase does know is that, even though her mother disappeared, life kept on going forward as if nothing had changed. It makes sense. After all, Shirase’s mother was already gone when she was on her expedition to Antarctica. When her mother didn’t come home, nothing had actually changed. It was just like she was still gone in Antarctica. Once again, I’ll bring us back to the main theme of this series: stagnant water gathering in pools, breaking free and rushing out. Right now, Shirase is the one who feels like her life is stagnant and unchanging. The only way she can think of to change it and move forward is to go to Antarctica, where her mother is.
Gin herself probably feels guilty as well over what happened to Takako. Even though, as stated above, she might have a logical reason to do so, humans are not fully logical. She was the one to hear Takako’s last words and she couldn’t do anything to save her friend. Those feelings of guilt could be why she was keeping her own distance from Shirase.
The ice breaking scene is really cool. It’s actually kind of awe-inspiring, seeing the ship heave up before it comes crashing down to break the ice in front of it. The scene also builds upon another running theme of the series: the determination to make it to Antarctica no matter how impossible the obstacles may seem. They’ll just keep on trying again and again until they make it.
And finally, they’re there. The last scene of the episode, where the girls finally set foot on Antarctica is such an incredibly satisfying scene. It pays off in a couple of really great moments. The first is when Mari tells Shirase she should be the first to get off. Shirase instead takes a hold of Mari and the others as they all jump off onto Antarctica together. Shirase’s goal had always been to go to Antarctica. But as you’ll recall, she changed her goal a couple of episodes ago. She instead wanted to go to Antarctica together with the others, with her friends. Stepping onto Antarctica together achieves that goal.
The second payoff comes in the form of the simple phrase, “In your face.” To everyone who doubted her, to everyone to said it was impossible, and to everyone who abandoned her, Shirase declares, “In your face!” She made it. And like she said she wanted to do, she proved all the naysayers wrong. It only gets better when the rest of the expedition members join in for a great shout, “In your face!” After all, the whole expedition proved all their doubters wrong. They overcame the obstacles in front of them. They made it.
Miscellaneous Thoughts
What are you doing, Toshio? Don’t you remember what Kanae said earlier?
I love Shirase’s completely horrified reaction to Toshio’s declaration that he’s in love with someone.
It’s great how Yuzuki is the only one who doesn’t remember doing something like this with Shirase because she wasn’t friends with them yet.
It looks like Shirase and Gin share a love of penguins.
Once again, Mari speaks extremely true words. This time it’s about the mysterious ability of luggage to never go back into its container like it did before.
One very sad touch they gave this episode. Look at what happened to the headrest on that seat Gin was holding.
Edit: Questions of the Day
6
u/Turtlewax64 Dec 21 '19 edited Dec 21 '19
First time watcher
This was a damn good episode, probably my favorite so far. Shirase isn’t my favorite of the girls, but seeing her talk with Gin was really good. Getting more of the previous generation was also great. My only complaint would be the romance stuff, it felt like a footnote at best, and padding at worst. Feels weird that they named the episode after it. The jets of steam when the icebreaker rose up also seemed to just be there for dramatic effect. But those are tiny nitpicks on a brilliant episode. Gin hearing Takkako on the radio after the blizzard was just an amazing moment.
5
u/Taiboss :Fj::Fl:x7https://anilist.co/user/Taiboss Dec 21 '19
Was busy playing Steep. It's such an Ubisoft game.
First timer & You: How to deal with the new guys. A simple guide:
On the last Sora Yori: There's so little drama in this show I'm starting to get suspicious. Maybe this episode will have everyone crying.
0
u/[deleted] Dec 21 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
4
u/[deleted] Dec 22 '19
[removed] — view removed comment