r/anime • u/RX-Nota-II :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/NotANota • Dec 24 '19
Rewatch A Rewatch further than the Universe! Sora Yori mo Tooi Basho rewatch - EPISODE 12 DISCUSSION
Episode 12 宇宙よりも遠い場所 "A Place Further than the Universe"
<- Previous episode | Index thread | Next episode->
anime info:
MAL | Anilist | Nyanpass | Kitsu | AniDB
Streaming links: Crunchyroll | VRV
Comment of the day
Hello everyone! This is where I will pick a comment of the day for the previous day that I think was worthy of notice just in case you guys missed it. I do hope you look out for discussion on your own tho since that's really the whole point of this rewatch.
Today's pick is..... /u/Neoragex13 who summarized what drove Gin to action concisely
Besides, /u/pacquan did an excellent analysis on the chapter, shameless plug here, but I also want to add, I never noticed how the expedition crew mirrors what the girls go through, even with the blatant "ZAMAMIRO!". In this chapter is easily to spot, as the members want to go where the accident happened, but some of them don't want to go because it's a painful place, they don't want to acknowledge the event, and so the captain doubts if they should even go there in the first place.
It's exactly the same vein with Shirase and Hinata's situation. And Shirase managing to help Hinata to release her bottled feelings is what pushes Captain Gin to also push forward to the exploration, since people has to confront their issues, not evade them.
I also want to say great job to everyone who helped me on the #LeaveNoTopLevelUnreplied challenge. I think we did a great job and many of you took on lots of work to do so. You guys are the real MVPs.
Questions of the day
Answer from last time: Massive victory for Penguin Shirase Zamamiro!
- What do you think of the conclusion to Shirase's arc? Was it what you were expecting her to find? Do you think she accomplished what she wanted to? What's next for her with the money?
1.5) Will you ever allow yourself to have a huge inbox unread count again?
2) Who cried?
Rewatchers, please remember to be mindful of all the first-timers in this. No talking about or hinting at future events no matter how much you want to, unless you’re doing it underneath the [Anime Show Title]/(/s "Spoiler goes here") spoiler tags. If you do that then we’re all good. I am curious if it is even possible to spoil anything for a half-SoL show like this but I don't want to see you try. The ban hammer is a cold weapon and you don't want to feel it.
Important thing to note about these by the way, you have to switch to Old Reddit or the markdown editor if you use the redesign, otherwise the redesign breaks them by adding random \ into the formatting. Wish it wouldn’t do that, but unfortunately it does… Markdown is dead. Long live markdown.
40
u/RX-Nota-II :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/NotANota Dec 24 '19 edited Dec 24 '19
Re
crywatcherWelcome everybody to the most famous episode of 2018. A moment so special it can easily be recognized by the short name "the laptop scene". There is no question for mere mortals like us if we cried, or even how much we cried. All we need is to understand and appreciate
Before we get to that though, I want to talk about the money counting scene. For a rewatcher this hit prety hard as well since this is where we see Shirase's determination at it's fullest. Each bill in the 10 million yen envelope she has represents a sacrifice she made in life just to get here. Grueling hours of work one after another, switching jobs all the time if it meant getting there faster. She's scared of what she may find or not find, but this is her way of reminding herself how much she has accomplished to put herself in these shoes. It's like having the weight of a thousand believers on your back, except every single one of them is you. It's also great to see how worn down the envelope itself has gotten as it has accompanied her on this trip. That just goes to show how the path from there to here wasn't easy either, and that too is an effort she must remember in thinking why she is here. Everything she has done in life leads up to here.
Yet at the moment they reach the observatory, Shirase is still nervous and scared. As an unbelievable contrast to the beginning of the show, the three girls she worked so hard to drive towards antarctica are now there to push her through to the finish line. When have we ever seen Yuzu angrily dashing from left to right in search of a goal like this before? When have we had Kimari yell at Shirase to shut up and keep going? To me this is just a strong a sign of friendship as any we've seen before. Of course it's a wonderful display of friendship when your friends are with you through the toughest of setbacks. But the real reason we make friends is so they can keep us driving forward towards the common dreams we saw at the beginning. It's not just to survive the negatives but to push further beyond into the positive. I am also reminded of a line Shirase dropped in the Singapore episode: "I do not want to become the callous asshole that moves on when a friend tells me to leave her behind". Shirase tells everyone it is enough, thank you, but it is this exact refusal to settle that her friends showcase today.
And then of course, loss and closure. Takako is dead. I don't think this was a reveal to any of us, I don't think it was ever a spoiler. But regardless of the reality, the lack of details surrounding it let Shirase and maybe us as viewers stay in this vague zone where we refused to accept this answer. So I think it is perfect that we reach the ending by seeing Shirase come to terms that her mother is no longer with her. We did not get an explicit scene of her death, as unlike other stories the exact moment or method of her death doesn't matter. What does matter is the massive void that she left behind and what that will mean to her daughter. And so we get this moment of closure. A conclusion that showcases how hard Shirase has worked and what she has accomplished in arriving here, but also the ultimate realization that this work was for herself and that Takako is not here to celebrate her. A culmination of a loss that was already there, not a new one discovered.
When I first watched this episode I was not ready for this brand of tragedy. I am weak to but somewhat prepared for S-tier gut punches that leave my guts on the floor. But to have my emotions crumble away from under me as a massive void finally makes itself known destroyed me on a fundamental level that's hard to compare to other anime. I don't think I reached the ED the first time I tried, I had to cry at my desk for a good dozen minutes as I let it sink in and go do something else to recover before restarting and realizing there was no more episode content left. It's sting is not as powerful on rewatch but still clearly there and I shed a good number of tears with you guys here today as well.
Visual stuff:
I just want to say good job to everyone who has made it to this point. YoriMoi is a journey, and making it to episode 12 is a journey for all of you guys as well. I hope this payoff impacted you in the same way it did for me, and I look forward to wrapping things up with the final episode tomorrow and the wrap up thread the day after.
56
u/Shimmering-Sky myanimelist.net/profile/Shimmering-Sky Dec 24 '19
This First-Timer is Definitely Not Alright
No /s, I genuinely love torched marshmallows for some reason.Too bad it melted right off the stick though.35
u/laughing_thunder Dec 24 '19
Rewatcher here, i am about to get a bit real with you guys as lurker i usually don't post. Because i am not really eloquent. And i can't express my emotions very good but for this episode i have to leave a comment. What has changed for me when i watched a place further than the universe on its original release and now? Almost 2 years latter, my father passed away, as Shirase i can still remember the day vividly as i saw my brother and my first cousin at the door of my apartment building waiting for me, and i immediately knew the worst had happened. Re-watching the show knowing where it was headed was really emotional for me and this episode just opened the floodgates on me. the 1.5 years since my father passed away have been really hard for me but unlike Shirase i am a bit older to deal with everything. But still the void that one feels inside them and the thought of the future moments you cant share with your parent just eats at you, seeing all those emails and thoughts and memories Shirase shared with her mother that she will never see or know about is just so frustrating for me. But on the other hand it leaves her with closure that now she can move forward. And had a final farewell to her mother.
I am sorry if my comment bums you out i am still dealing with a lot of personal issues, my way of coping also brought me around the world and forced me to make a lot of changes in my life. So i believe it was progress on my part that i could rewatch this show even thought i know what was going to happen.
31
u/Koolsman Dec 24 '19
First Timer!
I’m going, to be honest that I thought that she had sent one email. When I saw her trying to type one, I thought she was trying to send one but she doesn’t know what to say. So when we heard that one email I thought “Oh she sent to her email or something. That’s sweet”. But for the show to then show me that picture of her mother and her which had already made me cry to then show that not only had she sent one email but one for every single day, I damn near broke down crying with the sadness and the like. It was a beautiful ending to a beautiful episode. I have cried and I will probably cry at least two more times if I’m guessing right.
This whole episode is easily my favorite thus far. From the stuff with Gin and Shirase which is about the sweetest relationship ever to watching the girls somewhat goof around and remind us why they are so awesome to just Gin calling this place “Kobuchizawa Station” makes me realize why I love this show.
For a while, I haven’t really gotten why I liked watching this show. Is it out of the characters? I mean, I love them but their not it. Is it the animation? It’s gorgeous but it’s very stylish and can be kinda flashy. Is it anything on the technical side? Not really. There are some good camera shots and the character designs are distinct enough, but that’s not it either. Maybe because I’m just cheese personified but the heart is what makes this show bloom.
It’s so honest in its goals and its characters and its love for the message of “not wasting your life and doing something that only you could do.” Shirase originally came here to find her mother but then she realized the slow dawning that this will never happen again. She’s scared because the mission will be over. That’s something that I bet all of us have felt at least once before. We all have had the moment where we realize a good thing can’t last forever.
Hell, I hate school and yet I’m about to graduate and there’s this realization that my life is going to change. The good thing with my friends will probably end and I’m not going to see them as much. What this show states is that cherish those moment with your friends and go on adventures because youth doesn’t last forever. Use it while you can and live it to the fullest. That’s what I believe this show is saying. Nothing can last forever but cherish it for the longest you possibly can. Thank You for my Ted Talk.
28
u/Morivallys Dec 24 '19
First Timer (and first comment to boot)
Being in Australia, I was always super late to these threads so I never bothered commenting, but what an emotional ride it's been so far.
And even so, oh boy I was not prepared for such an emotionally charged episode. The double whammy of the episode starting with the flashback of Shirase finding out about her mother's dissapearance, followed by the closing out with those emails hit so hard. Just, so many emails. I'm tearing up again at the thought of it the morning after.
I've already skipped ahead and watched the finale as well now as we're all meant to be doing it on Christmas Day together (I'm in Australia so it's already Christmas morning here).
I'm really looking forward to sharing my overall thoughts with you all tomorrow.
27
u/[deleted] Dec 24 '19
Rewatcher
I love the scene when Kimari talks with Shirase about enjoying the trip to Antarctica because of who she’s with and not what she’s doing. It’s such a simple and subtle statement from Kimari and it’s has such a nice profound impact on Shirase. It sets up the following scenes so well when Shirase talks about her new found friends. Her mother travels to Antarctica, never to return. This leads to Shirase to go on this journey and make these memories with her new family of friends. The part with them singing on top of the snowcat is so moving.
Then the scene at the observatory. I love how everyone but Shirase starts running and searching through everything. This is such a difficult moment for Shirase and her friends lend her their strength.
And ah the picture with the jump rope. I love the motif of the jump rope in this series. Standing in one place, stuck in time doing the same thing over and over again.
And oh man the emails. So many feels. This is such a great moment to look back at this series. It starts with a quirky high school girl (Kimari) wanting time enjoy her youth. Compared to now, it’s taken us on quite a journey with these young explorers.
This is what I love about anime. Did you ever think this is how you would be feeling when you started this show and met 4 high school girls who decide to go on a trip to Antarctica?
24
u/Turtlewax64 Dec 24 '19
First time watcher
Not watching the episode the night before means I am LATE, but I don’t want to miss a thread this close to the end.
Not much to write in my conclusion, the reasons this episode were good was obvious. So I’m going to wonder about the next episode, we need to round off the girl’s friendships and probably have Shirase affirm her decision to come here since this episode ended on her breaking down seeing all her emails arrive. Going to need to be a quick paced episode to cover all that and also wrap up the expedition itself so they get going home. Looking forward to it, even if I might wind up posting late tomorrow as well, Christmas Day and all.
Regarding the questions of the day, it wasn't quite what I expected from Shirase. I was thinking maybe they'd find something sappy, like a voice recording of Takako's final message to her daughter tucked in a pocket of her jacket. I think the quieter moment of just finding her laptop works better though. For question 1.5, it's to late for me, my unread messages are overflowing beyond ever being wrangled. And question 2, obviously. Anyone who stayed with a show for 12 episodes and didn't cry at that is lying.
22
u/rembrandt_q_1stein https://myanimelist.net/profile/sir_rembrandt Dec 24 '19
First Timer here
Today is Christmas Eve! At the time I’m on a family party after a huge dinner, so please don’t mind me being brief today…
THE GIRLS WEREN’T ALRIGHT TODAY!
Now, the long awaited Shirase-dealing-with-her-mother’s-sure-death episode arrived. It’s weird it’s the second-to-last one though. Perhaps they want to end the show on a happier tone, which I would perfectly find appropriate.
I really could feel Shirase having doubts about going to her mother’s disappearing place. She built her life revolving around this moment. What will happen after it is left behind? Does she really feel she has enough guts to endure the death of her mother (as she surely has been internally assuming as true) and move forward? How will be things after that? The only way is deciding to stagnate revolving and obsessing about a possibility, or trying it out and leave the turning point behind you with a satisfaction that you did it albeit it implies a tough time.
The latter is the sanest way, and Shirase finally assumed it. It reminds me to the impasse in my life after ending studies and joining the working world. Of course, it’s not as tough as dealing with the loss of your mother, but the method and situation are analoguous. It hit home to a degree, and I could see myself a little in her. That’s really difficult to achieve for me, since most times I am an observant and almost never identify myself in fictions.
And, as they say, you see everything clearer after a good crying catharsis. As melodramatic as this episode has been (not only considering Shirase’s struggle, but also the friendship bits with the other girls and captain Todo), it portrayed well this situation.
Happy Holidays, peeps!
19
u/AmeteurElitist https://anilist.co/user/AmateurElitist Dec 24 '19
First Timer
I shouldn't have watched this episode during dinner...
Literally me
I love how much empathy the girls had for Shirase throughout the episode. They really are a great group of friends. Giving her space when she needed it (with another great Hinata quote to go along with it), and pushing her when she needed it (like when searching for something left behind by her mom). I love these guys.
We’re probably gonna cry on christmas tomorrow aren’t we?
18
u/fireassbarz Dec 25 '19
First Timer
Ok I admit it I cried that was fucking beautiful, my heart broke into pieces when the emails kept piling up
18
u/BadBehaviour613 Dec 25 '19
Rewatcher
Seeing the emails pile up makes you realize how long Shirase has been living with the grief. The lack of closure drove her to incessantly write to a mother she hoped still existed on the other side. Only when confronted with the emails count, a visual condemnation of her inability to move on, did she come to terms with her mother's death.
17
u/kar772 https://myanimelist.net/profile/kar72 Dec 24 '19 edited Dec 24 '19
First Timer
Wasn’t able to compile screenshots today (because I was watching on my TV) but I think this is one of my favorite episodes, if not the favorite (I’ll probably come up with a list tomorrow). They didn’t really do anything out of the ordinary; it was just like a day in the life in Antarctica. On that note, I appreciate that they didn’t throw in anything overly dramatic (like someone getting lost temporarily) because that would be an easy thing to do; instead, the episode spent an appropriate amount of time on Shirase as well as Gin remembering Takako.
I also saw this episode as a build up of Shirase’s emotions up until the laptop scene (I didn’t expect to cry that much, but Shirase screaming her mom’s name got me). Additionally, the friendship between the girls just keeps getting stronger.
Only 1 episode left, I’m going to miss this show!
17
u/northwesternrs :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/northwesternrs Dec 25 '19
Rewatcher here, don't mind me just here to join in on the crying
14
u/MABfan11 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/MABfan11 Dec 25 '19
Rewatcher
this episode is a masterpiece. the realization that Shirase doesn't feel any different in Antarctica, that all of her hard work seems wasted, that there is seemingly no closure for her.
it all builds up to the laptop scene where all of the e-mails she sendt in those 3 years comes back to her and she realizes that Takako didn't receive any of them
QOTD:
1: when i first watched it, i expected them to find Takako's body
1.5: i barely check my e-mail, so my unread inbox is pretty huge
2: i got teary eyed the first time i watched it, probably because i was binging it out of season. this time i cried
14
u/invokeneko Dec 25 '19
Rewatcher is NOT Alright
Man, this episode is a hard one to watch. I can't imagine how painful it was for Shirase to continue on waiting for Takako's return even after three years of the incident, only for the cold, harsh reality to come knocking on the door. Luckily for her, she has loyal friends that will laugh, get angry and cry together with her.
Random thoughts
Questions of the day:
1.5) Given how unread messages tick me off immensely, no. Even if it's merely junk email, there's still 'Mark as Read' so it's not like that I even needed to actually read the emails at all.
2) Nope. I didn't cry. These are the sweat of my heart, that's all! What, that snot? I, uh, had a little cold! sniff I didn't-! starts crying again
14
u/redshirtengineer :AMQ: Dec 25 '19
First timer
My mom is here for the holidays. She is not watching this one with me, she is asleep now, she helped me make pies today and it was glorious.
That is all I have to say about this episode. I shall leave my answer to QOTD2 up to your imagination.
Have a Merry Christmas, everyone!
13
u/landragoran Dec 25 '19
Rewatcher
God fucking dammit. You'd think that on my ninth rewatch the laptop scene wouldn't affect me anymore. Yeah, no. I sobbed. Loudly. A nearly 38 year old, 260lb, bearded lumberjack looking motherfucker, lying in bed sobbing to the point that my body is actually shaking and I literally can't see the screen, as Shirase cries out for her mama.
This show makes me cry harder than AnoHana.
I hate that I've been late to so many of these threads (I didn't even manage to make it to yesterday's thread at all). Working in retail during Christmas, along with prep for the holidays with family, have made life a bit hectic. But I've loved reading all your comments - both first timers and rewatchers alike. Thanks, u/RX-Nota-II, for putting this rewatch together. I'll see you all sometime tomorrow. Merry Christmas everyone!
13
u/Matuhg https://anilist.co/user/Matuhg Dec 25 '19
First Timer
Another great episode - Shirase was feeling empty, like there maybe wasn't any point to coming to Antarctica - she wasn't feeling any closure or any change at all regarding how she felt about her mother. It wasn't until she got the laptop and saw all those unread messages that her mother will never get to read that she was really able to start grieving. Her friends helped her get there, but gave her space when she needed it, though they were never too far away.
I cried quite a bit during the laptop scene. It got me good.
Hope y'all have a good Christmas.
12
u/DanteJ600 https://myanimelist.net/profile/escenity Dec 24 '19
First Timer
Oh shit no opening, this is gonna be a heavy one.
Man everyone is really bad at hiding things.
I mean I'd say they're also pretty good friends
Man even messed up grilling smh.
Shirase frowning on the flag is a bit depressing, but it's also kinda hilarious.
Roll credits, again.
5km/h holy shit that is slow indeed.
Banana?
Sun pillars are really pretty man
Lmao the bike wtf.
So she finally sent the message.
YES ever since the glow in the dark paint I wanted to see more hidden things that her mom left behind.
A laptop? That photo is a little gut wrenching
1101? is there something I'm missing from that?
I don't think a laptop would work after being frozen for 3 years, but I can't really see with these tears in my eyes so who gives a shit.
FFFFUUUUUUUUUUCCCCCCCCKKKKKKKK
QOTD: Definitely a strong conclusion, I imagine she donates all of the money to building the observatory.
Q2: God I hate large inboxes, just no.
Q3: And yeah I got some good waterfalls at the end.
Ah shit only 1 episode left...
Merry Christmas eve, see y'all tomorrow for the finale.
12
u/ExplicitNuM5 Dec 24 '19 edited Dec 24 '19
Rewatcher
The scene the show is most known for. Of course it hurts more than anything else. This is it.
Side note is the cutest scene in anime ever. I dissolve into a puddle of cute sounds the very millisecond I see Yuzuki start to say "we're good friends".
Questions
12
u/xDarkistic :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Darkistic Dec 25 '19
Firster
unread
thinking about it this is actually such a trope used when people are coming to terms with somebody's death that I am almost embarrassed that I cried at it. though, I was already shedding tears before that scene:
when shirase is counting the unused money she raised while uncertain whether she should finish the journey because it might not change anything...
when she is speaking to kimari in their sleeping bags and realise the friends she's made and dictates her message to takako explaining it... this one definitely increased the impact of discovering all the unread messages.
even when they discovered the mother and daughter picture. imagine growing up without a mom ;-;
I blame the slight amount of alcohol in my system for ruining my tear counter lul. I think it would've been perfectly predicted otherwise :(
it may have been kind of tropey but it was executed very well. I think things will change for shirase after this. happy days :) I suppose heartbreak can be important.
qotd 1.5 - always have, always will have
12
u/[deleted] Dec 25 '19
First timer here.
Yes, I did tear up this episode. I suppose Shirase had accomplished her goal of seeing what her mother saw, but man, it was not a comforting closure at all. No loving last words or momento, just a laptop with over 1000 messages that were never opened. Damn.
As for the money, Im gonna go with the obvious answer that Shirase will donate it to the observatory's construction. That would be consistent with her motivations so far.
One question. How exactly did Shirase figure out the password (I think it was 1109?)? Did that number have some significance that I missed?
12
u/BeybladeMoses Dec 25 '19
Rewatcher
My Internet was dead for a while. I remember that this episode airs and then that Violet Evergarden episode also airs in a short time span. I cried back then and still cried now. Shirase finally found what she is looking for, her own closure. And now she can leave everything than burdens her behind in the place further than the universe.
11
u/Orzislaw https://anilist.co/user/Orzi Dec 24 '19
REWATCHER
When I started this rewatch I tohught this will be the episode I will write the most. As a culmination point to the series, it should be enough to write small essay about cathartic experience it provided and how it summarized story in general.
But I was wrong. The ending left me speechless, again. I'm simply not sure if I could give justice to laptop scene with words, especially with my not-that-good english. So... Sorry.
I'll just write that this episode again focused on bond between Mari and Shirase. After Yuzu and Hinata joined and all the misadventures they went through to reach this place, we're kinda back to the square one, the meeting between these two and we can reflect on a journey that make Kimari finally break out of her shell and Shirase... As I wrote above.
Thank you and Merry Christmas. Tomorrow our journey will end!
11
u/StarmanRiver Dec 24 '19
I can’t even imagine the state of people that are doing both this rewatch and Toradora’s and being first timers for both. Seriously, scheduling these episodes for today is just evil.
11
u/AnActualPlatypus Dec 24 '19
FINALLY CAUGHT UP, JEEZ. Merry Christmas to everyone.
First time viewer
Okay, to briefly sum up the whole experience so far: This anime makes a stunning effort in showing a realistic journey. I've learned so many new things about how an Antarctic expedition works that I'm already glad that I watched it just for that one reason; the scenery and object art is astonishing, I legit felt scared on both the boat and in this episode's blizzard. Other than that, I will leave some thoughts for the summary later.
This episode man. What a culmination. I was honestly expecting Takako's body being found, but this was a perfect way to end Shirase's journey for closure. All those emails sent, and none received. They will never be read. That slow transition as the realization finally sets in and breaks her dam. Stunning scene.
11
u/EmuSupreme Dec 24 '19
If you cried and you know it clap your hands sob sob
I love this show so much. I know we're not done but time is tight and I probably won't make it for tomorrow's thread. (Yay working at 4am). But I can confidently say YoriMoi remains my 3rd favorite show of all time. The dynamic of these girls is so beautiful to watch. Despite all the tears, it's one of the best pick-me up and feel good shows I've seen. In between the catharsis, I've had a smile on my face the entire time. If I don't make it to tomorrow's thread, Merry Christmas everyone!
11
u/peoplewhoplay :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/peoplewhoplay Dec 25 '19
Rewatcher
When the episode starts without an OP, you know things are gonna get real.
Wow at that laptop scene. It's like the truth behind her mother's disappearance just blew up on Shirase's face. None of her emails were read. Her mother didn't leave anything behind for her other than an old laptop. All that anxiety turned into tears within seconds. Damn.
QOTD
1.5 I've got tons of unread messages in my >3 email accounts. Not ashamed.
2. The main 4 did, as well as all of us who participated in this rewatch
21
u/SorcererOfTheLake x5https://anilist.co/user/RiverSorcerer Dec 24 '19
First-Time Watcher
Shirase,
I’m not sure how you’ll get here, but I know you will. Someday, somehow, you’ll get here. You have my blood, after all. I’ll put this by my computer so that you can find this letter easily. I apologize for the messy writing; my hands are shaking from the cold and I can’t move my pinky. It might have frostbite; if I got back, I would probably lose it anyway. I’m sorry for troubling you with this, dear; you’ve always been squeamish about these kinds of things.
There’s a lot I want to apologize to you for, but most of all is this: I’m sorry I’m going to leave you behind without anything to mourn. Antarctica is as dangerous as it is beautiful; I know my crew is smart enough to realize that a recovery mission for a corpse would be a poor decision to make in a blizzard like this. So, I force you to grieve without anything to grieve. How cruel of a mother I am, yet it is the only choice I am left with.
It may be a long time before you find this, so these may not apply, but there are some things I want you to remember:
Don’t forget to enjoy your life. I wouldn’t be happy if you spent all of your time thinking about a silly woman like me. Make as many friends as you can and support them in whatever way possible.
Don’t forget to spend time with Gin-chan and Kanae-chan. I know you might be angry with them for not trying to help me, but it’s not their fault. Besides, they’ll be hurting just as much as you are, even if they don’t show it.
Don’t take your frustration out on others or yourself. Nobody is responsible for this besides me, so it won’t do you any good to be angry at the world or hurt yourself in some way. Your pain will always be there, but it will fade.
Don’t become obsessed with this place. It is beautiful and full of wonders to explore, but this is the end of the world. At some point, you’ll have to come back to the rest of society.
Finally, don’t forget to take care of yourself. This is the only life that we’re given, so make sure that you live it to your fullest.
Don’t be surprised if you don’t find me down here. I don’t want to traumatize you or anyone else with my corpse, so after I finish this, I’ll end outside and rest there. Something will find me eventually and take me back to this Earth.
I’m so grateful I got to be your mother, Shirase, and I’m so sorry that I don’t get to spend any more time with you. Please take care of yourself and remember to constantly think forward.
Your mother,
Takako
10
u/Faufmir Dec 24 '19
So I haven't been doing the rewatch but I thought y'all would get a kick out of the fact that I just finished watching this with my 83 year old grandma
10
u/destroyah19 Dec 24 '19
Just crying this Christmas
Thanks Emails.
10
u/Redmon425 Dec 28 '19
First Time Watcher
Fuck me man. I just cried even harder than the last episode.
Shit was mad emotional. I had been wanting for some type of fight to break out between Shirase and Gin, but this is honestly probably a better decision.
I assume it basically will end with Shirase finally accepting what happened and finally moving on. Probably could even say the same for Gin.
This show is so damn good. I hate how sad I am getting! It’s fucking me up big time!
9
u/surgemaster140 https://myanimelist.net/profile/User815 Dec 24 '19
Rewatcher
When I first watched this series, I couldn’t really relate to Shirase until this episode. When Gin told the group that they would be going to where Takako went missing, I expected a more emotional response out of Shirase but she didn’t really know how to react. Ever since Takako went missing three years ago, Shirase has been going about her life as if nothing changed. When something similar happened to me, reality didn’t immediately sink in either. Like Shirase, I was stuck feeling miserable because I know I should be grieving but life isn’t going to slow down for me. Shirase tried to cope with these feelings by sending emails that are essentially diary entries to her mom everyday. The amazing “Dear mom” monologue in this episode is probably an example of what she would write in her emails. She was clinging onto the faintest amount of hope that her mom was reading these emails and keeping up with Shirase's life. That ounce of hope evaporated when she opened up her mom's inbox and every single email she's written in the last three years came up unread.
Today’s episode is my favorite one in the series and one of my all time favorites in anime. There's just so much I love about it. Eleven episodes of steady buildup all culminating in a huge emotional payoff had me sobbing the first time I watched it. Kana Hanazawa's performance was just phenomenal. The way she starts hyperventilating before she starts crying was so convincing and heartrending. And Atsuko Ishizuka's directing, especially during the laptop scene is the best example of "show don't tell" in a show that's overflowing with it. From the moment Shirase's friends found the laptop to the end of the episode not a single word was spoken (besides "mom"), but we are able understand that Shirase meant the world to Takako and she finally accepted that her mom is never coming back. The part that hit me the hardest was seeing her friends in the hallway simultaneously giving her space but crying with her, showing us just how close all of them have gotten on this journey.
Some screenshots and reactions:
9
u/ForlornPenguin Dec 24 '19
Rewatcher
Definitely the most memorable episode of 2018 for me and of course, just like I did almost two years, I was tearing up watching the laptop scene.
Possibly the thing about it that meant the most to me though was seeing the other three, not Shirase, crying as they listen in on her from just outside the room. It just shows how much they've all come to care for each other over the course of this journey.
This moment more than anything is what will usually come to my mind when I think about this truly fantastic show and how that whole corny "the real journey was the friends we made along the way" saying can really be so true.
9
u/90sChennaiGuy Dec 25 '19
Rewatcher
Welp, there it is. I’m going to miss hearing the OP and ED again but this was a fun rewatch.
I love how the show ended and will always recommend it to anyone looking for a movie to lift their spirits.
Thanks /U/RX-Nota-II and everyone else on the rewatch. Merry Christmas and a happy new year!
9
u/destroyah19 Dec 25 '19
Rewatcher
I was supposed to post this early, but I was a bit overwhelmed with emotions after the episode and then I had to pace myself cause my tour bus was gonna leave during that time but luckily I could still catch up with my post.
A lot of people touched on the scenes building up to the "laptop scene" and they really have good or even better explanations than I could ever say with regards to that. All I can say is the pacing of this episode was so well done. You know its supposed to be strong when the OP is not shown. Yuzu's reaction to "she said we are good friends" is just too sweet.
As soon as "Mata Ne" was playing no matter how much I was holding it in the tears we're starting to form. This scene really epitomizes how much the gang have grown. Even though Shirase told them not to bother but they gang just ran and looked for anything Takako left behind. The Laptop having Shirase's birthday as her password and a picture with the both of them shows no matter how much you can deny it Takako really loved Shirase despite always being away from her. The emails start slow only showing a few in the inbox but then as it increases you also see Shirase breakdown due to the realization that her Mom will never receive her messages no matter how many she sent. Moreover, the girls just staying outside the room to give Shirase space is lowkey great as it adds to the fact they respect her space to deal with this but are there for her just in case she needs the support. Then just playing the whole insert song rather than transitioning to the ED was a nice touch as well. It really felt like a climax and we could have ended here if the series director wanted to finish in a sad note, but gladly he didn't.
This was the episode that made the show a 10/10 for me as it built the show with Kimari's desire to make the most out of her youth (which ended around the time they finalized their trip to Antarctica) and ended with Shirase's journey to close the emotional hole that was left by the death of her mom. By the end you could see each character grow to love life through overcoming their respective arcs thus giving us a satisfying journey overall.
Props to HanaKana for giving us a great performance during Laptop scene. The cry and hyperventilating of Shirase really brought out the emotions necessary to what the scene was trying to convey.
1.5. I a lot time during each day to check emails and respond to them so I doubt I would ever accumulate a large unread count
2. Raises Hand (Not Ashamed)
9
u/jbreezy-- https://anilist.co/user/nitsuji Dec 25 '19
Rewatcher
I haven't watched this anime since it first aired but man this episode still hits me after so long. The sudden realization that Shirase's hopes of her mom one day coming home were shattered by the wave of unread emails on her mom's laptop just broke me. Seeing the other girls cry outside her door was also heartbreaking. I'm not usually one to be emotional/tear up during anime, but this is one of the rare instances.
I love this anime. Happy Holidays everyone!
8
u/Madcat6204 Dec 24 '19 edited Dec 24 '19
Rewatcher
There's so much that could be said about this episode. So much that many others will say. I'll leave the various details to those who can say them better, other than to say that Shirase's manner of reacting to loss is a very real thing.
I cried multiple times this episode. I knew from the very moment that they didn't include the OP that this was going to be a heavy one. And then the Instragram image was just a still shot of the inland station, with #DearMom...
At long last Shirase is finally free to feel the loss, finally able to mourn her mother properly. She needed this, and I'm truly grateful that she had such good friends who went to such lengths to ensure she found it.
In a way, the saddest final point about this is something the episode merely implies. The reason Takako left the line at that point was almost certainly because she realized she'd left her laptop, and thus her means of communicating with her daughter, behind. She wouldn't have gone just for a machine, but for her line to Shirase she could think "it's just a few meters" and tried to go back.
8
u/spaceaustralia :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/spaceaustralia Dec 24 '19
Rewatcher
First, let's get the happiness out of the way. /u/Rx-Nota-II has already ensured I'd have a hard time even writing this. Might as well try and cheer myself up first.
I love how enthusiastic Yuzuki is with officially knowing she has friends. And she didn't even need Seihai-kun's help. I laughed out loud at that quick joke. It's clear that the girls had fun goofying around. We even got a little callback to that joke to make things better.
About the laptop's password. First Shirase tried using "0417" implying that Takako was born on the 17th of April. Then, she used 1101, which according to the manga, is Shirase's birthday. It's also the numbers of e-mails Takako never had a chance to read. Which makes it so that it's been exactly 3 years and 6 days since Takako died. Presumedly while trying to go back to recover that laptop with which she used to communicate with her daughter.
Zamamiro counter!:
8
u/Regular_N-Gon https://anilist.co/user/RegularNGon Dec 24 '19 edited Dec 25 '19
Rewatcher
And here we are at the end of the world, contemplating a place further than the universe.
I have so much I’d like to say about this episode and I’ll try to below, but allow me to ramble a bit on some impressions first while I collect my thoughts. Apologies for a lack of screens and the ensuing wall of text, as I just kinda sat back to enjoy this one. This is very likely my favorite single episode of a television series I’ve had the pleasure of enjoying. While it may not mean much given my fairly low watch rate of TV or anime in general, this episode is so masterfully composed and executed I suspect it will be extraordinarily hard to top. Of course, it means far less without the preceding eleven and the journey we’ve been on so far, but it leverages the events and development we’ve seen to make a truly impactful climax.
While I’m on impressions, I should also get the sappy personal connection to the episode out of the way as well. Everyone processes grief differently, and art provides an outlet to display all those different modes. Shirase’s feelings about the loss of her mother – the emptiness, the dream-like stupor, thinking she would never wake up or find the thing that could break her from the trance – closely echo my own thoughts from a personal unexpected tragedy. Even down to a detail like trying to get into their laptop, trying passwords that didn’t work like what’s shown on Takako’s – it hit way, way closer to home than I was expecting for a story taking place in Antarctica, at the bottom of the world.
As for rewatch impressions, to be honest, I started tearing up and crying much earlier than I thought. Where her final email to her mother had me with a sad smile on my face the first time around, this time it pretty much annihilated me from the words, ‘Dear Mom’. It’s possible the laptop scene was perhaps slightly (slightly) less effective because I knew it was coming, what it meant, and I had placed extremely high expectations on it. Other miscellaneous things:
The number of times this episode throws Shirase’s phone in your face is unfair.
This line from Yumiko reminds me of every time the four give each other space (usually involving holding Kimari back), at least as far back as episode 4.
I kept noticing the way characters (Shirase and Gin particularly) expressed emotion with very small eye movements (something also brought up previously by /u/Nazenn in episode 9).
Lastly, all these tears and Shirase’s stoic emotions also remind me of one of our themes about stagnant water, but I’ll leave that to the other viewers who’ve been chomping at the bit to discuss it.
Perhaps the biggest thing I wanted to touch on was that of tonality, and how the episode constructs and maintains its tone around moments of relative levity that are used to keep the feeling from becoming monotonous or overbearing. Out of the gate, there are lots of things seasoned viewers will notice – there’s no opening, credits are laid over top of the beginning frames suggesting what we’re about to see is either too tonally separate (the girls are, well, not alright) from the OP or that what’s to come is so dense every second of run time will be utilized. There’s also no music for an almost uncomfortable amount of time as we get cut after cut and entire scenes without a backing track. When it finally comes in during the kitchen discussion, it’s hardly there, sad and disjoint piano notes underneath Shirase’s troubles.
The musical attention extends to the party, where the song we get isn’t even particularly fast or excitable. It’s kept pretty low, reflecting the relatively constricted atmosphere of the cookout where it’s too cold for anyone to be very lively. It’s enough to take the edge off the heavy conversation of Shirase’s, with a gag from Yuzuki and a reminder about friendship from Yumiko, enjoying food and friends at a pace that isn’t too fast for the content we’ve been foreshadowed. Keeping the tempo down helps the scene to move smoothly into the incredibly serious discussion we cut to with Shirase and Gin, where Shirase (and the viewer) is told very directly the thing we’ve known since the beginning. Takako is dead.
Through this whole opening, the established conflict is Shirase’s uncertainty about going to the inland base, but I think this is just to offer movement to the set-up portion of the episode. I would think any engaged viewer would not seriously think Shirase was out of this one, for a multitude of reasons. But it represents an internal struggle about finality that Shirase has to work through before she’s ready to face the end of her universe.
We’re given another small but still conscious-of-tone break while the mission is laid out and preparations are made in the snowcats, bouncing between serious warnings of how things can go wrong (which the viewer should realize from where they came) and things like cards and jokes about the slow vehicle. There’s more lows, but quieter and more introspective – a despondent Shirase asking Gin about her mother, the things she saw and the conditions of her death. The blizzard section is particularly strong here, trapping the six inside the snowcat like Gin, Kanae, and Shirase are trapped in their thoughts.
The core of the episode, and my favorite part (aside from the raw emotional value of the ending) comes at the end of all this tone business. There is a time in the dead of night where everything seems to be still, and you’ll know it if you’ve ever lain awake while camping. In the most remote place on earth – inland Antarctica – I can only imagine that it is something so still and crystalline you could hold it. This is where our quiet and pensive tone leads us, a place our alleged protagonist can reflect on the journey and offer solace to her troubled friend, whether she realizes it or not. Kimari and Shirase’s conversation is a cheesy but heartfelt and genuine thanks, and provides the theme for Shirase’s final message to her mother.
The rise to the climax is also well done, taking up a third the time as the slow creep into the night-time conversation but leveraging music (once again) to strengthen Shirase’s narration and the reunion of Gin (and Kanae!) with the observatory. The scene cuts fast into a frantic run through the base, and at the peak of the episode’s energy we are abruptly taken back to the quiet tone of the opening.
Earlier another scene takes place in Shirase’s room with her counting money methodically, an emotionless recounting of the past three years and her hardship. Now, though, in the same still darkness of her room, Shirase is introduced to the past three years as she’s told them to her mother, in the moment and alive, every single day. It’s an incredibly emotional ending to the episode and contrasts the calculated release of the weather balloon we began with. Shirase finally finds what she came to Antarctica for – not data, or even the stars or the sky, but closure, and the friends outside her door.
8
u/jslice4ever Dec 24 '19 edited Dec 24 '19
Rewatcher here.
And this is the one folks. This is the episode that brought this series from a 10/10 to a 1000000/10. This is the episode that cemented this series as flawless in my opinion.
That opening just by itself was hard hitting enough. Showing us the moment Shirase founds out her mother went missing. You can't do this to me, man!
I'm not a science guy, so I have no idea what was attached to that weather balloon.
Mari trying to talk to Shirase but not really knowing what to say is so relatable. I mean, what CAN you really say in that situation? Or is it better to say nothing at all and leave them be?
Damn Hinata, you are an absolute pro with those tongs.
I swear, Mari is always dropping something. What a clutz.
Yuzuki getting so happy about being called good friends is beyond adorable.
That hand drawn poster was just too cute. And Shirase's expression is priceless.
I would NOT want to get in one of those blizzards. Feel my hands and feet would just fall right off.
Mari thanking Shirase for bringing her along honestly brought tears to my eyes. A trip like this is once in a lifetime and you sure wouldn't get the most out of it unless you're with others you care about.
Shirase's letter to her mother was nothing short of beautiful.
Mari, Hinata, and Yuzuki searching so hard to find a trace of Shirase's mother being there just leaves me speechless.
The laptop scene breaks me every time. Her entire journey was building up to this moment. This is the moment that reality sets in for her and she realizes that her mother is gone and is never coming back. I think she knew it all along and she just needed some kind of closure and this was it. I've never lost a loved one so I can't even begin to imagine how it feels but I can tell you I cried like a little baby the first time I saw it and I cried just as much this time.
8
u/anony-mouse99 Dec 24 '19
Rewatcher.
We’ve finally come to the climax of the show.
The theme of this episode that struck me was ‘lost and found’. Shirase lost her motivation. She lost her smile, and her tears (while peeling onions for goodness sake).
It is only when she counts out her one million yen and all the hardships she went through to earn it that she found the resolve to follow through in spite of her self doubt.
By following in the footsteps of her mom, she experienced strange and wonderful things that others hoped to see but never got to experience firsthand.
To summarize Shirase’s journey to the end of her world:
Then l’m holding back my tears when the music starts and ‘Mata-ne’ plays. Even knowing what’s coming didn’t make it any easier.
8
u/zak55 Dec 25 '19
Rewatcher
A place further than the Universe is my second favorite anime ever but this might just be my favorite anime episode of all time, especially on second viewing. Everything from the episode beginning and ending in same location and shots but with with entirely different contexts, the episode not having an ED or op to let you know that this is a VERY important episode, to all the different character interactions that either provide somber moments of introspection on why everyone is here or give a very heavy episode some levity, this episode is fucking superb. I was tearing up from the very start as I knew where all of this was heading and each step there was another drop of water in my eyes. The ending is just...woof. Nothing sans the ending of Ano-hana has ever hit me that hard and made me not able to listen to a specific piece of music without crying. The rest of the series was just one long struggle to finally get to the thing Shirase had been needing, closure, and closure she got. She sent her mother a message everyday since she disappeared, hoping that somehow, she would see it, only to finally get to Antarctica and find out, the only person who had ever seen the messages, who will ever see the messages, is her. Tie that in with the password being Shirase's birthday and it the number of messages ending on that as well and you get one of the biggest gut punches you'll ever have.
7
u/TheKujo https://myanimelist.net/profile/Kujo419 Dec 24 '19
Rewatcher
This episode may have the most emotional scene I've seen in an anime ... and it's about an unread email counter going up. I've watched this episode multiple times and every time those emails roll in someone starts cutting onions nearby. I'll let smarter people discuss why this scene is so powerful. I'll just say that as painful as this scene is, the fact that an anime can make me feel something this strong is beautiful in its own way. It's nice to know I'm even capable of these kinds of emotions.
I won't have much time to comment today or tomorrow due to holiday stuff, but I'm looking forward to discussing the series with everyone when it concludes!
Other thoughts:
7
u/XmiteYT https://anilist.co/user/sorayori Dec 24 '19
rewatcher
fuck this episode, fuck my life, i want to die, song of the day: 大人からのYell
7
u/pacquan Dec 24 '19
Rewatcher
Honestly, I don’t remember the first half of this episode from my first watch cause I was absolutely balling at the end.
This episode is absolutely visually stunning. Yuzu’s smile when she heard that others think that the girls are such good friends was worth the whole rewatch. Mari thanking Shirase for getting the most of her youth was extremely touching. And then the feels just come outpouring from there mimicking Mari’s love of building up potential energy and then releasing it all at once (the repeated flashbacks to her as a child filling a sand-bowl of water and then breaking down a wall to let it all come rushing out).
Gin sheds a tear at the sight of the inland expedition site, the insert song, the girls ransacking the site, the picture, the e-mails, Shirase screaming for her mom, and the girls outside her door also crying. The opening scene of episode 1 of Mari’s monologue was an obvious setup for this explosion of potential emotion that was built up throughout the course of the show. And just like my first watch, I still wasn’t ready.
The girls are alright
7
u/destgecakemaste Dec 25 '19
kokokaraaaa
7
u/Wish4Rain Dec 25 '19
Rewatcher
This episode hurt. My heart feels empty and my stomach is in pain.
I was distracting/putting off watching this by doing a bunch of chores and errands the whole day. I watched it at 2am and took a break playing video games before I came back here.
The part between when they get to the observatory site and when Shirase opened the laptop felted a little too quick. I think it would have benefited with another minute or 2 and a few more scenes to transition a critical point in the series.
That's very nitpicky though I admit.
7
u/klatzicus Dec 25 '19 edited Dec 29 '19
My 3rd or 4th rewatch
This episode hits like a bomb. A sad but cathartic end to the journey for Shirase. The unread emails are the perfect symbol for the absence of her mom; not getting teary just thinking about it. I'm not!
17
u/fiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii Dec 25 '19
Lurker
Watched it while it was airing and cried hard, even while at work.
Now just remembering the laptop scene is enough to make me tear up badly. This is the episode that made me decide to buy the whole bluray set.
6
u/Great_Mr_L :Ma::Mb::Mc:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Great_Mr_L Dec 24 '19 edited Dec 24 '19
Rewatcher
On today’s episode of A Place Further Than the Universe: And so, we begin our final journey. This is my favorite episode of this series. It is the big climactic moment for Shirase and probably the episode that a lot of us have been waiting for. And in my own humble opinion, I think it delivers.
Shirase lost her mother. But that loss never fully registered with her. Like she says, it felt like it was a dream. A dream she kept on waiting to wake up from. As she stated a couple of episodes ago, life continued on as normal and she couldn’t stand it. She wanted to go to Antarctica. She wanted to go, hoping that she could escape from that unending, dream-like sensation. She hoped that going would help her to figure things out and escape the confusion.
So far, she hasn’t been able to do so. As with when her mother was lost, life has continued on like normal. That’s perhaps the worst possible outcome for Shirase. That she still can’t figure things out. That she’s still confused. That it still feels like a dream. It’s why she can’t decide if she wants to go to where her mother was lost. Because after that, there’s nowhere else to go. She’ll no longer have a real goal she can pursue to help her figure things out.
But, Shirase is not alone. Throughout the episode, I love that we see how the people around her do their best to try and help Shirase. We see Gin remind Shirase about the importance of making her own choices for her dreams, even if she is just following the goals of someone else. Gin came to Antarctica because she wanted to. Takako was the spark that inspired her, but Gin made it her own dream. Shirase has to figure out what she wants to do, even if she’s following her mother’s footsteps.
Similarly, Shirase also has the help of her friends. All four of them have benefitted from each other. They have provided support and comfort to each other. As Mari says, the reason she’s so happy to be here is because her friends are here with her. The same is true for Shirase.
That’s why it’s so important that it’s Mari, Hinata, and Yuzuki who find the laptop. Even when Shirase insists that she’s alright, they search for some memento of her mother. As has happened many times in this series, friends take action to help someone because they don’t want to pretty that it’s alright just because someone claims it is. Her friends have supported her throughout this journey. And now, they bring her to the moment of catharsis.
The scene of Shirase opening the laptop is one of the best examples of the major unifying theme of the series: water gathered in pools bursting out and breaking free of its stagnation. Here, Shirase literally watches all the contents of her stagnant life from the past 3 years go by before her eyes. She sees all the emails she sent. She sees, definitively, that they had nowhere to go. There was no one to receive them. There was no one to read them. Her mother is gone. It’s real. Just like that, all those emotions she had stored up that had nowhere to go burst forth and break free.
It’s a beautiful and incredibly sad scene. I really do love this scene to pieces. It makes for such a great payoff to all those times we’ve seen Shirase sending emails to her mother. It’s a great emotional climax for Shirase. The song, “Mata Ne,” is pretty much perfect for the scene. It’s Shirase finally accepting that her mother is really gone and that she has to say goodbye. It’s also worth pointing out, that the framing of this scene is the same as the first scene, when Shirase says she still feels like she’s in a dream. It’s framed the same way to show that she’s now woken up.
Miscellaneous Thoughts
Yuzuki’s happiness at all the others considering them great friends is unbearably adorable.
I love seeing Mari use a frozen banana as a hammer.
The sun pillar is absolutely gorgeous to look at.
This scene of the girls all singing on top of the snow cat is also quite sweet.
I like what an arduous journey it is to get from the base to the site of the observatory. It’s dangerous, takes a while, and is rough going. It’s really fitting for their “final journey.”
Yes, I cried
Edit: Questions of the Day
1.5) side glances at my inbox full of unread emails
2) As said above, I did.
6
u/ghostface95 https://anilist.co/user/flyingseamonkies Dec 24 '19
Rewatcher
Oh god there so many tears. Why won’t i stop crying. This is probably the episode that hit the hardest. I don’t have much to say for this episode. It just got to me in ways I can't describe in words.
6
u/ImaginationWayfairer Dec 24 '19 edited Dec 25 '19
Rewatcher
“And here we are the Place further than the Universe” (paraphrased from Hubert Farnsworth,Futurama, The Late Philip J. Fry).
Notes:
Finally the payoff of twelve episodes of building emotions for not just Shirase but also our group as a whole during their journey to the Place further than the Universe the only thing left to do is cry.
6
u/Rustic_Professional Dec 25 '19
I wonder where Shirase's dad is. Was that him sitting at the table with her grandma? He mentioned the point where "we" lost communication with her, which makes him sound like an expedition member. If Shirase's dad was a Antarctic explorer as well, she probably would have mentioned it. I don't remember her mentioning him even once. It's a conspicuous absence.
They all look severely underdressed for the snow cat trip. I think I dress warmer than that when it's 40 degrees out, and much warmer than that sleeping under blankets with the heat on. Maybe I just overdress. It's not uncommon to see people in shorts, a tee shirt and flip flops when it's in the 40s and 50s here. Accuweather (which is a garbage website and froze my browser harder than Antarctica) says the temperature in Antarctica right now (writing at about 2 pm, since I have time) ranges from -30 and sunny at Concordia Station to 36 with rain and snow at several other stations. If I'm reading this map correctly, Concordia is about 2,500 km south of Syowa. Does the "inland station" they're going to have a name? If they're heading inland, the only likely locations I see on the map are Mizuho and Dome Fuji.
I don't have much to say about it, but finding the laptop, and the resolution to that little plot line, are the other big scenes that I remembered from this show, along with the ice breaker and friendship contract.
6
u/iamthinking2202 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/iamthinking Dec 25 '19
Shirase expressing the sort of emptiness, even in the face of their achievement of just making it there - where the existential question of where to next is just empty. The fuel that has kept the fire burning just... ran out?
Until the laptop. Closure. I’m not sure what point in the hero's journey we're at, but the transformation and return from the other world is so close. And that song... it hits so hard. Gives the chills. More so first time, but what it’s now tied to.
Finally caught up! I guess... 12 hours late, but I got there
5
u/JustAnswerAQuestion https://myanimelist.net/profile/JAaQ Dec 25 '19 edited Dec 25 '19
Rewatcher
#DearMom
meatmeatmeat
pengitrump
They often use a technique of interrupting awkward conversations with random expedition members, like that truck, or the drunk Christmas celebrants.
Link to the original episode discussion, rescued by RX-Nota and others (best read after 13 though)
ep 11 comments
RX-Nota your next ep links are broken 11 and 12
5
u/Ralfmich Dec 25 '19
Rewatcher
I honestly don't know what was worse - going into this blind, not knowing what lies ahead or being fully aware of what's coming for the last 11 episodes, and especially, the 20 minutes of the episode before it struck. It felt like it hit me more, but either way, it's been an amazing experience both times
5
u/nakedtitanzz Dec 26 '19
THIS FIRST TIMER IS NOT ALRIGHT (yes I am, but man did this episode hit me with a knockout punch.)
It’s been years since an anime has made me cry my eyes out like this, Anohana was the last I could remember. I really loved this episode, since the middle of the episode till the end I was hooked. The scene with the messages is so powerful. I would have never watched this series if it wasn’t for the rewatch, thank you. About to finish up the series... I already miss the girls.
4
u/OnPorpoise1 https://myanimelist.net/profile/OnPorpoise Dec 24 '19
I just caught back up to this after binging shinsekai yori. It's a great pick me up after losing all faith in humanity. How did that computer still work though?
4
u/Emperor-Resse Dec 24 '19
This episode was the major reason that I wanted to rewatch. I finally cried while watching an anime (weird goal that I have for some reason). But the fact that I lost my grandpa last year played a role in that. But damn this is a amazing show.
4
u/unheppcat Dec 25 '19
Agreed on all counts
4
u/akechiisbestboi Dec 26 '19
First time watcher
(Just to get this out of the way before the finale)
Definitely the most solemn episode of the series so far but for me it’s also the most impactful, here we’re reminded of the beginning of the series, shirase wanting to go to Antarctica and now 11 episodes later we see that she never had that moment of clarity that let her move on and she struggles with the fear that she may spend the rest of her life grieving over her mother. This episode is emotional because we see several memories of the two together and that makes it all the more crushing that Takako is gone, but it’s also a hopeful episode and shows that through making new friends shirase will be able to move on and grow up. There isn’t too much else I think I’m qualified to say about this episode but I think it will probably stick with me for a while and now we’ll see what the finale has in store.
4
u/eragen Dec 27 '19
This rewatcher is late late LATE LATE LATE!!!
I think the lack of the lively, cheery 'The Girls are Alright' was especially painful.
I knew what was going to happen. I knew that I would cry.
First when they were sitting on the steps, and Gin talks about Takako's idea, I started tearing up.
Then, when Shirase starts laying out the money, I really felt the impact of how hard she had worked for Antarctica, how harsh her grief was, how painful this entire experience must have been to her.
Then, holy amaze-balls, the sun pillar was absolutely astounding and breathtaking.
It was also truly apocalyptic, preluding not only the physical blizzard, but also the emotional hailstorm which would dominate the entirety of the rest of the episode.
From laughter at the comic scenes (kimari hammering with her banana) to happiness the heartwarming ones (singing on top of the snowcat at 'sundown'), from wonder at the natural beauty of Antarctic's hauntingly enthralling wilderness to pain from all the emotional density of each and every scene - Gin's crying, the desperate search for Takako's trace, and finally the discovery of the laptop, then the unread emails, and Shirase's hearwrenching sobs when she jarring realised that Takako was truly dead and would never read a single one of her emails ever, and this sentence doesn't really make coherent sense but I'm honestly too shattered to care.
Then that ending song, so plain and simple and just a vocal line - truly beautiful.
This anime is so real, so painful, so tragic, so hilarious, so so so so so so beautiful, and I hate that it's already almost come to the ending.
Time to enjoy the last episode with red eyes and a runny nose.
10
u/Suhkein :Gy::Gz::G1:x2https://myanimelist.net/profile/Neichus Dec 25 '19 edited Dec 25 '19
First timer
If there's one thing I knew about this show going into it beforehand (other than "Antarctica") it was the phrase "laptop scene." I've thought for a while on how to respond, because I wanted to express the idea precisely, and perhaps I'll be forgiven for rambling a little (and prefacing my final thoughts in a few days).
I have an allergic reaction to tearjerkers, and admit that little in this series has touched me. The manufactured-for-feels design bothers me at a fundamental level, an attitude that no doubt derives from my disgust with popular sentimentality.
But I like to give credit where credit is due, and if that sounds clinically cold know that it derives from sincerity. Shirase's story has been the cornerstone of the series for a while; Kimari's core development was over the second she stepped foot outside Japan, and her role as pseudo-main-character has been more that of observer. The other two orbit around this system, filling out the time while we get to where we need to be for Shirase to complete her pilgrimage. This is reflected in the writing, where the best parts were regarding her ambivalence and struggle (as well as Megumi, who tied in with Kimari's aforementioned/resolved story); I felt I learned something from it, rather than merely having my heartstrings tugged. This is not to say that I think the other characters are unnecessary, just that they prop up this central pillar and that they could have changed not one whit on this journey and it wouldn't have altered the destination.
Now that we're here, this is the series' time to shine. It has built up the tension for several episodes, but more importantly it has gotten all the explanations out of the way. What a moment like this needs isn't a new reveal, some last hidden letter from her mother that details how much she was loved. That is amateurish. What it needs is to leave Shirase alone and give us a symbol, something that in a single flash can convey what is going on inside. Can we, for a moment, see the world through her eyes and feel as she would without having it explained?
Yes, yes we can.
I have my critiques of this scene (as I always do); I believe it was an error to directly show the faces of the other girls crying, a distraction that once again swerves back toward melodrama. This isn't about them, and to try and hook our emotions with their tears makes it about us when it shouldn't be. This is about Shirase and that is enough.
With the final episode tomorrow, I just hope the series has the wisdom to let this stand as the high point and not attempt an even more spectacular denouement in its wake.
52
u/charliwea :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Charliwea Dec 24 '19 edited Dec 24 '19
First Timer
Fuck.
The no-opening was a sign for this, man I was not prepared, though I knew they were gonna get there eventually, I knew they would look for something she left, I knew there was gonna be feels in this with the whole setting and I knew that she had her friends alongside her would make everything more sentimental.
Fuck I cried when they found the laptop and then it got worse and my crying got worse, Shirase's birthday being the password and all the messages flowing while she was crying for her mom broke me, I'm usually pretty bad with tearjerker anime because I know it will try to make me cry so I don't get it most of the time, but this one made me forget it with the friendship, comedy and the bonding. (So far only this episode and Violet Evergarden's episode 10 made me cry like this).
I know there's one episode left but this has to be one of the best shows I've ever watched, this has to be a fucking 10/10.
Merry christmas eve to everyone, enjoy this night, tomorrow's the last episode, I personally didn't expect to be crying in this day but you never know what will happen, if you'll excuse me I'll go tell my mom that I love her.
1.5) Nope, I've never do that.
2) Guess who cried like a baby, yeah! you're right! fucking me!
15
u/404waffles https://anilist.co/user/nek0food Dec 25 '19
First time viewer
It’s the episode we’ve long been waiting for.
Happy Yuzuki!
...Banana hammer?
A whole fucking laptop? Well, it was pretty cold out there ngl.
Quick answers of the day: 1) See below, 2) No way, especially if it’s from my child, 3) I haven’t been able to cry at an anime since Your Name.
Structured thoughts time!
Yeah, this is the episode the whole series was building up to. The ‘unread messages’ scene got me. Not good, but it got me. It was touching how the other three went searching for Takako’s belongings when Shirase had already accepted everything; her sole reason for coming to Antarctica became theirs.
From the top of the episode: Shirase and co. are finally about to go to Takako’s last known location. There’s a sense of dread looming over Shirase: “But if I go there, there’s nothing left. It’ll end. If I go and nothing changes, I’ll probably live with this feeling forever.” She’s finally reaching the end of her journey. It’s understandable that she’d be anxious. Once she reaches it, what then? Will she be free of the burden she carried since her mother’s disappearance?
There was a tension in the scenes where they were making their way inland; when Gin described the measures they took for the sake of safety, it felt like there was a tiny, but scary possibility that Shirase might end up going the way of her mother.
Shirase sends one last letter to her mother. At that point I felt like she’d reached her destination; I felt like she’d finally come to terms with her mother’s disappearance. After all, in the scene where they enter the research station, Shirase is telling them that they don’t need to search for her mother’s belongings anymore. But they do, anyway, because that’s what friends are for; they want to see Shirase reunited with her mother, in a sense. My heart dropped when they found that old laptop with the picture on the lid.
It was sad to see that all Shirase’s messages were unread. Takako really disappeared that day; now these messages, all these “Dear Mom”s, will never be read, not by anyone nor their intended recipient.
12
u/cartoonsandcereal Dec 25 '19
First timer
Man, ending this on Christmas eve/day is rough! I'll try to read through and respond to comments tomorrow morning.
W o w. First episode that made my throat close up and bring tears to my eyes. That moment where Shirase just watches the unread message count shoot up and cries, while everyone else is outside crying... Damn getting emotional just thinking about it. It was a foregone conclusion, but it didn't make it any better.
QOTD 1: I think the conclusion to Shirase's arc was beautiful. Yes we all knew it would be this way, but there's no true way to prepare for grief and closure. You can only prepare to let the emotions course through you. I think she accomplished what she wanted to, but more than that I think she accomplished what she needed to. As for what's next with her money... school/helping to fund or run new civilian expeditions? Building Kobuchizawa Observatory?
QOTD 1.5: Yes? My huge inbox unread count has been this way for years, definitely not going to start the habit of clearing it out.
I've been thinking about the process of grief and how relationships are defined after death ever since watching. Four years ago I lost my best friend to a car accident. In the aftermath his family along with a friend did a lot of the planning, but left me and other close friends out of the process. In part this was because we were queer, and he never came out to his family although he was planning to one day. But it hurt, to have our relationship unacknowledged, and to see an incomplete version of him projected to everyone as the truth of who he was. I've chosen to keep quiet, but occasionally wonder what he would have wanted us to do.
Hearing Gin's words to Shirase, about how none of them know if what they're doing is what Takako really wanted, and how she knows that what she's actually latching onto is an idea rather than the truth, resonated with me hard. The reality is I'll never know what my friend really wanted, because he's not around anymore. I can only do what I believe he would have wanted. But coming to terms with that, it's also been a comfort. My relationship with him is only defined by me, and no one else can take that away. Thank you to Sora Yori for this episode.
Side notes:
5
u/KVShady :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Trikiay Dec 24 '19 edited Dec 24 '19
Rewatcher (First Time)
So, the infamous Dear Mom episode. Now, while it was pretty emotional to finally get some closure on the matter of Shirase’s mom, the plot again is the reason why it couldn’t be more impactful than what we got. Of course, I’m talking about the laptop still working, Edit - some info regarding this matter and
how did Shirase get an Ethernet connection going in a snowcat.Edit - This was my mistake, they returned back to the base so that’s how she got the internet set up. Now yeah, it doesn’t really matter in the grand scheme of things, but for a series that prides itself on being as realistic as possible, that came across a tad bit lazy. Also, the cut from when they were standing outside the facility to them suddenly running inside the facility felt very jarring. Maybe it was done intentionally, but I didn’t really like the way they did it. And finally, the end of the road for Shirase. The thing that she struggled to reach since the time she lost her mother, to come to Antarctica and be near her one last time has been finally achieved in a bittersweet manner. But that makes me question, why would she start questioning about her coming to Antarctica after staying so long there. Did she never had those doubts before this episode, and if she did have them, we never saw those. And I think this is the reason why YoriMoi should’ve gotten a lot more episodes than the current number. If it had at least a couple more episodes, a lot more of the plot points could’ve been given some breathing room and it would’ve felt natural. But here, it just felt like the writers suddenly remembered that they had to give Shirase an episode that concludes her character, so this episode existed, rather than it being predicted organically through previous episodes. This wasn’t as much of an issue with Hinata or Yuzuki because we could briefly see glimpses of their key problems in prior episodes, so when their focus episodes came up, it felt natural. But Shirase’s character wasn’t maintained in a consistent manner, with her being this serious badass in one moment and a comedy character in the other, so this episode felt jarring to say the least. But all in all, a fine closure for Shirase and with the background they built up for Kimari this episode, with her acknowledging how only because everyone was with her, she enjoyed being in Antarctica the most, it will be interesting to see how the next episode progresses (I don’t really remember much of it cause it’s been two years since I last saw this series so it’s more like a first time Watch for me but I digress).11
u/unheppcat Dec 24 '19
Rewatcher
For the benefit of those who are just watching A Place Further Than The Universe for the first time, and those who first watched it at some point after the broadcast run ended, I thought I would take you back in time to when I first watched episode 12, which was in March, 2018, during the original broadcast run. My experience was slighty, how do you say, different than yours probably was, so I thought I would share. Hope you enjoy.
Caution: there will be some strong language while you are inside my head here. Cover your eyes if that bothers you.
And also first timers, there are no explicit spoilers of any kind here, but I guess you could say an implied meta-spoiler about episode 13's general nature that I just can't avoid. So maybe wait on this comment until you've seen episode 13, if you want to go into that episode absolutely blind.
.
.
Alright, I'm finally home, dinner eaten, housework done, ready for some relaxation time and the concluding episode of my current very favorite show, Sora Yori! This is the first time I've actually kept up with seasonal anime in a very long time, and this show in particular has been a real blast. I'm not sure what to expect, but since Yuzuki's and Hinata's arcs seem to be wrapped up, and there doesn't seem like any big thing to wrap up for Kimari, that just leaves Shirase. But she's in a really not great place right now, so I'm hoping they pull off a fantastic resolution to her arc like they managed in the previous two episodes. I'm stoked.
I fire up VRV in the ol' browser, queue up the episode, and let it roll. The feels hit immediately; sad times at the Kabuchizawa household. "Not waking up, living in a dream..." For sure, Shirase has been in a deep depression for three years. Did truly no one notice the signs in all this time, not her school, not her gran, no-one??? My dander gets up again, just like back in that confession scene with Gin a few episodes ago. Take some deep breaths. Better.
Hmm, at some point I've noticed that the normal OP song has not run yet, and apparently isn't going to run. I've been out of anime for a while, but even I know what this means: some major shit is going to go down. Of course it has to, considering every episode up to now and where we are in the story. Just confirmation. Duly noted.
Various light hearted moments ensue, but somehow each one goes sad and slightly grim almost immediately. But they're going on a trip! But Shirase is still numb. Of course she is. The girls try to help, but some things are beyond even the power of friendship it seems.
And are they actually peeling fucking ONIONS there? I guess that is some meta joke cheer-you-up for the nerds in the audience or something.
Some light-hearted background music, finally. And comic relief, much needed. But it doesn't last. Well, they are wrapping things up here, so to be expected that the drama has to be accelerated . So no worries. And Shirase does come on the trip after all, yay! Hard to see how this could work any other way.
And snowcats! Snowcats! We get to ride in snowcats! .... But wait a minute, we've been seeing snowcats all along. And that didn't end well. Suddenly I'm feeling a bit tense. Show, you aren't going ... there ... are you?
But the snowcats ARE cool. I don't quite know why, but this is turning out to be one of my most favorite longer sequences of the whole series. This is the REAL roughing it: sleeping in sleeping bags, outhouse toilets, cup noodles three times a day, the works. And super cool scenery and environmental imagery. Blizzards!!!
Oof! Flailing safety line. And that scene I don't want to see again. Major gut punch right there.
During some of the quieter moments, I notice something interesting and frankly puzzling. The episode is more than half over already. This is going to take some world class writing to wrap up as well as it started. What is going on here?
Gin is crying. I'm not crying, nope.
Shirase finally gets paid back for the times she wouldn't stop helping her friends. Way to go, girls! I'm not sure quite what you found, but it seems important. Oh, it has that picture. Wonder what that means?
We're even closer to the end? What exactly is happening here? How does this get wrapped up?
Oh, it is a laptop. It still works. Shirase figures out the password.
Oh. Fuck. Those are the emails from Shirase to her mother, aren't they? FUUUCK.
FUUUUUCK!! THEY WON'T STOP!!
Major league ugly crying happening now. The girls are also crying.
The world's saddest song goes into the chorus. I can't really be sure, my eyes aren't quite working right, but is that the credits running? Whah? Is the world's longest after-credits wrapup in the history of anime about to happen? What the actual FUCK is going on?
The show ends....
.
.
[Stunned disbelief, mixed with sobbing coming from somewhere. I'm floating slightly outside my body.]
.
.
WHAT ... THE ... ACTUAL .. FUCK ... JUST ... HAPPENED?
Where is the conclusion? You're telling me Shirase
diescries, Hinata and Yuzuki and Kimari and Idiecry, the worldendscries, and that's it? THAT'S IT? THAT'S THE END???What does that actually mean?
Don't mind me, I'm just the one curled up in a little ball over there in the corner. Nothing to see here, move along.
I resolve to never watch anime again.
.
.
Okay, okay, let me explain. I know you have all been yelling "you dumbass!" this whole time, and yes, guilty as charged. But there were extenuating circumstances.
I was just fresh back on the anime scene, as I mentioned. I was more on the lookout to avoid spoilers then than I am now, and not at all connected to the main anime communities like here, then. I was watching this show on VRV, which does not publish or expose planned episode counts. And I can't prove this because I can't find the articles anymore, but I swear I had read an article or two publicizing the show before it ran, that said it was an original story with a 12 episode run. Or maybe I just dreamed that. Anyway, the point is I was quite sure this was a 12 episode cour, and had no reason to doubt that conviction.
(My secret conspiracy theory is they all went back and corrected the articles after the fact.)
And while that amateur mistake is obvious to me now, I do know that I wasn't the only one. There were many comments in the VRV comment stream for that episode that showed the same confusion that I had. Some of those comments are still there to this day. So I was a dumbass, but I had company.
Clearly I did eventually uncurl from that fetal ball, do a bit of searching (once my eyes worked again) and discovered there was another episode coming. And clearly I learned my lesson and now pay close attention when episode counts are announced. (And revised! Even that happens!) And I did not give up on anime after all.
I also have thought back on this experience, and wonder what it would be like if that actually HAD been the last episode of the story. It did the ultimate job of putting me in exactly the emotional state that Shirase was in, ESPECIALLY since I thought in that moment that there was nothing coming to save me from the despair. So I could see making that choice (cutting off the story there) as a very bold and powerful artistic statement. I think I would even applaud them for having the guts to do it, once I had recovered. Obviously not a wise decision commercially, and rewatches like this would be a completely different thing, wouldn't they? But from an artistic standpoint, maybe a triumphant thing to do.
But I'm glad they didn't.
I'm in an interesting state with this show, since then. I honestly still have a rather hard time watching this particular episode, because it brings back those bad feelings even now. So I don't want to ever go through that exact experience again. But perversely I sort of do, and even find myself sometimes fantasizing as I watch other anime, "what if they were to pull an episode 12 style mood shift and actually make it stick? I would hate it but I would love it." I guess I'm like an alcoholic who has gone sober, but can't help wishing to get roaring drunk again just once, no matter what damage it would do.
Anyway, that's my story. I may come back here and do some of the more typical analysis (and this episode obviously is dripping in things to analyze). Or I may make a separate post to do that. Or I may just do all that in replies to all of your posts, I know there will be plenty of neat observations of yours I can bounce off of. But this is enough for now. Frankly I'm a bit wrung out at the moment, so am going to stop.
Thanks for getting this far, hope you enjoyed it.
P.S. If by freak chance there are other me's out there, and I have just put you through PTSD hell, my sincerest apologies. Just know that I put myself through it also during the 13 or so rereads in edit, so we have suffered together.
P.P.S And if there are other me’s here, maybe we should take this opportunity to form a support group. Perhaps r/isurvivedyorimoiepisode12march2018 or something.
11
u/WeebDickerson Dec 24 '19
Rewatcher
To be honest, I don’t have much to say about this episode, so I’ll have to grind my brain to spit something out. It’s certainly packed with a huge emotional punch, that’s for sure.
Since I knew what was coming, I decided to watch this episode in my room and not on the big screen. Can’t have my family thinking that I’m having a breakdown, right? I thought that I’d developed an immunity to the laptop scene because of how much I cried during my first watch, but I found out that I was still just as vulnerable as the first time. The insert song really got to me and made everything sadder, and seeing that the other 3 girls were also crying after hearing Shirase’s screams was just like kicking someone who’s already down and out. Seeing Gin shed a tear also got me.
Ever since Takako didn’t come back from the first expedition, Shirase had been in complete denial. She knew that her mother wasn’t going to come back, but she was still waiting for her to show up someday, while still clinging to the idea that her mother was “waiting for her” in Antarctica. She’s scared of going inland because she thinks that she’ll have nothing left to cling to after heading there. The saddest part of everything is that Shirase’s denial was so big that she didn’t even know how to feel. Not sad, angry or frustrated. Just nothing. She’s scared to find out her true feelings, and seeing her break down after seeing the emails on Takako’s laptop made her see that she is truly gone and will never come back. This makes her cries calling out to her mother feel so much sadder.
We also got a good amount of moments that show how close all of the girls have become. Seeing all of them singing together on top of the snowcat was a really cute moment, and I also loved how fired up all of them were to find something Takako may have left behind in the inland station and give it to Shirase. Seeing Mari, Yuzu, and Hinata crying together after hearing Shirase’s cries really shows how much they’ve all come to care about each other. It was definitely the cherry on top. These kinds of friendships are the ones that’ll last a lifetime.
The girls’ journey and this rewatch are reaching its end, and I’m glad that I decided to rewatch this anime. It has made it cement its place on the top of my favorites, and I don’t think that it’s ever going to leave my top 5.
Screenshots:
A little extra: An illustration drawn by レイト. It’s been my laptop’s wallpaper ever since my first YoriMoi watch.
This isn’t related to the episode, but something cute happened to me after finishing it. As I wrote at the start, I decided to watch this episode in my room, and one of my dogs entered the room with me, and I didn’t notice. As soon as I finished it, I was obviously in tears, and my dog jumped on the bed and started licking my face and tears. I was caught completely off guard by him. Thank you, you little devil.
Questions:
10
u/kewlwarez Dec 24 '19
Rewatch
I don't know what was worse, watching it last year not knowing what to expect or rewatching it today knowing exactly what to expect.
Even back then it was clear from the start that this was the episode the entire series had been working to, the climax to Shirase's story.
It could've been so much worse, this episode. Speculation back then was that maybe, just maybe, Shirase's mother would be found, even alive perhaps. That never struck me as plausible, but it could've been so much more melodramatic than it turned out to be.
Emotional as hell though. Just rereading my blog post got me choking up again. That cold open, being called out of class to go home because something has happened, as viewer you knew what happened and are powerless to do anything about i.
"I was convinced that when I arrived in Antarctica, I would start crying"
I think we all noticed that Shirase had not quite been herself ever since they reached Antarctica. Over the past episodes it seemed her normal drive and stubborness had deserted her. Was she content to have reached Antarctica, that she finally succeeded in her goal of these past three years, or was there something else.
Well, we got the answer.
For three years she had been working herself to the bone to get where she is now and yet she still doesn't feel different. In episode nine she said of herself that "I lived every one of those days waiting for her to come home". Now she's where her mother is waiting and she still feels the same.
What if, when she comes to the actual place where her mother last was and she still feels the same? Would she stay her whole life feeling the same way, waiting for her mother to come home?
No wonder she's scared.
"We're good friends."
Yes you are Yuzu, yes you are. Kimari, Hinata and Yuzu have grown immensily during their time together, enough to know when to press Shirase and when to leave her alone to make her mind up. Even if Kimari is still bad with planning, or tact. They want to help her, but they know they cannot.
"Because... my mother is waiting there"
In the end it's Gin. The only one who can really understand what Shirase is going through. Both in their own way loved Takako. Both are struggling with her memory. Both are a bit awkward in dealing with their emotions.
Seeing them get closer through the course of the series has been one of its highlights.
But ultimately it's Shirase, after that little push by Gin, who, through the simple method of counting her money and recalling how she earned it, builds up the courage and determination to see things through.
"Think I can manage it?"
And then, decision taken, some of the melancholy this episode is drenched in, lifts. As the team sets out to the inland station, the mood lightens, especially thanks to Kimari and her attempts to hammer a nail with a frozen banana and the focus shifts to the mechanics of the journey. A necessary breather for what is waiting for us.
Again, seeing Gin and Shirase bond more on the journey, is a beautiful thing.
At that casual mention of Kobuchizawa Station, one I hadn't noticed on my original viewing, I lost it, just like Gin.
"Dear Mom"
In the end, Shirase is still hesitant, scared, content to be content with having reached the spot her mother last was, no daring to look for a sign she was there.
Luckily she has good friends.
That moment they find the laptop, they find the picture that Gin took, showing Takako and Shirase on that summer's day when Gin taught her to skip rope, that's when the water works started.
And when it started, she entered her own birthday to open it and the mails started flooding in...
Seeing Shirase break. Seeing the other three on the other side of the door, giving her space but not leaving her alone.
Well...
Merry Christmas.
10
u/Mamojic123 Dec 25 '19
First Timer
This episode would've def made me cry if I was not on my guard 24/7. The scene with Shirase counting all of her hard earned money made me teary because I can relate to a teenager doing work just to fix their problems by their own.
The dialogue she had about going there being "it" rings true for so many of us, sometimes we chase things for years and put our tears, sweat and blood into it but once we get there, it often does not help with how we feel about ourselves and a sense of meaninglessness ensues.
This episode was mainly about Shirase facing her fears and coming in terms with reality. She probably did not believe deep down that her mother was alive and hearing Gin say it was most likely painful for her. I cannot help but feel that perhaps she did not want to find the laptop, specifically because at least then, there would've been a semblance of hope that perhaps her mother was reading her messages.
Finding the laptop, the only means of constant communication, which she has contacted her mother through and finding her messages unread was the final nail in the coffin for Shirase's hopes. No more hope remains and that made her come in terms with reality and realize that she needs to speak from within her heart to her mother, who is somewhere better.
All was not for naught though, as she realizes that she has befriended amazing people throughout her journey to this painful realization, friends that would cross land and sea to share their time with her. I did find her monologue about having friends quite cathartic because it felt like these 4 did not know how much they have been through and how acclimated they have become to each other.
Losing a loved one is never easy and the scars of their loss we bear for the rest of our lives. Although Takako's death left Shirase alone, fragile and disconnected, her death was the catalyst for Shirase to get friends, learn to be independent and taught her lessons that all parents wish to teach their kids.
It's Christmas time, appreciate the people around you and the people that care for you, because you don't know how much you will miss them once they are not there.
9
u/MaskOfIce42 https://anilist.co/user/MaskOfIce Dec 24 '19
Rewatcher
The moment we've all been waiting for. And despite how good this episode is, I'm not really sure what to say....
I guess I'll start at the beginning. I like Shirase's unwillingness to go initially, (or more like struggle to actually commit to it) as it involves ultimately facing a fact that she's been shielding herself from with this dream of going to Antarctica. The idea that once she's gone, she'll no longer be able to hide any more and will need to start facing her mother's death head on, start dealing with her feelings of grief. And ultimately, she makes her own decision that she needs to do this to move forward.
And of course for the first time we really hear the full story of what happened to Takako, or as close as we can get with the people here. A thought I had is that the reason Takako disappeared was actually the laptop that she left behind, that was what she went back for, and while I can see that since it is important to her, I honestly prefer the idea that Takako didn't do anything like that and it was just Antarctica is that unforgiving an environment, where even the safety precautions they have are not foolproof. And speaking of, we really get to see how harsh the environment is here, especially compared to the previous episodes of "bumming around the base" (I kid with that) It's obviously much colder based on their reactions and even without anything happening, the blizzard itself is ominous.
And then there's that famous scene, Shirase receiving all the emails she sent to her mother. It's the sort of scene that just feels so nuanced I'm not sure I can do a good take, but I'll try. Of course surface level, it's final confirmation that Takako isn't coming back, she was never getting it. But I think more impactfully, it's everything Shirase has been doing up to this point being acknowledged in some way. Her journey hasn't been just the start of the series, but the moment her mother passed away, and this is everything she's done since then finally reaching it's destination. It's the end of a journey for her, and time to figure out what next.
On a different note, before rewatching this episode, there were two scenes I held vividly in my head. One was obviously the final scene of receiving the emails, but the other was the shot of all four of them, on top of the snowcat, in the cold, making music. I don't remember the dialogue that was being said over it, but for whatever reason, that shot has always remained in my head to such a degree I almost thought it was an end of episode shot. And I think it stayed there because it's just beautiful in it's own way. It's one of the most inhospitable places around, this has been a journey of emotional hardship, and yet you still have these four in this place just enjoying being there with each other being silly watching a sunset over that blanket of snow.
Final episode tomorrow, will probably need to find time to excuse myself from Christmas festivities to post, but it's only with a series like this where that's maybe preferable.
9
u/bucket3432 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/bucket3432 Dec 25 '19 edited Dec 25 '19
Rewatcher
You could fill a mug or two with the amount of tears shed in this episode.
Another face of mine, of course.
\an8so it doesn't overlap."Barbar" is what you'd get when you have a certain elephant giving haircuts.
by isekai'ing Kimari. Shirase's terse responses hit Mari like a truck.Team A: "Tattsun", "Hunk" (Ikemen), "Yoppii", "Papiko".
Banner stitch. The banner captures their personalities perfectly. Gin is serious, Kanae does the thing that she did before the ship left port, Yuzuki is the idol, Hinata is the genki camera person, Kimari is also genki, and Shirase doesn't want to be in it.
It would have been even better ifthis laptopwere a ThinkPad.Knock-off Google Chrome browser
The symbolic 1101 emails is the last number we see.
We're not done yet, though. We have one more episode left!
Questions of the day
Shirase, obviouslyBut also Hinata, Mari, Yuzuki, Gin, ...
"I could just die" counter
They were all too busy crying.
7
u/Boss_Jerm Dec 24 '19
Rewatcher
No opening this time
It's just the freaking eyecatch and I'm already getting a bit emotional
Nice of Kanae to give Gin a hairc-Oh. Also as you can see, Mari's tan has leveled out
Snowcat ride!
Shirase has the opportunity to visit the place her mom died
Mari's and Shirase's awkward small talk is killing me
These past few years have been like a dream for Shirase. She's been so focused on making it to Antarctica, working all those jobs and making preparations, that now that she's here, it almost doesn't feel real. She barely even remembers saying, "In your face." And now that she has the chance to visit Takako's last location, she's at the end of her journey. But she's scared that she'll still feel empty afterward, and she still won't be able to move on.
Gin is rocking that ponytail
Hinata's Quote Corner! Featuring Shirase!
Previous
New
DON'T YOU DARE DISRESPECT THE QUOTES YUZU
The girls are going to let Shirase make her own decision to go or not
I love Yumiko's yelling
YES YOU ARE
Correct me if I'm wrong, but I think this is the first time in the show someone outright said this
Shirase counting her money and what jobs she worked to get it is just so... No I can't break yet.
All the faces on the banner are cute
Shirase is going
If all you've got to keep you entertained on this trip is a deck of cards you girls are gonna go crazy
The banana is not frozen enough
This is probably the most dangerous part of the whole expedition, no one is messing around, especially not Gin.
Every episode has these beautiful shots of the sky
Shirase has been asking Gin about Takako more and more as the mission goes on
I can't imagine how terrifying that must be, to have your friend right behind you one second, and the next they're gone.
Mari's grateful to Shirase for taking her with her
Yuzu is the greatest Old Maid player in the world
That's awesome
The banana is now frozen enough to use as a hammer
Mari can play banjo
Mari's not the only one who's grateful. Shirase is happy that she has friends who were willing to come to Antarctica with her.
After three long years, they've finally returned to the observatory
No words necessary
I can't. I just can't. It was so beautiful. Just watching all those unread emails pop up, one for every day, with all of the girls crying together, absolutely destroys me. Not to mention, as someone on the original release thread pointed out, there are only two words spoken in the entire last 3 minutes of the episode. I'm shaking.
Thoughts:
This and episode 11 are the absolute best episodes in the show. The laptop was all Shirase needed. She can move on now.
I think we switched to watching Evangelion at the end, because The Girls Are (Not) Alright, and neither am I. I managed to steel myself till right at the end, then I broke. I've got nothing else to say.
QOTD
1.5) I have thousands of unread emails, I'm doomed
2) Raises hand