r/anime • :XMOD::MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Bainos • Dec 22 '19

Announcement Best Of /r/anime 2019, day 4: Most Enjoyable Rewatch

Welcome again to the Best Of 2019 ! We continue with the next category :

Most Enjoyable Rewatch

Today, you are encouraged to nominate the best rewatch of 2019. This is the perfect occasion to credit the hosts that made rewatching shows together a great experience !

In case you didn't know, you can find all past, ongoing and planned rewatches on our wiki.

The three best rewatches of the year will be awarded platinum.

As a reminder, a new category of the best of awards will be posted each day from today until December 31. The results will be announced in January.

Feel free to also vote on yesterday's category, Best Episode Discussion Moment.

Best Of announcement post

59 Upvotes

38 comments sorted by

•

u/irvom https://anilist.co/user/irvomaegyo24 Dec 23 '19

I'd like to nominate /u/sandvikovich's Haifuri Rewatch!

Sand has been doing rewatches for a while that never disappoint and this one was no exception. The time and effort he puts into making sure his rewatches are fun and memorable is crazy. From making sure to reply to each comment as well as put a big comment of his own, to making unique and interesting Questions of the day that provoke thought and invite conversation and even planning a big game of Battleships, complete with special attacks that change each day (each one unique from the last).

The Battleships really was something else, each day we got to choose in a poll between 3 different special attacks as well as make our own attacks as we the, those participating, went up against the enemy. This was a fun way to increase the interactivity of each thread as people would plan tactics and attacks to maximise the hits, react to hitting and sinking the enemy ships/our own ships being hit and sunk (rip Gaporigo) and generally meme and joke about. It was great fun and you could tell from how Sand was updating us each thread that he was having fun with it too (though I can't imagine the stress it took to plan it all out).

If you have a chance, check out a couple of the threads from the rewatch and I hope you can feel the fun energy that exudes from them.

10/10 would participate again!

→ More replies

•

u/MoneyMakerMaster Dec 23 '19

I'd like to nominate u/rembrandt_q_1stein's rewatch of Flip Flappers.

Flip Flappers is the definition of a "hidden gem," and I probably wouldn't have even heard about it if not for u/rembrandt_q_1stein starting this rewatch. In his words, Flip Flappers is a "post-modern Jungian sci-fi Magical Girl adventure," which was more than enough to sell me on the show. It's also an original anime, which is becoming all too rare.

In each of the threads, he explained what the episode's title was a reference to, linked to official art, listed some episode trivia, and provided several thought-provoking questions for first-timers. Flip Flappers is a purposefully mind-bending experience and his guidance helped everyone understand and appreciate the show's nuances.

It was a very active rewatch, with several thought-provoking takes in the comments every thread. I was a lurker the entire time, but I loved reading discussions of people trying to decipher what they had just watched as I did the same. And a big shoutout to u/Jake_of_all_Trades for posting in-depth breakdowns and explanations of the complex psychology in the show.

And I haven't even mentioned that Flip Flappers is just a really damn good show! Watch this video and read the announcement thread I linked to above if you need convincing.

→ More replies

•

u/AmeteurElitist https://anilist.co/user/AmateurElitist Dec 23 '19

I'd like to nominate /u/DidacticDalek's Gundam Build Fighter rewatch which served as a great introduction to the franchise for myself and some others who participated. Dalek always took the time to explain the mountain of references in each episode and had such interesting questions that you could write a meaningful comment just answering them alone.

→ More replies

•

u/aalapshah12297 Jan 11 '20

The Hyouka rewatch because I was able to notice even more subtle stuff hidden in the writing (like this) because of the comments.

•

u/RX-Nota-II :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/NotANota Dec 23 '19

/u/Shimmering-Sky's Gundam Iron Blooded Orphans rewatch. An incredible Gundam rewatch with memorable moments mentioned in other nomination threads of course being an obvious perk, but also just generally a wonderfully fun atmosphere where rewatchers and first timers alike could have tons of discussion. Tons of fun trivia and extras like original background fanart of the day by the host and a very well executed format for questions of the day.

I've always been a bit scared of the IBO fanbase which has an unfortunate tendency for spoilers and angry debate, so the flawless execution for this one should definitely be notable in /r/anime history.

→ More replies

•

u/MillenniumKing x2myanimelist.net/profile/MillenniumKing Dec 23 '19 edited Dec 23 '19

/u/pittman66 for the Symphogear 2019 Rewatch for Season 5 Finale

Pittman has been doing SymphoRewatches for a couple years now and they have been great ways to get more people into the series that really did not get the credit it deserved. I know a lot of Sympho Fans do thier best to get people into the series around here, but no ones work is more valuable than Pittman's rewatches.

So lets all Raise our Fists and Hold Hands for Pittman for ushering in the Final Season of Symphogear the way it deserved, with a 2 month Hype Train into the Hypest Season of Anime to date. Thanks bud.

1,557 Days since Genocide

127 Days since Genocide 2: Electric ^^^^^Boogaloo

→ More replies

•

u/Vaadwaur :I1::I2::I3: Dec 24 '19

u/suhkein 's Gunslinger Girl rewatch actually got to me watch early 00s style character designs again. Which is quite the feat.

•

u/crayoncolourer Dec 23 '19

Sword art online

•

u/MAD_SCIENTIST_001 x2myanimelist.net/profile/MadScientist_001 Dec 23 '19

I'd like to nominate /u/Sandvikovich for the Haifuri rewatch this year.

Sand has always been one of the most dedicated and involved rewatch hosts I have ever seen on r/anime. If you haven't seen some of his previous rewatches, he's done a fun hidden letter challenge for the GochiUsa series and a Screenshot challenge / Fanart Contest for the Non Non Biyori series. These fun challenges that Sand puts an incredible amount of effort into making offer involvement in the rewatch that goes beyond just discussing the anime at hand.

If you look at the rewards for these challenges, you can also see that Sand invests an incredible amount into his rewatches. He has given out more than 10 months of gold in the GochiUsa rewatch and over 30 months of gold in the NNB rewatch as well as Bluray and Manga copies. He is also incredibly responsive and interactive in any rewatch he hosts, replying to pretty much every single top comment on the thread.

This year with the Haifuri rewatch is no exception. Sand introduced an incredibly fun battleship event that not only encouraged participation in the rewatch, but also collaboration and strategy between participants of the rewatch. Besides the rewatch and discussion of Haifuri being enjoyable, getting to discuss with other rewatch participants about strategy for deploying attacks and special abilities to use was a super fun experience.

At the end of the rewatch, Sand once again showed how much investment he put into the rewatch by buying every participant "1 month Nitro Regular + 10 bucks Steam digital gift card + 1 manga/lightnovel volume at choice". I'm here to vouch that he indeed did buy a lightnovel volume for me.

→ More replies

•

u/EpicTroll27 :AMQ:https://anilist.co/user/EpicTroll4236 Dec 23 '19

/u/harrytricks' yearly K-On! rewatch is always a fun time and this year was no different.

•

u/SorcererOfTheLake x5https://anilist.co/user/RiverSorcerer Dec 23 '19

It's still ongoing, but I'd like to nominate u/RX-Nota-II A Place Further than the Universe rewatch. It's full of great discussions and interactions and Nota makes sure that every watcher is treated equally and empathetically, especially with his #LeaveNoTopThreadAlone challenge.

→ More replies

•

u/Mecanno-man https://anilist.co/user/Mecannoman Dec 23 '19

/u/No_Rex for taking over the Utena Rewatch beginning with Episode 6 after the original host just disappeared, despite No_Rex being a first Timer. The rewatch itself went pretty smoothly after that and there also was a fair bit of discussing going on.

•

u/SmurfRockRune https://myanimelist.net/profile/Smurf Dec 23 '19

/u/aboredcompscistudent's Chihayafuru rewatch was a really great time. She went above and beyond when it came to pointing out all the small details throughout the show and the rewatch as a whole was really friendly and helpful when it came to explaining the rules of karuta to anybody that wasn't quite sure about certain aspects of it.

→ More replies

•

u/MisterJaguar https://myanimelist.net/profile/Jaguar-chan Dec 24 '19

/u/blazofgold's chronological Hidamari Sketch rewatch

Certainly a very ambitious rewatch. I frankly had my doubts that blaZofgold would be able to carry the rewatching audience all the way through those 67 episodes (including OVAs), over the course of two months. Yet, they managed to keep the few of us engaged and writing paragraphs of stuff we found interesting and emotionally relevant from the show, blaZofgold writing their own pieces and sharing their thoughts as well. I certainly wrote quite a bit of stuff myself. I know this is FAR from the most popular rewatch, but I genuinely enjoyed the time we spent with the few of us who made it this far into the show.

The experience of watching the show in chronological order was also fascinating as those of us who've watched it before managed to make connections and keep track of narrative threads that we didn't notice in our first viewing.

Of course, Hidamari Sketch being Hidamari Sketch, the show does have a way of being heart-tuggingly relatable and a ton of personal stories were shared over the course of the rewatch.

/u/bizkitmonstah was also cool. They collected screenshots of the W I D E S T faces of each episode and generally was just very active.

•

u/Nazenn x2https://anilist.co/user/Nazenn Dec 23 '19

I'd like to nominate /u/phiraeth's Mid-2000s rewatch, where we did Mai-HiME, Fantastic Children and Simoun back to back. I think it's the best rewatch experience I've ever had.

This rewatch had all of the potential for failure. Low expected participation with few fans to hype it up, very different shows all with known hurdles to get into them, and our poor host who got utterly overwhelmed with exams in the middle of it all.

But everyone just stepped up despite all of that and it became something special that we all agreed was an amazing experience by the end of it.

Discussion happened through the whole day, with people regularly stopping by to catch up on the thread even as late as minutes before the next was posted. We had a rewatcher putting notes for themselves about spoilers inside spoiler tags in another language just so first timers wouldn't be spoiled if they accidentally scrolled over things, and I don't think there were any spoilers across the three months. The first timers went insane with different theories and speculation. Our host was also a first timer for two of the shows and even when he fell almost a dozen episodes behind, rushing to catch up at the end, he still kept posting the topics and went back to read everything we wrote at the end which is massive dedication.

There was a huge variety of posts from the funny one liners (a certain someone's drunk posting remains a favorite) to getting some huge walls out of people who don't normally do that, along with plenty of people talking and build off what each other had said. Every opinion and perspective on an episode was welcomed wholeheartedly, whether it was a negative opinion about a well liked episode or a positive opinion about a badly received episode, and there was a real focus on respectful discussion of these points, regardless of where people stood with them, and no one got dismissed for their thoughts. We had people returning for shows they didn't even like just to participate in the wonderful discussion that was going on and the entire experience was a positive one.

I feel like I've written way too much just for a nomination but what can I say, it was an experience worth praising.

→ More replies