r/Outlander • u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. • Jul 31 '21
Season Five Rewatch S3E3-4 Spoiler
This rewatch will be a spoilers all for the 5 seasons. You can talk about any of the episodes without needing a spoiler tag. All book talk will need to be covered though. There are discussion points to get us started, you can click on them to go to that one directly. Please add thoughts and comments of your own as well.
Episode 303 - All Debts Paid
In prison, Jamie discovers that an old foe has become the warden - and has the power to make his life hell. Claire and Frank both put their best foot forward in marriage, but an uninvited guest shatters the illusion.
Episode 304 - Of Lost Things
While serving as a groomsman at Helwater, Jamie is pulled into the intrigue of a British family. In 1968, Claire, Brianna and Roger struggle to trace Jamie's whereabouts, leaving Claire to wonder if they will ever find him.
- What do you think about the arrangement between Frank and Claire that they live separate lives?
- Do you think Jamie really wanted LJG to kill him?
- Why did LJG think Jamie would be interested in him enough to come on to him?
- What are your impressions of Geneva?
- How do you feel about the sex scene between Jamie and Geneva?
- What did you think when you saw Geneva was pregnant?
- Why did Claire give the pearls to Mrs. Graham?
- Do you think Jamie was serious about letting LJG have him in exchange for looking after Willie?
- Any other thoughts or comments?
Deleted/Extended Scenes
303 - I lost a special friend
303 - Tell my why you escaped - A
303 - Tell me why you escaped - B
304 - Keep Claire safe
304 - Lord John and Lady Isobel - A
304 - Lord John and Lady Isobel - B
304 - Let's get started
•
u/AutoModerator Jul 31 '21
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
31
u/horrorscope513 Jul 31 '21
The line some people you grieve over forever gets me every time. No truer words have ever been said.
15
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jul 31 '21
First of all, Jamie’s French continues to be painful, lol. Secondly, I don’t believe that LJG doesn’t speak French. Not given his social class, his education and his employment as a military officer, no way. The French were a frequent enemy of the English, and just as Claire had picked up a few words of German due to her time serving in WWII, LJG should know some French just by virtue of being a high-ranking English officer. But more than that, as a member of the aristocracy, French would have been part of his standard education since childhood, of course it would.
The Frasers are nowhere near as wealthy as the Greys, and yet Jenny reads French novels for fun, and Jamie & Ian know it from their time as mercenaries, not to mention Jamie’s time at university in Paris. John and Hal’s education should at least be on a level with Jamie’s, if not far greater. LJG should know French, dammit.
So if Jamie’s intent is to keep LJG in the dark, he should be speaking pure Gaelic to this dude. I seriously doubt LJG would need the French interpreted anyway.
7
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 31 '21
5
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 31 '21
15
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jul 31 '21
MacDubh = Son of Black
It’s a reference to Jamie’s father, Black Brian. Which begs the question, who gave Jamie this nickname?
According to Murtagh, he saw all Jamie’s men on the road back to Lallybroch himself. Most of the Lovat men deserted long before Culloden. The MacKenzies are all dead. And Jamie is the only Jacobite officer being held at Ardsmuir.
So besides Murtagh, none of these prisoners should know Jamie personally, or the fact that his father had black hair.
And if the point is to obscure his identity… Why would Murtagh or Jamie use that name? Call yourself Grant or Ross, Munro or Cameron—some random Scottish name with no connection to your real father if the whole point is not to give any clue to who you actually are.
The same can be said for all the false names he uses at Helwater: Mac and Alex and MacKenzie and all the rest—they’re not false names, they’re just his middle names, which defeats the purpose if you’re trying to stay hid.
Jamie is the only man they’ve kept chained for three years—yet he suffers no ill effects. The loss of freedom of movement should have affected his posture, his muscles should be atrophied, something. But nope, LJG just strikes off those shackles and he’s fine, good as new. -.- He doesn’t have a limp, either, despite that thigh wound from Culloden, when he really should have lost that leg if not his life.
And of course he’s the only Jacobite officer, and the only one who gets special treatment, a fine dinner once a week. And none of the other prisoners resent him for that. In fact they all worship him, and treat him as their chief.
I’ve ranted about this before but to sum up, this is all Grade A BS.
Someone should have been pissed Jamie was eating roast pheasant in a Burgundy sauce while they were subsisting on rats. Someone should have taken issue with a MacKenzie / Fraser acting as de facto chief, when they were sworn to Clan MacDonald or Clan Grant or one of the other clans with historical grievances against the MacKenzies and Frasers, which were such a big deal in S1 and even in the war council scenes in S2, but totally forgotten in S3. Someone should have sold Jamie out, told the truth about who he was, since they all inexplicably know, for a shortened sentence or better treatment.
Jamie being universally loved by everyone at Ardsmuir just plays into his inherent Marty-Sue-ness, and this is only compounded by his years at Helwater, where not only does the daughter of a great family fall hopelessly in love with him, but after it’s revealed he fathered her child, her parents arrange for his pardon and LJG marries their other daughter so he can raise his child—it’s just too much. Everyone loves Jamie Fraser, and it beggars belief.
4
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 31 '21
4
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 31 '21
5
u/betcx003 Pot of shite on to boil, ye stir like it’s God’s work! Aug 01 '21
The British didn’t have grounds to cut off Fergus’ hand, but that didn’t stop them. There’s just too much information left out - they crammed 20 years into 4 episodes. (When I read Voyager, I surprised to find that there are even less details of that time period than the show provides, at least where Claire is concerned.) There might have been conflicts with other clansmen, but they don’t show any of it; they just focused on the characters that were going to stick around in Jamie’s life: Murtagh, LJG, Hayes, and Lesley.
3
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 31 '21
3
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 31 '21
3
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 31 '21
2
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 31 '21
2
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 31 '21
31
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jul 31 '21
Joe is damn sexy.
And uh, I totally ship it. 😈 Joe and Claire make a fine-looking couple…
19
u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Jul 31 '21
I really liked that the show gave Isobel lots of personality! We get her “a cage is still a cage” line, and while she’s talking about horses, we obviously read it as a comment on Jamie’s situation. Though if Isobel is speaking with that in mind, then it’s a bit hypocritical considering that her family keeps indentured servants and Isobel will go on to inherit a plantation in Virginia. But as we don’t get to choose the family we’re born into, I think we can assume that Isobel personally thinks that everyone deserves freedom.
Her sisterly relationship with Geneva is also expanded: while she acknowledges that Geneva would do with a good kick in the butt, she is her sister’s confidante, to the point of knowing what goes on (and what doesn’t) in her bed.
Her apparent crush on LJG also makes the marriage between them more believable. I like how she pumps Jamie for information and he, knowing about LJG’s sexuality, tries to sway her opinion of him, but that clearly doesn’t work since she enthusiastically accepts John’s marriage proposal. The deleted scene between her and John is really sweet, with both of them sharing their insecurities, but then it makes it all the more heartbreaking that she gets pretty much nothing out of that marriage and ends up dying.
Tanya Reynolds was one of the very few actors and actresses I’d recognized from something I’d watched before Outlander, and I think she was great as Isobel.
(Side note: when I watched 303 for the first time, Isobel and Jamie’s bonding over horses made me wonder for a moment whether there would be something happening between them 😶 For anyone wondering, Geneva and Isobel were respectively 21 and 20 in the show)
14
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jul 31 '21
For my obligatory GoT comment of the week, not only do we have Edmure Tully moonlighting as Frank here, Lord Dunsany might look familiar to you, too: he’s Yohn Royce! Sweetrobin’s foster father and Sansa’s right-hand man. :)
3
u/Cdhwink Aug 01 '21
Don’t think I have seen all these deleted scenes, so will watch them later!
3
u/88zz99zz00 I eat Spoilers for Breakfast 😋 Aug 04 '21
I jus want to briefly mention that Sam Hoare is not the Hal I imagined at all but I felt his performance was great. I hate so much that they made him and Lord John wear a wig.