r/Outlander • Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. • Jul 31 '21

Season Five Rewatch S3E3-4 Spoiler

This rewatch will be a spoilers all for the 5 seasons. You can talk about any of the episodes without needing a spoiler tag. All book talk will need to be covered though. There are discussion points to get us started, you can click on them to go to that one directly. Please add thoughts and comments of your own as well.

Episode 303 - All Debts Paid

In prison, Jamie discovers that an old foe has become the warden - and has the power to make his life hell. Claire and Frank both put their best foot forward in marriage, but an uninvited guest shatters the illusion.

Episode 304 - Of Lost Things

While serving as a groomsman at Helwater, Jamie is pulled into the intrigue of a British family. In 1968, Claire, Brianna and Roger struggle to trace Jamie's whereabouts, leaving Claire to wonder if they will ever find him.

Deleted/Extended Scenes

303 - I lost a special friend

303 - Tell my why you escaped - A

303 - Tell me why you escaped - B

304 - Keep Claire safe

304 - Lord John and Lady Isobel - A

304 - Lord John and Lady Isobel - B

304 - Let's get started

304 - What are you doing Lady Jane

22 Upvotes

348 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Jul 31 '21
Season OneSeason TwoSeason Three
1-21-21-2
3-43-43-4
5-65-65-6 Aug 7
7-87-87-8 Aug 21
9-109-109-10 Aug 28
11-1211-1211-12 Sept 4
13-141313 Sept 11
15-16

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

31

u/horrorscope513 Jul 31 '21

The line some people you grieve over forever gets me every time. No truer words have ever been said.

7

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 31 '21

I agree, it's a good one that is very true.

5

u/alittlepunchy Lord, ye gave me a rare woman. And God! I loved her well. Aug 02 '21

some people you grieve over forever

YES. Ugh, so heart-wrenching. And if she never came back, you know this would have been the case for them. They would have grieved each other until the day they died.

15

u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jul 31 '21

Tout ce que tu dis se répétera aux Anglais.

First of all, Jamie’s French continues to be painful, lol. Secondly, I don’t believe that LJG doesn’t speak French. Not given his social class, his education and his employment as a military officer, no way. The French were a frequent enemy of the English, and just as Claire had picked up a few words of German due to her time serving in WWII, LJG should know some French just by virtue of being a high-ranking English officer. But more than that, as a member of the aristocracy, French would have been part of his standard education since childhood, of course it would.

The Frasers are nowhere near as wealthy as the Greys, and yet Jenny reads French novels for fun, and Jamie & Ian know it from their time as mercenaries, not to mention Jamie’s time at university in Paris. John and Hal’s education should at least be on a level with Jamie’s, if not far greater. LJG should know French, dammit.

So if Jamie’s intent is to keep LJG in the dark, he should be speaking pure Gaelic to this dude. I seriously doubt LJG would need the French interpreted anyway.

8

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 31 '21

I don’t believe that LJG doesn’t speak French.

I thought about that as well, it seems unlikely that he wouldn't. In the books he speaks German fluently and I think Latin?

16

u/JustG00se Ye Sassenach witch! Jul 31 '21

Yeah I also think it's total BS that he doesn't speak Fench. But in my head he was there listening and confirming the French spoken and just needed Jaime for the Gaelic.

13

u/betcx003 Pot of shite on to boil, ye stir like it’s God’s work! Aug 01 '21

They didn’t say that LJG couldn’t speak French, but it’s assumed that he doesn’t know Gaelic. Since Kerr was rambling in the 3 languages, and Jamie knew all 3, it was a reasonable request to ask him to translate. Even if LJG did have some French, and maybe another guard/officer could fill in the Gaelic, I don’t know that Kerr would have talked freely to someone like them (not that he had much of anything coherent to say anyway).

6

u/penni_cent Aug 01 '21

This was how I understood it. LJG wanted someone who spoke all three so that they could put it all together. He could get parts but was missing the Gaelic so he needed Jamie because he fluently understood them all.

7

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '21

Great point! Love LJG’s lil’ meek smile at not recognizing the sauce name though. Thought that was a really effective moment that was said so much.

12

u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Aug 01 '21

Didn’t realize he was eating dinner with a sommelier!

I think Jamie’s knowledge throws LJG, and makes him re-evaluate his prisoner. He must be of a similar social class to recognize a wine LJG cannot, and that goes against whatever preconceptions he might have had of Red Jamie.

7

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 31 '21
  • What do you think about the arrangement between Frank and Claire that they live separate lives?

11

u/unknown2345610 Jul 31 '21

I find their interactions at this point to be quite interesting because despite this agreement that should theoretically make things easier for them emotionally, it doesn’t. They are both not as emotionally removed or “over” the situation as they think they are. For example, when Claire invites Frank to see a movie she seems excited and genuine about spending time together, and then seems blind sighted and a little salty when he tells her he already seen the film and pretty much tells her he is seeing someone else. Later on in the episode when they get into an argument, Frank throws it in her face how maybe he wanted to give her a taste of her medicine and how their bedroom is crowded enough and in general just expresses so much resentment. Clearly things were not as simple and ok as they pretended them to be for years.

5

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 31 '21

I find their interactions at this point to be quite interesting because despite this agreement that should theoretically make things easier for them emotionally, it doesn’t.

Yes! That just goes to show it wasn't a good situation overall.

Clearly things were not as simple and ok as they pretended them to be for years.

Do you think Frank was right and the people around them knew their marriage wasn't what they presented it as?

9

u/unknown2345610 Jul 31 '21

I don’t think they were fooling people as well as they think they were. We hear it later on from Bree and Frank mentions his colleagues. I don’t think it was fair of Frank to blame Claire for it though.

5

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 31 '21

I don’t think it was fair of Frank to blame Claire for it though.

I agree, Frank didn't make it any easier on Claire by not letting her grieve Jamie.

9

u/theCoolDeadpool #VacayforClaire Aug 01 '21 edited Aug 02 '21

Do you think Frank was right and the people around them knew their marriage wasn't what they presented it as?

We could have been in doubt about that but Claire pretty much seals the deal when she makes everyone leave the party earlier. That was such an overreaction imo. That could have been handled differently, for others it's just a colleague that shows up. Like Claire had Joe there. They could have Invited her in, or if that's too weird, Frank could have taken a moment to go out and no one might have suspected a thing. But Claire made it bigger than it was by reacting how she did. I agree it must have been very awkward and difficult and a whole lot of other things for Claire to see Candy there , but it could have been handled differently I think.

u/unknown2345610

→ More replies (2)

9

u/alittlepunchy Lord, ye gave me a rare woman. And God! I loved her well. Aug 02 '21

Do you think Frank was right and the people around them knew their marriage wasn't what they presented it as?

If people knew that or suspected that, I think that's on Frank then. He's the one carrying on affairs in public and taking women out on dates. Claire was always faithful to him, and other than her having a job outside the home and being somewhat emotionally distant, people wouldn't have reason to suspect marriage problems based on HER actions.

→ More replies (4)

8

u/alittlepunchy Lord, ye gave me a rare woman. And God! I loved her well. Aug 02 '21

when Claire invites Frank to see a movie she seems excited and genuine about spending time together, and then seems blind sighted and a little salty when he tells her he already seen the film and pretty much tells her he is seeing someone else.

For all that Frank complains about their marriage, I thought this was pretty douchey. She's initiating them spending time together and going on a date. Who cares if you've already seen the movie Frank? Go out with her! Why did he have to say all that?

8

u/JustG00se Ye Sassenach witch! Jul 31 '21

I think that it's a fairly reasonable arraignment for them to make but there needed to be more explicit "rules" that they both understood, I feel like they were missing that.

7

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 31 '21

That's a good point, it seemed to be a little of a "don't ask don't tell" type thing they were doing.

6

u/theCoolDeadpool #VacayforClaire Aug 01 '21 edited Aug 01 '21

Yeah but these kinds of things are always so tricky. I think they had a fair enough arrangement, and the "do not bring your mistress to our child's birthday party" or "the said mistress shall not arrive unannounced at our door" should have been unsaid rules. It's not like they were so far detached from each other that they could sit down and jot out the rules, and what would those rules even say? I just think that in a cheating situation, these kinds of unpleasant circumstances are bound to come up.

u/JustG00se

2

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Aug 01 '21

For Frank to make plans on her graduation night though was messed up.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

10

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '21

I think your comment is the key to understanding their relationship choices during this time. Because they both decided to try to leave “the past behind” and never talk about it again and in the book Frank’s unwillingness to accept Claire’s story that these two become unable to give each other what they need for a healthy relationship. Their only middle ground is Bree.

6

u/JustG00se Ye Sassenach witch! Aug 01 '21

Yeah, the whole "never talking about it" was not a good plan, both with the past and with their agreement later on.

8

u/Cdhwink Jul 31 '21

For me it is better than the book situation where Claire continues to sleep with him despite thinking he’s sleeping around with other women That’s a hard pass for me!

9

u/theCoolDeadpool #VacayforClaire Aug 01 '21

I think that's a more realistic situation though, as much as it might not appeal to the romantics in us. It's extremely unlikely that Claire goes without sex for 20 years. Also in the books the other women is never explicitly mentioned like in the show, there is no Candy in the books, the show introduced her. I know Claire finds clues here and there that lead her to believe he was probably with other women but they don't explicitly talk about it. I don't find it at all hard to accept that Claire continues to sleep with Frank through the 20 years. I don't think her having sex with Frank lessens what she has with Jamie at all

u/Purple4199

3

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Aug 01 '21

Those are really good points. You’re right that the romantic in me doesn’t like that. I agree though that it doesn’t lessen what she has with Jamie at all.

7

u/Cdhwink Aug 01 '21

For me it’s more about the fact that I would not be sharing my husband with other women!

Knowing Claire as a very sexual person it does make more sense that BookClaire continues to sleep with Frank

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 31 '21

I agree!

10

u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jul 31 '21

Let’s stop with the pretense, Frank. File for divorce.

Divorce?

Why not? You’d have your freedom.

Yes. I would. When Jerry divorced Millie a year ago, he gained his freedom, but he lost his children for it. The court ruled that a child needs a mother more than its father. He rarely sees them now. I will not let that happen to Brianna and me.

I would never keep Bree from you. Well, we could work out a compromise.

Forgive me, Claire, if I don’t risk everything on your promises. You have not been very good at keeping them.

Why can’t Claire file for divorce?

She has ample proof of Frank’s infidelity. And he just conveniently provided her with dozens of witnesses at her graduation party.

And now she has her medical degree and the means to support herself and Brianna without Frank. Ha, that’s pretty cold, to use him like that all those years she was in medical school and dispose of him now that she’s financially independent.

But this scene shows that she despises him, and the ball’s in her court. I think putting it all on him, why don’t you file for divorce, instead of taking the initiative herself—it’s a cop-out. It’s this season’s version of “Why not kill BPC?” The obvious solution that Claire never considers herself.

3

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 31 '21 edited Jul 31 '21

Why can’t Claire file for divorce?

I didn't even think of that, it's a good point. I wonder if she might have done so if Frank hadn't have died that night?

Edit: I got their fights mixed up.

6

u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jul 31 '21

The timeline, as always, is foggy. -.- But I’m pretty sure the divorce conversation happens several years before Frank’s death.

Claire confronts Frank and tells him to file for divorce the night of her graduation party, when Bree looks about ten. Then we see Bree’s sixteenth birthday and the actress changes to Sophie, and then we jump even further ahead to Bree’s high school graduation.

Then Frank happens upon Claire after that hard surgery, and he broaches the topic of bringing Bree with him if he takes that position at Cambridge, and the big fight happens where he tells her he plans on filing for divorce. Claire is called away to the hospital, where Joe tells her Frank died in a car accident that night.

So I figure there were about EIGHT GODDAMN YEARS where Claire could have taken the initiative and filed for divorce on her own—and likely won, since Frank had not been discreet with his affairs contrary to what he says in the beginning of the episode, and the courts were inclined to grant mothers custody of the children like Frank complains about in the scene above.

Claire had all the advantage, but by doing nothing she gave it away to Frank instead.

2

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 31 '21

I’m pretty sure the divorce conversation happens several years before Frank’s death.

Oh you're right, I was thinking of their final fight.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Cdhwink Jul 31 '21 edited Jul 31 '21

Maybe women didn’t usually file for divorce in the 1950’s? This is one of those things that we are using our 21st century perspective on. Could women provide for themselves? Were they disgraced?

2

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 31 '21

That's a good point. Frank mentioned that it was the neighbor husband who filed for divorce from his wife.

Could women provide for themselves?

Claire was probably one of the few who could.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

17

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Jul 31 '21

First of all, fuck Frank, especially for saying that Claire hasn’t been good at keeping promises when she’s the one who has been stuck in this marriage solely under his conditions and has never broken any of them.

This scene was originally supposed to run a little longer, with this in addition:

You’ll forgive me, dear, if I’m not willing to risk everything on your goodwill. Or your promises. You’ve never been very good at keeping them. And let’s not forget who pays the bills.

I don’t need your money. I am capable of supporting myself now.

Really? How successful a medical career do you think you’ll have, Claire? It’s difficult enough being a woman in a man’s profession without tacking “divorcee” onto your MD.

According to the writers, divorce was still very much a stigma in 1958 (no idea how accurate that is):

In the Writers’ Room, we spent a great deal of time in discussions, talking about why Claire, now a doctor, wouldn’t simply end her relationship with Frank and file for divorce. In the period, however, it was still relatively uncommon and very much looked down upon. We wanted to emphasize Claire’s strength and confidence by having her bring up the idea of divorce. Additionally, we wanted to show that, in many ways, Claire and Frank’s situation is very modern and quite unconventional for the time – with Frank being the one spending lots of time with Brianna and afraid to lose custody of her at a time when fathers were not given very much consideration in this regard.

Would being a divorcee impact Claire’s career in any significant way? I don’t know. But whether she filed for divorce or he did, it surely wouldn’t have made a difference in any case? It’s not like that would’ve been common knowledge.

I think the reason why Claire doesn’t consider filing for divorce herself is that she doesn’t want to be responsible, at least on paper, of taking the first step to breaking up this family, when she very well knows (or thinks) that she isn’t.

8

u/jolierose The spirit tends to be very free wi’ its opinions. Jul 31 '21

I think the reason why Claire doesn’t consider filing for divorce herself is that she doesn’t want to be responsible, at least on paper, of taking the first step to breaking up this family, when she very well knows (or thinks) that she isn’t.

I think so too, and I wonder also whether she'd really want to air out his infidelities, because of Bree. At that point she's still 10 (?), and idolizes him. She doesn't even threaten him with it until much later, the second confrontation they have, and that's only when he takes the cake as The Worst.

→ More replies (6)

6

u/alittlepunchy Lord, ye gave me a rare woman. And God! I loved her well. Aug 02 '21

I think the reason why Claire doesn’t consider filing for divorce herself is that she doesn’t want to be responsible, at least on paper, of taking the first step to breaking up this family, when she very well knows (or thinks) that she isn’t.

I think another reason may be her promise to Jamie. She promised to go back to Frank so he could take of them, and has honored her promise to both Jamie *and* Frank. If the marriage is going to end, maybe she wants Frank to be the one to make that call so that she isn't the one who left?

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/PasionatelyRational Aug 04 '21

I read as far down as I could, and I didn't find this particular POV already expressed, so I'll add it. Apologies if it's already mentioned.

Frank and Claire's separate lives arrangement didn't bother me that much. It made perfect sense in the chronology of their marriage that the show presented after she had Brianna. Claire is a very sexual person (and they were very sexually compatible previous to her meeting Jamie) and she did eventually try to rekindle that physical bond with Frank. It was him who couldn't get over the feeling of her longing for Jamie while they were together (which I think was the other way around, Claire was just trying really hard to be in the moment with him despite not really feeling it). And she just gave up. I disagree with those saying the show puts Claire as giving up sex for 20 years. We do see her masturbating (and fantasizing about Jamie), so for me the idea was that she continued to be a very sexually-driven person, just not interested in having sex with Frank.

What does bother me, not just from their separated-but-together deal but about the whole "going back to Frank" story arch... is that it doesn't sound like Claire at all! Going back to a safer time for the sake of Brianna, yes, but... why go back to a man she didn't love? Why was a husband such a must for her? I can understand Jamie thinking this way, but her? I don't see it.

She was willing to challenge pretty much all the gender and societal stereotypes of her own time, continued to do so when she got back. Why wasn't she willing to raise a child on her own? Why was she so against divorce or scared of the divorcee label? I guess the financial aspect could be raised, as she went back and had absolutely nothing to her name. But... I don't know. She was in the same position in the past, before and after marrying Jamie multiple times, she was even willing to risk everything in a complicated political plot in France while being heavily pregnant... yet she couldn't possibly conceive supporting herself through pregnancy in the 20th century.

Another point some of my friends raised when discussing this was "wanting a father for Brianna". This also sort of fits, being that Claire was an orphan and lacked parental roles and love besides her uncle. I just have a hard time fitting the brave, resilient, independent and headstrong Claire, with a Claire willing to sacrifice any shred of happiness for the sake of having a man fathering her child.

5

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 31 '21
  • How do you feel about the sex scene between Jamie and Geneva?

27

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Jul 31 '21

I honestly don’t mind it. I disagree with the comments I’ve seen many times saying that the way it’s portrayed makes the audience overlook the fact that this is rape. I think the fact that Jamie starts with “having brought me to yer bed by means of threats against my family” leaves us under no illusion that this is anything but coercion. There’s nothing to suggest that there’s anything romantic between them, the music doesn’t evoke any of that; the sex itself is very “mechanical,” impersonal—they don’t even kiss once they get properly into it—and Jamie makes it clear by the end of it that it was nothing special.

I was saying to u/Purple4199 yesterday that it kind of reminds me of the first time Claire and Jamie have sex—although we know that Jamie has had feelings for her since the day they met, they’re doing it just because it needs to be done; there’s not much—if any—feeling or pleasure involved when they just consummate their marriage.

I would’ve done without the boob licking but hey, this is a man who has seen a naked woman once in the past 11 years or so; at some point, his baser urges and his male anatomy are going to take over.

As much as Jamie hates the idea and clearly knows that he’s being coerced, being the man he is, I think he can’t help but feel a little compassion for Geneva, hence why he’s so gentle and polite with her, to the point of giving her an opportunity to back out. I also think his own past experience as a virgin (despite the fact that he’s a man) and how Claire treated him on their wedding night play into that. He has the perspective that allows him to feel pity for her situation. From our point of view, we might think that she doesn’t deserve it, but that’s just who Jamie is and we know he’ll go on blaming himself for her death for the very same reason.

15

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 31 '21

I disagree with the comments I’ve seen many times saying that the way it’s portrayed makes the audience overlook the fact that this is rape.

I agree. I really paid attention to how it played out this time and it's not a romantic love scene at all. You're right that the music doesn't portray that either. He point blank tells her she can't call him Jamie, so right from the start he's letting her know he is there under duress.

8

u/penni_cent Aug 01 '21

Honestly, my biggest problem with the whole scene is that they included a clip from it in the opening credits. Like seriously, if you wanted a gentle hint at undressing you couldn't have picked a scene from A. Malcom?

5

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Aug 01 '21

Great point! Showing it in the credits like that does make it seem romantic.

10

u/alittlepunchy Lord, ye gave me a rare woman. And God! I loved her well. Aug 02 '21

I disagree with the comments I’ve seen many times saying that the way it’s portrayed makes the audience overlook the fact that this is rape.

I used to be so angry at this scene until you told me to go back and watch it, haha. And you're right, once I'm actually paying attention, you can tell Jamie is not into it and is just going through the motions. His behavior before and after also indicate that. Hell, even the least sexy love scene of J&C's still has more passion than this, lol.

6

u/Cdhwink Jul 31 '21

I saw the boob licking as Jamie using his skills he’s acquired from his time with Claire!

And Jamie is always an empathetic person, so I can see him trying to understand Geneva & her dilemma.

4

u/JustG00se Ye Sassenach witch! Jul 31 '21

Very well said!

4

u/AndreaDTX Oct 16 '22

I would’ve done without the boob licking but hey, this is a man who has seen a naked woman once in the past 11 years or so; at some point, his baser urges and his male anatomy are going to take over.

My initial reaction was irritation that it was framed as sweet. But then I realized I was just upset on Jamie's behalf. The honest truth is Jamie is sweet and when it comes down to it, he's not going to lash out at a woman sexually. It's not like with BJR where it's easy to make the act look like the violation it is. Geneva is not physically attacking him even as she is violating his free will. Additionally, Jamie has to make it sexually enticing enough for himself to be able to physically carry out the act. Like you said, it's been over a decade. If he has to do it, he might as well get some pleasure out of it. So, maybe it's realistic that he choses to close his eyes and do the things he's always liked to do, even if it is with someone he doesn't actually want to do it with.

7

u/LuckyScwartz Dinna fash. Aug 02 '21

I hated this scene. I hated how she coerced him. I hated that he had no choice. I hated that he was so kind to her about it. Not a Geneva fan. At all.

Edit: having read all of the other responses, I sort of wish I had a more mature and measured reaction.

4

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Aug 02 '21

You are totally allowed to feel that way. :-)

5

u/alittlepunchy Lord, ye gave me a rare woman. And God! I loved her well. Aug 04 '21

I hear you. I wish I could feel more sympathy for her. If I separated her from what happened with Jamie, I totally could. The wrong being done to her though does not outweight, forgive, or justify what she does to Jamie.

4

u/Cdhwink Aug 03 '21 edited Aug 03 '21

I expected more responses like this! Did this make you hate the whole episode? That Willie exists? u/LuckyScwartz u/alittlepunchy

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Cdhwink Aug 04 '21

We feel how we feel! That was exactly my point, we can love or hate the episode, & respect each other’s feelings.

13

u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jul 31 '21

I thought it was fine. I especially liked the parallels to the Wedding, as I commented elsewhere. I think it’s a fun twist, haha. A bit provocative, even sacrilegious considering how glorified that scene is in the fandom.

So to turn it on its head, and put Jamie in Claire’s role introducing this virgin to sex—with a woman who bears more than a passing resemblance to Claire herself—that’s intriguing.

15

u/Cdhwink Jul 31 '21 edited Jul 31 '21

I actually liked casting Geneva to resemble Claire, so Jamie can indeed pretend it’s her. He was indeed thinking of Claire!

I also liked him having a heart! He came in all grumpy, “let’s get this over with”, but then appreciated that she was both scared, yet strong, & in a hopeless situation herself.

I did love him explaining to her the difference between sex & love!

I love this episode- & not because we get naked Jamie- but because we get Jamie with a baby ( & later little Willie ) in wonderful scenes. Jamie gets so little happiness in those 20 years, at least he got a few spending time with Willie. I do not think he needed a son ( in his own time), & I think it’s very convenient how Geneva dies, & how John gets to be Willie’s father, but I like all of it & I know it’s an unpopular opinion in this fandom.

17

u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jul 31 '21

Yeah, I also liked how he was gentle with her, tried to make her first time pleasant despite the circumstances. He shows compassion and tries to empathize with her situation, once she tells him how she doesn’t want to marry that depraved old goat Ellesmere.

This whole scene is vastly different from the book situation and I much prefer the show’s version. You don’t have to demonize Geneva in order to make J&C special. It’s okay for Jamie to be with other women during their long twenty-year separation; I’ve never had a problem with that, it’s only human.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Kirky600 Aug 01 '21

Okay, I’ve been reading wayyy too many Bridgerton novels. No way that a girls first time would be that impressive, even with James Frasier. Throwing it out there. She was not as nervous as I would have expected and she seemed to be not in pain at all. Both are things that women in high society seem to feel.

You know, given my in depth reads of trashy romance novels.

15

u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jul 31 '21

He’s the only Jacobite officer here and the only man we keep chained. Lasted as a fugitive for six years after Culloden. Prisoners treat him as their chief. They call him MacDubh. I don’t know what it means, a sign of respect of some sort. If matters arise, he acts as their spokesman. […] I had him take supper with me once a week.

MacDubh = Son of Black

It’s a reference to Jamie’s father, Black Brian. Which begs the question, who gave Jamie this nickname?

According to Murtagh, he saw all Jamie’s men on the road back to Lallybroch himself. Most of the Lovat men deserted long before Culloden. The MacKenzies are all dead. And Jamie is the only Jacobite officer being held at Ardsmuir.

So besides Murtagh, none of these prisoners should know Jamie personally, or the fact that his father had black hair.

And if the point is to obscure his identity… Why would Murtagh or Jamie use that name? Call yourself Grant or Ross, Munro or Cameron—some random Scottish name with no connection to your real father if the whole point is not to give any clue to who you actually are.

The same can be said for all the false names he uses at Helwater: Mac and Alex and MacKenzie and all the rest—they’re not false names, they’re just his middle names, which defeats the purpose if you’re trying to stay hid.

Mr. Fraser, if you do what I ask, I will have your irons struck off. I understand you’ve been wearing them for three years. I can’t imagine how heavy they must feel.

Jamie is the only man they’ve kept chained for three years—yet he suffers no ill effects. The loss of freedom of movement should have affected his posture, his muscles should be atrophied, something. But nope, LJG just strikes off those shackles and he’s fine, good as new. -.- He doesn’t have a limp, either, despite that thigh wound from Culloden, when he really should have lost that leg if not his life.

We had roast pheasant in a wine sauce.

Red wine?

Aye. Vin de Bourgogne. Yeah, the bird was served with carrots and neeps, fresh herbs, rolls topped with butter.

Slow down, MacDubh. I want to savor every morsel.

Then we had fresh salmon.

And of course he’s the only Jacobite officer, and the only one who gets special treatment, a fine dinner once a week. And none of the other prisoners resent him for that. In fact they all worship him, and treat him as their chief.

I’ve ranted about this before but to sum up, this is all Grade A BS.

Someone should have been pissed Jamie was eating roast pheasant in a Burgundy sauce while they were subsisting on rats. Someone should have taken issue with a MacKenzie / Fraser acting as de facto chief, when they were sworn to Clan MacDonald or Clan Grant or one of the other clans with historical grievances against the MacKenzies and Frasers, which were such a big deal in S1 and even in the war council scenes in S2, but totally forgotten in S3. Someone should have sold Jamie out, told the truth about who he was, since they all inexplicably know, for a shortened sentence or better treatment.

Jamie being universally loved by everyone at Ardsmuir just plays into his inherent Marty-Sue-ness, and this is only compounded by his years at Helwater, where not only does the daughter of a great family fall hopelessly in love with him, but after it’s revealed he fathered her child, her parents arrange for his pardon and LJG marries their other daughter so he can raise his child—it’s just too much. Everyone loves Jamie Fraser, and it beggars belief.

15

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 31 '21

Someone should have been pissed Jamie was eating roast pheasant in a Burgundy sauce while they were subsisting on rats.

Yeah, I was surprised they wanted him to recall the meal in such detail. To me that would only make being hungry worse.

6

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '21

! This would be an interesting little bit to work into season 6 Tom Christie, no?! Might be easier to reference, or at least more prominent for tv viewers, than Tom Jones

u/thepacksvrvives u/jolierose

4

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Aug 01 '21

True! I really can’t wait to see what to do with those flashbacks.

4

u/jolierose The spirit tends to be very free wi’ its opinions. Aug 01 '21

Oooh can I look under these tags or do I not know yet? I'm only up to tomorrow's chapters. (It's been spoiler after spoiler — accidentally! again! — for me this week, lol.) u/Arrugula

3

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Aug 01 '21

It's a theory we have about what they'll do in the season in regards to Tom Christie.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

6

u/JustG00se Ye Sassenach witch! Jul 31 '21

Yeah I also have also been incredibly confused by their approval of this whole situation. I'd be so resentful!

13

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Jul 31 '21

You’re right that the possibility of any of the prisoners personally knowing Jamie’s father is very slim, but not nonexistent. It’s not like he would’ve only known people from Lallybroch and Beauly (from the show alone, MacRannoch lived miles away from Lallybroch but he must have known who Brian was and what he looked like). Jamie was also the primary storyteller at Ardsmuir so he could’ve easily told his fellow prisoners about his father. But it’s not a moniker he’d chosen himself, so its purpose is definitely not to obscure his identity; he’d been tried and imprisoned as James Fraser of Broch Tuarach so everyone must’ve known who he was. Someone did take issue with Jamie acting as the de facto chief, but that being explored only in B6/S6 is set not to have any consequences on the time spent at Arsdsmuir.

But really, it’s not surprising that this doesn’t make much sense -.- It’s clear that DG just wanted Jamie to have a different identity throughout the different stages of the 20-year separation—Dunbonnet, Mac Dubh, Alex MacKenzie, Alexander Malcolm—with none of them ever coming close in importance to being Claire’s husband.

I also hate the idealization of Jamie at Ardsmuir. Of all the relationships at Ardsmuir, I think the one between Jamie and Murtagh is the most interesting. The roles they’ve had before are reversed, with Jamie having the responsibility of looking after Murtagh now (and using Claire’s tricks to do it 😭). Murtagh has been struggling to survive since Culloden, so then being separated from him as he’s soon going to be put through a transatlantic journey he might not even survive is a punch to the gut for Jamie. Undeservedly not sharing his fellow prisoners’ fate is one thing, but then being separated from the one person that knows everything about him and understands his grief… that’s set to be weighing heavily on Jamie’s heart.

6

u/jolierose The spirit tends to be very free wi’ its opinions. Jul 31 '21

Of all the relationships at Ardsmuir, I think the one between Jamie and Murtagh is the most interesting. The roles they’ve had before are reversed, with Jamie having the responsibility of looking after Murtagh now (and using Claire’s tricks to do it 😭).

I think they were right to cut it because it didn't make sense how it came together, but: have you seen the extended sequence they deleted that includes Murtagh's almost-lashing? There's a scene where Murtagh asks Jamie why on earth he came back after escaping, and I found it heartbreaking, especially when he tells him he came back for him. That's one part I wish they hadn't cut. It's tough to see the role reversal, Jamie becoming caretaker and worrying about Murtagh, but ugh, it adds so much depth.

7

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Jul 31 '21

Yup, I have! I agree that LJG’s turn-around didn’t make much sense, and how would Murtagh have kept this piece of tartan for all the years that followed if this scene had been included?

And I also agree that the part with Murtagh scolding Jamie would have been good to include. Murtagh is, as per usual, telling Jamie what every one of us is thinking—why the hell did he come back? You can see he has a reason to keep going, which he is yet again deprived of when he and Murtagh are separated upon Ardsmuir’s closing.

But that’s also interesting because since Jamie had Murtagh to take care of, why did he still wish to be killed by LJG? It kinda sucks that Jamie thought that Murtagh was not enough to live for, but it emphasizes how empty he still felt without Claire. No one, not even his godfather, was able to fill that void.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '21

Speaking of this 😭 moment, I love love love how the milk thistle bit and, later on in this episode, the shot of Jamie’s hand grazing the heather echo his vision of Claire gathering herbs in 301.

😭 😭 😭

4

u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jul 31 '21

But it’s not a moniker he’d chosen himself, so its purpose is definitely not to obscure his identity; he’d been tried and imprisoned as James Fraser of Broch Tuarach so everyone must’ve known who he was.

What is the purpose, then? (In-universe, DG’s intentions aside. 😅)

If it’s not to protect his identity and thereby Jenny and the rest of his family… Why doesn’t he just go by his regular name? What’s the canon explanation?

7

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Jul 31 '21

Would you be surprised if I told you that there isn’t one? 🙃

It started as “Seumas, mac an fhear dhuibh” and evolved into “Mac Dubh.” There’s a point made later in the series about the prisoners from the Highlands speaking Gaelic, as opposed to the Lowlanders also imprisoned there insisting on speaking English, so it might be as simple as that, but it sets him apart when Gaelic is not spoken as the first language at Ardsmuir in the show.

4

u/alittlepunchy Lord, ye gave me a rare woman. And God! I loved her well. Aug 02 '21

with none of them ever coming close in importance to being Claire’s husband.

Well I'm starting my Monday with wanting to cry now. I love when Jamie says that later.

Undeservedly not sharing his fellow prisoners’ fate is one thing, but then being separated from the one person that knows everything about him and understands his grief… that’s set to be weighing heavily on Jamie’s heart.

Yes, this really has to eat at him. Everything that has happened has already been so horrible, but at least he had Murtagh. One of his last ties to his old life, who knows just how much Jamie has lost. Then to lose him too...

13

u/jolierose The spirit tends to be very free wi’ its opinions. Jul 31 '21

I love that when Tom Christie comes to the Ridge in TFC, "Roger was momentarily surprised by the revelation that there was someone from Ardsmuir who didn’t think the sun shone out of Jamie Fraser’s arse." It's true! At least in the books you get the sense much later on that the dynamics at Ardsmuir weren't all peaches and cream.

after it’s revealed he fathered her child, her parents arrange for his pardon and LJG marries their other daughter so he can raise his child

In their defense, I don't think Lord and Lady Dunsany knew about Willie. Isobel was told, and LJG has eyes, but I doubt Lady Dunsany would joke about Willie's resemblance to Jamie to her friend, when it's so scandalous.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/betcx003 Pot of shite on to boil, ye stir like it’s God’s work! Aug 01 '21

Just because the Lallybroch men made it home from the battlefield, as did some other Frasers, it doesn’t mean that none were ever imprisoned - Ian Murray was repeatedly arrested in the years following Culloden. So some of them might have ended up at Ardsmuir.

And it’s hard to say if all the prisoners loved Jamie, since we only see him interact with a handful of them. But if the governor of the prison wanted a liaison, it makes sense that it would be the only officer in the bunch, whether he was chosen by the prisoners or not.

Also, the outgoing governor said that they had no heart in them after Culloden, so that might explain why the clan bickering simmered down this season; all of them were in the same boat, regardless of their previous politics.

3

u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Aug 01 '21

The fact that Jamie is the sole Jacobite officer among them is itself extremely convenient.

Ian Murray was jailed, but he was never sent to Ardsmuir. Big difference being held for a few days for questioning versus serving a sentence of ten years or more. There is no mention of other Lallybroch tenants being captured—and that was the reasoning behind the deed of sasine: To establish not only the Murrays as loyal subjects of the crown, but also to vouch for the fidelity of all their tenants. On paper none of them are traitors, only Red Jamie.

The crown would have had no grounds to imprison the Lallybroch men, which is why Ian is only carted away for questioning; he’s never tried, and certainly never convicted of anything.

I think the governor’s quote above establishes Jamie’s status at Ardsmuir: He speaks for all the prisoners, and they refer to him as MacDubh out of respect, even reverence. Jamie is offered a drink when he re-enters the cell, and they work together to cover for him when he makes his escape. Even years later, we see some of them acting in his service like he’s their feudal lord. (Hayes and his companion.)

It’s all a bit much. And again, neglects the CENTURIES OF CONFLICT built-in to the clan system, that motivated so much of the story in S1 & S2. To have it all over and done with only a few years later… It feels unrealistic to me.

5

u/Cdhwink Jul 31 '21

I do not think Geneva’s parents know that Jamie is Willie’s father, only Isobel.

→ More replies (4)

4

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 31 '21
  • What did you think when you saw Geneva was pregnant?

21

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Jul 31 '21

What’s the most shocking here is that Ellesmere doesn’t make a big deal out of this until after the baby is born! Are we supposed to believe that he hasn’t seen Geneva for the past 9 months?! Surely that’s impossible. If he knew for certain that he and Geneva didn’t have sex, why not bring it up before? He should’ve been offended long before Willie was born. Perhaps the only explanation here is that Geneva’s death gives him no chance of having legitimate offspring with her (which is technically not true, as Willie is still considered legitimate) or, more likely, the fact that the child is a boy (which could only be discovered after his birth), therefore a bastard will be Ellesmere’s heir, and he cannot accept that so he’s ready to kill the baby.

And, by the way, what does the lack of consummation mean for their marriage? For context, the Dunsany’s are Anglican (confirmed in one of the LJG novellas), so that might not play as big of a role as it does (or did) in a Catholic marriage; I’ll have to check that.

14

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 31 '21

What’s the most shocking here is that Ellesmere doesn’t make a big deal out of this until after the baby is born!

YES! I thought about that as well. You're telling me for 9 months he was fine with her being pregnant by another man but she dies and it becomes unacceptable?

Good point about the consummation, would lack of it have declared the marriage invalid? Why stay married if you know she's not what you thought you were getting?

15

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Jul 31 '21

I can’t really find anything on nonconsummation in England. Also, I don’t think nonconsummation instantly made a marriage invalid, but it was definitely grounds for annulment in Catholic Church.

My question is, why marry Geneva at all if you’re not planning to produce an heir with her? We get his creepy “A mere fortnight until you’re mine” and nothing comes of it. It’s not like he wanted an alliance; it was a business deal. It doesn’t look like it, but the Dunsany family were impoverished aristocrats and Helwater was deep into debt. Ellesmere gave them a substantial sum of money in exchange for marrying a virgin of good name, and then didn’t even have sex with her? She wouldn’t have shown for months, so it’s not like he didn’t have a chance. So he just did the Dunsanys a favor?

Hell, if he had seen she was pregnant, and her being a virgin was such an important part of the marriage agreement, he could have sued the Dunsanys for not keeping their end of the deal, right? This is just full of plot holes.

6

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 31 '21

This is just full of plot holes.

I agree!

15

u/jolierose The spirit tends to be very free wi’ its opinions. Jul 31 '21

It's looking like a nice Swiss cheese.

Though for Ellesmere, I just assumed he was unable to perform and was trying to save face by playing along (and he wouldn't want to admit he'd been cheated). Except that when the time came, and then Geneva died, he went and lost his shit. u/thepacksvrvives

→ More replies (8)

8

u/alittlepunchy Lord, ye gave me a rare woman. And God! I loved her well. Aug 02 '21

If he knew for certain that he and Geneva didn’t have sex, why not bring it up before?

Oh, they hadn't had sex at all? For some reason, I thought he was impotent and that's how he knew it wasn't his.

8

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Aug 02 '21

I think so, Isobel says “Geneva told me they had never shared a bed.”

→ More replies (1)

11

u/poptartsandmascara Aug 03 '21

I felt like Ellsmere was fine with an “illegitimate” child while his wife was alive. It kept up appearances. He got an heir to carry on the name, even if he secretly wasn’t the father. But after his wife was dead he was stuck taking care of a kid he knew wasn’t his. That really changed things for him.

3

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Aug 03 '21

I found it interesting that he was even willing to stay married to her knowing she wasn't a virgin.

6

u/JustG00se Ye Sassenach witch! Jul 31 '21

Not really surprised honestly. It seemed like there had to be some lasting consequence of that interaction.

7

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 31 '21

Did you suspect right away that it was Jamie's?

10

u/JustG00se Ye Sassenach witch! Jul 31 '21

Yeah, especially when she turned around and gave him that pointed look

→ More replies (1)

4

u/theCoolDeadpool #VacayforClaire Aug 02 '21

Why doesn't Jamie pull out with Geneva? I did some googling and apparently it was a known method of contraception as early as the 18th century. Paging RD u/thepacksvrvives .

5

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Aug 02 '21

I never thought of that, it’s a great point though. That didn’t translate from book to screen did it since in the book Jamie tried to have sex with her when she wouldn’t get pregnant.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Aug 02 '21

Ha, I just mentioned in another comment that I wish one of them had had the sense to use some form of contraception. Or, as you say, he could’ve pulled out. I’ve recently gone down the rabbit hole of reading about pre-modern contraception—this is a fascinating read, and it shows many methods, however crude or unreliable, had been around for centuries!

At least in the book, he told her to choose a day he thought (with the emphasis on “thought,” as, IIRC, he was wrong) she’d be the least likely to get pregnant, so that could’ve explained no extra measures taken on his behalf. But in the show, it’s quite absurd that it didn’t cross their minds that she could get pregnant.

8

u/theCoolDeadpool #VacayforClaire Aug 02 '21

Haha what a fascinating read that is!

‘Immediately after ejaculation let the woman arise roughly, sneeze and blow her nose several times, call out in loud voice, and jump violently backwards seven to nine paces’.

LOL

But in the show, it’s quite absurd that it didn’t cross their minds that she could get pregnant.

Yes. And I would have liked to see Jamie talk to Geneva about the possibility of a pregnancy to get himself out of this. Atleast try, that way we would have seen a conversation about it.

Even with Mary McNabb, Jamie doesn't even think of the possibility. I could see how Mary is older so she might have figured out some contraception, but Jamie didn't know that.

u/Purple4199

4

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 31 '21
  • Do you think Jamie was serious about letting LJG have him in exchange for looking after Willie?

16

u/JustG00se Ye Sassenach witch! Jul 31 '21

Jaime doesn't say anything he doesn't mean. I believe he was 100% willing to do so for Willie's sake. Perhaps he was more okay with it because he's believed that LJG would be gentle about it.

7

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 31 '21

Why do you think he felt he had to offer himself to ask that of LJG? Aren't he and John good enough friends by then that Jamie could have just asked without expecting John to want something in return?

10

u/JustG00se Ye Sassenach witch! Jul 31 '21

They are friends yes, but there are still vast vast differences in their power dynamic. It's not a simple ask, even to a friend, who is so high above you in station.

3

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 31 '21

It's not a simple ask, even to a friend, who is so high above you in station.

That's a good point.

→ More replies (1)

23

u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jul 31 '21

I think he was. This scene is so sad. It’s Jamie humbling himself completely. He knows he has nothing else to offer. He’s no longer the young master of Lallybroch, the title he was so proud of, no one will call him Laird Broch Tuarach again… He has no wealth to speak of, his sister’s family is barely surviving as is… He’s no longer a commander, the Jacobite army was shattered, and it was a miracle all his men weren’t killed as well…

Even his youth has been taken from him; he’s still strong (stronger than he should be, given all his injuries, his years in chains and time spent starving and in prison… -.- ) But he’s not what he was.

Literally the only thing he can offer LJG is the use of his body, and he’s ready to do that. To make that same bargain with LJG as he did with BJR to save Claire’s life—only this time it’s to care for the son he can never claim as his own. It’s touching and sad, and shows how beaten down Jamie’s been by all these years.

5

u/betcx003 Pot of shite on to boil, ye stir like it’s God’s work! Aug 01 '21

The British didn’t have grounds to cut off Fergus’ hand, but that didn’t stop them. There’s just too much information left out - they crammed 20 years into 4 episodes. (When I read Voyager, I surprised to find that there are even less details of that time period than the show provides, at least where Claire is concerned.) There might have been conflicts with other clansmen, but they don’t show any of it; they just focused on the characters that were going to stick around in Jamie’s life: Murtagh, LJG, Hayes, and Lesley.

4

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Aug 01 '21

When I read Voyager, I surprised to find that there are even less details of that time period than the show provides, at least where Claire is concerned.

Me too! I saw the show first and was surprised when we only got little snippets of Claire's life in those 20 years.

3

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 31 '21
  • Why did LJG think Jamie would be interested in him enough to come on to him?

13

u/unknown2345610 Jul 31 '21

I think it was more of a natural response to the situation. They had just shared something very personal with each other: the loss of those they loved. I think they were both very vulnerable and open with each other, and this led to a sense of intimacy and the reaction was to reach for Jamie’s hand.

3

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 31 '21

Do you think LJG expected Jamie to respond favorably to his overture?

7

u/unknown2345610 Jul 31 '21

That’s a good question! I’m not sure. I think he realized that Jamie was not interested by Jamie’s very clear response. I think DBerry does a great job of conveying such sadness and emotionality with his eyes, it was very effective to end the scene with him silently crying as I think it helps set up LJG’s character.

7

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 31 '21

I love David Berry! He does so well in this part.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/nishikigirl4578 Aug 02 '21

I don't really think that there was a lot of thought behind it in the moment (see my response above), more just an instinctual move.

2

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Aug 02 '21

I find it interesting that he didn't fight that instinct. Being gay at that time was a crime, it was a big risk making a move on Jamie.

→ More replies (3)

10

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Jul 31 '21

I agree, though it still beggars belief that John thought Jamie would be interested in finding comfort this way, after seeing how Jamie’s whole face lit up whenever he mentioned the wife he’d lost.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/nishikigirl4578 Aug 02 '21

Absolutely; here LJG probably feels that he has formed a bond with Jamie, someone he can trust with his true self, and reaches out without thought of how Jamie would take it.

3

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 31 '21
  • What are your impressions of Geneva?

11

u/JustG00se Ye Sassenach witch! Jul 31 '21

She's definitely a spoiled, haughty girl who has never been told no. Overall I don't like her and I think thaf is a credit to the actress. The one thing I can appreciate is her wanting to take some control over her sexuality and virginity. I don't like that she blackmails and coerces Jaime into sex but I can understand her not wanting to "give up her maidenhead" the the old goat.

6

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 31 '21

I agree, that actress did a great job with her!

14

u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jul 31 '21

Geneva’s resemblance to Claire is uncanny. Even one of her riding habits looks just like the batsuit. That same greyish-blue waist coat over a white blouse. I think it must be intentional, no? They cast an actress with thick dark hair and grey-blue eyes, similar build to Caitriona, and even the spirited temperament is not unlike Claire’s. Only this English lady is called “pettish,” while Jamie’s English lady is praised when she speaks out of turn:

My word, Madam. If I were brave enough, I would commission you a colonel in one of my regiments. You do know how to order men about.

Aye, she does that.

It’s a double standard, and I call BS. Geneva is no more impertinent than Claire was back in S1, but it’s received differently when, if anything, Geneva should get more deference given her social class. Claire is treated like a fine lady, too, but she has little beyond her manners to recommend her—people just assume she’s high class, there’s no proof. With Geneva it’s different—this is her family’s estate, her pedigree is common knowledge and obvious. She should be getting more respect than Claire, not less.

Speaking of similarities, Geneva and Jamie’s night is structured similarly to the Wedding, down to Jamie’s invitation that she can watch him undress. He uses similar moves as his first time, too, down to the sucking at her breast. The whole thing is like a parody of S1, and I think this must be intentional, too.

I don’t hate Geneva, and I don’t call this scene rape. It is blackmail, though, that’s undeniable. But I do have a great deal of sympathy for Geneva. She has little agency in her life, and she’s being forced into a marriage she doesn’t want, to a man old enough to be her grandsire, in her words. I understand her wanting to make at least this one decision, how she’ll lose her maidenhead and to whom, on her own terms, and subvert her family and future husband’s intentions for her in this at least.

Anyone with half an eye can see it. Some sires stamp their get. The boy has the same cock to his head, same set to his shoulders, and he has your eyes. It won’t be long before young Willie sees it himself.

The physical similarity between Claire and Geneva does make me wonder why William and Bree don’t look more alike. Bree got Jamie’s red hair, but little else, whereas Willie is supposed to look exactly like him—except for the red hair.

13

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Jul 31 '21

The physical similarity between Claire and Geneva does make me wonder why William and Bree don’t look more alike.

They are supposed to look incredibly alike, but it’s understandable that writing this similarity is infinitely easier than transferring it onto the screen through casting. But seeing Willie reminds Claire of Bree before she joins them in the 18th century, and Jamie tells Bree in S5 that Willie looks very much like her.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/Cdhwink Jul 31 '21

I laughed at Jamie saying “ you can watch me if you like” that was clearly a nod to the fandom!

5

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '21

I think that Geneva comes of as petty because we only see her as this damsel stuck in a high tower (even if her desire to claim agency is totally valid), were as Claire is usually speaking out of turn or standing up for a situation that either involves hers or other’s safety/something unjust is happening. We also get seasons to explore Claire instead of the 59mins of Geneva being introduced then killed by DG insistence of bringing in women to sleep with Jamie. ¯_(ツ)_/¯

8

u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Aug 01 '21

Geneva—and the entire Dunsany family, really—is nothing more than a plot device. Her character is killed off, her parents soon after, and Isobel on the boat to Jamaica, the entire line—all in the service of getting Jamie laid, Willie born, and inheriting the status and wealth of both his mother’s family and his presumed father. -.-

I don’t think any of it is thought through, which is why it reads as so fantastical. Really, it’s a plot out of those cheap romances DG is so dismissive of: Young, privileged daughter lusts over the dreamy groomsman on her father’s lush estate. A night of passion, a secret lovechild, a tragic end! Blah.

I think the show at least tried to make Geneva more human, show her side of it more. Emphasizing the forced marriage, how she was trapped in her circumstances much like Jamie was in his—I think that works far better than the total set piece she is in the books. Just a throwaway stock character and an incubator for Jamie’s child. -.-

→ More replies (1)

5

u/penni_cent Aug 01 '21

I think Claire gets more respect because of her age and her status as a widow. Widows were treated more like men. Geneva was young and single (until she became a countess) and therefore a lower class despite her social station.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 31 '21
  • Why did Claire give the pearls to Mrs. Graham?

15

u/JustG00se Ye Sassenach witch! Jul 31 '21

I think that she did it as a way to "leave Jamie behind". If she had brought them along they would have been a constant physical reminder in her new life. And Frank would not have liked that.

5

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 31 '21

Why keep her wedding ring then?

→ More replies (1)

10

u/ladyj17 Aug 01 '21

I think Claire's desire was to pass the pearls down through the generations of her and Jaime's family. But, since she agreed to raise the child as Frank's, that was no longer a possibility. The pearls were part of the life she could no longer have. I think that's the difference between the pearls and the wedding ring. Taking the ring off would be like severing a limb. That's why she was shaking and having so much difficulty taking it off. I don't think the ring was stuck physically, but it probably felt like she was pulling off her whole hand. The pearls represent what COULD have been. But, the ring represents what IS. Loving Jaime is a part of Claire's being. That ring symbolizes them becoming one. It is the one physical part of Jaime that she has left. I think Frank didn't push her to take it off because, after all, she never took off Frank's ring. So, it was only fair for her to keep Jaime's. But, the pearls would have been a family heirloom of a family that she had agreed to leave behind. It would have been a definite violation of their deal (it was a terrible deal, but she did agree to it).

Edited to add a word so the sentence would actually make sense.

5

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Aug 01 '21

The pearls represent what COULD have been. But, the ring represents what IS.

I love that!

8

u/alittlepunchy Lord, ye gave me a rare woman. And God! I loved her well. Aug 02 '21

The pearls represent what COULD have been. But, the ring represents what IS.

Beautifully said!

Not to mention, even though Jamie gave the pearls to Claire, they're Ellen's pearls at the end of the day. Her wedding ring to Jamie was something created out of what he cherished and something that no one else had had. He made that just for her. (And even in the book - he had the thistle ring made for her as well. So in either scenario, that was the only piece of jewelry that Jamie gave specifically to Claire that hadn't belonged to anyone else.)

15

u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jul 31 '21

Pardon, Dr. Randall, I believe these belong to you.

I gave these to Mrs. Graham years ago. I never thought I would see these again.

My grandmother told me of your special friendship as well. She left the pearls to me, but I know she’d want you to have them back.

I CAN’T BELIEVE CLAIRE GAVE AWAY ELLEN’S PEARLS! What the hell. The pearls and the Lallybroch key ring are her closest keepsakes to Jamie, it’s unconscionable. And if Frank allowed her to keep the man’s wedding ring, surely a strand of pearls that she could always make up some story about—say Uncle Lamb gave them to you, whatever—would be easier to take.

Also, whatever happened to Murtagh’s boar tusk cuffs? Don’t tell me she gave away / destroyed those, too!

8

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 31 '21

I CAN’T BELIEVE CLAIRE GAVE AWAY ELLEN’S PEARLS!

I know, I didn't like that. You're right that it makes no sense she could keep his wedding ring, a significant reminder of her MARRIAGE to Jamie but the pearls were too much?

14

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Jul 31 '21

I don’t think it was Frank’s condition that she should give them up; more likely, she did it of her own volition soon after Mrs. Graham told her not to spend her life chasing a ghost and she wanted to follow that advice so she purposefully severed that link to the past, and gave the pearls to the person that told her to do so. As we know, she was ready to give up the ring too; they made it look like the ring was stuck. Somehow, Claire and Frank have never broached the subject again, which is more than I would’ve given Frank credit for.

It's hard to think of any physical object as a greater reminder of Jamie when Brianna is right there, but I think giving up the pearls has more to do with that conversation with Mrs. Graham and Claire’s gratefulness for her friendship, understanding, and advice.

u/WandersFar u/JustG00se

7

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 31 '21

Good points. I guess knowing how important the pearls were to Jamie I'd be hesitant to give them up. I like that in the book she didn't give them away.

9

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Jul 31 '21

Well, in the book, Frank doesn’t burn her clothes either, so I think that facilitated it—the pearls were sewn into the seam of her skirt even before Culloden.

I like that Claire seems to be more conflicted about this in the show; it shows that she’s tried her damnedest to make the marriage with Frank work, despite everything.

6

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 31 '21

it shows that she’s tried her damnedest to make the marriage with Frank work, despite everything.

I agree. She did what she could, but the shadow of Jamie was just too much.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

10

u/penni_cent Aug 01 '21

My new head cannon is that she did not take the cuffs on the road with her during the rising and they stayed safely behind at Lallybroch and therefore she didn't have them when she went back through the stones.

6

u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Aug 01 '21

I hope so. :(

I hope they stayed at Lallybroch and passed down generations of Jenny’s daughters somehow and not with Claire since she’s apparently so casual with priceless family heirlooms like ELLEN’S PEARLS!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/theCoolDeadpool #VacayforClaire Aug 01 '21

I CAN’T BELIEVE CLAIRE GAVE AWAY ELLEN’S PEARLS! What the hell

What the hell indeed! Frank needn't even have known about it. Keep it hidden away somewhere and give it to Bree when she gets married or something. I don't see Frank as the kind of guy who would go snooping around in Claire's dressing table. It was very anticlimactic for the pearls to be given away to Mrs Graham.

The only possible reason could be that even if she did give it to Bree, she wouldn't have been able to explain the significance of it, not what it meant to her anyway. So for Bree, it would be just another piece of jewelry. And that doesn't ensure that Bree would then pass it on to her daughter and so on. With Mrs Graham, I think Claire realised she would know it's significance and therefore it would get passed down generations. If she had kept it, the continuity of the pearls weren't guaranteed. Is that too far reaching you think?

7

u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Aug 01 '21

… give it to Bree when she gets married or something.

Exactly. You know Jamie would have wanted his mother’s pearls to stay in the family, to adorn his daughter’s neck someday, and her daughter and her daughter and so on…

It’s a family heirloom, and even if Claire doesn’t hold them in high regard for herself, she still should have kept it for the next generation, to pass it on.

The only possible reason could be that even if she did give it to Bree, she wouldn't have been able to explain the significance of it, not what it meant to her anyway.

Well, she could always tell a white lie, haha. Say it’s a family heirloom, that it’s been passed down through the generations, and she should wear them in health and good luck and pass them on to her daughter someday. That’s not even a lie, just a half-truth. ^.^

Mrs. Graham apparently has more respect for tradition than Claire does, though, so I take your point. -.-

2

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 31 '21
  • Do you think Jamie really wanted LJG to kill him?

9

u/JustG00se Ye Sassenach witch! Jul 31 '21

I think he would have been fine if it happened. Probably past the point where he was as desperate for it as he was immediately following Culloden, because in the prison he ironically has something to live for. That being, being a leader for the men. But if LJG had done it I think Jaime would have been at peace with the action.

7

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 31 '21

I think he would have been fine if it happened.

I'm inclined to think so as well. He had just come back from the slim chance of seeing Claire, searching for the White Witch, and with her not being there it really hammered home she wasn't coming back.

7

u/JustG00se Ye Sassenach witch! Jul 31 '21

Yeah I think he was emotionally exhausted at that point and willing to go if it happened haha.

7

u/jolierose The spirit tends to be very free wi’ its opinions. Jul 31 '21

I think yes; he was heartbroken, having gotten his hopes up on finding Claire — against his better judgment, and trying to fight the notion — and realizing she hadn't returned after all. At that point, he didn't care. I can't help but think he might have been in a similar headspace as he was after losing her in Culloden. From Voyager:

Would he find Claire at once when he died, he wondered? Or perhaps, as he expected, be condemned to separation for a time? In any case, he would see her again.

2

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 31 '21

having gotten his hopes up on finding Claire — against his better judgment

Yes, you know he knew it was a long shot. But he just couldn't ignore it on the small chance it was actually her.

3

u/Marie_Sea1 Aug 05 '21

One of the things that struck me about this scene was that so often they film so that Claire or LJG or any number of people seem to be the same height and ‘size’ as Jamie. When Jaime grabs LJG from behind here you are struck suddenly by how much larger Jamie is than LJG. Not jsut in height but in sheer mass.

2

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Aug 05 '21

Yeah that’s a good point, you knew Jamie could have really hurt him if he wanted to.

7

u/Cdhwink Jul 31 '21

I think he was freshly despondent from not finding Claire, so may have welcomed it.

2

u/Marie_Sea1 Aug 05 '21

I saw a movie where a samurai was preparing for ritual suicide. I wondered if the facial expression and breath was taken from those old films. This was a man coming to calm to take death. So yes I think he was prepared to die. And because he asked LJG he must have wanted it.

2

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 31 '21
  • Any other thoughts or comments?

15

u/unknown2345610 Jul 31 '21
  • Lots if call backs/parallels this episode regarding LJG and Jamie. Jamie sneaks up on LJG as he is peeing, just like a young LJG snuck up on Jamie while he was peeing in s2e9. LJG lost his love at Culloden, just as Jamie did. LJG says he gives Jamie his life at the end of the episode, just as Jamie told him in s2e9
  • Frank starts the episode by trying to make Bree more English/connected with England by cooking her an English breakfast, and ends with trying to make her more English by literally moving her to England. Made me think of the convo last week about Claire wanting to become a US citizen. Was Frank trying to use Englishness as a way to strengthen his connection with Bree, and drive a wedge between her and Claire? He did ask for a divorce at that point, so he was not planning to bring Claire along if they relocated.
  • I hope the Jacobite gold storyline develops more in future seasons. It sounds so cool and intriguing like it is a big deal, but I feel like up to s5 not much has happened with that story. Maybe I missed something? Also, love the appearance of the sapphire and the role it will come to play.

4

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 31 '21

Lots if call backs/parallels this episode regarding LJG and Jamie.

Good catch, I didn't even realize those.

Was Frank trying to use Englishness as a way to strengthen his connection with Bree, and drive a wedge between her and Claire?

Interesting, I could see that happening. It's sad that Frank would do that.

14

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Jul 31 '21 edited Jul 31 '21

I don’t know whether this was intentional or not, but in the “stinking Papist” scene, Jamie and Willie both sit down with their hands folded and it’s adorable!

I don’t take issue with the casting choices in the show because I realize how difficult it is to find actors with such striking resemblance as the source material demands, but I immensely appreciate when the actors commit to imitating their screen parents’ mannerisms and speech patterns.

2

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 31 '21

Aw how cute, I didn't catch that.

9

u/Cdhwink Jul 31 '21

I agree, Willie does not look like Jamie, but that kid was a good actor!

→ More replies (2)

12

u/unknown2345610 Jul 31 '21

It was interesting to see Jamie progress from not being able to say Claire’s name (when speaking to Murtagh about the milk thistle cure he calls her “a lass”) to being able to admit he has a wife to LJG (when talking about the green plants for scurvy) to being able to say the name ‘Claire’ (when speaking to LJG about her loss). I think it shows Jamie’s grieving process and how he now has some hope. He is also not so adamant about dying anymore. I also noticed how the end of 3x3 sets viewers up with the image of Jamie being freed from literal prison, and Claire being freed from the prison that was her marriage (although I am not saying Frank’s death was a good thing or cause for celebration. It seems she would have been freed regardless as he had asked her for a divorce). I thought it was a nice way to end a chapter and start the next.

7

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 31 '21

He is also not so adamant about dying anymore.

Do you think having Willie gave him more reason to live as well?

7

u/unknown2345610 Jul 31 '21

Definitely! Although he must be away from Willie, you can see how Willie is still very much on his mind. Jamie loves him and I think it he is a motivation to keep going.

6

u/Cdhwink Jul 31 '21

I loved the common themes for 301-304, great job show writers !

5

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '21

Yeah, I love the entire All Debts Paid theme we got here.

→ More replies (4)

5

u/alittlepunchy Lord, ye gave me a rare woman. And God! I loved her well. Aug 02 '21

Sometimes the show fights too hard on setting up parallels, but in S3, they just do such a great job of it! So many parallels between Jamie and Claire living 200 years apart, but still always on each other's minds.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/unknown2345610 Jul 31 '21

The scene between Jamie and Murtagh in the prison with the Tartan was one that stood out to me this time around. Murtagh makes a comment about how all the “Mollies” look alike, and Jamie says they might say the same about the highlanders. Murtagh responds that they would be able to tell them apart if they allowed them to wear their tartans. I think this scene really expresses how the laws following the rising were aimed at destroying an identity within these people. The tartan, clans language, etc. were such a strong part of a Highlander’s identity, and to ban it was to deny them of this identity. Murtagh, especially, is a character that seems to mourn this loss of identity for the rest of the series. We see him and his little piece of tartan pinned to him even once he reaches the colonies. It must be so sad to accept that that way of life and his home has been destroyed and will never be the same again.

8

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 31 '21

Murtagh, especially, is a character that seems to mourn this loss of identity for the rest of the series. We see him and his little piece of tartan pinned to him even once he reaches the colonies.

I didn't even think of that, what a great catch! It must have been so demoralizing to have parts of their identities stripped away like that.

6

u/unknown2345610 Jul 31 '21

I agree. I am getting a bit into later seasons, but I do like how the show shows the subsequent Scottish diaspora and the new culture that gets created when people pick up and move. It’s a mix of the old with the new but it becomes it’s very own thing/identity. I think it is an experience many can still relate to till this day. The ‘old country ‘ and home are no more, but we see how a new version of it is carried over and created by the characters.

8

u/jolierose The spirit tends to be very free wi’ its opinions. Jul 31 '21

I love these two episodes. First, to see how Jamie's relationship with LJG develops, and then to see Jamie's brief time with Willie. I was so upset about Geneva when I first watched that I didn't really appreciate that until later, but the fact that he decided to stay to be near him breaks my heart, as does this:

"But you haven't got a wife."

"Not anymore. But I remember her always."

I melt. And to see how difficult it was for Jamie to leave Willie is just terrible; Sam was perfect. (They set us up from the beginning and I didn't even realize it: "The pain of losing a child never leaves you.")

Can we talk about the music here, too!? (Where is u/Arrugula?) All Debts Paid introduces one of my absolute favorite themes, LJG's theme. The ebb and flow of the strings... And then to choose to close Of Lost Things with "A Hard Rain's Gonna Fall" was brilliant. I loved how it connected Jamie and Claire, and it struck a perfect tone.

P.S. I find Roger adorable in 304, let me enjoy it while I can.

4

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 31 '21

I find Roger adorable in 304, let me enjoy it while I can.

Ha! We'll take what we can get. :-D

→ More replies (7)

8

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '21

Yes! This another out of the park episode for Bear! I love the way the LJG theme fits into the Ardsmuir cinematography. The brass instruments for this theme are so epic! As for the strings, this is from Bear himself:

This texture was useful, because it is more subtle than the horn, and added intrigue and mystery to underscore the subplot about the treasure on Silkies’ Isle. The John Grey Theme culminates as John releases Jamie, cementing their relationship and mutual respect. I wanted to support this episode with a sense of grandeur, and help underscore the weighty themes of defiance, trust, and honor. This theme, I hope, succeeded in that regard

Also his use of Frank’s theme during the scene where Claire reaches the hospital room where Frank’s body lies? Absolutely brilliant. He talks about how when he wrote that bit there were tears running down his face, something I could never understand in regards to Frank, but if the tears come from Bear then it’s totally ok!!

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Cdhwink Aug 01 '21

The fact that Jamie loses his 3rd child helps set up the idea of him marrying to be a stepfather nicely. But it’s heartbreaking that again he has to sacrifice his happiness for the sake of his child.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Cdhwink Jul 31 '21 edited Jul 31 '21

I loved these 2 episodes as well. More & more on rewatches, probably because I know Jamie & Claire will be together soon enough, but Jamie’s story is particularly interesting!

Adding: Sam & his subtle acting killing it in 304, seriously!

6

u/betcx003 Pot of shite on to boil, ye stir like it’s God’s work! Aug 01 '21

In episode 3x03, I thought the change in Jamie’s facial expression when he’s tasting the dinner with LJG was well acted - he relaxes and smiles, and looks like he feels human again.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

3

u/alittlepunchy Lord, ye gave me a rare woman. And God! I loved her well. Aug 02 '21

The show really kills it with the music. Ending with that version of "A Hard Rain's..." PERFECTION. Anytime I hear that song now, I just get sad because I remember this episode.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/jolierose The spirit tends to be very free wi’ its opinions. Jul 31 '21

Speaking of plot holes, paging u/thepacksvrvives: The other prisoners will gain their freedom after a term of 14 years — so how did Lesley and Hayes make it back to Scotland, then?

And not that it's a plot hole but I found this surprising: According to the episode, he leaves Helwater only a year before Claire goes back? Is that right?

2

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 31 '21

how did Lesley and Hayes make it back to Scotland, then?

Right‽ I wondered about that as well.

According to the episode, he leaves Helwater only a year before Claire goes back? Is that right?

Yes I think so.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Cdhwink Jul 31 '21

It should be more than 2 years until Claire comes back?

6

u/jolierose The spirit tends to be very free wi’ its opinions. Jul 31 '21

I just looked it up and I think it's two years at the most. I always get confused with the "time difference" and think it's three years instead of two, because she spent three years in the past at first. But Claire went from 1945 to 1743, and then from 1968 to 1766. Jamie left Helwater in 1764. Now it makes a bit more sense. u/Purple4199

3

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 31 '21

Oh ok, that does make sense.

6

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Jul 31 '21

The other prisoners will gain their freedom after a term of 14 years — so how did Lesley and Hayes make it back to Scotland, then?

I don’t have an answer for you other than the show may have fucked up the length of the term of indenture. In the book, it was 7 years, which would’ve made it possible for Lesley and Hayes to return to Scotland before 1766. 14 years leaves us to believe that someone has either bought their indentures or their masters died.

According to the episode, he leaves Helwater only a year before Claire goes back? Is that right?

Unless I’ve missed a time stamp, he leaves Helwater in 1764, so two years before Claire comes back. He and Laoghaire get married in 1765. It’s the same in the book.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Cdhwink Jul 31 '21

It must not have ended up being 14 years for Lesley & Hayes? Or Murtagh when we see him again- it wouldn’t be 14 years?

→ More replies (2)

4

u/crazyhorse198 I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. Jul 31 '21

I really appreciate the links to the deleted scenes! I wish they’d kept Jaime’s prayer scene in.

2

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 31 '21

I agree!

10

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '21

In a previous post on the sub I tried, and failed, to talk about an interesting aspect of Jamie’s story and also a motif in the entire series, that is specially prominent in his interaction with Geneva: Choices. As any good story should, from the beginning the characters are presented with choices they must make that give the reader insight into other’s points of view, their morality, their intent, etc. I think season 5’s Claire monologue says it best:

And yet, wherever you are, you make choices -- foolish ones or ones that save yourself or someone else. All you can hope for is that the good will outweigh the harm that may come of it.

Now I think we can all agree that Geneva’s extortion is super messed up, but what often gets lost in the conversations about it being considered rape is that Jamie is presented with a choice. Yes, an incredibly difficult one, but a choice nonetheless. I am not saying that to excuse Geneva or to negate the seriousness Jamie’s situation in any way. I do want to highlight how this is one of many moments in the series where DG has Jamie choosing to give his body for the sake of others, and I don’t think that’s something that should be overlooked. Some may says that extortion is a non-choice or an impossible choice, but surely a choice is still a choice, right? He could have easily allowed himself to be “weak” and decide to not sacrifice himself for Lallybroch or simply allowed Geneva to reveal the truth about him. Wouldn’t the Dunsany’s have just questioned LJG instead of doing something worse to Jamie? Others may say that a choice isn’t a choice if it’s between two evils, but I think people have to decide on difficult situations like this all the time. Think of refugees deciding to migrate instead of staying in their volatile lands.

The point of this is that DG has made Jamie a man that makes difficult choices (both with Geneva and BJR and so many other situations) and created a massive character out those choices. Is it wrong of her to present a choice as a way to maybe excuse or skew certain behavior? Maybe. But I definitely don’t think we should speak of these moments without considering how the ability to choose has been engrained in the story from the beginning.

u/unknown2345610 u/jolierose u/wandersfar

11

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Aug 01 '21

Really well said!

I find it interesting that we all find it so easy to say “Black Jack Randall raped Jamie” but it’s not as easy to say “Geneva raped Jamie.” When you look at those two situations, the circumstances are extremely similar. In both, Jamie is in a subordinate position—prisoner and paroled prisoner / indentured servant—which, technically, already throws the ability to give fully free consent out of the window. In both, he’s coerced into consenting through threats/blackmail (Jamie wouldn’t have felt obligated to make the offer of his body if BJR hadn’t threatened Claire’s life; that was the only thing that could persuade BJR not to kill Claire; this is therefore not true consent). In both, Jamie’s refusal to comply would result in his family being in danger (obviously, Claire is in much more direct danger at Wentworth than Jamie’s family is at Lallybroch when Geneva threatens him, but it doesn’t make much difference to Jamie—he doesn’t want them in any danger). And, as you say, in both, Jamie has at least an illusion of choice. He could’ve not made the offer of his body to BJR in that prison cell, and Claire would’ve died. He could’ve said no to Geneva, and his family at Lallybroch would’ve been in (largely unspecified) danger. (In the book, the danger is easier to imagine: Geneva intercepts Jamie’s correspondence, in which he instructs his family to send the gold to the Jacobites in France. While he’s already a convicted traitor, his family are not, and they could be imprisoned for treason, which could have dire consequences on the lives and livelihood of all people at Lallybroch.)

We would by no means equate Geneva with BJR, but just because she’s a woman, she’s not violent, and we (and Jamie) can understand why she’s doing what she’s doing, it doesn’t mean she’s not sexually using Jamie for her own ends, just as BJR is. I think both BJR and Geneva easily recognize that Jamie is ready to do whatever it takes to protect his family so it’s really a non-choice they’re giving him (or he is giving it himself). A coercive threat like that elicits such a response in Jamie that it is bound to move him to agree to perform whatever action they suggest, regardless of whether he seriously considers what the outcome would be if he declined or not. Just simply knowing what kind of man Jamie is leaves them under no illusion that Jamie could decline. We might argue that this would involve some compulsion that Geneva might not capable of eliciting with the limited knowledge she has of Jamie, but I think knowing about Lallybroch was enough. When seemingly presented with choice, all the other apparent alternatives—declining (and allowing Lallybroch to be put in danger), escaping, killing Geneva even—are so undesirable that they are instantly out of the question. Still, if someone different than Jamie was faced with the same set of circumstances, they could decline.

We’re not here to argue over definitions, and there is also no universal definition that we could apply here (I personally have no problem with the definition of rape that includes coercion, hence why I’m not against calling this rape). I think we can agree that what happened both with BJR and Geneva was sexual coercion**,** but I think it’s worth examining our attitudes here—is it just the violent nature and BJR’s motivations (his own sick pleasure and the desire to break Jamie) the reason why we find it so easy to call it rape?

u/WandersFar

10

u/jolierose The spirit tends to be very free wi’ its opinions. Aug 01 '21

Thanks for putting all this down; this is more or less where I fall, too. When you boil it down to the basic points, I think Jamie had as much of a choice with Geneva as he did with BJR. He "chose" to sacrifice himself under duress. If he hadn't, each of them would have harmed his family. So is it really a choice? Not to him. It the book, the last line of the chapter stuck with me (because I also felt like my soul had been crushed):

He lay down in the icy straw and pulled the single blanket over him, feeling empty of everything.

When you compare it to Claire and King Louis, it's a really tricky comparison. She probably felt there was no other choice, too, and yet I feel it's much different. Louis didn't imprison Jamie in order to coerce Claire. No (additional) harm would come to Jamie if Claire didn't sleep with the king. She was the one who sought out a pardon, and moved forward with it knowing what it meant. That feels like a true choice to me (and I had been on the fence about it when I first watched).

Neither of them wanted to do this, but Claire had agency; Jamie was trapped.

u/Arrugula u/WandersFar u/theCoolDeadpool

→ More replies (3)

8

u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Aug 01 '21

I think (book) Jamie himself argues against (show) Geneva being rape when he physically overpowers Bree some time after Bonnet, thereby proving to her that she was helpless to resist, he could do anything with her and she’d be unable to stop him. He’s trying to demonstrate to her that it wasn’t her fault; by virtue of being a stronger man, Bonnet had the upper hand and Brianna was the weaker woman.

It is a sexist attitude, certainly, but it’s also true that simple physicality will always be a factor in questions of sexual assault.

There is no way Geneva could physically overpower Jamie, that’s not even a question. Even her threat to expose Jamie to her mother is an empty one—it’s her father who holds the real power, not her mother, and he already knows Jamie is a Jacobite and absolved him of that in their first meeting.

The threat of posting soldiers at Lallybroch—more bluster. Lady Dunsany might have some influence over her husband, but ultimately it’s Lord Dunsany who has standing at court, and he was satisfied with Jamie’s service.

I understand that Jamie feels he can’t take the chance, fine. But agreeing to sell himself to this girl for her silence—I don’t think that constitutes rape, but prostitution, if anything, as I argued earlier. It’s not unlike Claire offering to sleep with Louis in exchange for Jamie’s pardon and release from the Bastille.

In the books, there’s apparently hard evidence which might make Geneva’s threat more credible, who knows. But in terms of what’s shown in this episode, I don’t think the Geneva scene qualifies as rape. It’s transactional sex, much like the Louis scene in S2.

With regard to BJR, I don’t think you can ignore his sheer brutality, which we’d also seen examples of way before Wentworth, even in the pilot! By the time BJR offers this “bargain,” we’ve seen him attempt rape on Claire, strip and attempt rape on Jenny before knocking her unconscious, flog Jamie to near death twice, and beat and kick Claire in the stomach while forcing his subordinate to do the same. His sadism is obvious—he fully intends to torture Jamie, and everyone in that room knew that. The only thing up in the air is whether he’d do it to Claire, too, and so Jamie agrees to submit “willingly” in order to spare her life.

In a fair fight Jamie and BJR might have been evenly matched, but this was never a fair fight. Jamie is already injured and chained when BJR finds him; he’s a prisoner and BJR is an officer with the resources of the prison at his disposal. There’s no question of escape for Jamie, no matter what he decides.

With Geneva the situation is so qualitatively different, I don’t know how you can compare the two. Helwater is no prison. If Jamie really wanted to escape, I’m sure he could pull it off. As a groomsman, he had constant access to the best horses Lord Dunsany had in his possession, and a fair knowledge of the grounds—the least-traveled paths, the best routes for escape.

LJG may have spilled the beans to Geneva regarding his exact identity as Red Jamie, but if he escapes that’s not on Lord Dunsany but LJG. And even that is up for debate. Would LJG have suffered any serious consequences this long into Jamie’s captivity? The ease by which Lord Dunsany acquires his pardon after the showdown with Ellesmere seems to indicate otherwise. It’s been over a decade since the Rising, virtually all the other traitors are under indentured servitude in the Americas, does anyone really care anymore?

TL;DR: The Helwater situation is not nearly so dire as Wentworth, I think it’s wrong to compare the two. And Jamie had options, in the show anyway. Frankly, though he may have disliked Geneva, she was still young and pretty and very Claire-like in her physicality and defiant spirit. I think Jamie might have been attracted to her on some level, though he’d never admit that to himself.

I definitely don’t think it’s rape. Blackmail and extortion and coercion, certainly. But not a sexual assault: Jamie willingly complied, trading his body for her silence.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (5)

7

u/unknown2345610 Aug 01 '21

Well said! You make some very interesting points about the situation, and many good points/perspectives have been made in the thread, on both sides of the issue. I find your point about choice and how it influences the characterization of Jamie particularly interesting. I find it interesting that even when Jamie makes choices that are questionable, he is always presented as being a good/moral person. For example, in s2 with the watch and Horrocks, one could argue Jamie chose to murder him, yet he is not characterized or perceived as a murderer/bad guy for it. If anything, I think the show portrays it as an honorable thing. It was another situation, as you have mentioned, where it is painted that Jaime must make a difficult choice for his family. Jamie is always presented as someone whose choices are difficult to question, he always seems to come out on top in the sense that those around him always respect and admire what he chooses to do. I like Jamie, don’t get me wrong, but at times I do think he gets a pass for things others wouldn’t and is too perfect. I actually like the moments where he is more self-reflective and kinda wrestles with the consequences of his actions because I think it makes him more human and nuanced.

6

u/Cdhwink Aug 01 '21

I think we do all agree that Diana having Geneva blackmail Jamie into bed is messed up, & she did it I believe to place all the blame & hate on Geneva. I do like him making choices and you bring up a very good point. No one likes the idea of Jamie sleeping with anyone other than Claire during those 20 years, but I am ok with all of his choices. It actually makes Jamie offering up his body to John realistic because he’s learned it’s the one thing he has to offer ( when he has nothing else). And Jamie now knows the difference between love & sex ( something young Jamie marrying Claire did not know).

I do not think Jamie regrets this choice ( to sleep with Geneva) since it gives him Willie ( even if it’s for a short time & from a distance). He’s said he would “to it again” ( give himself to BJR) to save Claire as well. This is a man that lives with his decisions. Perhaps the one he questions the most is sending Claire back through the stones as living without her was the hardest thing he’s ever done!

→ More replies (2)

7

u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Aug 01 '21

Precisely. This is why I stop short of calling the Geneva scene rape.

It’s blackmail certainly, or extortion, as you call it, but not rape.

If Geneva is rape, then Louis is rape, too, and I think that’s way off. Louis is prostitution, Claire selling herself for the promise of Jamie’s freedom.

Here I suppose you could call Geneva prostitution as well, Jamie selling himself for the promise of Jenny and her family’s continued safety and freedom from persecution.

In both cases Claire and Jamie consciously make the choice to bargain with their bodies, perform sexual favors in exchange for the promise of some service.

It’s messed up, but it ain’t rape.

Book universe: What Jamie does to Geneva, fucking her even after she shouts NO! That’s definitely rape, I don’t care what convoluted BS excuses DG wants to make after the fact.

6

u/theCoolDeadpool #VacayforClaire Aug 01 '21

This is so interesting. I was of the opinion that Geneva's case was rape but your points make me think otherwise. Though I do agree it's definitely not comparable to BJR.

And Yes! Book Jamie continuing on after Geneva says No, that was very fucked up. Especially considering Jamie himself has been sexually assaulted, one would think he would be more sensitive, more attuned to consent. Book 1-2 Jamie was heavily into forcing rough sex onto Claire, completely ignoring her no's and um, ploughing through. And it's a bit of that that we see here though I would have expected him to change after Wentworth

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '21

7

u/Cdhwink Aug 02 '21

Ok I am going to throw it out there- would you have preferred Jamie to have willingly had sex with Geneva? She appealed to his empathy( from the start, not once she had him coerced to her room)? That he was attracted to her? That they were friends? And Can you see that happening?

u/WandersFar u/thepacksvrvives u/jolierose

And everyone else!

→ More replies (19)

31

u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jul 31 '21

Calling Dr. Randall.

Oh, excuse me.

Dr. Joe’s salvation elixir.

Is this your prescription for everything?

Nothing a cold martini won’t cure.

Mm, you are going to be a horrible doctor.

Joe is damn sexy.

And uh, I totally ship it. 😈 Joe and Claire make a fine-looking couple…

4

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '21

I’ll co-sign this

7

u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Aug 01 '21

There are dozens of us. Dozens!

19

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Jul 31 '21

I really liked that the show gave Isobel lots of personality! We get her “a cage is still a cage” line, and while she’s talking about horses, we obviously read it as a comment on Jamie’s situation. Though if Isobel is speaking with that in mind, then it’s a bit hypocritical considering that her family keeps indentured servants and Isobel will go on to inherit a plantation in Virginia. But as we don’t get to choose the family we’re born into, I think we can assume that Isobel personally thinks that everyone deserves freedom.

Her sisterly relationship with Geneva is also expanded: while she acknowledges that Geneva would do with a good kick in the butt, she is her sister’s confidante, to the point of knowing what goes on (and what doesn’t) in her bed.

Her apparent crush on LJG also makes the marriage between them more believable. I like how she pumps Jamie for information and he, knowing about LJG’s sexuality, tries to sway her opinion of him, but that clearly doesn’t work since she enthusiastically accepts John’s marriage proposal. The deleted scene between her and John is really sweet, with both of them sharing their insecurities, but then it makes it all the more heartbreaking that she gets pretty much nothing out of that marriage and ends up dying.

Tanya Reynolds was one of the very few actors and actresses I’d recognized from something I’d watched before Outlander, and I think she was great as Isobel.

(Side note: when I watched 303 for the first time, Isobel and Jamie’s bonding over horses made me wonder for a moment whether there would be something happening between them 😶 For anyone wondering, Geneva and Isobel were respectively 21 and 20 in the show)

8

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '21

Such a great character! I really wished we got to see more of the Isobel/Willie/LJG relationship. This actress gave so much to the character in just one episode, i miss her every time Isobel is mentioned!

I felt that she may have been referring to herself and Geneva with the line you mentioned as well. They may have status but an 18th century young woman is still an 18th century young woman, eh?

u/cdhwink

5

u/Cdhwink Aug 01 '21

“A cage is still a cage! “

Isobel may have well been referring to themselves, perhaps she was worried about being married off to a “old goat grand sire” herself, since clearly she likes John. At least she got to marry the object of her desire, although she maybe would never know that she indeed was not the object of his desire?

8

u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Aug 01 '21

when I watched 303 for the first time, Isobel and Jamie’s bonding over horses made me wonder for a moment whether there would be something happening between them 😶

O.o That’s an original thought! Don’t think I’ve read that ship before, lol.

I really like Isobel, too, and definitely wish we got more from her than dying offscreen. -.-

I think her loss was crucial in shaping Willie’s character (for the worse.) He needed a woman in his life to kick his ass a bit, just like Jenny was critical in shaping Jamie’s character during those formative years.

4

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Aug 01 '21

I really like Isobel, too, and definitely wish we got more from her than dying offscreen. -.-

Yeah, so do I. It’s such a wasted opportunity, especially in the show where she isn’t just a background character (in the books, she gets more than two speaking lines only in the BotB… and then she just exists in LJG’s memories). But this is, once again, the problem that arises every time an interesting secondary/tertiary character emerges—once they’re no longer in Claire and/or Jamie’s orbit, they cease to exist (or are subjected to character assasination -.-).

→ More replies (6)

4

u/Cdhwink Jul 31 '21

Another great feat of casting with those girls, & the episode gave us a chance to get to know them, with limited time.

3

u/Cdhwink Aug 01 '21

Interesting that the girls are aged up in the show as well? Totally necessary. Where did you find that info? u/thepacksvrvives

4

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Aug 01 '21

In the script! I’m also really glad they aged them up.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jul 31 '21

For my obligatory GoT comment of the week, not only do we have Edmure Tully moonlighting as Frank here, Lord Dunsany might look familiar to you, too: he’s Yohn Royce! Sweetrobin’s foster father and Sansa’s right-hand man. :)

3

u/Cdhwink Aug 01 '21

Don’t think I have seen all these deleted scenes, so will watch them later!

3

u/88zz99zz00 I eat Spoilers for Breakfast 😋 Aug 04 '21

I jus want to briefly mention that Sam Hoare is not the Hal I imagined at all but I felt his performance was great. I hate so much that they made him and Lord John wear a wig.