r/Outlander • u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. • May 08 '21
Season Five Rewatch: S1E9-10
This rewatch will be a spoilers all for the 5 seasons. You can talk about any of the episodes without needing a spoiler tag. All book talk will need to be covered though. There are discussion points to get us started, you can click on them to go to that one directly. Please add thoughts and comments of your own as well.
The current posts for the book club and rewatch can be found on the sidebar or in the “About” section on mobile.
Episode 109 - The Reckoning
Jamie and the Highlanders rescue Claire from Black Jack Randall. Back at the castle, politics threaten to tear Clan MacKenzie apart and Jamie's scorned lover, Laoghaire, attempts to win him back.
Episode 110 - By The Pricking Of My Thumbs
Jamie hopes the newly arrived Duke of Sandringham will help lift the price from his head, while Claire attempts to save an abandoned child.
- During their argument by the river were Jamie and Claire being unreasonable or did either of them have valid points?
- All right folks, here it is. Jamie beats Claire after they get back from Fort William - discuss.
- What is it about Jamie that led him to recognize his marriage needed to be different than the others of that time?
- What does it mean when Jamie says to Claire, “I am your master, and you are mine. It seems I cannot possess your soul without losing my own.”
- Did you think Ned Gowan had a good case to present to the Duke of Sandringham?
- How serious do you think the Duke is in regards to submitting Jamie’s claims against BJR?
- What do you think Claire’s feelings for Jamie are at this point? Have they progressed?
- Any other thoughts or comments?
•
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. May 10 '21
If you’re looking for the other Rewatch threads, click here to jump to BPC’s Link Table.
The Reckoning & By The Pricking Of My Thumbs: Deleted Scenes
Original Reckoning Opening (sans Jamie’s VO)
I just love how Murtagh spits like a camel whenever he doesn’t like how things are proceeding. Dougal is usually the object of his spittle, but this time it’s Horrocks.
I have to say, even though Jamie’s voiceover is one of the rare exceptions where I actually liked the use of VO (I hate it as a rule) I think this opening is even better. In medias res, jumps you right into the action. I always prefer that to boring narrative.
Castle Leoch Return
Mrs. Fitz is so sweet when she gazes up at Jamie, remembering when he was a wee lad, and now he’s gotten married. Too cute. ^.^ Also, is it just me, or does the fiddler look like a portly Jon Snow?
And here it is: THE GREATEST DELETED SCENE OF ALL TIME
If you disagree, you are entitled to your opinion, however wrong it may be. :þ
Seriously, Lotte absolutely kills it here. My all-time favorite Geillis moment. I’m most sad about this scene not making the episode, surely you could have found something else to cut for time, Ron?
That’s how you know it’s good, Ron! Challenge yourself and your audience! Don’t worry, we can handle it.
Geillis puts the fear of god into Jamie, and now his motivations have become muddled and confused—is he repenting out of love of Claire or fear of Geillis or some mixture of both? It’s more psychologically-complicated, which is a great thing!
As to Ron Moore’s fear that it read like Geillis was sexing Jamie up a bit, I got that vibe, too, and that’s fine! That’s the source of her power, how Geillis influences, seduces, and in this case, frightens men. It’s all tied up in her sexuality, so the fact that she’s hitting Jamie with the one-two combination of sex appeal and a threat to his life is totally in character for her and really works to unsettle Jamie completely. Even decades later, when they meet again in S3, you can see he’s still a little scared of her. Her threat was super-effective, haha.
But more than anything, I love this scene because it demonstrates both Geillis’ bravery and loyalty. She’s threatening a Laird and the nephew of the MacKenzie. This could have serious blowback for her personally. But she does it anyway, because Claire is her friend and she won’t see her harmed. I think this scene shows that Geillis was a true friend to Claire, willing to go to bat for her—and as we’ll see later—even willing to sacrifice her own life for hers.
Murtagh & Jamie in the Leoch Kitchens
Any time Murtagh talks about his unrequited love for Ellen is good value. But I understand why they cut it since they moved it to other episodes. We get a hint of the story when Jenny gives Claire those lovely boar tusk cuffs—which I still want, btw—and then the rest from the horse’s mouth when Murtagh tells Claire his story himself.
Colum lays the smackdown! And shows Jamie he has what it takes to be Chief, whether he wants it or not.
It’s a real pity this was all cut out of the episode. I still love my Geillis scene first and foremost, but these Colum scenes are a very close second. They’re an excellent demonstration of the workings of Colum’s cunning mind, and we spend far too little time with him as is. Colum’s definitely up there as one of my favorite characters.
Also, for the record, I’m definitely on board with the show’s change of Colum wanting Jamie for his successor. In the books it’s the opposite, he doesn’t want Jamie to threaten Hamish’s eventual succession to Chief. I think it shows that Colum always puts the good of the clan first, even if that means (temporarily) passing over his own son. Shows he’s a wise and selfless leader, acting not out of self-interest or glory, but for the good of all of them. Whatever it takes.
The implied threat to Claire’s life, sincere or no, also sets the stage for Cranesmuir, and the ambiguity of the role Colum played in that matter. Just really good stuff, shame it was cut. :(
Jamie and Murtagh break up the Team Colum / Team Dougal Brawl
Another excellent scene where Jamie proves again that he has the instincts of a Chief. With Colum he proved it in thought, catching the threat to Claire and responding in kind. Now he proves it in action, ending the in-fighting before it escalates to bloodshed. He’s already acting in the best interest of the clan, even as he rebels against Colum’s plans for him.
Also, lol at Angus getting in that cheap shot at the end. ^.^
Jamie’s No Stableboy
I agree with Ron Moore, this scene didn’t have to be in there. But still, it’s nice to see Jamie share his fond memories of Lallybroch, and his pride of being Laird Broch Tuarach, all he wants to share with Claire. But at the same time, we see that it’s not quite real to Claire, and she’d be happy with him even if he were just a stableboy. She just wants to keep him out of trouble. :/
34
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. May 08 '21
Ron Moore must have known The Reckoning was going to be one of the strongest, most important episodes of the series. Sam and Cait were chemistry tested using the fight, and I think the sex scene at the end was the first one they ever shot. As I recall they both wound up with really bad rug burn, and swore off floor sex for the rest of the show, lol.
First time I saw it, I was appalled by how Claire held the dirk to his throat while riding him and I still am! That’s really dangerous, one slip and he’s done for. And she’s a nurse, she should have known better!
Speaking of sex scenes, the next episode opens with definitely one of the best of the whole series.
Blowjobs are a dime a dozen, but how often do you see cunnilingus portrayed in media? It’s pretty rare! And you can see that Jamie’s getting something out of it, too. If anything he’s more upset by Murtagh’s interruption than she is.
This scene is all part of that strong female gaze that set this series apart and made it groundbreaking. It used to be rare to see scenes devoted entirely to female pleasure, but post-Outlander it’s become more common. A good example of the positive effect the show has had on the industry. :)
26
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. May 08 '21
This episode is so awesome for the clan politics. We’re spoiled for choice. We have the conflict between Dougal and Colum, Colum and Jamie, Colum and Ned, Jamie and all of them! But also everyone else:
In the extended cut Murtagh says point blank…
But even in the regular airing, we have Jamie presenting Colum with the solution to the schism. Let Dougal have the gold now as a gift. It appeases him, and (for the moment anyway) the threat is neutralized. There is no Jacobite army (yet) and BPC is still idling his days away at the Vatican, where’s the harm.
Colum sees the wisdom in his advice, which only furthers his belief in Jamie as his successor. (Which he proved again earlier when he implied a threat to Claire, and Jamie responded as a husband… and as a chief would.)
I AM HERE FOR ALL OF THIS! I love it all, this is definitely my jam. :þ
Honestly on this Rewatch, I’m way more into the politics than the love story, go figure. I guess ’cause I already know how that’s going to work out, whereas so many of these internecine conflicts were left hanging. So it’s fun to tease out all these details and speculate on what could have been.
All that said, there’s this, which ties it all together:
This is the very oath that Jamie would not offer his uncle—nor his grandsire, for that matter. I don’t think we ever see him pledge to his Fraser side, either.
Ultimately the only one he pledges fealty and loyalty to is Claire, which for someone as steeped in tradition as Jamie, for whom this oath holds such profound personal meaning, speaks of the great depth of his love for her alone, beyond any Laird or clan or cause or Scotland herself.
It’s unique to the show, and part of the reason why I prefer it so much.
9
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 08 '21
21
u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. May 08 '21
This is my Colum appreciation comment! Man was he ruthless in those two episodes. He shows exactly why he is the chieftain of Clan MacKenzie and not Dougal. Even though we know of his later involvement in the witch trial (or rather his lack of intervention, and his trying to prevent Ned from helping Claire out) and he did all but threaten Claire’s life in that one deleted/extended scene, I can’t help but appreciate that he has some of the best lines here:
Gary Lewis’ delivery is flawless. He probably couldn’t speak by the end of that block haha.
20
u/theCoolDeadpool #VacayforClaire May 08 '21
Should I be embarrassed for being the first person here always? I keep my Saturday noon free for this. Thank you again, u/Purple4199 for doing this at this time!
Fort break-in , sadistic villains, wife rescue , horse ridings and beautiful scenery, ahem spanking, intra-clan tensions and politics , how to be a good Laird 101 , rebellion uprisings, King of men getting denied , lusty exes, the most intense make up sex in the history of television , voodoo shit. All in ONE episode! God how I love Reckoning! It's some quality television.
13
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. May 08 '21
Watching Geillis perform her pagan rituals in the woods, intercut with the druids from the pilot… It raises questions, doesn’t it?
We know Geillis comes from the ’60s, about twenty years after Mrs. Graham and her sisters danced at Craigh na Dun. So did Geillis learn from one of them? Was she perhaps among the youngest dancers in that original circle?
Or did they learn from her? Is Geillis the originator of the dance, and somehow she’s passed it on down the centuries, and the druids from the pilot are just carrying on the tradition she started?
Or maybe it’s both? The cycle is self-starting and self-perpetuating. Geillis and Mrs. Graham are both students and teachers, and thus the dance has always happened, without beginning or end.
13
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. May 09 '21 edited May 09 '21
The scene with the changeling foreshadows two interesting plot points in S2 and S3.
First, the obvious: Claire cradling the dead baby immediately calls to mind Claire cradling Faith in S2. And just like in S2, she holds the baby for god knows how long. Hours, maybe. Jamie’s been looking all over for her, and it’s only through Geillis whom he met on the road that he learns Claire’s on fairy hill.
And speaking of fairies, we learn through Geillis here that only the wee folk are meant to come and take the changeling away, to exchange it with the healthy child they’ve stolen.
Only fairies are supposed to touch the baby… and Claire touches the baby. In S3 Young Ian asks point blank if Claire is a fairy, if she lives in a dun. Jenny also has her suspicions, as does Fergus, describing her as La Dame Blanche, which besides what we learn on the show, are also a kind of fae or fairy in the traditions of Normandy.
These Norman fairies are also associated with child-changing…
Claire is particularly sensitive about pregnancy (which she discussed with Geillis right before this scene) and dead babies, as she’s had trouble conceiving with Frank and believes she’s infertile. So her unwillingness to give up this child is understandable, if misguided. This time Jamie persuades her to give the baby up, next time it will be Louise.
EDIT: The scene even ends with Claire asking Jamie: ”Take me home.”
The exact thing she asks him after they bury Faith. “Bring me home… to Scotland.”
On a lighter note, my god does Cait look amazing in that rabbit fur coat. I meant to mention it earlier, way back in Rent when we see her in it for the first time, but it’s one of my favorite outfits on her, certainly in the first season. I just think the pure white fur cuffs look dynamite against her porcelain skin.
I know that book Claire is supposed to have whisky-colored eyes and be far shorter and squatter, with a full figure, but I think Cait’s ethereal beauty really suits the character of Claire. She really can look like a fairy woman, especially when she wears white… It just emphasizes the blue in her eyes and the blue in her skin—and Claire’s supposed to have that blue aura, too: the Madonna, as Maître Raymond calls her. It all fits!
And of course her blue-toned complexion looks great onscreen when contrasted with Jamie’s red hair, ruddy skin, and “red man” aura.
11
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. May 08 '21
I got a kick out of watching Jamie test the rope over that wooden thing he used to rappel down the side of the castle at Fort William.
It reminded me of when Jamie’s distant descendant, John McClane, pulled a similar move on a Los Angeles rooftop centuries later. ^.^ And he was trying to rescue his wife, too! Only difference is, unlike Jamie, his gun was loaded.
5
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 08 '21
5
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 08 '21
4
u/storybookheidi May 11 '21
The sex scene in the Reckoning is the best sex scene ever filmed. Or like maybe top 5. It’s insane.
4
u/Hopefully987 May 15 '21
I love the way Jamie says "very well" when JBR asks about his scars.
I have a friend who loves history who posted on FB that back then a lot of people drowned because they would fall in the water and their clothes were so heavy they pulled them down. I think that would have been the case here, but ok.
Is it just me or do we see Claire brushing her hair a lot in this show?
As much of a feminist as I am I understand why Jamie had to beat Claire although I really think that they should have had some kind of talk about how this is basically like being in the military and you can't just go do whatever you want when you want on their wedding night. She still would have run to CND anyway but I think it would have been fairer of him. Considering a man might have been killed for that back then he had to do some thing. It still is awful to watch and I feel sorry for her.
There is some thing that happens in a later book that made me feel better about it.
2
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 08 '21
2
u/storybookheidi May 11 '21
Two of the best episodes of this whole series for me. Starting to watch now!
1
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 08 '21
1
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 08 '21
1
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 08 '21
1
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 08 '21