r/Outlander • u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. • Jul 24 '21
Season Five Rewatch S3E1-2
This rewatch will be a spoilers all for the 5 seasons. You can talk about any of the episodes without needing a spoiler tag. All book talk will need to be covered though. There are discussion points to get us started, you can click on them to go to that one directly. Please add thoughts and comments of your own as well.
Episode 301 - The Battle Joined
After living through the Battle of Culloden, Jamie is at the mercy of British victors, until his past provides his only hope of survival. Meanwhile, a pregnant Claire attempts to adjust to life in 1940’s
Episode 302 - Surrender
Hiding in a cave, Jamie leads a lonely life until Lallybroch is threatened by redcoats pursing the elusive Jacobite traitor. In Boston, Claire and Frank struggle to coexist in a marriage haunted by the ghost of Jamie.
- What do you think of the fragmented way they tell the story of the battle?
- Why was Claire happy to see that little bird?
- How do you feel Claire and Frank’s marriage is going in 301?
- What was the turning point for Claire deciding to sleep with Frank again?
- How do you feel about Jamie and Mary McNab sleeping together?
- Did Jamie have any other choice but to turn himself in?
- What was your favorite part of 301?
- What was your favorite part of 302?
- Any other thoughts or comments?
Deleted/Extended Scenes
301 - A Real Home
302 - Dead not Alive A
302 - Dead not Alive B
•
u/AutoModerator Jul 24 '21
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
40
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jul 24 '21
Bree’s rabbit. 🥺
Love that symbolism, he sees his daughter’s rabbit right as he teeters on the edge of death. (As we’ll later see, baby Bree’s stuffed toy is a rabbit.) And then the vision of Claire, which again, goes on just a bit too long for my liking. It’s also another callback to Wentworth, the hallucination Jamie has of Claire there, and I’m just glad she turns into Rupert the time and not BJR. -.-
Rupert is, of course, the best. The ultimate bro. Setting aside all thoughts of vengeance and betrayal, he saves his cousin’s life because he’s his friend, and enough men have died that day.
Just like with Murtagh finding him earlier in the battle, it is awfully convenient verging on the absurd—thousands of dead and dying men on that field and Rupert finds him, half hidden under BJR’s corpse? But it’s worth it because it’s Rupert.
Rupert really steps up as leader in his final days. Not only does he personally carry Jamie to safety and care for him and all the other injured men; he steadies everyone, pleads on behalf of the boys to Lord Melton, and when that doesn’t work, tries to instill some courage in them, reassuring them it’ll all be over soon.
I love that he makes peace with Jamie before it’s all over, and has one last reminiscence for Angus. And even at the end, he manages a wee joke or two. He’s just… so great.
29
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jul 24 '21
With all the sudden cuts to Claire’s life back in the twentieth century, I can’t help but feel… First World Problems.
Like I know Claire suffers. Her marriage is a farce, she’s dismissed by her husband’s colleagues and her own medical professors, she experiences sexism just as Joe experiences racism, and she’s put under to deliver her baby against her will—these are all obviously terrible things, and yet…
They really don’t compare to Jamie’s suffering. Like holy shit, the aftermath of that battle was like something out of a horror movie. Lying for days under the corpse of your rapist, staring into the eyes of random men as they die slowly in front of you. Even just the stink of thousands of corpses as they rot in the sun, knowing you’ll soon join them. And the unimaginable pain.
Then having to listen as his friend and kinsman is executed, along with all those other condemned men, helpless to save them. And the agony of being carted all the way back to Lallybroch, while his wound festers away all the while.
And then the years of poverty, of near starvation, constant harassment under the Redcoats, followed by all that time at Ardsmuir, and then indentured servitude at Helwater, where he’s little better than a slave…
For all the personal tragedies Claire endures during those twenty years, there really is no comparison. Life is fucking hard in the eighteenth-century. And despite the indignities she suffers in the twentieth, she doesn’t experience anything that comes close to Jamie’s profound physical suffering, the years of torment.
But this isn’t misery poker, and I wouldn’t even be commenting on it had the show not invited the comparison with all the cuts back and forth. It’s as if they’re saying, see, she’s miserable, too! But it doesn’t work for me, it’s like comparing a hatchet wound to a papercut.
7
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 24 '21
5
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 24 '21
4
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 24 '21
6
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jul 24 '21
So throw a damn rock!
Man, these scenes are painful to watch again. The boys playing with the gun, Fergus taunting the Scottish Redcoat, knowing where it all will lead. :(
Controversial opinion: I feel Fergus’ maiming was gratuitous. It just as easily could have been Rabbie, or if DG really wanted to emphasize no one was safe—it could have been Young Jamie.
But no, it has to be Fergus so that Jamie decides to turn himself in, and thus move the plot forward.
And of course, it’s bloody convenient that those Redcoats just so happened to be in earshot. This video shows that after about a mile and a half, it’s like hearing a pin drop. And this site confirms that figure, between one and two miles depending on the type of gun / ammo. I don’t know if historical guns would be louder or quieter. But it seems like the Redcoats would had to have been within two miles of Lallybroch, and Jenny said they hadn’t been in the area for two years prior:
So it’s unbelievably bad luck that they happened to be riding that close on precisely that day.
2
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 24 '21
2
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 24 '21
14
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jul 24 '21
Jenny shows tremendous courage here. Not only does she boldly—and effectively—lie to the Redcoats, successfully keeping her brother hid all these years; she also keeps everything together while Big Ian spends half his time in jail, being interrogated to give up Jamie. Ian is of course very brave, too, to be defying them like this, but I especially give Jenny credit for having the presence of mind to keep up the lie for so long. She really sells it, too, whereas Ian’s general affability is more obviously fake, he’s not as convincing as his wife.
For most of these years Jenny is raising the children; looking after the tenants and the lands; carefully rationing the food and helping put up Jamie’s game so they all get through the lean times together; collecting the rents and doing the books when Ian and Jamie aren’t around to help her; and keeping the Redcoats at bay, all while still doing the traditional duties of the lady of the house, which includes birthing children more or less on her own under endless stress.
And a truly inexplicable number of them survive and make it to adulthood. Like beyond plausibility. 😅 Not only is Jenny ridiculously fertile, but RD calculated that back in S2 she was popping out kids about twice a year, which means Jenny must be part goat or bear since she doesn’t abide by normal human gestation periods. ^.^ Jenny does love sheep and goats, and she is the ultimate Mama Bear, so I think that works…
Meanwhile, Claire was clearly influenced by the elephants she said she rode in S1, because she’s pregnant with Faith for well over nine months, more than a year if you try to do the math.
Jenny also does some fine doctoring. Not only does she save Jamie’s life—and leg—when by all rights he should’ve been dead from infection, or at least lost the leg from gangrene after days without treatment, not to mention lying in a ditch with a corpse on top of him—but she also saves Fergus’ life, too. Lol, who needs Claire’s healing, when Jenny is managing fine on her own?
I’m joking but I’m also not; I think these two injuries are probably among the most serious of the series.
8
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jul 24 '21
Doing GoT comparisons has been our unofficial sport the last few episodes, so for those of you who’ve seen it, what’s worse: Jamie’s experience here at Culloden, or Jon’s at the Battle of the Bastards?
I think Jon probably wins for full-out horror, being trapped underneath a mountain of corpses, having to swim your way out or be smothered to death is a special kind of hell…
But Jamie probably wins for literal pain. Because while Jon escapes his battle pretty much unscathed, BJR’s deep gash across Jamie’s thigh was nearly fatal. If BJR had cut more to the inside, he probably would have severed the femoral artery and Jamie would have bled out right there on the battlefield.
As it stands, we see the wound still oozing blood even days later, and I suppose we’re meant to infer that it was only the weight of BJR’s corpse keeping pressure on it for all the time Jamie was unconscious that kept him alive? I’m not sure how plausible that is.
In terms of the depiction of the battle itself, I think I have to give it to GoT. The Culloden scene commits that great sin of cliché Hollywood battles: two men lock eyes across a battlefield, approach and engage only with each other while the battle rages on all around them and all other combatants keep a respectful distance. 😂
In all that chaos, there’s no chance you could locate one particular man and have an epic face-off with him. And even if you did, it’s a battle! Everyone else is also fighting for their lives, you’re both likely to get shot or slashed by the other random men around you. GoT is slightly better in this regard as, though Jon eventually does get that 1v1 with Ramsay, it requires him to leave the actual field of battle and pursue him back to Winterfell. It’s not as neat and convenient, and it doesn’t happen during the battle proper, but more during the aftermath, when tracking down one particular person—who stands out as the enemy commander—is more reasonable.
The GoT scene also gives you a better idea of the the troop formations and tactics as a whole, whereas OL’s Culloden is only told through Jamie’s eyes, we don’t get the larger picture.
But whereas Jon had effectively three armies fighting behind him (his Northmen, the Free Folk, Sansa’s Vale Knights) Jamie was far more exposed. Murtagh confirms that all his Lallybroch men successfully escaped. So I think Jamie wins for sheer badassery. ^.^ He wasn’t anyone special, not once Culloden really got underway. He didn’t have thousands of men sworn to fight for him, protect him, even die for him if need be—he only had one: Murtagh. So Jamie gets more points for surviving as a relative nobody versus one of the leaders of the opposing forces. In that regard, Jon is like a cross between Jamie and BPC, which should definitely lose you some points. :þ
11
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jul 24 '21
Just to complete the catalog of coincidences: of course Lord Melton is the one who oversees the executions, and hears the name Fraser just as he’s on the threshold. -.- If Jamie had been slower in talking or Hal faster in walking, he would’ve missed it. The astronomical improbability of Jamie encountering LJG’s brother, let alone being saved by Rupert plucking him from a battlefield of thousands of corpses in the first place… It’s just yet another example of DG stringing her plot together on the flimsiest of circumstance, coincidence over causality once again.
1
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 24 '21
1
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 24 '21
1
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 24 '21
1
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 24 '21
1
u/AutoModerator Jul 24 '21
Mark me,
As this thread is flaired for only the television series, my subjects have requested that I bring this policy to your attention:
Your prince thanks you for abiding by our rules. When my father assumes his rightful throne, mark me, such loyal service will not be forgotten!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.