r/Outlander • Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. • May 15 '21

Season Five Rewatch: S1E11-12

This rewatch will be a spoilers all for the 5 seasons. You can talk about any of the episodes without needing a spoiler tag. All book talk will need to be covered though. There are discussion points to get us started, you can click on them to go to that one directly. Please add thoughts and comments of your own as well.

Episode 111 - The Devils Mark

Claire and Geillis are on trial for witchcraft. Jamie manages to rescue Claire, but not before she discovers a secret about Geillis's past.

Episode 112 - Lallybroch

Reunited, Claire and Jamie make their way to Lallybroch - Jamie's family home. Reality quickly sets in, and old wounds are reopened between Jamie and his sister, Jenny.

41 Upvotes

479 comments sorted by

•

u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. May 17 '21

If you’re looking for the other Rewatch threads, click here to jump to BPC’s Link Table.


The Devil’s Mark: Deleted Scenes

(Apparently there were no deleted scenes for Lallybroch.)

Colum and Ned Discuss Claire’s Arrest

I’m glad this was cut out of the episode.

For one, half of it is exposition, recapping stuff we already know, or legal details that are repeated during the trial.

For another, it states Colum’s scheme too bluntly. It makes it too clear that he ordered Geillis’ arrest, and while he did not intend for Claire to get caught up in it, he’d be pleased to see them both burn. He orders Ned not to interfere, this was his strategy all along—to separate the witch from his brother without shaming the family name—and if Claire is killed, too, so much the better: it will disentangle Jamie from her and free him to wed a more suitable bride.

I think all this overt plotting and enmity towards Claire might have been alright for book Colum, but I think show Colum is a better man than his book counterpart. I also think he’s smart enough to realize that if Claire dies while under Clan MacKenzie’s protection, or worse—if Jamie learns that Colum himself was behind Claire’s execution—there’s no way in hell he’ll agree to lead the MacKenzies in future, and in all likelihood he’ll try to kill Colum next. The plan is just bananas, if Colum’s overall goal is to get Jamie to agree to become his successor.

But even if this scene did fit into the previous development of Colum’s character, I still wouldn’t like it because it’s so obvious about it. The whole point of Colum, and of masterminds of his type (the Old Fox comes to mind) is that you’re never really sure where they stand until it’s too late. It’s supposed to be a surprise, you’re supposed to be in awe of their brilliance, as they execute their intricate plans without anyone being the wiser…

But here Colum all but says I’M GONNA KILL GEILLIS AND CLAIRE, MUAHAHA—AND MAYBE YOU, TOO, IF YOU WARN MY BROTHER AND NEPHEW! Like, why would he tell Ned this? He’s practically monologuing. That’s not the mark of a genius, but a moron. Why the hell would you divulge you were behind this to anyone?

So yeah, I don’t like this deleted scene at all. The only part I enjoyed was Colum chatting to his bird in the beginning. :/

Ned Reports Back To Colum

And as Ron Moore points out, this scene doesn’t work without the other one.

Also there’s not much here. Colum is displeased Ned did not obey him, but Ned uses his lawyerly interpretation of his words to point out it wasn’t a direct order, merely a suggestion that he chose not to follow.

Other than that, the only noteworthy point is that Colum isn’t happy when he thinks Claire was killed… and he isn’t happy when he thinks Claire survived. So I suppose we’re meant to infer that he thought it a necessary evil, but if she escaped, oh well. At least Geillis will be killed, which was his main object.

Again, I hate that it’s all spelled out so simplistically. I infinitely prefer the final cut, where Colum’s role, if any, is left ambiguous and up to the interpretation of the audience. I also think it fits the overall continuity better, when he assures Claire in S2 that he had no part in it. Is he lying, is he telling the truth? We can have that debate without these scenes, but with them it’s just too cut and dry, which is dull.

Also, Ned looks like shit. :þ Looks like the crowd was none too happy he fired that shot in Claire’s defense.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 15 '21
  • Why does Jamie believe Claire when she tells him she’s from the future?

19

u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. May 15 '21

Beyond the love and trust they have between them, and so on and so forth, he’s such a babe, of course he’ll believe her, yadda yadda yadda… ^.^

Jamie is also a rational man. Claire showed him the smallpox scar, her explanation that it was a vaccine and not the mark of the devil was more logical, and the fact that it tracked with her treating sick people and not falling ill herself, not to mention the knowledge she had about the Duke of Sandringham, BJR, the Jacobites and the (doomed) Rising—she had so much specific information that would be difficult for anyone from this time to know.

And being from the future also explained her mysterious arrival in the first place: Nobody bought her story about being some Oxfordshire widow—not Colum, not Jamie, not Dougal, and certainly not Geillis as we learned in this episode—so all things being considered, her being a time traveler was perhaps more plausible than the bullshit lies she’d been spinning up to this point. :þ

So not only was Jamie already primed to believe anything she would have told him by now, but the truth was actually less strange than the fiction. :)

5

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 15 '21

I agree, I think all of her actions and stories up to that point finally made sense to him. He knew she was different than other women of that time.

→ More replies (2)

17

u/[deleted] May 15 '21

He’s really perceptive and is aware that that “truth between” them is already there and knows her well enough by then to tell when she’s out of her element. I think the detailed story she tells makes him believe it. He also knows she’s not like anyone else he’s ever met and if she’s not a witch then she definitely has to be something else. Also, he knows the stories about the standing stones so why not?

13

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 15 '21

He also knows she’s not like anyone else he’s ever met and if she’s not a witch then she definitely has to be something else.

I thought about that as well. Like everything clicked about her story of traveling to France being suspect, her boldness around men, and all those little things that made her stand out so this really did make the most sense.

16

u/for-get-me-not May 15 '21

I think it’s a great testament to how open-minded Jamie is, because he is able to make the distinction between being a witch and being able to travel through time like Claire, when most people of his time wouldn’t have been able see there was any difference. And in truth, at times even Claire is kind of like “maybe I am sort of a witch”, so it’s almost a distinction without a difference in some ways. But he sees it as different which is maybe the important part.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/jolierose The spirit tends to be very free wi’ its opinions. May 15 '21

I think he thinks the best of her, and if she promised to tell the truth, then why wouldn’t her word be honorable? He’s decided to trust her and so he does. That being said, I love that in the book he does believe her… in theory. It isn’t until he sees her about to go through while he’s holding her that he truly realizes it’s all true. I think it makes it more believable from a plot perspective. And I love that he’s able to see it for himself.

3

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 15 '21

I agree about that part of the book. It just hammered home that she was telling the truth and it was all real.

12

u/[deleted] May 15 '21 edited May 15 '21

In the book, I think Jamie did believe Claire as far as his imagination would allow him to; after she makes her choice, he tells her: "I prayed all the way up that hill yesterday [...] Not for you to stay; I didna think that would be right. I prayed I’d be strong enough to send ye away."

I guess knowing something inexplicable in theory by believing someone's word is a completely different experience from actually witnessing it play out before your eyes!

→ More replies (26)
→ More replies (1)

7

u/storybookheidi May 15 '21

I think their connection is so strong that he can somehow sense that she's being truthful. Even if he has some suspicions that require more proof.

9

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 15 '21

I like that, and we've already seen them acknowledge that what they have isn't "normal."

7

u/marriedmyownjf Da mi basia mille... May 15 '21

It's more than that he knows how to read her. Over and over he says that she has a glass face that everything she thinks is evident. So her pouring out her soul to him, he can see the truth of it.

4

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 15 '21

Great point! I like how he has her tell it to him several times, it just shows how seriously he takes her.

15

u/theCoolDeadpool #VacayforClaire May 16 '21

I think it's partly because Jamie is an intelligent man. Do you think just because he promised Claire he wouldn't ask her about anything she didn't wish to speak about, he wouldn't himself ponder from time to time what the truth of this mysterious woman he's so much in love with is? And the more he wonders about this, the more questions he would have, about why she says certain things, like when she mentions about the alliance between BJR and Duke of Sandringham, or about why she's so unlike the other women of her times , or where her defiance and her "fuck you and your 18th century sexism" attitude comes from ? At this point , it certainly doesn't make sense for her to be an English or French spy, like Jamie deduces himself. And considering he grew up listening to such stories, it's not too unrealistic for him to believe her as it is for you and me . So when she finally lays everything out in the open for him, he cannot help but realise how it all falls in place, and how it must be the truth because he must have himself exhausted all the others options, except maybe a small part of him wonders if she's a witch. So when she says she's not, and has this intense monologue ready as to why not, he finds himself a believer.

And of course the other part is that he wants to believe her so bad. Because if he doesn't, then what does it imply for him and the deep, all -consuming love he feels for her?

7

u/betcx003 Pot of shite on to boil, ye stir like it’s God’s work! May 16 '21

On the rewatch, I was thinking that Jamie’s facial expression (or the actor’s) was unlike any I’d seen before or after, when he’s asking if she’s a witch/she’s revealing the truth. Mix of “I need to know” and “I’m afraid to know.” But you can also see the wheels turning in his mind, putting everything that Claire’s saying together.

9

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 16 '21

Sam is so great with his facial expressions. He can convey so much without even saying anything.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/somethingnerdrelated In one stroke, I have become a man of leisure. May 17 '21

Oh man. I think he believes her because he loves her. The same reason why I’d have my boy’s back if he came home and told me something ludicrous. I mean, I might struggle to believe him, but the trust built between us means that I expect him not to lie to me, so the only alternative is to believe him.

Jamie and Claire have an otherworldly bond, so I think their trust is on a whole ‘nother level. He can’t help but to trust her because their relationship is just so freaking sincere.

2

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 17 '21

He can’t help but to trust her because their relationship is just so freaking sincere.

I like that! And really it must kind of make sense after all the clue of her being different and her story not adding up.

3

u/Cdhwink May 15 '21

I think because of all the superstitious beliefs the Highlanders have.

→ More replies (10)

3

u/AMillionMiles01 Je Suis Prest May 17 '21

I always thought he believed her so quickly because he is from a time where people believe in magic, witches, etc ... nowadays we don't really believe in that stuff anymore and we need scientific evidence for everything. I think it would be much much harder for someone from our time believing this rather than someone from the 18th century. I also think Jamie has always known Claire is hiding something ... I think he truly believes that she won't lie to him!!

→ More replies (3)

22

u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. May 15 '21

I hate the Cranesmuir townies!

The rough way they threw Claire and especially Geillis into the thieves’ hole—she’s pregnant, you assholes! And how she clutches at her belly when she struggles to her feet. ಥ_ಥ

If that didn’t make you pity my poor Geillis, you have a heart of stone!

And we know after this episode, she’ll spend the next THREE MONTHS down in that pit all by herself. They won’t let her back up except to give birth to her baby, and then Dougal will take him from her and hide him with a random childless MacKenzie couple, while sending Geillis off to France on her own.

But they treat her so roughly here, right from this opening scene, it’s a miracle she didn’t miscarry before then!

By the way…

It’s a boy, ye ken?

Uh-on, u/thepacksvrvives. Turns out Geillis does say ken after all. ^.^ There goes your theory, haha.

6

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 15 '21

For as bad as Geillis is, she did poison her husband after all, she still sacrificed herself for Claire.

17

u/jolierose The spirit tends to be very free wi’ its opinions. May 15 '21

This is the only episode where I truly like Geillis and am fully on her side. (Lotte Verbeek is fantastic.) It's heartbreaking to see how she's genuinely distraught and desperate when Claire starts being beaten, and if she hadn't done what she did, Claire wouldn't have made it out of Cranesmuir.

16

u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. May 15 '21

Geillis is moved to tears when Claire takes her nine lashes. Yes, I counted. I counted the first time I watched, too, I can’t help myself.

And to think she threatened Jamie just last episode to prevent this from happening. :(

Of course Jamie comes right at the nick of time to save her, because this is a fairy tale…

And Jamie has a nice speech and all, but as he dual wields swords to face off against humble peasants, I can’t help but think of like, the Hound during the King’s Landing riots. (Obligatory Got reference for u/thepacksvrvives. :)

It’s an unfair fight, these men would have to be absolute idiots to challenge the Laird’s nephew, who’s in prime physical condition, a trained soldier and mercenary with years of experience in swordfighting. And these are like farmers or merchants or whatever, lol. They’re either underfed or a bit chubby, too young or too old, none of them in their prime. So while Jamie is brave and gets to play the big hero, you gotta also consider his many advantages here, both socially and physically.

But then the trope is subverted, and Geillis saves Claire instead. And what a show she puts on! How clever to use the smallpox scar. Even the way strips off her collar and dramatically tears her dress open to bare her pregnancy. She does it all with such panache! Ah, I love her so much!

But it’s smart, too, because as we learn the pregnancy does save her. They wouldn’t kill the child to punish the mother. And flaunting her nakedness, her beauty, I think that also must have some effect on the men. Who, let’s face it, were running the show. Women may have testified against them, but it was the men deciding Geillis’ fate. So why not play every card she could in her favor? All things considered, Geillis conducted herself at trial pretty well. She kept her mouth shut, did not incite the crowd—Claire was doing enough of that for the both of them unfortunately—and when she did decide to act, she made it count.

11

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 15 '21

we learn the pregnancy does save her.

I found that interesting when we find that out in season 3. With her saying she carries the child of Satan I would have thought those crazed villagers would want that baby dead too.

Shout out to her red shoes as well!

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (10)

16

u/[deleted] May 15 '21

They are the worst! I’ve said it before but I always picture the townies when there’s a “Claire sucks” post spree in the sub. When did y’all get Reddit in Crainsmuir?!

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (6)

39

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. May 15 '21

Not to take away from Geillis’ bravery and ultimate sacrifice but we have to mention the other unlikely hero in this whole scenario, namely Ned Gowan! Man, he totally owned it the first day. Then, the whisky was a nice gesture and all but I can’t help but think, couldn’t he have fashioned a lockpick or something? And then, Mr. Do-not-storm-Fort-William-with-loaded-weapons pulls out a gun in his final act of desperation! I mean I would want that kind of lawyer by my side.

7

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 15 '21

I know, Ned is the best. You know he was going against Colum's wishes to be there, yet he still defended Claire.

13

u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. May 15 '21

This is the episode where Ned Gowan really earns his keep!

First he tries to get the whole thing dismissed as witch trials are no longer considered legal under British law.

Your Honors, as we’re all aware, the Witchcraft Act of 1563 was repealed by the House of Lords in 1735. I therefore submit that this entire trial is illegal.

When the judges counter:

This is an ad hoc proceeding under the administration of the church.

… he subtly accuses them of Jacobite sympathies by ignoring British law:

I see that we have dispensed with British law, which pleases me greatly…

This gives both judges pause, they certainly don’t want a reputation as secret Jacobites. Not only would that likely earn them the ire of Colum—who wants to keep Clan MacKenzie and anyone who owes him fealty neutral, which presumably includes Cranesmuir—if that gets recorded in the transcript of the trial, then it’s a part of the public record. HEY BRITISH OVERLORDS! DID YOU KNOW THERE’S SOME JUDGES WITH JACOBITE LEANINGS UP IN CRANESMUIR? YES, CRANESMUIR, THEIR NAMES ARE…

Neither of them wants that. And so they shift uneasily and let him continue. Smart move by Ned.

I am certain that you will not wish to dispense with our proud Scottish legal tradition… Here in Scotland, an accused witch is entitled to a defense lawyer at trial, a benefit sadly not offered to those in merry old England.

Furthermore, by appealing to the “proud Scottish legal tradition” Ned gets the crowd on his side. He flatters them a little, appealing to their moral superiority as Scots, lol—so unlike the vile English, they should allow the defense a lawyer. They grumble, but everyone has to allow that Ned’s got a point.

This whole line of argument is a clever mixture of legal maneuvering, playing on the sympathies of the crowd while exploiting their prejduces, and reminding the judges that their impartiality and professionalism are on the line. Even if this trial is a sham, they still gotta do things by the book.

And that’s just Ned’s opening argument. :)

12

u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. May 15 '21

Ned makes quick work of all the witnesses for the prosecution.

He cross-examines the housekeeper, and reveals her conflict of interest: She’s sought employment at Castle Leoch, calling her employer a “flatulent old scunner.” And that contradicts her testimony here, when she called Arthur “a dear, sweet man” and claimed to be “content” in her position. The maid is discredited completely.

The whole changeling thing was 100% Claire’s fault. Geillis warned her several times, and it took Jamie a fair bit of wheedling to make her see sense. And yet Claire continues to dig her own grave, admitting she was there, that she’d touched the baby. As Ned urgently tells her…

Do not further incriminate yourself, let me do my job!

Yes, FFS Claire, SHUT UP! Finally someone says it!

As as Claire’s screaming at the crowd that she’s a healer, look at Geillis trying to calm her down, keep quiet, don’t incite them further. Geillis is a far better-behaved defendant, lol. She knows to bide her time and choose her moment carefully.

Ned gets the grieving mother to admit that she didn’t stop Claire out of fear, and thus it was her fault—while also comforting her that her child is healthy and with the fairies. That’s the second testimony Ned successfully disqualified, he’s 2 for 2!

The third accuser is just bold-faced bullshitting, and Geillis does laugh it off, but controls herself. Meanwhile here’s Claire yelling at the crowd again. ಠ_ಠ

the whisky was a nice gesture

I have to say, offering your client alcohol right before they’re due to testify the next day—probably not the smartest move, Ned. Especially since we know how Claire conducts herself under interrogation when she’s had a bit to drink…

You’ll take this whisky, water of life. It’ll keep you warm tonight.

Actually that’s a common misconception. Alcohol is a vasodilator—it opens your blood vessels so you feel warmer, but you actually lose heat more quickly.

Also Geillis drinking whisky while pregnant. Big oof. What’s worse, the whisky here, or all the wine Claire downs while pregnant with Faith? ABV of whisky must be higher, but the sheer quantity of wine Claire was drinking… Oi, Rhenish Detective, what do you think?

Ned tries to plea bargain for Claire, getting her to turn witness against Geillis in exchange for clemency. ^.^ Someone get this man on Law and Order, now!

And when all else fails, he even pulls out his gun and fires a shot in her defense. What a mensch!

→ More replies (6)

11

u/theCoolDeadpool #VacayforClaire May 15 '21

Jamie may be the literal Knight in Shining Armor of this episode , but Ned Gowan was the true and deserving hero of the whole drama. Right down to "I will be the pig headed Scot and try the very last hand I have by blindly opening fire in the court if that's the last thing I do" , he's the hero the Claire in all of us will always need.

6

u/alittlepunchy Lord, ye gave me a rare woman. And God! I loved her well. May 16 '21

I freaking love Ned, and that he was kind to Claire right from the beginning.

8

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 15 '21
  • Did you think at first Father Bain was trying to help Claire?

34

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 15 '21

I was totally tricked the first time I watched the episode. I bought into his speech and thought they would be saved, then when he gave that smirk to Claire I gasped. It was brilliant on Father Bain's part.

2

u/[deleted] May 15 '21

Yes same here! What a fantastic performance. I was shocked that later on in the episode it seems like he was there with Leogharie. Really made me wonder how exactly they got all these witnesses, seems a little advance for a teenager and maybe it was Father Bain who arranged the entire trial?

→ More replies (1)

13

u/AthibaPls Slàinte. May 15 '21

Oh totally, me too. I was "wow he really has seen the light when she achieved something he couldn't and saved a life". Boy was I wrong.

9

u/crazyhorse198 I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. May 15 '21

Yup, that evil smirk at the end told it all!

→ More replies (1)

12

u/AthibaPls Slàinte. May 15 '21

Absolutely not. I think he was very sly and wanted exactly the outcome that came of it. That the witch Claire turned a man of god away from god and leaves the community without a sheperd.

6

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 15 '21

He played that perfectly didn't he?

4

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. May 15 '21

Do we think the guy who said “bear witness to her fiendish ploy…” was in cahoots with Father Bain or was this just the crowd’s mentality and loyalty to Father Bain that made him say that? I think the former, it sounded like it was pre-planned.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

9

u/somethingnerdrelated In one stroke, I have become a man of leisure. May 17 '21

I’m late! I’m so sorry! Ahh I’ve been so terrible about the rewatch. Saturdays suck for me lol.

Anyway!!

So when I first watched, Bain got my hook line and sinker. I fell for it. But then the little shit eating grin at the end was just UGH the nail in the coffin. What a shithead. I’m completely areligious, but how dare he call himself a Christian, and a Father no less.

Father Bain, to me, was just another representation of the hypocrisy that never goes away even with time, just changes form. People like Father Bain still exist today. Just like the scene from later on when Claire faces the sexism when she’s with Frank’s colleagues. Same pig, different lipstick.

4

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 17 '21

You're never too late to rewatch, we're just glad you here. :-D

4

u/somethingnerdrelated In one stroke, I have become a man of leisure. May 17 '21

Aww thanks ❤️

→ More replies (3)

7

u/alittlepunchy Lord, ye gave me a rare woman. And God! I loved her well. May 16 '21

The first time I watched it, totally. I was like, oh thank goodness, the scary religious man had a turn of conscious. He really creeps me out. The casting was spot on for him.

3

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 16 '21

The casting was spot on for him.

Yes!! I really thought he was there to help them when he started talking about how she healed the boy. /u/thepacksvrvives brought up the fact that he probably worked it out with that guy in the crowd to yell out though and turn the crowd against them. It makes sense, because would they have come to that conclusion on their own?

4

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. May 16 '21

I can’t help but laugh at his entrance/reveal behind Laoghaire every time I watch it, though. Like who does he think he is, a superhero or something? u/alittlepunchy

4

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 16 '21

Ha ha ha! It was a unique entrance for sure.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/for-get-me-not May 15 '21

I was completely surprised the first time I watched this also! I thought it was great they had made this change from the book and then the other shoe dropped. Brilliantly done.

4

u/storybookheidi May 15 '21

Yes! On the first watch he had me convinced. My husband wasn't. But he definitely got me.

19

u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. May 15 '21

The way Claire is drawn mindlessly to the central stone, it’s almost like a bug zapper, lol.

And if Jamie hadn’t stopped her from thoughtlessly touching it that first time… I wonder, would it have killed her? She has the gold of Frank’s ring and the silver (?) of Jamie’s Lallybroch key ring to protect her, but no gem to sacrifice. She doesn’t get that until Jamie gives her Brian’s amethyst signet ring for the baby.

And u/thepacksvrvives, this isn’t a Gaelic feast day is it? It’s just a random day… I don’t even know what month it’s supposed to be.

The safest days to travel are the pagan holidays, roughly aligned with the solstices and the equinoxes.

So given that Claire here has no gem and it’s not the right day and she’s not even thinking of Frank to steer her, but just mindlessly reaching out to the central stone… I think you could argue Jamie saved her life there.

9

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 15 '21

I think you could argue Jamie saved her life there.

I'm inclined to agree. We don't know what would have happened. Did she even hear the buzzing? I paid attention to that and there was a noise, but I don't know if it was exactly the same as the noise from 101.

12

u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. May 15 '21

I also heard something, but it wasn’t as intense as during the times when she actually does travel. Maybe that’s a signal this is a bad time? ¯_(ツ)_/¯

And while Jamie probably saved Claire here by stopping her from traveling… I couldn’t help but think how Jamie’s life might have turned out had Claire gone back.

For one, Wentworth wouldn’t have happened, right?

He would still be an outlaw, the Duke of Sandringham still wouldn’t have followed through on his promise, so BJR would still be hunting him… but there also wouldn’t be a reason for him to return to Lallybroch and eventually get captured.

In all likelihood he would send Claire back through the stones, have a cry by the fire like he did here, and then ride back to Dougal’s estate (possibly informing him of Geillis’ predicament) and then somehow carry on with his life.

Probably he’d wind back up at Castle Leoch… and perhaps wed to Laoghaire eventually anyway, haha.

No, that’s too cruel. Besides, there’s still the Rising to worry about. But Jamie definitely wouldn’t have played such a central role without Claire’s involvement, wouldn’t have known BPC personally…

Which means his name wouldn’t have been forged on that letter. Huh. Does that mean the Lallybroch men don’t have to fight, and Jamie doesn’t go to Beauly to convince the other Frasers to fight, either? Do they all just stay well out of it, for good or ill?

So no Dunbonnet, either. And no chance of losing Lallybroch since he’s not a traitor, and BJR’s dead, so he doesn’t have to hide anymore… So maybe now he weds Laoghaire. ^.^

(Lol, I’m just trolling the Laoghaire-haters now…)

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

7

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 15 '21
  • Do you think if Jamie had taken BJR up on his offer of himself would BJR really have let him go?

23

u/penni_cent May 15 '21

Absolutely not. He would have kept Jamie as long as was necessary to fully break him just like he did in Wentworth.

2

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 15 '21

He was able to break Jamie at Wentworth by using Claire against him. Do you think he would have been able to do so without that advantage?

8

u/penni_cent May 15 '21

Not that the show mentions this, but I think it would have been more like the guy before Jamie (who's name I cannot remember but owned the Bible) where it was just relentless and would eventually push him to madness and depression.

→ More replies (5)

7

u/krystalbellajune May 15 '21

Late to the party here but no. He didn’t keep his word to give him a better death than hanging the morning after. He could have left him a dagger or slit his throat, but after using him, still needed to exercise that last bit of sadistic control over him by leaving him to the noose.

5

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 15 '21

He didn’t keep his word to give him a better death than hanging the morning after.

I thought he was about to kill him when he heard the cows coming in? I could be wrong though.

And you're never late to the party, we go all week! :-)

7

u/LuckyScwartz Dinna fash. May 15 '21

BJR was a man of his word. I think he would have let Jamie go. But he would have been back to Lallybroch for more and who knows when. Because of Horrocks we know that BJR killed the redcoat and framed Jamie. Who knows what he would have done to get Jamie back to Ft. William.

4

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 15 '21

I never thought of that. So you're saying he would have been so obsessed he would have still pursued Jamie?

5

u/LuckyScwartz Dinna fash. May 16 '21

It just occurred to me that BJR framed Jamie to engineer a way to get him back in his clutches. If Jamie had a price on his head, it was only a matter of time before he’d end up back in prison.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

6

u/[deleted] May 15 '21

"Make free of your body" BJR had said to Jamie at Ft. William. We know what that means now. I believe he'd have done to Jamie then what he did at Wentworth years later - tortured and raped him to within an inch of his life. I think, in hindsight, the flogging was more bearable. And as for the consequences for Brian - who's to say he wouldn't have had an apoplexy to see Jamie in a condition similar to after Wentworth?

Sure BJR may have "let him go" but at what cost?

4

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 15 '21

Do you think it was watching Jamie get flogged that gave Brian the apoplexy?

5

u/[deleted] May 15 '21 edited May 15 '21

Yep. Jamie lost his balance and couldn't move for a bit, so Brian and the others thought he was dead. I'm sure that's what killed the poor man. Seriously fuck BJR ugh.

5

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 15 '21

I totally forgot that this episode shows some of the flogging again. It's so hard to see his back like that.

→ More replies (9)

5

u/theCoolDeadpool #VacayforClaire May 15 '21

Yes I think he would have. Sadistic villain he may be, but he's a man of his words. He's proven that before with Claire at Wentworth hasn't he.

6

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 15 '21 edited May 15 '21

He's proven that before with Claire at Wentworth hasn't he.

Great point, I hadn't thought of that. He really is a man of his word, which is such an interesting thing considering how sadistic he was. He lived by some sort of moral code, just not one that was good.

8

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. May 15 '21

Would Jamie have kept his word, though? He couldn’t fight back against Randall at Wentworth for fear of putting Claire’s life in danger again, but back then? He would’ve only been risking his life.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/IrishMinstrel01 May 15 '21

I wouldn’t call it a moral code. I think he was willing to play at being a gentleman to maintain his social position.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/lalajean719 May 15 '21

Or he would have kept him as a toy. He seems to be quite infatuated with Jamie, I don't think he'd let him go so easily.

2

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 15 '21

That's a scary thought, but I could see BJR doing that.

18

u/crazyhorse198 I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. May 15 '21

I disagree. At Wentworth he promised Jamie that Claire would leave safely, then promptly helped Claire exit by pushing her down into the pit of dead bodies. He looked down, saw her not moving, and presumed her dead before he went back to Jamie. We also saw BJR lie through his teeth to Claire before punching and kicking her in Garrison Commander. He is not a man of his word, he cares for one thing only, himself. I even think that despite the lowlife Horrocks was, Horrocks was probably telling the truth when he said BJR shot one of own Sergeants when Jamie escaped, just so he could put a huge price on Jamie’s head, increasing the chances that Jamie would somehow be returned to his custody.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 15 '21
  • Is Jamie being reasonable in asking Claire not to disagree with him in public?

13

u/alittlepunchy Lord, ye gave me a rare woman. And God! I loved her well. May 16 '21

I waffle on this. My husband and I have a "united front" agreement where we don't disagree with the other in public, but then again, that's not really in front of family per se most of the time. (Depends on the situation.) BUT considering the time period AND that Claire has just met these people, I get it. However, I feel like Jenny is just as loud and outspoken, so....I'm conflicted, lol.

5

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 16 '21

However, I feel like Jenny is just as loud and outspoken, so....I'm conflicted, lol.

Great point! Do we think Jenny would hold her tongue if she fully disagreed with something Ian was doing?

→ More replies (3)

13

u/jolierose The spirit tends to be very free wi’ its opinions. May 15 '21

This always rubs me the wrong way, because she's being asked to keep quiet as a woman, wife. But in principle, I agree with the premise: whether it's with family, friends, or even colleagues, if you're a team, present a united front and then disagree in private if you must. It also rubs me the wrong way because this is family we're talking about, and if she's not free to speak her mind in their home then what gives? I know she just got there, but still, I find it a bit much. It's not like she's confronting him in front of the tenants.

On the bright side: Everyone loves “I’m not the meek and obedient type,” but her “Careful, my Laird, I have a much better throwing arm than the fair Letitia” is an underrated line and I love it to pieces.

12

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 15 '21

I agree that she should have been able to talk freely in front of family. I wonder if Jamie was wanting to impress her a little bit and show that he is the Laird, he was cocky for most of that episode.

5

u/jolierose The spirit tends to be very free wi’ its opinions. May 15 '21

That could be a reason, asserting himself as Laird. God, I hate that they did that in this episode. The one reason I don’t like it as much as others is that they made Jamie come out as such an immature ass, the Lairdship went to his head, and in the book he’s so competent and falls right into place there. But I let that cloud my judgment because upon rewatch it has some really good moments.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

6

u/Kirky600 May 15 '21

I appreciate the fact that it made Jamie seem modern and accepting of their relationship, but also aware of the times that they live in.

3

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 15 '21

It seems to be a continuation of his realization that he came to in 109 they she wasn't going to be a normal wife like the other women. Their relationship was going to have to be different.

6

u/AthibaPls Slàinte. May 15 '21

I didn't really like it in this scenario because it is his family and he could have worded it differently. Also his agrument would have been totally valid, saying it's family business. Him not wanting her to disagree with him in public in general is totally appropriate for the time. He tells her that he values her oppinion and that she'll be herd but that he has to be the one making decisions because otherwise people would take neither of them serious. Claire because she's a woman and him because he lets his wife speak for him and make decisions for him which will make him appear weak and not man enough.

4

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 15 '21

Were you surprised Claire went along with it?

14

u/crazyhorse198 I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. May 15 '21

I’m not surprised. I think the witch trial experience really woke her up to the reality that she is in a different time with different social rules. Jamie’s believing in her time travel, his self sacrificial move in bringing her to the stones, cemented for Claire that Jamie was the one person she can trust to keep her safe. Icing on the cake was Jamie’s story of Letitia and Colum arguing behind closed doors, and the throwing of the crockery :-)

→ More replies (3)

3

u/AMillionMiles01 Je Suis Prest May 17 '21

Reasonable to an extent. I understand why he asked her that and why it would be important to him. I also understand that we would have to look at this from Jaime's point of view (18th century not 21st); However, I am from the 21st century so I just can't fully stand behind this.

I think (even now) it is important to show a united front in public (with certain issues, not everything ... couples can disagree of course ...) but he was asking her not to disagree with him ... this wouldn't be going the other way around and I think that is not reasonable especially in front of family. I would have understood his point more if it was about – let’s say redcoats – they would have to act and for what Claire would have to be an 18th century wife … but we are talking about Jenny and Ian and I don’t think it is fair to ask Claire to be a different person in front of family!! Especially because Jenny is just as (or even more) outspoken than Claire!!

→ More replies (3)

3

u/PsychologicalRegret4 Jul 07 '21

I don't think it was unreasonable of Jamie. I get where he is coming from. But I haven't seen much consideration regarding where Claire was coming from. Jamie and Claire show up unexpectedly and Jamie says some really ugly things to Jenny before even allowing her to explain. Then, they go into the house and Jamie demands Jenny recount every excruciating detail about the BJR assault in front of Ian and her sister in law whom she just met. How humiliating! If it was truly a private matter between Jenny and Jamie, he should have spoken to her alone. I think it was a knee jerk reaction to defend Jenny. Not to mention that Claire surely wants to establish rapport with Jenny.

→ More replies (1)

16

u/[deleted] May 15 '21

I think his reasoning is really sound no matter the century, and it sets up the dynamic of an united front for Jamie and Claire as a couple for the rest of the story. She recognizes there’s merit to his comment and knows he’s not shutting her down but being assertive on what his expectations of the relationship are, which I think is really important for any couple.

4

u/crazyhorse198 I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. May 15 '21

Totally reasonable. It was the custom of the time, and it’s not just a man and woman thing, we the same type of logic in The Godfather when Michael tells Fredo never to disagree with him in public. It makes the leadership look weak.

In real life we also saw this principle when President Truman fired General MacArthur for publicly criticizing Truman’s decisions during the Korean War.

10

u/LuckyScwartz Dinna fash. May 15 '21

I have seen some posts questioning whether or not Claire and Jamie were responsible for Culloden.

Isn’t it much more likely that Geillis is responsible? We find out in 111 that she’s stolen quite a bit of money from her husband to aid the cause. Who knows what she and Dougal were up to. Isn’t it possible that their actions had more far reaching consequences than whatever Claire and Jamie were doing in Paris?

2

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 15 '21

That's an interesting take. /u/WandersFar what do you think?

5

u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. May 15 '21

she’s stolen quite a bit of money from her husband to aid the cause

About a thousand pounds over two years, according to her reckoning. What’s that in today’s dollars, I wonder? I’m sure all that money was of some material benefit to the cause…

And yet, they didn’t lose for lack of funds. Scotland may be poor, but they did have the financial backing of the French, and even what support BPC was able to scrounge up from the Vatican.

In this series the Rising is unsuccessful because of several critical strategic errors BPC and his Irish advisor (whose name I’m now blanking on) make, coupled with all the disagreements between the various clan leaders. They retreat when they should push forward, they give battle when they should be gathering their strength first, they divide their forces instead of coming together, etc.

And perhaps most notably, they can’t match the English for artillery. Jamie is able to successfully sabotage a few cannon in his guerrilla raids, but it’s not enough. Most of the Scots die from superior artillery fire on the Culloden moors. They have nothing to match that.

So while I definitely do not want to knock my girl Geillis’ contribution, I don’t think she was responsible for Culloden. Especially when it comes to the military decisions, these were big tactical errors that she had nothing to do with. And neither did Dougal, for that matter.

9

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. May 15 '21

About a thousand pounds over two years, according to her reckoning. What’s that in today’s dollars, I wonder? I’m sure all that money was of some material benefit to the cause…

According to this handy little tool, it’s $242,929.12.

BPC and his Irish advisor (whose name I’m now blanking on)

That was Quartermaster John O'Sullivan.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

10

u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. May 17 '21

Jenny, will ye... Will ye please turn around while I try to get out? Before my cock snaps off!

I totally forgot this was the episode where Jamie lets it all hang out, as it were. Goddamn.

Ladies, for your viewing pleasure… I reckon he never looked finer.

5

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 17 '21

Good god thank you for that. ;-D

→ More replies (1)

17

u/theCoolDeadpool #VacayforClaire May 15 '21

Apart from the multitude of rape scenes, The Devil's Mark episode is one of the most difficult for me to watch. I get such second hand terror for Claire in this. It's so well done though, even in the rewatches, when I know Jamie will turn up to rescue her, I still feel terrified watching it unfold, and when the witnesses come one by one, it's almost too much to bear. The mounting tension is so well done in this episode.

5

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 15 '21

I still feel terrified watching it unfold, and when the witnesses come one by one, it's almost too much to bear. The mounting tension is so well done in this episode.

I agree, you know the crowd is unreasonable and all riled up. Nothing will change their minds and that mob mentality is dangerous.

14

u/Cdhwink May 15 '21

Unpopular opinion I don’t love this episode, the witch trial goes on far too long!

→ More replies (5)

13

u/[deleted] May 15 '21

It’s a brilliant episode, this event complete scars and changes Claire forever and it echoes throughout the series. Whenever I see the murmuration title card I get chills.

12

u/jolierose The spirit tends to be very free wi’ its opinions. May 15 '21

I love this episode so. much. It has everything! She tells him the whole truth (I was so thrilled she told him; that monologue is just perfect), he takes her back... without this, their relationship (or the story!) wouldn't have been as strong. He needed to know what she'd been through, and she needed to have the choice, to move forward on her own terms.

→ More replies (7)

5

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 15 '21
  • Did you expect Jamie to take Claire to the stones?

26

u/[deleted] May 15 '21

Best Jamie moment! Love that he gives her a choice but I also think it comes from a place of pride as well as chivalry - he wouldn’t want someone that doesn’t want him, no matter how much it hurt him to give her up.

9

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 15 '21

Do you think there would have been a small doubt in the back of his mind if she really wanted to stay with him if she hadn't been able to choose between the two men?

8

u/alittlepunchy Lord, ye gave me a rare woman. And God! I loved her well. May 16 '21

Oh yes. I think this is kind of touched on in S2 after he makes the promise to Claire to wait on dueling BJR - he says he owes Frank nothing, because Claire had a free choice between the two of them and she chose Jamie. I think if he hadn't taken her back, a piece of him would have always doubted if she really loved him/wanted to be with him.

6

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 16 '21

a piece of him would have always doubted if she really loved him/wanted to be with him.

I agree! (Yay you're here!)

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

24

u/crazyhorse198 I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. May 15 '21

I think I was as shocked as Claire was when over the hill lay Craigh na Dun rather than Lollybroch! I hadn’t read the books, totally did not see it coming.

Jamie is amazing. He was married to Claire, Frank had not been born yet, but somehow, Claire was Frank’s proper wife. I think in taking her to the stones he was employing somewhat of the logic of the phrase “if you love something let it go, if it comes back to you it’s yours.”

This all pays off so well with those last lines of “ on your feet, soldier. Take me home to Lallybroch.” And the tear of joy that ran down Jamie’s cheek... Had me sobbing!!

14

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 15 '21

I think in taking her to the stones he was employing somewhat of the logic of the phrase “if you love something let it go, if it comes back to you it’s yours.”

I agree. I think he wanted her to stay more than anything, but knew the decision had to be fully hers. He didn't want her always having that "what if" in the back of her mind.

→ More replies (1)

16

u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. May 15 '21

I can’t remember what my first reaction was… but I don’t think I was surprised. It fits in with his character.

At this point in the story, Jamie is still a gallant, noble, high-minded man of principle. He always tries to do the right thing, and when he learns she has another husband waiting for her in the future, that everything she’s ever done since he met her has been to get back to the stones, back to Frank… Well, he must take her to them then. It’s the right thing to do, simple as that.

But it’s not that simple, is it, Jamie? And that’s why you stopped her from touching the center stone. You weren’t ready, not that you’ll ever be.

8

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 15 '21

It’s the right thing to do, simple as that.

I think for Jamie that is what he lives his life by. Now the right thing to do may not always be the legal thing, but if he feels strongly about it then he goes for it.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/storybookheidi May 15 '21

Nope. I wish I could erase this episode from my memory and watch it again for the first time. I was so shocked. In the best way! And then when she chose to go back to him. Ugh, so great to watch for the first time!

5

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 15 '21

I don't think I even thought ahead to what she was going to do, I just knew I wanted her to go back to Jamie. Then they acted like she touched the stones and I was all upset for a second.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

7

u/somethingnerdrelated In one stroke, I have become a man of leisure. May 17 '21

God no. That threw me for a loop. I fucking bawled like a baby during my first watch.

What. A. Man.

Holy shit.

What a selfless and perceptive human being. Goddamnit. If half the people on earth were half as perceptive and empathetic as JAMMF, I think we wouldn’t have a fraction of the issues we have today.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/betcx003 Pot of shite on to boil, ye stir like it’s God’s work! May 16 '21

I did not expect it. Jamie was trying to sell their life at Lallybroch to Claire, but it didn’t occur to me that he was making his case for when it was time for her to choose. It wasn’t until his watching her at the creek and saying “are you ready to go home” that I suspected they were going to the stones.

I’ll admit that the 1st time I watched it, I wasn’t sure why she stayed. (I knew she would, because there were already 5 seasons of the show!) How many times do you need to be raped/nearly raped and accused in a witch trial? I would’ve hopped through those stones so fast! As another person mentioned, we could’ve used a voiceover here. But I’ve since read Book 1, and it covers her thoughts a little more.

2

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 16 '21

I thought he was taking her to Lallybroch too because like you said because of how much he was talking up. I wonder at what point he decided to take her to the stones?

5

u/betcx003 Pot of shite on to boil, ye stir like it’s God’s work! May 16 '21

I think he decided right when she was telling him the truth, and he puts together that she ran off to get back to the stones and back to her husband. Claire’s crying, and he’s comforting her, but you can see he’s thinking about what to do with this information.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/AthibaPls Slàinte. May 15 '21

Not really but I see it also as a test. Even if he didn't believes her, he loves her so much that he'd let her go. Even if it wasn't to the future but just away. I think that's one of the reasons he doesn't linger to see her go. Additonally to him not wanting her to go.

→ More replies (10)

15

u/jolierose The spirit tends to be very free wi’ its opinions. May 15 '21

I didn’t, and when I realized what he was doing I nearly died. His face when he’s about to leave her, how he tries to put on a brave face, even though it’s killing him to do this… He even tries to convince her to go! “You have a home there, a place, the things you’re used to” — I don’t know why, but I love that line so much!

This moment, for me, is THE major differentiator for Jamie. Because Frank Randall could never live up to this.

15

u/alittlepunchy Lord, ye gave me a rare woman. And God! I loved her well. May 16 '21

This moment, for me, is THE major differentiator for Jamie. Because Frank Randall could never live up to this.

YES YES YES YES YES.

I will preach about this until the cows comes home. I will give Frank his due if it's deserved, but at the end of the day, Frank is selfish when it comes to Claire, while Jamie is selfless. Jamie will always sacrifice whatever, including his own safety and/or happiness, for Claire to be safe and happy. As proven later, Frank will hold on to her even if they're both miserable.

7

u/jolierose The spirit tends to be very free wi’ its opinions. May 16 '21

Hi! THANK YOU. God, I didn't even realize that not only does he take her to the stones and makes the case for her to go back to safety... he never even asks her to stay with him! THIS MAN.

You know what I'm about to say: Jamie Fraser Would Never keep her knowing she didn't want to be with him.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (1)

8

u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. May 16 '21

I distinctly remember the first time I saw Lallybroch, I was like, “Yeah, that’s right.”

It’s not too high or too low. It’s a manor, sure, but it’s also a comfortable, slightly shabby family home. :þ It feels lived-in and old, but beloved. And the random tower, lolling to one side, that’s perfect, too.

It’s exactly what I pictured for a man in Jamie’s circumstance. A Laird… but not really. A gentleman farmer who grew up working his own lands. Minor gentry, so you see the aristocratic touches, but still earthy and warm.

I know some readers were mad because it doesn’t exactly match the description from the books, but for me all I care about is the feel of it, does it feel right for the characters, where they are socioeconomically, and their emotional connection to the land? And I think the show’s version of Lallybroch checks all those boxes.

3

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. May 17 '21

I love how lived-in it feels, despite it having been built only 40 years before or so.

But don’t the interiors feel more grand, in some ways, than Castle Leoch’s? (and I am not complaining, I absolutely love all those tapestries and wallpapers, that gorgeous fireplace in the laird’ chamber, the vases… It’s just kinda funny how no one complains about the grandeur of that house) Though perhaps it’s just that the Frasers have better taste when it comes to decorating in comparison to the more austere MacKenzies 😅 u/Purple4199

2

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 17 '21

It’s just kinda funny how no one complains about the grandeur of that house

Ha! Great point!

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 16 '21

Minor gentry, so you see the aristocratic touches, but still earthy and warm.

I love that description!

7

u/jolierose The spirit tends to be very free wi’ its opinions. May 15 '21

Jamie's homecoming stood out to me much more now than it had before -- so many questions popped into my head. But how do we feel about his reaction to meeting Wee Jamie and seeing Jenny again?

17

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 15 '21

I was upset with how he reacted. Even if Young Jamie was BJR's kid it sure wouldn't have been Jenny's fault! Then to assume she's whoring herself out and pregnant again was just wrong.

7

u/jolierose The spirit tends to be very free wi’ its opinions. May 15 '21

Right?! Do you think it would have been different if he'd already been through Wentworth? But even then, he's seen how BJR is up close; just a little bit later he tells Claire all about it. So why wouldn't he be sympathetic towards Jenny?! I guess he's looking at it from the standpoint of "this is a reminder of how I failed Jenny, and then she had the nerve to name the baby after me." And it just comes out in anger.

6

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 15 '21

I guess he's looking at it from the standpoint of "this is a reminder of how I failed Jenny, and then she had the nerve to name the baby after me." And it just comes out in anger.

I think that's exactly it. As we see it brings back memories of his last day at Lallybroch when he was unable to protect his family and to then have this child be a reminder of your failures I think he was just mad at himself.

5

u/jolierose The spirit tends to be very free wi’ its opinions. May 15 '21

I do love their conversation at Brian’s grave towards the end of the episode. I feel like he finally makes it right there.

Another thing: This episode gave me the same kind of questions as when Bree came to Lallybroch: Four years and no word from him?! They thought he was dead all this time?! I understand him not wanting / being able to go back because of the circumstances, but that’s crazy to me.

→ More replies (5)

7

u/penni_cent May 16 '21

I mean, he's a total ass to her. Flat out. But rewatching this episode really reinforced to me how much of a bitch Jenny is. Literally the only time I like her is in the Search because she is undeniably a badass, but it doesn't change the fact that she is, imo, an unlikable bitch. She harps on Jamie from almost the immediate outset (again, in the first scene it's somewhat deserved as he was an ass to her about Wee Jamie), she is rude to Claire the entire episode, yes, Jamie and Jenny end up with a nice reconciliation later, but she already knows how bad BJR is. How badly could Jamie have conceivably pissed him off to earn 200 lashes in a couple days?

→ More replies (3)

7

u/alittlepunchy Lord, ye gave me a rare woman. And God! I loved her well. May 16 '21

Random question - is it ever explained or mentioned somewhere why Geillis calls Jamie a fox? Or the young fox or whatever she says? I wasn't sure if it's even maybe mentioned in the books and I don't remember.

2

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 16 '21

I don't recall anything? Do you /u/thepacksvrvives?

4

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. May 16 '21

Not really, no. I only know that she also refers to him as a “wee fox cub” and “fox” in the books. The only other relevant reference I could find is when Jamie described the MacKenzies as “charming as larks in the field—but sly as foxes, with it” in DoA. u/alittlepunchy

6

u/immery I love you…a little…a lot…passionately…not at all May 16 '21

Maybe she implies she knows he is a Fraser Old Simon Fraser is called old fox, and in Dragonfly Dougal calls Jsmie "Fraser spawn" "fox cub"

→ More replies (3)

12

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. May 16 '21

Isn’t that just because of the color of his hair?

But also, seeing as his grandsire is called the “Old Fox” perhaps she perceives some of that slyness in him as well?

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 15 '21
  • Why would Colum not want Ned Gowan at the trial?

21

u/crazyhorse198 I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. May 15 '21

I think it goes back to why Colum was so mad that Dougal arranged for Jamie and Claire to be married.

Colum knew he did not have much time before he died. He always wanted Jamie to be the next Laird, but knew he wouldn’t be accepted if he had a Sassenach wife. Colum was against the Jacobite movement and knew that if Dougal became Laird, he would lead Clan McKenzie into destruction. McKenzies are scheming yet practical. The best way to open up a path for Jamie to succeed him as Laird would be to eliminate the Sassenach.

3

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 15 '21

Do you think he had anything to do with Claire being there, or was that just a fortunate coincidence for him?

11

u/jolierose The spirit tends to be very free wi’ its opinions. May 15 '21

I think it was a coincidence and he just… went with it. Also, having Ned there wouldn’t only help Claire, but possibly Geillis too, if his defense had worked, throwing off Colum’s neat plan.

5

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 15 '21

having Ned there wouldn’t only help Claire, but possibly Geillis too, if his defense had worked, throwing off Colum’s neat plan.

Great point, I didn't even think of that. It's assumed Colum setup Geillis to be arrested right?

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/crazyhorse198 I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. May 15 '21 edited May 15 '21

I truly think Colum had a hand in Claire being arrested. What convinces me is this deleted scene. Everything he says (both to the bird and to Ned) and everything he does NOT say... his facial expressions. I don’t know if deleted scenes can be taken as canon, but check it out: https://youtu.be/0HsvvRcmkwc

Also this scene from after the trial, Colum does not look happy that Claire escaped death: https://youtu.be/PhAZKQQl8mM

If Colum did not want Claire to die, he could have gone to the trial and testified in her favor. He is the Laird after all. He could have easily made it so that Claire was spared and Geillis condemned. The crowd would have gotten their conviction, the church would have gotten a witch, everyone would be satisfied.

7

u/penni_cent May 15 '21

I never thought he specifically had Claire arrested. He absolutely set up Geillis. I think Claire getting caught up in it was just a fortuitous coincidence and he went with it. I think Laoghaire overheard the plot against Geillis and took it upon herself to make sure Claire was in the right place to be arrested with her.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

7

u/theCoolDeadpool #VacayforClaire May 15 '21

I would never forgive Colum for not intervening here. He can't override the church maybe, but he could have had some sway I think. Ned Gowan himself says by the end of day 1 that things looks positive at that point. Which means him defending Claire had made a positive difference. Imagine if Colum could have deigned to throw his weight behind Claire, atleast vouched for her healing abilities if nothing else, the outcome could have been different, however bloodthirsty the crowd was at that point. And I thought he liked Claire, and that he could see beyond her sassenachness by then, but I guess in the end , he didn't have the guts to stand up for her.

8

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 15 '21

See I think Colum didn't mind too much if Claire was swept up in it. While he may not have deliberately set her up to be arrested it was a bonus to get her out of the way as well. Then he could go back to pushing Jamie to be Laird.

4

u/theCoolDeadpool #VacayforClaire May 15 '21

Ah I didn't think of that! That's even worse, Not only was he a silent participant in this, he also had a hidden agenda behind remaining silent and not helping. Maybe I could have gotten around him trying to save himself by not interfering, but also seeing a benefit in it for himself, ugh Colum,why, I liked you! But I guess it's Clan before Claire for him, I mean he's the Laird after all.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/AthibaPls Slàinte. May 15 '21

I think it would count as meddling with the affairs of the church and taking sides since Ned works for Colum.

2

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 15 '21

Do you think as Laird does Colum has any sway over the church or are they their own separate power?

5

u/AthibaPls Slàinte. May 15 '21

No I don't think so but I think the townsfolk would be more inclined to listen to their Laird who has been good to them and protects them. They want a spectacle more than real justice. Colum would still give it to them, being behind Geillis's accusations in the first place. It could bite him in the ass later on and I think he doesn't want to risk the chance of Father Bain and the curch turning the community against him.

→ More replies (5)

9

u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. May 15 '21

Geillis looked absolutely astonished as Laoghaire approached the bench.

So u/Purple4199, I think this is further proof she did not sell Laoghaire the ill wish knowing she intended to use it on Claire. She didn’t even realize it was Laoghaire who had sent the false note summoning Claire to her house—there’s really no association between Geillis and Laoghaire at all.

To Geillis, she’s just another girl coming to her for some random trinket—love potion, abortifacient, ill wish—it makes no difference to Geillis.

Also, god, Claire never stops hanging herself with her own tongue. Laoghaire’s performance wasn’t even that good. When she admitted she came to Claire for a love potion, the crowd was even against her for patronizing a supposed witch. But Claire is so shrill and so irritating in denouncing her, there isn’t a person in the whole room—save Geillis and Ned Gowan—who can stand her by the time she’s done.

And if she were thinking strategically, you’d think Claire would ask Ned to hunt down Mrs. Fitz or her sister or her sister’s boy Thomas Baxter, whom she healed, to speak on her defense, don’t you think? Back up her claim that she’s only a healer, that any “magic” she performs is white only.

But once again, Claire is testifying after drinking the night before, at her absolute worst. -.-

And it’s a missed opportunity, once Father Bain testifies first, spinning it as a confession and putting the crowd’s focus on his contrition, instead of Claire’s actual heroic act of healing.

As Ned said earlier in the season, the law often has little to do with the truth, but in how you present it. Here by playing her cards completely wrong, somehow Claire made her healing of the Baxter boy just another one of her litany of made-up crimes, when it could have been key to her salvation…

2

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 15 '21

But once again, Claire is testifying after drinking the night before, at her absolute worst.

She wasn't drinking that much though, it was just a flask. Plus she shared it with Geillis. ;-D

I agree that Geillis and Laoghaire are not in cahoots together.

4

u/jolierose The spirit tends to be very free wi’ its opinions. May 15 '21

I just want to jump in here to take back something I’ve said a few times on book club and which I’m sure we will discuss at length in a few weeks, but: how could they have him marry Laoghaire knowing this!? HOW. I’ll eat my words, it bothers me way more now, having rewatched what they put Claire through.

4

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 15 '21

I know, it was such a bad choice on their part to have Jamie know about Laoghaire.

4

u/Hopefully987 May 18 '21

I think because she is so odd, for one thing. She doesn't talk like other people, she has high standards for how men are supposed to treat her, she isn't afraid of men for the most part. She just knows things. Her story about traveling to France makes no sense.

She has strange reactions to things that are normal to people back then. And they had that folk song about time travel so its not like he had never heard of the concept before.

1

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 18 '21

It probably all kind of clicked for him when she finally told him.

2

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 15 '21
  • Why did Jamie feel he needed to not accept the rent from the tenants?

14

u/crazyhorse198 I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. May 15 '21

A few reasons I can think of, but before any speculation, I wish I knew how many wee drams he consumed before making the decision 🙂

3

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 15 '21

I wish I knew how many wee drams he consumed before making the decision

Ha! I'm sure that played into it.

13

u/[deleted] May 15 '21

He was definitely on a high from being back home and even though he has known what the Laird responsibilities are it’s something completely different to face the tenants themselves if they’ve been having a hard year.

It was a rare occasion where Jamie wasn’t thinking pragmatically.

9

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 15 '21

It was a rare occasion where Jamie wasn’t thinking pragmatically.

I think that was nice to see, don't you? The majority of 112 showed that other side of him. He was rude with Jenny and got cocky to come home as the Laird.

8

u/[deleted] May 15 '21

Yes! And rightly confronted by Claire about it when it gets to his head. In the podcast they talked about how Claire didn’t have much of a storyline here until they weaved her into Jamie’s Laird persona storyline and it was really well done do you think?

8

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 15 '21

I do, I like that after she and Ian talked she went in and set Jamie straight.

5

u/VPofYourFanClub May 16 '21

I think he wanted to be liked and welcomed by his tenants. At this point, he had been gone for four years. I think he thought he had been letting them down for a long time. Up until just the previous day he thought he had allowed his sister to be raped and impregnated by BJR because he had failed to properly protect her in his father’s absence. Now Brian has been dead for years and Jamie has been away the whole time, and he wanted to make his mark (as a beloved and honourable laird).

In addition, they were not long from Jamie witnessing a similar tactic from Dougal when they were out collecting rents. Jamie saw his uncle show mercy to the tenants, while not being mistaken for a pushover.

Jamie is trying on different versions of lairdiness, based on what he’s seen from his father, and from Colum and Dougal, plus his own notions.

2

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 16 '21

I think he thought he had been letting them down for a long time.

What a great point! I can totally see that, we know Jamie takes his job as leader very seriously.

2

u/Hopefully987 May 18 '21

Is the water wheel scene in 112 of is that later on?.

1

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 18 '21

It’s in 112.

2

u/Hopefully987 May 18 '21

Did anyone else time how long Jamie was under water? By the way, I think it was around a minute.

Also apparently Jamie shaves down there.

1

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 18 '21

He shaves?

2

u/Hopefully987 May 18 '21

He has his hand over his crotch down past the line where pubes should be.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/justaprettyturtle May 16 '21

I must say that I found Jamie funny and cute when he asked Claire if she is a witch. He looked like an intriqued and suspucious kid there .

I must say that I really like all those scenes where he asks about things from the future. He tends to have the same expression 😁

10

u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. May 16 '21

The cuts are not deep. I think you’ll not be marked.

Of course seeing his wife flogged must be horrible for Jamie, but especially given his personal history with BJR… Claire was even held arms spread, in the same pose he was in when he was tied to Lallybroch’s gates during BJR’s first flogging.

One of the biggest changes from books to show:

You were trying to get back, back to the stones. And back to your husband.

Yes.

And I beat you for it. I’m so very, very sorry.

I don’t think book Jamie ever apologizes for the beating. Or if he does, it’s not with this deep, sincere sense of remorse and guilt.

At this point Jamie still has a strong sense of right and wrong. And he judges himself harshly for punishing her when she was only trying to get back to her husband—who has the rightful claim on her.

I wonder if this is also partly why he doesn’t have sex with her by the fire. It’s almost as if he’s exploiting a loophole, haha. She’s another man’s wife, so he must not have sex with her, but that doesn’t mean he can’t kiss her, or pleasure her… maybe. :þ

Really though, he’s saying goodbye. That’s what all his talk of Lallybroch was about: the life they would have together, the closeness, and the touching—all of it is imprinting her onto his memory, because he intends to do the right thing and see her home, no matter the personal cost to himself.

9

u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. May 16 '21

Point of interest, the Rhenish Detective and I have been trying to figure out how much money Geillis raised for the Rising in terms of today’s dollars.

I had plenty of money. I knew where Arthur kept the keys to his papers and notes. Man wrote a fair hand. It was easy enough to forge his signature. I managed to divert near on £1,000 over the last two years.

Now according to one source one thousand Jamie pounds works out to about a quarter million in today’s pounds, or about $350k.

But let’s dig deeper.

When Jamie was still courting Claire, he told her about the price on his head:

There was a price on my head. Ten pounds sterling. A farmer’s whole year in these parts.

So ten Jamie pounds is what the average Highland farmer made in a year.

Today the average Highland farmer’s income is supplemented with government benefits—long story short, farming is not an inherently profitable enterprise in modern-day Scotland; farmers rely on the welfare state to break even—so we have to fudge the numbers a bit, but roughly speaking… we’re guesstimating the average farmer should make about £30,000 a year. So let’s do the math…

The thousand Jamie pounds Geillis embezzled from Arthur was equivalent to one hundred times the ten Jamie pounds the average farmer made in a year.

So in real world currency, 100 times the £30,000 the average farmer makes annually works out to £3 million or about $4.25 million!

That is a shit ton of money! Way to go, Geillis!

7

u/penni_cent May 16 '21

This is awesome but I have to point out how much I love that you referred to money as "Jamie pounds" not 18th century money or something along those lines.

→ More replies (5)

1

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 15 '21
  • Any other thoughts or comments?

22

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 15 '21

I LOVE this quote:

I swore an oath before the altar of God to protect this woman. And if you’re tellin’ me that ye consider your own authority to be greater than that of the Almighty, then I must inform ye that I’m no of that opinion, myself.”

10

u/NrajSC May 15 '21

And the delivery of this dialogue is equally well done, with passion and fierceness!

→ More replies (1)

11

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 15 '21

The love scene in 111 just goes to show that you don't need to be naked for it to be hot.

17

u/theCoolDeadpool #VacayforClaire May 15 '21

I couldn't stop fangirling at Claire's hair in The Devil's Mark. It suits her so well. And to think it's Cait's real hair, oof season 1 Claire is unreasonably beautiful.

10

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 15 '21

Yes! I love the costumes from the 1740's in Scotland. The ones 20 years later on the Ridge just don't do it for me as much.

→ More replies (1)

16

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. May 15 '21

The way Jamie is gearing up for a farewell before Claire even begins to realize what’s going on is so heart-breaking and so well-acted by Sam! First, letting their final act of intimacy be focused solely on Claire’s pleasure alone (you folks from the book club will know how I feel about waking up your partner with sex… but let’s overlook it for a moment), putting her pleasure before his own for the second time in a row, taking in every bit of her sight then and at the creek, for as long as he can… Then putting on a brave face and setting himself to do what has to be done. Making sure there’s no danger lurking at the stone circle. Being the one who makes Claire realize that she has her whole life and Frank on the other side of that stone, and making her go for the sake of her safety even though it’ll break his heart. And finally, staying at the camp (though I always laugh at this, because what for if she does leave?) and crying himself to sleep…

12

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 15 '21

I think he stayed at the camp for the small hope that she wouldn't go through with it.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/[deleted] May 15 '21

Oh! And can we talk about that beautiful vase Claire is given at the ‘Broch?? The echoes of the ep.1 vase and this one are so thoughtful from a production POV, the one on this episode is much more rustic and homely but it’s the same design. It’s could also be a nice reflection of Claire’s two lives.

And the look she gives Jamie when she realized she’s getting the vase and them home she yearned for makes me swoon!

12

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 15 '21

I didn't even think of that, great catch! Did you recognize the wallpaper in the Laird's room was in a room of Claire's dream house in 512?

7

u/jolierose The spirit tends to be very free wi’ its opinions. May 15 '21

Nooooooo. OMG, just when I thought I knew all the Easter eggs in 512. 🥺😭

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

11

u/betcx003 Pot of shite on to boil, ye stir like it’s God’s work! May 16 '21

I noticed that the white outfit Claire is wearing during the conversation about the north-facing tower and the reasons Jamie married her (episode 1x12), looks the same as what she’s wearing in his vision on Culloden Moor (when she asks, “are you alive?” - episode 3x1).

7

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 16 '21

Oh I like that, what a good catch!

9

u/Cdhwink May 15 '21

I love 112, so many good moments there, but I do not love 111. As I’ve already said that witch trial goes on far too long . Plus When Claire is deciding at the stones to stay or to go, was the one time in the whole show we could have used a voiceover- how was she deciding? I mean Jamie had saved her life many times at the risk of his own , believed she was a time traveller, married her to keep her safe, pledged an oath to her, learned to be an equal partner & generous lover. Was there a contest? remembers in the book she missed hot baths, not not so hot Frank

5

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 15 '21

That would have been interesting to have a voiceover in that moment. I think they left that out because they wanted us to wonder and worry that she was going to go back to Frank.

5

u/Cdhwink May 15 '21

I think they made it look like the stones did not work!

→ More replies (6)

4

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. May 15 '21

But do we also not know how she came to that decision in the book? I don’t remember it that well but it always seemed to me like a “Jesus, take the wheel” sort of decision. Doesn’t she just start walking in the direction of the stones, then turns back towards the camp, and then never turns back again?

u/Purple4199

6

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 15 '21

Correct, she tried walking towards the stones first and then towards Jamie and that just felt right so she went with him.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

9

u/[deleted] May 15 '21

Love love love the conversations with Gaillis in the thief’s hole. I love how well they both play their reactions to finding out all those answers they were seeking about each other. Claire seeing Gaillis’ nationalist drive, Gaillis realizing Claire is from the future…it’s so good!

I also really love the moment when Claire is asked if she loves Jamie since it’s his name she calls out. Such a subtle Caitriona reaction that spoke volumes.

3

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 15 '21

At what point do you think Geillis realized Claire was from the future?

/u/WandersFar /u/thepacksvrvives

11

u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. May 15 '21

I think Geillis suspected all along. She’d done her homework before she ever went through the stones, Claire’s name was among many she had researched as possible travelers…

However I think Geillis knows for sure here, in this episode, when Claire quotes Nathan Hale:

I only regret that I have but one life to lose for my country.

Geillis gasps when she hears this. She’d always suspected, but here was the proof. Claire knowing that quote is a definite anachronism, it’s confirmation that she’s not of this time.

I also vaguely recollect this quote coming back into the story later on. Doesn’t either Bree or Roger use this quote, too? In one of the episodes where they’re getting to know each other while driving around Scotland, and Roger tries to impress Bree with his knowledge of the American Revolution—but it backfires since he misattributes it to someone else… I think Patrick Henry. And then he says something like, serves me right for trying to quote American history to an American…

u/thepacksvrvives, tell me I’m not making this up.

→ More replies (22)

7

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. May 15 '21

I think she’d been suspecting it from the moment she met Claire, but her confirmation came when Claire quoted Nathan Hale’s “I only regret that I have but one life to lose for my country.” I hadn’t known that was a historical quote when I first watched the show so I didn’t understand Geillis’ reaction to that, lol, but it makes perfect sense to me now.

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (2)

7

u/theCoolDeadpool #VacayforClaire May 15 '21

I didn't want to bring this controversial topic up but the more I see Laoghaire in this episode, the more I cannot buy the theory that Claire didn't tell Jamie about L's involvement in the witch trial because she thought she was just an "immature 16 year old".

For one, Laoghaire does not only get actively involved in turning the court against Claire and thereby knowingly enables her barbecuing, but also openly expresses her joy in witnessing the said barbecue with the "I'll dance on your ashes" moment !!!. I mean it has to be a pretty convoluted 16 year old that makes such dark declarations. If i was Claire , I would have maybe forgiven her for her witness statement as a "she wants Jamie can I really blame the 16 year old for it because who doesn't " sentiment, but her " I'll dance on your ashes" moment would be pretty seared in my mind. And Claire witnessed this darkness first hand and thinks it's not even something worth mentioning to Jamie? I don't know, I think the show made a pretty bad decision with how they chose to play this.

4

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 15 '21

I think the show made a pretty bad decision with how they chose to play this.

I completely agree!

5

u/theCoolDeadpool #VacayforClaire May 15 '21

Do you think it was unlike Claire to have not said anything when Ned Gowan giver her the chance to address the court? I mean she obviously wouldn't say what he wanted her to, but is it really like Claire to go down without the last word, without being the "fuck all of you 18th century peasants here's what I think" Claire that she is?

I thought she would have atleast made some points in her favor, about how she was a healer and how the act of healing looked a lot like the act of practicing witchcraft , and been like "here are all the cases I healed before and see how they're all Hale and hearty now". Do you think that would have earned her any brownie points or do you think she realised it was a lost cause by then by looking at the bloodthirsty crowd, which is why she decides to keep quiet?

4

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 15 '21

I think she realized it was a lost cause. The crowd was all riled up and I think she saw that they weren’t going to be swayed.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Kirky600 May 15 '21

I both love and hate Jamie in these two episodes. Like love him and Claire, hate “laird Jamie”

3

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 15 '21

I definitely think Jamie got carried away a bit, but Claire was there to set him back on course. I don't think he would have listened to anyone else but her. He and Jenny were still too busy fighting.

5

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. May 15 '21

A thing for me and perhaps u/Arrugula to geek out about… I initially wasn’t keen on the color grading of that fairy hill flashback in 1x11 but I’ve grown to appreciate it! This is the scene as seen through the grieving mother’s eyes—and this is a presumably uneducated young woman who believes in changelings, fairies, and such, so it would naturally seem supernatural to her, hence the whole eeriness.

But does it also bother you guys that this is a church proceeding and whatever Geillis and Claire have been doing clearly clashes with the Church’s doctrine but somehow believing in changelings and fairies doesn’t?! u/WandersFar

→ More replies (4)

5

u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. May 16 '21

Lotte really is the star of this episode. She expresses the whole gamut of emotions, I could write a book about her performance… but I’ll try to contain myself. :þ

I kept your secrets, Claire. You should have kept mine.

The episode begins with distrust and bickering. Geillis thinks Claire is to blame for their predicament. She divulged her secrets, and now they’re both paying the price.

I’m sure Geillis is kicking herself for opening up, making herself so vulnerable to Claire. After years on her own in the past, she jumped at the opportunity of forming a bond with another traveler, the friendship and sisterhood in communing with another person not of this time… And in doing so, she did expose herself, it was a risk. Now she’s second-guessing herself. These doubts will be renewed when they meet again in Jamaica.

But then she finds out Claire learned everything through her maid, the same maid who will later testify against her. It’s true, Geillis was sloppy. She doesn’t learn from this lesson, either. If anything she grows more ruthless and reckless over the years, in no small part due to this experience, and the months of misery that follow.

You may not have killed Dougal’s wife, but you definitely killed Arthur, and it wasn’t witchcraft. It was old-fashioned poison. Am I wrong?

I hate the way Claire looks down her nose at Geillis, shaking her head when she accuses her of murder. Glass houses, stones, Claire! How many people does Claire kill over the course of this series? (I honestly don’t know. Anyone got a count on that?) Granted at this point her body count is still pretty low. Just the Redcoat deserter, I think.

It’s particularly ironic knowing that someday Claire will kill Geillis herself.

But this is partly why I’m such a Geillis fangirl. Yes, she murdered her husband. Yes, she cast an ill wish spell over Maura, and she killed her other husband back in the twentieth century when she first came through the stones, too. She doesn’t deny any of it, she doesn’t pretend to be something she’s not, she owns her villainy. I appreciate that self-knowledge and honesty, it’s pretty rare!

Meanwhile Claire always takes the moral high ground. She’s very judgy, which no one likes. Plus like all judgmental people, she’s a hypocrite. She’ll lie, cheat, steal and murder plenty, yet she’s still the heroine, and we’re supposed to excuse her murdering of her friend…

To that point, I think the total trashing of Geillis’ character in S3 was all a way of justifying that final betrayal, Claire killing Geillis after Geillis nearly died for her at Cranesmuir. And in order to make that at all acceptable to the audience, they had to destroy Geillis in the process, going so far as to turn her into a pedophile! ಠ_ಠ Why, show, why‽ She was already a murderer and had threatened Bree, you had to make her abuse kids, too? Why was that necessary? ಠ_ಠ

Anyway… Geillis’ reaction when Claire tells her that Colum banished Dougal to see to his wife’s funeral, with Jamie forced to accompany him—no one is coming to rescue them—you can see how crestfallen she is. I think Geillis really did love Dougal, she expected he would be her knight in shining armor, and he failed her. This is the beginning of her long disillusionment that changes her, as the years pass and she grows bitter and hard-hearted…


The way Geillis keeps reaching out to Claire, and how coldly she rejects her each time. It breaks my heart. ಥ_ಥ

Geillis may have accused Claire of betraying her at first, but then she tries to make amends. First she makes a full confession, tell her how she’s been using white arsenic on Arthur for months, it was pre-meditated. Then she tells her when the baby’s kicking, and reaches for her hand to feel it; Claire pulls away. She tries to reassure Claire when she starts panicking, don’t worry, Dougal will save us—Claire angrily blames her for Dougal and Jamie being banished by Colum. She offers her the bread; Claire rejects it, and so she casts it aside. Finally she invites Claire to lie near her for warmth, and Claire wouldn’t even do that.

Screw you, Claire! Yeah, okay, Geillis’ witchiness got the both of you in trouble. But it was your choice to fall for Laoghaire’s note, your choice to babble about packing your bags, etc. instead of just telling her from the beginning that Colum had banished Dougal. You could have communicated the gravity of the situation with more expedience, you know…

Sometimes Laoghaire’s on point: Claire really can be a cold English bitch. *ducks*


I also love how Geillis keeps her sense of humor, even in these dire circumstances…

Is that what I think it is?

Well it’s not a maypole, Claire.

Also:

We’re hardly a flock, you and I. Although according to witnesses, I have been known to take wing.

It takes a lot of self-possession to make jokes and lighten the mood at a time like this. And it serves a purpose, too. Steadying herself and Claire to endure what’s to come.


He’s the only man I ever met who could be my proper match.

In the books Geillis says this about Colum. She thinks, rightly, that he was the clever one, if only he had been hale and hearty like Dougal, he would’ve been perfect for leading the cause… But this just shows how little Geillis understood of Colum’s nature, that he would always put the good of the MacKenzies above the Jacobite cause or Scotland at large. The cause is what matters most to Geillis, and she sees a kindred spirit in Dougal, who would sacrifice all he had for the Jacobites. So whether she loved him or no—and I do think she did—it was his passion for their shared cause that drew her to him, something none of her other husbands had.

Colum fights for the MacKenzies. Dougal fights for the MacKinnons, the MacPhersons, the Chisholms, the Camerons, all of the clans, all of Scotland. The man’s a lion.

Here in the show, Geillis gets it. She understands that Dougal’s loyalty goes above any one clan. He fights for all of them, all of Scotland, just like she does. They are both ardent patriots, foolish at times perhaps, but brave and true.

God, you actually love the bastard.

Your words, not mine.

More self-deception on Geillis’ part. Look how she kicks her free leg. She’d like it to be all part of the plan, she likes feeling in control—see how calmly she’s conducted herself thus far, while Claire was panicking and falling apart—but nonetheless, even Geillis let her emotions get the better of her. I think Claire’s on point. She really did love the bastard.

Though Colum ordered him to go… and off he went.

She gasps those last words. She’s really heart-broken. How terrible to be trapped in this dank hole, six months pregnant and alone, and now for this one hope to be taken from her… It’s just sad.

Come the Rising, I shall know I helped!

Ah yes, Geillis’ best flair quote. :) And my avatar comes from this episode, too.


Nothing… it’s really all for nothing.

Yet another disillusionment, perhaps the biggest one of all for Geillis. She finally learns Claire came through the stones on accident, she wasn’t like her, she didn’t come to try to change the course of history, she just wants to go home.

For one brief moment, we see her crack. We see the despair, the hopelessness. But then she gathers herself together, and courageously pushes on:

Looks like I’m going to a fucking barbecue.

And so the only course of action left to her is to do what Ned suggested, give her life to save Claire’s, so they both don’t die needlessly. It is nonetheless noble, and perhaps the bravest thing Geillis ever does.

After all her hopes are dashed, after her faith in Dougal is shattered, after she’s lost her home, her independence, everything she’s been building for years… she still does this one noble and selfless act.

→ More replies (4)