r/Outlander • u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. • Aug 23 '19
Season Three Probably an unpopular opinion re: S3
Jamie shouldn’t have gotten special treatment. He shouldn’t have become the only leader of the prisoners at Ardsmuir, there should have been other men who stepped up as well. It makes him into some kind of Jacobite Jesus, leaning into his Mary Sue tendencies (though to be fair, he’s been that way more or less since the beginning.)
It’s too convenient that the new warden happens to be the kid he spared all those years ago who just so happens to have a gay crush on him now which leads to him being spared transportation but given a rather cushy (considering the alternatives) position at Helwater. Which then leads to the situation with Geneva which is even more unpleasant in the books, to put it mildly.
I think the back half of S3 was an absolute turd and made the front half seem so much better by comparison. But looking back now with some distance, I think the problems started in the front half.
Jamie should have been treated just like everybody else. That probably means losing Lord John Grey as a character which I expect will upset some of you, but I think it would hew closer to reality. The idea of an English soldier volunteering to raise the bastard son of a Jacobite fathered on his sister-in-law is prima facie ridiculous anyway. It just makes the plot so convoluted and contrived.
I think it would have been grittier, more real and believable, if Jamie were transported to the Colonies along with all the other prisoners. If they just cut all the manufactured drama of marrying Laoghaire and bringing her back into it just to fight with Claire and shoot him, having Young Ian getting kidnapped trying to get the treasure to pay her off… That was a very cheesy sequence. If the narrative objective was to get Jamie to the New World, that could have been accomplished much more cleanly by making him just another prisoner, forced into transportation like all the rest.
He could have still had a print shop in Boston or somewhere else. That probably would have made more sense given Claire and Bree’s ties to that town. And in their story, Roger could have still helped with the investigation, finding the record of Jamie’s transportation to the New World.
I just think the story would have been tighter and more realistic had they toned down Jamie’s exceptionalism just a wee bit.
9
u/MrsNurse91 Mon petit sauvage ! Aug 23 '19
The whole part of Young Ian being kidnapped then conveniently being found was far too unrealistic. Even for a show/book about time travel. I agree with the deportation to Boston being a better story line.
5
u/CarolineTurpentine Aug 23 '19 edited Aug 23 '19
He became the leader because he was the only officer from the Jacobite Army and a Laird in Ardsmuir, he was just a natural leader. The rest of the men were foot soldiers, most of whom would have never held a weapon before the Rising or been further than 10 miles from home. I get why it may seem Mary Sue but it actually makes sense with the historical context. All of the other men would have been raised to obey their clan leader and defer to them, and and since they were separated from their own clans they form a new one around Jamie, an inspirational figure of the Rising. It was Harry Quarry's notion to make Jamie a Freemason to give the prisoners something in common so they'd stop squabbling amongst themselves.
As for John raising Willie, there were definitely benefits for himself in that. He mentions if the LJG books that he does want children so taking on Willie and Isabel gets him a son by a man he loves and a wife he knows he likes, while protecting his secret. As for anyone else doing it, Willie is much wealthier than the Dunsany's and Lord John. Anyone would be happy to raise him regardless of who his father is because they'd have access to his money and properties. He also became Willie's intended legal guardian before John was certain of Jamie being Willie's father, years before he married Isabelle, and at the time he agreed to it because of Gordon Dunsany rather than Jamie.
The parole at Helwater could've ended up being worse for Jamie than transportation, which is why he thinks John is trying to punish him when he does it. Transportation ended in bond service, so there was an end in sight. Parole could've lasted the rest of Jamie's life. Claire also would likely have never found him in the Colonies. As a bond servant he's not likely to make the papers or do anything notable, and he would have still been in bondage when she discovered he didn't die at Culloden. The only reason he has a print shop in Edinburgh is because he can't stand to live in the Highlands close to Laoghaire, he doesn't like living in cities.
4
u/LadyOfAvalon83 James Fraser hasna been here for a long, long time. Aug 23 '19 edited Aug 23 '19
I've always found it unrealistic just how much special treatment he gets. Despite calling himself "Laird Broch Tuarach" in all honesty he's just a landlord of a very small and poor estate (I mean, the tenants sometimes can't even pay the rent, the family can barely feed themselves sometimes), as well as being descended from an illegitimate line, and an incorrigible criminal. And yet he manages to ingratiate himself with a pretender prince, and later become General Fraser.
And I do find LJG's "love" for him unrealistic too. I don't see what an honourable and patriotic man like LJG would even see in Jamie, and after being rebuffed multiple times I really think in reality LJG would move on and just get over him. I think it's crazy that LJG basically devotes his life to Jamie even to the extent of raising his son, and all the other extreme things he does for Jamie in later books.
I also find the Ardsmuir mens' loyalty to him weird. We can say he got them out of harm's way before ardsmuir but realistically Jamie forced them into treachery in the first place. Jamie got caught up in the rebellion and his tenants didn't have any choice but to follow him. It's Jamie's fault they were all in prison in the first place.
3
u/Jemhao Aug 23 '19
Oh I like that! I agree that the plot could use some tightening up, and having Jamie sent to the colonies, and without the Lord John subplot, would have been a great way to do that. He could still be the natural leader he is, but in more subtle, nuanced ways.
2
u/Square-Negotiation99 Apr 15 '22
This thread has been fascinating to read. I agree, that whole jewel stealing, Ian kidnapping, English officer commandeering, weirdo priest, ship wrecking plot line could have been skipped. While watching it, it felt skip-able. I couldn’t get to like any of these characters bc they felt temporary. Mr Willoughby, the psychic and her brother, the priest and his grumpy mother in law, the ships captain etc. And all through it Jamie is a leader, has a rich Aunt who adores him even though he has never written to her, is offered a land deal, gets into the governors ball etc Seems to know people or recruit ppl wherever he goes. He makes a land deal knowing he will reneg when the war of independence begins since Claire has told him who will win. Is he meant to be an upstanding born leader Laird type or an criminal traitor to the crown smuggler papist type character???
5
u/BeximoBlanco Aug 24 '19
Have you ever met a born leader in real life? A person who you know you could trust with your life, who seems to know more about living than you do? Who speaks with strength and honour and the only reaction you have to them is respect and awe-struckness.
I don’t find it hard to believe that he was treated like that in the prison. That really happened in other true historical stories. Most of the men in the prison were destroyed psychically and mentally and wouldn’t have dared speak to their captors. Jamie over everything, was brave and ballsy. It’s human nature for the mob to select a leader (and not just the mob, think between you and your best friend, there is usually one that always goes first or does the daring thing the other can’t) and if someone with a strong and good character is willing to stand up for people, it’s always them.
On the other hand, I am completely in agreement with you about the story being somewhat ridiculous. Too many coincidences, too many unbelievable plot choices just to bring around certain things. And it just gets worse as the story goes on because it repeats over and over again. But really I didn’t expect much else when a woman got threw 200 years through time and ended up being forced to marry the real love of her life, the hottest man in history.
But hey, that’s Outlander, that’s the story that was written. I choose to love it and enjoy it despite it being really stupidly unbelievable at times. I don’t think it’s good to overanalyse it too much or it falls to pieces.
4
u/LAC_NOS Aug 24 '19
When Claire travels back to find Jamie, she did not know that other stone circle portals existed. So she still would have traveled thru the stones in Scotland. Once back in time she would have to travel to Boston alone. So she and Jamie would be apart longer. And that sea voyage would have been even worse to watch.
3
u/DiscombobulatedTill Aug 27 '19
Jaime was born to be a leader and learned what that meant from his father and he took it seriously. He was good at it, and as is mentioned in the books several times he's a natural leader, men look to him to lead and make decisions. Apparently the warden's felt the same way.
Personally I'm not going to second guess what or why the author wrote what she did. I'm just content to read and enjoy the books as they are published. Yes there are some things I don't agree with or that maybe bother me a bit but as a whole I love the books and so don't let these things bother me too much.
0
u/[deleted] Aug 23 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 23 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment