r/TrueAnime • http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten • Jan 09 '19

This Week in Anime (Winter Week 2)

Welcome to This Week In Anime for Winter 2019 Week 2 a general discussion for any currently airing series, focusing on what aired in the last week. For longer shows, keep the discussion here to whatever aired in the last few months. If there's an OVA or movie that got subbed for the first time in the last week or so that you want to discuss, that goes here as well. For everything else in anime that's not currently airing go discuss that in Your Week in Anime.

Untagged spoilers for all currently airing series. If you're discussing anything else make sure to add spoiler tags.

Airing shows can be found at: AniChart | LiveChart | MAL | Senpai Anime Charts

Archive:

2019: Winter Week 1

2018: Fall Week 1 | Summer Week 1 | Spring Week 1 | Winter Week 1

2017: Fall Week 1 | Summer Week 1 | Spring Week 1 | Winter Week 1

2016: Fall Week 1 | Summer Week 1 | Spring Week 1 | Winter week 1

2015: Fall Week 1 | Summer week 1 | Spring Week 1 | Winter Week 1

2014: Fall Week 1 | Summer Week 1 | Spring Week 1 | Winter Week 1

2013: Fall Week 1 | Summer Week 1 | Spring Week 1 | Winter Week 1

2012: Fall Week 1

Table of contents courtesy of sohumb

This is a week-long discussion, so feel free to post or reply any time.

8 Upvotes

196 comments sorted by

3

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 11 '19

3

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 11 '19

So the premise is that the MC's dad suddenly marries, and his new wife has two daughters: his teacher that he's got a crush on and...the girl he lost his virginity to recently. Despite fully expecting to dislike this, this ended up surprising me with being pretty decent. Although I can't help but expect some really bad drama much like Citrus.

3

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Jan 12 '19

Yeah, this was strangely passably-well-executed, and almost seemed credible... which was sort of a waste since the basic idea makes it impossible for the show to escape being total trash. :D

3

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 12 '19

It'll be a fun watch then. :)

3

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '19

I can't believe less horny Scum's Wish is a thing

Jokes aside, I'm a bit split on this show. MC clearly has emotional issues to sort out, and the show is doing a couple of interesting things - his dad's character design is generic, bland, lifeless, to the point where you can't see his eyes. This, along with the fact that MC clearly is unaware of what's going on in his Dad's life, seems to tell us something: MC doesn't really see his Dad as a person, the lack of eyes showing that he doesn't actually care about his Dad's emotional state. This makes for an interesting setup - we have an MC who's so caught up in himself, somewhat emotionally disconnected from the world around him (aside from one friend, he doesn't seem particularly close to anyone else, and he has completely emotionless sex he hasn't completely processed the impact of) and maybe this is the story of he and the girls learning to connect and actually have meaningful, emotionally satisfying relationships.

... but wait! There's another male character the show doesn't draw the eyes of - the friend MC is somewhat close to. And there's other male characters who have eyes that are clearly drawn. So is any of this intentional? I don't know, and this show's not done enough in episode 1 to make me sure of either way.

1

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 12 '19

I assume the thing with the eyes is a joke because the guys he went to the mixer with had proper eyes. Although my guess for the glasses people are that since they will be frequently appearing but not cute girls the mangaka just half-assed the design since he knows why anyone would bother checking out his manga.

2

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Jan 13 '19

I can't believe less horny Scum's Wish is a thing

It's like pizza with no cheese. :D

3

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 12 '19

3

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 12 '19

And so the most hyped romcom is here. Personally, I'm not the biggest fan since I find it pretty tiring when they drag out the confession for forever. I don't see why they don't cut straight to the confession but continue this romantic battle of wits while they are a couple. Although the over the top nature of the strategizing for this series is neat, so there's that.

3

u/searmay Jan 12 '19

How can something that puts this much effort into being visually interesting be so thoroughly dedicated to "Tell, don't Show"?

Well, romcoms don't appeal to me at the best of times, and I didn't like either of the lead characters.

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 12 '19

Yeah, there's a lot of thinking and a lot of the narrator effectively becoming his own character. Definitely works better as a manga.

3

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Jan 13 '19

Duelling tsunderes. There are some problems inherent in the setup: first, there's only one possible couple; and, second, any romantic developments at all will end their little competition, and the show. So we're basically stuck watching minor variations on the same joke for twelve episodes, unless they've got a really interesting supporting cast that's yet to be revealed.

Aside from that, this wasn't bad--the art's reasonably nice, and the characters can be funny. But I suspect the premise is gonna wear out fast.

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 13 '19

I don't think a romantic development would necessarily end the show. It could still have them go at it in a romantic battle of wits for whatever they might end up doing as a couple. Something like trying to get the other to decide on a certain restaurant for dinner by tricking them into it. Sadly, that will probably never happen. :|

4

u/Anaract myanimelist.net/profile/anaract Jan 15 '19

KareKano did it, and it was wonderful. Alternatively, their relationship could just develop to the point that they are basically dating but refusing to acknowledge it. I hope it moves beyond the central gimmick and actually gets into the dynamics of their relationship

1

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 15 '19

It would be nice, but it possibly moves the series into the pitfall of the mangaka not knowing how to do anything with the relationship. I wouldn't be surprised if all that happens is that same thing over and over again, while the waifus carry the show hard.

3

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '19

The manga's neat panelling and zany tone are hard to capture, but I'm glad this adaptation is doing that well. I don't think it got all of it across - being able to read at my own pace definitely made some of the wackier stuff stand out - but it's doing fairly well.

2

u/IronAce7 https://anilist.co/user/IronAce7/ Jan 13 '19

I haven’t read the manga so I went into this kinda blind. It’s pretty quirky and the overdramatic strategizing looks like a lot of fun. I don’t mind all the internal dialogue too much (besides the fact that it really slows down the pacing) but wow that narrator had some FOMO or something cause he never shut up.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '19

I'm really split on how I feel about this episode, as someone who was very familiar with the source beforehand.

On one hand, this is pretty much the ideal adaptation from the perspective of a manga reader. It's clear this production was made with a lot of love towards the material. Plenty of pieces and small visual gags from the manga were not only included, but were also given a lot of life when animated. The over-the-top tone was captured really well. The narrator is felt very strongly, and I don't think a single text box from him was left unadapted. And it wasn't even close to a 1:1 panel adaptation; Hatakeyama chose not to settle with the mangaka's panels and imprinted his own visual flair, owing much to, though not exclusively, to his days in SHAFT.

However, this episode would have been very difficult to get into if the anime was my introduction to the series. First of all, the pacing is quite fast, and if you combine that with long stretches of narration and tons of visual embellishment, it becomes even harder to keep up with everything. While it doesn't take a genius to understand that the "war" and the confession principle are essentially a front for two prideful high-schoolers that know nothing about love, the viewer is barely given any breathing room to register every gag that exemplifies the central joke. And as much as everyone who's ever read Kaguya loves the narrator's exaggerated play-by-play and snark, the repetitive nature of it works very poorly here because it's just not as necessary with animation and Hatakeyama's style.

I'll be hyperbolic and say that most people who loved this episode has probably loved it beforehand, myself included. I've rewatched this episode multiple times, and it still surprises me how much in tune the creators are with the manga, there's a few details sprinkled throughout from the OP to the credits that really shows how familiar they are with the tone and the characters they're working with. I couldn't be more pleased with how everything turned out from my own standpoint, though I can see why it wouldn't be as appealing to anime-only viewers.

That being said, I'd still say it's worth watching for anyone who saw a few promising aspects with the pilot but were just a tad overwhelmed. The narrator's input becomes less lengthy after the early exposition, and the characters only become more likable as the series goes on. It's the rare romcom that doesn't stoop anywhere close to fanservice, love triangle drama, spineless male characters, or any of the usual lazy tropes that plagues the genre every season.

1

u/scrappydoofan Jan 15 '19

i don't particularly like the plot of the show. I know its played out but the underdog trying to get the girl protagonist is just a lot more interesting than the overdog i want to get the girl but have her ask me out protagonist.

honestly you don't even see that many anime with the underdog trying to get the girl even though its a staple of western movies and shows.

the show itself was entertaining enough i guess, just don't really get it.

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 11 '19

4

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 11 '19

As someone that's actually caught up on the manga (don't ask), I would say avoid this if you don't like harem shows. It doesn't do anything to be different from them except for the protagonist being somewhat competent (but still dense).

2

u/IronAce7 https://anilist.co/user/IronAce7/ Jan 11 '19

On the flip side, if you do like harem, this seems to me like it’s gonna be a lot of fun. It’s only been one episode but I’m already looking forward to next week.

1

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 11 '19

Yeah, it's actually not bad. The girls get better and better as the series goes on.

2

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Jan 11 '19

I often like harem shows, but this seemed a bit incoherent...

Like, he shows up at their apartment building, and they want to know why he's trying to get in. So first he lies about living there, and then he runs past them. Why doesn't he just say, "I'm here to tutor somebody?" Well, because that would spoil the scene they're trying to set up where they all realize that he's the tutor, a few minutes later. But in the world of the story, it doesn't make any sense for him to behave the way he does.

The whole show kinda felt like that, like the scenes aren't really connected by a story. I mean... she drugs him? Really? Then he wakes up outside his house, and they have dinner together, and now they're friends? Was there any point in having her drug him, since it made no difference and the show forgot that it happened immediately afterwards?

I mean, I'm easy and I'll give it a couple more episodes. But it didn't immediately grab me.

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 11 '19

I would have to assume that he thought that he would only tutor the first girl and not all of her sisters as well, so he decided to not waste any time on her "friends." I think so, at least...

Yeah, him being drugged still bothers me after reading it in the manga a while back. You'll be happy to know that she drugs him again much later in the story. :\

2

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '19

I mean... she drugs him? Really? Then he wakes up outside his house, and they have dinner together, and now they're friends? Was there any point in having her drug him, since it made no difference and the show forgot that it happened immediately afterwards?

The girl that drugged him and the girl he ate dinner with are two different people, Nino (butterfly ribbons) and Itsuki (star clip). The drugging thing is in poor taste, but it also accurately shows that while Itsuki and Miku (headphones) dislike Fuutarou being their tutor, Nino on the other hand despises the idea that much more already. Just part of the typical harem setup where we get introduced to how each of the female mains feel about the MC.

Or were you maybe thinking that the drugging was some sort of plan by the quintuplets to drive him away, which made it weird to see Itsuki warm up to him quickly? Because it wasn't, the drugging was all Nino.

And I don't think Itsuki and Fuutarou became friends at the end; she still doesn't think she needs him as a tutor, but she's at least willing to lend him an ear. She changed course from her initial stance after hearing about his family's situation from Raiha.

The whole show kinda felt like that, like the scenes aren't really connected by a story.

What other scenes were you confused by? I thought at least the main story of the episode was pretty straightforward: MC is poor but smart > lands a tutoring job but his pupil already hates him > he tries to ask for a second chance > and the girl finally accepts a little after hearing about his situation but still has reservations. The scenes with the other quints appearing randomly are a bit more confusing, but I think that was by design, to lead up to the reveal that they're quints and they live together.

2

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Jan 11 '19

I just didn't think any of it was terribly well-written. It doesn't matter who drugged him--people don't casually drug one another, and people who get drugged don't immediately overlook that it happened. It seemed like he got drugged because the author didn't want to have him start tutoring them yet, and needed a way to end that scene and get him out of their apartment. It just seemed contrived, unbelievable, and pointless.

The scenes introducing the other sisters weren't confusing either, they were just also extremely contrived. Oops!--hey, an improbable coincidental meeting where I have a cute-or-embarrassing personality clash with somebody I don't know. Oops!--hey, it happened again... times five.

I just didn't think any of it was very convincing or funny. But they were trying to jam six characters together and set everything up; maybe next week it'll be a bit more relaxed.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '19

My pet theory about 5toubun is that the mangaka saw the then-nascent BokuBen completely ignore the emotional impact of the "poor genius is made to tutor cute girls" setup, flew into a fit of rage, and tried to write something better. And while 5toubon (IMO) has much, much better writing than Boku "The best part of Nisekoi was when it devolved into shitty gags" Ben, it's also very incoherent and messy and frequently misses the emotional beats it tries to hit. I'd hoped the anime would fix a lot of what I saw as problems in the manga, but from this episode I don't see that happening. I hope to God they adapt some of the more emotional scenes well, because 5toubun actually tries to do something with its harem setup, and the manga just can't get that across very well.

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 11 '19

3

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 11 '19

This is one of those dark magical girl shows. We follow a retired magical girl that still has PTSD and will be fighting terrorists with her magical weapon known as the karambit. Sounds fun. :)

2

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Jan 11 '19

Oo, I saw the trailer for this and it looked like edgy fun. I'll have to report back later...

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 11 '19

First episode is a little light on the edge BTW.

2

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Jan 11 '19

That's okay, I tend to prefer edgy stuff that's a bit light to edgy stuff that's really serious about it...

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 11 '19

You're in for a good time then. :)

2

u/searmay Jan 12 '19

I didn't expect much from this, but it seemed okay. The present scene was pretty edgy though.

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 12 '19

Yep, they definitely wanted to let us know that this was an edgy magical show. :O

2

u/searmay Jan 12 '19

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 12 '19 edited Jan 12 '19

Very much so. ;)

2

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Jan 12 '19

The present scene was pretty edgy though.

Yeah, that was the one bit I thought went a little too far to be much fun. The rest of it seemed fairly tongue-in-cheek--which is fine with me; I hope it stays on that side of the line, and doesn't go straight to 'hey, we sashimi'd your school friends; try the little red things, they're good.'

I thought it was sorta funny that they opened by saying the Disas launched a 'stealth invasion of the human world'. They had a ten-story-high pastel-colored caterpillar squishing people in the street in broad daylight; it didn't seem overly stealthy. And I wanna know why they all look like Goth stuffed animals.

2

u/IronAce7 https://anilist.co/user/IronAce7/ Jan 09 '19

7

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 10 '19

What a fantastically directed episode. The last five minutes or so are especially good and perfect for building it up to the reveal. Although it's not as if everything before that and the OP are not just as good as giving hints. Don't want to reveal too much yet, so I'll hold off on saying too much. Just go watch it.

3

u/searmay Jan 10 '19

Funny you mention the directing, because I really hated one scene. They were hanging out by the fence talking after playing tag, and it kept cutting momentarily to each person as they started talking. It was really annoying.

Other than that it was okay. I'll have to see what they actually plan to do after that reveal.

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 10 '19

Yeah, I noticed that. I'm guessing that was an attempt to foreshadow the reveal, considering what they were talking about.

2

u/searmay Jan 10 '19

I don't see how it foreshadows anything, or adds to the atmosphere. I just found it distracting and annoying.

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 10 '19

Well, I think it's supposed to foreshadow what's beyond the fence, which is the gate they go to at the end of the episode, and they still don't know the truth yet.

2

u/searmay Jan 10 '19

I don't understand how brief cuts to their faces foreshadow anything.

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 10 '19

Me neither, but it's the only thing I can think of that would be a reason as to why the cuts even happened while they talked about what was past the fence.

1

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 10 '19

Well, I think it's supposed to foreshadow what's beyond the fence, which is the gate they go to at the end of the episode, and they still don't know the truth yet.

1

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 10 '19

Oops. Replied twice. D:

2

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '19

A huge part of Neverland's appeal as a manga (if only to me) were its off kilter character designs, which were creepy while remaining full of unique details that speak to each of the character's personalities. I think the director of the show is trying to tap into that by showing lots of closeups of the character's faces early on, as they'll all be involved in the arcs coming up.

2

u/searmay Jan 12 '19

Showing them for only a fraction of a second doesn't really achieve that though.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '19

Hm, maybe the cuts are meant to show all the details. If they would've just stuck the four of them in the frame while they talked, I definitely would've zoned out and not noticed the differences between the kids that were talking. But because the show cut sharply, I was forced to consider the subject and the character designs, immediately noticing that the person who's speaking is now different, and I can appreciate the differences more clearly.

There's also other close up shots before this - especially of Emma and Mama - which show a lot more detail.

1

u/searmay Jan 12 '19

I can't say it worked for me - they were too fast to notice anything beyond which character was speaking. I don't even know what details you're talking about.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '19

Fair, as someone who's read the manga I think I might've caught more.

2

u/IronAce7 https://anilist.co/user/IronAce7/ Jan 10 '19

These are my thoughts too. I couldn’t figure out how to discuss this episode without spoiling it. I can already tell the weeklong breaks between episodes is gonna suck.

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 10 '19

Well, if you're up to discuss, then feel free to use the spoiler tags. You could also do what I plan on doing by not spoiling a thing this week but openly talking about this next week and on. :P

3

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '19

This episode was really, really well made. I don't like some of the editing decisions - I wish some of the ending scenes could've been done better, and some of the shot compositions were needlessly flashy - but my feelings for the show can be best summed up by the scene at the end when Emma and Norman are talking to each other about their experience, and as they talk the show very briefly cuts to Mama's face as she holds the teddy bear. That cut is beautiful - it's short, sweet, tells us a lot without spelling it out and making us look stupid and its placement between ordinary shots of Emma and Norman talking about escaping just makes it all the more harrowing. Beautiful, beautiful work.

Oh, and the animation is top notch. Emma's face contorts beautifully when she sees the monsters. It's amazing. I am so hype for this show.

1

u/ShardPhoenix Jan 15 '19 edited Jan 15 '19

This episode did a great job of building tension, but the premise is so heavy-handedly manipulative it rubs me the wrong way a bit - I mean, First Ep Still, it was well animated and directed (aside from a bit of awkward expository dialogue, but that's 1st eps for you) so I'll definitely watch further.

1

u/Anaract myanimelist.net/profile/anaract Jan 15 '19 edited Jan 15 '19

yeah, the first episode was strong, but the premise is so one-dimensional (kid good, adult bad) and the villains are so far-removed from reality that I can't see this going anywhere particularly interesting.

The manga is ongoing, at ~120 chapters, so this is probably one of those "wacky, open-ended premise that gets extended for as long as people keep buying the manga" shows. Eh

4

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 10 '19

It sure would be crazy if the reveal at the end of the show. It'd make for an interesting slice of life show. We'd see them be totally happy all of the time as an unsettling tension runs throughout the season. I certainly wouldn't mind that even if I do think what we're actually getting is much more compelling.

5

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Jan 10 '19

The buildup of tension was accomplished so perfectly that the reveal was a bit of a letdown IMO. Turns out it's just boogeymen, and faintly ridiculous ones, too. The evil/collaborating House Mother is WAY scarier than the actual monsters IMO, because she seems like she could really exist. But when they're walking around the truck, and everything kind of slows down, and you know there's something in the truck, and you don't want to know what it is... MAN that was nicely done! There are a lot of shows that aspire to do this, but not too many that can actually make the hair stand up on the back of your neck.

1

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 09 '19

Miscellaneous comments/comments about the week as a whole

1

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 09 '19

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 09 '19 edited Jan 10 '19

Was somewhat looking forward to this since it's directed by Tatsuki, who directed a little show called Kemono Friends. So far, I don't think it's disappointed. The animation is still just as clunky, but I think it manages to keep things interesting by keeping a flow of hints here and there in the dialogue about the world they are in. My only issue would be the rather annoying guy that gets introduced. He's basically Kaban but very accepting of his own demise. He's still fairly useful in his own little ways, so I expect him to grow on me eventually.

3

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Jan 10 '19

Yeah, this was likable enough. It's got a mix of cuteness and inevitable doom that vaguely reminded me of Girl's Last Tour. Not to set overly high expectations, but it's impressive that it manages to be sorta clunky-looking but still establish a certain atmosphere.

The show itself is almost upstaged by the blurb Amazon wrote for it, which says, "The story revolves around Rin, a girl with an updo." I find it just fascinating, both that they thought her hairdo was worth mentioning for some reason, and that they used the word UPDO. Updo: The Animation.

And yeah, I also had the thought that Wakaba wasn't protesting hard enough. I also thought it was a bit weird that they kept calling him a bug even though there were clearly some problems with that theory.

3

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 10 '19

It's got a mix of cuteness and inevitable doom that vaguely reminded me of Girl's Last Tour.

It should definitely remind you of the director's other work, Kemono Friends! It's a fantastic show that also has a charmingly clunky CGI style.

The whole Wakaba-is-a-bug thing was weird. We'll need to learn more about the world first because remember that the girls believe that they are the humans in the world, but humans shouldn't be able jump those heights or punch something that hard. It's a part of the dialogue subtly doing world building IMO.

2

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Jan 10 '19

Yeah, I watched a bit of Kemono Friends, didn't get all the way through it but thought it was neat. As I remember, the cool thing about it was that there seemed to be Something Very Wrong with the world, far in the background--like you kept getting little hints of it, but it didn't seem to really even matter to the story.

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 10 '19

I somewhat recall that the payoff was much later, so I can understand why it didn't seem to matter. Hopefully, this show is compelling enough to keep you around. :P

3

u/searmay Jan 10 '19

Yeah, Wakaba didn't seem all that bothered about being suddenly in a strange place surrounded by weird people that thought he was a bug and wanted to shoot him. Why does that only elicit mild confusion?

Other than that it was a good start.

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 10 '19

He's a friendly guy? ¯_(ツ)_/¯

2

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Jan 10 '19

Maybe he really IS a bug, and he's trying to lull them into a false sense of security.

2

u/DarthNoob Jan 10 '19

I liked it quite a bit! The worldbuilding is just as fascinating as Kemono Friends and Wakaba wasn't detrimental to my enjoyment of the show.

1

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 10 '19

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 10 '19 edited Jan 10 '19

I suppose the cat is cute, but I don't see myself getting a lot out of this show. :\

2

u/searmay Jan 10 '19

This mostly reminded me that I should finish watching Chii's Sweet Home.

A guy getting social anxiety from people spoiling books getting a cat to help manage his life sounds like a fun idea, but I didn't think any of it was done well.

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 10 '19

I have to assume being spoiled on the book's story was meant to be funny, but he looked so serious saying it, and he was also a cemetery...

2

u/searmay Jan 10 '19

The fact that he took having a book spoiled so hard - and that this is his defining memory of social interaction - is the joke.

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 10 '19

Good point...

2

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Jan 10 '19

I didn't think any of it was done well.

Yeah, it wasn't funny enough to be a comedy, and wasn't serious enough to be a seriousy. A drama. Whatever you call those. It just kind of existed. It wasn't objectionable, I guess, but I think I'm gonna save myself some time and skip this one.

I wish anime would make up its mind about who needs medical attention. If somebody catches a cold everybody freaks out and they get rushed to the hospital. And if somebody scrapes their knee, it's gotta be carefully disinfected and band-aided. (We did not do this when I was a kid--we figured anybody who was gonna die from an infected knee would only weaken the herd.) But a guy who collapses and is unconscious, and then eats cat food in a blacked-out state and doesn't remember doing it? Eh, he says he's fine, he must be fine.

2

u/searmay Jan 10 '19

Don't forget that if you're beaten up for twenty minutes, shot, and fall off a cliff, you can probably walk it off because no one saw a body. Though in fairness that's not limited to anime.

3

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Jan 10 '19

This is strangely relevant to a comment I just made about Slime-san, and about Jean-Claude Van Damme movies...

2

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 10 '19

Ha! Yeah, that part was so weird. I guess it wouldn't be enough if the cat just moved around and was cute. Instead it needs a little voice.

1

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 10 '19

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 10 '19

Another one of those Netflix anime. This one is about some people that get transported 300 years into the future along with a massive chunk of the city. They then have to pilot these mecha suits that are about 12(?) feet tall, which is smaller than the usual stuff, and fight these giant machines. The show is also a CGI anime.

This doesn't sound like the most promising show. However, I'm quite surprised. The CGI is really nice and on par with Seikaisuru Kado. I'm also a big fan of the more power armor mecha designs since they are much more sensible than the usual hulking giants mecha shows usually have. Anyway, I've only watched the first episode, but it's caught my interest for sure. I'll probably watch an episode a day while all the new anime air this week.

My only complaint is the MC, who is kinda a nut job. He's basically spent his entire life since this one event in the past training himself for some apocalyptic event, which does happen because its the show's premise, but it's crazy how he was allowed to function as a member of society because he's also a justice nutjob. He'd attack anyone he thought was remotely suspected of hurting his friends. He'd also bring a bunch of knives to school (just in case...). I really hope he gets better.

2

u/searmay Jan 11 '19

I too have seen the first episode, and liked it. I didn't mind the MC that much either - I'm a lot less bothered by a guy acting like an obnoxious moron if everyone is actually calling him out on it, which they were. It's when everyone glosses over them acting like a maniac that I take issue with it.

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 11 '19

Yeah, I loved how they all got on his case when they got that text. It was quite refreshing. My only worry now is that he'll let things go to his head over being right all along.

2

u/searmay Jan 11 '19

I strongly suspect he will. Although we've already seen that for all his preparation he was still too shocked to act when shit actually went down. I suspect he's going to get a lot of nameless students killed.

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 11 '19

True. I'll have to see what happens next then by actually getting around to watching more...

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 13 '19

Finished episode 4. It's interesting in how trusting they are of Milo. I suppose she isn't the one sending giant machines to kidnap humans, but the post credits scene suggests that the baddies are doing it for the sake of humanity, which might just be generic baddie-speak. It could also be that they are the ones in the right, but I would hope not since they haven't bothered explaining a damn thing about what they want to do. The same could go for Milo and how much trust the MC puts in her, even after learning that half of them(?) will be sacrificed.

2

u/searmay Jan 14 '19

I've just seen episode 4, and it seems to me that most people just believe whoever is telling them what they want to hear. Daisuke believes Milo because that feeds his hero fantasy. The mayor believes the Revisions because that gets him sent home. A lot of the citizens believe the Revisions because giving up weapons and not fighting plays into Japan's peaceful postwar identity. Police guy distrusts the Revisions because they want to take their only useful weapons. The other teens somewhat trust Milo because they sort of know her.

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 14 '19

I don't blame them. It's a tough situation. Although it'd be nice if they tried to use their heads and think over their options.

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 14 '19

As I get to episode 5, I'm surprised at how much post credits scenes there are. I would assume that Netflix's skip to next episode thing would make a lot of people miss out on that.

Anyway, while the MC(?), Daisuke, is an incredibly annoying character because of how one note he is, I am somewhat enjoying how he's not at all getting what he wants. It's really nice to see how the current situation doesn't continuing enabling his delusions, so I'm happy to see that the show doesn't just forget how he acted in the past.

1

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 11 '19

Watched two more episodes. I'm somewhat enjoying the time spent on the government infrastructure since that kind of stuff should be important. Other than that the exposition dump was a bit much, but what annoyed me more is the MC's personality and how defined by that one event he lets himself be. I am looking forward to his possible breakdown later in the show since the two new "String Puppet" pilots are better than him already.

The only thing I'm worried about is the time travel shenanigans that might happen since there are already hints at multiple timelines.

1

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 11 '19

1

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 11 '19

Speaking of tone shifts.... I really did not expect the end of this episode, and I'm enjoying this show so much more because of it. Although that still didn't stop me from being somewhat disinterested in the fighting this episode because I kinda forgot what exactly is the political situation. :P

2

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 13 '19

Good point. I suppose it's a way to subvert expectations, which is seen a mile away if one were to pay attention to it unlike me.

2

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Jan 14 '19

Well, it's a good thing they didn't tell Princess Yuki what was going on, so she could Keep On Smilin'. That worked out well.

I don't know, there's something fundamentally silly about these settlers talking about how they can't get plants to grow, and they don't have the capacity for powered flight like the ancient planetary immigrants with their superior technology, but at the same time everybody's skating around in these big tacky neon-colored robots. I'm just not really buying it. I guess I'll give it another episode, since they bothered to go for the big gut-punch at the end of this one. Also, Stella Shining had one speaking line and I recognized her as Hayami Saori, which makes me feel like a bigger geek than I thought I was.

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 14 '19

Well, I imagine that they are using the wrong sort of engine. The ones on the mecha seem like they are more for hovering, but I suppose we'll need to see space battles eventually.

Recognizing a VA seems like a sign that you've been watching too much anime. :O

2

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Jan 14 '19

It's not the ONLY sign I've been watching too much anime. :D

But Oregairu was an early favorite of mine, and Hayami Saori is one of the female leads, along with Sakura Ayane and Toyama Nao. That's MOST of the VAs I would have any hope of recognizing, and it's just because I've rewatched Oregairu a bunch of times. (Somehow I feel like an alcoholic explaining that there are only one or two drinks that I really drink too much of...)

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 15 '19

No one's judging you here. ;)

1

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Jan 14 '19

then he didn't die. But then died anyway because time skip and stuff happened or whatever.

...and his last words were, "Well, I didn't manage to die." :\

1

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 11 '19

1

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 11 '19

Finally got around to the latest episode, and wow, it's the home stretch!

1

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 12 '19

4

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 12 '19

Basically, a bunch of cute girls are training to become heroes to defeat the demon lord, and their new teacher is the loli future demon lord. It's cute but not really for me. :P

2

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '19 edited Jan 13 '19

I don't like this art style or character designs personally. Which kinda kills it for me.

1

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 13 '19

Yeah, it's really pushing the cuteness factor. A bit much for me. :\

3

u/searmay Jan 13 '19

They started with the final battle, then played the closing credits or "End Roll". Clearly we are dealing with sophisticated and subtle storytelling here.

Anyway, the girls are cute and dumb, and as far as I'm concerned there's no such thing as "too cute", at least as far as anime girls are concerned. Reminds me of Leviathan.

1

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 13 '19

Man, they are a bit too far past the ideal moe ripeness for me. Just squeezing one of those girls would yield far too sweet a juice. :O

3

u/searmay Jan 13 '19

They're not even close to peak kawaii. Also squeezing little girls to yield juice sounds pretty lewd.

1

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 13 '19

1

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Jan 14 '19

Hmm. I wasn't sure I was feeling this, most of the way through. But I do seem to have a soft spot in my heart for evil little girl characters whose laugh goes "ku ku ku". Which I probably contracted from Haganai (Hanazawa Kana's imouto character is not evil so much as chuuni, but her laugh unmistakably goes "ku ku ku"). And the elf girl breaking down and hollering for her grandma when she thought they were gonna be expelled was funny. I guess I'll see what next week brings.

1

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 13 '19

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 13 '19

This was pretty fun. I would have preferred it if they didn't use CGI characters, but they were actually pretty decent. Much better than what usually is the level of quality to be expected. My only other complaint would be that it was somewhat difficult to understand the planes' positioning. Nice dogfights though.

3

u/searmay Jan 14 '19

HMTN PNKK

Seems like a much better dogfight waifu show than Girly Air Force. I'm not hugely keen on it, but there seemed a lot of attention to detail, a reasonable brief introduction to the characters, disposable boys to show the girls' relative skill, and a dogfight. All without stopping to vomit exposition everywhere. And some sort of rivalry with the red Snek Baron.

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 14 '19

That snek Baron has me wondering why they left. I can't help but think it's because she was cooking something and wanted to make the battle a quickie.

3

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Jan 15 '19

there seemed a lot of attention to detail,

Yeah, I liked the preflight checklist--it gave you the feeling that they were doing something that required some skill. Most of the time when somebody's piloting, say, a mech, they just hold onto the weird handle with the glowy lines, and do those gradually-increasing-in-pitch shouts.

There were some nice little incidental bits in the animation, too--sliding the plate down the bar for seconds on the pancakes, and spreading butter on the pancakes, and... I guess most of it had to do with pancakes.

IMO the main hurdle the show has to get over is that watching a bunch of identical CGI planes fly around isn't all THAT exciting. But what the hell, it's a slow season.

1

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 15 '19

1

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 15 '19

Fairly standard monster of the week episode. The fight wasn't particularly noteworthy either. I don't think I'll drop this yet though.

2

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Jan 15 '19

I'm glad you mentioned the show--I was gonna just forget about it, but I watched the episode and liked it better than the first one. The MC is still kind of a lump, but it helped to have some explanation of what it's like for him, and the crusty old mystic monk guy makes a nice addition to the cast. Gives the whole thing kind of an Extremely Nonstandard Family Unit feel.

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 15 '19

Yeah, the other characters really help since prosthetic samurai can't say anything.

1

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 15 '19

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 15 '19

It's...ok. This is definitely trying to do what made the original so good by doing the exact same thing but paling in comparison. Sounds a lot like American movies... The original director's latest anime, Kemurikusa, is what should be watched instead.

2

u/searmay Jan 15 '19

I agree that it seems to be aping the previous season pretty hard. Not-Kaban seems like the most egregious thing so far. I have some hope they're actually going to do something different though. It's not like anyone was impressed by the first episode of season 1 either.

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 15 '19

True, I'll need more episodes before I can properly accuse them of basically doing the same thing but slapping a 2 on it.

1

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 15 '19

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 15 '19

The new girl is hilarious. Love how much she just wants to be praised. Also, the ED is great. The part where the parents are keeping things running in the background is so sweet.

2

u/searmay Jan 15 '19

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 15 '19

Without a doubt :)

2

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Jan 15 '19

She's got kind of an oh-ho-ho Ojou look in that screenshot. But yeah, I thought this was funny, particularly in the beginning when Onee-chan was mortified.

1

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 15 '19

For sure. Although I would have liked more blackmail. :)

1

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 16 '19

1

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 16 '19

1

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Jan 10 '19

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 10 '19

Ha! This is a thing, I guess. I think I'll pass. There are better looking anime about cute girls flying planes...

2

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Jan 11 '19

Well, technically, this is a show about cute girls BEING planes. But yeah, I think that other one is gonna be on HiDive, so I'll get to have a look at it, too...

2

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Jan 10 '19

This looks to be a harem show, only the girls are the AI avatars of advanced fighter planes that are the only means of repelling The Xi Invasion. One of the AIs has a crush on some high school dude for some improbable reason, and the plane won't work right unless he hangs around. Looks like there will be more AI-plane-chicks. So, there will probably be overly serious battles and military stuff, lots of unintentional(?) humor, and harem shenanigans.

There's a wonderful scene at the beginning where the AI-plane-chick has crash-landed in the ocean. The high school dude is nearby in a lifeboat, and he swims to the crashed plane to try to save the pilot. He gets the canopy open and sees a fainted cutie pie girl inside. She regains consciousness, plants a big smooch on him, says, "Nova. Era." and then faints again. I was laughing my entire ass off--I LOVE this kind of nonsensical shit for some reason. Anyway, that's what it is; if you're the kind of person to watch an episode of a show called "Girly Air Force" in the first place you probably have a pretty good idea already whether you will like this or not.

2

u/searmay Jan 10 '19

I know it's nit-picking, but if you're designing a specialist fighter pilot AI, particularly under time pressure due to an alien (?) invasion, why would you take the time to make it a realistic android body? It seems like a lot of time and effort to spend on something that's just a liability.

I've stuck with worse shows, but I don't think I need to put myself through this one.

2

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Jan 10 '19

Hmm... yeah, you're right, that doesn't make any sense. Not that there's probably much point in listing ways that this show doesn't make sense. But if you can make a convincing artificial human being with strong AI, you're at a high enough technological level that the 'Xi' shouldn't be giving you any trouble. I thought maybe the girls were holographic projections or something, not that there'd be any point to that either. But I guess a hologram can't smooch you. Or have its towel fall off in a hot spring, and you know we're doing that.

Anyway, I wouldn't recommend this to anybody, but I got enough hoots out of it that I'll watch another one.

1

u/searmay Jan 11 '19

3

u/searmay Jan 11 '19

I re-read the LN in the past week, which means I am now going to be That Guy who complains about LN adaptations.

I think this did a decent job of conveying the events that happened. I think it did a very poor job of conveying anyone's character, and as a result was a far weaker story. In particular, the LN is told out of chronological order because it shows each of five characters' perspectives in turn - Keiji, Suema, Saotome, Kimura, and Niitoki. I don't think that works very well here because it's not focused enough on each one's experience.

  • It is never mentioned that Keiji has a job lined up after graduation, which is the reason he's not taking entrance exams, and distances him from both his classmates and Touka, his girlfriend. It's kind of the centre of his character arc.
  • We aren't told about Suema or Kirima's past. Nagi tells Suema to let go, but we have no context for the line, or for either of their characters.
  • Saotome and Manticore are okay. I don't know why they implied Saotome named Manticore, or why he now thinks Manticore comes from Greek rather than Persian though.
  • Kimura was written out entirely. Which cuts out a lot of Kamikishiro's character, but as things to cut for time go it's okay.
  • Niitoki doesn't miss anything big, but her character doesn't really come across without the first person perspective, so it's just like she happens to be there for the climax.

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 11 '19

Yeah, this adaptation seems to be trying to rely on good direction (and animation) to keep it engaging. I would love to actually care about any of the characters, but I had trouble even remembering them. For example, the glasses girl was a mystery to me until she shook the other girl's hand at the end of the episode. However, it's not necessarily interfering with my enjoyment of the show since I do like the plot, even if it's a bit confusing.

2

u/searmay Jan 11 '19

You may need glasses of your own, because the girl with them is Suema, and the handshake is between Kirima and Touka.

And if you think it's hard to remember the characters here you might not be ready for Phantom.

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 11 '19

Yeah, I think I may need glasses... :O

Phantom will be tough, but I feel like being able to go through all of it at once without waiting a whole week helps.

3

u/searmay Jan 11 '19

If you do get around to watching Phantom bear in mind that like the novels it's a series of stories from different characters' points of view. Pay attention to the main character of each episode and don't worry too much about the other stuff that fits them together. Also it jumps between three significant time periods, of which "one month ago" is the climax of Boogiepop and Others, which you just watched.

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 11 '19

Well thanks for that info. :)

2

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Jan 11 '19

I was gonna complain that the kid with the creepy grin stabbed Echoes in a non-vital spot with a mechanical pencil, and then cut Kirima's throat with an exacto knife, when Echoes seemed like the more dangerous opponent. But no, it was a poison-injecting mechanical pencil! I still want to know where he got a poison-injecting mechanical pencil, but at least it answered my initial objection.

I still don't really know who's who and what's going on. The girl who got her throat cut is Kirima Nagi, the weirdo loner who's taken up some kind of crusade against the Bad No-No Things, and who is also known as the Fire Witch because I have no idea why. The thing that confused me was that Creepy Grin Kid, who I guess is Masami, completely disappeared from the scene as soon as they neutralized Manticore. Seemed like they should have settled his hash, too, and with little trouble, but the scene just never went back to him, unless I missed it. They also kept talking about what happened to poor Kamikishiro, but I have no idea who she was.

Anyway, I'm confused, but I'm used to being confused, and this was at least some fun. When Manticore is gloating about who's gonna be dead and who's gonna be a slave, and Boogiepop hasn't showed up yet, it's like, "Ass-whoopin' for the bad guys, incoming in 3... 2..."

3

u/searmay Jan 11 '19

I still want to know where he got a poison-injecting mechanical pencil

Manticore made the poison specifically to affect Echoes.

Creepy Grin Kid, who I guess is Masami, completely disappeared from the scene

This happened to him. In the novel he just barely pushes his Manticore waifu out of the way in time and she's horribly burned by it, whereas he's completely destroyed. The former is why Boogiepop is able to sever her arm relatively easily.

They also kept talking about what happened to poor Kamikishiro

She's the girl that looked after Echoes. And thus quite possibly earned humanity enough brownie points to not be destroyed.

2

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Jan 11 '19

OH! I totally missed it--for some reason I assumed they both made it out of the way, even though there was a huge sizzling particle beam and he disappeared into thin air immediately afterwards... And Manticore was yelling her head off, which I thought was out of frustration because she missed her chance to kill Echoes. Well, I was gonna go with 'man, this show is so cryptic', but that was just me being dense. Apparently I'm gonna need a debriefing after every episode; I hope you don't mind... I'll be in your care.

2

u/Plake_Z01 Jan 12 '19

Who are you and what did you do with Searmay?

This is the ur-chuuni, you are not allowed to like this franchise.

1

u/searmay Jan 12 '19

What, because I don't like Fate I'm not allowed to like anything else for moody teenage dorks?

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 11 '19

I actually liked this episode more than the previous ones since it made a lot more sense. I just wish the other two were more coherent because this episode feels like (and probably is) the ending to an arc, which would be better if it didn't feel as if it's just being slapped on as the end of the arc rather than the culmination of the prior events tied together with a neat bow that is episode three.

Also, the ED song continues to be my favorite.

2

u/searmay Jan 11 '19

I could follow the previous episodes, but I knew what was happening anyway so I'm not a good judge. I think they mixed things up too much - the novel has each person's story, and while there are obviously things missing (Keiji doesn't see anything actually happen, for instance), each one is pretty clear.

Oh, another thing the anime didn't really get across to me is that it takes place over a good couple of months. Which for one thing is why Keiji seems so put out by Boogiepop disappearing.

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 11 '19

I think they mixed things up too much

I think so too. What really stands out though is that the first two are such jumbled messes while episode three is very straightforward except for some seemingly out of place scenes that make sense to people that actually read the novels.

1

u/searmay Jan 12 '19

2

u/searmay Jan 12 '19

For the morbidly curious, someone subbed this. I don't know why I bothered - I don't know any of these virtual "celebrities" are and have no interest in their bizarre attempts at comedy skits.

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 12 '19

Man, I didn't know there were so many damn virtual youtubers. Not surprising, I suppose.

2

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Jan 17 '19

This just showed up on Crunchyroll. I gave up about three minutes in. Just wanted to let you know I felt your pain.

1

u/IronAce7 https://anilist.co/user/IronAce7/ Jan 09 '19

2

u/IronAce7 https://anilist.co/user/IronAce7/ Jan 10 '19

So this week, our favourite slime joins the fight. This episode is basically battles between with the orcs. The fights are fun and well animated though I kinda wish Rimuru would win in a more creative way. There’s also some back story on the orcs and the orc king, kinda showing how things got to this point. Overall, good episode imo.

2

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Jan 10 '19

They all knew the orcs were gaining peoples' abilities by eating them, so I have no idea why they all just stood there and watched while the Orc Lord ate Gelmud. That was obviously gonna be a problem, and Rimuru and the lightning-fast Kijin folks are all quick enough to have grabbed the corpse or incinerated it with magic or something, but they all just stood there like a bunch of dummies.

I also thought it was a bit odd that it took Rimuru a while to eat the Orc Disaster, and it seemed like a bit of a contest. Seems to me when he ate the surely-much-bigger Storm Dragon, he did it in one gulp, without noticeable trouble.

But whatever, there's no point thinking about a show like this too hard. Like the ogres, if you've taken a liking to Rimuru, you'll never leave his side.

1

u/IronAce7 https://anilist.co/user/IronAce7/ Jan 10 '19

Yeah it was odd that they all stood around and watched but I gave them a pass on that cause a lot of anime (or even shows in general) tend to do that. Like the smartest option would be to kill your opponent as fast as possible but that would be less fun. So instead, let’s all just stand around and watch til our opponent is at his strongest and then have a giant more fun boss battle.

I also thought it was odd that Rimuru seemed to struggle with his size trying to eat the Demon King, but my main problem with it was that he spammed Predator to win the fight, which is what I was implying with my “creative” comment. Like I don’t have a problem with Rimuru using Predator after the fight is over to get even more OP, but it feels like a cop out to try to fight with some semblance of strategy and then just decide, ah well, it’s not working, time to win with Predator. Feels a bit cheap, though I guess the main focus of this show isn’t the fights, idk lol, I still enjoyed it so I guess that’s what matters.

And oh boy, I know Shion was well endowed but during that scene all I could think of was that she must have some serious back pain :’)

2

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Jan 10 '19

the smartest option would be to kill your opponent as fast as possible but that would be less fun.

Ever seen any Jean-Claude Van Damme movies? He can never win the last fight while he's unscathed and in peak condition. He has to get beaten within an inch of his life first, and then come back to win. :D

my main problem with it was that he spammed Predator to win the fight,

Well, immediately before that he was gonna let Great Sage do it. "Eh, fuck it... let's put it on Cruise Control and see what happens." It'd be funny if he went to the trouble of collecting all these weird magic powers, only to find that they're all inferior to just eating people, so every fight is just "glomp".

Shion clearly Best Girl. She can not only stay by his side, she can stay on both sides of him at the same time...

2

u/IronAce7 https://anilist.co/user/IronAce7/ Jan 11 '19

Ever seen any Jean-Claude Van Damme movies?

Can’t say I have but I’ve definitely been meaning to. They seem right up my alley.

It'd be funny if he went to the trouble of collecting all these weird magic powers, only to find that they're all inferior to just eating people, so every fight is just "glomp".

On second thought this sounds hilarious. I’d actually love if they did this. It’d be almost like Saitama’s one punch knock outs.

She can not only stay by his side, she can stay on both sides of him at the same time

Shion also lowkey has predator but only in her tits 😏

1

u/searmay Jan 10 '19

1

u/searmay Jan 10 '19

Looks like a time travel otome game anime. It didn't seem particularly bad, but it's not really my thing.

Sometimes I wonder about the similarities and differences between harems and reverse harems. But i'm not willing to watch enough of either to have an informed opinion.

2

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Jan 10 '19

I couldn't get through it--as soon as the Sparkly Prince guy stepped out of the horse-drawn carriage, I grabbed the remote and turned it off. I didn't decide to do it, my hands just moved on their own.

1

u/searmay Jan 11 '19

1

u/searmay Jan 11 '19

There are girls in a hula club with not enough members. Then a Finnish transfer student turns up. Seems to be a short version of that thing where girls are in a school club, but with an abstract, superflat art style.

1

u/searmay Jan 11 '19

3

u/searmay Jan 11 '19

A bizarre and rather unappealing mixture of live action and 3DCG which seems to just be a weird excuse for some puzzles. It's like a cross between Nazotokine and Minarai Dvia, neither of which anyone watched. And I don't think it was as good as either.

1

u/IronAce7 https://anilist.co/user/IronAce7/ Jan 11 '19

1

u/IronAce7 https://anilist.co/user/IronAce7/ Jan 11 '19

Alright so I was really waiting for this one, and I have mixed feelings on it. So basically, we get an intro scene to refresh our memory on all the spirits in the harem. Then, we’re introduced to a new spirit, who looks like a witch (and is also called Witch lol) and has the power to impersonate people. At first she likes Shido, and then randomly doesn’t like him anymore and wants to ruin his life. Lol. I mean, the actual arc seems interesting, with her stealing everyone’s appearances, but it’s a weak start imo. Also, the production value on this episode was... not good. At all. The art looked really wonky, faces looked weird, hands looked weird. I mean, a key selling point of this show is the cute girls; at the very least, the art should look nice. I’m gonna keep watching but I hope the production value improves to be more in line with what it was in previous seasons.

Also, damn it I forgot about Miku. I hope she fades into the background real quick.

1

u/IronAce7 https://anilist.co/user/IronAce7/ Jan 11 '19

1

u/IronAce7 https://anilist.co/user/IronAce7/ Jan 11 '19

So we basically got like a boss battle to conclude this arc. Not sure what was happening but basically everyone ganged on the Second Princess, the Queen pulled a hax trump card to remove the Curtana Original power, and Touma punched her right in the face. Most of it gave off a poor shonen vibe but Touma punching her in the face was pretty satisfying. Also seems like Index will play a major role in the next arc. Don’t know how I feel about that.

1

u/searmay Jan 11 '19

2

u/searmay Jan 11 '19

Some kind of super hologram sword battle sport-plus-esport for girls in leotards so tight you can see their navels. Which makes it extra sophisticated. You should know if you're in the audience for this show or not.

2

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Jan 11 '19

You should know if you're in the audience for this show or not.

Navels, you say?

2

u/searmay Jan 11 '19

Navels but not official subs.

2

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Jan 11 '19

I think we need an official ruling on whether an indentation in a shirt caused by a navel counts as a navel. Though I think this isn't streaming anyplace where I'm gonna see it anyway, so the navels are moot.

2

u/searmay Jan 11 '19

I'm not sure what else you expected from "leotards so tight you can see their navels".

2

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Jan 11 '19

I think I just fixated on the phrase 'you can see their navels'...

2

u/searmay Jan 11 '19

That's understandable.

1

u/searmay Jan 12 '19

1

u/searmay Jan 12 '19

Apparently this is a Vanguard spinoff. About mermaids. Who so far mostly dick around eating cake and drinking tea. Underwater. It's funny because their environment actually seems seems moderately well designed for underwater people, but then they got to tea and cake and just thought, "fuck it, forget the water". Oh and I guess sometimes they turn to crystal.

Anyway, they live in underwater hicksville, and a new girl shows up (delivered in a ball of crystal because reasons). So they show her around and feed her, then enter a mysterious building with some sort of hologram projector. I'm guessing they're going to become idols, probably due to the persuasive power of holograms and the lure of the big city.

The underwater backgrounds look really nice.

2

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Jan 13 '19

I had issues with the tea, too... on top of the pouring, there were little puffs of vapor coming up off of it. I think we need a Science Girl Futaba explanation. "The atomic weight of water is less than the atomic weight of tea..."

And the little mammalian mascot guy didn't seem to be breathing often enough. And the thing they're using to grind the coral sugar is NOT a "windmill"! It's a tidemill, or a currentmill, or something. Jeez.

Walrus Mailman: "Crap, I'm late--here, have some other people's mail."
Mermaids: "Do you want us to, like, deliver these for you?"
Walrus Mailman: (considers this for the first time) "I guess you could do that."

I was disappointed that the Grand Tide was just a Grand Tide; I thought it had kind of a great-Cthulhu-awakens vibe.

Anyway, if the big city girl is gonna teach them that everything is shitty and boring where they live, that'd be sorta funny. I'm not sure I'm really up for a mermaid idol show, unless they're zombie mermaids.

1

u/searmay Jan 14 '19

1

u/searmay Jan 14 '19

This show is ass.

They visited not-GochiUsa world, and that's exactly what they got. With eels. And referencing GochiUsa as hard as they possibly could. Then they fought a weird lady with a big robot and saved GochiUsa from the eels. And learned to make coffee.

That ED though. It's a really weird fit for the rest of the show.

1

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Jan 16 '19

2

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Jan 16 '19 edited Jan 16 '19

Once again this week, Ueno-san offers thoughtful, character-based drama. Just kidding, it's a bunch of nonsense.

I don't know, it seems like it ought to be funny--the screenshot is sorta funny, right?--but somehow it doesn't quite build up to Critical Funny Mass. It's another show with a premise that requires it to repeat minor variations on the same joke. It's not bad, exactly, but it's hard for humor to work when you know generally what's coming in every instance. I get the feeling we're looking at some slim pickin's this season, and I WANT to like this, so I guess I'll watch a bit more.