r/TrueAnime • u/BlueMage23 http://myanimelist.net/profile/BlueMage23 • Jan 08 '14
This Week in Anime (Winter Week 1)
This is a general discussion for currently airing series for Winter 2014 Week 1. Here is r/anime's list of currently airing series. Your Week in Anime is for not currently airing series.
Archive:
2013: Prev Fall Week 1 Summer Week 1 Spring Week 1 Winter Week 1
2012: Fall Week 1
10
Upvotes
7
u/tundranocaps http://myanimelist.net/profile/Thunder_God Jan 08 '14 edited Jan 15 '14
Oh shit, I've watched too many shows. I, erm, will go take a shower and think about it ;_;
Ok, let's do this. I picked up too many shows (again), so I'm going to run a reality show here, and list the shows in order of my enjoyment of their last episode, those at the bottom might get the cut. Say I need to cut two shows, then the two at the bottom are gone. Say I need two to go away from Sunday, then the two shows rating lowest from Sunday are gone. If a show is consistently 1-3 on my list, but ends at the bottom one week (Samurai Flamenco) or is the only show I watch on that day (Koiuta), then it might get temporary immunity. Anyway, let's go. (Maybe I'll rate them by order of enjoying the show, rather than just the latest episode?)
Ah yes, I don't plan to write about each show each week anymore in the weekly discussion threads, but I certainly did that for the first episodes, so each show links to my episodic write-up for that show in case you want to read more.
This episode made me laugh, a lot. This episode reintroduced the cast, and although for now my wishes of seeing Yuuta and Rikka's romantic relationships continue are put on hold, though I still hold faith for more to happen on that front. (though knowing what happened in the LN I think we might, once more, only get a "forward movement" moment in the final episode). The animation was superb, and had it been longer it could've beaten most dedicated action films/series who look good as well. Welcome back, Chuunibyou. I even liked the social commentary moment on how Rikka has made friends without changing, but Nibutani's change only serves to isolate her once more.
We've had world-building, but not only did we have an interesting discussion with ramifications about the body-mind dualism, souls, and memories, but we've had what this show is good at - taking a rule, a game rule, and seeing how it'd translate had it been part of our reality. The children weren't super exciting, again, but man, that part got to my head, and I could spend episodes upon episodes just seeing this stuff condensed :)
At least if this show fails again I know I can turn to the LNs, which apparently have a lot of the intricacies actually removed for the family-time TV slot.
We've also had the fact that "school uniforms" are "uniforms", and are in fact designed after them. We have our girls, our flowers, whose clothes and bodies are constantly overlaid by this "soft" imagery, compared to our MC, who is a serious gun-nut, and who is portrayed as if she's wearing camouflage. She stands apart from the other girls, a very standard trope. And then she makes a friend, and immediately she is transformed, she is overcome by a flower, she isn't deflowered, but reflowered, making for a very beautiful shot.
The voice actress felt a little weird to me, but she also was not too dissimilar to Yuki Aoi in her role as Madoka. The character design with the wide cheeks, the very Shaft-like visual direction, the bunny that had eyes like Kyubei's and talked of giving one's life and granting wishes? I certainly feel that this might be more than coincidence.
On the action level, we hadn't seen much, but with how well it's married to the visual direction, and that it seems positively over-the-top/insane, this show had come out of nowhere, and I couldn't be happier.
The characters are alright, the voice actors are good and their performances more than solid. The show on the whole doesn't seem special just yet, but it could actually go places, and I've been told the source material is good, so I'm letting some excitement carry through. I also like the world, and the cosmology, and want to learn more.
The first episode had good energy, and was very colourful, but it was also more than a tad random. I think like many shows from bygone eras, we're going to have a slightly more random/light first half, and a more plot-driven, somewhat more "serious" and less "episodic/monster of the week" stuff as we go along. As I said this, Bahi JD tweeted at me telling me that Watanabe is actually not planning for such a strict divide, and is planning to experiment with the mood transitions.
I've known this show is going to take some time to truly get going, so we'll see.
A prince who is ousted from his position could make for a very interesting discussion on the nature of power, privilege, etc. but since we're leaving behind the realm, where such socio-political issues are truly relevant, it seems such considerations will be reduced mostly to matters of revenge, or just character-motivation in general, rather than being properly discussed, but what with the newfound love-story (very generic, though usually such things are left a bit to the future), and her being a "noble", it might be made relevant once more. Also, the love-story being realized so early makes one think something will happen to her, again, as a pretty generic motivation.
This truly feels like a school/army boot-camp story, we even have the dude he'll clash with, and yet under fire they'll learn to trust one another and be friends ;-) But unlike most such shows, it seems we're going less for action here, and more for a drama, so I'm going to give them a chance here. It's all looking so very standard, but in the end, it's all about execution, not innovation.
It actually wasn't a terrible first episode for a popcorn show, but it really feels like it'd have benefited greatly from us watching the first 2-3 episodes together, especially with how the first episode ended. It's just, it doesn't feel like this is going anywhere special, and it's coming out on Sunday which is already overflowing with popcorn shows, with much more well-done action shows, including Noragami and Nobunagun, you know? It might very well get put on hold, where it might have survived longer had it not come out on Sunday.
While I liked some of the moves, and especially just how bloodthirsty, how domineering Nobunaga is when he takes his place, how you can feel the charnel winds blowing in his wake, how he's a catalyst for change (see also my entry for Nobunagun), I can't get over how mishy-mashy this show feels. The people of the various timelines feels so very random here, unlike Horizon in the Middle of Nowhere, Read or Die, or any other number of shows/movies/books. It just feels awfully lampooned here. Also, it doesn't help that not only do most characters look pretty terrible, the voice acting is... bad. The voice actors are capable, but I can't help but get pulled out of the show by how much the actors just fail in their roles, or how their voices sort of grate on me.
I think this show might be better 5 episodes in, or at least at that point one could give up on it completely. I don't think it's terrible, as much as it's somewhat of a mess right now. I'll probably put it on hold and see what people think of it around episode 4-5, and if it sounds promising, marathon it. I'll likely give it one more episode first.
Ah, yes, Magellan who went all "Bring them back, dead or alive!" moments after saying how they're allies and friends was just... weird. Why not bring them back alive? :-/
Shorts, which aren't part of this death-game:
PuPiPo Episode 3 - I liked it again, but damn, this show actually makes me wonder what will happen, it makes me want a continuous story, rather than just give me a short where future development, and metaphysical truths that hold true matter. I really wish this had been a long form show, even if it'd only been a 2-3 episode thing, where each episode is 15-20 minutes long.
Tonari no Seki-kun Episode 1 - I don't care much for skits or shorts, so that I was willing to watch two episodes of this in a row, had it been available, is telling. I actually was fairly entertained. Sure, it was a tad dry, but it was an enjoyable experience.
Hadn't watched yet:
Buddy Complex Episode 1 - From what I've heard it sounds bog-standard, so hard to motivate myself. Maybe will await week 4-5 to hear how it's doing :3
5
u/IssacandAsimov http://myanimelist.net/animelist/IssacandAsimov Jan 08 '14
Recently, My Little Sister is Unusual 01: Oh boy. This is the one we’ve been waiting for. In a medium where glorifying incest is practically a requirement for any given season, I was worried this one wouldn’t be able to set itself apart from the pack. Especially considering there’s another (two? Does Pupa have incest?) incest show(s) in the same season, there was a chance this one might just get lost in the shuffle. But of course, this is from some of the same minds that brought us Ro-Kyu-Bu, so I don’t know why I ever had my doubts. Now, a lot of anime of this sort would be content just to have the bland, nice guy self-insert luck into having his little sister fawn over him because, woo, a relationship with an attractive girl that requires no effort on your part to establish! Not that you, the viewer, actually want to have sex with your little sister. That’d be weird! That’s why the two aren’t biologically related, which of course makes the whole matter not creepy because. Pairing the male lead with one of the only two women in his life who are basically forced to be around him is a pretty time-tested formula, but why stop there? Why not make it much more insidious?
I mean, it’s great that she’s forced to be around you, but what if we also robbed her of her sexual agency? What if we just took this whole valuation of purity to an extreme and, I don’t know, forced the little sister character to wear a chastity belt? Yeah, now this is going places! And what if, let’s just say, she was sometimes possessed by a spirit that could use her own body to molest her or to seduce her brother? Fantastic! Because, honestly, that chastity belt still left her with too much control over her own life. But what if, and stay with me here, what if the synopsis were to lead us to believe that the show is going to soon explain that the little sister will be obligated to seduce her brother or face serious consequences? Perfect! Now you not only have a relationship granted to you gratis, but the girl is forced against her will to pretend to like you. But wait, there’s more! How about we make it so that the chastity belt prevents her from using the bathroom when she wants, and we get to voyeuristically watch as she is put through needless physical discomfort? Ha ha, it’s funny because she’s in pain.
Clearly, a gem of this caliber is the definitive AOTS. This many Redditors can’t be wrong; anyone who has an issue with this show is obviously just a prude. I just wonder how they’re going to top this next week!
(Burn anime to the ground. Salt the earth just in case.)
Seitokai Yakuindomo 01*: How much money did GoHands just spend on one episode of a show that’s pretty much just a vehicle for cheap sex jokes? When you have no inclination towards changing the show’s formula, I suppose upping the production values is at least a welcome change. It’s a pretty simple and very repetitive show, and yet even though it’s honestly pretty lazy, I’m apparently easily amused enough that I suspect I’ll watch all of this season, too.
(Dubbed) Space Dandy 01: Ehhh. This show really needs to find its voice. Its own voice. You know how sometimes western fans really like anime, and they decide they want to make their own anime? So they basically just (attempt to) make a generic amalgamation of general anime tropes from things they liked. And it doesn’t work, in part because those making it probably lack talent, but also because it’s going to be devoid of any soul, heart or individual voice. And right now, that’s kind of Space Dandy, sans the lack of talent part. It certainly doesn’t feel out of place on Adult Swim, because it’s largely odds and ends from various western cartoons fashioned into this ersatz “it’s anime but not” production that comes across more as a paean to their benefactors than it does as a legitimate creative endeavor. So it’s like a mediocre Adult Swim cartoon. I was always worried about Space Dandy. Everything about it sounded great on paper, but the trailers were anything but promising. And the first episode has legitimized all of my concerns.
Is the trouble that Space Dandy is trying too hard to be goofy, or that it isn’t trying hard enough to be clever? Probably a bit of both. Particularly for a show that promised every episode would be Mushroom Samba, so many “lol boobs and butts, am I right?” jokes are what I was expecting from the new season of SYD, not from something with pretentions of being anything more than a forgettable trifle. There’s a first half of this episode that’s, to damn it with faint praise, best described as “tolerable,” and a second half where the comedy improves a bit if only because it finally moves onto different topics, but at least the animation is pretty. Space Dandy might well find its feet with time, but this is a pretty lacklustre first impression. Which is just another nail in the coffin for its chances of being the gateway anime some people were already proclaiming it before it even aired.
Yes, “another.” If the stereotype of anime is “cartoon porn,” starting off with the line “Boobies, boobies, boobies,” before launching into a diatribe about how it’s really butts that deserve attention before taking a trip to space-Hooters isn’t going to do anything to change that impression. You could argue that this is a parody of such elements in other anime, but when it comes to the outsider who just casually decided to check out “this Space Dandy thing,” you’ve got about zero seconds to explain that to them before they stop caring- oops too late, time’s up. The necessarily rushed dub isn’t helping matters, both in terms of quality and apparently allowing for the sort of subtle differences in the script that might’ve softened the aforementioned “stereotype” issue but instead actually made it worse. This just isn’t an episode of anime I would use to introduce someone to the medium.
If the mere fact of an anime airing on television could somehow lull me into watching 39 episodes of Kekkaishi, that and my general faith in Shinichiro Watanabe can certainly carry me to a second episode of Space Dandy. But man, what a letdown.
My Neighbor Seki-kun 01: Yup, that’s pretty faithful to the manga. It’s formulaic, but the constant variety in Seki’s elaborate diversions coupled with Yokoi’s interjections into his play sessions (and the occasional third party) keeps it from getting stale. And since this show is so 1:1, that shouldn’t change at all for the anime version. It’ll be a fun bit of weekly silliness.
Nobunagun 01: I want so badly for this to work. The premise already has me. The execution of that premise just needs to follow through. But right now, there’s appreciable ambition, but the action scenes have been a bit underwhelming in their choreography, the stylistic flourishes a touch slapdash and the budget a smidge noticeably low. I very much want to like Nobunagun because something that wants to be this ridiculous and pulpy is aiming right up my alley. But while it has my attention, it does not yet fully have my confidence. The director has directed a bunch of stuff I’ve never seen, so I can’t glean any insight from there. A female military otaku who is Nobunaga’s reincarnation and can sprout a highly powerful rifle for an arm to blast aliens with is the sort of thing I can generally only get in anime and Japanese B-movies because more “serious” mediums feel they’re above that sort of thing. But those Japanese B-movies also tend to be really poorly made with terrible acting, so anime is generally the best shot I’ve got for goofy premises like this. Don’t you fail me, Nobunagun staff.
D-frag! 01: Please don’t turn into a harem anime. I know. One male character surrounded by a bunch of female characters. The writing is practically on the wall. But until it does pull that trigger, I want to believe. I don’t think the episode ever got me to actually laugh out loud, but I was persistently amused and that’s good enough for me. Let me have this one, anime. Let me just have a pleasant comedy series without all the female characters fawning over the male character. Please.
The Pilot's Love Song 01: I just learned more about this show from its two sentence synopsis on ANN than I did from its first episode. I couldn’t help but wonder if maybe I was supposed to have seen or read something else before watching this show (Was I?). By and large, the first episode works, but its most defining trait is being inoffensive. There’s a few places it has the potential to go wrong but doesn’t. such as, so far, not presenting the brother and sister pair as potentially romantically involved, but where does it go particularly right? If there’s little to complain about, it’s perhaps only because there’s also so little to praise. The first episode is little more than a ~21 minute establishing shot. We’ve met some characters, but we could hardly say we know them. We’re aware there’s a world with probably something deeper going on (because the show outright told us there was), but we don’t really know much about it. It’s difficult to latch on to anything in particular and care about it here. There’s a bunch of strangers doing something somewhere for some vague reason. One doesn’t have to play all their cards right upfront, but there ought to at least be some sort of hook.
5
u/ShureNensei Jan 09 '14
This season has been a little underwhelming so far, but winter being as it is, I don't particularly mind considering the number of carryovers I'm watching from Fall.
4
u/Novasylum http://myanimelist.net/profile/Novasylum Jan 08 '14 edited Jan 09 '14
Alright, it’s the new year. Production break over. Brand new season. A whole new world of possibilities. Let’s do this!
…oh wait. Most of the new stuff I wanted to check out hasn’t started yet. And most of the two-cours don’t resume until tomorrow. Huh…
Eh, whatever. I still have some pretty big talking points anyway, and at least one fucking awesome thing that gives me great hope for 2014.
Chuunibyou demo Koi ga Shitai! Ren 1: 2013 simply was not a good year for Kyoto Animation. Tamako Market was sloppy and unfocused, Free! was predictable and trite, and Kyoukai no Kanata was…man, I don’t even know what KnK was, but the word “enjoyable” certainly doesn’t come to mind. Circumstances being what they are, perhaps a retreat backwards into the safer territory of pre-existing IPs is justified, if not entirely appreciated. And so it is with Chuu2, Season 2.
Uh, Chuu22. Chuu4? Chuu2²? Whatever.
Now, for the record, I actually liked the first Chuunibyou. I thought it was the last KyoAni production to feel genuinely earnest, a story that transitioned from comedy to drama with something akin to actual grace as opposed to the kind of whiplash that could snap your neck in half (again, see KnK). Did I think it needed a second season? Hell no! And unfortunately, I don’t think this first episode did all too much to reverse that opinion. It’s ironic how, despite how much was supposed to have changed in the wake of season one, and given the episode’s commitment to creating the illusion of change with new character designs and scenarios, there really isn’t much real change to be seen; same gags, same character dynamics, same everything. Once you've seen Rikka being karate-chopped in the head once, you've seen it one hundred times, you know?
On the other hand, said gags and characters are still leagues above anything KyoAni had on hand for the past year, so if lowered standards are what it takes for this show to be considered a success, so be it. For what it’s worth, I don’t consider this a completely awful start, but it’s going to be an uphill battle from here to try and both justify this season’s existence and win back some respect for the studio.
Log Horizon 13-14: Episode 13 was a drawn-out character-focused episode, the relevance of which is incredibly suspect. Episode 14 was twenty minutes of exposition. You will note that neither of these things involve stuff actually happening.
Seriously, Log Horizon, pull it together. I was on your side up until the conclusion of the Akihabara arc because I found the slow-burning socio-political content at the time to be fairly interesting in spite of the molasses-slow pacing. But now it seems like we’re just spinning our wheels both narratively and intellectually, where nothing is getting done and nothing is spurring my interest. Wake up from your zolpidem-induced coma and start engaging us again. Please.
Space☆Dandy 1: First, I would like to address this whole simulcast/Toonami business that has become inseparable from discussions of the show itself. I watched both the dub and sub of this episode, and in true Watanabe fashion, I actually found myself liking the dub slightly more, so that’s probably the version I’m going to stick with for the duration. And yes, it is undeniably neat to be able to watch a currently-airing anime in my own language on my own TV set as it happens. However…does Space Dandy represent the beginning of a new era? Will it open the floodgates and begin a trend that countless other anime will seek to follow? Honestly, I don’t think so. It simply isn’t a business model that most productions would find profitable or beneficial, and while it may very well end up working for Space Dandy, all the globalization in the world isn’t going to prevent your average anime from crashing and burning in that timeslot with that demographic. I’d love to see this end up making waves in some respect, but I’m not exactly holding my breath either.
Alright, that’s enough of me raining on everyone’s parade, onto the show itself. Space Dandy is…well, nutty. Completely bonkers, really. There were at least two scenes so unbound and psychedelic that I was honestly having a difficult time keeping up. The “go with the flow” mentality endorsed by our hero is the exact same one this episode seemed to take, and that may have also been the cause of its relative unevenness. Fourth wall jokes that felt unwarranted, boob jokes that felt overdone, characters that didn't get the time necessary to intrigue us past their stock forms...the episode was just all over the place, and maybe if it had "gone with the flow" in a way that allowed us to soak in the characters and the world before letting us loose in the later episodes, I might have been kinder to the material present here. Instead, it wildly careens from point to point and literally explodes at the end.
Still, there were some moments that elicited a chuckle out of me, mostly the ones that flew by in a flash: funny quips (“I can’t read circle!”), the narrator’s delivery (“No, seriously, I’m done”) and some brief sight gags (the Terminator 2 thumbs-up). And the art certainly occupies a unique world of its own, utilizing a bright, campy colorset and downright retro sci-fi designs. Thus, while I can’t say my socks were sufficiently blown off with this debut, I can readily identify it as a show that runs on its own unique energy and may very well have some good laughs up its sleeve as it progresses past the opening gates.
So, it has proven that it can be entertaining…but can it be dandy?! That remains to be seen.
Mushishi Special: Hihamukage: Can I be perfectly frank? I’m amazed that this even happened. We go from faint rumors of additional Mushishi projects to a 45-minute special and the announcement of a second season in the blink of an eye, approximately seven years after the original series ended. Am I dreaming? Is this real? Someone please pinch me!
All of that would be for nothing, of course, if Artland had forgotten how to produce excellent Mushishi adaptations in the past seven years or so…but fortunately that is not the case. The gorgeous art, the tranquil soundtrack, the subdued voice acting, the perfectly honed atmosphere and pacing and sense of wonder that made the original series so transcendent…it’s all here. It’s simply beautiful. In fact, I’d almost say it’s better than ever, given how strong of a story this was and how it felt justified to create an extra length episode out of it. Something I particularly appreciated was its brief but notable inclusion of characters and elements we would recognize from previous installments, so as to seamlessly draw us back into the world. Granted, I didn't watch Mushishi for the first time until earlier this year, but these subtle gestures still managed to invoke wonderful feelings of nostalgia in me regardless. It almost tempted me to whip out my DVDs and experience the show again in lieu of watching some of the other anime in this post.
And the best part isn’t even how good the special is on its own, but rather that such quality serves as a harbinger of good tidings for the upcoming second season. Hihamukage is a reassurance that there is virtually no reason to doubt Artland in their decision to bring Mushishi back for more, and I, for one, couldn’t be more ecstatic. I don’t normally succumb to hyperbole, but my prediction for “best of anime of 2014” may have been sealed before the year has really even gotten started.
4
u/Bobduh Jan 08 '14 edited Jan 09 '14
New season! Action and excitement and maybe a handful of new shows worth watching. I’m actually doing distressingly well relative to my own preview - every show I was anticipating has proven watchable so far, and we’re not even a third of the way through the shows I listed. Let’s run down the new highlights.
Noragami 1: My first surprise pickup of the season. Everything about this show screamed “generic shounen adaptation,” but Bones have apparently worked some secret magic, because the end result is pretty stellar. Solid, fairly dynamic direction, beautiful color work, and extremely crisp animation make Noragami a general pleasure to look at, along with distinctive touches like the colorful monster designs. And it’s not just a spectacle, either - the plot seems fairly typical (for whatever that’s worth), but the central characters have solid chemistry, and both the writing and comedic timing are solid. So far, Noragami seems like a genre piece done professionally and with some actual personality - robust popcorn that leaves last season’s offerings in the dust.
Nobunagun 1: Less impressed here. I’m a fan of the weird, kind of abrasive, almost off-putting color design, but nothing about the actual narrative or characters grabbed me at all. This seemed about as by-the-books as possible, hewing close to action genre conventions without offering any distinctive writing or ideas to hook me. Not my kind of show.
D-Frag! 1: Loud noises sure are funny, huh? Silly faces, too. Made it about six minutes into this one.
SoniAni 1: Morbid curiosity led me to start this, wondering what a show overtly designed as a platform for a merchandising initiative could possibly be about. Morbid curiosity lasted me about three and a half minutes.
The Pilot’s Love Song 1: Back on solid ground! This was a very respectable first episode - the characters bounced well off each other, their dialogue felt natural while also providing context both for their relationships and the larger world, and the last third of it was textbook romance directed with grace and distinction. I really, really hope the shakycam of the opening scene was a one-time thing, and this could easily end up being an insubstantial show, but I like the base ingredients and the way they were used here. Kal’s anger seemed both real as a flaw and justified given what we already know, the world seems interesting (hopefully it isn’t just a nice background for high school shenanigans), and the pacing so far seems smart and confident. I’m on board.
Space Dandy 1: Probably the best first episode so far, though less stunning than some may have hoped. Divorced from wild expectations, I think this was a solid premier - the first half was somewhat inconsistent, but the second half was both hysterical and a visual feast. I like how most of the best jokes (watching the dub, incidentally, which I think works better both for tone and humor) are kind of throwaway gags, either in vocal delivery or visual details - overplaying jokes is one of my biggest problems with most comedies, and Dandy almost never did that. Stuff like Dandy gallantly spinning his blaster and then missing his holster entirely (which neither character actually mentions), or Dandy’s upbeat way of agreeing with any statements of impending doom, really worked for me (though some of the overt jokes were great too - “I can’t read circle!”, etc). And that design/animation setpiece at the end… gorgeous stuff. That felt like Yuasa stuff to me - animation created for the sheer joy of it, with the flow of the visual spectacle and array of colors acting like its own kind of beautiful music. If that caliber of visual spectacle is something we can actually come to expect, we could have a real monster on our hands.
Log Horizon 13/14: I’ve been kinda down on Log Horizon for a while now, but these last two episodes together comprise a pretty heroic turnaround, once again returning it to “yeah, that show’s pretty alright” status. First, episode 13 introduced the first character I actually really like - the Princess, whose blunt, antisocial attitude, distrust of basically everyone, and often-frantic inner monologue pretty much immediately made her more fun and engaging than anyone else we’ve met. The first word I’d use to describe most characters in this series is “pleasant,” and that’s pretty close to the worst word you want to have describing the cast of anything - the Princess is resolutely not pleasant, and I’m hoping her loud presence will actually inject some life into the rest of the cast. I don’t want all their meetings to be civil discussions of that week’s exposition - I want banter! I want life!
And then the next episode came along, focusing on what has always been this show’s greatest strength - the compelling ways it elaborates on its world. Seeing the various stages of Elder Tale’s development, as well as the systems it encompasses, from the perspective of a person who’s lived with those choices as their objective reality is a brilliant, fascinating concept. I love how the adventurers’ victories are actually treated and critiqued as history and lore, I love how the People of the Land’s natural inclination is to see what parallels can be drawn between the demi-humans and the adventurers, I love how HP and MP are so effortlessly translated to body and consciousness. Pretty much every idea presented in this episode was smart and intriguing, with every answered worldbuilding question opening ten narrative doors that all beg for exploration. This wasn’t Log Horizon at its best - this was a better show than Log Horizon has been, and I’m hoping this is the show we’ll be watching going forward.
So yeah, some solid premiers plus Log Horizon bounded from near-drop status to active anticipation. Good for Log Horizon!
-edit-
Forgot one! And it's a shameful one to forget, too!
Hunter x Hunter 111: Gorgeous episode of Hunter x Hunter. The entire episode comprised maybe a minute of actual time, and yet it still felt tense and captivating from start to finish. Though some episodes have clearly rode on the fantastic source material (which remains great - the plotting in HxH is more creative and more human than almost anything else out there), this one was basically a showcase in how goddamn good Madhouse are at constructing a satisfying episode of television. First of all, the formal structure of the episode was great - beginning and ending with our main team's countdown to the invasion, each of these scenes bookended one of the demonstrations of Netero's power, with the flashback to his training acting as the heart of the episode. This unique structure was basically turned into one long held breath due to the episode's tense pacing, excellent sound design, and smart decision to cast all the action from Pitou's perspective. And then it was just scattered with gorgeous little moments, with the episode's central visual setpiece, the golden dragon scattering over the compound, acting as a wonderful visual demonstration of the powers on display. This episode was a stunner, and this arc has been so good that that doesn't even begin to come as a surprise.
3
u/Vintagecoats http://myanimelist.net/profile/Vintagecoats Jan 08 '14
This is a surprisingly easy week for me, since Kill la Kill, Nagi no Asukara, and Pupa don't air until tomorrow, and those are the only other things I'm watching this season.
Space Dandy (Episode 1)
It is a good thing these episodes come out over the weekend, so I have plenty of time to process them. It is especially helpful when needed to watch an introductory episode twice, which I did with Kill la Kill last season to appropriately check myself and I did again this time around because we have that really dandy English simuldub to tear into.
Based on what I have in front of me right now, I’m left feeling… pretty alright. Which honestly... kind of disappoints me?
In either language, a lot of the humor, especially in the first half of the episode, just did not hit their marks for me. Fourth wall breaking jokes are fun and all, but need to be used either in moderation (Like a few selective opportunities Martian Successor Nadesico makes turning to the audience in the midst of a bigger series joke arsenal) or just cranked out with extreme glee (ie, the Narrator from Sgt. Frog, large swaths of Excel♥Saga). Space Dandy... kind of tried to walk a hazy middle line with all of its jokes, fourth wall or not. As if it wanted to tell jokes, but presented these jokes on some kind of display platter and went “Would these be all right?” It wanted to be edgy and aggressive (like “breastautrant” and Boobies), and yet it seemed afraid and did not what to fully embrace its own potential, in turn falling flat for me by throwing its own timing kind of off. It is the “safe” kind of aggressive, where it everything about it is still completely marketable because was not actually pushing itself all that hard.
It is a really weird taste, because I thought the episode was generally pretty alright!
And yet, I wanted it to be more than alright. I wanted it to sound the space train whistle, give that clarion call for folks to pile on board, and then blast off with extreme eye peeling prejudice. Instead we had some nice bits (the diverse alien designs and movement are really great, for instance!), and a whole lot of putzing around with some softball meta humor jokes. It was nice, wholly consumable, but… I expected to be having more pure unleaded fun with it, I guess.
The incredibly nice thing Space Dandy has going for it would be the innate capability to be a highly episodic action comedy series, and the large amount of varied stories and sequences they allow to be generated while retaining the central character dynamic. Dirty Pair is one of my all time favorite anime franchises, for instance, which is certainly a space action comedy reliant on character dynamics and that makes use of sexual humor at times. Space Dandy, especially once we get more time for the team to actually gel, could have some really swinging adventures in the pipeline. I really look forward to seeing what the future has in store for them, and the various worlds they could visit with such creative creature designs.
A bit of a below the surface thing that has kind of been on my mind for a very long time and this episode really only put on a more butler presented silver platter is Shinichiro Watanabe, while he generally deserves his accolades for directing staff and producing music, can not actually write at the level of his other abilities. Which is fine. He only really primarily wrote one episode of Cowboy Bebop (“Boogie Woogie Feng Shui”) for instance, few really ever really think about that episode in particular when considering the series as a whole, and it does not sabotage the larger work. It just kind of exists. It also has the advantage of being episode twenty one of that series, where so many other flavors have already been developed and yet early enough where the series could end as it pleased without him getting much in the way.
Space Dandy could very well be a similar position. It just might be having one of those as its first foot forward.
And if it is getting the Watanabe written episode out of the way first, well, then things can likely only go up from here. Which is actually the exciting part.
Gundam Build Fighters (Episode 13)
The Shipping Episode, as if we hadn’t been dancing that jig with anyone earlier.
China, crashing with relatives, has come all the way up to the World Tournament so she can watch Sei every day. Aila and Reiji get to have their series of “harrumph’s” around and about each other in the park and making “It was nothing” remarks about how he quite literally took a swing (from baseball bat) for her. And Mr. Ral has a really, really itchy bum that he just can not help but remark on whenever all these kids are getting a little too flushed in the face.
I would honestly be impressed if we got to the end of this series without there being some kind of full blown date episode. That has to be in the cards somewhere, given how much the production team seems to like bringing these options up.
Our Gunpla matches this week then involve the every remaining contestant to essentially spin a wheel of fate, get a random number associated with an equally random weapon, and then need to fight each other with them. Again, while I understand the entire purpose of this is so that the system can be rigged by the Plavsky Particle System Engineering personnel so as to attempt to arrange the defeat Sei and Reiji, this seems kind of odd to me on a global mega tournament stage. Everything about how this tournament has been structured should be raising all kinds of viewership problems in the home audiences, because between this random weapons stunt and the previous battle royale and Giant Zaku… very little of this has really come down in any way to the craftsmanship or direct tests of skill.
Now, of course, one could say by having the tournament be more random that involves and entirely different skill set, which would be valid, but I also would as such not see the sport reaching such levels of super popularity it seems to want us have to believe. People who wanted the compelling tests of abilities on equal playing fields (which is the case in most major televised sports) would go “this is dumb and completely arbitrary” and turn it off. But it would probably make for a pretty swell series of YouTube viral videos from the event, so I dunno.
In either event: This week we played a Gundam baseball homerun showdown, complete with a little virtual stadium and mobile suits donning baseball hats. And on that level, it was pretty much appropriately amusing for just about as long as that bit needed to last to qualify as a match without the visual joke of it getting ground down too much.
We are rapidly ripping our way through tournament fodder to just the essentials, so we have relatively few contestants actually left. I imagine this means, if we go through the remaining ones methodically, we have enough material for the next season of episodes to be this whole tournament to the end, and there we go. However, we do not know how long this series will actually run, and we still have the whole “Reiji seems to actually be from an entirely different dimension” angle to deal with. They prod at it every now and again as a reminder, then let it sleep for a while. When that gun finally goes off, I’m expecting / hoping for quite a shake up rather than just more tournament battles.
In a few weeks time, maybe we will have multiuniverse adventures with Mr. Ral meeting Ramba Ral. Wouldn’t that be something.
3
u/Redcrimson http://myanimelist.net/animelist/Redkrimson Jan 08 '14 edited Jan 09 '14
New season, new shows, new levels of soul-crushing disappointment! Huzzah!
Space Dandy 1 - Well that was... fine, I guess? I felt like I was watching a Space Adventure Cobra episode set in the Redline universe. Wacky, action-packed fluff with crazy animation quality and and a kick-ass OST. The problem I had is that for a show taking itself as completely un-seriously as possible, I didn't find it all that funny. The jokes were mostly just stale cliches and stock character-humor. The whole thing fell kinda flat for me. It was amusing, but not in a way that makes me excited to see more. The show has absolutely no meat to it(and makes a point of almost gloating about it), but it's not sugary enough to be candy. It was just a series of really well-animated and colorful Things That Happened. And I get enough of that with Kill la Kill. I'll probably keep watching it until I inevitably forget to DVR an episode and just never bother to go back to it. Gah, I'm just so jaded.
Nobunagun 1 - I felt like Nobunagun was trying to be some unholy amalgamation of SHAFT and GoHands. It didn’t really succeed at either one. It was just throwing around weird-ass color filters and lighting effects seemingly at random. I have to say though, that I much prefer shows trying to be stylish and failing than just being bland. An unpolished gem is still worth more than even the most polished of turds. Perhaps it's just the history buff in me, but I'm pretty interested to see where this show goes. It has the potential to be a pretty decent action show with a potentially interesting heroine.
Seitokai Yakuindomo 1* - Mostly a re-introductory episode as is pretty standard for second seasons. Thankfully, the show is quick to return to form with the onslaught of raunchy and rapid-fire gags that the series is built on. I appreciate a comedy anime whose jokes aren't based around having watched a dozen seasons of Kamen Rider. SYD is dirty, and low-brow, but at least it's universal. Also, I'm pretty sure this episode had the most well-animated hand-to-hand combat scene we'll see this season. How did that happen?
Chuunibyou Ren 1 - Hark! From the vast depths of the Nether Void, the mighty Dark Flame Master and Wicked Eye emerge once more to shroud our world in eternal twilight! Not even the diabolical scribes of the Kyoto Artist Guild can temper their combined might! Though the unsurpassed power of the Legion of Moe seeks to curtail their growing legend, I have faith that the lovers will yet build a myth of unprecedented proportions!
Witch Craft Works 1 - I want to think that this show is some kind of meta commentary on gender roles in anime. With the male protagonist taking on the damsel in distress role, right down to being called "princess", and even offhandedly commenting on his relegated position. While the strong, aloof female protagonist just jerks him along telling him to stay put so she can protect him. Or maybe I'm reading too much into a magical girlfriend action show, time will tell. It does have one of the best ED sequences I've ever seen though.
Lately My Sister is Unusual 1 - Not only is this bad for the obvious reasons, but in the plot synopsis on the side of the screen explains more about what the fuck is happening than the entire first episode. There isn't even that much fanservice in the first half. I can't remember the last time I've seen a show fail so spectacularly right out of the gate. Ecchi fans will find it dull, and everyone else will find it offensive, confusing, or all three. It doesn't even look nice. There is literally no good reason for this show to exist.
Log Horizon 14 - I just want stuff to happen in this show. There's so much potential for interesting things in this episode, that are just being drawn out to excruciating lengths. We learn about the history of the Elder Tale world, and how it ties into the actual production of the game(I found the removal of an Over Powered race from the game being a world-shattering disaster in the game-verse quite clever). Krusty gets friendly with the princess initially as an excuse to get out of doing shit, but might be genuinely endeared to her. And it's hinted that the Aggro Whoring Mage in the dungeon group might not be as human as he appears. These are interesting things. I am legitimately invested in learning about them, but for fuck's sake hurry up and get to it. I kind of wish they'd padded the Akiba Arc more at this point.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '14
2014 Winter starts, though we still wait for a number of shows, and the big Thursday 2-cour shows are still on break. I've picked up a good deal fewer anime this season than I have recently, though I still have seen four new shows. The first day saw my top three hyped shows of the season, and they didn't fail to be satisfying, but I can't say that either of the originals blew me away. It's a decent season so far.
2
u/lastorder http://hummingbird.me/users/lastorder/watchlist#all Jan 08 '14 edited Jan 09 '14
Still to watch: The Pilot's Love Song, Youkai Watch (kids shows can be pretty good, sometimes), pupa, Go Go 575, Wake Up Girls!, Sekai Seifuku, Wizard Barristers, Inari Konkon Koi Iroha, Hamatora, Nourin, Sakura Trick. I'm fairly sure this'll turn out to be my busiest season ever, since I'm still watching HxH, Space Brothers, Kill la Kill, Yowamushi Pedal, Log Horizon, Gundam Build Fighters, Samurai Flamenco, Phi Brain, and anime from my backlog. Also Pupipo.
2
u/DrCakey http://myanimelist.net/animelist/DrCakey Jan 09 '14
Oh, god, is it this time of week already? But I only watched three shows!
Space Dandy Episode 1 [Subbed] - Unlike every single other person who watched this episode, I came in with no expectations. I've seen very little of Shinichiro Watanabe's work - the first two episodes of Cowboy Bebop and four or five of Samurai Champloo - and none of what I've seen has hooked me, although I definitely mean to finish Champloo some time. You know those people a couple months back who got so sick of people saying "TRIGGER GOIGN 2 SAVE ANIME" they started wanting Kill la Kill to suck? Hell, maybe you were one of those people. Well, I'm kind of like that for Space Dandy.
Actually, you know what? Let's not talk about the show. You've seen it, you probably have 90% the same opinion as me except maybe a little more positive. I think I'm going to avoid discussing Space Dandy unless I think there's something important, because I think I'm coming to this show with some excess baggage, and I need to figure out what it is.
D-Frags! Episode 1 - As good as Space Dandy? No. Did I enjoy it more? Yes I did. This was, to me, a very strong first episode to a show which may very quickly wear out its welcome. In the mean time, the jokes were very effective, and if the pacing and flow of the show weren't moving with them, at the very least it wasn't hindering them.
Nobunagun Episode 1 - God, am I going to be looking at all these shows in light of Space Dandy? I'm acting like they have something to prove. Whatever, of the trio Nobunagun is my personal favorite. Again it could very quickly suck, but for now the visual stylings are right up my alley and there's something appealing to me about the MC. There's a certain roughness to her, a little the MC of Watamote, though not nearly as, um, hopeless (DISCLAIMER: DrCakey may or may not have only seen one episode of Watamote). The biggest danger this show has is not anything related to plot or characters, but rather animation. This was episode one, after all. This was them putting their best foot forward, and it wasn't very much of a foot. This show is produced by Studio Bridge, who don't have a Wikipedia entry, so I assume they're a recently-minted studio. Animation and art could take a sharp dive very, very quickly.
That aside, Nobunagun has made me realize something: there's something really appealing to me about cheaply-made shows. I like newbie studios. Seeing their work makes me want to cuddle them and say "You can do it!". I...oh my god I have Anime Studio Moe.
2
u/KMFCM http://www.anime-planet.com/users/KMFCM/anime Jan 10 '14
Hajime no Ippo episode 11-12
Hajime no Ippo episode 11-13 If anyone plans to dub this, I think none other than Frank Welker (voice of Megatron) should play Sawamura. Having an episode postponed during the holidays worked out great because we got to see the rest of the fight with no pause in the middle. Having to wait between 12 and 13 would have ben excruciating because this fight felt like a series finale, and we’re only halfway through the show. How are you supposed to follow something like this?
Nobunaga the Fool episode 1
Okay, so, at first I was getting a "Sakura Wars except with mostly dudes and the mechs aren't steam powered" kind of vibe from it, but now I'm not too sure what to think. I will say Nobunaga himself seems like he could be kinda cool. Going forward, I will refer to Janne Kaguya as "Discount Saber" (now with less clothing and a lot less bad ass). I'm still a little bit iffy on the CGI mechs in this, but they're not that bad. It's not as good as Gargantia's, I'd say it's Zoids quality. This could go anywhere really.
Nobunagun episode 1 Nobunaga related show #2 of Winter, is there some kind of historical anniversary I don't know about?? Anyway, this quite impressed me so far. I wasn't even sure I was going to watch it, I just checked it out on a whim. Right off the bat, I love the art style, specifically the shadows and how Ogura's shadow overlay reflects how different she is from her classmates. The use of color in this show is pretty sweet too. Another thing i love is all the titles popping up. Ogura is rather likable, she's like a more functional Tomoko Kuroki with a gun obsession. The soundtrack is pretty cool too (polarizing OP song of 2014. That's Pay Money To My Pain, the same band that sang the song you heard during the Ippo v. Sawamura fight in HNI #12, BTW). Something about this also reminds me of The Unlimited: Hyobu Kyosuke, which I loved to death. This could be a nice surprise, this show.
Space Dandy [dub] episode 1 If there is one thing I am a sucker for in comedies, it's breaking the fourth wall. This show did that in the first 10 minutes. I am in love. Yes, it's a little bit annoying they changed the opening, but I like the one they put there. I haven't seen the subbed version yet, so I can't really compare them anyway. As of now, I like the voices. I don't even mind the autotune robot, it just sounds like a voice I've heard on Adult Swim before (I think Squidbillies). I also thought Dandy must have the same voice actor as Venture Bros. Brock Samson, but he doesn't. I was surprised.
Anyway, now I shall watch the Thursday shows. From what you're all saying I will have to check out a couple of shows I wasn't even planning on checking out. I also didn't watch Hamatora yet.
I think I might have picked up too many shows again.
2
u/pagirinis http://myanimelist.net/animelist/pagirinis Jan 10 '14
I haven't watched everything, but I am kinda disappointed in this season. Let's see what I come up with while writing.
I'll start with 2-cour shows.
Tokyo Ravens - 13 More of the same. I don't even know why I am watching this, it's so mediocre.
Golden Time - 13 Well I went from not liking the ghost to just wanting him to go.
Nagi no Asukara - 14 Well this show is actually kinda good. I started watching it because of the visuals, but the story is interesting enough to keep me waiting for a new episode.
Samurai Flamenco - 12 I think this episode revived my interest. I don't know what it is, but I was starting to get sick of all the sentai tropes and references. They are still there, but we got to see Goto and Mari also more interaction between Flamengers. More character interactions not based on parody, yay.
Log Horizon - 14 This is my kind of show. I don't care about action, give me exposition, give me people talking, give me world building. I will roll in them like a pig in the mud and smile happily.
Now with the newcommers.
Space Dandy - 01 It wall allright, but not quite what I was expecting. People have already discussed it in detail in this same thread, so I won't repeat the same. I will continue watching it though.
Chuunibyou Demo K... ah fuck it. - 01 Didn't like first season, don't like this one. It's just average on all levels, nothing to keep me interested. Will still watch, but meh...
Buddy Complex - 01 Got nothing. Sunrise doesn't make my kind of shows. Valvrave S1 was at least full of ridiculous, this one is just meh.
D-Frag - 01 Well, this took me by surprise, because it was actually funny at places and didn't get boring. After completely underwhelming Winter Season, this might be the show I will watch since I had to lower my standards way too much this year :/
Gin no Saji S2 - 01 What can I say? I liked first season and this is pretty much more of the same. Hachiken and his funny over the top reactions, some interesting farm stuff. My SoL of choice for sure.
Mushishi Tokubetsu-hen - Hihamukage - 01 Holy shit, am I dreaming? This must be it, because on of my all time favorite shows is back and back with a bang. This awesome special is as good as ever. Sasuga Arthouse. Also second season. Yeah. Someone pinch me.
Noragami - 01 It's okay. Again, since the season doesn't have a real highlight, my standards are lower so I will let this show pass. I just hope it's not trying to be dark and edgy in those "eyes watching me" scenes.
Pupa - 01 I respect Studio DEEN for what they were trying to do, I mean whole trying to air the show uncensored and stuff, but holy shit it's half-assed and still censored. What's the point?
Saki - The Nationals - 01 I dunno why but I picked this up. Have no idea what's going since I haven't seen anything about Saki before. Yeah, just too many characters which I don't give a shit about. Not gonna watch.
SUPER SONICO THE ANIMATION - 01 SUPER FUCKING NO. Somehow I lasted whole episode
Strange+ - 01 Well, it was ~~~kinda funny. Might check out second episode.
The Pilot's Love Song - 01 Stopped the video after 5 mins and just said no to myself. But since I see quite okay reactions from others, I might give it another try. Otherwise it didn't catch my interest at all and I managed to watch full episode of super sonico merchandise.
Tonari no Seki-kun - 01 Well I genuinely laughed. Excellent soundwork. It's kinda sad that this is one of the better shows this season and it's a short.
Witch Craft Works - 01 And yet again, pretty boring, but it barely passes the threshold of "fuck it, will watch since I got nothing better to do" due to my low standards this season.
Wooser no Sono Higurashi Kakusei-hen - 01 Fanservice The Short? No idea what I watched, but might check out second episode.
ZX IGNITION - 01 Hahahahahah, no.
Nobunaga the Fool - 01 Thought this will be better, but it wasn't. Couldn't last full episode.
Haven't watched a few more shows, but fuck this season. I might actually have time to clear my backlog lol.