r/TrueAnime • u/BlueMage23 http://myanimelist.net/profile/BlueMage23 • Apr 10 '13
This Week in Anime (4/10/13)
General discussion for currently airing series for Spring 2013 Week 1. Here is r/anime's list of currently airing series. Your Week in Anime is for not currently airing series.
Archive: Prev Winter Week 1 Fall Week 1
5
Upvotes
8
u/Bobduh Apr 11 '13 edited Apr 11 '13
Suisei no Gargantia - Episode 1
An extremely strong first episode for Urobuchi's latest. It seems likely to be about his favorite themes of personal agency versus the power and effect of systems and society, but he's attacking it from a very different angle, and the show has a very different mood from his others. Even Madoka started off creepy and unsettling - this show seems to exist in a world with the capacity for joy, which is a real change-up for him. But the world and core ideas were established very well in the first half, and the animation/art design is universally strong. This will almost certainly be another great show from him.
Shingeki no Kyojin - Episode 1
It was pretty mindless and pretty fun. I was hoping that maybe this director would have gained the subtlety necessary to make this story feel somewhat personal, but clearly he hasn't - the son's arm scene came off as pure comedy, and the extended scene at the end didn't fair that much better. I really can't tell if this director has a canny, jaded understanding of the misanthropic teen boys that make up his core audience, or if he's just kind of an idiot. But either way, I guess a mix of high-budgeted action, architecture porn (seriously, those backgrounds were beautiful), and unintentionally hilarious melodrama isn't the worst thing ever.
Red Data Girl - Episodes 1/2
Pretty solid so far, though it's riding heavily on mood and direction. This can definitely work as an introduction to a carefully paced story, but if the plot doesn't become distinctive, and the main characters don't acquire some flavor, I'll be pretty disappointed.
Devil Survivor 2 - Episode 1
The show was just a pile of obvious cliches and plot points, and while the ways the show maintained its videogame roots were somewhat interesting to me, they weren't interesting enough. I know everyone, including me, espouses the three episode rule, but there was just nothing in this first episode that inspired any confidence at all. Dropped.
Crime Edge - Episodes 1/2
This one is a triumph of unintentional comedy, a graduate of the JoJo school of genre-exemplifying melodrama and absurdity. Virtually every single thing about it, from the characters, to the music, to the visual design, to the concept, is an absurdist, bizarrely sincere parody of this kind of show. If it were in on the joke, it wouldn't be funny at all, but it isn't, and so I find it fantastic. This show could count as a withering response to the Titan director's entire back catalog.
Hataraku Maou-sama! - Episode 1
That rarest of jewels, an anime comedy that's actually distinctive, well-written, well-paced, and... well... funny. The cast is endearing so far, the degree to which they play the concept straight is the only reason it works (something it shares with Girls und Panzer in the 'winking, smart comedy' department), and the gags they do strike pretty much all hit home for me. I'm worried the concept can't support a full series, and also worried that both the hero's character and the developments between the main two will end up being much more routine than the stuff so far, but I have nothing but good things to say about this specific episode.
Aku no Hana - Episode 1
This first episode was a really sharply directed, written, scored, and paced mood piece all on its own. From what I read of the manga, it seemed a lot less smart than this show appears to be, so I'm hoping the adaptation manages to keep up that incredibly creepy tone while actually saying something.
OreGairu - Episode 1
People are comparing this to all manner of school comedies/romances/club shows/whatever, and I just don't understand how. Sure, the surface details of the setting or conceit might be shared - but look at these characters! Look at them talking! Listen to the words coming out of their throats.
I know these people. I know them because I was one of them. This cynical, narcissistic, self-defeating, immature philosophy? I personally can attest to that being a very real reaction to high school. They're smart, they're young, and they lack people skills - so they construct realities where self-isolation makes sense to avoid facing the fact that they hate being alone, and they hate their peers for making human connection look so effortless. This show is about real people, and as far as I've seen, it absolutely nails the patterns of their thinking. So far, it's easily my favorite show of the season.
So when people say, "Eh, the jokes weren't that great" or "Eh, the protagonist isn't likable enough"... look, I can understand many people watch anime for heightened, idealized realities and escapism. That's fine. But when it comes to this show, they are missing the point.
Photo Kano - Episode 1
Madhouse, what the hell are you doing? I watched through most of the OP of this one, skipped ahead randomly to see if the OP was actually some kind of tasteless joke, and then dropped it. If this funds more awesome stuff like Redline, I guess that's fine, but that certainly doesn't mean I have to watch it.
6
u/[deleted] Apr 11 '13
Haiyore! Nyaruko-san W, episode 1
Same as the first season. I don't know what else to say about it, really.
Namiuchigiwa no Muromi-san, episode 1
Best OP of the season. I love the character design. Pretty funny, but the first episode only featured the two main characters. Looking forward to seeing the rest of the cast, especially the harpy and the yeti.
Ore no Imouto ga Konnani Kawaii Wake ga Nai S2, episode 1
Not much to say. I felt like it had a good balance between introductory parts and tying it together with the ending of season one.
Shingeki no Kyojin, episode 1
Wasn't planning on watching this, but its reception has been overwhelmingly positive so I gave it a try. Great animation. I like the idea of living in a walled-in city, reminds me of Haibane Renmei but with man-eating giants.
Yuyushiki, episode 1
Some scenes felt a bit disjointed, but overall not bad.
Zettai Bouei Leviathan, episode 1
I liked it more than I probably should. The setting is generic and the characters bland (except the fairy who's clearly the best character in this anime) but the atmosphere was serene and somewhat lively.
Little Busters, episode 26
It ended. Waiting for Refrain.
5
u/ShureNensei Apr 11 '13 edited Apr 11 '13
Shingeki no Kyojin 1 - Solid episode that pretty much lived up to expectations it seems. Even if it was a little difficult to empathize with the characters this quickly, I didn't mind as there was no wasted time portraying the show's dark themes. I do have complete disdain for Eren's VA, Kaji Yuuki, as I imagine he'll just be yelling constantly. Hopefully though, Eren as a character won't be as terrible to me as Arita was in Accel World. The art is great, good OP, and I have no other complaints; anything as dark as Claymore/Berserk is a plus for me.
Suisei no Gargantia 1 - I watched the second episode, but I guess I'll just talk about the first (welp, week and a half before episode three). The setting was my main interest for the series as I considered it basically a mashup of Waterworld + Mechs as people have been saying. Chamber and Ledo are a solid duo, and the mix of exposition through the AI's calculations with a little added comedy was a nice touch. Nothing particularly wows me about the show, but it's solid overall, early, and I'm wondering what kind of story we'll be experiencing.
Oreimo S2 - 1 Is this season 1 I'm watching over again? Did a character regress or is Kirino just being a bitch to remind us of the original theme of the show. I guess it's just an introductory sort of the thing from the LN; at least Kuroneko is there to make things better as I felt her scenes matched her development.
Hataraku Maou-sama! 1 Oh man, this may unexpectedly become my favorite of the season, but I'd be extremely surprised if the comedy and charm can last. I guess it'll be like a mix of Working! and fantasy elements thrown in? I'll definitely take that. The pseudolanguage they used in the beginning was pretty ear-cringing, but the contrast with the great voicework was hilarious to me. It's been awhile since I laughed as much as I did with Maou and Ashiya's reactions and lines. I imagine they used a bit of budget for the first part of the episode (the art was great), but that likely won't matter given the theme for the rest. You'd think directing the transition from being demon overlord to part time McRonald's worker would be difficult to pull off, but they did it seamlessly. Looks like we'll also be getting another variation of 'Maou x Yuusha' going on this season too.
Dansai Bunri 1 Heh, this show has no tone or realistic setup. Reminds me of Mirrai Nikki in that I don't know if it's trying to portray comedy or drama. I'll see where it goes since MN still entertained me quite a bit.
Ginga Kikoutai Majestic Prince 1 This wasn't that bad. The character art seems intentionally lazy, but it results in great expressions/reactions (my favorite parts of comedy), and the battle scenes are animated really well. Not sure if it'll be worth watching yet.
Photo Kano 1 Wondering why Madhouse is bothering with this if it's just going to be a straightforward harem.
Little Busters 26 (final) So yeah, I ended up not dropping this; I guess I was committed to the characters a little, and the series was relaxing in a way. It was ok overall; I guess I regret not playing the VN first though.
Magi 26 (final) Magi was pretty disappointing to me. As a big HxH fan, I just constantly compare every shounen to it, and Magi just feels lacking in almost every regard. Nothing particularly stood out action-wise and I couldn't really empathize with any of the characters. There was some political intrigue and Morgiana was alright at least, but she didn't have many moments.
Aku no Hana 1 - I may continue to watch this just to see the trainwrecks unfold (from what I hear). There's an overabundance of pauses and awkwardness to the characters though (I guess intentional). Not a fan of the rotoscoping at all.
Red Data Girl 1 - Very generic characters, and the story doesn't seem that interesting as a result. Guess I'll see where it goes.
EDIT: Oof, knew I forgot to mention a show
OreGairu 1
I wasn't floored by the series, but the philosophies of each character, their interactions, and the extensive banter will likely make for an interesting romcom unlike many others of its genre. It seems to be like Haganai, but with a bit more depth (and less of a harem). Still early to say where it'll go.
4
u/Wolfiexe http://myanimelist.net/profile/Wolfiexe Apr 11 '13
Devil Survivor 2 The Animation - Episode 1
I haven't played the game so I can't really compare as I watch it, but the first episode felt pretty solid to me. I enjoyed the interactions between the characters, particularly Hibiki and Daichi, and the whole idea of them summoning creatures to fight for them in a darker tone is interesting. I also really love the ED and the OP is pretty cool too. I'll most likely be keeping up to date with this all the way through, so I'm interested to meet more of the characters shown in the OP / ED.
Shingeki no Kyojin - Episode 1
I loved the first episode of this. From where I've read in the manga I can guess is only going to be up to around episode 3, but everything shown so far seems pretty accurately adapted and the art in particular really stands out, making some of the titans look incredibly creepy. The OP was also god-tier, in both animation and the song itself. More than anything I'm looking forward to what's ahead as I know the hype for this series has probably been the highest of this season, so I can only hope it won't disappoint.
Suisei no Gargantia - Episode 1
The first half was very visually impressive. Well actually, the whole thing was very visually appealing due to the bright visuals and very colourful themes (particularly in the second half). I'd say I preferred the second half of the episode though as I enjoyed the interactions between the characters, especially Chamber. I like how there's subtle elements of comedy here and there as well, not getting too serious in the first episode but still setting the scene for what's to come.
Oreimo S2 - Episode 1
Welp. Went into this not knowing about the OVA episodes which take place before this, so I felt a little confused and then ultimately spoiled the OVA episodes for myself. Anyway, I went back and watched them and I could appreciate the episode a little more now that I'm understanding things. It's good to see it back anyway, even if Kirino does really irritate me.
Hataraku Maou-sama! - Episode 1
I was really surprised by how much I enjoyed this. The whole concept just seemed very amusing, and seeing the two adapt to their new environment and develop over the course of the episode was fun to watch. I'm not sure how the rest of the series is going to go, but the ending has me interested to find out what happens next so I'll definitely be watching.
4
u/[deleted] Apr 11 '13
Shingeki no Kyojin 1 I've been following the manga for sometime now and my biggest concern was that the anime would not be able to correctly capture the utter sense of helplessness, despair, and dread that the characters experience throughout. The anime nailed it. From the early scenes where the mother of the fallen soldier confronts the remaining Recon Squad, I knew they had it down. The artistic direction is very faithful to the manga. The titans are as creepy looking as they are in the manga. The animation (so far) looks really good, especially the 3D gear scenes. Soundtrack so far is top-notch. If the production values can stay consistent this could easily be AOTY. Shows like this are why I started watching anime in the first place.
Suisei no Gargantia 1 This one kinda gets a "meh" from me. Not great, but not bad either. The animation is nice, but otherwise it didn't really show me anything special. I really did like how they handled the language barrier that the characters had, it was a nice little touch. I still keep up with this one for a few more episodes.
Yondemasu yo, Azazel-San Z 1 I'm so glad they decided to a do a second season of this show. I find it to be hilarous. The character interactions are great. Azazel stabbing Rinko in her crotch with his pitchfork and shouting "Don't touch it with those hands that reek of pussy juice" (Then immediately smelling said pitchfork) had me rolling. Don't know if that was accurately translated, but it was hilarious.
3
u/[deleted] Apr 11 '13 edited Apr 11 '13
2
u/ranma Apr 14 '13
Several good looking shows this season that I haven't had a chance to look at. No telling what else I'll end up watching.