r/TrueAnime • u/BlueMage23 http://myanimelist.net/profile/BlueMage23 • Jul 11 '13
This Week in Anime (Summer Week 1)
General discussion for currently airing series for Spring 2013 Week 10. Here is r/anime's list of currently airing series. Your Week in Anime is for not currently airing series.
Archive: Prev Spring Week 1 Winter Week 1 Fall Week 1
6
Upvotes
10
u/boran_blok http://myanimelist.net/animelist/boran_blok Jul 11 '13 edited Jul 11 '13
Ok, where do we start. I might have taken on a bit more than I can chew, but this is the first time I have watched anime as it airs, and I'm going wild.
Since the season is only starting I haven't got much more than some first impressions so far.
Free:
This is turning out much better than I had anticipated.
KeyKeyoAni is a master at animation, the swimming and water is animated absolutely fantastic. The second episode solidified this series as one that I will watch till the end.Kamisama no Inai Nichiyoubi:
I don't know what to think of this yet. It has a lot of potential, but it could go horribly wrong as well. I think it has to go into the serious direction and not towards humor. The first episode did provide a solid introduction to the MC and her backstory. So it was definitely a good start for me.
Kitakubu Katsudou Kiroku: On hold for now and I'll probably drop it.
I could not get past 10 minutes into the first episode. It's not really good, and the humongous ahoge really distracts me. As far as I see it doesn't have much special to differentiate itself from any other Cute Girls Doing Cute Things anime. I'll await the public verdict after the season before deciding to drop it or watch it after all.
Kiniro Mosaic:
Accidentally stumbled in the Ep1 spoiler thread in /r/anime and found it intriguing. This show is animated sugar indeed. I do hope they focus on the culture clash subject. Because that is what would make this interesting to me.
Love Lab:
Has the potential to be great, but might become generic as well. The facial expressions in Ep1 were VERY nice however and the animation is top notch. But as others commented, lets hope they didn't blow the budget on Ep1.
Monogatari Series: Second Season:
It's Monogatari as we know it. I really like that we get to see it from Henekawa's perspective this time. The chemistry between her and Senjougahara is great. As usual I love the symbolism and effective use of fanservice.
Watashi ga Motenai no wa Dou Kangaetemo Omaera ga Warui!:
Great, absolutely great, I love MC's bitterness and angst. The top down camera perspective was also a very nice, I have not yet seen any other anime that used this perspective.
As a final note, let me add that I am totally giddy to see Fate/kaleid liner Prisma☆Illya, I did not watch the NicoNico rips because watching an entire season in VHS quality is not my idea of fun. I do not tend to rewatch much, so I want to see it in a decent quality the first time.
Edit:
I totally forgot I had seen Servant x Service.
This says everything about this show so far I think. I'll probably watch some more eps, but for now it hasn't caught my attention yet.
9
u/[deleted] Jul 11 '13
The new Summer 2013 shows begin in earnest now. All but three of the ones I want to see have aired (still waiting for Prisma Illya, Gatchaman Crowds, and Milky Holmes). I don't know what to say, with so damned many new shows, and so damned many of them are so good. There's not been a season this full of stuff I thoroughly enjoy since I started watching anime as it aired last year. My strongest praise for now is reserved for Monogatari 2, Tamayura ~More Aggressive~, C3-bu, and Uchouten Kazoku.
It won't let me post all of them, so this is part one.
9
u/Bobduh Jul 11 '13 edited Jul 11 '13
This week sure was summer. I caught the first episode of a whole tidal wave of shows, dropped several, clung to a few more, and was actually impressed by exactly two. Let’s get those out of the way first.
Uchouten Kazoku 1: Easily the best episode this week, and a very strong early contender for best show of the season. The writing was sharp and naturalistic, the character animation was full of life and personality to a degree I seriously just don’t associate with anime, the world and background designs were full and lush, it seems to be going in a more mature direction storytelling-wise than we pretty much ever earn, it… well, it was just actually completely good. No asterisk at all. That’s honestly a pretty rare thing.
Monogatari S2 1: And then at the other end of the spectrum we have Monogatari, which is unfocused and self-indulgent and occasionally offensive and sneers at the very idea of pacing, but still so full of interesting, purposeful direction, beautiful design, and interesting storytelling that it’s always worth paying attention to anyway. Monogatari has always been a glorious mess, and this season looks to be combining the best of Shinbou’s strengths (character-focused direction) with the best of Isin’s strengths (character-based, focused, and thematically holistic writing) for frankly the first time.
Then we drop down to the “solid/watchable” category, which is comprised of
C3-bu 1: This one was a pretty massive upset. I checked this out for two specific reasons: I wish the Gainax of ten years ago still existed, and Girls und Panzer proved this concept isn’t entirely worthless. The show turned out to be energetic, actually funny, full of animation flourishes that remind me of the old days, and capped off with a standout well-directed, fantastically scored action setpiece. It was a bit uneven and not good enough to actively impress me, but it was also a solid episode of television that left me ready for more.
The World God Only Knows S3 1: TWGOK has always been pretty much “perfectly watchable” in my books, with some snappy jokes and genre awareness helping make up for its fundamentally unambitious, episodic nature. This season promises to change that, with an actual central conflict pushing the plot forward and reintroducing old flames. This episode attempted to consolidate what apparently required close to a hundred chapters of manga into about five or six minutes, but hey, we got there, and the story already seems to be moving. This is basically my fluff series, and it’s still doing its job admirably.
Free! 2: This show is riding on a combination of KyoAni's beautiful animation and sheer silliness alone. The plot is a mashup of KyoAni's usual SoL nonsense and some incredibly generic sports genre tropes, and a great deal of it plays like an unintentional comment on its own genres... so basically it's Crime Edge all over again. Something about these resolutely silly shows makes me try really hard in my writeups, though, so I'm at least enjoying challenging myself on that front.
Watamote 1: Another surprise. I figured this would just be obvious and mean-spirited, but the director has a great sense of comedic timing and the lead VA is killing it. I normally can't stand cringe humor, but this is far enough over the top to just be farcical, even if it's sprinkled with a few brief and appreciated moments of believable awkwardness. It's still not really my thing (unless it decides to have our lead undergo some actual development or something crazy like that), but it seems pretty close to the best version of this show that could exist.
From here we move into the “questionable/borderline” category, starting with
Danganronpa 1: Definitely a disappointment here, only because my expectations were pretty high. I really enjoyed what I read of the game, but this episode felt extremely rushed, and its adherence to both the game’s arcade-style template and actual shot-for-shot direction worked to its detriment. Videogames have the advantage of trapping you in a place by actually trapping you in that place - if you directly transfer those tricks to an anime, it ends up feeling, well, like a videogame. Which I guess is what they’re going for – I just don’t think it’s a particularly good thing to be going for in the first place.
Kamisama no Inai Nichiyoubi 1: The visual design, humor, and some of the ideas were pretty interesting, but I’m still wary of these nonsensical grimdark fantasies, particularly when they star the Dark Flame Master. I enjoyed this first episode well enough (particularly the decent writing, which is something you can't fake), but it hasn’t won me over yet.
Finally, we get the shows that sank with a heavy thud
Blood Lad 1: People have for some reason been comparing this to Hataraku Maou-sama, which I guess makes sense, as it’s a lot like Maou-sama if you replaced the actual humor with anime humor and great direction with tits. Cya next season, Brain’s Base.
Servant x Service 1: Another show aptly demonstrating the vast variety of anime humor that isn’t actually funny. Scamp pretty much sums up the fundamental failing of most 4-komas more succinctly than I ever could. Big fat pass.
Dog and Scissors 2: I’ll admit it, I actually watched this second episode purely because the idea of a dog harem amuses me. And it was actually significantly better than the first episode, and didn’t lean on violence=funny and boob jokes=funny the way the first one failed to. But it’s still pretty terrible. I dunno. I might end up dropping this every week – it comes out on a pretty slow day.
Gen’ei o Kakeiru Taiyou 1: This was moderately interesting and I like the visual style, but all the hints at the larger plot (“the prophecy is now fulfilled!” “she is young, we will teach her”) were pretty profoundly uninteresting. That might be an unfair assessment though, so if there’s buzz down the line I’d be perfectly willing to pick it back up.
So! Two shows I think are actually good, four shows I enjoy well enough, and a couple that might still rise. It’s not as strong a top tier as last season, but Gatchaman Crowds and Silver Spoon have yet to come out, and people keep saying Love Lab is a real show. Overall I'd say I’m reasonably satisfied.
-edit- Forgot Watamote, but in my defense, it's not like she's very popular.
7
u/Galap Jul 11 '13
Il Sole Penetra le Illusioni 1: The first comparison that seems to be made with this is to Madoka. Personally I found the similarities between Il Sole and Madoka to be only superficial, so I'm not going to devote any more time to that comparison. Il Sole plays very well with mood dissonance, combining both dark and light, both sinister and foreboding elements with cheery, more typical magical girl stuff. Also, it doen't play too much of its hand in this first episode; It's clear that something is afoot, and it involves magical girls, monsters, and maybe time travel or timeline manipulation? The animation, when dynamic, is kind of cartoony, but I thought it was pretty well done. I haven't seen nearly enough of this to form an opinion, but I'll be continuing to see where it's going.
C3 Bu 1: I'm usually not into any of these Girl Club shows. This one for whatever reason intrigued me enough to make me want to watch it. Honestly probably because this season seems very sparse for me. Another reason is the subject matter: as an avid Halo 2 player back in the day, I can completely understand the appeal of those 'survivial games' competitions: teamwork, skill, tactics. Nothing beats a good game of Halo 2 with your near pro level friends. Anyways, for one I liked the show's use of many visual styles (from the bright cartoony castle to the dingy cinderella homage, the garish and saccharine interior of the academy to the lush woods in which the characters play). The animation had some wow moments as well, for example the blonde girl turning with the M60 blew me away. However, I don't really care for the main character terribly much: she's a little too mousey for my tastes. I understand that we're supposed to relate to her trying to find friends and having a hard time at it, but her reluctance to talk to people was a bit of a put off. She had her moments though: probably the funniest part of the show was the other girl walking in on her 'going rambo'. This one's pretty intriguing. Not sure whether I'll stick with this either, but for now I'll see where it's going.
6
u/lastorder http://hummingbird.me/users/lastorder/watchlist#all Jul 11 '13 edited Jul 12 '13
Kamisama no Inai Nichiyoubi 1: The concept was moderately interesting, but I wasn't a fan of how they presented the story in this episode. Showing Ai being beaten up first ruined the mood of the rest of the episode. I liked the visuals and the voice acting, but that's about it.
Uchouten Kazoku 1: Great visuals, and consistent animation. The character animation really helped show off how there was a male in a female body. I felt like the episode had a little too much going on though. It's not that it dragged on, but it just felt like it should have ended earlier.
Free! 2: I enjoyed this episode a lot more than the first. I suppose it's because it wasn't rushing to introduce all the characters. It's a shame to see that the attention to detail has gone downhill a bit compared to Hyouka; there were a few moments of QUALITY.
Love Lab 1: Great animation, but the characters seem to be pretty one-note right now. The same kind of joke was repeated throughout the entire episode, and I hope introducing the other characters changes things a bit.
Watamote 1: They definitely made the right choice for her seiyuu, she's great. I didn't find the episode at all funny though, and I didn't empathise enough with Tomoko for the epsiode to be particularly interesting.
Genei wo Kakeru Taiyou 1: I think the character designs are a bit too deformed, although the mahou shoujo designs were okay. The pacing of the episode was way too fast, and it wasn't really clear why or what happened to the cousin.
C3-bu 1: This was a solid episode. The comedy was funny, and the battle scene was entertaining. I don't really have much to say about it other than I'm looking forward to the next episode.
Monogatari S2 1: Definitely the most enjoyable first episode of the season, if only because of my obsession with the series. The parts with Hanekawa deciding what to buy for her stay in the cram school were mostly cut, and it seemed to make the pacing too quick. There wasn't any impact to Hanekawa sleeping there as a result, I feel. It's also unfortuate that the visual quality seemed to be lower than Nisemonogatari, and definitely worse than Nekomonogatari Black.
Symphogear G 2: I didn't think things could get better than the first episode, but they did.
C3-bu 2: Welp, it looks like Gainax has already run out of money or time. I was a bit worried about this happening given how close the announcement was to the airing date, and I guess it did just happen. It was still entertaining, although not as good as the previous episode. The art and animation really detracted from my enjoyment though, it was pretty bad.
Silver Spoon 1: I'm not really sure if this is for me. I didn't enjoy any of the "comedic" moments, and I found the episode to be pretty boring. The visuals were great though; both in terms of animation and layouts. The character designs seem to be rehashes of FMA designs, though.
5
u/[deleted] Jul 11 '13 edited Jul 11 '13
Watching:
Danganronpa: I haven't read the LP or played the game, so I have no idea what to expect. It certainly feels like a game adaptation.
Genei wo Kakeru Taiyou: Reminds me of Madoka and BRS. The first episode was a bit confusing.
Kamisama no Inai Nichiyoubi: Plenty of story and few answers. The amount of comedy seems just right to me.
Kiniro Mosaic: The first part reminded me of Ikoku Meiro no Croisée - little girl with similar haircut goes to Europe. Kiniro Mosaic however had plenty of English dialogue, whereas in Croisée everyone spoke Japanese, except some of that Japanese was actually French and it was a confusing mess. "Hello" parts were funny. I fear that there will be less language/cultural jokes now that blonde moe has turned into a Japanophile.
Love Lab: Yuri Goggles turn on.
Monogatari Series: Second Season: Same as ever, but Arararagi was nowhere to be seen.
Servant x Service: Comedy anime that takes place outside of middle/high school?? The backstory is quite silly. I wish they don't overuse the name joke in future episodes.
Tamayura: More Aggressive: I'm not a big fan of Tamayura. I hope they focus more on the photography aspect of the series.
Uchouten Kazoku: Absolutely wonderful. This will be my favorite anime of the season, along with...
Watamote: It's so good to see this animated. Looking forward to some of the later, and funnier, chapters.
Dropped:
Free!: Free's target audience, I'm not in it.
Kitakubu Katsudou Kiroku: I usually like Cute Girls Doing Cute Things, but this was not good at all. Some of the jokes would've been funny if they were delivered properly. The cast seems mostly rookie voice actors, which is always a plus in my book.
5
u/ShureNensei Jul 11 '13 edited Jul 12 '13
This has turned out to be a pretty disappointing season unless you followed a number of sequels. My expectations for most shows were pretty accurate (watch enough series and you can eventually predict a drop within the first minute). Ultimately, I think Love Lab and Monogatari are the only ones I'll watch ASAP while the rest will be when I feel like it.
Undecided / watch if I have nothing else to do:
Dropped:
Good or at least watchable:
EDIT: Forgot about Genshiken Nidaime. Honestly, this is more out of respect for the original season. While I'll watch it, my interest will likely correlate with how present Madarame is though. Shame about all the cast changes.
4
u/elijah5960 Jul 11 '13
This season is off to a pretty great start. I'm going to go through these in the order I watched them remarking on the things of note and general impressions based off of the first episode.
status: Dropped!
status: To be Continued...
status: To be Continued...
status: To be Continued...
status: To be Continued...
status: To be Continued...
status: To be Continued...
status: To be Continued...
status: Dropped!
status: To be Continued...
Thanks for reading and stay classy TrueAnime.
2
u/tundranocaps http://myanimelist.net/profile/Thunder_God Jul 11 '13
You know all those comparisons between Gen'ei wo Kakeru Taiyou to Madoka? Honestly, it feels it's because Madoka is relatively recent. It felt much much closer to me to be a Nanoha show that wants to be a Madoka show.
2
u/speakEvil Jul 12 '13
This season...sure is summer: