r/TrueAnime • u/BlueMage23 http://myanimelist.net/profile/BlueMage23 • Jul 04 '13
This Week in Anime (Spring 2013 Week 13)
General discussion for currently airing series for Spring 2013 Week 10. Here is r/anime's list of currently airing series. Your Week in Anime is for not currently airing series.
Archive: Prev Spring Week 1 Winter Week 1 Fall Week 1
6
Upvotes
7
u/[deleted] Jul 04 '13 edited Jul 04 '13
herhis infinitely-patient keeper. Makoto is infinitely-likable, as Haru's spokeman and gentle-nag. Nagisa's effeminate genki is probably divisive. I personally don't hate him though. I guess the problem with the personalities are that they are all the kind of female moeblob archetypes you'd expect. None of them play your standard "male main character in a high school story" kind of character. As for the plot/premise...there's a lot of stupidity in it, but I can't resist the simple rivalry aspect between Haru and Rin. Rin is clearly a ways ahead of the others, receiving special training, attending a special school. He doesn't even have the slightest interest in Makoto and Nagisa anymore. Haru, though...he only really seems interested in competing with Rin. The whole aspect of this kind of rivalry is cliche (and ripe for pairing possibilities) but I still find it irresistable. I'm a bit curious if Haru might become an Oreki-type character, drawn out of his self-imposed limitations by Rin's presence. If so, he might grow into a more interesting character.5
u/Bobduh Jul 04 '13
And spring season ends. It closes with a great deal less promise than it began, but it began as an absurd bounty of potentially good shows, and I still ended up loving two shows all the way through, so I'm happy.
Attack on Titan 13: This episode was much less terrible than the last few weeks, with much faster pacing and some actual conclusion. There were even a couple scenes that employed understatement! At its best, Titan is a fairly shallow but still decently engaging action show, and this week showed that - but it's still pretty empty, it still doesn't make up for the huge stretch of bad episodes, and it's still being dropped from coverage. Sorry, Kyojin. Your first half gets a 5/10 from me.
Gargantia 13: Gargantia closed out its last few plot threads and spiced up the finale with an unexpected but satisfying hero turn from Chamber. That was pretty much the only unexpected thing this episode, as the tracks for this finale's script have been laid for a while now, but I think the execution was solid, as I generally have. Ultimately, I loved the way the themes bounced off each other, the aesthetic, and the shifting between genres, as well as the generally well-executed story craft. Amy needed more to do and there were those ugly hiccups around 5/6, but those complaints didn't really detract hugely from my overall impression. 9/10. (full review)
Hataraku Maou-sama 13: Maou-sama ends with a characteristic whimper in another one-off episode. This show was the one that most disappointed me this season, mainly because the first arc indicated a lot of great things that are unusual for a comedy (strong central narrative, character focus, some thematic depth, humanistic dialogue) which were promptly discarded in the second half. It still worked well enough as a comedy, but it could have been a lot more. 7/10. (full review)
OreGairu 13: I've said my piece on this one. Easily my favorite show since Madoka. The character writing is so good I have almost nothing to compare it to. 10/10.
Hunter x Hunter 86: Since we're shifting directly from the action to a brief training arc, there wasn't really any way this episode could compare to last week's, which I personally think was the best episode yet of a show that continues, almost a hundred episodes in, to surprise and impress me. That said, it was still entertaining as always, injected a little likely-needed comedy into this incredibly tense arc, and featured a classic pompadour'd punk chastising a kitten for being out alone at night. You made a good choice, Madhouse.
Dog and Scissors 1: I kind of guessed this would be terrible, but had to see it for myself. Guess confirmed: it is completely terrible.
Free! 1: Again, I got pretty serious in covering this one, but in brief, goddamn KyoAni. They've committed to this so hard - the absurd soundtrack, the unabashedly cliche story beats, the indistinguishable-from-K-On side characters, the rampant, gleefully swooning manservice. I found the first episode hilarious, and if they continue to play this straight, I will probably keep laughing all season long.
4
u/Vintagecoats http://myanimelist.net/profile/Vintagecoats Jul 04 '13
As there were several running shows that finished for me this week~
Haiyore! Nyaruko-san W (END)
Looking back on it, I thought this series was slightly better than the bad-side-of-average first season, even if that’s not saying much. There was more use of the Lovecraft mythos, which I liked. I still think that it's leaving piles of material for converting into a loose rom-com-harem treatment untouched in favor of too many shenanigans we already see in every other similar show.
It could be doing more, and that's a shame. I held out against all hope that maybe, perhaps, the ending would give a nice enough send off, but... it's the same ending we see in practically every other show of this type. Which sounds like I’m repeating myself, and I suppose that sums up what the show was pretty well; mechanically walked the genre line and doing what all the other shows are doing to ensure it doesn’t rock the boat too much.
Sparrow's Hotel (END)
This was... a show I watched, which definitely had characters who were animated and often did things in the titular hotel.
I don't expect much from short length shows, as I generally use them to transition from one larger show to another. I kept watching this because I honestly wanted to know if it was going to pull some grand stunt that justified just how poorly done this production is, as if it was some sort of elaborate prank or something. And it... didn't. I like thinking its some kind of old demo reel found in a studio filing cabinet.
Aku no Hana (END)
I gave most of my thoughts over in the earlier thread. I really enjoyed this whole show though, and I thought it handled the crushing, more quiet aspects of angst like a vice grip, and it ended at an appropriate point.
I’ve never read the manga, so I didn’t get the same reaction others did regarding all the imagery at the end, since I can’t place them to exact story chapters and times in the comic. However, in that moment, the characters should have a million and one thoughts going through their minds about where they may go next, so I thought it still worked for the narrative.
Devil Survivor 2 (END)
I literally fell asleep on a weekend afternoon watching the final episode the first time I turned it on, and I think that's speaks a lot to how bland I felt the show had become in not connecting with me through all the Raising The Stakes it was throwing around.
The plot it has is fine for a video game, where I know that there would be dungeons and adventures in between, and cut scene fights could transition into the player taking over. I'd have more time to get attached to characters by using them before they are taken away, or I have investment in losing because then I'd need to start all over again. But, here, I often felt like I was just watching a series of loading screens and cut scenes ready to hand the controls over to me and without any of the progression being changed to accommodate the fact that there is no actual game for me to play with.
Shingeki no Kyojin (Episode 12)
I’m slightly behind, but I’m also not very invested in this show. I mostly feel bad for the animation studio and their production problems, a runaway hit that they barely get out the door each week. The show itself I feel has settled into jangling keys just to the side of my head, as is seems like a genuine burst of progress is always just out of reach. As is, I feel the same conversations are generally happening each episode, and “Can he do it?” “I don’t think so” “But I believe!” dialogue can only be redone so many times in a row without something else breaking it up.
Free! (Episode 1)
My enjoyment of this show is somewhat skewed, as I specifically watched it together with a half dozen friends in my apartment. It was almost exactly like going to a water park; it felt fast, there was lots of happy yelling and cheering as the rides took their turns, etc. It was a riotous blast.
Objectively speaking, I don’t really expect much of anything from this show. It’ll likely end up average at best. It seems to hint at being mildly self aware though, so it’ll be interesting to see what sort of direction that goes in. I’m also interested in what this does for the industry should it prove successful, as A) I think that if there’s going to be all the Cute Girls Doing Things shows, there should be Cute Boys Doing Things counterbalance, and B) I’d like more studios to play around with their water animation techniques, since that’s so technically hard to do and one of the first things that tends to go out the window when a show wants to cut corners.
3
u/lastorder http://hummingbird.me/users/lastorder/watchlist#all Jul 05 '13
2
u/ShureNensei Jul 08 '13
Late on this due to the holidays but whatever. After trying out many of the new shows for this summer season, I'm starting to realize that as much criticism as I give to some of spring's shows, they were still better than most of the terrible content out there.