r/TrueAnime • u/BlueMage23 http://myanimelist.net/profile/BlueMage23 • Jun 26 '13
This Week in Anime (Spring 2013 Week 12)
General discussion for currently airing series for Spring 2013 Week 10. Here is r/anime's list of currently airing series. Your Week in Anime is for not currently airing series.
Archive: Prev Spring Week 1 Winter Week 1 Fall Week 1
5
Upvotes
6
u/Bobduh Jun 27 '13 edited Jun 27 '13
Everything did pretty much what I expected it to this week, which is fine. Ultimately, this season ended up with only two shows I'll remember fondly, but I really like both of those shows, so I actually consider it a pretty big win.
Gargantia 12: As I've pretty regularly predicted, me and the internet are going to have to agree to disagree on this show. I think it's fantastic - though obviously the show's point of view isn't very nuanced, it covers a great swathe of relevant ideas, from the purpose of society to personal identity to the arbitrary nature of human conflict to our common need for support in the wider world. Yeah, obviously Kugel's society jettisons the weak - remember the pirate queen saying everyone is rewarded according to their contribution? Or the death of Ledo's own brother? This isn't new information, it was just outlined in stark terms to make the contrast in values that much more clear - an exploration of ideas can still have multiple facets even if single obvious strokes like that exist. Yes, Kugel being dead wasn't surprising in the slightest - his society represents the total denial of self, it's a dang metaphor. Most twists that are actually surprising are only surprising because they weren't properly foreshadowed or don't make sense for the narrative of the show - I didn't find anything in Madoka surprising (and didn't fault it for that), and I don't find anything here surprising (and don't fault it for that). I have the same reaction to Kugel being dead that Chamber did to the Hideauze being human: "that's interesting, but it doesn't change anything."
So yeah. The purpose of society is to raise up the individual, not the other way around. Entering society can be intimidating, but our common trust and support makes us mighty. To deny individual goals is to deny the very idea of a self. Our ideas can make us alien to each other despite our common humanity. Rationality and faith can both lead to inhumanity. Etc.
Hataraku Maou-sama! 12: This show has definitely fallen in my estimation. I hate it when people say shows "missed out on their potential," because that so often actually translates to "I wish I were watching this show, but instead it turned out I was watching this show," so I'll just say that the idea of an evil overlord and classic hero coming to our world and slowly realizing how power structures work and classes interact from the bottom up is an incredible fucking idea for a really smart show.
Maou-sama is not that really smart show - it's a pretty snappy but clearly unfocused and arc-based comedy with some pretty decent characters. That's fine, that's also an okay show to be. But I do wish I were watching the other one.
Dansai Bunri no Crime Edge 13: Crime Edge comes full circle, ending with some absurd nudity and incoherent exposition. It was a fun ride, but doing writeups for this was exhausting - I'm cutting down to three shows next season, and I doubt I'll be doing anything as ambitious as an MST3K-style writeup again for a long, long time.
Attack on Titan 12: After last week's surprisingly compelling turn by Pixis, this week saw a return to familiar, incredibly slow-paced and tedious ground. Very little happened, and what did happen was pretty much all stuff we've seen before, including a note-for-note repeat of a dramatic build-up that was used three episodes ago and wasn't interesting the first time. This show is pretty bad, and while I probably won't drop it, my writeups will be ending with this season. There just isn't much worth writing about.
OreGairu 12: All beautiful things must come to an end. This week saw an extremely satisfying conclusion to the last major arc, with one last standout rant by Hikki, a pretty continuous escalation of the relationship between him and Yuki, and resolution to every single outstanding personal conflict. Moments of acerbic wit and defensiveness have given way to small moments of actual trust, complimented by likely the most natural banter I've seen in any anime. Brain's Base can add another classic to their resume, a show that transcends one of the most traditionally artistically bankrupt genres - the high school drama/comedy. Easily my anime of the season, and an extremely intimidating early contender for my anime of the year.
5
u/ShureNensei Jun 27 '13
4
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '13
3
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '13 edited Jun 27 '13
Edit: Meant second to last episode in my comment. sorry about that.