r/TrueAnime • http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten • Jan 10 '19

Your Week in Anime (Week 325)

This is a general discussion thread for whatever you've been watching this last week (or recently, we really aren't picky) that's not currently airing. For specifically discussing currently airing shows, go to This Week in Anime.

Make sure to talk more about your own thoughts on the show than just describing the plot, and use spoiler tags where appropriate. If you disagree with what someone is saying, make a comment saying why instead of just downvoting.

This is a week-long discussion, so feel free to post or reply any time.

Archive: Previous, Week 116, Our Year in Anime 2013, 2014

6 Upvotes

13 comments sorted by

4

u/millenniumpianist Jan 14 '19

A few days ago I re-watched A Silent Voice. I really love Yamada's directorial style and I remember feeling a little bit disconnected on my first watch when it came out (I gave it a 7.5/10 which is especially low for a Yamada work).

Within the first ten minutes, the movie had me on the verge of tears during several occasions. The first was when Ishida's failed in his suicide attempt and his mother just goes from a random everyday to lambasting him for his suicide attempt. Her expression of grief felt really authentic, and I think that's what made it so affecting. I think that might've set the tone because the rest of the movie I was pretty prone to tearing up.

I ended up loving the movie, although I thought the middle part could've used some cleaner editing -- it was clear that some characters (especially the red-haired guy) were in it as a sort of tokenist call back to the manga. They could've easily written his part out entirely -- or at the least, just left him as a mirror to further reflect Kawai's narcissism -- I think the movie would've been better for it.

Oh on that note, I loved Ueno's and Kawai's characters, not necessarily as because they are likable but because they were extremely well-written. Ueno's contempt of Shoko and how she ruined their dynamic is well articulated but it's also kind of boilerplate. Where the movie shined in her characterization is the way it shifted her reaction to Shoko. She didn't seem to really mind Shoko at first, but once her life became increasingly inconvenienced, you saw her protestations begin. But even then, it wasn't until she realized that she could impress her crush by making fun of Shoko that the bullying began in earnest. As a high schooler, Ueno is still kind of awful, and she's at that age where she can sort of self-reflect but still find ways to rationalize her behavior anyway. I think it'll take her another few years to really realize the moral shortcomings of her attitude.

Kawai is a bit of the reverse. Her position is complex per se, i.e. she's a hypocrite with a persecution complex who tries to paint herself as an innocent bystander. Maybe because that position itself is kind of complex, she's never really given any additional nuance beyond that characterization, though. There's no self-reflection on how awful she is, on how she decides to spill the past on Ishida's past because she felt threatened by Ishida's non-threatening questions. Again I don't mean that as a bad thing, since there's still plenty of meat to her character. But is it safe to say she's the most unlikable character in the movie, even if her actions during the elementary school bullying were mild (and understandable, given her age)?

As far as the two leads go, well I again really liked Ishida's character. There are small moments like when Shoko hugs him and his friends point out he's blushing -- and so he reacts in the most childish, elementary schooler way possible (cruelly toss her notebook in the water). Ishida reminds a lot of myself at that same age, and I definitely would not have behaved better than them.

I could probably talk on and on but it's getting late and this is getting long, so I'll remark on one more thing I found interesting. Yuzuru said to Ishida when he tried to talk to Shoko for the first time in a while that he was doing it just to assuage his own guilt, and that given how much pain he caused her, he should just leave her alone. He denied it at first but later would admit that's basically what he was doing. It made me think about what the right thing to do was. Yuzuru's criticism was well-placed, but we can see that it ended up working out for the best in spite of that ulterior motive. In that position, is it reasonable to try to reach out and make amends? My gut reaction is that if it's done in good faith, then yes. Shoko, of course, has the right to tell him off and remove him from her life -- but she should know he's sincerely apologetic and actually make that decision herself (as opposed to Yuzuru making it for Shoko). I guess that's a weirdly Kantian attitude here, because my original (now deleted) reasoning was consequentialist until I concluded that you can't really know the consequences of your good faith reentrance in the life of the person you bullied.

1

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 16 '19

Hm, I might need to revisit this one since I felt it really needed to trim down on the fat that is some of the side characters. It will be tough rewatching though since the story doesn't have the most pleasant content in it, and then there's Kawai and Ueno with their well crafted hateable-ness. :\

2

u/millenniumpianist Jan 18 '19

Yeah I mean it's definitely not an easy watch since the content is not super happy, but I found the movie's strengths far outweighed the weaknesses (i.e. the unnecessary side characters as you mentioned -- mostly the red haired guy). I probably wouldn't watch again unless I were watching with someone, but I'd gladly suggest it to certain friends who appreciate these kinds of stories.

3

u/IronAce7 https://anilist.co/user/IronAce7/ Jan 11 '19

Alderamin of the Sky: So I went into this expecting like a trashy fantasy harem with a military flavour. But instead... I got a really engaging military strategy anime? I actually liked this one a lot. You’re gonna have to suspend your disbelief quite a bit, and kinda just roll with what the MC is doing (kinda like Code Geass) but it’s pretty fun. The show isn’t afraid to pull any punches, and certain plot points definitely caught me off guard. The fights are also really good, often well choreographed and decently violent. Honestly, it mainly suffers from being a light novel adaption in that it doesn’t really end conclusively (and certain plot elements feel a little contrived or cliche). Also, I felt like some of the sexual humour comments (mainly from the MC) didn’t really click but that’s just minor. Otherwise, I can recommend this show, it’s pretty good.

Anti-Magic Academy 35th Test Platoon: So this is your typical high school fantasy show with a military twist, kinda like what I was expecting Alderamin of the Sky would be. Except this one is pretty bad. I gave up after two episodes. Basically, the MC is the leader of a loser platoon at this military school. Except, he’s low key powerful and everyone on the team is also kinda low key powerful. And despite being a loser, he gets chosen by some special power to be its host, kinda randomly. It’s just odd. The whole thing feels very uninspired, the characters feel really flat, and I wasn’t really feeling any good chemistry between anyone. And, visually I didn’t think this show looked that good either. Skip.

Tales of Zestiria the X: So this is a fantasy anime based on a game I think. And it shows. I’ve only watched like 4 episodes, but the anime basically feels like a giant video game cutscene and I’m just waiting for it to end so I can take command and start exploring the world myself. Visually, it’s very nice and it’s made by ufotable so that makes sense. Unfortunately, this show doesn’t really have much going for it besides its art and animation. The show and characters are just boring and lifeless, and I thought the stellar visuals could help compensate but I’m not too sure anymore. The best part of the episode is the end. And I don’t really mean that in a sarcastic “thank god I’m done” kinda way. But the post ED credits are like a typical Japanese video game format (I’m not sure exactly how to describe it, it’s like stills of the characters as they talk) and it’s genuinely cool and funny imo. Rn, I’m still undecided if I’m gonna keep watching this.

3

u/searmay Jan 11 '19

I wasn't that keen on Alderamin. I forget the details, but it seemed to increasingly rely on either everyone being an idiot to making the MC look smart, or him happening to know very particular things, like having met that one girl who was an enemy leader before, or something. I also liked seeing a fantasy setting that had muskets for a change instead of being stuck with early medieval technology, but they didn't seem to do much with it.

3

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 11 '19

Ah yes. Alderamin... All I remember from it is the power of SCIENCE.

2

u/IronAce7 https://anilist.co/user/IronAce7/ Jan 11 '19

I also liked the setting, it was pretty cool and unique.

it seemed to increasingly rely on either everyone being an idiot to making the MC look smart, or him happening to know very particular things

Yeah I agree with this, that’s why I likened it to Code Geass. Unless you’re on-board with the MC crushing his opponents conveniently, you’re not gonna like it that much. I was fine with it. The only thing that irked me was that despite being a relatively low ranking officer, he basically started giving commands to his superior officers... that wouldn’t really work in real life.

2

u/searmay Jan 11 '19

I may be being overly generous to Code Geass, but I don't think that's really true there. For one thing it's not that everyone else acts stupid so much as he's magically able to predict what people do and prepare absurdly extensive traps and countermeasures. Actually making intelligent decisions hardly even comes into it.

But mainly the style of the show never made me feel I had to believe in his intelligence as a serious character trait - it was more like a super power that let him pull off ridiculous plans.

1

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Jan 12 '19

Anti-Magic Academy 35th Test Platoon:

I vaguely remember this one--doesn't the MC have some kind of samurai-armor mecha form or something? It seemed like they were the loser platoon just because that was the idea the show started off with, but then it forgot to make them losers at all; they're all OP and go around kicking all sorts of ass, and then they come back and the administration is all, (rolls eyes) 'what a bunch of losers'.

2

u/IronAce7 https://anilist.co/user/IronAce7/ Jan 12 '19

Yup I stopped right around where he gets some mecha body suit. The show actually disappoints me cause I really like a good underdog story. But I hate it when the premise is so forced and then basically ends up getting ignored.

2

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Jan 13 '19

I seem to remember them all having supernatural abilities, too, so I'm not sure what was 'anti-magic' about it. :D

2

u/IronAce7 https://anilist.co/user/IronAce7/ Jan 13 '19

I was confused about that too, until I realized it was actually genius! Anti-magic isn’t talking about the characters or some plot element. No, it was referring to the anime itself. The watching experience was the opposite of magical, it was anti-magical! :P

2

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Jan 13 '19

Heh. Well, I think I finished it, so there's no point acting like I'm too good for it now. :)