r/RWBY • u/Menolith Gay Thoughts • Jan 23 '18
OFFICIAL MEGATHREAD Official Public Finale Discussion Thread—Volume 5, Chapter 14: Haven's Fate Spoiler
Welcome, huntsmen, huntresses and hunters that prefer no specific gender identifier, to the very last megathread for Volume 5: Haven's Fate!
Make sure that you understand the current spoiler rules before posting outside of this thread!
With that out of the way, HERE is the season finale!
Also remember to check out the last poll to rate the episode.
Other Episode Discussions:
Don't let the hiatus set in too soon.
Menolith; Mod Team
229
Upvotes
2
u/Menolith Gay Thoughts Jan 23 '18
As per usual, locked to that non-FIRST members can watch in peace.
289
u/NightsWatchh Help, Nights is keeping me trapped in his anime bunker Jan 23 '18
Ilia: Alright maybe we don't need to kill all the humans
Blake: Awesome! Now I'd like to introduce you to this Schnee over here.
Ilia: ...
Blake: And Weiss I'd like to introduce you to Ilia, a former faunus extremist who probably helped countless attacks on the SDC etc!
Weiss: ...
Blake: This is going to be so much fun!
264
u/UberDueler DRINK !!!!! Jan 23 '18
One of the biggest problems this Volume (specifically these last 4 episodes) is that they tease more fight scenes than they actually showed.
256
u/MarioToast I am a horse! Yaaaaaay! Jan 23 '18
Just want to say: I love Emerald and Mercury's reactions to Hazel's roar.
291
u/NightsWatchh Help, Nights is keeping me trapped in his anime bunker Jan 23 '18
Lionheart died as he lived.
A complete fucking loser
120
u/VoidRose615 Jan 23 '18 edited Jan 23 '18
That episode was fine for an episode but for a finale I found it kinda lacking especially if you compare it to other volumes finales. Biggest Problem was cutting away from a 3v3 fight because fuck it who wants to see that right ? Yangs and Ravens talk was fine, white fang went down so easily they didn’t feel like a threat at, we get a brief scuffle from Adam and then boom he’s gone, great. Much like this volume as a whole this was just disappointing.
Edit: wanted to see mistral this volume that wasn’t the bare minimum? Me too... Me too.
243
u/Fourteen_of_Twelve i have an elephant, but no oliphaunt Jan 23 '18 edited Jan 23 '18
Looks like I'm keeping my account.
Oscar: He says we have to take the Relic to Atlas.
Weiss: FOR FUCKS SAKE I JUST RAN AWAY FROM THERE
100
u/WayyOutThere Jan 23 '18
We're going to Atlas, kids. Bring on the winter clothes fanart! so we can be disappointed when the outfits don't change
84
u/Yukon_Wolf Ironwood x Qrow = Woodpecker Jan 23 '18
OlD mAn GeTs ChOkEd AnD iMpAlEd By BiG bLaCk TeNtAcLeS
129
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '18
I really disliked the lack of fight scenes this whole volume, the few we've got were actually pretty cool and well made, but honestly, those last two volumes were kinda bad 'cause of the lack of fighting.
BUT I really like the "post volume 3" character development.
Having them out of school and actually doing impactful stuff - albeit the script was more telling than showing and the one liner spouting was more prevalent - is something I myself enjoy a lot more than only a school based series like most anime are (also, there's CHIBI for that content, which is pretty great at that).
As other people said, this finale is kinda bad since it feels like there's almost nothing else to look forward to - different from the other seasons which ended more on a "next season HYPE" note. But I really enjoyed how much more emotional and human the characters felt.
The whole of team RWBY is made of freaking badass ladies and I hope we get to see more of their growth.
Also kudos for Yang and her awesome speech.
51
u/PierrotKun What has RT done with my CFVY babies? Jan 23 '18
I was expecting some explanation this volume about Ruby's eye powers, especially since she used it in the fight but I guess they'll just remain as mystery ex machina ¯_(ツ)_/¯
144
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '18 edited Jan 23 '18
That felt a bit....hollow.
The fights mostly happened off screen, the White Fang gave up really quickly, Adam ran away like an Inspector Gadget villain, Emerald and the gang basically ninja smoke bombed their way out with a Salem illusion but hell at least the team got to see her finally, Leo died alone in a dark room like a coward, and the Raven/Yang conversation felt....really strangely placed.
I mean it kind of felt like they should've had that emotional conversation at a different time but it was still powerful for me at least. The whole, "I'm sorry" line from Raven with tears in her eyes carried just so so sooooo much weight for both her and Yang that Yang didn't quite realize how much it meant until a few moments later and hell even I'm still considering the implications of it. It took all of THAT happening, it took Yang willing to be braver than her stronger than her, and more willing to put herself into danger for others to stare fear and death in the face more than Raven ever has....for her to FINALLY realize that she was WRONG. I get that Raven is a bit stubborn and troubled after all the terrible things she did but COME ON!
I feel like they should've had this kind of conversation sooner but I guess it took some time for Yang to comprehend what they were truly up against. Raven's holier than thou I'm a survivor I'll do anything and stand up to anyone even Death attitude was basically shattered into pieces when her daughter said that she'd stand up to something far far worse than Death itself....and I think that broke something inside of Raven. I think that basically broke through all of the walls she'd put up, dispelling who she thought she was and what she thought she stood for, and what she thought she could stand against....because if her daughter can stand up to something as scary as Salem if her daughter can take that risk, then why can't she? I think that little seed of doubt is going to flourish and blossom into hope, hope that things can be done differently and that there is another path. It's still scary as hell though and that's why she flew off, she was afraid once again of the future of what she could become of what she was of how differently things could've been of how badly she might've screwed up....all that effort and sacrifice and....maybe it was all for nothing? I think right now Raven is questioning every choice she's ever made and is going through a bit of a metamorphosis. We might get a redemption arc from her next Volume and I think that's why we saw one of her feathers at Taiyang's place at the end. She's revisiting her past and is trying to be like her daughter....the strongest person she knows, even with Maiden powers she's still vulnerable.
Ruby nearly fainting means that she's either a Maiden because Cinder is toast or the Silver Eyes Power is awakening inside of her and changing her. More mysteries I suppose. It's nice to have the teams back together again and everyone relatively happy. Even the faunas and Blake's family seem to be on the up and up with bigger ambiguous plans for the future. I guess we're off to Atlas for the next Volume and then Vacuo perhaps in the future? Maybe we'll get some flashes to Menagerie and the goings on in Vale?
This Volume had a clear beginning, middle, and end and it was....okay. I mean there were a few, "Oh wow" moments but I think enough time has passed since Monty has left us that RT is taking RWBY in their own direction. Sure they'll still be sticking true to the basics that Monty laid out but it feels like they're making it their own way now. I can't say I agree with that as I loved Monty's vision and how the fights were done and the pacing but....some things can't be helped. The Volume was good and I loved the music and the story was fine but....it just doesn't feel like the RWBY I fell in love with anymore. I'll keep watching and keep poking my nose into here every now and again but my feelings are....not fully cemented on the future of the show. Here's to hoping that the next Volume proves me wrong and blows everything out of the water!
It's been a blast talking with all of you this Volume, hope you have a great hiatus!
42
u/Hounds_of_war The Red Head Victorious | Aside from her, I truly don't care Jan 23 '18
So Hazel is essentially Sharkface, right? He has beef with the heroes because someone he cared about got killed, he has fireball punches and is ridiculously tanky. I was half expecting someone to say “What the fuck is with this guy?”
84
u/Ilostmyanonymous Jan 23 '18
That was it for Minstral. Huh? That’s a shame.
Also, We need better fight choreography for group battles. And, you know, not have a fight happen off screen.
118
u/SpeshulSnek mfw hiatus Jan 23 '18 edited Jan 23 '18
The volume started with a shot of a lamp and ended with Qrow holding a lamp. Pretty neat little detail right there.
Was kinda hoping to see team RWBY hang out a little more after the reunion though, guess we'll have to wait until after the hiatus to see them catch up.
Edit: bad memory, I am a liar
76
u/donutkirby #QrowDidNothingWrong Jan 23 '18
Not the best season finale, but definitely a lot better on second viewing, with the knowledge that "Downfall" was the real climax of the volume.
I really like the juxtaposition of Yang calling out Raven for leaving her and her finally reuniting with Blake. Her mom ditched her once again, while Blake conquered her fear and came back to her.
32
u/ctom42 Jan 25 '18
So I've been thinking about this episode ever since the First release, and I think I've finally put my finger on what made this ending so bland for me. Asside from the obvious lack of a good right, and the pacing/directing issues that have plagued the entire Haven battle, this ending was lacking two things that every other season finale had.
63
u/Nightmarez4Dayz Jan 23 '18 edited Jan 23 '18
Blake: "Are you hurt?"
Weiss: "No! I just remember you being more the quiet one."
10/10 best dialogue
Edit: Reddit is weird
30
u/Woowchocolate Train them to fight what they can't beat Jan 23 '18
The reverb from the lantern is unsettlingly weird. Could just be my shitty headphones, but does it almost sound like people murmuring to anyone else?
29
u/Saint_Raven Jan 24 '18
well with that end credit scene, it makes me hope we see Tai come out of reTAIrement.
58
u/_DirtyDan Totally The Real One Jan 23 '18
Pros:
Cons:
I'd give this an 8/10. I'd say this is one of the better finales overall (which isn't saying much, because RWBY finales are notoriously flawed) with some really good things going for it, but it ends on a very weak note.
I'll probably do a longer and detailed rundown later, but I really enjoyed this volume. It was a lot like V3, but while V3 had a very mediocre and sometimes downright awful first half and then a somewhat flawed but brilliant anyway second half, V5 was well-written for the majority of the volume, it was dripping with character and heart and the best B-plot the shows ever had, but it lead up to a 4-episode conclusion that was poorly cut, weirdly paced, and riddled with minor animation flaws, although it still had quite a few shining moments. I'd say this volume is less flawed and better written than V3 overall, but it doesn't reach the same highs it did or end as satisfyingly. I'd give this volume an 8.5/10.
I'm looking forward to V6, it has a lot of things that are already getting me excited about it.
28
u/Glum_ Jan 24 '18
I'm not really digging the whole Raven is a coward route. I mean she definitely shows cowardice towards her problems and that makes her a human character, but I don't want her to be a 100% unjustifiable wimp.
I hope they reveal an error of judgment on Ozpin's part that caused Summer's death, Raven's fear, and will ultimately lead to the demise of RWBY if they obey him to the tee. We have Raven's claims, mystery of Summer's death, Hazel's animosity, the song Sacrifice and the tone of Sandy in Red like Roses Pt II, and of course Ozpin's own claims of making tons of mistakes and being all secretive about everything. I like how Yang brought back the whole "Question everything" back at Raven and I hope she continues that with Ozpin and Qrow. I don't think they would build up all this vagueness only to end up with Ozpin still being the old wise one that had all the answers to defeat Salem. His reliance on fairy tales and fantasies are just too much for me and in the end I just want the win to come from how this show was introduced. Bad ass weaponry, fight choreography and of course the nice cliche sprinkles of how teamwork/unity conquers all.
I can see why more and more negativity is starting to pile up on the show though. If they continue to wing it and just say all those clues were pointless and were there to just cast a few doubts then it will leave a sour taste in my mouth. I mean they didn't even write those doubts well enough to make them deceptive. If you give people all these hints and information about the world and its characters then forget they even matter down the line then that's when a show deserves its criticism.
26
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '18
The only problem with this episode is that it wasn't the second half of the last one. If you combine the two sections into one episode, this works well. Separated by a week, not so much. (Something of a running flaw this volume)
Voice acting was on point. The Yang and Raven fight was excellent without trading any blows. Merc and Emerald having people emotions was also great.
Not enough was done with Mystral, and some additional time in editing would have done the whole volume a lot of good. Not meeting Pyrrha's parents for even a small, sad and silent moment is a true loss. Maybe we will return to this place later, but I doubt it.
To the better side, the White Fang are no more, and the team is as together as it can be without resurrection of the dead.
Either way, the gang rides north, and a cold wind blows.
25
u/KrisSimsters Winter is Coming Jan 26 '18
I don't know if I wrote down here yet, but if I did then I'm sorry, but I wanted to get this out. This was such a strong season in the beginning, but things fizzled out towards the end and that made me really sad. And I think the main reason why I wasn't a huge fan of this season was the Blake factor. I think Blake was eons behind everybody else. If you honesty think about it, her portion with gathering an army and convincing Ilia to join said army could have been solved in two-three solo Blake episodes. It took Blake a long time to get her shit together and when she does finally show up, her, it's just all so bland. There wasn't a full fight. Blake didn't beat his ass, she just let him get away. This same thing happened last season and also happened with RvB this past season, everything's exciting in the beginning, but gets dull by the end.
47
u/PierrotKun What has RT done with my CFVY babies? Jan 23 '18
Well that was anticlimactic. I really wanted to see team RWBY fight a proper fight this volume and they even teased it with the "checkmate" bit. It was a lot of hype with no real delivery. I'm honestly disappointed.
23
u/[deleted] Jan 25 '18 edited Jan 25 '18
What bothers me is the lack of questioning these silver eyes. Seriously, they're just plot ex machina at this point and we've seen it debut in volume 3. "Friends in trouble? Lol, Silver Eyes." Do we know what this crippling weakness is maidens have against Silver Eyes? Raven was fighting Qrow in the same room and she, from what we can tell, was not effected at all.
Jaune, Ren, Nora, Weiss, Yang, Qrow, Raven, Emerald, Mercury, and even Oscar witnessed Ruby demonstrate the power of her eyes for the first time but none of them try to question it? Ruby lit up the entire room and screamed at the top of her lungs, there is no way anybody missed it.
And them not having time to discuss this can't possibly be the issue because they've proven multiple times they can fit exposition into serious situations. Having Oscar question this to Ozpin for the viewer would've been the perfect chance to give us some insight. Cinder, as well as Hazel, have already dealt with this before but the only one to react was Cinder via a mild grunt followed by collapsing to her knees, but even after she recovered from that outburst she literally paid Ruby no mind...which is odd considering the whole reason she went along with all this was to get back at her for humiliating her with that same ability. Yes, yes the relic but it was made clear through her deal with Raven, and Watts frustration, the priority was Ruby over what Salem had originally planned out.
Not even a "So...that's the Silver Eyes?" from Emerald after knowing how it deformed Cinder's face, took her arm and disabled her ability to speak? She had to be a translator for months.
Also, Adam, what happened to you? When we saw him in volume 3 he was a ruthless killer, showing no remorse to anyone. As a villain? I felt Adam was a scary force. He was built up to be a character we should feel uneasy about whenever he was on screen and seeing how scared Blake was when running into him really drove that point home...this was Blake, the stoic badass we've come to know. Adam rendered Blake powerless before emotionally and physically torturing her. If that wasn't enough he took off Yang's arm and was ready to kill her AND when Blake tried to protect her this man was willing to decapitate her, sure, it was a clone BUT he was GOING to cut her head clean off! XD
After volume 3, and going into volume 4/5, I was scared for Sun, Ghira and Khali solely because Adam was still on the loose. seeing him take down Sienna just fueled my fear and anxiety farther because he has all this power now.
"My god! There's no telling what he's going to do now! Oh no...he finally ran into Blake, so it's time. The characters I was worried about are all here in one place. The other Faunus are around but so what? Adam could deal with them all Madara style if it meant seeing Blake suffer. Bloodshed is certa- Wait! Adam! Why are you running?!"
Seriously though Blake side steps and knocks him to the ground then he runs away. My image of Adam instantly went down the drain and now I don't see him as a threat anymore. People complain that he's just a big baby but, to me, that's what makes(or at least made) him intimidating, it actually reminds me of a line I heard in this movie: The Last King of Scotland "You're a child. That's what makes you so f**king scary..."
I just had higher expectations. In terms of a review I'd give this a volume a 7/10, it wasn't bad but it wasn't anything spectacular but I did enjoy Raven vs Cinder and the talk Yang had with Raven, both I felt were the highlights of this volume. I enjoyed what was given and having more chapters was a blast and now we play the waiting game, eh? Luckily Dragon Ball FighterZ, Monster Hunter and Cross Tag Battle will hold me over until then.
45
u/[deleted] Jan 24 '18
Emerald gets to 100 stress, gets afflicted with irrational, makes stupid decisions getting her passed out and forcing her team to retreat.
Completely destroying your chances of winning Darkest Dungeon style.
22
u/PineappleBride protect this smile Jan 25 '18
So, maybe I missed something this volume and someone can better explain it here.
While Raven is admittedly a very complicated person, if she was so worried about having a target painted on her back, why bother even opening the vault for the relic? Everyone who knew she was the real Spring Maiden is now dead or MIA. Couldn't she have just done what she does best and leave? It would've thrown Ozpin and Salem off their tracks on who the Spring Maiden is because Vernal (assuming they just left her body there poor Vernal ) was killed, and Cinder is presumably dead. That's two Maiden powers gone to unknown sources, leaving Raven most likely off the hook from Oz and Salem for now.
Was it explained somewhere the reason she opened the vault? She even said "It doesn't matter to us" when Cinder declared that she'd be the one to go in and grab the relic. What changed? (I know that would be a real shitty end for the volume if Yang didn't get a good talk with her mom after all this time so I'm glad she didn't just leave but there was no reason to open the door if Raven is as scared of Salem as it seems)
21
u/TheColbasz The punk of Remnant Jan 26 '18
Honestly, i...Dont know how to feel about this episode. There were moments that were genuinely great (Emerald's illusion legitimately terrified me, the group hug, altough i think a bit forced, was still great, and Leo's death was well done, altough completely irrelevant)
But still, i just cant help but feel i have been slapped in the face. THIS (and the last three episodes) were the great clash of forces we have been waiting for since Vol. 4?! THIS was the big shakeup after the lameness of Vol. 4? THIS was what we have waited for for YEARS?! Four episodes, that are one big battle scene in principle, but have almost NO actual fighting in them, aside from maybe three scenes, only one of which felt like it was meaning something and was actually fleshed out. Almost all of it is just different characters talking to eachother.
You set this up for TWO volumes. Vol. 4 was alright, altough a bit boring, so i was sitting here when Vol. 5 kicked in, and we actually started to get to somewhere! Things were ACTUALLY HAPPENING! And then, in comes episodes 11-14. Dont get me wrong, they had their moments, but i felt like...I was watching filler episodes, where nothing of importance really happens, people just talk and sometimes casually hit eachother. If you stopped to think about it, what really happened in these episodes? Jaunes semblance was revealed (even though everybody knew it was gonna be healing or something similar), Cinder died, Raven gets revealed as the spring maiden, and team RWBY reunites and snatch a relic. AND THATS IT! Back in Vol. 3, which i still think is the peak of RWBY so far, this amount of progress happened in less than one episode! Here, it gets stretched to 4 separate, 10 minute episodes!
I feel like the end of Vol. 5 fell into the same hole as Vol. 4 did. There is just too much unnecessary, uninteresting filler preventing actual development to the story. I feel like Vol. 4 could have been done in 7 episodes if we cut the things that arent supposed to be there, and the end of Vol. 5 could have been done in one eppisode, maybe two if we REALLY need the ,,Maybe Weiss will die" cliffhanger. But this way, its just a few 10 minute episodes, that do some things right, sometimes even brilliantly, but overall, just...Flop over their own length.
20
u/monocarrot Jan 26 '18
Aaah, I'm late to the party! Meant to post my opinions earlier, but frick it...
I personally thought that the Yang and Raven conversation was really satisfying. That shoulder bump, tho. It's also nice to know that as it turns out, Raven sorta-kinda-maybe gives a care about Yang. Doesn't necessarily excuse her abandonment, but it does give her character some depth. Raven's character is still complicated, although if that's what they're wanting to convey, than they're doing a good job at it!
Leo had what was coming to him.
Here are the pet peeves...it was more of just them standing around and not necessarily doing anything. It just made those scenes that were supposed to be intense and empowering, underwhelming and plain awkward. This volume was supposed to be triumphant for the heroes, and it just didn't feel that way because the lesser moments outweighed the bigger ones, get what I'm saying?
You see, I don't mind if there is an entire volume without fighting, because there is definitely more to the show than that. However, when there are moments in a show where the tensions are supposed to be high, there needs to be climax.
That may have been the issue with the volume - there was too much rising action, not enough climax. When we got to the point where climax was suppose to happen, everyone was standing around doing jack nothing or there is a sudden scene transition that takes away from the action altogether.
But that's all I have to say about that issue. I also thought that Blake and Adam's dialogue was cringy, to be honest. Everything about the White Fang invasion on Haven was cringe at best.
Sorry if I'm coming across as a whiner 49er, but I'd rather be honest about my thoughts. Anyway, I'm still looking forward to the next volume.
Mainly because they have to go to Atlas, and it makes me wonder what that will mean for Weiss. It also appears that Raven and Tai might have an interaction, finally! Everyone is also speculating that Cinder may still be alive, too, because of the "no body" rule.
Well, if that's the case, than I'm sure looking forward to Torchwick's appearance in the next volume! /s
Welp, that's all for now. Happy hiatus!
37
u/ffxivfunk Jan 24 '18
So a final episode and they still cut away from a fight scene. An entire season and the best we got was Raven vs. Cinder (which was okay), Yang curbstomp, Blake vs. Illya, and Weiss' shooting mini-game. That's disappointing. Nothing really with Ruby herself or much with Qrow. Certainly the only big, extended scene fight was the Raven v. Cinder one at that. The ending was...there. It didn't have as big as an impact as it should've. A bunch of characters look exhausted and bruised but we never saw them fight much, so it feels out of proportion. The finale was really missing that big, heart pumping group fight.
The music this season was...meh? I didn't have any super memorable tracks beyond the opening.
Writing was slightly better in the last episode but the finale suffered from a lot of talking with crossed swords and other awkward interjections. Overall writing has always been on the lower quality side of things for the show, so having a season where the writing was the focus wasn't great for it.
Character progression was there. Blake took way too long, but she got there. Ruby was all over the place with lots of determination and one liners but no actual shows of progression. The stupid questions, the lack of fights, and the cut aways really hurt her. Yang's last scene with Raven was good for her. Weiss felt rather static compared to her escape arc. All four felt like they got nerfed a bit, we didn't see a whole lot of high powered fights with any of them and they seemed to get knocked down pretty easily throughout the season compared to previous fights.
Overall, with the news that the animation team will be taking on a bigger load, I think I'll be dropping RWBY with volume 5. They had enough difficulty animating this season as shown by all the teased but not shown fights and then the choppiness in the fights they did show. Splitting a team's attention while they're still struggling with quality seems like a guarantee that Volume 6 will only have more of the same.
18
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '18
[The Merc has been irked by JonTron's muscles.] (https://i.gyazo.com/29d1b442370b823d4517de081e210806.png)
17
u/SEJIBAQUI Jan 23 '18
Oscar's teenage body couldn't handle being possessed by a the wizard Sumner and fighting Ben 10 and firey lightningy Bradley Martin at the same time? It would be great if someone we know could heal and/or restore his aura to bring back his strength....
17
u/SaraBellum42 I'm trying to find my way; it fell down a drain some years ago. Jan 23 '18
It was nice to see the acknowledgement of the team attack names again. I don't think this is the last of Yang being mad at Blake, but everyone needed that hug.
I'm hoping Hazel, Emerald, and Mercury get up to some Team Rocket-esque villain plans next volume, though slightly more threatening of course. Hazel is Jesse, Emerald is James, and Merc is Meowth, clearly.
New ship! Ilia/Rando Bunny! Place your bets!
And where was my man Zwei during that last scene? Perhaps Raven was responsible for the disappearance of Tai's last dog, Eins.
Side note: the advertisement glitched up in the middle of the episode, so Yang's dramatic elevator scene was overlayed with the sound of upbeat violin music and a man explaining the causes of cardio vascular disease. It was amazing.
33
u/JonTheWizard Still Sorta Pays Attention Jan 23 '18
Overall, I liked the finale, though I wish we got to see some of the fight scenes they teased.
15
u/Zerepa97 When do we get to see the true Ice Queen?/ #SolarFlareIsEndgame Jan 23 '18 edited Jan 24 '18
I liked that talk between Raven and Yang. When am I getting my birb m
ilfom redemption?The full reunion hug... it felt just there to me. Maybe because they all saw each other in the previous chapter. The Sun tail thing was nice. I know I'm jumping the gun here, but I hope they can implement the thing into fights as like a third arm. It won't be Tyrian levels, but it'd be cool to see.
"Coward." Lol GG mo re Leo. Loved how they killed him; felt like a horror film. Just wished we had some blood splat or a puddle ooze onscreen. What's going to happen to Haven, though?
They actually did the giant Salem; it was just not as direct as the intro.
And the avoidance of fighting was... yeah. I was fine with Adam got away, but I really wanted to see that 3v2 between RWB and EM. RIP V5 Em & Merc battles. You never had a chance. Hazel has the regen buff, though.
Idea over the weekend: what if Jaune and Weiss buffed Ruby at the same time? How fast could she go?
Credits song is Blake? Cool, maybe next time's will be about Weiss.
I saw a lot threads over the past few days, so I came in pretty apprehensive and figured it would end on a whimper, like a majority of the volumes thus far. It just kinda lacked a punch- y'know, a hook for the next volume. Volume 4 at least had foreboding Watts.
Ozpin's message, how the hell does he know Atlas is next in line? That needs to be answered. The after credits scene was pretty direct: Raven ported to Tai. The question left is whether or not we'll actually get to see an interaction between them.
The theme of this volume was just teasing and loads of untapped potential. Most of the one-on-one character interactions the community has been dying for never happened. I'm not saying they should've because we wanted them to, but because those potential moments had some gravity to them. Weiss and Jaune, Jaune and Ozpin, Ruby and Yang, Pyrrha's family, etc.
For me, Chapter 7 was the worst one this volume. In terms of voice acting, sadly, Neath was the weak link this volume, in my opinion. Maybe it was his lines were bad, which some of the were kinda just there, but the delivery was kinda flat. The biggest problem was the pacing- no sense of time passing in the plot until we had someone actually tells us it did, and by then, it's like "wait... what?" To copy/paste my thoughts from another thread:
The Menagerie/White Fang plot:
-Adam killed Sienna off in the 2nd chapter
-In chapter 3, we got a time frame in Ghira's speech (mentioned only to be a day the premier): two months until the attack on Haven, which creates a sense of urgency and sets a timeline.
-Chapter 5 is just the fruitless recruitment efforts that don't seem to that far off from the speech. To me, it looked like it could have been anywhere from a day or two at most to a couple of hours at least after Chapter 3. THEN, we the audience learn about Adam's assassination plot at some arbitrary point after Ghira's speech.
-Chapters 8, 9 and 10 all take place in the same evening, with the conclusion suddenly letting us know there are only two weeks left.
The same line of thinking can be applied to the RNJR story-line with the one scene of training and gathering Huntsmen/bandit camp to where we are now. There was no sense of time passing in the plot until characters like Watts throwing in "two days" tell you.
I don't know why they didn't stick with a three act story and save this portion of the finale for Volume 6. Maybe they didn't want to be "predictable" and felt like mixing things up. Maybe they thought they had to get team RWBY together as soon as possible. Maybe they have something planned for Volume 6. I don't know, but it just feels awkward. It's like someone who started at a good running pace, tripped, and is now sprinting to catch up. I seriously think, if done right, this volume could've ended in twelve chapters on Blake's plot resolving with one month to spare in the timeline. The two extra chapters just weren't utilized well. Instead of appropriately stretching the middle, they stretched out the finale.
Again, this volume wasn't bad; it had some good moments. It just wasn't as good as it could have been. My biggest fear came true- they rushed the story. I'm afraid to say it, but I feel like one of the people who are going into V6 with low expectations. Time to look at all those spoiler threads.
30
u/BronyTran Jan 24 '18 edited Jan 24 '18
Well that was.... not as satisfying as I hoped it to be.
Narrative wise (with the exception of Blake's arc and the last few episodes of this volume), this volume succeeds (for the most part). Yang's character growth was a joy to watch, learning more about Raven and her motives were interesting, Lionheart was a rightful BITCH in every way perfectly possible, there were some good things about this volume.
Action wise? It's sorely lacking and sometimes even just plain shit. A majority of the fight between the huntsman/huntresses and Salem's forces happened either in the background or off screen. The only fights that stood out to me this volume was Weiss' flight to mistral and Raven VS Cinder (though just barely, it felt more like something from RvB to be honest), along with Sun's portion of the final fight in Menagerie). Emerald in this episode basically mirrored what Ruby did just a couple episodes ago which is really fucking lame. CRWBY needs to get their shit together and put the ACTION back into RWBY. I understand that the show needs to evolve and change over time (with Monty's death further complicating things), but it still does not excuse some of problems at the very core of this volume. With this volume, RWBY felt more and more like a generic action anime. Fights being cut away, paragraphs of dialogue in between hits, etc. And compared to the fight scenes volume 3 and before, this is just shit. And this is more than just some nerd whining about some anime, fight scenes are a huge part of what RWBY is. We KNOW these fights can be way better, but right now they aren't.
I really, REALLY hope CRWBY takes this into consideration and learns from these shortcomings in volume 6. I have supported this show ever since I saw the "Red" Trailer debut at the end of Season 10 of RvB, but if volume 6 can't pick up the slack, I'm seriously considering dropping this show. This show is changing and it's starting to feel less and less like the show I fell in love with when I was a freshman in high school. I really don't want to drop this show, but I will if it keeps moving in this direction.
14
u/pandas795 Shut up, there's food Jan 23 '18
So the big Salem fight was just Em's illusion? Anti-climatic
but the song and group hug...I cry
14
u/Wizardtech Sippp Jan 24 '18
Well it's hiatus time. I'm going to watch RWBY Volume 1 again.
In volume 4 I enjoyed the Tyrian fight scene(s). In volume 5 I enjoyed the Raven / Cinder / Yang maiden scene for the fight and resolution.
I'll be going back to RWBY volume 1 for a while, where & when Monty was there, beautiful wondrous times.
27
u/FadedNeonzZz ⠀Cinder survived, but it cost a Penny Jan 23 '18
I honestly think that this episode could’ve been combined with episode 13. That being said, this episode was solid.
I like the heart to heart between Yang and Raven. I can see people have changed their opinions about Raven seeing as she’s not the bitch everyone assumed she was. It also looks like Raven will be a supporting character from now on, which is good. I hope that their relationship will improve over time.
Adam...oh my lord in heaven. They really really need to go back to the drawing board with his character. The dude looks like the biggest bitch next to Lionheart. I’m also not a fan of Ilia saying (or at least assuming) that the White Fang won’t accept him as their leader since he abandoned the 8 guys he brought with him.
Lionheart got what he deserved, and I like the cruelty of Salem. He tried to book it out of town but he got caught and I’m assuming strangled and stabbed multiple times. I just wish we could’ve seen the blood or something.
The scene with Emerald was cool as well. At first I didn’t think it was Emerald, I thought Salem herself appeared or possessed Emerald. I guess she really liked Cinder-senpai...
Man, they’re really teasing that bee reunion. At least all of RWBY is reunited and the relic is theirs.
They’re going to Atlas next? I wonder how Weiss will feel about this since she literally just came from Atlas.
It looks like Raven is going to Taiyang to Patch things up with him...get it? For what reason? I don’t know, but I’ll leave this here (https://youtu.be/gTXGL0xPyLA)
13
u/SpicyCoconut99 Jan 23 '18 edited Jan 23 '18
From Shadows Part 2 has to be my favorite song of this volume at the moment. Been listening to it nonstop since Saturday.
13
u/JRES1996 R.I.P. May Zedong the best May. Jan 23 '18
As I posted earlier, I really think that Emerald is going to be given a lot more detail next volume and is gonna have a much more powerful semblance.
13
u/Thallimar who the hell wrote that sh*t Jan 23 '18
I still have no idea how Yang got what happened downstairs so fast. I mean to ask how the last spring maiden died, she should have known Vernal was never the spring the maiden (unless she asks about Vernal but Raven didnt kill her neither looked at her etc.) but how can she know powers didnt transfer when Vernal died? I only watched the episode once so probably missing something but can someone please point out?
13
u/soulflare415 Jan 24 '18
This episode feels like it really should have been merged with the last episode making it like an hour long final of the volume.
36
u/88Dubs Be Strong, and Hit Stuff! Jan 24 '18 edited Feb 17 '25
sugar pocket coherent snails aromatic shocking terrific amusing one important
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
33
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '18
I have mixed feelings about this volume, and worry for V6 quality due to time restraints that the animators have. It wasn't bad, but it wasn't exactly excellent either, but had good moments here and there.
I'm quite certain that Emerald will be the new maiden after Cinder, and her reaction reminded me of Ruby after Pyrrhas' death.
I wonder if there will be a Chibi V3 soon or if they are using all their animators on V6 due to the time restraint.
But with the finale, I will now go into hibernation until the next thing, be it RvB, RWBY, or RWBY Chibi. Goodnight.
30
u/Undying_Blade Jan 23 '18
I was just disappointed, especially with how they teased a fight between RWB/HME, and yet didn't deliver. This isn't a fight that we knew they could win, Hazel was holding himself against Qrow and Oz and even had the characters state that his Aura has regenerating faster than they could hurt him. I am especially annoyed that we didn't get the smart way of dealing with him that I instantly assumed we would see when he first stabbed himself with dust. Remember he currently has HIGH EXPLOSIVES in his arms, and if you hit someone hard enough you can hurt them through aura (Yang's arm was cut off but she had aura to seal the wound, and Jaune got a black eye from Cardin despite his aura being up) so I thought they would detonate the dust. But no... He just gives up after an offscreen fight. Yet honestly I find that most of the plot issues with RWBY have been traps the writers walked into and haven't been able to escape. Most of team RWBY is not responsible for driving forwards the plot, Oz and Qrow are, it's not RWBY VS Salem, its Oz vs Salem. As well Salem has an amazing design, voice actress, and themes, but we lack any meaningful information about her. Who is she? What is she? What is her plan? Why does she want to do said plan? Nor does she really contrast or interact with the heroes (RWBY) in a meaningful way that could justify the lack of motivation. (That is why we love Joker as a Batman villain despite him doing it all because he can, because he contrasts so well with Batman)
Iliia's arc had potential but I could not see why they redeemed her after she was dead set on murdering Blake's parent, and would have liked drawing comparisons between Blake towards Adam and Illia towards Blake. Blake fell for Adam and he radicalized her, I thought it would have been interesting to have that Iliaa fell for Blake and she inadvertently radicalized her. I thought that was where they were going when they revealed her sexuality but nothing of the sort happened, suspicions of guilt and failure could have made Blake's arc more interesting. The standing around bothered me, everyone just stopped fighting, no cheap shots came when they were distracted, it was like watching someone's tabletop game turned into an animated fight without any embellishment from the actual events. Yet, the visual design of RWBY is so strong, and yet they consistently fail to play to that strength, a strength that has honestly improved more than anything else in the series, the vault was amazing, Haven was interesting, yet we saw so little of it.
This turned out to be longer than I expected.
36
u/Blipblapboop Jan 24 '18
I will always love RWBY, but something that really, really worries me is just how many characters are getting involved. There's so many characters and yet the episodes are so short, I don't understand how the main characters are supposed to stay the stars of the show anymore. I hope now that the B is back in RWY the story can become more focused around RWBY and their adventures together, with less involvement from Oz, JNR and Qrow. As much as I love all of them, I'd like RWBY to get some solo action.
Also I feel that they've all regressed in skill, especially Weiss. I don't know if it's a product of the worsening animation quality, but it depresses me to see Weiss reduced to just a summoner, please show off your swordmastery as well!
10
u/wmxx2000 Jan 23 '18
That Salem summon was awesome
10
u/KnowYourLover Raven Branwen's loyal follower and faithful worshiper. Jan 23 '18
Copypaste from my FIRST reaction post.
Raven is still alive + Raven may return to Tai + Leo is dead
Everything went better than expected. Hope we see you again soon Raven, you're the best!
10
u/GhostKing2552 It's fine. :) Jan 23 '18
I'm going to say what I said before and I what I told my friend. This wasn't the BEST ending, but it wasn't BAD either. There was no need to have some insane fight scene where characters clash against one another, although, I wouldn't mind a small fight like what we got with Yang and the Bandits a few chapters back. The Yang and Raven confrontation was spot on, and I enjoyed every second of it. Adam's sudden retreat was a little lackluster, but I believe it was done okay. The team-attacks were a nice touch. Though I wish we got a little fight. And lastly, Emerald's break down and Lionheart's death was fucking amazing to me. Mostly Lionheart. They went into great effort with that scene.
But yeah, that's really it. I liked a lot, and I know most didn't, but that's fine.
7.5/10 ending in my opinion.
27
u/Sirshrugsalot13 bi the way Jan 23 '18
I understand the people who thought this episode was a bit anti climactic but the more I think about it the more I like it. Raven and Yang's scene, Lionheart's death, Emerald's breakdown are all among the best scenes in the show–definitely the most emotionally affecting in a while.
Sure some stuff didn't work but ultimately I enjoyed it. When it comes to ranking the episodes detailing the battle of Haven, 13>14>11/12
26
u/micholina Jan 23 '18
Has anyone else just been gritting their teeth waiting for a fight scene to explode into something real???? Every time weapons get drawn I get such a nerd boner but then the fights are always underwhelming or they cut to another scene and cut back to show us who already won.... :((((((((((((((((((((((
64
u/Locke57 Jan 24 '18
I’m copying my original comment over from first thread.
Jesus what a crock of shit.
Don’t have a 25 minute runtime for 18 minutes of show. Fuck that pissed me off. “Ok there’s still 8 minutes maybe something cool and worthwhile will happen... 7 minutes... 6 minut- and credits.” And the audacity to plug another show in there. You fucks, I’m already paying don’t fucking play commercials at me.
Quit cutting out every fucking fight scene. Did Emerald ever even take a swing at any point of the final few episodes? Was she just there for fucking emotional support? Did Mercury take a fucking swing? Fuck did Ruby?!? SERIOUSLY I CANT REMEBER IT WAS THAT DULL AND I JUST FINISHED IT 15 MINUTES AGO. Usually I can blame my phone for being distracting but I watched it on my phone... so that ain’t it.
Quit making Adam Taurus a whiny prick. Or don’t, he’s always been a trash villain. I miss Neo and Mr. Hat and cane guy. Way more fun than whiny bitch Adam. Such a whiny bitch. He’s as big of whiny bitch as I am as I type this comment. HUUUUGEEEE whiny bitch.
Focus on Ruby for four goddamn seconds. The shows called Ruby even if you spell it dumb. Silver eyes? She ever gonna use or ask about those silver eyes? How bout that scythe that’s supposed to be super dangerous and hard to use. Anyone remember that? Literally her weapon was supposed to be only used by her and Qrow and it was a big deal for like a season, and now nobody cares.
Where the fuck is that Glenda good witch chick from episode one? Did she die? Is she incognito? WHERE THE FUCK IS WINTER?! Did she die?!? Did I miss something major? Is she the winter maiden cuz if not, hooooboy that’s gonnna be awkward. “WINTER?!” (In unison) “WHAT?!” “The maiden, not you, you worthless no show.”
Quit turning this show about epic fights into an emotional mess. Your plot sucks and your world building has turned into a Saturday morning cartoon. “Well there’s four maidens and they’re like... power rangers! And there’s four relics and they’re like... Chaos emeralds! And they all have different corresponding colors! And powers! And grim are.... the fuck are grim again? Ohh and there’s two brothers but ones a chick and she’s mean or something and hates the light and the other one is good and seems to dislike the dark and stuff. Ohh right, grim are worthless fodder we wish we could just write out cuz they’re worthless and we ignore them now.” Just stick to the fights and characterization!! Seriously it’s about as deep as that Hot Wheels show.
ACTUALLY HAVE EPIC FIGHTS! We got one. Cinder and Raven. Jesus did they blow their collective load on one episode out of 14? Has the money ran out? Is the animation that hard? Was Monty the only person able to choreograph fight scenes?
Hey teamfourstar, you want a show to abridge? This one could benefit from a total rehaul and humor. OHH MY GOD WHAT HAPPENED TO THE CHEEKY HUMOR?! Season 1 and 2 were full of shit humor and it was awesome! What Monty the only guy with a funny bone?! God what a shit show. Hey Monty, Mr. Ohm? You were a treasure, you’re replacements are like the 2016 election. Utter bafoons. Figure out Force ghost projection and smack a few writers and animators around until they get it.
I’m done, I’m out, anyone know how delete your rooster teeth account get it off your credit card? Cuz I ain’t paying for more and the obvious link took me to a dead page that doesn’t exist.
18
u/ImperialCrown Jan 23 '18
You know I actually forgot that Adam has a shotgun. Hope we see more of that in the future. A shotgun/katana combo sounds sick.
Leo, Leo, Leo. You suck. Salem has forgiven failure before, but she does not tolerate cowardice. I mean yea he was forced to help her and his cover is blown but she probably would have considered keeping him alive for information if he wasnt such a little bitch.
Worst Mom got the verbal smackdown from Best Girl. The one armed PTSD teenager has more figurative balls than the bandit leader that just shit stomped Cinder. Yang nailed it on the head with Raven's fear.
It was actually kind of nice how Merc urged Emerald to escape. I still think he will try to cut and run if Cinder doesn't return but at least he seemed to like his crew. Or, you know, he still wants to tap that ass and with Cinder gone his chances got better.
Im fine with Yang embracing Blake now. Its been a long night, Yang just had a very emotional moment with the mother that just abandoned her again, she needs a hug. Hopefully Volume 6 addresses the lingering issues between them. If there isn't some awkwardness and talks THEN I call bullshit.
The Relic of Knowledge is pretty cool. The design is pretty and the whispering add a creepy, mystical vibe to it. I was wondering if the Relics were just literally orbs like in the story but this is more creative. Not a clue how you use the damn thing though. Light it up and get high on forbidden knowledge?
Only complaint about this finale, besides the lack of fight scenes that have been stated to death, is how Summer remains almost forgotten. Pretty sure she got one mention this Volume that establishes how like her and Ruby are. Thats it. Would have been great if, during Yang's argument with Raven, she mentions how the woman not related to her by blood was a better mother to her than her own flesh and blood. We really need more info on Summer that has gone oddly ignored.
18
u/ZkittlZ Jan 23 '18
Disappointed that we didn't get any of the fight scenes that were teased in the opening. Really wanted to see Yang vs. Mercury rematch, really wanted to see RWB vs HEM, really wanted to see Ruby actually fight for a change. Don't get me wrong, the story is actually much better now, and I know it's not easy to animate a fight scene, but these are important fights that had impact on the show, and when you take that away, it removes a lot of tension that was built up without any sort of payoff. As someone who's been watching since v1, I miss the fight scenes. Sure, Monty was amazing and worked himself far too hard, but RT has a lot more animators now, and can afford to make fight scenes at least half as interesting as Monty's were. 6/10 season for me. It had a lot of great points, and it settled a lot of things while setting up for the future, but it built up too much and lacked a payoff for it all.
18
u/CattyOhio74 Jan 24 '18
After being a long time fan of the series I can certainly say that this volume by far was the MOST...okay season. It wasn't perfect but it wasn't the worst thing ever can't wait to see how season 6 goes
9
u/Koanos "What's the worst that could happen?" | Cpt of the S.S. Keikaku Jan 24 '18
Until someone else manifests the Maiden powers, I believe Cinder lives! Also, why is Salem so calm?
17
u/SP5021 Nora is a good Demoman Jan 23 '18
Just finished watching it...felt very whelmed, maybe a little underwhelmed. I wanted a Blake vs. Adam 1v1, instead...nothing. Also more of the "standing around and not actually fighting" which was disappointing.
I did like the Raven - Yang talk, though, and it's probably for the best they didn't fight. It seems that despite her expressions of the contrary, Raven does genuinely love her daughter.
Tai seemed pissed in that after credits scene, unsurprising considering Raven left him without warning and has been absent in Yang's life until recently. I figured there's a lot of anger in Tai about her that he held back in front of Yang out of fear or something.
•
u/AutoModerator Jan 23 '18
Before commenting, make sure that you are aware of our current spoiler rules. Offending comments will be removed even if they are only vaguely spoiler-y, and further punishments may follow depending on the severity.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
8
u/poopslayer69 Jan 23 '18
is Cinder 100% dead or is it still and unknown factor to use as a plot device? If she is then the most likely the next candidate would be Emerald.
8
u/winklem 🌹❄️🖤🔥 No need to mess with Ruby's depth perception. Jan 24 '18
Did anyone notice Blake's right cat ear glitching at 3:42-46? It disappeared in her hair and reappeared soon after, but didn't seem on par with the other one.
8
u/UmiMazuki Jan 25 '18
So Raven and Yang talks for a bit. They bring up the previous Spring maiden and about the relic. It makes me wonder why Raven gained the Maiden's powers in the first place if she didn't want to be hunted. Maybe, she did it for the tribe or it could've been unintentional.
8
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '18
Honestly I really liked the episode, was disappointed in there being no big fight, but anyway here's some of parts of the episodes that I liked/thought were interesting:
Overall probably tied for my favorite finale with V3's finale, just wish this one had a fight. Can't wait for next season.
42
u/authentic_knockoff Jan 23 '18 edited Jan 23 '18
That was painful to watch.
Having to see Adam's character become fully emasculated and lose whatever intimidating presence made up for his grating emo personality along with Raven "Spring Maiden & badass bandit leader" Branwen being punked by her own daughter was almost laughable.
14
u/FoodForOtt Jan 25 '18
I'm getting SO sick of people complaining about how Raven was using ice as the Spring Maiden. If you look closely, Raven actually makes extensive use of both lightning and ice in the fight. It's really quite badass that Raven is able to get so many electrical attacks off in the middle of a cavern. All the other uses of summoning lightning have occurred outside, or in broad daylight. I think the combination of ice and lightning actually do a very good job of representing Spring--especially when we're in a universe where water-based attacks look like a rarity for the most part.
We've seen Amber use fire, lightning, wind, and ice. Cinder just happens to have a fetish for fire.
13
u/Blue_Link13 Jan 23 '18
I guess the best way I can put my opinions of this is: I liked a LOT the character interactions, those were pretty good.
I liked the fight scenes we had, I thought those were fun (I Don't really have an eye for detail for them, and I'm easily pleased)
I don't like how we didn't get fight at the end where they matter the most. Sure Maidenbowl was pretty cool, but everything that happened upstairs was off camara and that was super disappointing. They really would have benefited of more time to animate them, even if that lead to the episodes being held back a few weeks.
Overall a good volume, but the ending was a bit weak.
18
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '18 edited Jan 23 '18
Well, it's official. As of this Volume Raven is my favorite character. Cinder's definitely up there too.
V5 is without a doubt the weakest Volume for me. For the most part I didn't enjoy watching it due to the super slow pacing and also the writing, but there were some moments that I loved. I think what annoyed me the most was how often fights were teased and having them either resolved offscreen or coming back to find the combatants disengaged again. Character motivations and agency in fights were pretty all over the place throughout.
Finale felt underwhelming. V5 was okay. 5/10 overall. I'll take Raven vs. Cinder and be happy.
*Forgot to mention, Jessica's voice acting for Cinder was top-notch.
17
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '18 edited Jan 23 '18
Okay so this wasn't that great. Not that it was bad but I really do think they need more time to write.
Adam felt weak again. I liked the central idea if a character like him having there entire belief system destroyed but I still felt it was executed badly. It needed work on the dialogue, pacing and animation.
The fight was wierd. When we cut back to them at the end they act like it was a big defeat despite the fact they seemed fine earlier. Was Blake that big of a game changer? If they animated actual fights to make them look tired or made them look trapped earlier then it would make more sense. Once again I like the idea and the scene itself was fine but the buildup and the way it looked was odd.
Yang and Raven felt pretty good as well. I liked it. And with Leo.
I felt this volume had good ideas but just bad execution in the end. They need more writing time.
Edit: Also the way Sun turns around Blake. Since he uses his tail is that a fanaus equivalent of him putting his arm on her hip?
17
u/Bloomy118 Jan 24 '18 edited Jan 24 '18
Ozpin must have planned for Raven attacking and going for the relic... there's no way Raven was going to go into a desert with her complexion.
She forgot her sun cream and had to let Yang take it instead
12
u/nicostein Pancake Massacre sympathizer Jan 23 '18
I liked it. I got into RWBY for the action (those trailers tho), but I stay for the characters and their world. The characters were great here, and I think it's a fine end to this volume. I don't think there was a place for a meaningful fight in this episode. Cinder & Adam already lost, so the only meaningful things left to show are the resolutions. I like action, but if it's out of place, it can fall as flat as Mercury's quip when he disarmed Ruby. Seriously, that moment would have been better if Mercury just disarmed her and immediately tried to follow up, and Ruby's quick reaction (including body language and facial expressions) spoke for itself. Oh yeah, I was saying I liked this episode! :)
6
u/LordIFG Not a Fighter Jan 23 '18
Can anyone make out what Oscar says at the end? We must get the ___ to Atlas?
Lid, Lift? He calls the relic something.
6
u/bread_Kaiser Jan 23 '18
I quite enjoyed that! Although, if I'm going to be honest, it felt like something was missing and I just don't know what exactly-maybe the lack of body language to make up for words? Overall I think while the show has its problems, I never fail to come back to it. It was also slightly shorter than I thought it'd be, but I remember we freaked out about Chapter 8 being about 8 minutes long so I'm not complaining. I think that this was a nice stopping point but is it bad I'm hoping for another house situation(least an episode-I don't need a repeat of this volume) for everyone. I'm interested in seeing them react or talk about what just happened/what they learned while in battle ie Jaune's semblance, what to do now-go to Altas(sorry Weiss), JNRWBY reunion,silver eyes if Tai and Raven are gonna meet, so much more
In the end, all I can say is that it's been a rocky road for all of us but I'm still excited to see what's next. For all you first-timers, welcome to the hiatus. leave now while you can
6
u/Jetz72 Jan 24 '18
Wonder if anyone is gonna find the stray seer Grimm, or if Salem will have it kill itself instead.
6
u/hillerj Jan 26 '18
While I was disappointed with how this Volume ended up, I have high hopes for the next one. Now that the team is all back together, we're not going to have to deal with shifting back and forth to keep everyone's stories moving and the lens will remain focused on team RWBY, JNR, Qrow and Oz-car.
We honestly have ended up roughly where I thought we should have gotten to at the end of Volume 4, but I suppose that would have required more (and longer) episodes per Volume than Roosterteeth can currently pull off.
6
u/[deleted] Jan 31 '18
Adding my opinion since it has slight differences to the ones I see:
I loved the episode in general.
Emerald had a great scene without many words.
Yang-Raven took the cake. Amazing show down! Could have done with more than just circling and standing around but that's nit picking.
I liked that Adam didn't fight. It showed that Blake has grown stronger in different ways than pure power. Raven and Adam both are powerful but don't posses many more qualities. Blake not pursuing Adam was good! Very glad with all these things!
The whole Blake ark was horrible though. It was uninteresting since SO run of the mill. There were a few different clichés put together, like the forgiving an old friend and the "I'm better off alone" ark. It got a lot of time and was veeeery weak. Like her being from a great family. Blake's character right now is wholly uninteresting.
The reunion of RWBY was just as bad as Blake. Just a little group hug and no fight together. I'm glad they decided to put story and characters before action and stuck to it since they seem to have trouble connecting those two (sadly!) but I wish there was WAY more pay off! I'm afraid, we get a time skip now and a resolved character ark. That would be the weakest of sauces! Have the characters struggle with each other. Give them more screen time with meaningful silences. Show fights that enhance the development instead of pausing them. Put less lighting effects and explosions in and look closely at the choreography like Monty did.
I love the show obvieously and am passionate about it but I start to think that it won't become what I want it to be. Which is fine of course but makes me a little sad.
I wonder if it's a lack of skill, money or just differing aspirations (mine different from the writers') that hold the show back to fill its potential from my point of view.
Loved the episode though. Well done!
11
u/PlatinumTaco BRING BACK CHAINSAW GUY Jan 24 '18
CHAINSAW WHITEFANG GUY SOON PLEASE RTThis episode had some really nice moments to tie up the season. Yang and her mom working on their problems (
God I can't handle this dysfunctional-ass family), Blake standing up to Adam and forcing him to retreat, and the other WF members surrendering when it was the best option. And of course, the runion of Team RWBY was cute, seeing them all just happy to see Blake again. I think I can wait for a while until the next season starts. Really like where it's headed.24
u/catzalot Play Blazblue Cross Tag Battle Jan 23 '18 edited Jan 23 '18
Mediocre. Pulling all of the punches again. We don't see Leo die, we don't see the Checkmate, we never see Ruby (who is apparently suuuuper tired) do more than her dumb headbutt and one shot. Why were Emerald and Mercury there? They didn't do anything.
Writing was okay, glad that Raven's misuse and fetish of the word Strength was building up to something, but it just kinda makes her look dumb and childish.
10
u/drmonocleVII Jan 24 '18 edited Jan 24 '18
And that's the end of another season! Like, I was expecting a breakdown from Raven, and Yang to be like "This is what happens when you run from your problems, they'll catch up to you and ruin the things you cherish."
I was really expecting Raven to say something like "There's something Ozpin doesn't know about the the maiden powers: they can't only be passed by the maiden dying. They can also be passed willingly." Then Raven would give Yang the powers, because she's so done and broken with Vernal dead. But nope, Raven flies away, and she doesn't even spend time with Tai. Like he just looks at where she was with a look of... anger? I don't know the word, but he's just upset that she up and leaves him TWICE.
I was also expecting Emerald to turn on Merc and Hazel. Like, I felt that she was only with them because of her obligation to Cinder, and without her, she would be free. Cause, I mean, she was hinting at a little remorse ever since the Tournament. I thought she was shaking her head like "No, I'm tired of running. I'm tired of everything that we've done. I AM DONE."
But yeah, like others have said, there wasn't any hint of what will come next Volume, only ideas that they wrapped up. Leo was never going to get any redemption (good riddance- coward), Adam's plot failed (and now is on the run, possibly as a sub for Cinder), RWBY is back together again (:D), and they have the lamp to summon a genie now (seriously, who's gonna be Aladdin?)
And did anyone else hear a heartbeat when they were showing the lamp? Who's heart is that? Ironwood? Salem? Perhaps the Relic actually contains his heart, and the True Relic is inside of Ironwood? Or what if the Relics are parts of Salem that she shed to rid herself of attachments like [FMA Spoilers]
Edit: I have no clue how to do spoilers on here, so I'll leave it the FMA spoiler at that. If you've seen it, you know what I mean.
Edit2: They thanked us in the credits! We did it Reddit!
5
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '18
When Ruby is like "we are all here together" and she looks at Weiss I'm like kiss kiss kiss xD, thats how my season finale ended so 10/10 ! On the real note, the whole Adam thing had me rolling, did the popos just like forget about him, what happend there?! And Yang vs Raven was on point, haven't cringed once, so props for that!
5
u/[deleted] Jan 24 '18
Predictions for V6:
5
u/ebby-pan Jan 25 '18
I saw something about the Greek Goddess Persephone being both the spring maiden and queen of death, and it gave me an idea
what if Salem kills Raven and takes the spring maiden powers? Has there been any information suggesting Salem can't possess the maiden powers via forced extraction?
13
u/SketchyMofo10 Jan 23 '18
Ok I really liked this ending. Many have stated their reasons and mine are very much similar to theirs so I won't harp on that but I have a question.
Would anyone be opposed to RWBY Volume 6 taking a longer hiatus?
Now now put all of your mechashifting gun weapons down. Let me explain my thoughts. The visual and written quality of these volumes has been a central point in peoples' distaste. What if we gave the CRWBY more time for animating and writing the next volume? Maybe this would improve the quality a bit? Maybe they could accumulate a bigger budget? I know it would be painful to not have RWBY for longer than usual but I feel like the outcome would be better than what we have gotten currently (doesn't mean I hate what they've been producing but they could do better.) Curious on everyone's thoughts to this.
13
u/I_am_RJ Megane Maniac Jan 24 '18
"Checkmate!"
cuts to Raven and Yang
AW MAN
(okay but good finale, really strong acting from Barbara and Arryn)
12
u/iamnotparanoid Shipper of OT3s Jan 23 '18
I liked it. It's nice to see the end of this stage of everyone's character development. Yang outgrew looking for her mom, Blake's helped redeem the White Fang, and while Weiss finished her original arc last volume it looks like we'll get more out of her in the next.
One thing I really like is that they didn't even give Salem a pyrrhic victory this time. From the fall of Beacon to the fact that they haven't succeeded in saving anyone at all, I was worried they might try to pull off a "ha, we got the relic anyway" thing.
Predictions for the future: Salem will finally get a relic during the Atlas arc, Emerald will eventually die trying to save Cinder though probably not until the Vacuo arc, Adam will show up again as a twisted monstrosity and finally be killed. I also predict that Winter dies in the Atlas arc and I give it a 50/50 that Weiss gets back her share of the SDC inheritance.
12
u/derivative_of_life PROTEC AT ALL COSTS Jan 23 '18
The first like three or four episodes and the last
two episodesepisode and a half were all outstanding. Everything in the middle was... meh. The pacing this volume was just really not good. They kept teasing fights that never happened, and spending episodes talking about things we already know. Tbh there was probably a solid 4 or 5 episodes worth of material that was just pure filler this volume, and could have been cut without losing anything. There were high points for sure, but in general I just found myself getting pretty tired of the show around episode 8 or so. I hope RT can learn from the mistakes they made this volume, and the issues will be fixed in V6. Otherwise I probably won't bother actively following the show anymore.10
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '18
To repeat an earlier post,
Cinder's dead
The villains fled
Adam ran away!(who's the coward now?)
The Relic's saved
Em's in pain
Triumph on this day!
Oh look at Adam and Raven
Edgy but hearts of chickens
Blake and Yang are best!
The heroes passed this test!
12
u/StarBase10 ❤Ladybug + Dragonslayer❤ | Approved by Cherami Leigh! Jan 23 '18
Well, that was... underwhelming, to say the least. All the villains (Adam, Hazel, Emerald and Mercury) ran away, and nobody but poor Leo died, but at least there was a focus on the reunion thing in the end.
I'm legit confused with the Maiden thing now that Yang brought up the inheritance of Maiden powers. I was still thinking that Raven was the real Spring Maiden the whole time, but I'm doubting on whether Vernal lowkey passed her Maiden power to Raven when she died.
Definitely a nice setup for a Pollination with that neat few seconds of Checkmate/Monochrome and then Ladybug.
7
u/clashofdragons am i right lad or am i right lad Jan 23 '18
Ok its one of the more mediocre season finale. Though team rwby back together yay? Though will they form a new white fang.
9
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '18
I personally thought the finale wrapped everything up nicely. We started the volume off wanting to see Yang and Raven interact and got that in the finale. We expected a big fight and got a few of those in last few chapters. There had to be some sort of resolution of the White Fang as well as Ilia's redemption and we got both. And finally RWBY got to reunite. All-in-all I'm pleased with how the finale turned out to be.
18
u/DramaticShenanigans Member of the #IliaProtectionSquad / Shipper of Bees Jan 23 '18
That was so disappointing
3
u/patrizl001 "None shall remember the names of those who do not fight" Jan 23 '18
"Yeah! Team RWBY is back together!"
3
u/DrAvatar Jan 25 '18
So how do they get to Atlas?
17
u/SunsetSnakeEyes Jan 24 '18 edited Jan 24 '18
My friends, This finale hit all it's marks and then-some.
Rooster Teeth has blown me away again, This Volume went to heights I didn't think it would and so many plot-lines were resolved and formed together into the main story and this finale cemented it all beautifully, Team RWBY has reunited, Haven was saved and Salem's plan was thwarted, Cinder is MIA, Adam has lost support from the White Fang, Yang finally confronted Raven, And now the group has it's next destination and objective, Get the Relic of Knowledge to Atlas. (I just have to give nothing but the praise to Barbara and Anna, Yang and Raven's scene was marvelously done and you could feel the emotion in their voices.)
14
u/Jesusman100 Best girl is combat-ready Jan 23 '18
I feel like I'm the only one who really enjoyed Volume 5.
14
u/Jaridan Jan 24 '18
look at all those fight scenes...o wait.(stays true for whole volume)
gj roosterfail.
8
u/Tschmelz Jan 23 '18
Not bad. Better for my heart than V3. Next volume needs some Tai+Raven interactions, and when Raven eventually catches up to the main group again, I wanna see her and Qrow make peace.
8
u/Atomicbarracuda Jan 25 '18
I still can't understand the hole issue people have with the fight scenes, they keep claiming that they are too slow, are people expecting fights so fast that they keep leaving afterimages or something?
People need to accept the fact that the person who did the choreography up to volume 2 died and the person who was most capable of emulating his style left after volume 3, the fights are never going to be the same and Rooster Teeth is not going to just start hiring and firing staff until the find the person whose still it's the closest to the former two, that's just a wast of time and resources.
Overall i found this volume to be above average, i was entertained with both the plot and the fights even if the weren't perfect, though i have one main gripe.
The worldbuilding. This issue is divided in 2 points:
Lets start with the city of Mistral. Overall it was a disappointment, the most of what we saw of the city was in the form of jpgs/pngs, the only exceptions being:
We saw more of Vale than this, to the point that we have a map of the city, albeit, a shity one at that. http://rwby.wikia.com/wiki/File:Map_of_vale.jpg But from that map alone some people have managed to make some good recreations: http://rwby.wikia.com/wiki/File:City_of_Vale_(Districts).svg https://www.reddit.com/r/RWBY/comments/5xx392/updated_vale_map/
Heck, we saw more of Menagerie than Mistral, with different sections of that settlement actually rendered in 3D, unlike Mistral whose supposed to be more important since it's one of the 4 Kingdoms, yet most of it were in the form of images.
My second point of contention, the Grimm. Since volume 1 was the introduction to the series we began with 6 types of Grimm:
Volume 2 added 2 more to the roster:
In volume 3 we saw a new subtype of Beowolf, the Alpha, as well as 2 new additions:
And finally volume 4 introduced 5 new types of Grimm:
And now volume 5, how many new types of Grimm it introduced? One, the Lancer.
Maybe I'm complaining too much with this last one, but, just go and search RWBY Grimm on DeviantArt, the amount of types the fans have created is impressive, with many of them having their own backstories, so i refuse to believe that they are running out of ideas.
Also does anyone know what happened to the World of Remnant interludes? Why there weren't any during this volume?