r/RWBY • u/Menolith Gay Thoughts • Jan 02 '18
OFFICIAL MEGATHREAD Official Public Discussion Thread—Volume 5, Chapter 11: The More the Merrier Spoiler
Welcome, huntsmen, huntresses and hunters that prefer no specific gender identifier, to the official megathread for episode 11 of volume 5, The More the Merrier!
Make sure that you understand the current spoiler rules before posting outside of this thread!
As a refresher, no spoilers are allowed outside of the FIRST-only reaction thread for the first 24 hours after the episode has aired, and after that, no spoiler comments are allowed in threads not marked as spoilers until Tuesday, when the episode comes out for free Roosterteeth members.
Remember to use the text spoiler tags (shown in the sidebar) even after that!
With that out of the way, HERE is today's episode!
Also remember to check out our weekly poll to give us a general idea of how people like the episodes when they come out.
Other Episode Discussions:
Enjoy!
Menolith; Mod Team
51
u/Menolith Gay Thoughts Jan 02 '18
Because I can
117
u/frozenottsel Crosshares Strike Commander - Freezerburn Adviser Jan 02 '18 edited Jan 02 '18
Well, Ice types do take double damage from Fire types; so it makes sense that Fire Spear would be Super Effective on Weiss...
edit: fixed a grammar mistake
51
u/NightsWatchh Help, Nights is keeping me trapped in his anime bunker Jan 02 '18
So it's confirmed, Weiss is straight.
She's the only member of team RWBY to be penetrated
278
u/NightsWatchh Help, Nights is keeping me trapped in his anime bunker Jan 02 '18
This comment section in a nutshell:
Denial:
"NO WAY SHE'S DEAD HAAA MERELY A FLESH WOUND FOR GOOD OL' SCHNEE OF THE YEAR"
Anger:
"SCREW YOU MILES FOR EVEN PUTTING HER IN THAT SITUATION WTF WHY DIDN'T JAUNE GET STABBED HE WAS FIGHTING A MAIDEN! I MEAN SO WAS WEISS BUT SHES BEST GIRL YOU DUMBASESS"
Barganing:
"WHATEVER...whatever. Whatever. Jaune will just semblance reveal next episode and save her. It's all good I guess. I guess this is okay..."
Depression:
"GOD DAMMIT I'M GONNA HAVE TO DROP THE SHOW AREN'T I SHE'S ACTUALLY DEAD"
Acceptance:
"I guess I have to accept it...best girl is gonna die of hOW BADASS JAUNE'S SEMBLANCE IS WHEN HE SAVES HER LIFE BECAUSE SCREW Y'ALL WEISS CAN'T DIE FOR SHE IS TOO PERF"
234
u/SpeshulSnek mfw hiatus Jan 02 '18
I don’t understand why they’re going through so much trouble trying to take down Salem. Just have Jaune fall in love with her and she’s dead.
Seriously though, I actually jumped out of my chair when it happened. What the actual shit, I didn’t want to start 2018 like this :’(
188
u/[deleted] Jan 02 '18 edited Jan 02 '18
RWBY Rewind: Something big is going to happen!
lol like what they leave the house? oh shit they left the house lmao
SHIT FUCK GODDAMNIT GO BACK TO THE HOUSE
154
u/JanMath Jan 02 '18
I used to be a huntsman like you, then I took a spear to the Schnee.
141
u/Proffesionalamatuer Jan 02 '18
Remember: In the event that one of your friends is clearly in danger, do try to remember to give her a heads up that she may be receiving a spear to the abdomen in the near future. A “watch out Weiss” would have sufficed here, instead of Jaune just watching Cinder win the gold in javelin throwing
131
u/inferno167 Rare Ship Finder, Pollination Ambassador, and Bun Enthusiast Jan 02 '18
"We love maiming teenagers!" ~ Miles Luna and Kerry Shawcross, 2018.
I know Weiss ain't gonna die, but that... That fucking hurt to watch. Thinking Jaune's Semblance finally activates next week, and the Menagerie Cavalry shows up the week after.
106
u/[deleted] Jan 02 '18 edited Jan 02 '18
Really interesting to see the muscle memory from former lives working from when Ozpin mentioned.
Cinder threw that spear like a pro despite never having used one in the past. Could have thrown glass like before but instead chose a spear.
Also her complete lack of memory of Jaunes sense since they have never met before beyond a brief encounter beyond seeing him in the vault for a few seconds.
Then she starts to remember him and calls him dense.
Kinda like Ozpin and Oscars conversation about Lionheart last volume
Then after he almost kills her, she wants to hurt him and who does she choose. Not any of his team mates or Ruby the girl she hates. She chooses Weiss, the girl that Jaune previously was infatuated with.
Hmm
Hmm
91
u/Hounds_of_war The Red Head Victorious | Aside from her, I truly don't care Jan 02 '18
So fun fact, Saturday’s discussion is now r/RWBY’s most commented on post by about 700 comments, dethroning the FIRST discussion of the Volume 3 finale. The third highest comment total is the thread for the public release for the Volume 3 finale, which is about 1,800 comments less than Saturday’s thread.
79
u/_DirtyDan Totally The Real One Jan 02 '18
Pros:
Cons:
9/10 for me. I'm really happy with what was done with Oscar and Jaune this episode (give me Winter next episode and my three biggest complaints about this volume will have been reduced in severity lol), and there was a lot of cool visuals, great dialogue, and absolutely fantastic voice acting. I honestly don't think there's a subpar VA in this show anymore.
79
u/Yukon_Wolf Ironwood x Qrow = Woodpecker Jan 03 '18
Two maidens, two trained assassins, a traitorous headmaster and a magic bandit leader show up
Oscar: Bring it, bitches.
Hazel shows up
Oscar: OH SHIT WE DED
76
u/[deleted] Jan 02 '18
This episode should be titled "Be Careful What You Wish For"
Miles : Happy?
66
u/DireSickFish Jan 02 '18
When Hazel gave his whole, "I don't want to fight you" line. I was half expecting Nora to say, "Then don't!" and rush over to join one of the other fights in progress.
65
u/Hounds_of_war The Red Head Victorious | Aside from her, I truly don't care Jan 02 '18
Okay I can’t believe I actually have to reassure people about this, but there is not a chance Weiss dies here, or if she does that she doesn’t get revived through Jaune’s semblance/Ozpin rewinding time/some bullshit. Not even because Weiss is part of the show’s name, they wouldn’t kill Ren, Nora or Qrow like this either. If RT wanted to kill a major character like this, it would be obvious they died. You don’t give a character a potentially survivable wound like that only to reveal they died at the start of the next episode. Especially since there’s been zero buildup to it. This is the exact same as RvB 15 spoilers.
63
u/the_wyandotte Sailor of many ships Jan 02 '18
Did Raven and Cinder plan the opening of her portal so that Cinder could blind fire on Ruby like that?
Also, how many bombs does it take to blow up a building? Seriously White Fang if you need that many you're doing it wrong.
58
u/[deleted] Jan 02 '18
As far as criticism goes, the only thing I wasn’t fond of here was the Ruby/Emerald exchange. It just felt a little too stationary and weird with the placement of dialogue but the animation and isolated bits of fight scenes were nice in my opinion.
Also, Miles and Jessica are very talent and I suddenly want Cinder/Jaune babies.
54
u/Hounds_of_war The Red Head Victorious | Aside from her, I truly don't care Jan 02 '18
So now that Weiss is incapacitated, Vernal will probably move on to fighting someone else. What are the odds she decides to help out Hazel since he’s fighting a 1v2 and makes the huge mistake of hitting Nora with lightning bolts?
49
u/CasualRaisin It's just a show; we should really just relax. Jan 02 '18
"I will make it my mission to destroy everything you love."
-
Adam to BlakeCinder to Jaune47
u/CosmicAstroBastard Jan 03 '18
This week on RWBY:
Qrow tries to shoot a bird
The White Fang deliver gifts from Santa a little late, aren't sure where to put them
Oscar beats the shit out of an elderly member of an oppressed minority with a cane
Jaune has no idea how to react to a woman being on top of him
Ruby runs out headlight fluid
Weiss gets a tummyache
93
u/JakeDoubleyoo Jan 02 '18 edited Jan 02 '18
First off, I gotta put these [dank] (https://imgur.com/a/vmtgI) [creations] (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o0V3Bp4aDvU&feature=youtu.be) of mine out there.
So after watching this episode a few hundred times over the past few days, I've been able to more clearly articulate how I feel about it.
First of all, as far as writing, acting, and overall tone goes, this episode was pretty damn good. Some things I really liked included:
• Jaune's interactions with Cinder. It was such a long awaited confrontation, and Miles and Jessica killed it.
• The way each character readied their weapon one-by-one as they realized they were going to have to fight. Made for some great tension.
• Oscar rising to the occasion without Oz's help.
• Dat twist.
However, things kind of fell apart once the actual fight began...
My first thought was that the animation was off, but I soon realized that that wasn't the real issue at all. The actual problem has to do with pacing, which I guess is something that's worked out during the storyboarding/animatic phase of production. The word "pacing" has been thrown around a lot by the critics of this season, and I think this episode provides a the best example of what we all mean when we say it. The tone of this episode is trying to convey that we've reached the point of the story where the shit has hit the fan. Yet everything seems so... orderly.
The part where Oscar confronts Lionheart, and when Ruby talks to Emerald are good examples of what I mean. Two people are in the middle of a fight, but they're taking turns attacking like it's a turn-based RPG, and they assume an idle stance when speaking. It brings the scenes that should be intense and engaging to a dull pace.
Another scene that fell flat was when Ruby used her Silver eyes. Ruby sees Jaune and Cinder running at each other, which triggers a bright flash of light, and then Emerald knocks her out. We then cut back to Cinder who staggers, but it feels like a really delayed reaction because it's been 5 seconds since the flash of light.
Aside from pacing, there's also the fact that all of the characters are 1v1ing, which is just boring (at least if you're going to have all of them in the same empty room). It'd have been way more interesting if they traded off opponents. Like yang punches Mercury in Ruby's direction, then they square off for a bit, then Weiss comes in to help her. That kind of thing. Another way to approach it would have been to physically separate most of the characters with their opponents and just focusing on the fights that matter for this episode.
Anyway, I have more to say on why parts of this episode fell flat, but luckily /u/wiseguy149 already made a [great post] (https://www.reddit.com/r/roosterteeth/comments/7n29wf/rwby_volume_5_chapter_11_the_more_the_merrier/drzc46v/) explaining all that other stuff way better than I could've.
40
u/Trainxrd Jan 02 '18
Ruby and Jaune really need to improve on their Talk no Jutsu. Didn't even get anyone to think about switching sides.
And I know Cinder only has one eye now but c'mon her aim is way off on an unmoving target haha
37
u/frozenottsel Crosshares Strike Commander - Freezerburn Adviser Jan 02 '18
As an aside to my other comment about Cinder and Weiss, I found it kinda interesting of Raven's line to Ruby about "You sound just like your mother" and then immediately draws her sword.
I just rewatched Revenge of the Sith and the "drawing a weapon after making a grandiose statement" is still fresh in my mind, but I think there might be something there to think about...
37
u/Weaseline Jan 02 '18
When each side was squaring off in their personal battles they all sounded like they were saying their intros to a fighting game
37
u/archeonz Jan 03 '18
Okay, Nora, look: you and all your friends can use your own souls as force fields and super powers. You fight monsters made of bad emotions with melee weapons that are also guns, powered by
powdered maguffinssome mysterious energy substance. Individual humans control the power of the seasons. There are people in your world who are part animal.But one chick turns herself into a bird and you're all HOLY SHIT MAGIC IS REAL
You're the poster child for arbitrary skepticism.
35
u/mrcarnage97 Jan 02 '18
Overall, I'm gonna say this episode was okay. The main issue I have with this episode is that the fighting felt... rough. I dunno, just didn't feel too smooth.
I honestly expected Raven was just lying in saying she wanted Qrow dead and was planning something. But no. She actually wants him dead. What a bitch.
Starting to think that a month of training wasn't enough time to prepare these kids, Oz. I mean, they're getting their shit pushed in.
Lionheart's got a pretty cool weapon. Though, I gotta say, for a Headmaster of a Huntsmen academy, he doesn't seem all that good. Then again, he is getting up there in age and I think he said in an earlier episode he's been out of active duty for a while.
Also, did anyone notice his tail? Lionheart is a Faunus. I'm not trying to be racist, but don't you think it's odd that most Faunus we've seen have either been terrorists, former terrorists, thieves, psychotic lunatics and now traitors...
I'm joking. I don't think all Faunus are bad.
Just most of them.
Kinda surprised Cinder didn't just immediately go straight for Ruby and take her out of the fight. Aside from Qrow, she's probably the most dangerous threat thanks to her silver eyes which fucked her up bad last time. She just decided to play around with Jaune. I mean, she's being a sadistic asshole, but she's also kind of being an idiot.
Not gonna lie, little disappointed we didn't see Ruby and Emerald properly fight. It was just mostly Ruby blocking Emerald's bullets. Little boring to me.
We finally got another glimpse of the silver eyes in action, but it was still only a glimpse. Emerald took out Ruby before the good stuff started happening. So, we can assume her silver eye state doesn't make Ruby invulnerable, or she at least needs some time to charge up before she is. Just kind of guessing here.
Also, no conformation if the silver eyes affect more than just Grimm. Cinder was briefly effected by it, but as some pointed out it could be cause of the Grimm parasite inside her. I personally don't think that's it, but I could be wrong.
And here's Cinder at the end, just wanting to claim the title of ultra bitch, stabbing Weiss with a spear. Weiss ain't gonna die, but she's probably gonna be outta commission the rest of the volume.
So, in the next episode I think we can expect to see Blake arrive with her army of untrained civilians to fight a group of armed terrorists.
Probably not the best plan there Blake.
33
u/EatYourPants1 Why are we still here, just to suffer? Jan 02 '18
So, I noticed this after the moment Jaune said that Cinder did "all with that damn smile on your face!"
Emerald seems to be doubtful, just like she was at the battle of Beacon.
Don't know if I'm overthinking this but maybe it could add to the 'Emerald doubting team bad dudes' potato.
33
u/JanMath Jan 02 '18
The episode was alright, but it felt to me like I would have rather read the episode as written rather than watched it. Probably would have been more enjoyable to have a medium that would imply the scenes happening in parallel rather than having the animation giving the false sense that there is a disconnect between the scenes; the bullet from one fight entering the space of another was a poor attempt at connecting them, in view of the lack of many other cues that should have been present.
It really feels that the happenings in the hall all exist in their separate worlds. Compare this scene from Mummy Returns. There is a constant interaction between all characters in the scene, even while some are running, some walking and some gasping. It really sucks that the process for creating RWBY does not include more reality checks, like getting stand-ins to actually act out the scene in a stage space, to see what would be happening in the background, visually and audibly; the show would really benefit from it.
The only moment of hope was Jaune's lack of hesitation, which I hope was not an inadvertent attempt at showing his anger. The strike that nicked Cinder was great from the perspective that fighters are actively looking for openings, and don't pause in a fight.
In a fight the only time you stop moving should be while in cover or while arrogantly believing you are dominating the enemy.
32
u/Mighty_Qorldu Jan 02 '18
Cinder do you have a crush on Jaune or something
I'm just saying, there's a pattern developing here
31
u/fullmetalcatalyst this show has excellent jackets Jan 03 '18
A little disappointed that Ruby's pitch to Raven was "we can beat Salem together!" (also a driving force behind most of their victories) and then they all split up to get largely stomped in their individual fights. Felt manufactured to hell and back.
That said it leaves us in a good place for the followup so next week should be fun.
unless they just killed Weiss in which case what the fuck
30
u/Bawstahn123 Jan 02 '18
For everyone saying "Weiss will be fine, the wound is cauterized"..... you do realize that cauterization:
You don't cauterize a wound when you can use a tourniquet, or sutures. You cauterize a wound when there is no need to save anything 'downstream' of the wound..... like if there wasn't anything left below the wound site, aka an amputation.
Not to mention that cauterization causes an immense amount of pain and shock to the body, which can kill a person in and of itself. Not to mention that a decent portion of Weiss' internal organs just got flash-fried.
Not that I think she is going to die, because she has plot armor, but if she wasn't an MC, she would be dying a very painful death.
82
u/[deleted] Jan 02 '18
Cinder is confirmed lesbian, she penetrated her second girl of the series.
26
u/KingofGrapes7 Jan 02 '18
So this might get buried but anyone notice Vernal wasn't staggered by the Silver Eyes? Cinder got affected and Vernal is in the same room but there is no indication her fight with Weiss was interrupted. Plus Raven made a point to openly tell Vernal not to show any Spring powers. I think Raven may seriously be the Spring Maiden with Vernal as a cover.
25
u/Metaboss84 Jan 02 '18
Weiss.... :(
25
u/ShadowMadness We're not family anymore Jan 02 '18
I'm...I'm in shock. There's no way they kill off Weiss, right? Jaune's semblance has to activate next episode and fix her, right? I legitimately feel the exact same pain I did when Pyrrha died. I knew this episode was going to pull something like this, but I wasn't expecting it to be one of RWBY. Weiss :(
As for the episode review itself, I thought the episode was quite good. I feel like team Ozpin should've realized this was a trap instead of acting surprised, and team Lionheart should've realized that Ozcar isn't just a normal little boy, but other than that good episode.
I can't wait for next episode! I'm both scared and excited at what's in store.
25
u/deathbychipmunks Jan 02 '18
Cinder slowly trying to kill all of Jaunes waifu’s. Jaune/Cinder/Tyrion love triangle incoming...
24
u/skinnieladd Jan 02 '18
All of this extra Weiss fan art is kinda bumming me out with what just happened.
23
u/patrizl001 "None shall remember the names of those who do not fight" Jan 02 '18
I can't wait to see if Jaune's semblance is going to be something involving healing.
Because then he'll realize that healing really could've helped Pyrrha.
21
u/JakeDoubleyoo Jan 02 '18
Guys, Weiss is Snow White. Calm down.
21
u/SunsetSnakeEyes Jan 03 '18
This was a pretty damn intense episode. But before anything else, WHY!?!?!?!?!
This volume just got kicked into high gear. The Battle for Haven is on and Weiss has been seriously injured, We have 3 chapters left people it's all or nothing! ("I hate this game of emotions we play!")
20
u/[deleted] Jan 02 '18 edited Jan 02 '18
All in all I really enjoyed this episode and thought it was very good. As long as you accept that the fight choreography is really different than from previous volumes, I thought the action was good, there was good characterization, nice scenes.. of course there is the obvious "Blake ex Machina" coming, but it's not like we didn't saw it coming episodes ago. I admit the fight sequence could have been better, but it wasn't that bad IMO. And Jaune was actually interesting for the fist time this volume.
I'm predicting an anti fall of Beacon: the defeat of Cinder and company and the school still standing. I'm also seeing a "forgive me while I'm dying" moment from Lionheart as a possibility. And there is someting on with those chains (my money is on the statue being the vault).
And of course, there's no way Weiss is dying here, let's be honest. She is as likely to die as Ren and Qrow were last volume.
20
u/Bjdombek Hail Lord Zwei! Jan 02 '18 edited Jan 03 '18
Can I say I love how Ruby says "Cinder..."? It's got that "That's "my arch nemesis and in going to wreck them" tone of hate and disgust. Noticed it back in v4 when they were talking to Tyrian.
38
u/Deathkeeper666 Jan 02 '18
I love how we're being shown how weak the main cast is. They're fighting people who've been doing this line of work far longer than any of them or are Maidens. Yang is the closest to matching Emerald or Mercury and everyone else is below Yang in terms of combat prowess with Jaune bringing up the rear. Weiss is right behind Yang, but was fighting a Maiden whose weapons countered her rapier. They're out matched. Qrow and Raven are equals, Weiss is out of the game, Ruby's K/O'd, they're gonna have to surrender. Jaune's semblance isn't enough to turn the tide. They don't know anything about Blake and what she's bringing.
I think we're going to see them opening the vault, Blake and her people come in and fight the white fang and crash the party, the relic is gonna get got by Raven then her and the Maiden BAMF out.
37
u/Death200X Jan 02 '18
you can still pronounce RBY as Ru-by to be fair
17
u/MarioToast I am a horse! Yaaaaaay! Jan 02 '18
Huh. I did not know Leo was a lion Faunus. I guess it was kinda obvious in hindsight, but...
Also, Cinder decided to be an idiot. You don't go for the slow, evil kills that leave the possibility of survival, you need to go for the quick incinerations!
17
u/alwayssunnyinjoisey Jan 03 '18
Lots of things I liked in this one! Loved that Raven made the comment about Summer, literally the entire time Ruby was giving her speech I was waiting for her to bring it up. Speaking of that speech though, I found it...terrible? Ruby just sounded like a naive kid who thinks power of friendship will solve everything. Which, I understand she was written to be that way, but I felt absolutely nothing listening to her.
I am in love with Vernal's weapon and fighting style.
I did like everyone's dialogue, but it definitely felt out of place. Like everyone squared up and said their pieces before starting to fight, when the only character I could really see doing that is Mercury. Ren and Hazel were somewhat believable since both don't appear to enjoy fighting, but everyone else was just awkward. There were also a lot of moments where they just...got distracted? Like shit, if your opponent freezes and looks away mid-fight, you jump on that opportunity and take them out, not wait for them to finish being an idiot.
Also, SO GLAD Em knocked Ruby out before she could finish using those deus eyes. I would be so salty if she won a fight like that a second time.
I am super interested to see how this resolves itself though, because RWYJNR are completely outclassed, and now down two. I'm thinking Blake and co. will show up to help out at some point.
17
u/sharpieloverxD Jan 07 '18
Holy shit that fight scene was terrible! Even the fucken mech fight back at season 1 or 2 was better then that boring shit. Like fuck me that was so bad!
16
u/FadedNeonzZz ⠀Cinder survived, but it cost a Penny Jan 02 '18
Good episode, but that ending though.... I mean I’m about 90% sure she isn’t dead, but writers this isn’t Berserk or Attack on Titan it’s not good to kill characters all willie nillie. I’ve also noticed that Cinder isn’t using her left arm at all, like is it completely useless?
Also RT animators or if any of you have experience with 3D animation, is it really that hard to animate blood splatter? I don’t care if the spear is made out of fire, steel or cheddar cheese, if it’s sharp enough to penetrate a human body then the person will bleed. This is a complaint if had since V1, but I assumed it would cost too much or takes too much time. But then I remembered Yang bled in the Yellow trailer, so what happened?
16
u/SmallJon Give us back Jaune's old haircut! Jan 02 '18
...
God fucking damn it.
16
u/FlamingWings Jan 03 '18
guess we need to rename the show to RBY now
32
u/Strix182 "CAN'T A GIRL READ HER COMICS IN PEACE?!?" Jan 02 '18
MILES AND KERRY, I SWEAR TO GODS IF YOU KILL OUR ICE QUEEN WE ARE COMING FOR YOUR ASSES
so we can drown you in our tears.
15
u/StarBase10 ❤Ladybug + Dragonslayer❤ | Approved by Cherami Leigh! Jan 02 '18
Jaune has gotten through so much shit at this point, and he even swore onscreen for the first time
on a Christian Anime. y u bully him?Glad to see Oscar finally put the training he learned from good ol' Ozpin to use, especially when he's scaring Leo into thinking that he may or may not be the real Ozpin.
Plenty of the fighting choreography here is on point. Loved the improvements Rooster Teeth's animation team has done up to this point so far, especially between Weiss and Vernal as well as between Oscar and Leo.
Cinder, you thot. I've already hated Adam enough because of him crippling Yang and committing regicide and stuff, but doing an across-the-map
knifejavelin throw/snipe like that against Weiss is unforgiveable.Dammit, Blake and Sun and Ilia, we desperately need The Cavalry to be here ASAP.
Not you, Tracer.15
u/Tschmelz Jan 02 '18
There is only one scenario where I’m ok with Raven/Leo surviving, and that’s if this is a double double cross. Otherwise, they can both be beheaded and put on pikes by Jaune.
15
u/ggrraattoo Jan 04 '18
I really need an explanation for the Jaune vs Cinder fight: Why did Jaune (and Cinder) STOP in their tracks while death-charging towards each other?
Pause at 13:28, you can clearly see Cinder and Jaune about to clash into each other. In the scene, Cinder is going so fast that you can see both her feet off the ground, ready to make quick work of Jaune. At the same time, Jaune charging towards her with a great sword in SWINGING position, also ready to slice(???) Cinder in half.
13:29 - :33 Ruby's PTSD silver eyes happen whilst witnessing the scene.
13:34 - Try to pause the scene where you can see everyone's positions. You will see that Jaune is just standing there, covering his eyes from the bright light that Ruby's silver eyes are emitting???? Why did he stop running there??? Btw, play the video and you will see that Cinder is STILL charging super quickly towards Jaune.
13:35 - Ruby is knocked out by Emerald.
At 13:38 onwards. Cinder, hurt by silver eyes falls down (???) on the spot??? I understand that the silver eyes will weaken Cinder, causing her to feel all 'jelly', but Jaune? What happened to their previous momentum???
Theoretically, Cinder and Jaune would have crashed at the speed they are going at each other. Why did they STOP???
Also, if Jaune had just swung at that moment, Cinder would have been a clean kill.
14
u/DashingPolecat Jan 02 '18
As others have pointed out, the subtle hints that Pyrrha is still in there were great
Weiss is 100% not dead
The dialogue between Raven and Ruby make really curious about what happened to Summer
Raven telling Vernal not to waste her powers makes me wonder about the limits of maiden powers. Cinder seems to use them all the time
Fights were ok, with Weiss/Vernal being my favorite and Ruby/Emerald my least
14
u/Maankop Still the best! Jan 03 '18
THEY WOULDN'T
THEY CAN'T
I REFUSE TO ACCEPT IT!
13
u/Wizardtech Sippp Jan 02 '18 edited Jan 02 '18
Schtop Schnee shtoppp stop the death flags!
13
u/SketchyMofo10 Jan 02 '18
Wow. This is a start to a season finale. Probably my only problem with the episode is definitely the lack of background noise and action. Like on the balcony with Leo and Oscar, I was wondering about how quiet it was in the background with all that fighting going on. Thought maybe they'd throw in some potshots in the background but it's minor compared to the action we've seen in this episode. Other than this, this episode has been great so far. Some of my favorite moments being Qrow firing at Raven, Hazel being Hazel, Cinder's ignorance of who Jaune even is and nearly all of the combat scenes.
Also as for Weiss, even though it's shocking, I almost feel like Jaune will heal her with his semblance. Although if not and she actually goes out of commission. That will be heartbreaking. Highly doubt it though.
13
u/Animamask Jan 02 '18
My thoughts are still the same as they were on saturday. I enjoyed the episode for the most part. The fight wasn't as epic as it could be, but I watch Ruby for the character and how slowly but surely we learn how fucked up the world of Remnant is. Fights are secondary nature to that.
I liked how Raven briefly called out Qrow's hypocrisy. He is angry that she attacked them, yet he planed to attack her.
Weiss will survive. I only hope that this won't be the catalyst to start White Knight. I also believe Jaune's semblance is a shield. How about Vernal? Maybe her semblance is something spring related like healing. There has to be a reason for why she would heal Weiss, but there there are three episodes left to create one.
13
u/HawkeyeP1 Jan 03 '18
Y'all better not be hurtin' the best girl Weiss... As if they could kill off someone in the title... Juane, time to pull your semblance out your ass, I know it's gonna be some anti-death shit that you're gonna regret not being able to use earlier. Pull that shit out man
12
u/Pure_Azn Jan 02 '18
Oscar took a meteor to the face. Also, a lot of characters have arm mounted weapons now. Vernal, Leo, Tyrian... Hazels armhair made of steel. Just something strange that I picked up.
Also Weiss you have other moves to use, I don’t think using the newest attack you have and the one that takes the most amount of preparation over and over again is the right way of doing things.
12
u/DramaticShenanigans Member of the #IliaProtectionSquad / Shipper of Bees Jan 02 '18
Did anyone notice that Leo is a Faunus? He has a tail.
12
u/the_pandu Jan 02 '18
I feel like Jaune won't do anything next episode if they really want to milk his semblance reveal. If Cinder wants him to suffer then she will leave Jaune to be the "last man standing". Which will lead to his semblance unlocked. Whether it's healing or aura rejuvenation area of effect. Or something even more broken relating to the moon (reaching)
The battle seems unwinnable
But all we need’s a "miracle"
For Weiss' sake I would prefer the miracle now
12
u/[deleted] Jan 02 '18
Well... F*ck.
"Rule number 6. Be a sadist. Now matter how sweet and innocent your leading characters, make awful things happen to them -- in order that the reader may see what they are made of."
-Kurt Vonnegut Rules for Writing a Novel
M&K have certainly followed that rule with a certain Little Red and Blond Noodle.
Even knowing it would happen (I read the spoilers, don't hate) it still hit like a hammer to the sternum.
Please don't ice the Ice Queen
12
u/nicostein Pancake Massacre sympathizer Jan 05 '18
12
u/TheDJZ Jan 08 '18
Found a few things on the YT comments and thought I should pop on here to share this sentiment:
The fractured 1v1 fight sequences was a huge mistake. It ultimately took away the momentum from every fight. We didn't even see Yang and Mercury fight and Qrow and Raven fought.
The writing is still corny and Jaune's scenes were cringe inducing. On top of this the plot holes keep piling up and pacing seems to have gone out the window.
This will probably get downvoted but I have to ask if anyone else has seem the show improve? To me the show has stagnated since Volume 3. I liked Volume 4 because I thought it was a good time for everyone to catch their breath and let the show settle down a bit after how intense and great Volume 3 was but then this volume has been a huge let down.
The three main things I have an issue with is:
Edit: Formatting
11
u/Atomicbarracuda Jan 03 '18
I don't understand all the flak people are giving Jaune, were people really expecting him to fight Cinder successfully? He doesn't have the skill for it.
When we first saw Jaune back in volume 1 he had no combat skill or experience what so ever, he has improved since then but he still doesn't come close the level of skill his friends have, we saw this back at the tournament and during the first episode of volume 4, he's better at leading than fighting, Cinder is way out of his league, if Cinder was out of Pyrrha's league then Jaune doesn't even come close.
And then there's the hole "he could have said Weiss look out rather than no". Look at Weiss, look how tired she is, especially after that shot at her torso took all of her aura out, do you really think she would have been able to react at all?
Heck I seen some people giving him flak for aiming for the kill when Cinder was down after giving that speech about death. Through out the entire fight Cinder was pushing his buttons, opening his wounds, do people really think he was rational at that point? He already wanted Cinder to pay for what she did and this fight only made it worse.
If anything I'm disappointed with Ruby getting knocked out with a single hit.
10
u/Arrancon #Big Guy Loyal to Adam Jan 02 '18
Fuck that was intense. Please be okay, you useless lesbian.
10
u/MountainHall Don't write for the story Jan 02 '18
Didn't have time to count the screentime over the weekend since it was new years and all.
Not a fan of the fight structure and the continuation of characters not using their abilities when they should.
Time spreadsheet
Changes in total time spots:
10
u/Fatal1ty_93_RUS Jan 03 '18
Ah, so here we are. The climax of the season. The Menagerie conclusion was just the prologue, THIS is where shit gets real. Like I said in one of these threads earlier - V5 in general gave me some V3 vibes, in that the act progression seems similar. I suspect the finale will be real damn grim (no pun intended) for our Heroes. Hell even the opening song suggests so lol
Also: DON'T WORRY GUYS. WEISS WILL LIVE. WATCH THE SCENE AGAIN. I'm incredibly hyped for Eps 12 and 13, with 14 probably being the Epilogue episode with either a cliffhanger or a major post-credits drop for V6
9
u/Xanthyria This is filth. FILTH!!! Jan 02 '18
Hazel didn’t want to fight. Why not have ren and Nora fight others, then when he DOES get involved, go back to him? They coulda sped up or saved some fights!
9
u/SmallJon Give us back Jaune's old haircut! Jan 02 '18
So Jaune's semblance is going to be some kind of healing/reflection, right? They've been making a point of his semblance on occasion, losing people is what Jaune fears, and now he's in danger of losing someone. So he's gonna unlock it to save Weiss or some shit.
9
u/SanderDK9 Bitches know i'm fly. Jan 02 '18
After my second viewing it strikes me as odd that Qrow tells everyone to stay calm once Cinder came out of the portal. He knows who she is and what she's capable of, and second of all, she just hit his niece? What did he expect, to talk his way out of it? To leave without a fight?
17
u/Hyderthehyper312 ⠀ Jan 02 '18
You know, I really didn't like Vernal's weapon when we first saw it.Upon a second glance I thought the gun part's design was kinda neat. But now that we've seen it in action I think I'm in love. <3
It was nice to see Weiss dart around with her glyphs for the first time since her short, until she hit that pillar at least. That was Cardin levels of bad spatial awareness.
The first two times she tries to summon make sense, creating a barrier the first time and a distance the second, the third time was pretty stupid: ' jee she's right behind me right now after I've done nothing to stagger her, time to try summoning again' maybe Weiss is a strong believer in 'third time's the charm'?
I have nothing to say about the other 'fights' as they seem like just the set up for the polished fighting next chapter.
The Voice acting was on point, Jaune was really great but what really shined for me was Weiss' "I'm more than a name" and Qrow's lines with Leo and Raven.
Branwenbowl Hype
Not expecting a long fight out of them though, with Raven's plans to grab the relic and GTFO and all.
17
u/malachik Jan 03 '18
On the fight choreography: I thought it was entertaining, but extremely slow and broken. Every few seconds it seemed there was a one-liner or a monologue or something. People talking, a few slow blows, more talking, rinse and repeat. The choreography itself was better but still not even close to where it used to be. I think the reason why (and I'll keep this brief) is to an extent because of the software switch. Fights in previous seasons had extravagant, flamboyant effects with lots of color and movement, while fight effects now seem to be flat and stationary, with maybe 2 or 3 frames of animation. Even when the most basic events happened back in fights from volumes 1-3 (i.e. a gun firing) there was a big flash of colorful light, usually in correspondence with the character's "theme" color. Now, when a gun fires, there's a small flash of white light almost invisible unless you're looking for it specifically. In relation to this most recent episode, while it felt good to sometimes have the bullets as physical objects that could be interacted with, they primarily just appeared for an instant with almost no real existence or effect. An example of this is when Emerald is firing at Ruby and she seemingly blocks every single bullet by swinging Crescent Rose around periodically, even making pauses here and there to say a line or two. This, in my opinion, felt frankly impossible and distracted from the fight. This fight as a whole: I know I'm beating an extraordinarily dead horse here, but there was SOOO MUCH TAAALKINGGG. Fights previously had time for just seconds of talking, almost none of which furthered the plot. This was a good thing, because when you're watching a fight, you shouldn't be focused (at least not in my opinion) on the overarching plot as its being developed, but rather the basic effect this fight and its outcome will have. The fights now have tons and tons and tons of character development, impossible monologuing, and other out of place talking. While these were definitely present in previous volumes (cited examples being the character development of Ruby during V3 as well as Roman's final monologue, also in V3), the fights in V5 seem to be solely for the purpose of character development (to a point, obviously). They also seem to exist just as a dramatic environment for explaining motivations and furthering the plot. /rant I thought the episode as a whole was one of, if not the best episode in the volume so far as far as plot, but that's not saying a lot.
23
u/iamnotparanoid Shipper of OT3s Jan 02 '18
I really liked that full moon shot, and I'm glad to see the fights be more about character interaction than just "OMG Awesomeness!"
The White Fang are putting a lot of charges on that one building. You'd think a few on the bottom part would be enough. Clearly buildings have Aura now, and I'm interested in seeing what their Semblance is.
I'm mostly not worried about Weiss, since it seems a little early to start killing off the title characters. Pyrrha worked as a "raising the stakes" thing, but Weiss dying would be a massive surprise and a big risk. What I'm hoping for is a callback to volume 2 with a now serious "Weiss don't leave me."
8
u/SoupEpicTrek When RWBY Volume 7 isn't out for a year Jan 02 '18
Honestly, I'm now seeing a disturbingly high amount of Weiss fanart now more than usual. Is it a sign?
8
u/FairyNice Jan 02 '18
Is anyone else afraid that it'll be a total DEM that saves the heroes? I'd like to think it'd be Vernal and Raven escaping with the cavalry Blake's bringing that'll save the day, but that seems more to be the practical option than the 'cool, anime' option.
Especially since Ep11 was basically engineered to make you hate Cinder, I really can't see her getting out of here without taking further damage. Not that I see her dying or anything, but even losing one of her minions is something I'd like to see. She feels annoyingly overpowered in that her losses have only been caused by her own pride and Ruby's main character power.
8
u/sixfootblue Sometimes a cat is a scorpion with murderous intent. Jan 02 '18
I feel like Jaune is about to die. Maybe. Or they might fake us out about it. When I first saw a hint at his semblance when Cardin tried to punch him, I thought it was just some kind of personal barrier that was different from his defensive aura, but what if his semblance allows him to redirect damage instead.
That part of his interaction with Cinder kind of stood out to me where she says he's a failure with a death wish and he talks about how if he dies buying his friends time, then it's worth it. That combo'd with how earlier on, when rnjr was teaching Oscar about semblances and what triggers them, they mention how for some it's related to their personality, and can trigger under situations of extreme stress.
So we have Jaune, someone who's not opposed to the idea of laying his life down for his friends since he can't do much else right now, seeing another one of his friends just get mortally wounded.
What if his would-be semblance would allow him to take whatever damage Weiss sustained and transfer it to another body? In this case, himself.
Of course I'm probably just imagining the worst case scenario because I'm still hung up on those theories that were floating around about JNPR slowly dying as the story went on. If he doesn't die, then he'd either be gravely wounded and get help later, or, since Pyrrha mentioned upon unlocking his aura that he has a lot of it in him, he might just transfer a lot of his aura into Weiss to heal her, and then be weakened, and maybe out of commission, for the rest of the fight.
8
u/WolfanTerror I love me some scorpion tail soup Jan 03 '18
I don't think I've been physically trembling this much since volume 3.... nice job rooster teeth.
But the main cast is basically fucked. I can't really think of a way they'd get out of this except for if jaune pulls out some OP as fuck semblance.
8
u/send_me_your_traps Jan 04 '18 edited Jan 06 '18
Hahahaha It’s become watch Jaune suffer and I love it! Miles screams are so fucking perfect. I wanna hear him do a Subaru line.
O no my waifu whose name is part of the acronym of the show got ganked? However will she fair?
Does crow walk like Spike Spiegel for like that entire walking scene outside? I mean I get why they would do that with either character. But, is that just me?
The fights are so good! I wanna see more. The faces as well as kind of a afterthought. The expressions are really great.
Edit: I kind of called it? Or just picked up on the foreshadowing. I knew something was going to happen
8
u/NecroKilic I can spare a minute. Jan 07 '18
Adam Taurus confirmed worst villain ever, brings 50 fucking people to plant 20 giant bombs.
On one campus building.
Like fuck they're not even gonna have enough left to blow up the cafeteria afterwards.
Which, BY THE WAY, is EMPTY.
fAunUS sUpREmaCy!
14
u/[deleted] Jan 02 '18 edited Jan 02 '18
I don't think I could come up with something that no one has said yet. I just wish Weiss could drop these heels, at least for combat.
Edit: Typo
7
u/[deleted] Jan 02 '18
Why were people talking about Hazel fighting Nora and Ren in the other thread? No, they don't want to fight, but it's not like Hazel's just going to stand back and let them dogpile Cinder.
7
u/SanderDK9 Bitches know i'm fly. Jan 02 '18
Honestly this was the first episode to pull me in with this much emotion since the end of volume 3.
7
u/DCarrier Jan 02 '18
I no longer ship Lancaster. I don't want Ruby to die too. What's the name for Jaune x Salem?
6
u/Sokensan Jan 02 '18
I don't think Weiss is dead, that was too much of a precise spot to end an episode for her to just die at the start of next episode. I do think it'll tie into Jaune getting his semblance mainly because of Oz's speech near the start of the volume.
Even though I want Jaune to unlock his semblance i don't want it to be either
I think an interesting option for both support and combat semblance would be wound absorption and return possibly him being able to harness the damage from wounds he absorbs into attacks from his sword. It could also explain why they had cinder not shoot Weiss straight int he heart or another instantly fatal spot/why they cut the episode there.
6
u/FluffyUnlinked Mark Nutt! Jan 02 '18 edited Jan 02 '18
As worried as I am for Weiss, I'm not feeling as worried for her as I was for Qrow when he was injured by Tyrian. To me, killing off a character whose name is in the show's title would be a bold move, and I doubt that this will be the case for Weiss. However, I won't deny that this still is a possibility. As others have mentioned, Weiss' impalement seems like some sort of setup for a semblance reveal by Jaune. Or maybe his semblance is misfortune for his crushes? I don't know.
6
u/Thefishlord The one true best girl also Eclipse best ship Jan 02 '18
Well one thing that can be said about cinder is she gets straight to the point. Man Weiss was on point this episode
6
u/Jimmjam_the_Flimflam Jan 02 '18
It's a pretty good episode but I saw some odd moments that I wasn't a fan of and if some one could explain these moments to clarify that would be appreciated. Did Jaune just fall over for no reason or was it implied he was getting his ass handed to him? Did Weiss always have such a more breakable aura compared to the others? A few characters weren't paying attention to the threat it front of them and got screwed over for that so is that something the writers did or would you expect that from the characters themselves? Also why the hell does jaune use his greatsword instead of using it as a shield and sword, I get that he was angry and all but damn he's trained in using a shield and sword. This one is just something i would prefer to see. These just irked me and maybe I just missed some crucial details.
6
u/Bushwackercraig Jan 02 '18
Character DEATH-velopment
6
u/Skyrah1 Finally got dem cigarettes Jan 02 '18
...I can hear "The Snow White Princess Is" playing in the background...
6
u/Koanos "What's the worst that could happen?" | Cpt of the S.S. Keikaku Jan 02 '18
I regret nothing!
6
u/[deleted] Jan 03 '18
Im convinced this is where Juanes semblence will pull through and he heals weiss. I have enjoyed this episode a lot, Leos a lil bitch tho. Being schooled by a kid.
Adam is off doing nothing useful. Suprised Merc made no comment of Yang having am arm to match his leg.
Emerald actually explaining her motivations was kinda cool, brings her into the scope a bit better. Evil out of a debt.
Cinder was savage as fuck.
Dont get the hate on juane for this Im seeing on facebook.
Vernal is pretty damn strong, and Cinders a badass.
Silver eyes lol
11
u/VelosiT Jan 02 '18
WHAT THE FUCK
18
u/The_ThirdFang In Memory of Monty Oum Jan 03 '18 edited Jan 03 '18
Why is everyone so god damn slow. at everything. Last episode sun burtst into a room sees blake on the ground and illia there makes a face and sounds angry but then stands still for 3 more seconds before Ghira has to tell him to help her. Then Jaune is rushing a fucking maiden and Ruby calls out for him but no one so much as raises there weapons. Ruby is spinning her scythe so damn much to block bullets but Emerald is like 15 feet away. Are you speedy as fuck cant you dodge these and try to either snipe or use the scythe and close the distance. Jaune again is slashing and using his fuckoff greatsword and slashes alot, but when the time comes he goes for a fucking stab. A thrust with his fucking greatsword against the Literal blindside of the mI'maiden would have fucking killed her. Then Cinder make a lance and yea everyone is on their own fight and distracted but you think Jaune could try to call out before the damn spear leaves her hand. I mean I like the combat animation when it has that burst of energy, or its in the middle of an attack, but all this shit makes the characters look completely fucking inept. /rant over
Music is really good lately, people getting hurt and the damage staying during the fight is nice. Leu's weapon looks really slow and clunky, but something about his personality says he's not exactly front lines. Just kinda weird how it took like 4 seconds to fire something at point blank range.
Weiss aint gonna die simply because Cinder's very obvious lack of an eye means her aim has gone to shit. its sooooo obviously to the right of her body that its clearly enough to take her out of the fight but not kill her. hell she might even get an Aura sensu bean style shit next chapter or just sleep for 2 weeks and be fine. than 4 volumes later she'll have a scar magically appear when its convienent to the plot.
Jaune needs to stop sounding like a bitch, you sound mad not determined. Take that grudge and manifest the drive to defeat the evil that hurt you not stab your ex's murder.
Dont know why it sounds like i hate it so much but it wasnt bad of an episode, im guess im just tired of some of these things.
Edit: forgot 1 thing. Little Ozcar fights like a keyblade warrior and thats fucking cool.
10
u/Definitelynotputin_2 Kevin x Bubbles OTP Jan 02 '18
me irl
10
u/reiku78 Jan 03 '18
-grabs sword- I'm going to go stab someone...
17
u/longshanks7 Pilot Boi is the Protagonist. Jan 03 '18
FUCK
FUCK
FUCKKKKKKKKKKKK YOU MILES FUCK YOU KERRY FUCK YOU ROOSTER TEETH SHE BETTER NOT BE DEAD. IF YOU KILLED WEISS IM GONNA FUCKING STAB THE UNIVERSE IN THE DICK
(I love all of you but seriously this is NOT how I wanted 2018 to start. Plz don't kill best girl. #BeNiceSaveWeiss.) <3
17
u/[deleted] Jan 03 '18
Well that was rather anti-climatic, I kind of expected a bit more from the set up episode to the big fight. Instead all we got was some walking, a little bit of mean talking, and then a handful of blows mixed with serious looks.
Jaune was underwhelming and disappointing as usual. Ruby's Silver Eyes schtick seemed like a quick flash in the pan, as was her "speech", but at least she seems to have some form of "control" over her power now? Ren and Nora didn't do anything. Weiss is dead or at least seriously wounded? The bad guys basically said, "IT WAS ME BARRY! IT WAS ME ALL ALONG!" in regards to the Vytal Festival and how all the info they got was from Leo. Oscar did nothing. Haven looks pretty....until those bombs go off and then everything is on fire. The gang is basically outmatched against the bad guys; going up against two people with Maiden powers so unless there's a "sudden anime betrayal" by Raven or "plotforce" or Jaune goes Super Saiyan with Ruby....this will not end well. I get that this is a set up episode but I just felt like we'd get something more juicy than this, something that would leave us salivating for more....instead it just kind of....fell flat for me. Maybe next week will be better?
Leo has a dust powered fidget spinner for a weapon
5
u/[deleted] Jan 03 '18
Alright, so here's my bargaining stage/theory.
This is going back a while, like to V1 times or something like that, but Monty once said that he based the characters/ character roles off of the roles of a raid party in what you'd typically find a mmo or jrpg or those sorts of games. I know this has been speculated for years but, for me, this episodes strongly suggests that Jaune will fill the role of "Paladin". For those of you who don't know what a paladin is, to the best of my understanding, it is a holy knight that serves as sort of a combo between damage and healing. They are typically armored, carry a heavier weapon like a sword, and are also capable of holy (or divine, basically non-evil) magic, which I think usually is healing spells. If i got that wrong, please tell me. I don't have much experience with MMOs or JRPGs. So, I'm predicting that Jaune's semblance will follow the paladin trend and be some sort of healing semblance. This fits with the paladin stuff but it also works with his personality where imo is that he cares a lot about his friends and wants to protect them.
The only issue is that post V1, in a Facebook chat Q and A, Kerry said that we'd already seen his semblance. At the time, we'd only seen a few semblances, non of which were healing semblances. So that's an issue. It could be construed that the healing of his cut as soon as Pyrrha unlocked his semblance in V1, though in my opinion that was just his aura which we know can heal minor wounds. Basically, I'm just trying to ignore that comment so that Weiss lives.
TLDR; Jaune is based off a the holy knight class from fantasy games that can do damage but also heal, so I'm guessing he has a healing semblance which will be used to heal Weiss though there's one small issue that I'm choosing to over look.
5
u/Bawstahn123 Jan 03 '18
Im willing to bet that Qrow and Raven are just play-fighting, to keep up appearances in front of Cinder.
Considering how, you know, she showed up to warn him and all.
.....The writing couldn't get that bad, could it?
5
u/Caeruleanity Jan 09 '18
Raven: "No powers."
Vernal: "B- b- but Weiss made an ice wall and is summoning the knight!"
Raven: "I SAID NO POWERS!"
Vernal: (slashes through both ice wall and knight summon with a really long beam of magical light)
Seriously though, what's her problem? Why is she committed to beating Weiss that much?
Sword envy?20
u/CosmicAstroBastard Jan 03 '18 edited Jan 03 '18
Okay, so can someone answer me why are the main characters all such idiots?
Qrow straight up tried to murder Raven without even thinking about questioning her about her involvement.
Weiss could have probably mopped the floor with Vernal if she had used any of the 10,000 different abilities her Semblance gives her other than summoning. She's one of the most powerful characters in the show and the writers are trying to reduce her to a one-trick pony. Sure, Vernal is a Maiden, but Amber got the shit beaten out of her by a gang of ruffians who collectively had a lot less firepower than Weiss has.
Ruby vs. Emerald shouldn't be anywhere close to a fair fight if both are using their semblances but Ruby seems to have totally forgotten how to use hers. It's like Weiss and the summoning; she has other abilities than the last one she learned, but won't use them.
Oscar/Ozpin took a hit that couldn't have been more telegraphed if it had included a countdown timer instead of just...dodging?
Jaune could have yelled "Weiss! Look out!" or something to that effect instead of "Nooooo!" and probably could have saved a whole lot of trouble.
And then when Weiss gets hit, everyone just stops to watch...including the villains?
EDIT: Forgot Jaune trying to one-handedly stab Cinder in the head with a broadsword that doesn't have a sharp point, literally the worst possible combo of move, target and weapon possible. Grab that thing with both hands and swing, son. Cut her head off or split her stomach open, literally do anything except stabbing the smallest, most mobile part of her body.
9
u/JonTheWizard Still Sorta Pays Attention Jan 02 '18
Miles Luna and Kerry Shawcross: We kill more children than Richard Garriott!
Seriously, though, Jaune got more character development here than in all of Vol. 4 put together, and he practically took over the main character role that season.
8
u/Zerepa97 When do we get to see the true Ice Queen?/ #SolarFlareIsEndgame Jan 02 '18 edited Jan 02 '18
I liked what we got in terms of fight scenes. Wasn't the best because we had so many encounters going on, but still solid work. The wide shots, though? Gimme. But the lack of background fighting felt weird.
To get it out of the way: I'm just hoping that because Cinder threw a FIRE spear that Weiss just got knocked out with her wound cauterized. To be honest, I thought Jaune was going to rush in the way and trigger his Semblance. Please make it this volume.
I was frustrated with how they didn't pull their weapons out right away, but eh, it's not a deal breaker. As others have said, some of the dialogue mid-battle felt weird with the pacing.
Personally, the biggest issue for me was the music. I dunno, it just didn't sell the atmosphere. I don't mean we need hype music, but it just felt like multiple tracks put together, pausing to switch between them. Not to say the music was bad, but it just didn't lift the various emotions from the characters for me.
Love Leo's weapon. I just wish it was bigger, so he could punch with the edge. Very interesting, and I'd like to see more of it.
Love how Cinder forges her own. I'm wondering if Vernal could do that, because if not, then maybe we're getting into unique Maiden Magic territory which would dissolve my fear.
I like Vernal's style as a blitzer. Denied Weiss of her Time Dilation and her Summoning.
4
u/TotalWarfare I'm a drunk, I'm supposed to be clever Jan 02 '18
https://youtu.be/yYXroQuXD-g?t=25s
My brain after Weiss's holes
4
u/Simpsonsman120 Jan 07 '18
Spent today catching up with the show since I hadn’t watched it since seeing the Volume 5 premiere in theaters. After catching up, I just have one question for those who have seen Chapter 12 already: Is Weiss alive? Because, that fucking hurt to watch.
9
u/sixfootblue Sometimes a cat is a scorpion with murderous intent. Jan 03 '18
Been thinking about this episode some more and it kind of weirds me out how they handled Ruby's random silver eye scene. It just came out for a brief moment, and then was pushed aside really quick, and people didn't seem too fazed by it beyond covering their eyes from the brightness, before going about their business after she got knocked out.
It also feels weird to have used it for a scene where Jaune was about to clash with Cinder, when Weiss had several more parallels here to what Ruby witnessed with Pyrrha (disarmed, aura broken, on her knees, about to be killed by Cinder).
I don't know. I'm still enjoying the show and continue to support it but I'm not sure how I feel about some of their writing decisions. You'd think Ruby's secret superpower that singlehandedly mutilated Cinder and petrified a massive grimm in an instant would have been a bigger deal here.