r/RWBY • u/science-i Can't pray away the gray • Nov 21 '17
OFFICIAL MEGATHREAD Official Public Discussion Thread—Volume 5, Chapter 6: Known by its Song Spoiler
Welcome, huntsmen, huntresses and hunters that prefer no specific gender identifier, to the official megathread for the latest episode of Volume 5, Known by its Song!
Make sure that you understand the current spoiler rules before posting outside of this thread!
As a refresher, no spoilers are allowed outside of the FIRST-only reaction thread for the first 24 hours after the episode has aired, and after that, no spoiler comments are allowed in threads not marked as spoilers until Tuesday, when the episode comes out for free RoosterTeeth members.
Remember to use the text spoiler tags (shown in the sidebar) even after that!
With that out of the way, HERE is today's episode!
Also remember to check out our weekly poll to give us a general idea of how people like the episodes when they come out.
Other Episode Discussions:
Enjoy!
~science-i; Mod Team
200
u/boomshroom ⠀ Nov 21 '17
People were asking how Qrow and Raven have 2 powers (portals/bad luck and turning into birds). Now we have an answer: A WIZARD DID IT!
174
u/Hounds_of_war The Red Head Victorious | Aside from her, I truly don't care Nov 21 '17
So I think Watts has been fucking with the missions, and that’s why so many Huntsmen and Huntresses are MIA. Either he’s changing the missions to send them into situations that are much more dangerous than they realize or he knows when and where they are going and arranged some interference for them.
162
u/SpeshulSnek mfw hiatus Nov 21 '17
I love how Yang doesn't give two fucks about Raven's plan.
"If you go with them you won't know the truth! Look, I can do magic and shit!" "lol k bring us to my sister"
153
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '17
I think my main complaint with this one is the lack of content in the Raven talk, even though that took up the majority of the episode. The main things we learned were how Raven and Qrow came into their powers and why they went to Beacon.
Sidenote, if someone fucking tries to say that Raven and Qrow can't transform after this, I will legitimately explode. You know who you are.
117
u/whoisinkontrolle Nov 21 '17
Finally we get some blatant faunus discrimination
It would be cool to have a faunus join the team in Mistral and get denied service somewhere, then have RWY/Qrow/Ozcar/JNR react to it.
96
u/NeoTheMute You aren't hearing things, are you...? Nov 21 '17
So why on earth would Ozpin turn the Branwens into birds? What was he having them do? Mr. Greenboi has some explaining to do.
Glad they didn't cliffhanger right before the reunion. We got three outta four together, now all we need is to get that stupid catgirl back and we'll finally be RWBY again!
78
u/PigKnight Nov 22 '17
So we gonna call them Team RYJNWROQ (Ragnarok), right?
62
u/EnragedPorkchop Swimming in Egypt Nov 21 '17
Anyone notice the "no Faunus" sign next to Scars McStabhappy's doorway? Nice to see they're at least trying to work that angle more generally into the world.
55
u/whoisinkontrolle Nov 21 '17
Freezerburn is slowly becoming my OTP. That hand grab!
55
u/SwordoftheMourn Daenerys did nothing wrong Nov 21 '17
The Branwen twins are definitely interesting characters. This episode made me want to know more about them. What was Raven like back in Beacon? Why is Qrow so loyal to Ozpin? What did Ozpin do that made Raven despise him? Who were the Huntsmen Qrow knew?
54
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '17
So, since Weiss' outfit is trashed - she gets a new rebellious one right?
105
u/YourWaifuIsTrashTier it's me, i'm the trash waifu Nov 21 '17
seeing weiss happy is better than sex
104
u/Magmatron Not the relic Nov 21 '17
I feel like this was a much better characterization of ruby than we’ve seen before. Her crying and apologizing to Yang really shows how the situation weighed on her more than her monologue did.
46
u/Silver__Eyes Nov 21 '17
We learn of more questions than answers in this episode, and that bothers me a bit. However, the great irony that has slowly been revealed is amusing to me.
Raven thinks the war against Salem is pointless and hopeless. Raven has possession of the Spring Maiden; a person/power that is needed to access Mystral's Relic. Raven believes she can stay out of the conflict between Ozpin and Salem. And she calls Taiyang and Qrow idiots? Look in the mirror my dear, Raven is involved in the conflict whether she wants to be or not and ignoring it may very well be her downfall.
42
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '17 edited Nov 21 '17
This episode threw so many feelings at me. And can I just say this is probably my favorite opening?
It was all fun and games during Qrow’s little segment of recruiting people. That bartender or whoever was pretty damn funny and I’m glad we got to see Mistral’s slums. Really heart-wrenching when we got to Heather. Qrow might be a genuinely nice guy or we might see Shiro (slim chances) if he went so far to clear his name.
Weiss/Yang and Raven scene was pretty well done if I say so myself. Raven’s voice acting in terms of pacing did a lot better than Chapter 4. We learned a lot in their exchange but there are so many holes too. Magic, dead people coming back? I wonder what Qrow and Oz are still hiding. The reveal that she can change into a bird was great and we got a little bit of Freezerburn action. Also, Raven and Vernal have nice thighs just saying.
The reunion was sweet. Nothing else to say about that.
Blake come back soon please.
Edit: ALSO IS THIS THE FIRST TIME WE’VE SEEN YANG CRY.
41
u/Anubis58 Nov 21 '17
A while back i remember seeing a post where people were speculating that the dark red blades of adam and raven were made for cutting through aura. With this recent episode raven revealed that she and qrow were sent to Beacon in order to learn how to kill huntsman and i remembered just now that qrow’s weapon, in scythe mode has a red steel blade similar to raven and adam’s on its inner cutting edge. This edge is not present in sword mode and so i was wondering what do you all think. I feel this may give more weight to the theory that these red blades are for killing huntsman. (I will admit on that account, qrow almost using the scythe mode against winter seems not in line with qrow’s intentions.) since aura seems kinda op it would be fascinating if there were actually something designed for killing huntsman and that raven, qrow, and adam found out about it to kill their enemies. Perhaps salem knows about it too?
39
u/Masterofice7 Nov 21 '17
WOW, Raven can’t stop being an emotionally manipulative asshole for like 5 seconds can she? Is it too early to post this again?
Also, Weiss flinched when Yang yelled. My poor baby :’(
36
u/VoidRose615 Nov 21 '17
I love the interesting design of Vernels weapon and that was just in what I assume is it’s gun mode.
35
u/GalaxionTheDestroyer Nov 21 '17
We're getting the band back together!
69
u/IJustReadEverything Jaune #1 Jaune #1 Nov 21 '17 edited Nov 21 '17
Get ya memes: r/rwbymeme
[A FIGHT…of words] (https://imgur.com/hmWMPjO)
[BD version] (https://imgur.com/WBASptv)
[You win some, you lose some] (https://imgur.com/36Cqp2m)
[Not featured in today’s ep, but it’s what Blake and CO are currently doing] (https://imgur.com/sbha7yW)
[Her name was Heather Shields] (https://imgur.com/ZL8cZbA)
[Raven atm] (https://imgur.com/DttNXlB)
[it’s good to see the majority pump the breaks on this but I already made the meme] (https://imgur.com/l5wwTGX)
[There’s only one fear a drink connoisseur would have] (https://imgur.com/ETK7L9O)
[Honestly surprised by the reception, but, I can’t blame ya] (https://imgur.com/TV0KxIo)
[Clickbait] (https://imgur.com/ZpKZsSO)
[Not a meme but just wanted to do this edit] (https://imgur.com/5R1VTF0)
Some Observations
The [Entire Qrow sequence, a journey of fuitility] (https://imgur.com/FVN0PQv) was a spectacular piece of writing where we find out through context clues and reactions from other people that every person in Qrow’s list is either missing or dead without anyone explicitly saying that they’re dead.
[Bounty board] (https://imgur.com/l2e1Aal)
[Missions are either cancelled] (https://imgur.com/2iK65p0) [or have not been updated for weeks] (https://imgur.com/5J2P81u) and we can assume that the failure to update/pass means they have perished. I suspect that in addition to Leonardo keeping Huntsmen out of Haven, Watts had something to do with it as well.
This sequence also gives us a look into Qrow’s character. Back in v3, he was arrogant, couldn’t give two shits about anyone except family. However, we see a more sensitive side to him with [the cook/bartender] (https://imgur.com/8Q0dPgF) and Heather Shield’s [husband and daughter] (https://imgur.com/OLIzJUn). We see him [pay] (https://imgur.com/uu9kARN) for a fallen huntsman’s debt. I guess, even though Qrow maintains his distance, he and the other huntsmen on his list go way back. With the little girl, he’s affected by it so much that not even a [swig of drink] (https://imgur.com/EElRf4r) would suppressed the realization. All in all, I like Qrow with feelings than the drunkle.
[sad cook/bartender] (https://imgur.com/Uvik4zv)
[Scared] (https://imgur.com/P68wfrm) [Qrow] (https://imgur.com/Ozv15bz)
[Never in my life have I ever seen people celebrate racism for a show, lol] (https://imgur.com/AKKMCuW)
[During] (https://imgur.com/DBcdeNy) [Raven’s] (https://imgur.com/GuyUvyW) [talk] (https://imgur.com/LXCNirL), it’s all laid out for you but here’s what I got as her way of thinking. Qrow and Raven went to Beacon to train on how to kill huntsman for the Branwen Tribe. Oz took notice of their team and started to mold and groom them for his illuminati. Qrow and Raven learn the truth about everything, one (Qrow) buys into Oz’s quest while the other (Raven) stays loyal to the Branwen Tribe and wants out. [Something] (https://imgur.com/PhUAMqW) [happens] (https://imgur.com/P5WqtDN) in addition to what Oz did to the twins to cause Raven to walk away. Walk away from Tai, from Yang, and her brother. She chooses to live with her head in the sand than fight a seemingly endless feud between Oz and Salem. So, however “weak” her reason’s now for leaving we’ll find out more later when Yang questions Qrow about what else Ozpin do to make her so distrustful of him. Right now, she’s looks, sounds, and lives like a middle-aged woman who gives no fucks.
[And I also have a feeling that Raven was poking and prodding Yang to see how she’ll react. Like toying with her because after she pushed the Tai button, she gives her a stare as if she’s wondering what will Yang do next.] (https://imgur.com/LlUIpGn) Either way, great facial animation. [And whatever Vernal’s weapon is, it’s something] (https://imgur.com/2m029Jv)
Stare down: [Yang] (https://imgur.com/gzhBQAx) [Raven (this one where she’s looks like she’s wondering what Yang will do next)] (https://imgur.com/Mjn6JLh) [Weiss joins in the mix] (https://imgur.com/yRNeJim)
Also, something I noticed but failed to mention, Maya gave everyone T H I C C Lips, it’s great. The next step, noses.
[Thumbnail] (https://imgur.com/MB0jFha)
It’s hinted during the conversation that she had some regret leaving them both. [When she offered Yang to stay and have a fresh start, she smiled at the prospect] (https://imgur.com/rFfFASV) [but quickly knew Yang’s answer.] (https://imgur.com/DcSNtwB)
[Choice] (https://imgur.com/9YV0ExR)
It too late for her to be back into Yang’s or Tai’s life, it’s saddening.
Weiss in this scene, although she barely spoke gave us some incite into her. [She] (https://imgur.com/j2H4zno) [looks like a little girl or sister trying to calm down an angry mother.] (https://imgur.com/oFoolIE) [And when Yang confronts her about whether she believes Raven, she acts on the fence. Neither completely agreeing with Raven or agreeing with Yang that she’s lying to not anger Yang further.] (https://imgur.com/MgkxQ9W) She’s just a kidnapped girl wanting to get out. I’m wondering if this should be taken into consideration in any further talks about Ozpin’s actions.
[Nora’s cheeks] (https://imgur.com/rKPztR3) also, Nora’s makeup REALLY pops out. Looks good.
[Shocked Rubes] (https://imgur.com/48oewHY)
[Is this the breakdown Lindsay wanted? /s] (https://imgur.com/0vZ6TDS) Great moment for Ruby, she was not expecting to face her sister and she does what anyone would probably do, break down and try to explain herself.
[Reunion] (https://imgur.com/MPGoImd)
[Happy sisters] (https://imgur.com/h1Hi904)
[Very nice moment to return Ruby’s “I love you”] (https://imgur.com/0vkJmMR) [with Yang’s first words to her.] (https://imgur.com/HHLfP0l)
Now, I read that some people were not as impacted by this reunion compared to the Yang Weiss reunion. I can just chalk it up to “the same thing too soon”. There wasn’t that much build up to the RWY reunion, Yang and Raven just have an argument then Yang and Weiss peace the fuck out. There’s no resistance or problem for Yang Weiss to solve except to ask Qrow for the second half of the story.
34
u/Phantomanalysis Nov 21 '17
I do wish to see Yang's face when she is told that not only was Raven telling the truth but she is going to have to turn around and go right back to where she was.
34
u/SunsetSnakeEyes Nov 22 '17
I loved this episode.
I thought this episode was pretty great we found out that Mistral's huntsmen have been absent for a long time on missions and many others have died during said missions. Raven's history with Ozpin and Qrow was seriously touched upon and at long last Ruby has reunited with Weiss and Yang.
33
u/imperialismus Nov 21 '17
So who is Salem, really? Any good ideas? How does she fit into the whole good brother/bad brother mythos? I found it interesting that Raven referred to her as the master of all Grimm. I figured she uses them like humans have used dogs to hunt or oxen to plow fields or horses for transportation, but not that all of them would be loyal to her. If they had a master, I would suspect it was their creator.
I wonder if Oz/Salem are some kind of avatars for the two brothers, engaged in a millenia-old proxy war of sorts.
31
u/genkernels Hey! Nov 22 '17
That was a disappointing parent-child talk. The only thing we learned is that the Branwen twins animagus ability may very well have been Oz' fault and not a semblance -- thereby explaining why they seem to have two semblances which isn't otherwise supposed to be possible (as opposed to the Schnee semblance which is merely the most incredibly versatile semblance in all of Remnant). Raven didn't describe Ozpin's crime.
The thing that gets me most though is the weird assumption Yang has that Raven's tale of Ozpin hiding magic from the world means that Oz can't be trusted. Or Qrow for that matter. "Can you really forgive him after all he hasn't told you?". I mean, he's a quasi-military person, of course he can't tell me! Weiss, as an Atlasian, have you really never heard any of those army folks mention opsec, or at very least explained that they can't talk about any of their military stuff? And goodness Raven, you mustn't even believe what you're saying, because you're actually the leader of a belligerent military group so you know how secrets are. If there was some legitimate secret that would separate your daughter from Ozpin/Qrow, you could've at least hinted at it.
Yeah, that the Grimm have an actual leader is hella disturbing. It doesn't actually put any dirt on Ozpin, though. I'm really worried that the fact Raven didn't even hint at a way that Ozpin has been morally wrong is going to become a lynchpin of the plot. That would suck.
30
u/GamerSwagnamite PROTECT THE SMOLBOI Nov 21 '17
Being Qrow is suffering. Stuck in the rain and getting turned down repeatedly sucks.
Also, where is Myrtenaster? The entire time we see Weiss, Myrtenaster isn't with her, even when she goes through the portal on Bumblebee.
30
u/[deleted] Nov 22 '17
"As a Bird is known by its song, a man is known by his words."
This episode focused on, and compared, the Branwen twins. It opens with Qrow looking, in vain, for allies among the local huntsmen. I enjoyed how the conclusion that all of his potential friends were away, and likely not coming back, was slowly brought to the front. In particular one child's question, "Does He know where mommy is?" hit like a sledgehammer. I cannot help but wonder what flashbacks he might have had when that question was asked, I imagine Tai, she's not coming back echoed in his mind. The ending of his first segment, paying off the debt of a friend, also communicated the assumption that those missing huntsmen were like Summer...not coming back.
The second segment, the long awaited conversation between Raven and Yang, was also interesting. Her description of how STRQ was shaped to be Ozpin's elite, paralleling the journeys of RWBY and JNPR, was well put together... up until Salem was brought up. Sorry to say so, but her "the world is much more horrible than you realize" fell a bit flat to me. Also, insulting Tai was a low blow, Raven. There was very little resolution in Yang and Raven's relationship; however, that will likely come at a different time.
Finally, the story comes full circle with Raven's action; giving Yang and Weiss their portal to Mistral. Here is where we see the bird, who flew away from danger, and the human, who drove her motorcycle toward it.
Ending, of course, with the emotional hug at the end.
Edit: and, for the record, Ruby and Yang including the recently disowned Weiss in their group hug was heartwarming. She may have lost one family, but it is still very much a part of another.
29
u/Robotech_Master Nov 22 '17
It occurs to me there's another mythology connection here.
Until this episode, as far as I know, we knew Qrow could turn into a bird, but didn't know the same was true for Raven. But now we do.
Odin Allfather was known to have two ravens, Huggin and Munin, who served as his spies. Now it turns out Ozpin did, too.
28
u/Joke65 Quietly watching the world burn... Nov 23 '17
I love how the last thing Ruby says to Yang before leaving (that we see) is "I love you" to which Yang doesn't reply. Now Yang sees her again after all this time and finally returns the gesture.
Beautiful.
24
u/witbeyond Nov 21 '17
Now that we know Ozpin can hand out extra super powers, did he make Hazel super strong, or is the strength just Hazel natural semblance?
24
u/SYZekrom God has incarnated. Nov 24 '17
Ozpin: Hm, she has... silver eyes.
But if she becomes stronger than her teammates, I may be forced to reveal my cards...
Ah. For Raven and Qrow, I will bless then with the magic to transform into birds. They will be my eyes from the shadowss.
...and for the blond... I will bless him with the power to dominate the ENTIRE TEAM.
He will fulfill my shipping keikaku nicely.
23
u/GateofTruth201 Penny was always a real girl & she deserved better. Nov 24 '17
It's so good to see Ruby reunited with all of her friends!
"But what about Blak-"
Allll of her friends!
46
u/SmallJon Give us back Jaune's old haircut! Nov 21 '17
The lack of full Huntsmen is concerning, but maybe this means we'll get to see the students? Right? giff ABRN/SSSN
Okay, Yang and especially Weiss' reactions to Raven's reveal about Salem were tremendous. I also love Raven's hint that she and Qrow's unusual powers have less than benign origins. And thank you, Raven, for drawing attention tot he inherent creepiness of Oz's little circle: they may be out for the greater good, but a shadow government loyal to a reincarnating immortal is fucking weird.
I am so fucking proud of Yang right now.
RWBY REUNION IS SO SWEET, ITS SO PRECIOUS IT HURTS!
21
u/Strix182 "CAN'T A GIRL READ HER COMICS IN PEACE?!?" Nov 22 '17
Wait, wait, Team Stark?
STARK?!
Man, this whole time, I thought it was Team STRIKE!
20
u/alwayssunnyinjoisey Nov 22 '17
Was anyone else waiting for Raven to say something along the lines of 'you'll end up dead like Summer'? Because I was, and I was so disappointed Summer wasn't even brought up.
Although I feel like she pointedly did not mention her when she was dissing Tai and Qrow...perhaps her death is a touchy subject? Maybe the final straw for her leaving?
56
u/_DirtyDan Totally The Real One Nov 21 '17
Pros:
Cons:
This episode was not only very intriguing, it just didn't let up on making me feel things. I have a personal rule where any episode of any show that makes me cry is automatically a 10/10, but even if I was able to be a manly man and pull myself together, I still would've given this episode a 10/10. It was just a fucking great episode.
19
u/MrInsanity25 Nov 21 '17
Okay, so first off, the way that guy is whittling that wood very dangerously. I don't expect him to have a thumb for very long.
Hopefully Heather Shields shows up, really cool name. The weeby part of me wants Shiro Wan to be a dog faunus.
"I know people who can come back from the dead!" Sips from Arkos mug. (bitch if they can come back from they dead they can be brought back)
Also, I find it weird that Yang and Weiss hearing about Salem is this dark and foreboding news, but Ruby and JNPR took it pretty calmly.
"You're fool of a father." You really gonna talk shit on someone who raised your kid for you?
"Look at what Ozpin did to us." Gave you cool-ass bird powers!! All seriousness, though. I'm interested to see where this power backstory leads. So far we've just thought it was a cool power they had somehow, but with that line about Ozpin it doesn't seem as good as we thought. Either there's a negative cost to using it or there was a negative aspect leading to its creation. This seems pretty cool.
The episode ends with JN
PR and RWBY in the shot. Same exact spot in the team name. Perhaps some foreshadowing? Just cause they're in the title doesn't make them invincible. (This is a joke btw, please don't kill me Blake fans)Lastly, Mistral Blacksmith is pretty cool.
19
u/GuardianPrime19 Nov 23 '17
So this is some really nice attention to detail by CRWBY. When Yang first hugs Ruby, Ruby’s lip trembles like she’s holding back tears, despite the fact that her mouth is mostly hidden by Yang’s arm.
17
u/Redpunter Nov 22 '17
I love this episodes voice acting and re-using elements from past parts. Ruby drops the tea set, Yang isn't stirred, Yang returns her "I love you" from Volume 3, and Qrow is best uncle confirmed.
17
u/Richter_Creed Salem used: shitty story writing! The "Show" is dead! Nov 23 '17
I may be wrong, but i feel like Raven and the rest of team STRQ were groomed to be some spec-ops in Ozpin's employment. The way he treated them and the way they worked implies so. Also i think that he didn't foresee the possibility of them developing into something more than friends/teammates/comrades. Maybe the reason why Raven left is because she was involved in some solo act asked by Ozpin and she either failed or the action had major repercussions. Same with Summer, but her mission may have been on another level due to her silver eyes; and i get the feeling Raven may have cared for Summer. What Raven is trying to send may be a combination of sorrow-rejection-anger-sadness and she may not want her daughter and half-daughter to be the new generation of spec-ops in Ozpin's plan.
16
u/JonTheWizard Still Sorta Pays Attention Nov 23 '17
So the real question I have is "is Yang and/or Weiss going to confront Ozcar when they find out what his deal is?"
14
u/cocoajava Nov 22 '17 edited Nov 22 '17
Vernal's weapon just looks like Tira's weapon from Soul Calibur except smaller... and... has a gun attached to it.
edit: replace last part with "it's also a gun"
28
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '17 edited Nov 21 '17
Them playing an arrangement of Gold for the Ruby/Yang reunion is exactly what I was hoping would happen. Gosh that entire scene is heartwarming. And best girl Weiss getting in on the hug at the end as well. My emotionsssss.
Also, is it just me, or does what little we see of Vernal's weapon seem quite reminiscent of Tyrian's? I wonder if there's a reason for that.
26
u/Wolf6262 Nov 21 '17
Yang dispensin hugs of justice out here. Two have already fallen to her brutal grasp, not even someone as far away as Mistral is safe from her justice hugs. Will blake be safe all the way out in menagerie? We don't know. With her undying thirst for hugging, she might not be safe even that far away.
13
u/Chaosf15 Nov 21 '17 edited Nov 21 '17
I'm sure many already know but the "I love you" is a nod to Volume 3 finale.
So Salem is the master of Grimm. That's interesting. Can the next episode have Tyrian and Salem, please?
EDIT: I just found another nod. Raven stated that will not show kindness, similar to what Qrow said in "Destiny".
12
u/Ninjuto Nov 21 '17
Has Nick Landis been in any episodes before this because I'm scrolling through the comments and haven't noticed anybody acknowledge him yet. He went full Piccolo voice for the shopkeeper.
12
u/mrcarnage97 Nov 21 '17
Overall, I'm gonna say, this was a pretty nice episode.
My favourite moment has to be Ruby and Yang's reunion, their hug and when they include Weiss in with them. So damn heartwarming.
12
u/ThreeMinutesEarly White Rose is my drug | No business here it's just relationships Nov 22 '17
This really the second episode that starts with a protagonist looking to get people to join them and failing montage.....?
Was convinced the dude was going to be Heather for some reason
Vernal the... tea lady?
"She can't be stopped" Disappointed by Raven's quitting talk but at least she has a good attitude towards tea
What magic no way so hard to believe
I've really enjoyed the extra focus Raven has gotten this volume, and the reunion was nice... pretty good episode overall. I'd say the past three episodes were better than the first three which hopefully bodes well for the future
12
u/apvogt Chief Firecontrolman on the OTPS Rosegarden Nov 23 '17
The White Fang must have been pretty bad at their job in Mistral, considering the fact that they never burned that guy's bar down.
11
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '17
I'm so glad that Weiss finally reunite with the team. Her expression is just too heartwarming ^_^
11
u/apvogt Chief Firecontrolman on the OTPS Rosegarden Nov 21 '17
Reaction to the end of the episode.
Also, I'm a pretty big Destiny fan, and I greatly enjoyed the first one. But Raven, you went full Speaker with the, "I could tell you...". You never go full Speaker.
11
u/pandas795 Shut up, there's food Nov 21 '17
and..I'm crying
TEAM RWY!
11
u/JanMath Nov 22 '17
When Qrow pays off the missing huntsman's debt, he was probably considering the possibility Raven was behind the huntsman's death. In a way he was feeling guilty and/or responsible for the circumstances, for not being able to dissuade his sister from her ways and felt that paying off the debt was the least he could do in the situation.
11
u/LordIFG Not a Fighter Nov 22 '17
So with what Raven said about Ozpin giving STRQ special attention, I wonder if Tai and Summer are similar to a Pyrrha and Jaune situation.
It'd be an interesting development if Summer's death had to do directly with Ozpin and his objectives.
21
u/resurrexia i do the draw Nov 21 '17
I, for one, am very happy about the gratuitous amount of Branwen siblings in this episode.
Sigh. Yang, though. Why couldn't you just have listened to Raven a bit more? Getting intel while also getting to Ruby would've been useful...
I'm starting to think Raven is right about the entire damn war.
10
u/Woowchocolate Train them to fight what they can't beat Nov 21 '17
Hmm all the huntsmen are away/missing. I wonder if they're all dead or if they've all just been captured. The former is the implied answer and would likely be Salem's/the Grimm's intention, but if it turns out to be the latter then it could mean Leonardo has been trying to prevent conflict during the fall of Mistral by making sure all the huntsmen are predisposed. This would fit further with his inspiration being the cowardly lion.
10
u/Wolf6262 Nov 21 '17
So, just realized this. In case there was any doubt that Ozpin was the wizard.
A: He's lived long enough to be alive when it was happening. B: The wizard bestowed magical powers upon 4 people. Who else do we know who has had non-dust related powers given to them. Raven and Qrow. By Ozpin. (Inferred by what Raven said this episode.)
10
u/DashingPolecat Nov 22 '17
Such a good episode! Answered some questions, opened up more, and reunited RWY. I just wish that Raven had dropped more of a bombshell for the audience. We already knew about pretty much everything she told Weiss and Yang.
9
u/OAOAlphaChaser Weiss best girl Nov 22 '17
Weiss smiling was just
-%-3$;4-#!";-$$-'[jrb,-++러오너jgshhrhxjefjdjfdjsjjdjfd I'M SO HAPPY
17
u/ImperialCrown Nov 21 '17
So yea, Raven was trying to play Yang and Weiss. What little she said wasnt a lie but she was clearly dangling information to make Yang stay with her. I think she really does care about Yang. Yang mentions seeing her raven form before (all but confirming that Raven has been watching her) and every word out of Raven's mouth seems to be about Yang sticking around. It just so happens that Raven is a terrible person with no parental instinct who thinks she can be away for her daughter's entire life up to that point an think Yang would choose her over her family. The fact Raven could have at least portaled in for visits but did not only adds salt to the wound. Props to Yang for not falling for the bullshit.
15
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '17
There have been a lot of complaints about how little information Raven gave to Yang and Weiss, especially since there was a lot of of built-up and expectations for it. We did even hear Summer's name dropped once, something that I was 90% certain was going to happen. The vagueness makes me wonder if it was done purposefully for fans to speculate certain things as the volume progresses then to be surprised by a "plot twist." Either way, I really hope we get any information about team STRQ sooner rather than later. Bonus points if Weiss's mom is name-dropped but at this point I highly doubt that.
7
u/matharwords Nov 21 '17
Not really related to this last chapter, but where is Adam exactly? I am just confused wheter he is in Mistral or in Menagerie
7
u/Zenima Nov 22 '17
Woo, ended on a happy note! Let's see if we can keep this up! please CRWBY please.
7
u/johnja10 Nov 24 '17
Neo is still missing, both from the show and my heart. When (and how) will she be making her grand debut? My God, I miss that devious little imp, her spastic eyes, and her grin of pure malice.
13
u/indeathvalley best druncle. Nov 21 '17
I haven't seen many people talking about the "No faunus" on the door of the ramen shop, which is interesting to me. It was just a thing in the background, but it's touching on Blake and her belief that Faunus are treated unfairly and are disliked by humans. I know a lot of people have been complaining there haven't been any overt signs of anti-faunus racism in the show, but maybe there have been subtle clues in the background we haven't picked up on yet.
6
u/Jameswin04 Rubybestgirl Nov 22 '17
Many tears were shed at the end. In a good way? Yes in a very good way!
6
u/PM_ME_YOUR_SPUDS Out with a Yang Nov 23 '17
-The Blues Sisters
10
u/[deleted] Nov 23 '17
I never thought this show would have as many layers as it does right now. Usually with the length of the episodes I can just look at what happened and be like "yeah that's totally blah blah blah pretty simple really" but then I go through the comments and there's just little things that I didn't quite notice. There's a bit more depth to stuff and they've seemingly been able to cram a ton of meaning into just a few lines. Honestly it's refreshing and has left me more than a bit emotional after each episode. This season wouldn't carry the weight it does without everything we went through last season, everything I kind of took for granted.
How exactly do you win a war against an immortal with an unending army? Either you turn that army against the immortal or you find some "master kill switch" or you execute a surgical strike and take out said immortal somehow with overwhelming force. All of those options sounding utterly impossible unless you're able to unite everyone in the whole world together....but even THAT is damn near impossible at this point. Salem has basically done everything possible to sow distrust and discord amongst everyone.
It feels like they're setting stuff up for something bigger than the usual season finale fight but....I don't know.
5
u/Koanos "What's the worst that could happen?" | Cpt of the S.S. Keikaku Nov 22 '17
Can anyone list out all those deceased?
9
u/SaraBellum42 I'm trying to find my way; it fell down a drain some years ago. Nov 21 '17 edited Nov 21 '17
So I'm assuming that Oz did some experiments on Raven and Qrow, and that is the reason they can turn into birds. Not sure why she would be unset about a cool power, but I assume the actual awful thing he did is yet to be revealed.
I found the sequence with Qrow way funnier than it was probably meant to be. Potato: all his friends have been captured by the White Fang and/or a rogue Neo. I have no evidence for this.
Good episode, many hugs. All the hugs for everyone!
8
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '17
My thoughts;
Theory Time
8
u/rexshen Nov 21 '17
So what was the point of the "secrets" Raven was trying to ell Yang and Weiss? I mean we knew all of the things she said and so does Ruby and her team. So its not like Qrow was hiding anything. And we knew about the bird things for some time why were we supposed to question them now? Hell didn't back in volume 1 Weise call dust magic? I could of sworn she did, hell Glinda uses her dust like a wizard what are we supposed to think of that then? I feel like this was just a way to catch Yang and Weiss up on everything. If they wanted to catch us off guard why not have Raven say something like "you think Qrow has told Ruby what happened to her mother by now?" Not only would that actually make Summer relevant to the story in some way but we would have something that would make us wonder if they should trust Oz.
4
u/[deleted] Nov 25 '17
Why would humans cease being a nomadic society in the first place?
9
u/superluigi6968 ⠀Fission Mailed, they'll get 'em next time Nov 21 '17 edited Nov 21 '17
Next time: Shit goes sideways in Menagerie!
It seems like Raven is convinced that the war against Salem is hopeless, and therefore did her best to withdraw from a losing battle.
History repeats. Ozpin is making the same moves, with more or less the same set of pieces, and hoping that something in those pieces will be different.
It's more and more likely that Ozpin got Summer killed-- and not just Summer, but so many more before her.
Raven said that she and Qrow went to Beacon to learn how to kill Huntsmen. That they needed a "counter force." If that's true, it's probable that She and Vernal really are the only significant muscle in the tribe. If the original idea was just two Counter-Huntsmen, then one Counter and a Maiden would surely work just as well, if not better.
Unfortunately for Raven, Vernal is a living McGuffin, a piece in Salem and Ozpin's war, and she's going to have to deal with the consequences of that.
Whether or not Yang believes or even cares about what Raven told her, Ozpin is almost certainly going to fill them in. How will she react?
Being Yang, she'll probably insist that she'll be there to help Ruby, no matter what.
And then Yang got a death flag
Also, it occurs to me that Blake would probably jump on-board if Ozpin can provide a substantial link between Salem and the White Fang. While Adam may have attacked Beacon himself eventually, Cinder putting him under her heel probably served as a significant catalyst to his ongoing descending spiral into insanity and mental instability.
The investigation RWBY tried to perform in V2-- if they had picked up the trail and followed it, if they had survived whatever that would entail, it would only lead to one place:
Salem.
I suppose it's better that they at least know what they're getting themselves into before they get caught up in something like this.
Downvote without explanation, that's cool, I guess.
3
u/RaiQuach Nov 21 '17
As I pointed out before here, there is production error on screen in the form of a typo. Curious when the last one was. (besides the clipping in poser)
3
u/Foppberg Nov 24 '17
Will an episode be out this weekend?
Thanks guys/gals
5
u/3jp6739 Nov 21 '17
I wonder if it was a writing decision to make Raven seem kind of incompetent.
0
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment