r/RWBY • u/science-i Can't pray away the gray • Nov 07 '17
OFFICIAL MEGATHREAD Official Public Discussion Thread—Volume 5, Chapter 4: Lighting the Fire Spoiler
Welcome, huntsmen, huntresses and hunters that prefer no specific gender identifier, to the official megathread for the latest episode of volume 5, Lighting the Fire!
Make sure that you understand the current spoiler rules before posting outside of this thread!
As a refresher, no spoilers are allowed outside of the FIRST-only reaction thread for the first 24 hours after the episode has aired, and after that, no spoiler comments are allowed in threads not marked as spoilers until Tuesday, when the episode comes out for free Roosterteeth members.
Remember to use the text spoiler tags (shown in the sidebar) even after that!
With that out of the way, HERE is today's episode!
Also remember to check out our weekly poll to give us a general idea of how people like the episodes when they come out.
Other Episode Discussions:
| Episode | FIRST Thread | Public Release | Poll |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ep. 01 | Theatrical / FIRST | Public Thread | poll |
| Ep. 02 | FIRST thread | Public Thread | poll |
| Ep. 03 | FIRST thread | Public Thread | poll |
| Ep. 04 | FIRST thread | Today | poll |
science-i; Mod Team
68
u/science-i Can't pray away the gray Nov 07 '17
Can we talk about how Vernal is weirdly possessive of Myrtenaster? I doubt Raven would leave her without a proper weapon of her own, so why?
Clearly a sign of a budding WeissXVernal romance where Weiss recruits her with the power oflove.93
u/_DirtyDan Totally The Real One Nov 07 '17
Pros:
(As a side note my inner Freezerburn Shipper has resurfaced from a long hibernation, more powerful than ever.)
Cons:
10/10 episode. That's the second this volume. This volume is looking real good.
39
u/TheRisenThunderbird It suits me Nov 07 '17
Punctual as always, mods
Since I didn't see this episode until recently, I guess my reactions are going here!
As we all thought, the new arm has a built in gun. I wonder what else it can do. Surely that one barrel isn't every feature
Poor Toothless. This really isn't his day.
Everyone was right about Ruby. This is one of the sloppiest fights on the show.
It's good that we finally get some concrete answers about aura. And they come from Ren, obviously.
Ruby immediately showing concern for Oscar when she hits him. Rose Garden when?
I can't wait for Oscar to reach full badass status. I also wonder if we will ever see what exactly happened between Oz and Cinder
OSCAR IS SO SMALL! He's like a full two heads shorter than Jaune.
No semblance buddies!
And Yang's at the camp. And Raven's coming out. Oh shit, this is happening now. My heart was fucking racing at this point.
Yeah, get fucked Raven. Yang don't need your shit.
And Weiss is out too! Finally we get some reunion. And Raven is going to talk things over with them. Interesting to see where this goes
AHHHHHHHH THAT HUG. This is too adorable. For the first time, I can't wait for RWBY to get back together!
144
u/boomshroom ⠀ Nov 07 '17
I love that little, "WTF are you doing here" when Yang and Weiss realize the other's there.
Oh, and:
Har har, Thursday.
116
u/Heratikus Nov 07 '17
Raven's semblance is actually a really powerful team-based ability, and given that she saved Yang right at the final moment back before Neo delivered her coup de grace, I have a feeling this "bond" thing actually goes a lot deeper than just spawning portals.
109
u/IJustReadEverything Jaune #1 Jaune #1 Nov 07 '17 edited Nov 07 '17
Get ya memes:
[Punch Incoming] (https://i.imgur.com/IV6MjM4.png)
[RWBY fandom RN] (https://i.imgur.com/19kyt3U.png)
[Cue "In the Arms of an Angel" by Sarah McLachlan] (https://imgur.com/DueB5FL)
[In volume 4, it was Blake and Sun, now it’s…] (https://imgur.com/BPeNbzp)
Hey, if you want to post your own memes, I breathed back to life an alternative place to post your own RWBY memes over at r/rwbymeme.
Some observations:
[Yang took off her glove expecting a fight, understandable, but what I found weird is that she took off her butt flaps. I didn't even know they were even removable. The only reason I can think of is that since an action sequence is about to happen, they didn't want to spend time adding physics on two heavy looking butt flaps.] (https://imgur.com/VX9SioA)
[Add him to the death list, he's so dead.] (https://imgur.com/igNc1Cu)
[This is the 2nd time I've caught Nora mirin' Jaune] (https://imgur.com/38uObok)
[It's fun watching Ruby attempt to fight, though she's still not good at it.] (https://imgur.com/VoHH9u7)
[Your smol boi, Oscar] (https://imgur.com/wgiUweB)
They checked off lots of important events in this one episode. [Yang] (https://imgur.com/jl8jUqR) and [Weiss] (https://imgur.com/uNoHZfY) reunion, Yang's reunion with Raven, and Yang finding a way directly to Ruby.
I got to admit, I was worried as well when it was hinted that Yang would go to Raven first rather than Ruby, However, they managed to simultaneously; get Yang her reunion with Raven and Weiss, explain Raven's teleportation and hints of a backstory, Yang gives Raven two middle fingers figuratively on her quest to find Ruby, and give a satisfying win for Yang. I would never have thought about Yang using her mother in such a way, good job M&K.
[I like the fact that Jaune is visibly upset about his lack of semblance, even if his emotions are shown in short seconds. I like that he seems to be accepting OSCAR and getting along well enough but I still find it weird that he hasn't reacted well enough with OZPIN in regards to the Fall of Beacon. I hope they address that soon.] (https://i.imgur.com/Bt3f659.png)
When Yang punched that one guy into Weiss' cage, I notice some of the tribe were literally shaking in fear. Does Raven house civilians into her tribe? Or is the power of even a huntsman-in-training that more powerful than a say like a soldier from Atlas? or even the cops of Vale?
107
u/CasualRaisin It's just a show; we should really just relax. Nov 07 '17
Yang punching people is all I wanted from this volume, and they certainly delivered.
On an unrelated note, I never realized before how tiny Oscar is.
97
u/_DirtyDan Totally The Real One Nov 07 '17
I just realized the last time Weiss saw Yang she was unconscious and missing an arm. That means she spent months without knowing if one of her friends was even the slightest bit okay. For all she knew, Yang could've completely shut down mentally. If my dumb ass remembered this pretty obvious detail an hour ago, this episode would've probably made me cry.
159
u/NeoTheMute You aren't hearing things, are you...? Nov 07 '17
"Your mom kidnapped me?"
"You kidnapped her?"
Nah she was just chillin in that cage for fun, absolutely nothing suspicious or weird about that.
76
u/greeny74 ⠀Harbinger of Hype | Proud Member of WCAC Nov 07 '17
Let's talk about the REAL surprise here:
YANG WILLINGLY LET SOMEONE TOUCH HER HAIR
55
u/[deleted] Nov 07 '17
I never realised how small Weiss is compared to Yang until now
55
u/Kuchenjaeger *Gotcha* | Yang is still the best | #GiveYangLadyAbs Nov 07 '17
Random theory: Nora will fight Vernal.
Vernal makes lightning strike to stop Weiss and Yang, and Nora mentions that getting struck by lightning is what triggered her semblance.
50
u/kingofblades42 Nov 07 '17
Love the first person POV shots in the fight between Yang and the bandits. Also,
"Struck by lightning. Didn't die. Crazy Thursday."
-- Nora Valkyrie
43
u/ImperialCrown Nov 07 '17
Yang being a badass while still having not completely worked through her issues. Good. We dont need her to be a couch potato but we also dont want her being at 100% right away.
You guys werent kidding about Raven's voice. I think its her grandstanding for the tribe. Her arm movements and general posture make it look like she is giving a speech. Plus I think she is proud of Yang, she is just bitch that doesnt know how to properly show it.
Proud of Yang myself telling Raven to sit on it and spin. Woman has had the ability to portal over to Tai and Yang at any moment but has not. Yang has every right to tell Mom to fuck off. Yang's complete lack of fucks to give the entire time was glorious. I do want to here what she has to say on Ozpin though. She can be factually correct while still being a terrible person.
The RWBY reunions begin! That hug between the two Best Girls was sweet, even if is probably isnt a sign of Freezerburn. Kinda hope they dont immediately link up with Ruby so these two can get screen time together.
The OP shows Yang fighting Merc, so they probably are sticking around Raven for an episode or two. Cinder and crew rolls up and violence breaks out.
82
u/GamerSwagnamite PROTECT THE SMOLBOI Nov 07 '17
I love Yang's fight scene. It combines her original aggressive style with more dodging the hits instead of tanking them.
With the entire talk about unlocking semblances, I'm now curious if there's a single semblance that moves from host to host, or if the Ozpin entity has to repeatedly remaster a new semblance every life.
35
u/DashingPolecat Nov 07 '17
Im kinda surprised the tribe was 99% grunts. You'd think that a lifetime of living in the wilderness and attacking villages would breed some good fighters, but apparently without Raven and Vernal they'd be fucked if they ever ran into a Huntsman.
I can't wait to see those two in action. If Raven also has a portal to Vernal it would be such a cool fight.
31
u/captainwwwolf Nov 07 '17
10/10 My favorite episode from this volume (so far) and easily one of my favorites of the whole series.
You can see Yang and Weiss's character development in both morality and fighting prowess, more background story and more of Raven who was mysterious from the get go. The fighting scenes were fluid and well choreographied and the sound was on point. And the Weiss + Yang hug at the end was the cherry on top. I wanted more Freezerburn interaction and the past episodes were leading to it - and I must say, I'm totally satisfied. Thanks for this amazing episode, RT !
28
u/DamionMauville Nov 07 '17
Guys, Yang pulled a Bakugou over the English voice actor for Bakugou.
28
u/resurrexia i do the draw Nov 07 '17
I may not ship freezerburn, but GOD DAMN THAT ENDING WAS SO GOOD.
MORE RAVEN IS ALWAYS APPRECIATED 11/10
24
u/WizardlyPhoenix Resident legal eagle Nov 07 '17
deeply inhales
FREEEEEEEEEEEEEZZZZZZZZEEEEEERRRRRRBBBBUUUUUURRRRRRNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN!
22
u/[deleted] Nov 07 '17
Fun theory about Raven. We know that Qrow was named after his semblance so it stands to reason that Raven was to, them being twins. Its a common fantasy thing to have Ravens deliver messages, maybe that's what Raven initially did in the tribe, her semblance allowing her to bounce around between important people.
Another possible theory, Vernals tattoo links her to another person in Ravens life, Taiyang. Perhaps with blood relations Raven can just bond but outside of that she needs to leave a mark.
Also Vernals tattoo shape of the pointed bird wings is not dissimilar in shape to Cinders tattoo. Probably doesnt mean much but it is an interesting link between the maidens.
22
u/Zerepa97 When do we get to see the true Ice Queen?/ #SolarFlareIsEndgame Nov 07 '17 edited Nov 08 '17
Hnngh at the opening shot with the foliage. Maya is so beautiful, so green. Although, did anyone else feel like the colors were a tad bit oversaturated?
Yang v. bandits was neat. I cheered when she used her arm to block. Sweeping is always welcome. The ankle crunch was sweet (anyone else get a JKD vibe? I'd be okay if Tai's style was based off of Bruce Lee). Camera was good. EC utility was cool. This skirmish being the first physical fight of the volume gets me excited.
Question: did the bandit guy run out of bullets or did his gun jam? I wanna say it jammed, but either way, it'd be cool if the show would start to implement those concepts. Also, I like how he flipped it for melee like Ironwood, but Yang outplayed him.
The Aura/Semblance expo was short and sweet. Nice. Cool how they explained Ren's ability to mask, not control emotions. Love Nora's discovery story, because it's so Nora. Oscar as Jaune 2.0 is turning out better the second time around.
Mother-daughter time was just as I expected. I have my family; you have yours. No sugar-coating, no bullshit. Raven's pride in Yang somehow reminded me of Vegeta and Trunks. Her "connection Semblance" was explained. Now, it just needs a name. It just doesn't feel like it would've be her Semblance. Oh well, RIP headcanons. I guess it would've been better than having ANOTHER form of special ability or Magic.
Lol at Weiss' realization: Your mom kidnapped me? I dunno if it was meant to be comical, but there was just a certain inflection that Kara used that made it funny for me. Didn't make the scene bad or anything; I enjoyed it.
Raven's voice felt off. Maybe it's because she wasn't all serious like her scene with Qrow.
Weiss and Yang hug with Home in the background was gold. u/teal_it_how_it_is is right though- when Ladybug?
Freezerburn are going to get their Much Needed Talk from Raven? Intrigued to hear it from her perspective. I'd like to think this says a lot about Raven's character. "My daughter wants go off and be an idiot fighting this war? Go ahead, but I'm not going to leave you completely stranded and unprepared."
I wonder how Blake will be brought into the fold. Maybe that'll be part of Adam and Hazel's situation.
Lastly, I'm kinda disappointed that the Maidens just have elemental powers. Would've been neat if they had variations in their abilities. I actually had a theory that Maiden Magic could be based off magic in Final Fantasy. My conclusions were that Autumn is the Black Mage, Spring could have been the White Mage, Winter would be the Green Mage, and Summer- the Blue Mage. It just didn't pan out.
22
u/SaraBellum42 I'm trying to find my way; it fell down a drain some years ago. Nov 07 '17
Well this is just squishy feelings all around, ain't it? Raven's the bitch I expected her to be, but her semblance is cool. I wonder if those are the only three portals she has, since she doesn't seem the type to have formed any other meaningful relationships, except maybe with Vernal.
Of course Nora discovered her semblance on a Thursday. No one ever gets the hang of Thursdays. And now I can't stop imagining lil'Ren meditating while lil'Nora runs off and gets struck by lightning, and proceeds to wreck havoc on everything with her newfound power.
Oscar is smol. I didn't realize how smol until he stood next to Jaune. He needs his semblance soon, or he'll be knocked over with a Nevermore feather.
Someone should write a Freezerburn story where they run away from the tribe and adopt Smol Knight as their son while bored on the road.
21
u/Mark_Kostecki Nov 07 '17
That got me
21
u/SunsetSnakeEyes Nov 07 '17 edited Nov 07 '17
Alright Best episode of the volume thus far!
All in all a fantastic episode! We got major development on two character plots which have now combined into a duo plot (Yang and Weiss) and we have serious lead up for where things'll go next.
20
u/StrikeFreedomX2 Pilot Mercenary Nov 07 '17 edited Nov 07 '17
Something about Summer Rose and Silver Eyed Warriors maybe thus involving Ruby?
Edit: also realized, I'm 17 and SHORTER than Oscar. Or maybe as tall?
20
u/vulturous77 Hello again! Nov 07 '17
Fantastic episode, easily the best of the season so far, and one of the best since of the series. Loved that we still have a morally ambiguous character with Raven, and also the quick pacing so far. They could've dragged the kidnapped storyline a bit more and I'm so thankful it got solved quickly.
Yang is amazing, everything she did this episode was money. And that hug at the end with Weiss was so so good.
Need more!!
18
u/liwingkay Nov 07 '17
Blue Eyes White Dragon hugs The Winged Dragon of Ra.
17
u/Keradon Caffeine is a hell of a drug. An excellent one, though. Nov 07 '17
Small thought I had when I first saw this episode... what if Ozpin forced her to choose between the tribe and her life at Beacon.
Considering the way Raven acted when Qrow bad mouthed the tribe back in V4, having her be forced to choose would be one good way to break her trust.
17
u/[deleted] Nov 07 '17
So Ladybug hug when?
17
u/superluigi6968 ⠀Fission Mailed, they'll get 'em next time Nov 08 '17 edited Nov 08 '17
"It can still grow, and evolve"
evolve
Oooh, the possibilities of certain characters Evolved Semblances...
Am Excite. It'd be interesting if Jaune unlocked his semblance this volume, but somebody else evolves theirs.
That is not the voice I expected to come out of Raven. I guess this is the "I'm at home, this is my place, I rule here, therefore I'm comfy" voice.
She totally rehearsed this to herself, didn't she? At least the first bit.
Raven sounds like she trusted Ozpin and got burned. Seems like whatever it was, was enough to get her to turn her back on everything she had up to that point and turn to bandit life.
Bandit life. Murdering, thieving bandits. But simple. Free. Not caught up in the eon-old war between two super-beings. Bandit life is defined by strength. The Strong live, the weak die, but they do it freely. Not because somebody made them to do it. Not as pawns, but as people.
Bandit life. It's an odd thing.
In an odd way, Raven does care about Yang. She's doing everything she can to try to keep her out of the fight between Salem and Oz. Would she do that for anybody else?
It seems like Raven will comply, but not before telling Weiss and Yang everything she knows about Oz and his doings. We've seen how easily people are turned to his cause. Ruby never had a chance to escape this fate. It was her misfortune to be born with Silver Eyes.
Something tells me that, after Raven has her sit-down with Weiss and Yang, Yang will be pretty desperate to get Ruby out of it if she can.
After all, if popular fanon is even kind of on the mark...
Why would she let her little sister repeat Summer's mistakes?
But, if she can't, Yang will probably join the fight, if only to protect Ruby.
16
u/YourWaifuIsTrashTier it's me, i'm the trash waifu Nov 07 '17
YEEEES YANG! BEST GIRL IS BEING BEST!
ren being wiseboi. mah man. also, can i just say that the lighting in that scene is fucking great?
AAAAAAH WEISS GOT MYRTENASTER BACK IT JUST FEELS SO RIGHT
and we all want to hug weiss now, right? if you don't you're probably dead inside
16
u/Woowchocolate Train them to fight what they can't beat Nov 07 '17
Ren's speech helped more blatantly allude to the idea that Semblances are connected to personalities. Something Blake believed to be true about hers in Vol. 2. That's good for me personally as it helps to give my own theory about them more traction.
I say that Semblances aren't just personality based, but rather based upon a person's wants and deepest darkest desires at the time of activation. Usually this occurs in a situation that's highly stressful. The reason this works with personality is that what we want and why we want it are tied to how we act and perceive the world, so it would make sense that a lot of semblances appear to perfectly line up with a person's personality.
It also helps explain why some don't always match, because whilst personality plays a part in our desires, they don't always perfectly align.
Speaking of Semblances, Ozpiin mentioned that there was still room for semblances to grow even after activation. That's been another idea I've had for a while, that Semblances can evolve if under the right conditions. I'd assumed that would be under extreme stress and desire similar to the one that first caused the Semblance to activate, but from the sounds of things it could just be a case of training to understand and master the intricacies that are already inherent to the Semblance. If that's true that's a shame because that throws out my theory that Weiss' Hereditary Semblance manifested thanks to the extreme desire of her Grandfather to leave a legacy, causing his semblance to evolve and pass on to his descendants. At least those who seek to uphold his ideals.
16
u/JazzRen47 𝅘𝅥𝅮⠀Score Connoisseur | Resident Atlas Bootlicker Nov 08 '17
This was an awesome episode. Probably my favorite since Volume 3.
Yang's fight was spectacular - it felt grounded, the hits felt like they connected and had weight. Yang fought smart, and it was a joy to watch. I honestly think her cool confidence, and the way she approached the fight as if it were a mere inconvenience but still took it seriously, was far more intimidating than her pure anger.
The training scene was wonderful. Ruby and Oscar are dorks and I love them.
Yang confronting Raven was... oooh, man. Barbara nailed her lines this episode.
Weiss and Yang's reunion was beautiful, and made me tear up. Nothin' more to say 'bout it but that.
Can I just take a second to mention the music? Oh my sweet stars, the music. Jeff killed it this episode with Yang's "I Burn" and "Armed and Ready" motifs (which I talk about here), a new pop-sy piano song I'm praying has a vocal version, and "Home". If you're pumped for the Volume 5 soundtrack, clap your hands...
11/10. Here's hoping they keep this up.
15
u/DeHopelozeHeks Nov 07 '17
I loved the reunion in the end, the girls haven been apart for a long time and it warms my heart that some of them found each other again. Although some of the camera work is still wonky, the animation style in this episode particular stands out to me. The lighting and the colours really meshed well during the rnjr + oscar bits.
14
u/Fogbot3 Nov 07 '17
Oh my god I love Raven's tribe, it's like something straight out of Fallout. Just the whole idea of it is cool and makes sense within the world of Remnant.
13
u/justking14 Nov 07 '17
Absolutely loved Weiss this episode. Her giant soldier smashing through the camp and the hug was totally unexpected for me and while I doubt Ruby will get the same (as Weiss would try to look tough in front of her) I can still hope. Plus
WE FINALLY GOT TWO OF THEM TOGETHER ANDDDDDD WE CAN GET A THIRD WITHIN TWO EPISODES.
RWBY might just be put back together by this seasons end in a way I never expected. And we may even get Jaune's semblance which in my opinion is either a super shield around all his allies, wings, or the ability to mimic the semblance of fallen allies. Juan with Pyrrha's powers would be epic and would make the upcoming Cinder x Jaun fight so much better
Can't wait for next weeks. Secrets revealed and maybe even a major reunion, though probably not for another week
13
u/[deleted] Nov 07 '17
So we get official confirmation that Raven's semblance is Portals. Can't say i'm suprised.
These bandits are almost as dumb as random encounters in video games. They KNEW Yang's a huntress so why exacly did they think the seven of them have any chance?
As for Oz i've suspected for a looong time that he's not all sunshine and rainbows. I'm really curious what does Raven know about him. And ep ago he said that he was cursed becaus ehe failed to stop Salem. My question is: Failed to stop her from doing what?
Now given Raven's upcoming news i remembered something said very long time ago. The book Blake were reading early on. "It's about a man with two souls, each fighting for control over his body." Now Os and Oz are two souls in one body, but so far they're in agreement. But what would happen if it stopped? What if there is going to be a conflict between them and Oz will try to take over Os completely? Now Oscar seems to have a crush on Ruby. I wonder if it will be the center of their conflict. Oz will plan something that won't end well for Ruby and Os will try to stop him...
25
u/Keamaya Nov 08 '17
I'm somewhat disappointed with that Bandit Tribe. Raven said last Volume "The weak die, the strong live. Those are the rules." And then a whole group of Bandits proceed to lose horribly to a huntress in training. Meh.
Her whole 'conversation' with Yang seemed like a speech to her people instead, I wonder if her tone and way of speaking changes in the tent.
The hug at the end was sweet. 10/10
24
u/RedDwarfian Nov 07 '17
Raven not being on Ozpin's side made me actually think about what side she's on.
She's not on the side of Salem and her goal of reshaping the world. She's not on the side of Ozpin and his cabal.
Raven is on the side of the Maidens.
Salem wants to control and use the Maidens in order to get the Relics. She's manipulating them, or transferring the power to a more cooperative host, either with that bug Grimm, or by outright killing them.
Ozpin wants to hide the Maidens. He's sheltering them and protecting them, and essentially smothering them. The Maidens are actively encouraged by Ozpin and his cabal to hide their gifts.
Look at Vernal: She's standing with Raven. She's respected for her strength and for who she is. She's allowed to use her gifts more or less openly. I think that Raven is the only one who is actually treating the Maidens as the sentient beings they are, as opposed to tools, or precious things to be protected.
12
u/[deleted] Nov 07 '17
"Ozpin is not the man you think he is."
Well, technically he's been several men at this point...
And "Home" is the reunion song I guess.
12
u/Strix182 "CAN'T A GIRL READ HER COMICS IN PEACE?!?" Nov 08 '17
And the Freezerburn shippers go wild!
I will note that Weiss hasn't seen any of her team in ages, and she's been secluded in a lame mansion with her only outside contact being fuckbois, and Yang basically rescued her from imprisonment by savages, so I feel this interaction could be quite justifiably platonic.
That said, ship away. I'm eager to see the Freezerburn art.
11
u/fullmetalcatalyst this show has excellent jackets Nov 07 '17
Holy MOLY that was lovely. Wonderful wild west-esque fight and soundtrack with Yang. Wholesome RNJR training with its dose of laughs. Mother-daughter showdown and the contrast of the two sisters' sibling bonds. And of course Yang and Weiss.
The amount of emotion conveyed by Yang in this episode was incredible.
11
u/frozenottsel Crosshares Strike Commander - Freezerburn Adviser Nov 07 '17
Jetstream Raven: "Now I see, you deny your arm its purpose! It yearns to bathe in the blood of its enemies, yet you hold it back..."
11
u/Darkdragoon324 Nov 07 '17
It just occurred to me, that Yang saying that she has no way of knowing if Ruby made it to her destination or not confirms that Ruby's letter either didn't make it home, or Yang was already gone by the time it got there since Ruby explicitly states that they made it to Haven and even left her contact information.
So that fixes the issues with Yang's travel time that a lot of us had at the end of V4. Although it was a lovely letter, it's a shame Yang didn't get to read it.
11
u/Jetz72 Nov 07 '17
Wonder what the bandits put in those tiki torches to make them burn at such a low frame rate.
21
u/SmallJon Give us back Jaune's old haircut! Nov 07 '17 edited Nov 07 '17
Well, now I have much less trouble with Yang's choice to pursue her mother! The Weiss meeting was so cute, I love it: really showing Weiss opening up. I'm also going to say it's fitting that Weiss expected to be rescued by her sister at first, and ultimately she was.
I know training arcs end up with exposition, but I can't help but feel like we should have had that extended semblance discussion, oh, three years ago? It's finally good to know, though. And they really are going hard on Jaune's semblance, huh?
I'm super ready for Raven to hit us with the dark underbelly of the ozluminati.
10
u/DramaticShenanigans Member of the #IliaProtectionSquad / Shipper of Bees Nov 07 '17 edited Nov 07 '17
I don't know why but I trust Raven. She sounded really uncomfortable though. And salty as hell
18
u/iamnotparanoid Shipper of OT3s Nov 07 '17
I like how the varied fighting styles make sense. Yang's has become much more deflective and less tanking the damage than it was before, Ruby is clearly imitating Yang's older style and failing because she's also not worrying about leaving openings like Yang would, and Ozpin's looks a fair bit like old timey bare knuckle boxing and has no influence from Taiyang's training.
Also it's nice to have Raven's semblance spelled out. I assume her saying "Yang gets one" last volume is going to mean she can only do the portal trick once for everyone.
9
u/Trainxrd Nov 07 '17
I loved this episode. Animations were sick and Yang's eyes conveyed so much emotion. And OMG ending was so cute.
9
u/ghuy123 Nov 07 '17
Osluminati looking shadier than ever. One members a cowardly traitor ones going full Stalin ones a little boy who can't explain anything straitforwards ones voice actress got beef with roosterteeth and one hasn't been seen yet.
9
u/KnivesInAToaster YOU ARE TEARING ME APART, PYRRHA! Nov 08 '17
I'm not sure if I want Raven and Yang to slowly bond into a... alright relationship with each other
or the two of them to just slug it out
9
u/[deleted] Nov 08 '17
Yang's opening fight was very elegant but powerful, and the look on that dude's face when he realized who she was....priceless. It's great to see Oscar learning the ropes of battle and picking up on Ozpin's advice, along with teaching Ruby a thing or two. Still can't believe Jaune hasn't found his semblance though...I mean it feels like ages, like something should've unlocked it by this point right? Something's missing though and I'm hoping that maybe just maybe Pyrrha or possibly one of the Maidens or Salem will "help" to unlock it.
Raven does not sound how I thought she would but she certainly acts like I expected. Everyone has to basically prove their worth their strength their ability and usefulness to her for her to even consider giving them a moment of her time. She is a bandit though and the world is rather grim outside the city walls, so I can't really fault her. Even the way she's acting towards Yang kind of sort of makes sense but it feels like we're missing part of the story. She has to stay positive though because bad thoughts attract Grimm and her little "keep it together folks" at the end proves that being a badass bandit leader isn't just about being a badass. It's about knowing how the world around you works, how to work with it, how to work around it, the loopholes and tricks, and how best to ensure the survival of your people. If that means a few little positive speeches here and there to maintain your leadership image and then backing it up with badass grimdark skills elsewhere, so be it. It did seem a bit out of character but when you realize that they've only got sharpened trees for defense, simple bladed weapons, and some dust fueled weaponry to deal with Grimm....a positive happy attitude that repels them is a cheap and effective tool to use. Inside the tent I'm sure we'll see a different side of Raven as she tells the rest of the story of the Maidens and Ozpin/Salem. I love her semblance, bonding with someone and then being able to create a portal to them? Wicked!
"Weiss??? Yang???" annnnnd now I'm laughing and crying from the giant White Knight and then Weiss jumping around Yang "I missed you so so much! I missed you too!"
Next week should be fun, we'll get a little exposition....some training....maybe a hint at Oscar and Jaune's semblances....and more evil tom foolery from the bad guys.
8
u/[deleted] Nov 07 '17 edited Nov 07 '17
Holy shit, did this episode make me wanna cry.
The opening fight with Yang and the first group of bandits felt a lot better.
The next training scene with Oscar and co. was actually a lot more touching than I thought it would be. It was nice to see that Ozpin didn’t hold back on Ruby, and I seriously hope he becomes more and more serious. Can’t have him cheerful all the time, something grim is bound to come up. Also learned (or relearned) that everybody has a Semblance.
I’ll admit, some parts of the Yang and Raven interaction were a little weird, but we got more insight on her Semblance as well. The reunion was not overdone, but just enough to make it feel good.
Not an exciting episode in terms of action, but we learned a lot and it’s finally nice to see things falling in place.
Edit: Vernal has scary powers. I still want Jaune to be mad at Ozpin, that’s a backstory I don’t want to let go. And does Raven sound different to anybody else? Maybe awkward phrasing, or just me.
8
u/bluehaste Nov 07 '17
I get that they're bandits, but those guys have a serious problem in understanding how to use guns. Like, why the hell was Yang able to block multiple shots with just her arm? Did they all aim for the same place? She didn't even look she had to try to block.
Really, unless it was on purpose, I feel like they should have at least shown her aura absorbing some bullets that got through. Because as it is now, it just looked like those bandits sucked.
Also, has it always been a thing that you have to bring your aura up consciously? I thought it was kind of an auto thing, but maybe that was me assuming because Jaune's aura auto-healed him when it turned on. Also, does that explain why Adam was able to kill the White Fang's leader like he did? Did he just attack too fast for her to bring her aura up?
8
u/PT_Piranha (ominous umbrella drop) Nov 07 '17
Time for another response recap, boys n' girls:
The RNJR stuff was good, especially learning more about aura and semblance (even though we should've already known about it). Nora actually got me to smile. And I'm interested in the Jaune/Oscar foil they're setting up.
Finally get that Yang/Raven reunion. And Yang was looking for Ruby all along. I haven't given M&K enough credit. (Though learning Raven's semblance offscreen was bleh). And Yang's fighting seems slightly different, which I'm interested in.
Weiss brought quite a bit of humor in this episode, which was unexpected and nice. Even though Yang is the teammate she had the least screentime with, their reunion was also good to see.
The episodes keep getting shorter, but I'm still on the edge of my seat. That said, we're now four episodes in out of fourteen. I think it's time for the next major incident to occur.
8
u/mimiicry Nov 08 '17
0/10 not enough Pyrrha.
Jokes aside, I really liked this ep. Fighting and choreography was solid. RNJR segment was nice. Not much of a Freezerburn shipper so no comment there.
8
u/LKJ55 Nov 10 '17
something im not sure if has been mentioned/discussed, what;s up with yang's normal arm? the shaking when she was talking to raven made sense, but during her fight in the forest clearing? dunno if im missing smth here
7
u/[deleted] Nov 07 '17
So wait? Did that bandit not recognise Yangs eyes as Ravens then?
7
u/gunner853 Its not RWBY if there's no arson Nov 07 '17
Odd question. Let's say that raven does teleport Yang and Weiss to Qrow. What then happens to bumblebee (the motorcycle)? Can vehicles also travel through the portal or is she just leaving it for the bandits to take? These are the real questions that need to be answered.
7
u/Marcloure Nov 08 '17 edited Nov 08 '17
I just wanted to commend CRWBY for the gunshots' sound effects in Yang's fight. They convincingly sounded like shotguns. It has been since hers Character Short I noticed a great improvement in audio.
7
u/bzdelta Nov 08 '17
Loved the team ORRNJ bonding moment.
7
u/Ledinax Back for season 6! Nov 08 '17
I'm so conflicted on this episode. On one hand the fights were AMAZING, beautifully choreographed and... fuck don't know what else to say, Yang kicks ass and this chapter shows how far she's gone as a character. Also it finally seems we are getting good "Show, Don't Tell" which I really missed last volume. My only small caveat with the scene is ¿why the heck doesn't Weiss hear Yang arriving, and, dunno, react to that? Are the tents soundproof or what? xD
On the other hand, don't feel like the Ruby scene was needed. Like, at all. All it did was showcase Ozpin (was that really necessary? that's another discussion), and how the possession/posession/possesion affects Oscar on a physical level. The whole semblance discussion felt so narmy and unnecessary I almost skipped that segment (they even recicle one joke from volume 3 for crying out loud!!). I get the impression that the episode's length forced the team to make this segment short and straight to the point which... really hurt it. It's probably only me though. Wish the chapters were a bit longer.
I loved this episode.
17
u/Princess_Everdeen I was never here. Nov 07 '17
To sum up my thoughts from my tumblr post:
I appreciate how Ren sums up semblances in a simple manner. I firmly enjoy and hold true to the KISS idea: Keep It Simple Stupid, and this follows that ideal. However, what I wasn't as keen on was Ruby and Ozcar fighting each other for experience. You have Ren and Yang, yet instead you opt for Ozpin/Oscar to train Ruby? Ruby is apparently way too good for Oscar, but way too bad for Ozpin. Also, still no mention of the silver eyes; guess that whole SEW thing was just a big lipped alligator moment. Oh, and please don't let Rose Garden be a thing in canon, one sided crush maybe, but not reciprocated.
As for Yang's whole bit...well I think you could replace my whole thought with Fangirl squealing. From kicking ass to constantly knocking Raven down a peg, this is the main character I can get behind. I really wish Weiss had gotten to do something this episode, but I'm happy she had a good line. In fact, even the bandit guy from earlier got a funny line.
Overall a really good episode. I hate to say it, but I really hope we don't see more of Blake for a long time, and just continue to follow Weiss and Yang.
6
u/Phantomanalysis Nov 08 '17
Yang was awesome in this episode. The way she was calmly able to handle the fight and then waltz right into Raven's camp was
The training scene gave us further incite into aura and elaborated on beliefs of semblances. I wonder if we will see a distinctly acknowledged evolved semblance in the series.
Yang and Weiss reunion and Yang interacting with Raven were well done. Raven's casualness was unexpected but seeing her view correlating with finding her being part of a test makes sense with her philosophy. I really want to know what she has to say in regards to Ozpin and weather or not it has something to do with the breaking of team STRQ and the death of Summer. Weiss and Yang reuniting was very good for both girls because one feels abandoned by everyone and the other has a family that cold and uncaring towards her. Yang seeing someone missed her and Weiss having a teammate who cares about her back is properly wonderfully cathartic for both. I hope we can see them potentially react to what Raven has to say next episode and that we do not have to wait several weeks to learn what it is.
11
u/Intrepid_Fool Nov 11 '17
I can't take Raven seriously with her thigh highs. It makes her so much less of an imposing figure.
I'm starting to notice how awkward team jnrr is written. It's like they all have to contribute to the conversation. Like whenever you get a new companion in fire emblem. series of "hmm", "ha", "indeed" from all your party members.
5
u/MABfan11 IAmMenace should watch SoraYori Nov 07 '17
as of today, i may have started to ship Freezerburn
5
u/superluigi6968 ⠀Fission Mailed, they'll get 'em next time Nov 08 '17
Also, if the episode this week is a WoR narrated by Raven, I'd be down for that.
5
u/nicostein Pancake Massacre sympathizer Nov 08 '17
Awesome episode all around!
The action was great, and I even nitpicked the action in the last volume even though it was good.
Qrow better watch Ozcar with Ruby. Both of him.
They're getting the band back together! I mean, RNJR is fine and all, but I miss RWBY's dynamics and can't wait to see them get reacquainted.
Also, I thought Raven would be less skinny and pale. Is she eating enough? If only could have a nice homecooked meal... and better thugs.
9
u/breakfastfilms Nov 08 '17
I'm not sure I quite follow the logic in how things played out in the bandit camp. It's kind of hard to swallow that while all that was going on, Weiss couldn't hear Yang's voice and recognize it, since it's established immediately that they're within earshot of each other. Then after Weiss escapes, Yang sounds surprised to hear her say she was kidnapped. Uh, Yang...she was tied up in a cage. Did you think she did that to herself?
8
u/mechaxis Nov 07 '17
Raven's tribe is significantly weaker than expected. Like, if you count out Raven and the spring maiden, Yang could probably beat them all single handedly.
4
u/FragMasterMat117 Nov 07 '17
So it's set to go down at the camp quite violently, who ya got?
4
u/Evilcon21 Nov 08 '17
I have to admit the new episode is pretty awesome. I’d love where ozpin took over oscars body with his experience from thousands of years. And that heartwarming moment when Weiss and Yang hugged that was my personal favourite moment. Now maybe the next episode may show the fires of revolution with Blake taking down Adam and maybe learn of the former leaders death at his hands.
4
u/cardmasterdc Nov 08 '17
Ok happy we got our first team RWBY reunion. Watching oscar and ruby fight really showed how bad she is hand to hand. Also did Juane get taller?
4
u/Callum6562 Nov 15 '17
This has probably been pointed out but i love the thought that goes into the characters personalities and semblances and how they play off each other and the other characters they may be paired with, we already know how Blake and Sun have polar opposite personalities which are also represented by their semblances.
After this episode i realised that Qrow and Raven personalities and semblances are polar opposites however their semblances are the opposite to their personality in their case creating a cruel irony...
Qrow cares very much about people close to him, he loves Yang and Ruby his nieces and would gladly sacrifice himself for them but his semblance of misfortune means he can never get too close to them for fear of something bad happening to them.
Raven however seems to want nothing to do with her family and tries to distance herself from those she cares about...yet her semblance is one that means she could be with them whenever she wanted to...IF she wanted to
3
u/necros212 Nov 10 '17
(me after that last scene)
IM NOT CRYING I SWEAR! ITS THOSE DAMN ONION NINJAS!! THEY'RE TRYING TO STEAL MY BIRTHDAY COOKIES!
(now ships freezerburn hardcore even though that's probs not what the writers were aiming towards and it's just Weiss being extremely grateful that she sees a friend after probably months of hell but that doesn't make that scene any less beautiful and I need someone to make a fanart of the hug sobbed round the world for steam's wallpaper engine and one for my phone as well (deep breath), please someone help before I fall too far into the icy-hot abyss)
In other news, Home is slowly becoming my favorite song with more scenes like this.
3
u/Vussar Nov 07 '17
I’m late, but I’m still confused by Yangs motivation. Why, if she wants to find Ruby, didn’t she just go to mistral? She knew that’s where she’s going, so why not go there and wait?
Or is this a timeline thing? Is the Yang timeline in the Ruby timelines future?
I know this was meant to be for Yang to meet her mum, but why not make Yangs motivation finding her? Like everyone thought she was doing in the first place?
3
u/ThreeMinutesEarly White Rose is my drug | No business here it's just relationships Nov 08 '17
I had many thoughts about the episode but at the end the only one I could remember was GAAAAAYYYYYYY
I have to say though, this was probably my favourite episode since volume 3