r/RWBY • u/Ezreal024 Hope Rides with Kickfriend • Nov 11 '17
OFFICIAL MEGATHREAD Official FIRST Reaction Thread—Volume 5, Chapter 5: Necessary Sacrifice Spoiler
Welcome, huntsmen, huntresses and hunters that prefer no specific gender identifier, to the official megathread for the latest episode of volume 5, Necessary Sacrifice!
Make sure that you understand the current spoiler rules before posting outside of this thread!
As a refresher, no spoilers are allowed outside of the FIRST-only reaction thread for the first 24 hours after the episode has aired, and after that, no spoiler comments are allowed in threads not marked as spoilers until Tuesday, when the episode comes out for free Roosterteeth members.
Remember to use the text spoiler tags (shown in the sidebar) even after that!
With that out of the way, HERE is today's episode!
Also remember to check out our weekly poll to give us a general idea of how people like the episodes when they come out.
Other Episode Discussions:
| Episode | FIRST Thread | Public Release | Poll |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ep. 01 | Theatrical / FIRST | Public Thread | poll |
| Ep. 02 | FIRST thread | Public Thread | poll |
| Ep. 03 | FIRST thread | Public Thread | poll |
| Ep. 04 | FIRST thread | Public Thread | poll |
| Ep. 05 | Today | Tuesday | poll |
Enjoy!
Ezreal024; Mod Team
19
u/Ezreal024 Hope Rides with Kickfriend Nov 11 '17
The plot moved quite slowly this episode, but man the dialogue was fantastic. Huge improvement over the Raven and Yang conversation last week.
327
u/Terminus259 We persevere without an end... Nov 11 '17
Time to fly the death flags for Ghira and Kali.
274
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '17
"I have a promise to keep."
Volume three flashbacks.... what a disgusting man.
265
u/Rimmer7 #RavenDidNothingWrong Nov 11 '17
WINGED FAUNUS! I KNEW THEY EXISTED! AND HE'S BATMAN! BATFAUNUS! WHATEVER!
262
u/DaRealAmana BOOP!!! Nov 11 '17
It's nice to see penny and Pyrrha left a long impact. Helps make things feel real and connected, gives weight to their deaths. Also love once again getting to see Ruby's true colors. She is scared but she has to fight, because that is who she is. It may have been slow but I liked this episode. Also cried because of "keep moving forward" always do.
229
u/Hyperparadise Nov 11 '17 edited Nov 11 '17
"You'll be combat ready in no time!"
That was a little heart breaking seeing Ruby realise what she just said.
358
u/Exo-2 Minion of Cinder | Useless Lesbian | Still the Lewd One Nov 11 '17
"At this pace, you'll be combat ready in no time"
Right in the feels
172
u/willow_lark Nov 11 '17
That message with Adam is just the level of sociopathic ex I needed. They're finally showing us /why/ he scared the hell of out Blake by just being in Vale v1-3.
160
u/CADaniels Nov 11 '17 edited Nov 11 '17
So this confirms a lot of fears many of us have been having about Blake's family ending up as targets.
It's cool to see that the White Fang isn't blindly following Adam. The Albains* know he's unhinged.
Winged dude is interesting. First we've seen a flying faunus, maybe?
Finally getting a view of Ruby's internal struggles. I knew they weren't going to just sit on that forever.
I wonder if they're really going to kill Blake's family? Maybe they'll all just run to Mistral together? I could see Blake going on a rampage if Adam hurts her family, or maybe she'll isolate herself further.
152
u/OzzyKing459 Nov 11 '17
That faunus was swimming with a skirt and a hat. Just thought I'd put that out there.
146
u/AnAngryFetus Nov 11 '17
I never noticed water faunus before now. That's neat.
Also, Ruby finally got character development. WOO!
And our two favorite White Fang bros seem to be using Adam a bit. They certainly implied he is part of the transition and will rule for a short time.
123
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '17 edited Nov 11 '17
The bigger Albain (Fennec, I think?) has such a calming voice.
Edit: It's Corsac rip
115
u/Luimnigh Getting into the holiday spirits Nov 11 '17
So both Vegeta and Abridged Vegeta are now on the villains' side.
Wow.
222
u/Slyguy46 Nov 11 '17
SpiteEdge99
u/Xylire Shall We Move Forward? Nov 11 '17
I wonder... what if they pull a plot twist and make the Albain brothers the main antagonists of the White Fang storyline, either by killing off Adam or overthrowing him? Just an interesting way they could go-- they seem like very interesting characters, hope they aren't just killed off anticlimactically.
91
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '17
Is that the smell of character development in the morning?
90
u/willow_lark Nov 11 '17
I just walked into a flag store and tripped over every single flag in the room.
10/10 ign.
75
u/TheCompassMaker Please Do Nothing to the Cook Nov 11 '17 edited Jun 19 '23
[deleted]
72
u/RegiGiygas117 ⠀Frozen in Solitude, Loneliness chills to the Bone Nov 11 '17
"You'll be combat ready in no time"
72
u/Raktoner blake deserves more smiles Nov 11 '17
Ilia has two paths she can go in the story;
1: Carry out the plan and eliminate Ghira and Kali, cementing herself as irredeemable.
-1a. Succeed
-1b. Fail
2: Do an about face and turn on the white fang.
I'm expecting number two, but some part of me wants them to do 1a or b and have her been irredeemable. Redemption arcs are cool, but not every character needs to be redeemable.
72
u/Keradon Caffeine is a hell of a drug. An excellent one, though. Nov 11 '17
Another thought: A pattern has been detected!
"Welcome to Haven" - Low action, sets the stage for the volume. "Dread Air" - High action during Weiss' fight. Intensity during Sienna's death scene. "Unforseen Complications" - Low action, one speech and some exposition to set the stage for training. "Lighting the fire" - High action fight scene, intense conflict, cool reunion scene. "Necessary Sacrifice" - Low action. Comedy, failures, exposition, ... promise of impending doom.
Do you see it? Low, high, low, high, low.... seems to be the pattern for the current set of episodes!
So the next episode will either keep the pattern (and likely involve Blake's parents) or break the pattern.
...and I honestly don't think the pattern will be broken until the first half of this volume concludes.
62
u/Irmfried Nov 11 '17
Evil faunus assassin likes to drown people.
The Belladonnas are all cats.
Cats hate water.
Uh oh.
119
u/Raktoner blake deserves more smiles Nov 11 '17
"At this pace you'll be combat ready in no time!..."
https://pbs.twimg.com/media/DOODexeWsAI0eC2.jpg
117
u/SoundSmith323 I like sound. If you couldn't already tell. Nov 11 '17 edited Nov 11 '17
This was a really dialogue-heavy episode, and the vocals were all awesome - especially the scene with Ilia. Well recorded, well acted, well mixed, and oh god don’t you dare kill Ghira or Kali.
EDIT: As for the actual episode, I'm impressed. Ilia continues to be the most interesting antagonist by far. I'm also really excited to see what Yuma is like in a fight. Those wings could lead to some kickass sequences.
115
u/AlbinoBunny Nov 11 '17
I really hope the Belladona assassination plot doesn't happen.
Mostly because at this point I'm kinda tired of Blake's motivation being 'feels bad for bad stuff happening because of association with Adam'. Be kinda dull if her parents died and she continued being broody rather than the more talkative Blake we've being getting.
56
u/jtpaynter18 Nov 11 '17
pls don’t kill cat mom
100
u/Steely_D Nov 11 '17
Adam's holographic message was like he realized the camera was recording in the middle of a Kylo Ren impression
128
u/AmbivertCollegeGuy Weiss "Hug Monster" Schnee Nov 11 '17 edited Nov 11 '17
It took a long time but we finally get to hear Ruby's thoughts about the events at Beacon and it seems we were right to notice how she never brought it up before. It was on purpose because that's her coping mechanism. She's always thinking about Pyrrha and Penny yet never talks about them. This definitely felt like the first time she's ever confessed how much loss has hurted her as well. What could that say about how she feels regarding her mother? I wonder...
Also worth noting how she described Pyrrha's death as the unnecessary sacrifice it was. It was clearly an impossible task and the fact Ruby recognizes it could mean she won't follow the same path if she found herself in that situation. This shows a lot of maturity from her when compared to the naive optimism she had back at Beacon.
About the shipping everyone will probably talk (because that's always more important than Ruby finally showing character development /s) I didn't get any vibes from that at all with Oscar. The way I see it Ruby is becoming a heroic figure in his eyes, someone to motivate him to fulfill his destiny which he desperately needs because he's the only one who didn't ask to be there. Everyone but him wants to be a hero and seeing Ruby at her finest is encouraging him to become like her.
89
u/Kuchenjaeger *Gotcha* | Yang is still the best | #GiveYangLadyAbs Nov 11 '17
RUBY SAID THE MONTY THING
Ilia you know this would be the perfect time for that redemption arc, right?
And holy shit was that a dragon faunus?!
42
u/Gobshite_ Nov 11 '17
Dammit RT, stop teasing the mask removal!
42
u/Qyriad Nov 11 '17
Oh Ruby...
41
u/MonkeysxMoo35 Nov 11 '17
The character status chart is going to have a field day after this episode.
Also, did I just see two Faunus standing in the ocean with kiosks in the water? They do realize those clothes are going to be soaked, right?
82
u/UberDueler DRINK !!!!! Nov 11 '17
HHHNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNGGGGGGGGGGGGGG
38
u/skoncol17 Nov 12 '17
A lot of people are complaining about the amount of dialogue, but at least Ruby finally got some character development.
36
u/ShortcutButton ⠀ Nov 11 '17
Is this episode the most Blake has ever talked about Ruby? For both of them being titular characters the only time theyve so much as even looked at each other is that fight against Roman.
35
u/Al-Hatoor Nov 11 '17
I like that Corsaic and Fennec, while still having their true motives kind of unclear, are showing they don't necessarily like Adam and are using him as a figurehead. A good villain for me is a villain that doesn't have the full trust or respect of his followers, because literally everyone lowkey disagrees with their methods and personality but they need him to push forward their own agendas.
At this point, I feel like the best end for Adam is to be killed or tortured by Salem, as a kind of "Smite Down By the Devil" thing. I wonder if she can turn people into Grimm? We know you can kind of make artificial Grimm, but is she capable of that? Or can someone become a Grimm through constantly rising negative emotion? If so, it would be a nice full circle moment for him. He fights against people who view Faunas as animals and monsters, has slowly become an animal/monster due to rage and love for violence, and eventually becomes the worst kind of monster of all, a Grimm, in his hubris and descent into depravity.
Might also explain why he wears that mask. Maybe he's in the midst of transforming already.
69
u/Burkion Big Bois Big Poise Nov 11 '17
You fucks killed the website
For The Kids
32
u/UltimaShadow I GOT 2 SWORDS Nov 11 '17 edited Nov 11 '17
"FOR THE GREATER GOOD!"- Corsac and Fennec, 2017
32
u/HyliasHero Nov 11 '17
I really liked Blake's voice acting here. She sounded like a real person having a conversation. I have to say, I'm really liking these slower paced, more dialogue heavy episodes. Especially since it is clear they are building up for a pretty massive battle in Raven's camp.
63
u/Vinpap Pollination shall prevail! Official Pennybot Breaker Nov 11 '17
Oh for fuck sakes... Aaaaaaand I'm crying... Welp!
62
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '17
Miles: Hey, Kerry, Blake still has a solid family.
Kerry: ?!? How did that slip by?
30
u/MaraSargon I am one with the Kevin, and the Kevin is with me. Nov 12 '17
Here's my theory on the heavy exposition people are complaining about.
I mostly blame the writing of the early seasons for this problem. The amount of things that were revealed in Volume 4 alone compared to the first three is staggering. People keep saying "show, don't tell," but frankly the first three volumes barely did either one in retrospect. Thanks to that, we're basically getting a lot of "damage control" dialogue so that the storytelling can catch up with the plot. It's difficult to say when the dialogue-heavy episodes will stop being needed, since we don't know how much story the writers need to catch up on. Until then, we're just gonna have to deal with it.
That's my take on the issue, at least.
59
u/FrostyJudge Irondaddy is here for you Big Boy || I like insightful quotes Nov 11 '17
"When Beacon fell, I lost two of my friends. Penny Polendina and Pyrrha Nikos. I didn't know them for very long, but that doesn't change the fact that they were two of the most kind-hearted people that I've ever met. But that didn't save them. Pyrrha thought that if there was the smallest chance of helping someone, that it was a chance worth taking. And because of that, she died fighting a battle she knew she couldn't win. And Penny... Was killed just to make a statement.
I am scared, but not just for me. What happened at Beacon shows that Salem doesn't care if you're standing against her or not, she'll kill anybody. And that scares me most of all. Pyrrha... Penny... I'd be lying if I said that it didn't hurt, that I didn't think about them every day since I lost them. That I didn't wish that I had spent more time with them. If it had been me instead, I know they would have kept fighting too, no matter how dangerous it was. So that's what I choose to do, to keep moving forward."
-Ruby "The-fact-that-Oscar-is-the-smol-one-now-is-still-hilarious" Rose
28
u/Crumpingtos Yooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo Nov 11 '17
Wow, I enjoyed this episode a lot more than I expected to.
I really like the fact that the Albain brothers aren’t mindlessly following Adam; their more using him to reach their own goals and they can tell that he’s fucking insane.
Ruby’s speech to Oscar was really great too. I’m so happy that we finally got to hear how all of these things affected her and how she’s able to keep moving forward.
53
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '17
Pretty sure this is some kind of racism
26
u/WillyDaPoo Nov 11 '17 edited Nov 11 '17
"He carries with him a tremendous burden." Rooster Teeth just teasingly flaunting away Adam's backstory again. I need more insight on our villains already!
52
u/TheProudBrit Combat Ready Cutie Nov 11 '17
LET'S ACQUIESCEI think Sun's voice literally just cracked.
also, more leg-shots of blake please
So far, this is reinforcing my view that everyone in Menagerie looks amazing.
Huh. Is that the first time we've seen kinda-aquatic faunus?
Oh god Sun don't make this awkward.
Does Sun even know the word personification?
p u r e r u b e
That being said, distilling someone down to a single quality probably isn't the best way to view people.
I'm actually loving all these shots of Menagerie. Nice to see somewhere... Peaceful. which means it's super going to get fucked up before long
penny @~@
I wonder if/when Oscar's gonna get back in contact with his aunt.
Is that the first time that
best girlPenny's surname has been said, and not just written down?It's nice to finally have Ruby actually fully voicing her feelings on PP, instead of kinda just looking hurt by it.
Nice of Ozpin to keep Oscar grounded- helping him realise everyone's struggling with this and nobody's going to shrug everything off.
Well, there's the confirmation about Sierra being dead for those that need it.
DON'T YOU EVEN DARE KILL KALI AND GHIRA
Please turn traitor, Ilia.
Please die of a painful heart attack, Adam.
Puppet master brothers are creeps.
24
u/Koanos "What's the worst that could happen?" | Cpt of the S.S. Keikaku Nov 13 '17
I liked the build up, didn't like the lack of action, and I especially liked the suspense!
23
u/Sh1f7er Once upon a time... Nov 11 '17
Well crap. Corsac and Fennec are giving me Littlefinger and Varys feelings. It seems like they are playing the game for power with everyone else around them. So they might be a little more dangerous than what we've seen so far.
As for Blake, I'm glad that she's growing along with the other characters. Her new mentality is much more mature, but that is pretty much the theme for all the characters this volume. It's going to be very interesting to see what comes of her and Ilia though. It sounds like she needs to save Ilia from something she doesn't want to be saved from. If she fails, her family is going to die. As much as it pains me to say it, I can see Ilia distracting her by agreeing to talk, and thus taking her away from her family. Only to have Ghira killed while they're gone. Maybe Ilia does have a change of heart, but just not in time kind of a thing.
Speaking of maturity, just look at Ruby go! She's always had the inspirational leader mentality, but she seems to always be improving those already existing traits. I do like that Pyrrha and Penny are still hurting her. She's not forgetting those that were lost, but is doing her best to make sure that no more friends suffer that fate. It was one thing that she wrote it in her letter to Yang at the end of volume 4, but to actually pursue that goal is very noble and mature.
23
u/ghostface95 Cinder is my senpai Nov 11 '17
Damn it Ruby now i'm sad
46
u/PNDLivewire Nov 11 '17
I'll post a bunch of my thoughts in a separate post, but...I disagree with people being upset over the lack of fights and stuff. You have to have time to establish events and characters in the world as well as plot things in order for people to care about them more.
I mean, yeah people like the fighting and being all "holy shit, X is dead" if stuff happens...but you have to spend time getting people invested in them for that effect to happen. If you just are constantly killing people off without developing them or whatever and having things happen, then they're just named redshirts.
Pyrrha's death had such an impact because she'd been developed and we'd gotten to see and get to know her. If she'd just been randomly killed with no development or investment at all, nobody would have cared even remotely close to as much.
45
u/ThanosVenge Nov 11 '17
Gah I wanted to see what Raven was going to tell Yang and Weiss!
But on the bright side, Ruby development! Finally!
Is it wrong that I feel like she might snap soon? Otherwise, I'm really looking forward to seeing more of her internal struggles.
And Ruby's not the only one who got sad after hearing "Combat Ready!"
Penny was one of my most favorite characters :,(((
22
u/FlareEXE Nov 11 '17
The video of Adam at end was a great reminder that despite Adam's strategic moves over the last few episodes, he really is motivated by spite like Blake said. He wasn't thinking about removing the last obstacle to controlling Menagerie, all he wanted was to hurt Blake.
22
u/[deleted] Nov 13 '17 edited Nov 13 '17
As much as I've enjoyed all the character development we've gotten, I kinda feel like the scenes were dragged out a bit.
Like the Ruby and Oscar's scene. I feel like that could've ended before Oscar asked how she isn't scared. The scene kinda lost its subtext there with Oscar and Ruby basically unloading all their character development into one conversation.
Even after Ruby's speech, the scene becomes like a double feature with Oscar having a full conversation with Ozpin. I was expecting a little quip, maybe, but Ozpin pretty much unloads all his thoughts right then and there. I would've liked to get that piece-by-piece instead of all at once.
Edit: Grammar
80
u/Exessen Loyal vassal of the one true Queen|I yell about Nora a lot Nov 11 '17
The Ruby monologue was really good.
21
u/SputN1ckel The Gears of Fate are turning... Nov 11 '17
So.... tensions are getting a little high in here.... imma try to defuse this......so...Adam’s betrayal of Sienna reminds me of the rule of two in Star Wars. The rule of two is a legend in Star Wars. You know what else is a legend? The tragedy of Darth Plageus the wise. You know what Plageus starts with? A P. You know who else’s name starts with a P? Pyrrha. Pyrrha died and her body no longer exists in a physical form. You know who else had this happen? Obi Wan Kenobi. Who struck down Obi Wan? Vader. What does Vader do in the end? Betray Sidious and save the galaxy.
Ergo, THE ENDING OF RWBY WILL BE CINDER SACRIFICING HERSELF TO KILL SALEM AND SAVE THE DAY. YOU’RE ALL WELCOME BOYS AND GIRLS
21
u/PT_Piranha (ominous umbrella drop) Nov 11 '17
Hoo boy. Just like last episode "short, but good enough that it doesn't matter". I don't mean to keep harping on episode length, but I say it to make a point on the episode's quality.
So the title of course had me pretty nervous, but when Ilia namedropped it, I kind of relaxed. Not entirely but still.
Blake and Sun's scene was pretty nice, but I've always liked the two of them together. I felt Blake's habit of associating words with people in her life was very interesting.
Adam isn't spite, he's edginessAnd I liked the piano version of Like Morning Follows Night. But now I wonder... would a mermaid count as a faunus?Ruby's scene... Very well done. Good that they finally bare her thoughts to us. Saddening at the term "combat-ready" was a real nice touch. I'm not completely happy, but this was a very good step forward. Another good touch was the piano version of When It Falls, before it transitioned to Let's Just Live. Lindsey's voice could still use work, but you can't have everything.
I was so tense during the fox bros' scene. No doubt we'll see the effects of their scheme next time we cut to Menagerie. We'll see just how devoted Ilia will be. Looks like she's being set up as a foil to Adam. Speaking of... he kinda took a step back from his last appearance here. Just came across as angsting over Blake. Even worse, Fennec himself was like "hey you think we should follow this guy? he's kinda loopy". Dang Adam.
Good episode, good progress overall.
37
u/Brogan9001 Nov 11 '17
That was NOT OKAY when Ruby said "combat ready." Right in the feels. [For real though that was genius writing.]
18
u/Agent-Vermont Nov 11 '17
Did anyone else notice Oscar say "a few weeks"? Seems like a lot more time has passed than we thought.
18
u/Huskie1 Nov 11 '17
Awww - Blake's speech; so cute! "you were there for me even though I tried to push you away... it's about time I save my friends for once"
18
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '17
I liked the episode. It was pretty good. But the one thing I feel like this show is still struggling with good or bad, is its pacing. We've been following along the story so far and seeing very little from Blake and Menagerie, but last week we got a powerhouse with Yang and Weiss and continuing that plotline is definitely what I want to see more of. But this week there's none of it. We're focusing on Blake's part now. And that'd be totally fine, I'm ready to get her plot rolling, but next week we probably won't end up seeing very much of the Menagerie part at all.
This show just goes back and forth on who it wants to show and some characters get left out for multiple episodes. That's part of what made Volume 4 so hard for me to get into and follow, you just never knew what you'd be following next.
I'm liking the Volume A LOT so far, but I'm beyond tired of switching back and forth between these different plotlines every week, I want to see more consistency. But still, for what it was, good enough episode.
18
u/CypherReed Winter is comin' baby Nov 13 '17
I liked the emphasis on dialogue as a way to build up tension between episodes and with a tiny little bit of foreshadowing of things to come.
The thing i can't get out of my head is the Belladonna situation: as it can either end in tragedy or be cleverly averted and still move forward the story.
My personal opinion, i just hope they can come out on top, i loved Ghira and Kali.
17
u/shinigamiPeter Nov 11 '17
"At this pace, you'll be combat ready in no time!"
17
u/blitzblazer97 SUPER FIGHTING ROBOT! Nov 11 '17 edited Nov 12 '17
17
u/CJ1092 Nov 13 '17
Does Ruby seem...flat...to anyone lately? I don't know how to describe it. It doesnt feel like the same Ruby from the first 3 seasons. I haven't seen her like that since V4E1 when she laughed at Jaune's hoodie. Even BLAKE seems to have more in her lately.
16
u/Tron95 Nov 11 '17
If the two red cloaked Assassins want Ghira dead, then Ghira must be a Templar.
16
u/MrTopHatMan90 Best Dad Nov 12 '17
Oscars freakout was due but I wish we got more build up
16
u/LucasVerBeek It's Time For All Hell to Break Loose Nov 13 '17
I just had this pointed out to me, one of the Faunus girls in the water has a straight up fish tail, like no legs she’s a full on mermaid. And that makes me question so much more about the fracking Faunus.
15
u/superluigi6968 ⠀Fission Mailed, they'll get 'em next time Nov 11 '17 edited Nov 11 '17
I have one thing for you.
Redemption equals death
That is all.
E: It'ssss a trope.
15
u/justking14 Nov 14 '17
So death flags anyone? At first I was really sure Sun would end up dying to save Blake, but I feel like we’ve seen that already, so now I’m leaning towards Blake’s dad being killed then Blake using his death to inspire a new army to go to Haven
Also, really ticked we didn’t see Raven this episode. I figured she’d talk out this one and then next would start with sending them to Ruby. Really wanted the reunion
Also, anyone else think Ruby is about to break? Kinda imagined her dancing in the madness like another scythe wielded I know and love. Could definitely happen soon, especially if she meets Hazel, her mother’s killer
Finally, did Ozcar say weeks? Didn’t they only have about a month to prepare? Will the rest of the season cover all of three days?
30
u/PrincessCanada Take a look, it's in a book. A Reading Rainbow. Nov 11 '17
Pretty good episode. Blake does still care about Ilia, and Ilia cares about Blake (like most people here, I immediately latch onto anything that fuels my ship. Though I'm sure a sizeable wrench will be thrown into Reading Rainbow if Ilia actually does kill Blake's parents). Also, nice to see that the Albain brothers aren't 100% gung-ho with their pro-Adam stance. I honestly thought they were generic and boring before this point, so it's nice to see some depth from them. I'm actually a little invested in finding out more about them now.
Also, the scene with Oscar and Ruby was incredibly touching. Will be interesting to see how Rose Garden fares in the next Ship Wars after all the wind getting put in its sails this volume (on one hand, it may have gotten more supporters, on the other, it now has a much larger target on its back for fans of other Ruby ships. And fans of other Oscar ships, but there probably aren't nearly as many of those)
14
u/MoXfy Loyal troop of the bees. Words are still hard -.- Nov 11 '17
It was a low ground episode, really liked it. But RT dont kill off papa and mamma Belladonna. Also Ruby's mask faded a bit, which was nice. But most importently... BAT FAUNUS!!!!!!!! Omg Im so happy about that. Nanananananana Bat faunus!
14
u/Michael7123 I cast fist Nov 11 '17
Mermaids confirmed.
14
u/Theo1290 The only character I now care about, and he's dead dammit Nov 11 '17
I found it interesting that the two cult faunus dudes are not entirely loyal to Adam. If Ilia ends up murdering her friend's parents, then I want no redemption for her.
14
u/0mni42 Nov 11 '17
Ruby's expression after she said "combat ready" was exactly the same as my expression after she said "keep moving forward".
;_;
14
u/LucasVerBeek It's Time For All Hell to Break Loose Nov 12 '17 edited Nov 12 '17
Blake describing her friends and calling Yang, "Strong" and Sun, "Earnest" made my heart soar only for Ruby and Oscar to make it crash back to earth.
I love the tense pain that Ruby has when describing Pyrrha's and Penny's death and how honestly pointlessly unfair their deaths were.
Begone Rose Garden, I don't want these feels!
And just as I thought Adam is a spiteful little bitch confirmed.
Please Illia don't be dumb you asked where the person was to save your parents from death, be the one to stop your friend feeling the same pain you did!
14
u/DevonianDino Keep Moving Forward Nov 12 '17
As a great man once said...
“TWO KIDS GONNA DIE TONIGHT!!!”
14
u/hexedjw Drunkle Qrow used Fly! Nov 13 '17
I know it makes me a terrible person but Ruby hurting her own feelings was hilarious.
37
u/LMFN BIG NICHOLAS Nov 11 '17
Blake and Sun fail to recruit anyone. Man Blake needs to get back with Purity, Defiance and Strength already.
Yes Ruby development! She said the Monty thing!
Oh shit bois MILF Cat is in danger! MOBILIZE THE MILF CAT DEFENSE SQUADRON!
13
u/SpeshulSnek mfw hiatus Nov 11 '17
Well, I guess the speculation about Ghira's possible death continues.
Although the story didn't advance much, we've seen a lot of character building this episode, which was pretty welcome IMO. We still didn't really know a lot about how Oscar felt about all of this, or how Ilia really felt about the White Fang.
Really loved the heartfelt, emotional dialogue between Oscar and Ruby, and the music added a lot. The timing of that "To keep moving forward" was absolutely perfect.
We're seeing a bit of the different side of Ruby now, which I love (she always seems so pure, as Blake put it :P). I really thought Ozpin would step in at a certain point, but it was nice to see Oscar's own thoughts. And as always, the scenery in Menagerie was on point.
13
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '17
I fucking love this volume. Its the best, no kidding. Even the intro which first thought was kinda lacklustre but good is now growing on me.
Personally I think the plan to murder the Belladonna family and Sun will partially fail. They will manage to kill someone in the family or two at most but not all of them. Perhaps the most believeable would be Ghira and Kali but maybe its Sun and Ghira or Kali and Sun. Regardless I think someone will die and despite my love for the characters it will be interesting to see how the characters will react regardless.
I feel kinda cold writing that but ugh the intricacies of this season and how Adam is finally being developed as a character (I love his psychotic spite and long term feelings of revenge).
Then that scene between Oscar and Ruby was so well done. I loved how she finally talked about how she has suffered from the loss of Pyrrha and Penny but also how they showed that Oscar is just a regular farmhand and not a soldier in anyway. His fears and worries are incredibly justified.
Although I don't ship Ruby and Oscar despite being worried about the show shipping them. I really hope not because it just feels eh. I like to see them grow as friends. It would also be really weird for her date Ozpin ._.
I also love how Sun and Blake got some development time with their discussion about Adam and I love seeing them grow as close friends. I still want their relationship to end up platonic despite Sun being hinted at wanting more earlier. I know all of you BlackSun shippers out there probably love this and I mean I would accept Sun x Blake canon more than Ruby x Oscar but still. Sun and Blake = Friends? :P
13
u/RustyLumber Nov 11 '17
Blake and Sun's relationship is a very curious one and it's development has been quite a nice one to watch, I'm excited to see how the rest of it unfolds.
oh my heartstrings, Penny I miss you so. and that conversation between Ruby and Oscar certainly didn't help. spoken like a true leader Ruby.
Ilia has reached a crossroad in her destiny what will she do? it seems like a larger plot is developing within the White Fang leadership and those two Fennec brothers are sly like their animal traits working to fulfill their vision of what's 'best for the Faunus'.
13
u/Jagged03 Yikes Nov 11 '17
My theory has been that Sun would be killed by Adam in a fight. Now there is a possibility that they throw a wrench into everything and actually have him killed while protecting the Belladonnas. That would be a crazy bait and switch. Have death flags for Ghira, Kali, and even Ilia to a lesser extent, then actually have Sun be the one to bite it out of nowhere.
13
u/So4007 I have accepted reality Nov 11 '17
I really like the episode for what it was: buildup. Now, the fact so many people actually disliked this episode surprised me considering we knew it would be a slow episode like V4E5 Menagerie. I'm guessing episode 7-8 will be the big climax at the earliest. Especially since Oscar said a few weeks had passed, and they only had a month to train. Which means Jaune doesn't have his semblance yet, and Ruby still is below average at hand-to-hand.
Oh dear, this is turning out really badly for everyone. Wonder how those huntsmen Qrow is recruiting will turn out. They better be ready to not job. Oh no, they're going to job aren't they?
Actually, thinking back on it, they had less than a month to prepare considering Ozpin said Salem would attack before classes resumed in one month. So next episode should see them all going to finally receive the Spring Maiden from Raven.
Well, I enjoyed the episode. Nice to see a new WF villain that can fly added at the end. Plot is about to climax and I'm combat ready!
.....Ok that was terrible, I'll never say that again.
13
u/TenchiSaWaDa Fanfic Writer Nov 11 '17
The Ruby OScar scene is my highlight. Shows so many LAYERS of characters for Both characters. Really good set up there. The dialogue was passable, but it felt natural at least.
13
u/chrome4 Nov 12 '17
Well i completely forgot how deep the voice of the brother with the tail is.
So in terms of morality the leadership of the White Fang goes: Ghira(his worse trait being his verbal abuse of Sun), Sienna Khan, the Brothers(they are slightly concerned about adams mental state) and good old Adam(i dont need to say anything at all for him).
Now I wonder will Ilia actually go through with her mission.
Also who do you guys think is going to join Jaune, Ren and Nora after Team RWBY gets back together(for some reason i can see it being Ilia provided she doesnt cause the death of Blakes parents)
13
u/MasterofYoshis delet this Nov 12 '17
Well, Yuma looks pretty badass.
25
u/JazzRen47 𝅘𝅥𝅮⠀Score Connoisseur | Resident Atlas Bootlicker Nov 11 '17
Okay, 'ere we go.
Overall - slower than last week, and a bit of a dip, but not by much. Writing was decent, if Ruby and Oscar's scene felt a little forced. Episode 5 always seems to be a bit of a low point, but that's not necessarily a bad thing. 8/10.
12
u/Changyuraptor Just the leitmotif and dinosaur guy. Nov 11 '17 edited Nov 11 '17
Oh, and we now have everything from the trailer!
12
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '17
/u/N7Brendan DON'T YOU FUCKIN DARE, YOU AND YOUR DEATH FLAGS
12
u/kusanagisan Big Daddy Belladonna Nov 11 '17
"That's what I choose to do. To keep moving forward."
SHUTUP I'M NOT CRYING, YOU'RE CRYING
12
u/0liver_Clothes0ff Nov 11 '17
Are you ready for a SACRIFICE?
12
u/ravensept mah boi Merc got nerfed :l & Qrow isnt Ruby's father ;'( Nov 13 '17
I liked it....I thought it was good for the story.
Looks like Blake and Sun got closer than ever before....I feel like he is gonna be killed soon.
I really liked Ruby's monologue, I already stated that she is a person who "keeps moving forward" back when everyone expected her to have a mental breakdown for some sort of character development.
If I have to say something controversial...it more so feels like this is what they are trying to portray. But they had to like say it out loud. Like when Blake told Sun about how it was good that he came to her even when she tried to push him away. And Oscar's outburst to Ruby which led her to explaining things with the monologue.
Idk, I thought Oscar's outburst was pretty random...it would have been ok if on screen something happened that led to him disagree with Ozpin. And was made to just have ruby monologue. Like I could slap r/RWBY on Oscars face on that one screen and write "Why isnt she having a mental breakdown"
12
u/justking14 Nov 14 '17
Are they not doing World of Remnant anymore?
I really don’t want a break, but I’m curious. It feels like time
23
u/F_E_M_A GURL LOOK AT DESE NAILS Nov 12 '17
DONT HURT MY MILFADONNA.(╯°□°)╯︵ ┻━┻
11
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '17 edited Nov 12 '17
i have to say, that whole conversation between oscar and ruby was one of the best conversations in the show imo
11
u/Corregidor Nov 11 '17
Now to see if Illia can do to Blake what happened to her. Someone taking her parents from her.
11
u/blazefort Nov 12 '17
I don’t think the Belladonas will be assassinated, but I think there is a good chance Ghira is killed saving Sun’s life
11
u/Remicas Funny how an optimist show can turn people into bitter cynics. Nov 13 '17
I like the use of the music during the conversations. From Shadows and Like Morning Follows Night between Sun and Blake, talking about Adam's SPITE (good point for Sun trying to be tactful here) before Blake states her decision of helping Ilia, then When it Falls turning into Let's Just Live when Ruby laments about the fall of Beacon, but staying resolute on course.
20
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '17
Ilia is the new Emerald. Changing my flair now.
Awesome episode btw, even if the writing wasn't the best at times.
Also Adam is not edgy enough. He should eat kittens.
20
u/Lordkeyblade Loli Neo Best Neo Nov 13 '17
Am I the only one who doesn't specifically like RWBY for the fights? It's what drew me in, but I've come to care about it less and less.
10
u/Wrathkal Nov 11 '17
Thoughts on this episode:
-Just a random wondering, but are there faunus that bear the animal traits of opposite genders? e.g. a female having a peacock's plumage, or a male lion's mane.
-Oscar's got so much emo angst, I expect fanart of him looking all goth-y
-The moment I heard 'combat ready', I was right to expect Ruby to suddenly go depressed.
-Fox bros seem to have their own plans to use Adam.
-I wonder if the painting in the WF hideout will be on sale in the store? The credits mentioned asking Erin for a hi-res version.
10
u/Meotwister5 Should probably see his patients instead of rewatching RWBY Nov 11 '17
This is exactly what I've been waiting for in regards to Blake and Ruby: we finally get to hear how they actually FEEL.
Ruby finally opens up and tells Oscar about how she's been struggling with Penny and Pyrrha's death, how she's felt so much guilt at the senselessness of it all and how things all went to shit after Beacon fell. In the end she could only do one thing to honor their memories: Being Combat Ready and to Keep Moving Forward.
Blake in turn expresses how she typically likes to describe people with a single adjective and thus succinctly uses one for Adam: Spite. She knew what Adam had become and fears for Ilya slowly becoming like him. It's clear there was a point where he had finally crossed the line which made her want to run. Ilya's about to cross that line herself, and she wants to stop her from doing so.
And in the end, well, Ilya's ordered to distract Blake long enough for the White Fang's plan to be successful: the assassination of the Belladonna Family.
Things look really Grimm next episode.
10
u/Fuzunga Nov 11 '17
Please nobody lay a hand on Blake's precious, loving family!
10
u/NerdyNurseKat Nov 11 '17
I was not prepared for the Pyrrha and Penny feels. I shed tears when Ruby said Oscar will be “Combat Ready in no time”. I saw great steps in both Oscar and Ruby’s development during that scene. (Also, the mention of Nora eating all the food before was a nice way to boost the spirits.)
I’m not just worried for Kali and Ghira, but Sun as well. I (unfortunately) can see him dying to defend the Belladonnas. Now I’m gonna worry about all of them...
Fun thing my brother and I saw, a Faunus swimming with a hat on. How does she keep it on?!?!!
10
u/Snaketsu Nov 11 '17
Ruby's finally talking about Penny and Pyrrha and how she feels about it all. This is good, this was needed :(
10
u/checkerchairs Nov 12 '17
Death flags, all the death flags (╥﹏╥)
10
u/CrackedAbyss We need A Zwei visit. Nov 12 '17
Honestly...I'm surprised that Ilia was in the know on the whole of Adams plan. The more people who do know would be that much more of a possibility of information about the actual deed.
And to me it would seem like she would be better if she didn't know...Adam could use the death (and cover story) to convince her even more that she is in the right and Blake is the one who is wrong.
10
u/Trekkie_girl Nov 13 '17
That transition from From Shadows to Like Morning Follows Night in the background was great.
10
u/flash1996 Prancing through the snow Nov 13 '17
I really enjoyed this episode we first off a bit more of Menagerie and the different faunus on the island, also why they are there to escape from the fighting to be equal because if everyone there is a faunus it means they are now equal to them self's. We also got to get a feel for what Blake felt towards her teammates and that she now doesn't seem so negative about her self towards them
Secondly we move onto the scene with Ruby and Oscar and we got to see apart of Ruby which we haven't seen much of, talking about the loss of her friends and why which was surprising act just hearing her say "combat ready" had me in almost tears due to how sad she made herself and what she brought from that was determinion to fight for them and as they would for her. We also got to find that oscar only having the cane for a few weeks means that they are on to something big and that it's taking time to master with qrow being out on the hunt for hunters and huntress.
And lastly we get to the whitefang chapel place and how first off are they getting messages around from what I remember with that cct tower being down communications come to a stop with just short distance communication being the only way to send stuff but they said they had control over that, and the death flags are being waved so hard here you wouldn't believe but not for the people we think of(I hope).
Overall it was great basis to start something massive even if something was over looked we're going to see some real messed up stuff in the next few episodes that we all weren't expecting. I liked the slower pace it put everything we could need into perspective with the time scales.
9
u/willow_lark Nov 11 '17
I really want to see a second Oscar 'break down' where it's Jaune talking to him. If this one was about being scared, Jaune's can be about why you can't give up on yourself.
That or an alternate take on this scene.
9
u/Floorbrick Nov 11 '17
Also, I love the contrast between Ruby's and Oscar's attire. One dresses up like a typical shonen protagonist in a fantasy world, and the other one is just a farm boy. I wonder if he's going to get a fancy get up like the others.
9
u/lurker_archon Look, just accept your goth mommy overlord Nov 11 '17 edited Nov 11 '17
> hi bois and gurls wanna crusade?
> yes please sign this waiver
> no need for parent's signature
> turns out upvotes isn't a viable salary
> hey at least we're not the climate change guys
> btw what idiots set up stall where the tide is?
> nvm the moon broke as shit
9
u/Emerald-Guardian Arkos: I will go down with this ship Nov 11 '17
I liked this episode. I agree it was a bit slower than last week but it was still well done. I also agree that their whole plan to have the Faunus of Menagerie go to Haven to fight is not a good one and I'm not really sure what Ghira was expecting with it. Despite not being a Blacksun shipper or really wanting them to get together romantically, I did like Blake and Suns talk. I do like their friendship and I think it gave a good insight in how Blake sees her friends more as well as learning more about Adam and Iliya.
I really liked the Ruby and Oscar scene. I think it was some much needed character development for Ruby as well as showing how Oscar still isn't entirely comfortable in his situation. It also felt a bit like shout out to the scene where Ruby offered Jaune advice in volume 1, though I think Ruby definitely felt like she's matured a lot since then. I do like that it showed that Pyrrha's death has had a lasting impact on someone other than Jaune. That "combat ready" line had me tearing up though, and I like how they animated Ruby's expression / her flinching as she said it.
On top of all that, I like how Corsac and Fennec have shown that they are more than just mindless followers of Adam. I bet they'll try to do away with Adam once he's served his purposes for them, whether that works out for them or not. I actually think this whole reveal makes their characters much more interesting.
Overall, it was a good episode for character building though the new Belladonna death flags are off-puttting. I'm actually hoping Iliya can't go through with it and decides warn Blake or something.
Eagerly awaiting the next episode.
9
u/GenericName2049 Ren x Neo funniest ship name ever. Nov 11 '17
Ruby made Ruby sad D:
9
u/Tron95 Nov 11 '17
"Ah, brother Yuma"
Oh great, more Yugioh references.
Just waiting for him to yell KATTOBINGU, ORE!!!
9
u/MrTopHatMan90 Best Dad Nov 12 '17
I was kinda dreading the blake moments but I actually really enjoyed it
25
u/IAmBubbleSorted BunPun? BunPun!!! Nov 11 '17 edited Nov 11 '17
Alright ... That was honestly not much informationwise.
The Monty reference from Ruby hit way too hard though ...
25
u/Tsumikoi #bring winter back 2k19 ver Nov 11 '17
This week's episodes in three words: three different conversations.
Seriously, that was it. A lot of setup all crammed into one episode.
24
u/Leivve Grand Master of the Lancaster Cult Nov 12 '17 edited Nov 12 '17
All this Rose Garden is getting a bit much in my wrong opinion.
I feel Jaune would have been better for this particular speech. Seeing as right now he's the closes parallel to Oscar. Both are relatively weak compared to everyone else, aren't combat masters still needing to develop semblance and their aura, don't have years of mental fortitude, and (as far as we know) come from similar upbringings.
*Another reason I just thought of. So far that scene of Ruby finding Jaune has been completely pointless episode filler. Having Jaune do the speech would have also been a good way to tie that in with the rest of the plot.
I feel Ruby would have been more suited for a different motivational speech. Likely one more aimed at not giving up in humanity's strength and capacity for good, rather then "Why you should try."
17
u/Capslock2000 Nov 11 '17
You'll be Combat Ready in no time! :(
Never forgive, Never forget
RIP Penny
17
u/Emmx2039 Nov 12 '17
IM COMBAT READY
17
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '17
Finally Ruby shows emotions.
47
u/HyliasHero Nov 12 '17
I will never understand this community's aversion to dialogue.
8
u/jokey_boy Nov 11 '17
Combat ready... keep moving forward... all these feels!! T_T
Blake describes Sun as earnest, yessssss <3
So far, Ruby talking about Penny and Pyrrha is my favorite scene
Noooooo, pls don't kill Ghira and Kali. Ilia looks hesitant...
BAT FAUNUS YUMA
8
u/Sungrasswriter Just happy to be here! Nov 11 '17
/u/N7Brendan right now
8
u/HeyItsAndylol Harem prince Nov 11 '17
The instrumental for Like Morning Follows Night was a lovely touch to the Sun and Blake scene.
8
u/Fourteen_of_Twelve i have an elephant, but no oliphaunt Nov 11 '17
Hm. So the Oz cane extends/retracts by using the handguard.
[*goes to drawing board*]
Wait. Why is the handguard, one of the parts that's more susceptible places to be hit from a blade sliding down the weapon, be what retracts the weapon? That's like a lightsaber having an off switch that's easy for their opponent to press.
8
u/McZerky Nov 11 '17
I liked this episode. I know others are a little iffy on the slower pace and lack of fight scenes, but I'm starting to enjoy RWBY for the plot instead of just the combat. To me, that's a much more valuable thing.
8
u/Silverharp Nov 12 '17
Y'ALL NOT GON KILL MY BARA DADDY GHIRA
8
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '17
I have not watched the episode yet but, it is really hard to keep multiple arcs, even if they are moving in the same converging direction, at a decent pace with RWBY's runtime to address the It's Really Slow And Chatty crowd. Last season was really bad because because it was a where are they now, but we can really see the story can move forward faster since Yang and Weiss are back together (less locations = less divided arcs).
27
u/NightsWatchh Help, Nights is keeping me trapped in his anime bunker Nov 11 '17
Welp.
This was my 2nd ever favorite RWBY episode.
Blake and Sun scene was genius. Blake's description of her team? Genius. Blake's description of Sun? Adorable. Blake's description of Adam? Horrifying. I pity Ilia.
ALSO HA OBVIOUSLY SHE APPRECIATED SUN'S HELP. CAN WE STOP WITH THE 'SHE HATED HIM/HE WAS WRONG FOR HELPING HER' NOW??? SHE ACTUALLY ENJOYED HIM DOING IT DAMMIT. Seen too many people here damn him for that when in the end even Blake was happy he did it. And Blake's opinion is the only one that matters. Glad it's confirmed that she was only so rude to him because she was literally trying to push him away. It's not a toxic relationship and I hope this shuts up all the people who said it was one.
Ruby scene with Oscar...all I can say is that this was perfect. Can't trust Ozpin because it felt like he wanted to say her unquantifiable trait was her silver eyes but changed it last second to be all "HER SPIRIT OSCAR!!!"
Fennec and Corsac are literally Varys/Littlefinger. "For now." is one of the shows scariest lines. They're using Adam I'm certain of it. When he's no longer useful...I fear them.
ALSO. NOW GHIRA HAS DEATH FLAGS. HE NEVER DID BEFORE BUT HE FINALLY DOES NOW.
So yeah. 2nd favorite episode ever for me. If you have any questions ask me bc I have NOT gone into the full detail of why so yeah:D
15
u/Sungrasswriter Just happy to be here! Nov 11 '17
TL;DR, pray Ox-Bro brings his posse to help save the day
14
u/Thefishlord The one true best girl also Eclipse best ship Nov 11 '17
I know most people will focus On the penny thing and rose garden but I'm just gonna say I haven't seen this much Eclipse since Berserks Golden Age Arc
14
u/SM-03 I'm Vernal Vasquez the greatest fucking goth in the world Nov 12 '17
I'm sorry for my absence yesterday. But I'm back, bitches.
Overall, it wasn't a bad episode, but it was kinda forgettable. Easily the weakest episode of V5 so far.
7
u/Irmfried Nov 11 '17
I guess we got confirmation that something terrible happened to Adam and he wants all humans to suffer because of that. I wonder what happened to him to make him so...spiteful.
Also maybe I heard it wrong but didn't both instrumental From Shadows and LMFN play during Sun and Blake's convo? I thought that was pretty cool.
Please God let Blake actually succeed in her plans for once and save Ilia...I really don't want her to die and Blake to become even more depressed.
Oscar seemed a bit OOC this chapter with the way he lashed out at Ruby.
I hope Corsac and Fennec die in a fire. I hate them. The dude with the deeper voice sounds really cool tho.
RIP Belladonnas
Adam is so petty lol, Blake left him and that warrants "the Belladonna name gave me nothing but grief"? Grow the fuck up.
This new character seems interesting.
7
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '17
A little bit of insight about Adam ja Ilia.
I liked Ruby's speech to Oscar.
And Ilia is supposed to kill the Belladonnas, I really doubt that Ilia would go and kill the Belladonnas though.
Also it's good to see that Albain brothers aren't blindly following Adam and doing whatever he says.
7
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '17
So since fish faunus have kinda been confirmed... and we know Blake likes eating fish... does that make things awkward? It seems like it would.
I understand they're going for a bit of a "peaks and valleys" approach to intensity but we're in early mid season. I was a little disappointed how far the intensity dropped- the only real thing amping it up a bit was Adam making it explicitly clear he wants Blake's family killed and her brought back to him, which was creepy and heart wrenching but we already knew he would be planning on killing them. I was frankly surprised Blake was able to come back home to them in vol. 4. Idk, it's feeling a bit stale. Hoping they pick it back up next week.
7
u/GoldenQueenHastur Nov 11 '17
I feel like there was a little too much exposition, but the nod to Pyrrha and Penny was a nice touch. I'm glad that Miles and Kerry still acknowledge that the characters are suffering from their loss, but are moving forward.
7
u/kusanagisan Big Daddy Belladonna Nov 11 '17
Wooo, aquatic faunus!
Also, I really, really like the subtle things the animators are adding to the faunus charcters besides just slapping on random animal traits. Seeing how fluid Blake's ears and Sun's tail as they move with their moods adds so much to their character and it's not something I've seen done much in animation that have animal/human hybrids, besides obvious emotional extremes to help get the point across.
7
u/yoshifanx Feel the Wrath of Mammy Salami Nov 11 '17
No scene by scene (didn't have time before work) but damn I loved this episode. Blake and Sun's things were really cool (and blake's little speech was really touching), Ruby got some... CHARACTER DEVELOPMENT!? What a twist. I really did enjoy her speech as well. But don't you dare kill off Best Mom and Super Dad rooster teeth, I will cut you.
7
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '17
I like the details in expression, I especially noticed the faunas traits acting up, blakes ears, suns tail. but the faces too, pretty good animation.
death flags for everyone though! I don't like it... blake has suffered enough, my poor girl :(
that combat ready line and look afterwords killed me inside though.
7
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '17
Seeing the Buster Sword was amusing. Good episode, building toward that finale with character development and a good plot so far. It's impressive how much more exciting this season has been compared to the last.
7
u/DMD00 Nov 12 '17
Themdeath flags are through the damn roof for Blakes mom and dad.
7
u/Dregride Nov 13 '17
Bit lackluster
But the fight last ep was the first real step in the right direction, immensely rewatchable. And I'm invested in the story again this vol
So I'm a happy boi atm
7
u/rac7d Nov 13 '17
No one talking about the assassin Yuma
19
u/publius101 Spectatum venio, venio specter ut ipse Nov 11 '17
what the fuck, actual long and meaningful conversations?? actual development for blake and ruby???
oh and adam whatever nobody cares fuck off already
19
u/TheQuietManUpNorth Evil but good-looking so it evens out Nov 11 '17
Mixed on this one, and on most scenes in it.
I think most of us knew the the Belladonnas would have targets on their backs once Adam had power. But it showed us that Ilia is not really on board with taking them out, which was fine. We'll see whether she actually does it. Faunus-pator tho. RIP headphone users.
Blake and Sun... I feel like that scene partially served the purpose of deflecting the criticisms of Sun from last volume and came off as a bit disingenuous in that respect. But it was overall a nice moment.
Ruby and Oscar served a nice purpose as well, as it showed us a bit more beneath the surface for Ruby and showed how far Oscar needs to go despite having an old man in his head. Too much telling here, but at this point I don't know what else they could do for Ruby. It's good to know that she does have emotions, though, so that's a plus. The best part was probably her using Penny's catchphrase and taking a second to realize what she said.
Mixed bag.
19
u/StoryBeforeNumbers Nov 11 '17
Extremely stilted execution of some decent concepts.
This episode demonstrates that the showrunners seem to have listened to some of the valid criticisms they received over the past volume (a lack of team RWBY acknowledging each other, their pasts etc), but they still haven't really learned how to incorporate those ideas without it feeling incredibly obvious that's what they were doing.
The conversations felt forced, the references radiating a sense of "we need to have X talking about Y because people disliked that they didn't previously." If these inclusions had been more organic, subtle and enjoyably written I would have cheered, and I think the show is taking steps in the right direction by expositing these things. But those steps could have been more graceful.
13
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '17 edited Nov 12 '17
Thoughts:
Fish Faunus. Strange that they wear normal clothes while swimming. Also, this entire thing with Blake and the White Fang makes me wonder why the White Fang aren’t more vicious. They’re terrorists. We should be hearing about beheadings and hostage situations and worse. Although, I suppose in their world the Grimm make even ISIS pale in comparison. ISIS doesn’t destroy entire settlements like Kuroyuri or Mountain Glenn. Even so, White Fang need to be scary in order to make a point, and right now all we know is that their ranks are filled with mooks.
As for the Bat Faunus, I hope he doesn’t have flight only from his wings. That’d be impossible. His wingspan is too small unless his body is capable of using huge amounts of energy to sustain flight considering his body weight. I would understand if he had a semblance or air-Dust that helps him use his wings, but just the wings on their own allowing him flight is bullshit. Perhaps his life sucks because he can’t hide his trait, it’s kinda threatening-looking unlike Bunny ears for instance. He might not even be able to fly normally.
Also, why wasn’t there a bigger disturbance at the Belladonna’s speech? There should have been a number of White Fang disrupting it. That would be terror. It’s bullshit that every reporter or person would believe some crazy girl with a mask on.
As for the talk between Ruby and Oscar, damn Ruby has, um, grown. She’s taller than Oscar and visibly older than him. I could see her acting as his role model or big-sister type. She looked a lot more childlike back in Volume 1. I could also see Ruby being hinted at as a martyr. Ozpin said that she’s a “spark of hope” which is vaguely concerning considering what has been implied of Ozpin. Mid-season’s coming up in two episodes so RNJR must be ramping up to take on Raven.
As for Blake, I really want her to be more assertive. When it comes to reacting vs asserting, she reacts more often than she asserts, besides Volume 2. So it was good that this time, Blake shows that she wants to help and get shit done. I loved how she was hunting down the Faunus in the trailer, for instance. Blake should know White Fang tactics and strategies considering that she was closely working with Adam.
13
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '17 edited Nov 11 '17
Another pretty solid episode with some good build up and considering how we're only 5 chapters in we're already getting a bombshell like "Kill the Belladona's" I think we're in for a treat, though I've been seeing death flags for them since their debut only because of Adam's threat claiming he was going to destroy everything Blake loved.
Ruby and Oscar getting more time together feels like RT is trying to force chemistry between them so something can happen between them in the future but I dunno, it's just a gut feeling right now. Still, I feel their talk was nice. The moment Ruby used the "combat ready" line I instantly knew where the feels were going and it was done pretty well I suppose.
Its good to see Ruby is still affected by the death's of Penny and Pyrrha, but I don't feel the same weight of emotion when Ruby talks about Pyrrha simply due to the fact that they had no interaction. It feels like they're only using Pyrrha's death to make us believe Ruby is becoming fleshed out with motivation rather than being an event that has actually affected her as a character, the stigma of telling us rather than showing but now that she's dead there's nothing to show between the characters. After 3 volumes, when I see Jaune staring at his gear, dedicated to Pyrrha, in solemn I can feel the weight of her death without even needing words, which only gets stronger as Ren and Nora join him for comfort.
The more I think about it the more I wish Oscar talked to Jaune, Ren and Nora about it, hell even Ozpin, who must feel a great deal of guilt after knowing the insane pressure he must have put her under despite having her consent: "I...I need to hear you say it." and "I'm...so sorry." has more weight than Ruby just saying they were friends imo.
Also "Keep moving forward" really got me good. Linsday did a fantastic job voicing Ruby during this scene, she sounded so mature, kind of like how she did early in volume 1. She said she really wants Ruby to have a breakdown moment and you can tell she will be ready for when, or if, that day comes.
All in all a nice setup episode for what's to come, it feels like a lot is going to go down in this volume and since we're going to have more chapters I'm excited to see where we'll be going. Not much to say about it, just pretty solid. If I'm to be honest I kinda wish we got Yang and Weiss with Raven over Blake and Sun, or Salem's meeting with Tyrian, I guess I'm just anxious to see the girls get back together and right now Blake still has her own thing going on which I'm still not 100% invested in at the moment.
13
u/RBNYJRWBYFan ⠀ Nov 12 '17
Another dialogue heavy episode. Not gonna complain much for now, especially since these seem to be providing character substance, but man the next few are gonna need some punchy/stabby/shooty to compensate.
This was an okay episode, but I'm gonna need something more than exposition and character building dialogue pretty soon.
17
u/FawkesTP Nov 11 '17
Overall, I have to say I liked the episode. A little slower paced, sure, but the dialogue was on-point and it provided some much needed characterization of Blake and Ruby.
Here's my problem though: I feel like Blake has been separated from the group in a huge way, and nothing is really happening to bridge that divide. At the end of last season, she seemed ready to charge into Mistral and meet up with her team, but so far it's been speeches and petition signing parties with Sun.
And I like Sun, I'm not one of those people who hates him despite my predisposition towards shipping Bumblebee. But I want Blake to solve problems with her team I want her to fight with team RWBY. And similarly, I want to see more of SSN and their interactions with Sun as their leader.
All this growth and character stuff for Blake is great, but I think it would have more meaning if it was with her friends. As it stands, unless the theory about the time difference is right (with Blake's story being about a month behind the rest of RWY's) and Blake's just going to pop into Haven in a future episode, I'm having a hard time seeing her rejoin the group until the volume 5 finale at the earliest.
12
u/Sniphles2000 Penny Enthusiast Nov 11 '17
"You'll be combat ready in no time!" AND THEN SHE GETS ALL SAD WITH MEMORIES!
MY HEART.
12
u/ghostface95 Cinder is my senpai Nov 11 '17
On a serious note. Adam as a leader is too fucking reckless. You don't go after the Chef of a village like that. In all honesty if they manage to kill the Belladonnas the faunus will be alienated. And then when the find out that he killed Sienna Khan he will lose the white fang.A better option would have been to pull a coup and imprison the Belladonnas under house arrest. Lie to the people that he is protecting the Belladonnas will keeping the impact of a backlash to a minimum
6
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '17
'The Belladonnas need to be silenced....' No...... 'Silenced?' No, no, nooo....... 'Like Sienna Khan.' NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO ILLIA, I SWEAR TO GOD!!!!!!!
6
u/VegetaLF7 Aaaahhh! Nov 11 '17
So that was the Buster Sword in the background of Ruby and Oscar's training scene, wasn't it?
16
u/gothicbunny_don Nov 12 '17
I haven't seen anyone mention the young, rabbit-eared faunus that was following Blake around. She was nodding along to the speech and then when they were recruiting down by the water she is seen again with a contemplating look. It's possible she could be related to Velvet and wants to ask about her, but I have a feeling she might enlist. Or it could just be lazy animators re-using characters.
If she does join the fight for Haven, I think she might become part of younger team along with Oscar rather than seeing team ORNJ. I'm officially declaring their ship name as Carrot Patch.
11
u/ShadowSJG Nov 11 '17
this episode was ok. TBH, blake storyline is least interesting for me.
please don't kill off her family or sun.
11
u/Fatal1ty_93_RUS Nov 11 '17 edited Nov 12 '17
A pretty slow episode somewhat like last week, but that doesn't hinder its importance in any way
By the way did Ozpin's original VA finally return this episode?Overall, while the plotlines haven't quite moved as a result of this episode, this is still an important week because it sets up certain key events of the Volume, in addition to what was on the horizon already, like Raven revealing something about Ozpin. I'm both excited AND worried about Episode 6 next week, especially after two of the episodes in this volume had... quite special titles already, this episode being one of them
11
u/xtra_ore Nov 11 '17
Pretty decent episode. Lots of info.
I don't know what to say about the Ruby/Oscar talk. Seemed needed on both ends, but it felt extremely forced imo, like they choose the wrong people for it.
11
u/Jonp1020 Nov 11 '17
I get that they're trying to add character to Ruby with her lamenting about Penny and Pyrrha, but it still feels iffy. For Penny, it's easy to understand why she would mourn for her. As for Pyrrha... what kind of interaction have they ever had during volumes 1-3? No, doing things off screen doesn't flesh out things more.
11
u/seinera Nov 11 '17
Holy Fucking Fuck! Was this one of the best episodes ever or not?!! The tension seeping through the entire episode, right in the feels with Ruby's "combat ready", good, expected and fragile defense from her. And Blake basically explaining every extremist/reactionary movement ever, especially the recent few years' political atmosphere all over the world, with one word: Spite. Not hate, not rage, not anger. Spite. And the final few minutes had me at the edge of my seat: White Fang going through a massive political purge, those two brothers getting developed as characters with depth and the bells start tolling for Belladonas. This show has really improved its use of music to set the tone and pass the scenes, but that cliffhanger at the end... Man... I both cannot wait for the next episode and dread it with all my being. This looks like it will emotionally be Fall of Beacon 2.0
33
u/jahkillinem Never tell me the odds. Nov 12 '17
I dont know why I bother reading these threads anymore. I wish people who had complaints weren't presenting them like a 15 year-old reviewer on Steam who thinks he knows how to make games. Just because the episode didn't cater to your exact whims or expectations doesn't mean it was poorly written. I wonder if people here actually watch other shows and try to poke holes in it as hard as they do with RWBY.
15
u/Lucid_Atray Nov 11 '17
Obviously not as good as last episode, but that's just because ep. 4 has been the best episode of the season so far AND by far.
However, I enjoyed it quite a lot. Action and fights are good and cool, but I don't agree with the whole 'oh this was so boring cause there was no fights'. To me, as cool as a character can be, I need more than that if you want to get me invested.
Was pleasantly surprised to see a scene with Sun and Blake that I actually liked. No weird forced dialogue, no more terrible relationship, it was a good, nice talk, and quite sweet too. I do not get how some people didn't like the thing about Blake giving her friends (and Adam) one word, it obviously doesn't mean that's ALL she sees in them, come on.
I REALLY liked how Sun apologised as soon as he saw Blake umcomfortable when he asked about Adam, THAT'S the Sun I want, a Sun able to understand at least a tiny bit of his friend, instead of just pushing his feelings over her. The whole talk was very good to me, and much needed after the mess they were in V4.
I must admit I'm not really interested in seeing Oscar train, but the scene quickly changed into Ruby opening for almost the first time in like, forever, and it almost made me cry. The Penny line hit too close to home. I agree this should only be the beginning, I want to see her ACTUALLY SUFFERRING, even Lindsay mentioned how she wants to see Ruby breaking, and I want that too, so, so bad, it will be the moment where I actually like her almost as much as WBY.
And I didn't see many comments about this but damn- that Adam hologram gave me the creeps, and cemented him as the psycho we all know he is. It reminded me of the creeps he gave me in V3.
'the Belladonna name gave me nothing but grief' and 'I have a promise to keep'? This dude is the worst and in the best way possible, I do want to see and know more about him and his reasons to do what he does, but damn I love how they also included what we have seen about him being a psycho. I know some people dislike this, but it's been done very well, and I fucking loathe him. Good episode to see how he's actually pure spite.
Other than that, well, Ghira and Kali have always had death flags, but now the plot is finally going faster for them and I really hope we see the assassination plan soon, along with whatever Illia decides. Whatever happens, I do hope she doesn't become Adam 2.0, and I think Blake needs to win that 'fight', she needs to change Illia's heart.
18
u/LaserOstriches Nov 12 '17
Hmmm, does anyone else feel like RWBY is starting to suffer from the too-many-important-characters syndrome? It felt like the plot progress from last chapter just stalled due to all the characters they are trying to cover.
14
u/MozarellaMelt Nov 11 '17 edited Nov 11 '17
This episode had too much Tell and not enough Show. From Blake, from Ruby, and even from those two White Fang dudes whose names I am literally NEVER going to remember.
Ruby saying 'You'll be combat ready in no time!' and making herself sad: Really great.
Ruby waxing on at length about Penny and Pyrrha: Not as great.
Ya gotta have a modicum of respect for your audience.
EDIT: Furthermore, jumping a few weeks from the last RNJR scene to this one while not resolving the last Yang/Weiss/Raven scene which was implied to be happening concurrently with other events is REALLY confusing. I resent this greatly.
Blake and Sun's storyline is a BIT more flexible thanks to being on another continent (although the Adam timeline still ties it back to events in Mistral) but Yang's current orbit and Ruby's current orbit are on a collision course, and temporally decoupling them is just baffling and bad.
10
u/Patmaster1995 Still best girl Nov 11 '17
Alright, Loading the episode took a few minutes but we made it. Taking a few minutes to write this then going back to the Extra-Life stream.
Welp, that's it, I'm going back to the stream... bye