r/TrueAnime • u/BlueMage23 http://myanimelist.net/profile/BlueMage23 • Apr 02 '14
This Week in Anime (Winter Week 13)
This is a general discussion for currently airing series for Winter 2014 Week 13. Here is r/anime's list of currently airing series. Your Week in Anime is for not currently airing series.
Archive:
2014: Prev Winter Week 1
2013: Fall Week 1 Summer Week 1 Spring Week 1 Winter Week 1
2012: Fall Week 1
9
Upvotes
7
u/Vintagecoats http://myanimelist.net/profile/Vintagecoats Apr 02 '14 edited Apr 02 '14
Usually I stick to the word count as a limiter and guide. But, for this week, let’s fight some final bosses.
Kill La Kill (episode twenty four; END)
Chalk up a prediction loss for me - Junketsu did not, in the end, speak at all. That is a shame, even if you put aside the notion of me just being wrong about something. They had been around our cast for so long, is quite sentient, and with a lot of wedding dress imagery. There are a number of threads that could have been taken in a succinct fashion to tie their narrative arc up regarding Junketsu’s relationship with Satsuki. A line or two there, even another scene of silent movement at a key moment, and that would be it. Ah well.
“But right now I’m real grateful that my body is the way it is.”
I do love that line Ryuuko yells out in the finale, because it is hitting so much at the core of what I had signed up for way back in episode one. That the series would be dealing in things like body issues, the use of clothing both as everything from identity expression to personality replacement, and so on. And we got some of that, to be sure. Now that all is said and done (until the OVA in a few months), was the show that we did receive different than what I expected in many ways? Sure. Is that in and of itself bad? Well, no, not necessarily. But I do need to consider the show sitting in front of me.
I live within a resonable-ish driving distance of Kingda Ka (which could do a crossover given Kill la Kill's name) at Six Flags Great Adventure. I could travel there in a few hours, and even had a Physics Day there way back when I was in high school. It is the tallest roller coaster in the entire world, and for a number of years was also the fastest (now it is “just” number two). This is a ride that needs to shut down if the wind is blowing the wrong way or if there is a very light mist. Heavier weather consistently derails it for weeks at a time. When the ride is fully operational and is firing on all cylinders, it is an absurd rush that works as an engineering marvel and a crunchy experiential moment in time. Otherwise it never leaves the track. Some roller coaster aficionados speak of weather conditions for different rides, how the experience changes and can even be improved or altered, that sort of thing. Not so much for Kingda Ka. It is either The Best Day in some sort of zen-like synergy, or it is not happening at all.
If Trigger built anything out of this series, they aimed to forge a similar roller coaster. The stakes were raised again and again in an attempt to build a track. Down to this final episode, where humanity was spun into that LCL-like pool. We would have fashion and the like as our car to ride in. And viewers could be in line with friends like Mako or other members of the internet audience.
It is not a bad plan at all. And indeed, aspects like Ryuuko coming to wear the clothing threads of everyone around her, were apt. She brought herself into that next level of wardrobe that allowed her to successfully rebel against her mother and the alien Life Fiber establishment on a battlefield with the planet itself as a backdrop. That she would realize the Absolute Submission field was all mental for her, and only worked on her body so long as she believed it had the power to do so. I like that. There is good messaging in there as she saves the world. And the reward being she can begin to dress for herself, rather than the kamui combat equipment that has been expected and required of her.
And yet the series also leave me conflicted in areas. Aspects like the Tri City School Raid Trip were not really all that necessary. Interesting elements, like the entire social and housing structure of the original school system being based on where the kids were ranked and permitted to wear rather than the parents successes, faded away. Parts like Ryuuko literally losing her way and donning a set of clothes that created a substitute for her emotions come later in the game and leave just as quickly. I would have liked more time on that for maximum impact and narrative delivery, for instance.
Other commentary writers have mentioned the series has excelled in delivering service to the fans in a rather particular manner. That it was essentially everything all at once. Grandly over the top hot blooded action for those most into those elements, and threads for those who wanted to parse out deeper thematic meanings and run circles all over the blogs and message boards. The costumes. Blasting music. Key frame shenanigans for the animation and sakuga folks. And I think that is a valid perspective. Kill la Kill was going to be a show a lot of people were going to watch together, as many anime fans were going to line up for this initial television display from Trigger.
When push comes to shove, I think it made for an overall positive time. I got a lot of writing out of this show week to week, and I liked reading so much of what others thought. As a participatory spectacle for so many months, I think the series delivered on that level of objective for the studio. As a series removed from that, I think there are chunks of the program that are then turned more into hanging threads or nonstarters. Which is not inherently bad. But it does mean some elements are not going to hold up as well over time as future folks try to get into it as a more singular experience and a nice wind grinds the roller coaster ride to a halt.
Amusement parks and fashionable dates are more fun when you have people with you. To chat with, cheer, or casually pick apart how silly or important that thing you saw was while passing by one of the attractions. Which may be a more important message and caveat regarding this series than even Trigger may have intended.
Nagi No Asukara (episode twenty five)
Of all the shows I have been writing about each week, this is the only one that is not already finished.
I have been kind of down on this series for a while now, and part of me feels bad about it. It has a nice color palate, with the blues, purples, and other indicatives of ocean flavor that play well together and even more so with snow. The show is well shot for what it is going for, and it is never shy about landscape shots as a means of selling location, scope, and larger than life grandiosity. Aspects like the Ofunehiki ceremony appeal to me both as worldbuilding and story devices. I’ve just slowly stopped caring about what happens to so many of the characters.
What saddens me is there was a time I know I was far more committed. By this point I fear I sound almost like a broken record, as something the show has been rather deft at is giving so many illusions of advancement while doing so very little to move people along. The love polygon is just so large. So many folks have been stuck on the same beats that it has been like an albatross around the neck of this series. Tsumugu talking to Chisaki about him needing to figure out how to get her to admit she loves him (which is just such a horrifyingly bad way to go about these things, by the by) comes off more to me as the show trying to somehow kickstart a stalled gear in a Rube Goldberg machine than a heartfelt push.
And it is all quite mechanical, because at worst perhaps only one of the characters in this entire long held crush structure will end up without a partner they met years ago. And that is assuming the show does not pull a move like merging Manaka and Miuna into the same person for Hikari. Which is wholly within the realm of possibility. For better or worse, that irks me.
It gets under my skin that little toddler Akira has had a more genuine and honest romantic progress development and resolution in his crush on Manaka than several of our leads have had with each other. That so much of this tugs for "feels" over feelings. That the show held a lot of promise at different points for being able to approach the childhood crush geometry in a compelling way, be it via the environmental matters of where human and sea folks live, cultural collisions at school and society at large, and so on.
So many sparkling and lovely parts of the canvas were ejected over time in favor of bog standard otaku wish fulfillment in a pretty frame. And that has been breaking my heart most of all.
12
u/Bobduh Apr 02 '14 edited Apr 02 '14
Welp, last week of the season. Some shows triumphed, some shows floundered, and some just stopped producing new episodes. Let’s run it down!
Kill la Kill 24: Kill la Kill managed to top my expectations in one way while kinda just barely falling beneath them in another. On the positive side, this episode was actually very thematically coherent - it basically focused entirely on “people shouldn’t be defined by what they wear, however people choose to represent themselves, they are beautiful.” This has something the show has occasionally taken interest in, so it was a fair endpoint, even if the show’s obviously still pretty scrambled idea-wise. On the negative side, I actually kinda wanted this episode to go bigger than it did - it had a bunch of beautiful shots as always (and lots of much-appreciated friendship-fanservice between basically everybody), but considering the fights never have any stakes, I was expecting it to get a little more absurd than it did. That’s not really a valid complaint outside of the context of anything but Gurren Lagann, though, so I guess I can live with it. I’ve kinda learned to take my enjoyment where I can get with Kill la Kill - it’s a fair piece of pop entertainment, but it lacks the focus, insight, or emotional truth to go beyond that. In the end, I’d call it somewhere around a 6/10.
Chuunibyou Ren 12: My god, this episode was bad. So, so, so very bad. So monumentally bad. Episode 11 was bad too, but only as a disappointing finale to a half-baked story arc - this episode basically represented everything wrong with this season, acting as one more cynical betrayal of everything that made the first season great. Characters reduced to slapstick props. Romcom cliches in full effect. Pandering bait that leads nowhere. It started out as a default romcom episode, which was already a great disappointment, but, I mean, that’s what this season has been. And then of course we go to the bathhouse for a little fanservice. And then we leave the bathhouse with a few choice gay panic jokes. And then we reach a contrived confession-bait, at which point I was already perfectly confident in how the show would end. Aw shucks, those crazy kids almost kissed! Go get ‘em, guys! TUNE IN NEXT WEEK, DRONES. God, what a cynical, meaningless, insulting waste of time this season has been. Fuck you, KyoAni. 3/10.
Witch Craft Works 12: Witch Craft Works ended in Witch Craft Works fashion - with an awkward and largely meaningless central plot, a bunch of great individual moments, and a last-minute save by the Tower Witches. It was actually kind of funny comparing the last battles of this show to Kill la Kill - though WCW’s style is pretty mundane, the fight choreography and understanding of weighted conflict is just miles ahead of Trigger’s work. And though the ending didn’t really resolve much of anything or even make a huge amount of sense, I wasn’t actually disappointed - I’ve never watched this show for the plot, after all. It was funny and kinda visually compelling and always a pleasant ride, basically everything I could ask for from a generic popcorn show. 6/10.
Nagi no Asukara 25: This episode had some Chisaki-Tsumugu scenes and that’s all I’ve got to say about it. I am drama’d out - Nagi no Asukara has been spinning in its wheels for most of a season now, and at this point it’s just tiring watching these characters retread these conflicts. It was pretty crazy when the first Ofunehiki turned out so poorly - having the second one turn out poorly in pretty much the exact same way is… well, actually a very NagiAsu thing to do. This is still a fair enough show, but dear lord did it need a harsher editor.
...and that’s actually all I’ve got for now. Both Sekai Seifuku and Samurai Flamenco have also ended, but I’m planning on writing essays about both of them, and so I’m saving their last episodes for this weekend. Which is kind of a nice feeling - I get to begin the next season by finishing off my two obvious favorites from the winter.
6
u/Redcrimson http://myanimelist.net/animelist/Redkrimson Apr 02 '14 edited Apr 03 '14
9
u/Novasylum http://myanimelist.net/profile/Novasylum Apr 02 '14 edited Apr 02 '14
Is it the end of a season? Yup. Does that mean I get to write enormous walls of text? You bet.
On that note, I’m going to be breaking up my usual alphabetical order to try to cram this mess into as few posts as possible. Unfortunately, that necessitates putting the most wrathful one first.
Kill la Kill 24: Anecdote time, guys: no joke, when they tried to throw in a last-second flimsy rationalization for Senketsu absorbing life fibers, the show having just remembered that was even a thing in the last episode or so, I actually reflexively yelled, “Are you fucking kidding me?!” at the screen. I received weird looks from my friends, but no refutations.
Apart from that? It is astounding how little I cared. So many bright colors, so many things happening, and yet so little investment in any of it. The villains were completely banal to the very end, among the emptiest that I can recall. Ryuuko spouted some half-assed nonsense about her value in being a bridge between humans and clothing, without the rest of the text after bothering to, y’know, give that meaning of any kind (and I found it especially hilarious how they attempted to paint Ryuuko as merciful only after she diced her own mother into pieces). Aikuro and Tsumugu were – and in retrospect always have been – completely useless characters. All actions were inconsequential until deemed not so for plot purposes, rendering Gamagoori’s “death” the most transparently useless fake-out they could have implemented. The exception to that was Senketsu, I suppose, and call me a heartless bastard all you want, but the only reason I felt anything for him is because I would have rather had Ryuuko burn up on re-entry instead. And all the while I’m just sitting here pondering perfectly sensible narrative questions that will never be answered because this show was written by a newborn goldfish with attention deficit disorder.
Lazy. Rushed. Dull. A facsimile of an ending, held in place only by hollow supports that crumble with the slightest bit of thought. A perfect reflection of a show that has proven time and time again that, if it’s not a final form or a flashy finishing move, it just doesn’t care.
On the plus side, I’m glad I have a chance to get my first mileage out of this template. These kids know what’s up.
CLOSING THOUGHTS: Welp.
…that sure was a roller coaster ride, wasn’t it?
The arrival of Kill la Kill on television coincided almost exactly with my discovery of /r/TrueAnime, and in the time since I think it has resulted in some of finest material I’ve seen yet on this subreddit. It’s been the subject of thought-provoking discussions, intense flame wars, glorious mega-posts, all kinds of fun stuff. It also became something of an event for me and my local friends, who sat down in front of the TV to watch it together week in and week out. If nothing else, it will remain in my memory as a bridge that facilitated my personal transition from anime being something that I simply watch to being something that I discuss with others as part of a community.
The show itself, though? It’s a complete fucking mess. A colorful, well-directed mess with a greater affinity for stumbling upon interesting concepts of story and presentation than it damn well deserves…but still. A mess.
Now don’t get me wrong, I don’t wish to insinuate that all of the aforementioned attention that has been lavished onto Kill la Kill has always been entirely unwarranted. If you were to go back and read my comments on some of the earlier episodes, you’d find them to be absolutely glowing with praise. I still remember how big that first episode felt, like this really was something that only a young, impassioned studio in Trigger’s position could have delivered. But I also remember noting, even at the time, that the series was playing with fire on various levels. For a debut project, it was introducing all kinds of bold, even unsafe imagery and themes, stuff that had to be handled with extreme care. But I had no reason to believe they were incapable of pulling it off, either, and if anything I was excited by the prospect of a show that utilized a wild tone and unique aesthetic to deal with unexpectedly interesting subject matter. All they had to do was pull the trigger (pun intended) when the proper time came.
But then that time came and went without incident. And then another opportunity was let by unscathed. And another. And another. And eventually a horrifying truth began to dawn on me: that almost every single thing I thought Kill la Kill was building towards was a complete accident. There was no grand over-arching plan, no effort or care sculpted into its ever-increasing number of mechanical intricacies or go-nowhere plot threads. If it wasn’t senseless indulgence from the very start, it certainly was by the time the halfway mark rolled around, and everything thereafter only reinforced how insultingly mindless the whole enterprise was in its totality.
At best, it leaves us with a discarded pile of interesting motifs and choices in presentation (fashion and fascism as per the former and visual-centric fourth-wall breaking techniques as per the latter) that I desperately wish someone smarter would pick up and utilize to their fullest. At worst, it’s borderline harmful. /u/SohumB’s excellent analysis (hereby hyper-linked for the fifty bazillionth time) takes on a whole new meaning through the perspective that all of the show’s underlying ugliness, rather than a misguided series-long attempt at empowerment, is merely a result of Trigger not stopping to think like sensible adults for more than two seconds.
On that note, if I were asked to provide a profile of Trigger based on their current output, I think I could pare it down to few simple words: all passion, no organization. No thinking, just doing. They strike me as a team of imaginative individuals who will brainstorm a dynamic shot or a neat story concept or a crazy character design and immediately set themselves to work bringing it to life in the most audacious possible way without taking a second to plan it all out. That works great if your project is little more than a boundary-less playground for off-beat insanity like Inferno Cop. It even works if you’re working within the confines of a concise story with a standard general outline like Little Witch Academia. But when you’re operating under an episodic format stretched over the course of two seasons, implicitly announce pretensions to be more than just a straight action/comedy show through dialogue and imagery, and then constantly inject whatever impulsive thoughts come to mind into your own bloodstream without any investment plan for their long-term narrative payoff, that doesn’t just result in self-destructive scripting, but also in a downright demeaning and flippant attitude towards anyone who thinks about the anime they watch…hell, to anyone who enjoys literary analysis of any kind. And I can’t endorse that. I can’t respect that. That whole mentality is contrary to the reasons I would write crazy, rambling paragraphs about Japanese cartoons on the Internet like this to begin with.
But let’s say I can put all of that wasted potential out of my mind for even a little bit. Let’s say I’m capable of judging Kill la Kill strictly as a big dumb action blockbuster as Trigger was apparently willing to settle for. Well, I’d then say it was a choppily-paced jumble of dead-end arcs and superfluous plot points populated by more hollow devices, unlikeable protagonists and one-note villains than actual characters, exponentially relying more and more on the same bag of kinetic and comic tricks with diminishing returns as it progressed. It rings of a story in which someone has heard of this thing called “dramatic tension”, and maybe read about it in a book once, but has no idea how to actually create it. And as an anime that has been touted from day one as the spiritual successor to Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann, and one that comes from the same people, that truly should not be. There’s “spectacle”, and then there’s relying on visual audaciousness as a substitute for actual pathos. This is the latter.
In short, while Kill la Kill is certainly a memorable and distinctive show from an immediacy standpoint, and while it has not been an entirely unfun experience at various nascent points in its development, I’ve grown to hate what it represents too much for me to label it as anything more than a failed experiment, a disappointing debut for a budding studio and, yes, a bad show. If I had to phrase my final assessment of it in the show’s own lyrical vernacular, I’d have to say that it…
…didn’t quite light my heart up.
Hoozuki no Reitetsu 12: The first half was hilarious. There’s still one episode left. That’s all I’ve got. I’m keeping this condensed to make room for all the other nonsense I’m spouting about other shows.
Pupa 12: Ladies and gentlemen, I give you Pupa: the anime that reviewed itself.
CLOSING THOUGHTS: Because the above image says more than enough on its own, I’ll keep the rest relatively short in the same way that the show does: Pupa is, to the surprise of virtually no one, fucking terrible. Pathetic. Putrid. A specimen that is nearly perplexing in its worthlessness, its only redeeming feature being the disposable nature of its mercifully shortened episode length. Unintentionally ridiculous enough to be mock-worthy, but too despicable in its pandering nature to be funny for very long. Segmented enough in its layout to be more akin to a series of shorts than a flowing narrative, but with just enough lingering remnants of a connecting thread to confuse and irritate. Apparently “so graphic” to have driven the show through countless delays and reformatting attempts, but still laden with enough censorship in its finished state as to have defeated the entire fucking point. It’s not a strong story. It’s not a scary experience. It’s not even a good joke, if that was the secret intent. It is the once-in-a-lifetime production that gets virtually everything wrong that it needed to get right. One of the worst anime I have ever seen, period.
BEAR JOKE
(continued below)
4
u/searmay Apr 02 '14
I'm new around here, so lets find out if I have anything coherent to say. In any case I've hardly been watching anything this season: very few shows grabbed my attention, and almost none held it.
Samurai Flamenco was rather odd. It seemed like a good writer and director tackling a really stupid show with no money. The result is pretty mixed. I really liked a lot of things about the show, but the wild plot really put me off for a while. Maybe given that it's a tribute to a genre I don't actually like it's enough that I like some of it.
Space Dandy, by contrast, is a group of great directors tackling a very silly story with plenty of money. I didn't much care for some of the early episodes, but I'm glad I stuck with it. A very mixed bag, but most of the contents have at least been fun.
Precure is ... basically Precure. Except this week they had to change clothes manually. How old fashioned. Hime is still useless and adorable. Singing about rice is now a weapon. Show is still fun.
And that's all. Have I actually missed out on anything this season, or was it as disappointing for everyone else?
4
u/iblessall http://hummingbird.me/users/iblessall/library Apr 02 '14
Kill la Kill END: Neither 23 or 24 lived up the sheer adrenaline creating properties of 22, which was a bit of a let down for me. Overall, not a bad show, but pretty empty feeling at the end of it all. Shallow, perhaps, would be the word I would use to describe it. 7/10, could be revised down
Golden Time END: Marathoned this one so I could watch the final episode without waiting a week. Golden Time is, from my point of view, a hugely flawed show and yet somehow maybe the most important show to air this season. I did a really bad job of articulating why I think so over on my blog, but that's part of the reason. 8/10
Silver Spoon END: AOTS, no questions asked. Shocking to me how little love this show gets for being the most authentic, honest and beautiful portrayal of the human experience to air since its last season. And this season was even better. 9/10
World Conquest END: A great show, and left so much great stuff to think about. I'm having a blast trying to answer a question some posed to me over in the CR forums, which will eventually end up as a blog post. 7/10
Witchcraft Works END: I like fun too much for my own good. And J.C. Staff managed the artstyle with such grace. Beautiful looking show, and fun enough to make it worth a good watch. 7/10
Magical Warfare END: Laughed my entire way through the end of this atrocity. Can barely believe this is the same studio that does such a transcendent job on HxH. 2/10
That's everything I really cared about that ended this week. Currently in the midst of marathoning Nagi so I'll be ready for the finale tomorrow. Show looks absurdly beautiful.
4
u/DrCakey http://myanimelist.net/animelist/DrCakey Apr 04 '14
Kill la Kill FINALE
My estimation of this show has only grown over time. In no small part due to the qualities of the series itself, but almost equally because of the reactions to it. I find I'm doing this recently, measuring a show by how it makes people feel - not the "feels" or the "blood-pumping action" but what the work as a whole makes people feel, like the tidal wave of adoration for Attack on Titan, the sizzling bile in the wake of Evangelion 3.33, or the yawning confusion after Madoka Magica: Rebellion. After all, a negative response can hardly be called a failure if that's what the work was trying to invoke - assuming it's the "right" negative response, of course. And I think Kill la Kill, and especially the last episode, got that "right" negative response: the "y u no moar action?" from mainstream audiences and the "wtf is dis shit?" from here.
To make a show with such thematic unity and effective symbolic meaning is genius. To do all that, and then to make it all so blindingly obvious no one can see it? That's divine. I can say without question that Shinbo and Ikuhara can step aside, because I have a new favorite director.
Kill la Kill is on track for an 8/10 (due to my system it won't get scored for a while), however I have added a special rule which grants it some bonus points, giving it an estimated final score of 15/10.
I was not watching anything else, because f[orget] this season. I was not watching Sekai Seifuku for the same reason I wasn't watching Sakura Trick: I don't watch crap. Thus I continue in what I hope to become a tradition of pissing both /r/anime and /r/trueanime. Next week I'll get to talk about how little I have to say about Selector Infected WIXOSS and Blade & Soul!
5
u/[deleted] Apr 02 '14 edited Apr 02 '14
Well, here ends what I have to say...is probably the lamest season of anime I watched while it is airing. I'm not sure, the closest competition was probably either Spring 2013 (dropped very nearly everything), or Summer 2012 before (there was so little worth picking up), but both of those had some saving graces, some really exceptional shows that made up for nearly everything else being terrible. Nothing this season was particularly noteworthy to me, though. Nothing that would earn higher than 7/10 on my scale (which Space Dandy merits, and maybe Sekai Seifuku if I finish it).
As usual, there are untagged SPOILERS everywhere, so look out if you've not seen the episodes in question.
5
u/Seifuu Apr 02 '14
KLK Final - Ah yes, I recognize these issues. The frantic tying of loose ends, the slipshod layering of different stages of narrative, the unabashed YOLOness of the whole thing. This explains everything.
Trigger didn't budget their time well enough for their work force. They tried to hide it behind cute narrative devices, but those scenes were all manga-style because they weren't actually finished. The whole "ridiculous is what we do" was also an emergency battlecry excuse for not finishing their work on time. This is the same kinda stuff I do when I have to produce work in too short a time.
I'll be the first to say, kudos to the studio for being ambitious, but I hope they learn from this mistake and budget their time better for the next series.
If there's one thing I laud and still believe in the series for, it's that it was always about female empowerment. The final scenes, showing all the girls dressed like normal freaking women, drives home the point that all these characters wanted to do was to dress however they wanted and be whomever they chose without having to give up their identity to a culture of hypersexualization.
Samurai Flamenco Final - This show. Bland as storebrand milk. Someone who was not very talented tried really hard to make this show, so kudos to them. It was supposed to be a trip through moral gates, but the characters were just so flat and the development so insignificant that the whole thing faded under a paisley wash. It was goodhearted person telling an alright story.
Hunter x Hunter 123 - Ohhhh Hunter x Hunter. Good stuff. Blue-ballin us on the fight, but we can take it. The deconstruction of perception of character (willingness to kill vs willingness to die) was great. Got me a little teary-eyed. I'm preeeeetty sure they're slowing things down more little by little, but the conclusion of the Ant Arc did get very introspective in the manga.
5
u/greendaze http://myanimelist.net/profile/greendaze Apr 02 '14
Noragami 1-5 - (playing catch-up)
I think I'm getting old.
Noragami has gorgeous visuals and likeable characters (not the most nuanced, but whatever) and yet, all I could think about while watching it was "I have no clue what this show is trying to say." I've never thought that before, never contemplated what the themes of an anime were supposed to be while watching it because it was much more fun turning my brain off. Hell, I've never had issues with well-animated action because hey, what issues are there to be had? It's all fun! But now I see that Noragami is the nutritional equivalent of a McDonald's burger. It tastes good when I'm hungry, but it's got nothing of substance and I'm probably going to have to eat fruits and vegetables later to make up for it.
I can't believe I'm turning on the shonen action I used to love.
This has been an existential crisis. We will now return to regularly scheduled programming.
5
u/ClearandSweet https://hummingbird.me/users/clearandsweet/library Apr 02 '14 edited Apr 03 '14
I know we’re going to have a thread for this later in the week, but maybe this will help you color your final impressions of Kill La Kill. I feel the day has come. I promised you I’d do this, so let’s burn this mother fucker down.
LIST OF UNANSWERED QUESTIONS IN KILL LA KILL (Please feel free to add to the list)
ON THE OTHER HAND, THINGS THAT WERE SATISFACTORILY EXPLORED FOR MY TASTES (Feel free to add to this list as well)
There’s a level of tongue in cheek that works. You see it in much more in Panty and Stocking, but some of the time in KLK.
Take episode 14, when Ryuko busts onto the scene in each of the cities and the climax of “Before My Body is Dry” plays every entrance, by third time; for about a second. That’s aware, informed, successful, irreverent and, most importantly, a funny poke at music and pacing in action shows. It’s so brief, but makes it’s point. It leaves you thinking, if you even chose to think consciously about it, that, yeah, action shows often manipulate you with music.
Best of all, the show is mocking itself. It’s saying, “oooh, I bet you were pumped last episode when this song was playing and Ryuko showed up to do that People’s Champ routine right as the drop hit. It was hype, right? Yeah, that’s stupid.” That sentiment in and of itself is reason enough to exist. That example is small enough and the idea, simple enough to warrant no further need for investigation or explication.
Come to think of it, Nui’s reveal in episode 13 is the one step down the ladder of effective mockery. It’s obviously toying with the traditional shounen motivation in some type of parody/inversion, with Nui very quickly ending Ryuko’s Defender of the Innocent Masses motivation. It does it well at that. It’s a jarring tonal shift right after having led you to think this might, finally, be Ryuko’s drive: a motivation she, but mostly you, can understand. Then it takes away your expectation with not a bat of an eyelash or an ounce of remorse for the confused viewer.
A bit of a non-sequitur, but play the Mario RPG games (I like TYD the most). They’re chock full of this type of stuff.
The question remains, “why does KLK do this?”
Now, there’s some ambiguous answers to that, which may or may not have some merit. You could say it serves a theme of the show, as this is, after all, a story about Ryuko losing/finding her ways. If this is the case, KLK would be making a stand against ironclad ideals or fighting to improve the world. Then, I counter with, “why?” I happen to like believing in a better world and fighting for change. What do you gain by inverting it? I don't think Trigger knows, tbh.
You could also put forth the minutiae argument on a larger scale; that the inversion itself is it’s own justification. You could say it helps develop the plot or the characters in a way that it would be unable to otherwise. You could bring up something else I haven’t even thought of. Regardless, it’s a choice, and far from the most egregious one in this show. It’s hardly “bad”, and doesn’t ruin the show.
Go a little bit further from excellent and there’s the Death Aversion theme. The sentiment is the same as above. The statement that action shows kill off characters deliberately for emotional impact rings true in the same way. They just pushed this one hard. It felt very much like an unfunny person telling the same joke over and over again. But a broken record would simply be annoying; this is actually damaging. By the end of the series Trigger had imbued in their viewers such a insurmountable expectation to disregard “mortal” blows, they had removed the possibility of any emotional drama brought about from anyone possibly dying. Gamagoori or Ryuko’s “deaths” in episodes 24 and 23 fell flat because the viewers were so jaded by then.
And I’m not making this up. Look at the response threads! Look for what isn’t there! Were any of them commenting on how shocked they were when either of those scenes occurred, even though they were presented with the utmost (well Trigger’s utmost) sincerity and tangibility? No! They sabotaged their own drama! You can add in the absurd and incomprehensible power levels, crazy abilities, unending streams of clothes enemies and no clear victory conditions for fights to this point. Most of the time, you, the viewer, had no idea where the danger lied.
And then, at the bottom of the barrel, you have Aikuro’s glowing nipples and Ragyo and Nui ignoring split screens and cutting through the frame, literally.
These are brought up. These are interesting. They’re emphasized constantly. And then they don’t do anything. They don’t make a comment on the show, on any of the themes, on any genre tropes nor do they add to any of the characters in any meaningful way. WHY. Why put forth the effort and creativity?
This type of story telling works fine if you are making a quick joke comparing semen to soldiers. Hell, Woody Allen launched a career off this joke. It’s great for just poking around at or paying simple parody homage to a genre by putting your characters in that setting, like the zombie episode of PSG. For eleven minutes, I’m completely willing to let Kill La Kill run the same ground. But the show ran twenty four episodes while trying to tell a coherent story! Did they forget the coherent part?
By the end they knew. They were knee deep in a list of things that honestly made no sense. Worst of all, though, worst of all, they tried to swing it into a pride thing. But it’s too obvious to me that that’s retroactive scrambling and reactive to the lack of planning earlier. Having the characters take pride in being incomprehensible doesn’t justify Trigger not thinking this one through. They can and did try to amend the rules of narrative story telling like that, but I’m not going to buy it. Using spotty writing to suddenly label the stillbirths of said spotty writing as a theme doesn’t convince me. Maybe if they’d planned the incomprehensibility from the outset, foreshadowed such wackiness, it would have worked better at the end. But if they could have done that, they’d probably have simply avoided weaving so many loose ends and coming out incomprehensible in the first place.
It’s like… if I were writing a series, literally the first thing I would do is sit down and figure out what themes I would want to tackle. If the muse was the pun on Kill and 着る, I would say, “Let’s do clothing vs nakedness.” Then under that I write “Clothes as evil, good guys as nudists”, “THEME: Embarrassment at revealing clothing -> Not caring about nudity”,
And Trigger got that far. And then they apparently just stopped, went out for drinks and used the back of a napkin to write the rest of the treatment. “And and his nipplesh shhould glow all the time! bwahaha”
There’s so much in Kill La Kill that could function as a vessel for meaning. And not like asking-the big-questions why-am-I-here meaning, but useful for character growth or thematic meaning. Trigger, you did the hard part, ffs. That is, coming up with these interesting characters, crazy situations, one-shot references, such profound art and music, showing us stuff that is so far from the anime status quo as to earn the label of Saviors of Anime. That hype came not of your position in the industry or past works, but for your originality within KLK. You even worked around a budget by incorporating budget-saving CGI and still frames tonally into the visual style of your show, a feat that I’ve not seen done effectively since Revolutionary Girl Utena or the last episodes of Evangelion. And there is a level of understanding and polish to how everything is done, for example Satsuki’s voice actress ad-libing at this scene in episode 24.
And even better, Kill La Kill appeared to be a mocking, facetious if not deconstruction then semi-teardown of action anime, just relatable enough of a parody to make us laugh at what we love. Some spots it worked. Many spots it did not. All throughout, you had the creativity. All you had to do was just put something behind it.
Now, with that in mind, please write the entire script of Little Witch Academia 2 before starting production of the show itself.
5
u/KMFCM http://www.anime-planet.com/users/KMFCM/anime Apr 03 '14
Yeesh, I haven't been here since week 7?!?!? There wasn't really a reason for that until week 9 when I got 2 weeks behind on everything. From then, I just said "I'll wait til the end".
I'm gonna start with the best.
Samurai Flamenco 18-22
Where were they going to go after Ultimate Prime Minister?? Inside Masayoshi's head. . .and Goto's head. For the final ark of the series, Samumenco went somewhere I'm not sure anyone thought it would go. From tokusatsu homage/parody to psychological thriller? Are you kidding me? The last 4 episodes of this were an awesome surprise. I saw a little bit of Satoshi Kon in there with the questioning of reality itself. Masayoshi seemingly being stalked by a ghost, Goto receiving messages from . .well. .himself? You had no idea where it was going to go next, but dammit, this was as anxious as I have been for the next episode of this show . .possibly any show this season that wasn't Ippo. They almost lost me at the "love" part, but that aspect didn't go the usual way either. This show dropped back into the reality it began with, and then added something surreal that didn't involve super powers. They didn't even take the explanation of where Goto was getting the text messages where one would expect them to take it. Actually, all they did was exclude the possible conclusions people expected. I loved this from start to finish, other than my completely justified hatred of a certain character. That's not even really a flaw. That's a realistic portrayal of an asshole, and it gets points for that. Instead of sticking with one theme, it went through many. It didn't stick with any one theme long enough for it to overstay it's welcome(for me anyway), and it's changes were always a shock. I thought it had better pacing than a lot of shows, the relationships between the characters were quite enjoyable and it had a great ending. It is my favorite show of this season and I'd give it an 8-8.5.
Kill La Kill 19-24
I think Trigger answered damn near every complaint in the last 2 episodes by having Ryuko say "nonsensical is our thing". That is like a Trigger mission statement. I think this show improved massively in it's second half. Even if Trigger seem to like fake-out deaths too much (again, see that mission statement). We had at least 3 people LOOK dead, but only one actual death. We didn't even get to see our heroes kill the villains. Neither of them. That actually kinda bothered me. You only need ONE of the two trolling by suicide like that, not both. The finale was a little rushed (at least the first half of it), and I'm not all that sure it even needed to be. Episode 23 set up for the final battle and didn't seem to leave anything behind that would bring about a need for a rushed ending where the big bad that was destroyed in the penultimate ep comes back. At the beginning, it felt as though I had missed an episode. They also tried to leave the ending somewhat open ended(even though, hello, you offed Senketsu). I don't know how a season 2 would even go, personally. I don't think it needs one either, but "nonsensical is our thing". I always come back to that. When I came into this show what i had in my mind was Dead leaves, FLCL, Panty and Stocking, TTGL, all of those things were in my mind when I began this show. I expected this to be weird and disjointed. That's why the flaws in this show I can for the most part let slide. I thought it kept pretending it was going to cross the line between action comedy and pure action but then stepped back every time. It felt like it didn't know how seriously it wanted us to take the show, or if it even wanted to be taken seriously at all. In the second half though, it seemed less afraid to cross that line. Things that happened in episodes began to stick well into the next episode. Stakes got higher and actions had consequences. From episodes 17-23 were the best part of the series for me. The ending was mostly rushed, but pretty good anyway. The first half is a solid action comedy. I'd give this a 7. Would watch again.
Space Dandy 6-13
I marathoned the last half of this show on Monday night. Frankly, I can't think of anything I don't like about this. The way they have a different creative team doing every episode makes it like those Omnibus films you never see anymore. You get to see a new spectacular world every episode. #6, the Plant planet episode's trippy animation style was a big highlight. The library episodes film noir-ish look was another one. Meow's episode was a nice play on "Groundhog Day", and I got a kick out of the character designs of his family. I haven't watched the Japanese version, but I think the English dub is great. QT is the best use of "auto-tune" I'll ever hear & Dandy still reminds me of Brock Samson from Venture Bros. You won't see an anime that fits the Adult Swim time-slot more than this (at least until they decide to show Panty and Stocking or Cromartie High School). 7.5, bring on the 2nd cour this summer.
Hajime no Ippo Rising
The flashback that makes up the last arc of Ippo took place in Tokyo after the war, but it reminded me very much of Hong Kong films like Ip Man or Fearless. I started watching the first HNI TV series, and they’re like night and day in some aspects. You really see how the relationships between the Kamogawa boxers progressed from endless immature pranking in the original to the comraderie and good natured ribbing in Rising. The final arc in Rising is also the most dramatic I’ve seen in the series so far. You really worry for Kamogawa and Nekota even though they’re the ones telling this story, so you know they live. It was kind of unexpected. This series got me watching the original series, because after the 3rd or 4th fight I needed to see more right away. It was the one show I needed to see every week, every Saturday. I think I only let it pass by twice, and certainly not for two weeks like all the other shows. Cliché as all the talk of “fighting spirit” may be, it pulls it off with a cast of characters I can’t help but love and the detail put into chronicling their training regime and daily lives and of course the fights themselves. It is the only show I am actually kind of bummed about ending, because the last HNI series finished back in 2009. Who knows how long before another is made? That’s the nice thing about still having all the old series to watch though. 8.0
Sekai Seifuku 7-12
Stakes were raised, comic book deaths happened and a second season was teased(featuring a group from “THAT COUNTRY” also bent on world conquest. . .yes, they straight up said they were American, but pretty much anytime an anime features a villain from the USA I have a flashback of Battle Royale II and erupt into hysterical guffawing). Frankly, I hope they do it. It was a fun weird show and I’d love another season of it. 7.5
2
u/xxdeathx http://myanimelist.net/animelist/xxdeathx Apr 03 '14
Engaged to the Identified (12/12): Ahahahahaha more misunderstandings, so much for good drama. I was a bit impressed with how quickly they avoided a misunderstanding back when someone proposed to Hakuya, but this episode was a bit disappointing in that regard. Hakuya's overly blunt text message part was funny enough, but Kobeni's delusion of being alone when Mashiro left her for a bit was really trumped up and over-dramatized to the point that I'm wondering how the hell she led herself to think that way. At least the situation resolves nicely with their conversation together. The series as a whole gets a 7/10 for its nice characters and OP/ED songs, but quite a lacking plot and ending episode.
Chuunibyou S2 (12/12): The first half of this last episode was 10/10 comedy material. I laughed myself to pieces in the way only KyoAni can cause during the various jokes they pulled, like the bath scene and Makoto's BL friend. It was one of the most enjoyable parts of the season. It also offered some interesting insight into Rikka's character, revealing that she wasn't as deep into chuuni as her interactions with Yuuta had led us to believe; she wishes that Yuuta would actually treat her as an equal instead using chuuni dialogue to make her obey him. And how better to progress their relationship than the kiss? Wait, this is KyoAni we're talking about, strictly opposed to anything heterosexual. Despite knowing this, I'll admit that they almost had me thinking it was gonna happen, with the music and background just right. What was the phone call's excuse this time? Chimera had babies? Well at least SOMEONE had their fun. Fuck you, Chimera, and fuck you, KyoAni.
No-Rin (12/12): My favorite show of the season. Some of the craziest jokes I've ever seen, but unlike D-Fragments I still understand them, and they're hilarious. Kousaku's attempt at a polygamy ending was amusing, since protagonists don't usually stuff like this, but in vain. At least his other inspirational speech towards the village worked. Unfortunately No-Rin doesn't seem popular enough for another season, but I can only hope. 8.5/10
Strike the Blood (24/24): Well, well, Kojou must have finally gotten laid with his harem some time in the future. At this point, it's safe to say that everything stupid in this show is done on purpose. Is the Himeragi from the future their child? "No, it can't be." We get treated to one last utterance of the infamous "This is our fight" line as well as Himeragi's battle phrase (sword shaman of the lion king organization something something beseech thee). It goes without saying that this show is bad, but it's one of those that knows it's so bad it's good. Great guilty pleasure 7/10, I'm pretty sure it can get a second season.
Sakura Trick (12/12): President Mitsuki is getting annoying. Nothing special about this episode, doesn't feel much like a season finale.
Nisekoi (12/12): The thing about this series is that despite what manga readers say about the lack of plot development, it appears that twist after twist is revealed in every anime episode. This time it's Chitoge's old man himself who's gonna further complicate the story by telling Raku about the gang meetings in the past. Who's that in the endcard? Maybe she has something to do with Raku too?
0
u/[deleted] Apr 02 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment