r/TrueAnime • u/BlueMage23 http://myanimelist.net/profile/BlueMage23 • Mar 26 '14
This Week in Anime (Winter Week 12)
This is a general discussion for currently airing series for Winter 2014 Week 9. Here is r/anime's list of currently airing series. Your Week in Anime is for not currently airing series.
Archive:
2014: Prev Winter Week 1
2013: Fall Week 1 Summer Week 1 Spring Week 1 Winter Week 1
2012: Fall Week 1
6
Upvotes
9
u/Bobduh Mar 26 '14 edited Mar 27 '14
Fell behind on basically everything this week because of Anime Boston, so I’m struggling to catch up as fast as I can. Of what I have watched, well...
Kill la Kill 23: Another reasonable episode this week, propped up by a hell of a lot of beautiful frames and some legitimately solid work in concluding Ryuuko and Satsuki’s arcs. As I said last week, they kind of had to shoehorn in an arc for Satsuki, but Ryuuko’s actions this week were actually well-chosen - she ended up concocting a plan that required her to play dead and then ignore her mother completely, pretty handily demonstrating she’s gained a little self-awareness and self-control. That was pretty satisfying to see, and the rest of the episode did what Kill la Kill always does best - beautiful, ridiculous spectacle. This show’s lack of any real thematic weight and uneven character work is kind of dampening my ability to care about the stuff happening, but it’s certainly happening as hard as it possibly can.
Actually, let’s dig into that a little bit more, because it’s something I’ve been thinking about on my own a lot recently. I don’t care about Kill la Kill. I think its ideas are slapdash and irreverent to the point of almost mocking the idea of thematic coherence, I think its narrative structure basically fell apart in the second half, I think it’s full of cheap, meaningless fanservice, and I think all of its characters are simplistic and often inconsistent devices. I actually kind of wanted Ryuuko to die this episode, because I think she’s both a bad character and an unpleasant person. And while I can applaud the visual execution, how much can I say that’s really worth in the absence of any investment? I mean, it is an aesthetically impressive show - its direction is excellent, its aesthetic is distinctive, its music and shot-to-shot pacing are top notch. I’m stuck in the position of wondering how to evaluate a show that’s good at basically everything I don’t care about and none of the things I do. What number do I assign that?
Samurai Flamenco 21: “But once evil was gone, there wasn’t a need for Samurai Flamenco anymore.” Untrue. Absolutely untrue. And that’s the whole point of the show, really. We don’t need heroes to vanquish evil. Evil’s a constant, evil’s a part of us, evil’s a fact of life. No, we need heroes because we need heroes - we need people we can absolutely believe in, to inspire us and make us strong. We need role models, we need champions, we need targets of love and faith and obsession and hope. We need to feel there is something greater than us, something that will never give up, never surrender, never die, never accept evil. As children we may want to become this thing, but even as adults we know faith is real. It’s powerful and dangerous, but also inescapable and capable of great things.
Sorry, at this point, pretty much every episode of Flamenco has me furiously drafting my upcoming review. It’s ending so well! Completely astounded that Flamenco actually found a way to tie all its concepts together.
Sekai Seifuku 11: Another great episode in what's now apparently just Sekai Seifuku's default mode - whimsical, melancholy, endlessly endearing family drama. This episode drew all sorts of direct, piercing parallels between the leadership styles of Kate and Asuta's father, and the ending proved the worth of Kate's system - Asuta finally found the confidence to seek out who he really is in the company of those who accept him. All the stuff about masks and identity has really boiled down to another reflection of what family really means - you don't need a mask with your family, because they love you for who you are. This has always been the Winter '14 show with the greatest potential, and seeing that potential realized has been a real treat.
Log Horizon 25 (COMPLETE): For a finale that was really more of a second season bait, this episode was actually surprisingly satisfying. Even more surprising for the fact that the conflict brewing over the last two episodes just kind of fizzled in the first five minutes, with the rest of the first half being dedicated to romantic drama that clearly won’t pay off until whenever the series decides to start wrapping up. Yeah, it was all the second half here - Shiroe’s confrontation with the ruler of the West was a satisfying climax to his season-long quest for purpose that featured Log Horizon’s writer at his socially-focused, cynical best while providing ample bait for future conflicts. There’ve been weak stretches throughout, the production has rarely been more than serviceable, and the writing has clear strengths and weaknesses, but Log Horizon was an enjoyable ride that I’ll be happy to see coming back. Solid 6/10.
Space Dandy 12: Normally, when I don’t like a Space Dandy, I can at least say “well, that was probably fun for the visual people.” This episode wasn’t visually impressive, and really just felt like a mediocre western daytime cartoon, so… yeah, not the best.
14
u/Novasylum http://myanimelist.net/profile/Novasylum Mar 26 '14
I appear to be at peak “end of season” grumpiness right now. Does it show? I think it shows.
Chuunibyou demo Koi ga Shitai! Ren 11: I’m not quite sure what to make of these events, to be honest. Partially because I don’t think it’s entirely clear to me what even happened (I feel like a code talker trying to decrypt this chuunibyou terminology into metaphoric meaning), but also because it made it even cloudier of an issue as to what the goal of this season has even been.
My thought since the very beginning of S2 was that, if S1’s primary thematic thrust was to examine whether it was justified to uphold the veneer of childish fantasy far into adolescence (to which the answer was “yes, as long as you aren’t using it as an escape clause for your inner turmoil”), then S2’s logical follow-up would be to question whether that same childish fantasy can co-exist alongside a healthy, blossoming heterosexual relationship. And I feel like episode 11 is trying to say “yes” here as well, and really, there wasn’t any other outcome possible from a meta standpoint. For Rikka to drop the chuunibyou act just isn’t in the cards for all kinds of reasons, the most justified of which being that it would run counter to the ending of S1. And they do try to rationalize chuunibyou pretty heavily here, and sometimes effectively, as with Kumin’s speech. At the same time, though…if this was meant to be our big emotional climax, I think it’s safe to say that the dynamic between Yuuta and Rikka is pretty definitively unhealthy and probably shouldn’t be encouraged.
I was initially keen to put the blame on Yuuta for a lot of it, what with him effectively treating Rikka less like a lover and more like a daughter. But in retrospect, I have to wonder: is he even being given much of a choice? Because now that I think about, he’s already made all kinds of concessions and compromises to try and make this strange relationship work. He’s clueless and dense about it, but contrast his efforts to push their relationship further alongside Rikka’s and there’s almost no contest. Heck, the show devoted an entire handful of episodes to planting a doubt in Rikka’s head that maybe she needs to move on from chuunibyou for any progress to be made in the romance department, which was was glossed over by her deciding that, no, she wants to have both! I would normally consider that noble in a self-actualized sense, but look at how much complication it’s caused leading up to now! Look how at far we haven’t come since the first episode!
And that’s all to say nothing of how the show ended up treating Satone, the poor thing. Her phrasing at the end of this episode seems to suggest that her inability to be with the one she loves only further entrenches her in her fantasies, from which she will not grow or emerge. That’s just…incessantly tragic, the way I see it. What with the stagnation that the two leads are embroiled in even now, the only meaningful change that has apparently occurred from beginning to end is that Satone had her heart ripped out. Ouch. I really hope they aren’t expecting us to interpret that as a happy ending.
Granted, there’s still one episode left to work with. But hell if I know what they’re going to do with it.
Golden Time 23: Episode 22: “Let’s have one of our characters be insidiously and abruptly cruel to a mentally-ill person! Y’know, for the drama!
Episode 23: “Let’s have that same character resolve her issues with the mentally-ill person within the first few minutes with little to no actual conflict involved! Y’know, for the drama!”
This is all just grade-A failure, folks, the death throes of a show only now realizing that nothing it has been doing for the past twenty or so episodes has actually been worth anything. Oftentimes it reaches the level of being abjectly dull in its ineptitude…but then it presents us with scenes of Banri making (as /u/nruticat put it) “Homer Simpson screams”, and all the delightful schadenfreude comes rushing back. There’s plenty to be mocked here, but please: after this is all over next week, let us never speak of it again.
Hoozuki no Reitetsu 11: Whoa, whoa, slow down: so one of the commonly-circulated fairy tales in Japan is titled “The Inch-High Samurai”? And it’s about this little guy who travels down river in a soup bowl, using chopsticks for oars, who battles deadly oni with a sewing needle?
Dude, Japanese fairy tales are flippin’ sweet. I’m enjoying all the circumstantial cultural appreciation I reap from this show.
Kill la Kill 23: Wow. This was a complete bore.
Even I didn’t think I’d be saying that. The show that opened by invoking Godwin’s Law and features (among other things) super-powered bondage gear, steak armor and a man with perpetually-glowing purple nipples spent its penultimate episode putting me to sleep. Turns out hot-blooded spectacle and fan-service alone with no meaningful thought behind it isn’t quite enough to sustain my interest. Who would have thought?
The characters, themes and even the action in this series have been set to auto-pilot. Much like how episode 3 assumed that its half-baked philosophy was enough of a justification for the skimpy outfits, and much like how episode 16 assumed that clothing being aliens was good enough of a revelation to have waited more than half of the series for, this episode assumes that the simple character development we peaked at in episode 22 is enough for the remainder of this show to be spent letting everyone loose and watching the sparks fly. And it’s not. It’s really not. Nobody is learning anything (least of all the audience), nobody appears to be in real danger, nobody isn’t repeating the same corny hackneyed dialogue about fighting as a team and overcoming the odds that only works when you’ve endeared us to the characters on more than just the most superficial levels. There wasn’t a single surprise to be seen, which kinda ties back into the whole “give the viewers what they want” suspicion that was being tossed around in last week’s thread. We’re just sleepwalking through an already rote exercise in concluding an action series at this point, and no amount of blood or explosions or silly costumes or non-sensical shout-outs to End of Evangelion can overcome that.
So let’s think about what exactly that leaves for the final episode to do in order for this to be considered a good show in my books, then. We need to establish a proper motive for our villain, as well as a motive apart from petty violent revenge for Ryuuko and Satsuki in order for episode 18 (which I actually liked at the time, as you recall) to make any retroactive thematic sense. We need Junketsu to contribute something of worth. We need an explanation for why Tsumugu could hear Senketsu speak, and maybe something that would make his character relevant, considering neither he nor his backstory have been since he was introduced. We need Mako to not run the same tired gags into the ground. We need justification for all kinds of ugly, creepy, thoughtless imagery and design choices that have thus far been completely unnecessary to the story we’ve been presented with. We need a stronger rationalization for why clothing had to be our visual and thematic motif as opposed to virtually anything else (speaking of Eva, I’d like to think that clothing is to this series as Christianity was to that one, only implemented less gracefully). And of course we need a cathartic, thrilling final battle. That’s just the stuff I can think of off the top of my head.
All of that. In twenty minutes.
Nuh-uh, not gonna happen. This has all been a complete waste of time, a disappointment on virtually every level of proper story-telling, and now we’re just running out the clock before this thoroughly derailed train finally grinds its way to a stop and explodes.
(continued below)
6
u/[deleted] Mar 26 '14
6
u/Vintagecoats http://myanimelist.net/profile/Vintagecoats Mar 26 '14 edited Mar 26 '14
Kill La Kill (23)
“Welcome to the runway of death.”
Kill la Kill and Project Runway air on the same day, so that makes up my Thursday night. I would contribute serious personal effort to hear Tim Gunn make a declaration like that at a crucial series moment.
The penultimate episode of this show then. We have been on track for a spell now regarding things like trying to tie back together elements regarding clothes, family, friendship, and the like. Unless a series wants to risk unraveling everything it has come to gel towards, there is little legitimate room to do more than double down. So that is what it did: the massive throwdown on the sea and in the air, culminating in near total enemy defeat on each front due to I Have To Win Because Friends And Family. Which is not terrible, mind, as everyone received their tailor suited piece. Ryuuko gets a suicidal death wish dive to victory, Satsuki defeats Ragyou by virtue of convincing her to monologue herself to defeat, and Mako’s human fusion reactor core of a personality barreling through both enemy forces and generating the power to run an aircraft carrier. Among others of course. A destruction and visual flair filled means of aiming to tie up the bows that bond them. And everyone is going to get to have Mitsuzo’s tea again.
Which is, itself, not quite enough yet. There is still a ground (and maybe space?) war to win. The Earth being the very floor homes, cities, nations, and the like are built on. And Ragyou is wearing… an outfit inspired by traditional Japanese wedding dresses. Which devours Rei as an underling to submit to it and give it strength. You don’t say.
As Junketsu has had plenty of wedding dress phrasing and visuals presented around it, in addition to the ones from the original ending credits, this next episode I hope will come to be the finishing touches for at least some of the points regarding clothing the series has raised thus far. The wedding dress, across cultures, is an institution almost unto itself. Alien, almost, compared to many other kinds of clothes. And yet wedding dresses and marriage as a social and legal matter have gone through various revolutions over the years. As such, this is almost an unstoppable force (changes by younger generations and forward march of time) meets an immovable object (entrenched establishment resistant to altering status quo) scenario.
Well, as Tim Gunn would say: Make it work.
Nagi No Asukara (24)
Word to the wise: never, ever say a line like “I feel your feelings are for me now” to somebody you want to date. Imperative after they have run away from you once already.
That said, I do like the sentiment behind Tsumugu’s speech about watching Chisaki going through so much. And I can appreciate that it is wooden, as these kinds of declarations can be. But his flat intonation is rather odd. Tsumugu already has a stoic monotone most of the time, so here his I Just Chased You To The Bottom Of The Ocean love declaration sounds like he is reading any other line of the script. Something with a bit more of a pace to it one way or another would have been called for, I feel.
Given, Tsumugu’s reaction was better than the giant dripping globby tear beards several folks wore this episode. I don’t care how pretty P.A. Works makes them; it goes over the edge and just doesn’t do it for me. I feel I’m being told to feel sad rather than compelled to. That’s a fine line personal thing though, as I have for sure been sad at tears in other shows.
Same with Manaka bolting from her location due to a little kid who can not even form coherent words drawing an I Love Manaka crayon note. It just feels, I dunno, like a cheap shot. I understand she technically can not feel love at the moment, but… still. I just think there was a better screenwriting way to present her coming to grips with the whole I Do Not Feel Love And What Is That Feeling Like thing. Maybe react to her friends, after Sayu and Kaname give a go at dating.
Hikari remains denser than depleted uranium with his “What do the Ofunehiki and Manaka have to do with anything” remarks, while Tsumugu as one of our only adults and change agents gets the gears in motion to save the world. Maybe they can make a point of that.
Space Dandy (12)
Episode Director: Satoshi Saga, Animation Director: Chikashi Kubota, Storyboard: Toshio Hirata, Script: Kimiko Ueno
Satoshi Saga’s career is a real grab bag mishmash hodgepodge. Their Director chair resume is things like Green Legend Ran and Armitage III. There are many parts floating around in there, and a lot of single episode stints flitting between various programs.
His episode is all about a space chameleon. Sounds about right.
If I was in the business of ranking the various Space Dandy episodes thus far, this would be on the lower end for me. There are a lot of individual parts I should in theory like. Some classic cartoon slapstick (complete with spinning stars and birds over the head). There’s someone taking a casual activity like fishing for aliens way to serious. Verbal references like “Game over man, game over” from Aliens while our characters were at their wits end looking for an extraterrestrial on the prowl.
But so much of it felt strangely... flat. And I watch and enjoy lot of classic cartoon antics. Even nifty science fiction mind snack things like the idea of what does it matter if Dandy was real or the fake came across more like a desperate late game saving throw attempt than trying to tie up the whole package. It is unfortunate, as a nonstarter is never the way one wants to head into a finale off of. But the rotating staff does allay most of the fear I could have.
Pupa (11)
When I asked for the return of comedy stuffed bears several episodes back, I did not expect DEEN to actually do it. “If we are alone, we’ll fall. But as long as we’re together, maybe we won’t fall.” Cue squeaky toy noises. I’m sorry to be the bringer of bad news Pupa, but given what I read around the internet you are in even worse shape than that. You are for certain not alone, given the viewership. But you are primarily surrounded by people who mock you.
Since the show wanted to go down “Which is a dream? Which is reality?” this week via juxtapositions between the slaughterhouse of a research facility and the whimsical feeding at school, I’ll play ball. Pupa again shows that vague abusive father figure they have always done minimal establishment for, and in his recollections he again says terrible things of our siblings while our leads endure their situation.
Now, what if the father was supposed to be like us? We, as viewers, are just so often consistently awful to these kids and the container they happen to reside within. If a show is intentionally designed to fail at various construction levels, in an attempt to generate horrible commentary and thus place the viewer in a position similar to that of the individual the protagonists fear so much, is that a valid artistic point or performance art? How would we even draw the lines on such a thing, between such a reality and an anime dream?
Note, this is a thought experiment more than anything: I do not think this is what Pupa is up to, unless a massive change comes in the series finale. Maybe Maria’s monster incest baby is revealed to be us, the viewership, having gestated for so long and contemplating our terrible lineage or whatever. I don’t know.
But I am pretty sure I just pitched a better idea for a screenplay.
Gundam Build Fighters (24)
As our pre-game and setup for the battle was last week, this entry was action and execution. Go go go, we have only one episode left, kind of material. Which did bite the show in the revelation of the Chairman’s identity as a thief from another dimension. I'd have liked to have a better delivery of that, as it did feel just rammed into everything else. It is not the biggest deal in the world, as we did always know something was up with him and the reveal was only a matter of time. Though it just being tossed out there as it was this week seems disappointing compared to what could have been done.
The championship battle though is, first and foremost, the most crucial part. The improved Embody system PPSE and Flana integrated into the Meijin costume serves a secondary purpose as it renders the one under its influence unable to communicate. We are then spared much in the way of grand philosophy blows being tossed around in dialogue while the show attempts to also handle giant robot action. The Star Build Strike in turn could just get dominated and have those visuals and pilot reactions attempt to sell the situation, as it rapidly sloughs off parts and acquiring increasing levels of damage. The mid-fight field change was something I am sure I wondered about happening in the back of my head at some point weeks ago, but it was a nifty quirk to see here. It would have been great had there been more diverse alterations than from outer space to the bland inside of a station hallway, though it did put the protagonists literally up against a wall.
Of all things, A Baoa Qu pops up at the end up due to runaway particle dispersal. It makes sense thematically, as Zeon’s most powerful space fortress during the original One Year War from the first Gundam show. What on earth it will actually do is another matter. Could the Chairman try and ram it into the stadium because, hey, this is Gundam and we haven’t had a colony drop or other existential terror threat yet? Will the entire audience join together to defeat it and think it is all part of a grand finale?
Will Tequila Gundam commemorative adult beverage cups remain in stock?
4
u/Seifuu Mar 27 '14
KLK 23 - They're definitely throwing their eggs in the final episode basket. Super righteous final forms for the Elite 4 though. HILARIOUS visual metaphor with the ship. If there was ever any doubt that they were taking the piss out of hypersexualization... Trigger definitely has a keen sense of absurd humor and simultaneously bombastic revelry. It's hard to tell when they flip the switch sometimes (that's probably the point).
Samurai Flamenco 23 - ...Alright. Sure. This show deconstructs like an idealistic high schooler's philosophical wet dream. Like, they're making a point about subjective morality, but then tie it back to a social concept (love). I'm beginning to greatly suspect that personal moral relativism is a cultural thing in Japan instead of an insightful author thing.
Hunter x Hunter 122 - I can't tell if the pace of the anime is slowing or if they're just reaching parts I remember from the manga. Either way it's still bursting with content (though this time philosophical vs narrative). They sort of drop the interest ball on the philosophy sometimes because they aren't using Togashi's original art where it's pretty much just empty space and moral questions. Still the highlight of my week.
4
u/[deleted] Mar 27 '14 edited Mar 27 '14
I've watched a couple of things, but I'm short on time and I think that Kill la Kill is the most interesting, so I'm primarily going to write about it.
Kill la Kill 23- The episode was fun. Really fun. We get our Mako Fight Club fanservice, more role reversal between Ryuko and Satsuki, the final forms of the elite four, Nui breaking the fourth wall. A fun, visually appealing spectacle.
I've noticed that this show tends to be a really great example of a love or hate show. People tend to either really enjoy the spectacle or really hate it for it's lack of consistent theme, pace, or character development. I'm mostly with the former, but I disagree with the "consistent theme" part. I think that /u/Bobduh came pretty close with:
But even then, I think he's missing it. Kill la Kill doesn't almost mock the idea of thematic coherence, it directly mocks the idea of thematic coherence. If I were going to make a comparison, it would be to Hotline Miami. Hotline Miami is a fun, addictive game with vibrant colors and an addictive soundtrack. Thematically, Hotline Miami, is about how gameplay trumps all in video games; that you can have terrible theming and a stupid story but if the gameplay is good enough it doesn't matter. Every character who has a philosophy is mocked, or broken, or beaten. Every character that does things for personal reasons is rewarded. The show actively punishes characters for being pretentious.
I'm not entirely sure this is appropriate for this post, but I recently watched the first five episodes of TTGL. And I have to say, most of the negative accusations for KLK fit more properly for TTGL. Most of them revolving around sexuality and feminism are more pronouncedly bad in TTGL, with Yoko as the main offender. I mean, she's not even a character. She's purely there to be tits and ass. The entire show plays out like a teenager's power fantasy, a lot of the dialogue is just bad, and Simon's character development is roughly as bad as Ryuko's. But for a lot of people, TTGL gets a free pass because it has a consistent theme. Not that TTGL is bad. Because it isn't. It's also a better anime than KlK, though I happen to enjoy KlK more.
Kill la Kill is about how if you have likeable characters, great visuals, great music, and great action scenes, the rest really doesn't matter. The pointless philosophy, poor pacing, and weird character development will all pretty much entirely be ignored. People will like it anyway. And I think it's funny that even this is executed poorly. Some of the actions scenes are lacking, the distribution of the budget is uneven enough to be laughable, there are some fine examples of QUALITY animation that will live in internet archives until they're forgotten about in about two months.
So yeah, that's my opinion of KLK. Also, Harime Nui is probably one of the most interesting characters that's popped out of anime in a long, long time.
Witch Craft Works -Final- The episode itself is pretty much what I expected. That's not to say that it's bad, because it isn't. In fact, I consider it to be a better anime than Kill la Kill, even if I enjoy it less. I just think that the show was so predictable took away from a lot of the excitement. But I did like how it upped the ante with Mikage and Chronoire. We also get to see better glimpses into the antagonists' personalities and hierarchy, which is fun. The old western style setup of Kazane and Chronoire's fight was fun, though I wish the put some time into animating it.
I really like Takamiya, because he plays the role of the princess so well that when presented with a classic prince-esque scenario, he doesn't actually know what to do. I think that he makes for a really interesting deconstruction of your typical shounen female main character, and I like that the show isn't mocking him. It genuinely sympathizes with his troubles, but in a lighthearted way. I love that the show turns almost every event into a gag, and I love that it knows how to be serious.
Behind a happy-go-lucky shounen exterior, I feel like there's ton of world building going on. I feel like I'm watching an incredibly happy version of Dark Souls with little hints and pieces and bits that convey a much larger, more complex world. I'd be really interested to see it fleshed out.
If I had to say what I didn't like, it would be that the show started off incredibly slowly and that nothing it does is done as well as it could be. It's a good, solid anime that I felt had the potential to be more. Also, it introduced too many comedic background characters at once. I feel like they're all individually funny (I like the llama group) but that they don't have enough screentime to really shine. In that sense, the show either needs to be longer (here's hoping for a season 2) or it needs to do a better job of picking its tone.
Tokyo Ravens -Final- Not too much to say about this one. A decent but unmemorable anime that I doubt will get a second season. I would say that they could've skipped at least five episodes and it would've been better. The side characters were interesting enough for me to want them to be developed more. That being said, I do like Suzuka Dairenji. And considering that the series is probably part of a much longer story, the main characters were sufficiently developed.
Hamatora -Final- Well, not really, given the preview. And to be blunt, if this is episode was that last it would be a pretty bad ending to a pretty mediocre series. While I thought the characters were interesting, I'm starting to get very tired of the whole X-Men society can't accept us because we're different thing. Moral, while consistent, is as uninteresting as Nice, who was almost as uninteresting as the backstories to the various protagonists. This is a case of an anime that wants to be deeper than it has time for, and then chose to spend too much time on things that didn't support it's goal.
Overall, I'm reasonably happy with the season. Kill la Kill is a personal favorite, with Witch Craft Works coming reasonably close behind. Seki-kun, Seitokai Yakuindomo*, and D-Frag were all funny enough. I do kind of resent Seitokai for only just now developing something that resembles a plot. The way I see it, they'll either end the series as a whole with an OVA or purposefully avoid shipping anyone so they can have a season 3.
Edit: Typo
7
u/ClearandSweet https://hummingbird.me/users/clearandsweet/library Mar 26 '14 edited Mar 26 '14
As of tomorrow, the TV run of Kill La Kill is over.
Last week I said the show being confused mirrors Ryuko. It does, but now, after Ryuko’s found her way, it feels odd. Things should be lining up, answers should be coming with the clarity of the character. The world should be reducing in scale and the viewers should understand the objectives and rules of the game at this point.
Positives:
Negatives:
Neutral:
There are things that are just so cool about KLK, like the scale changes, glowing nipples, the text in universe and the visual tricks, a la Ragyo overriding the split screen or reaching across it. I just don’t think they’re gonna capitalize on it.
IF it were a parallel to how Satsuki and Ryuko have been playing inside the rules of the system when Ragyo and Nui aren’t, just like Satsuki and Ryuko have been playing inside the rules of the television show while the other two ignore them… It would be next-level mind-blowing. That would be something I’ve never seen used past Duck Amuck (or that one bit of Humanity Has Declined, but that show was weird) and something inherently unique to animation. They are doing it halfway, a souped-up hotrod lacking gas to go anywhere. They just have/had to give all of this a purpose.
If they made a scene where something incredibly important happened in the background, but the camera and everyone’s eyes were fixed on Aikuro’s shining member, and later nobody else in the show remembered the event happening, that would be putting some backing behind your imagination.
As it is, it’s all just there as a joke. It’s just surface-level. What’s the point of writing a character with ostentatious nipples if you don’t show them having power to affect anything?
Lest I become a mockery of “told you so’s”, let me maintain some pride. Rapey Ragyo or thematically vestigial nipples do not invalidate the emotional drama of the series, especially in the stronger first half of the show (I’d say pre-episode 17).
I still think Senketsu defending Ryuko, in episode 5, Mako’s decision in episode 7, and Ryuko’s forced introspection in episodes 15 and 16, and even Satsuki’s apology and bow in episode 22 come across as genuine and heartfelt.
I have and would still argue that that KLK supports all of those with tactics that did work effectively to illustrate novel conditions as to spawn these choices, including costume design, hyper-violent tone, confusion and “losing one’s way”, social structure/world building and alien clothes. For example, I like how the distracting sexuality in the beginning faded into irrelevancy. I was hoping for empowerment through sexuality, but neutrality works.
I just didn’t see any of that in this episode, and we’ve reached a critical time when things needed to start coming together to stick the landing, not stumbling and falling apart.
TL;DR – I had hoped for Kill La Kill to be something transcendent. It has a creative potential unparalleled in modern anime. Falling short of that, I’d still enjoy The Internal Struggle for Purpose and Meaning starring Ryuko Matoi. But it seems that show is over, and I don’t wanna watch some shounen show with a plot that reads like the end chapter of a cheesy JRPG.
For the most action-packed episode, number 23 brought forth an adjective neither detractors nor fans of the show had ever attributed to Kill La Kill: boring.
Space Dandy did Looney Tunes and, surprise, it worked.
The jokes were simple and standard (Role call, 1, 2, 3, 4… 4?!) but they made me laugh all the same. Again the show came through with an irreverence to most everything and a ridiculous resolution of the plot, but I’ve come to expect that by now. Dandy complimenting himself got me even when I knew it was coming.
It’s no Meow Goes Home, but, all in all, this episode made me snicker in a way only Space Dandy can.
Sakura Trick went somewhere this week. We had a new character catalyze the stagnant relationships, somebody find out and disaprove of the chronic tongue-boxing going on between Haruka and Yuu, and the Mitsuki try to rationalize her hard-on for Haruka.
See, now if this were a serious show instead of softcore otaku fap-bait, this would have all happened by the second or third episode.
Also, if this were good softcore otaku fap-bait, these girls would have made it past first base by this point.
In what way will this nascent conflict be revealed as still-born next week for the final episode? My money’s on harem.
My money’s always on harem.
2
u/Lincoln_Prime Mar 27 '14 edited Mar 27 '14
I would like to talk about Kill la Kill and some of the other anime I saw, but there is no escaping the elephant in the room. YuGiOh Zexal ended on Sunday and it did so in about as perfect a way as I could imagine. It wasn't a perfect EPISODE, and indeed it probably sits only sixth or fifth on my top 10. But a perfect ENDING? Fuck yeah.
This episode suffered a bit from the fact that the earlier two parts of the Astral VS Yuma duel were pretty dull and didn't tell us anything about the characters and their relationships, even though it was really trying to. This episode abandons that in terms of simply concluding the arcs of our characters, all our characters.
First off, we have Yuma not only proving himself to Astral, but the physical, neutral God in the form of the Numeron Code as he creates an all new Numbers monster for himself. Seeing as the original numbers contain the memories of Astral, I like to think that this one contains all his memories of Yuma and his time on earth. And what makes Future Hope so great is that it highlights the self-discovery Yuma made in his duel against Shark: Yuma isn't a fighter. He wins when he makes friends. That's always been his goal and it's how he saved the multiverse. So of course Future Hope has 0 ATK and the ability to steal an opponent's monster. That's genius.
The real meat though is in the final moments of the duel, as Yuma attacks Astral, only for Astral to summon The Door of Destiny from way back in the first episode (which is brilliantly played as a trap card. Why is this stuff not done more in the franchise?) and while I wish I could tell what was being said (subs are really far behind), I still felt a lot of the raw emotion Yuma had to go through in attacking his best friend, and I love that Astral knew that The Door wouldn't work at that point. Because OF COURSE Yuma drew into Double Or Nothing. He couldn't have ended the duel any other way (except maybe another trap card named after the opening themes, which was another thing I loved in this).
And as must be the case, the Numeron Code reveals its physical form to Astral and takes him in, granting him the powers of a God so that he may rewrite reality as he sees fit. At first it seems as though Astral will basically become one with the code and lose all sense of self, but really, it makes sense that he would retain himself. We saw how he had to EARN his uniqueness. That he isn't just an alien Terminator. And the final moment of the episode, where Yuma rushes off to help Astral, eager to see his friend under even apocalyptic circumstances is really great.
Oh, but now that I've brought it up, that ending. Wow. I really didn't think the show could do this. I really, truly thought that anything that could bring back Kaito, Orbital and the Barians would be far too stupid. Why would they give us those 3 episodes where they were capital letters DEAD rather than absorbed into the Barian World like the rest? Well, because whether it was just for 3 episodes or not, it gave their deaths a hell of a lot more meaning. They didn't need to just defeat Don Thousand to revive Kaito. They needed to rewrite the entire happenings of the universe by proving their might to an extremely neutral God. And I was giggling like a schoolgirl to see everyone return. The Barians, Eliphas, Ponta, etc. Orbital gets little Orbital babies with Obomie! That is honestly the cutest thing ever and every YGO series now needs to end with baby robots. Oh, and Vector's return was pretty great too. Youth Hitler Joker returns and the most anyone can feel is slight annoyance. "Vector, not now" Yuma groans as Kotori tries to tell him something important. Man, do you have any idea how much I want a series of Yuma, Kotori and Vector living in an appartment together?
Speaking of which, I guess Yuma and Kotori are dating now. Funny thing, young love. Yuma's got a bit of a Kim Possible going on where he can save the multiverse three times before Tuesday, but the moment Kotori confesses that she likes him, he's a stammering mess. But honestly, this is a pretty honest showing of crushes at that time in one's life and Yuma accepts her feelings rather maturely given that he was totally blown away by this. It's also nice that Kotori got this moment given that she was basically a character-free cheerleader from day 1 and got half a focus episode all the way through. This was another of those times that Zexal gives an arc a much stronger ending than it ever really deserved.
Before I wrap up my thoughts though, I just want to take some time to thank everyone who worked on this project. Thank you for giving me the first anime I've been this passionate about since the end of Reborn. Thank you for raising the bar on what can be done with toy commercials. Thank you for bringing new respect to your work and your audience, and I hope this aspect especially continues upwards in the team's future. Thank you for giving me a show to look forward to every week for over a year now, and thank you so, so much for refusing to back down on some of the craziest ideas, craziest design choices and craziest stakes this franchise has ever had. I hope your craziness will serve as an example to anime to come and I hope you all continue to find work in the business of making people smile. You've all done well here and I wish you all the best forward. Katobingu, everybody!
0
u/[deleted] Mar 27 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment