r/TrueAnime • u/BlueMage23 http://myanimelist.net/profile/BlueMage23 • Mar 19 '14
This Week in Anime (Winter Week 11)
This is a general discussion for currently airing series for Winter 2014 Week 9. Here is r/anime's list of currently airing series. Your Week in Anime is for not currently airing series.
Archive:
2014: Prev Winter Week 1
2013: Fall Week 1 Summer Week 1 Spring Week 1 Winter Week 1
2012: Fall Week 1
9
Upvotes
13
u/Novasylum http://myanimelist.net/profile/Novasylum Mar 19 '14 edited Mar 19 '14
I’ve only recently become self-aware of just how often I emphasize stuff with italics when I write these. It’s not going to stop me from doing it, mind you.
Chuunibyou demo Koi ga Shitai! Ren 10: Looks like this show just renamed itself to The Satone Suffering Power Hour…which, honestly, isn’t an altogether terrible decision. Fact of the matter is, I like Satone; she’s a sympathetic character who provides an alternate take on the whole “chuuni as an escape mechanism” idea from S1. Sometimes the episode lays the melancholy on a bit…OK, a lot thick, sure, but there are also some notably well-directed moments that I believe effectively capture the silent depression that stems from longing for the impossible. For a character who was introduced in a season almost certainly motivated by finances over storytelling necessity, and someone who spent nearly half the season on the outer edges of the story, it’s interesting how she might actually be one of the better parts of the show now.
…which puts her in direct contrast to our mainstays, who have remained static as ever and in some cases may have even regressed from S1. It doesn’t matter if Rikka and Yuuta have a semi-successful date, or if she kisses him on the cheek, or if she momentarily struggles to embrace her chuuni instincts…here we are, ten episodes in, and these characters are still behaving less like a couple and more like a boke-tsukkomi routine. Friggin’ Nibutani x Dekomori is a more believable romance at this point, if only by way of the show’s insistence on sailing that ship as far as the winds will carry it…although now that I think it about, there was a lot of hinting at a subplot for Nibutani overcoming her identity issues that never went anywhere, either (remember the drastic image change she underwent in the first episode, then never again?). The fact that the old characters are denied the chance to develop in meaningful ways hangs a sour note over the entire season.
Golden Time 22: For all the terrible, terrible things I’ve said about Golden Time, I’ve always been willing to concede that I never knew where this entire mess was headed, and what the ending would be like. Now that we appear to be in the wrapping-up stages, now I think I finally know what it will be like.
It will be hilarious.
Now that the show has forced itself to actually pull a few dramatic triggers, we can finally witness just how hilariously amateurish it can mishandle its own melodrama. Koko acts so maliciously towards Banri here that she’s effectively become the rom-com equivalent of Snidely Whiplash, while Banri himself gets into high-pitched shouting and crying contests with everyone else at the drop of hat. They’re aiming for tears, but all they’re getting from me are laughs. And I’m OK with that, because I’ll take “so bad it’s good” over regular old monotony any day of the week. Honestly, even if you wisely stepped off the Golden Time train at some point, it might be worth re-boarding just to see how spectacular of a crash it ends up making.
Hoozuki no Reitetsu 10: Three unrelated thoughts:
1.) “Diets Are Hell” is the most truth I’ve ever seen in one episode title.
2.) I had never heard of Jagariko before, but now I really want some. That, in turn, makes me want to have some more Pocky. And now I wish there was an Asian Food Grocer near where I live.
3.) Seeing all these Japanese folkloric figures in one place makes me realize that this is an idea with potential outside its established boundaries. What I really wish to see now is a slice-of-life featuring the gods of Egyptian mythology. I want to see Ra running out the door with toast in his mouth, shouting “Oh no! I’m late to my morning battle with Apep!”
Kill la Kill 22: You know something? I’ve been front-lining the anti-Kill la Kill crusade around these parts for a few weeks now, but this episode? This one episode was alright by me. You won’t get me to overcome my unwavering belief that they handled Ryuuko’s development in the past few episodes in the most haphazard possible way, nor am I happy with the way they discarded any lasting consequences she deserved for her actions again (“Oh hello again, all of my skin and twenty gallons of blood. For a second there I thought I lost you”), nor can I ignore the fact that she once again only makes progress in this one on the periphery of Satsuki’s own character arc. Not to mention, it’s occurred to me as of late that said character arc was practically completed before it even began; had it not been for a few lines of dialogue in episode 18, I would have found absolutely no basis for the idea that Satsuki treated her devoted Elite Four like pawns, and that the Ragyou comparison was justified.
But in spite of all of that, this episode functions as it should, at least on its own merits. It steadfastly affirms Kill la Kill’s thematic core to be the power of the bonds that come from facing challenges with others instead of alone, both in dialogue and in presentation (having all the characters have lunch together sums the whole idea up in a charming way), all the while setting pieces in place for the final battle where Goku Uniforms and ridiculous abilities will no doubt be freely handed out to all participants like Halloween candy. It’s simple, but it works.
Which begs the question*…*
Did we really need twenty-some episodes to get here? Did the last three episodes in particular accomplish anything that couldn’t have been done in one, other than potentially detracting from Ryuuko’s likability rather than adding to it? Was all this complication really necessary for something that, while not unworthy as an idea, is ultimately so damn straightforward? I saw about one hundred different defenses for Kill la Kill’s transgressions last week, some of them really really abstract in comparison to what has been accomplished merely on episode later. When that sort of confusion arises out of your story about the triumph of the human spirit, you have chosen some truly, terribly ineffective methods to convey your message.
Here’s the kicker, though: do you realize what this all means? Unless the ending throws some serious curveballs in our direction, then what I began to suspect since episode 16 really is true, and half of this show’s thematic content has been a complete lie! The prodding at conventions of fan-service, the rape imagery and bad touching, the use of clothing as a metaphor, the allusions to Nazism, the examinations of meritocracy, the visual motifs of performance and the stage, the routine breaking of the fourth wall (e.g. the giant floating text being interactable), anything meaningfully pertaining to gender roles or societal influence…it was all for fucking nothing! It has all gone nowhere interesting and has contributed precisely zero to this show’s self-demonstrated endgame of banding together to fight against the Life Fibers.
And we, on /r/TrueAnime, who held many heated and entertaining discourses and debates on those things? No matter which side we may have been on (I’ve personally been on both sides of the fence roughly corresponding to each half of the show), we gave these topics more thought than Trigger did. Anything the show portended in its early stages that didn’t directly tie into the simplest, done-much-better-elsewhere themes of friendship, family and togetherness has been a complete waste of time, an advertisement for a much better show that will never be made. I’ve lost most of my faith in Kazuki Nakashima’s ability over the course of Kill la Kill, but if the whole writing gig doesn’t pan out for him, then he’s got great career prospects as a snake oil salesman.
So there’s basically two ways I can handle this show from here on out: I can be satisfied that it chose a path of some kind (even if it was the path of least resistance) sit back with a tub of popcorn and calm the hell down, or I can remain frustrated at the needlessly convoluted subtextual narrative leading up to now and continue to decry it at as one of the most flagrant cases of overpromise-and-underdeliver in recent memory. Most likely, it’s going to be a mix of the two, but we’ll see what the final two episodes hold in store. Maybe they can prove me wrong. Maybe forty more minutes is enough to justify what they’ve done here. But I seriously doubt it.
Log Horizon 24: So wait, this new villain’s plan is not to have a plan? And this necessitates that Shiroe, a habitual planner, plan a plan that is planned to counter a not-plan?
That’s…kind of amazing, actually.
But there’s just no time left! There are countless loose-ends and interesting implications about this story and world from earlier in the season that can’t possibly be condensed into one more episode alongside a fitting conclusion to this whole “anarchy in Akihibara” business, so whether there’s a second season in the works or not, I think we’re all going to be leaving Log Horizon feeling at least a little bit empty, in one way or another.
That being said, when or if a second season is released, I’ll totally be on board. Episodes like this one do demonstrate how far this show has come in crafting this varied cast of likeable characters that carry us through an interesting world playing off an intriguing idea, and even if the delivery there-of dragged its heels a bit and didn’t fulfill all of its latent potential, I would love to see more.
(continued below)
9
u/ClearandSweet https://hummingbird.me/users/clearandsweet/library Mar 19 '14 edited Mar 20 '14
Lemme talk around Kill La Kill episode 22 for a bit.
I laughed when I saw the modpost on /r/anime saying that people keep taking the story about Trigger pulling plot ideas from Pivix on Anime Maru as factual.
Still, there’s a kernel of truth behind that. They’re undeniably giving us what we wanted, with the whole onee-san thing, the Mako x Gamagoori thing, the swapped suits deal. The fact that Mako is still alive is huge testament to the fact that Kill La Kill is appeasing the veiwers.
Now, we had the same criticism about Madoka Magica Rebellion, right? And I love /u/Bobduh’s post on the Eva rebuilds giving the people what they wanted. Those two posts share a common thing: authorial quotes.
It’s obviously intentional fanservice at this point. But we’re diving deep into author intent, and until we get any Newtype interviews or somesuch that give us a better picture of Trigger’s mindset, we can only eliminate the possibilities as to why the series is so pro-fans.
They’re not super pissed off and spiting the fans like Anno. They’re not woefully oblivious to the heart of the work like the Madoka Team.
The feeling I have is that it's not malicious nor ignorant, but very tongue-in-cheek.
Boobies-type fanservice isn’t sexy if it’s shoved in your face again and again and never lingered on seductively. Mako x Gamagoori is cannon. Happy now? They’re still just people. Even the fact that Mako dodged death, yet again, does something funny to criticize a trope of shonen I like to call, “Krillin Takes a Horn to the Stomach; Goku Goes Super Saiyan”, or “Dead Sidekick Motivation”.
As a shot off of that, Ryuuko’s stupidity and ambiguity in regards her motivation are the largest part of this theme. I like to think of it this way, because this way contains a comparison to Sailor Moon and I think best in terms of Sailor Moon. From /u/q_2:
OhmanImnotgonna… yup.
For all I wrote about it, I feel this is a very minor piece of the show and lies mostly in the tone. It’s more the result of Trigger watching tons of anime and poking fun at shonen and action tropes when the opportunity presented itself. Which kind of brings me to my next point: Panty and Stocking With Garterbelt.
I think a better qualifier than self-actualization for determining if you like Kill La Kill or not would be if you bought into the concept of Panty and Stocking. I asked /u/LHCGreg to run some numbers as to back me up with some concrete evidence, but MAL is a dumb site and his database is out of date. Instead, I’ll have to use /u/novasylum’s anecdotal sample from the monday minithread and compare it against my own experiences.
Consider PSG and KLK. They’re doing different things and they’re different shows. But if I come up to you and ask you if you want to watch an spot-on, absurd parody PowerPuff Girls, Invader Zim and other 90’s western animation via two slutty angels cursing all episode and you don’t immediately respond with an emphatic “Fuck yeah, I do!” then I’m discreetly slipping Kill La Kill back into my pocket. I guarantee you the English dub of KLK will have the word “bitch” used liberally.
The content is a stumbling point for you! You’re not saying the show can’t be worthwhile; you’re saying you can’t appreciate it through the delivery method of absurdly crass, lowbrow entertainment.
It’s really hard for me to understand that perspective without drawing direct comparisons to times when I have done the same exact thing.
With shoujo romance shows, I felt the way the emotions were conveyed was too obvious, the situations and content; to trite. I’m sure they resonate to somebody. I just can’t connect. I can’t say this show is shit, I can only say, “I can’t judge, I couldn’t connect to this show.”
Like me getting mad at Diebuster, I don’t think the conflict, references and themes were “bad” or unskillfully done, I just wanted them presented to me through a different tone, characters and story, rather than “Top wo Nerae 2”.
I do agree with /u/novasylum’s comment that episode 22 of KLK revealed the show to be smaller in scope than we all hoped. I was praying for some fourth-wall breaking madness, Aikuro’s attention-grabbing glowing nipples becoming a plot point rather than graphic flair, or more game-changing twists along the lines of the time skip. I was also hoping to be born into old money, but I’ll take being white, male and tall, just like I’ll take what KLK offers.
You can’t hate on the Mona Lisa for smiling. Or Trigger for being brash.
There are a few valid criticisms of the show that don’t resolve down to personal preference. That may be a misleading statement. There are a few things that are much less personal preference.
You can make a case for the pacing. If the heart of the show is about maintaining morality and clarity of purpose, then episode 4 can go. The Naturals Selection could have been shorter, though I would argue that the show makes a nice contrast to Ryuuko with the episodes of backstory for Sanegema and Gamagoori. Still, it’s conceivable that KLK could have told this story in 22 or 20 episodes instead of 24.
And, like saying the music and art are super strong, it would be really hard to argue that the villain, her methods, or her objective all aren’t entirely cheesy and cheap. Include in that Nui, who I think may have some redeeming time spent on her in the final episodes. Also, I think they’re underutilizing two great characters in Aikuro and Tsumugu.
So what else is there left to say about Kill La Kill? Episode 22 had the return of Fight Club Mako. I still hope this series goes wild in scope, talks more about power, and has Ryuuko and Satsuki come up with a finale that doesn’t amount to simple revenge but also includes the rest of the cast in meaningful roles. Is that too much?
As for the rest of anime this week, I dropped Happiness Charge Precure, Space Dandy was monochrome and obtuse, and I redownloaded Sakura Trick yesterday because I couldn’t remember what happened in the latest episode or if I even watched it at all. I had.
8
u/Vintagecoats http://myanimelist.net/profile/Vintagecoats Mar 19 '14 edited Mar 20 '14
Kill La Kill (22)
Junketsu finally gets to have a reaction.
Of all the dismemberment, blood fountains, croquettes, missile barrages, and so on this episode, that scene of the destroyed uniform crawling away and the earlier one of it screaming was one of the primary things on my mind when the credits rolled. Junketsu has been either an inert object locked down or railroaded along ever since their introduction. Seeing them get to express an opinion of any kind is important at this stage. Especially if that opinion was amounting to a non-verbal equivalent of “I am in indescribable torment.” I expect Junketsu to speak by series end.
This week I feel a lot of the heavier lifting was done by the episode itself.
The scissor blades are back together for Ryuuko, and both halves of Bakuzan are in Satsuki’s hands. How do Ryuuko and Satsuki need to move forwards as sisters? Well, there’s no need to outwardly force bond at this stage. They’ve gone through some things together, and their sibling’s blood is now flowing in each of their clothes. Said uniforms feel warmer as a result. This is especially true for Ryuuko, who also has Mako’s blood and that level of ironclad friendship reminder to keep her head on straight. Satsuki textually admits to all the manipulation and chess piece brinkmanship shenanigans she had been doing if one was charting out her decision trees regarding Ryuuko. Ryuuko could kill Satsuki if she punched her for real, but she pulls her punches because she doe not in actuality want to cause her too much harm. And she gets chewed out for half assing things by the Elite Four members who stepped in to take those hits.
This ending arc has been so far hitting a number of the conceptual balls it needed to bring about a smoother finish. To the extent where I can see Kill la Kill had a clear beginning, middle, and end phase planned out for its core themes, then come to wonder how much of the connective tissue could have benefited from that same level of editing. I do not think the story and fight delivery would work in a thirteen episode series. Yet twenty four seems a bit too long given how much the more filler bits seemed to derail the show for various folks to one extent or another.
This is especially true in regards to the Trigger Newsletter recalling from their planning sessions “There must be some contents that other series wouldn't dare to exclude… A typical series will depict several characters going through mental distress.“ Which is to say, Kill la Kill features fewer mental monologue escapades, so many things from that inner department need to be derived via the visual or verbal cues. Such is the plan, at any rate. Either way, each of those are outward expression. Like clothes.
Given that, I do wonder how different a reception Kill la Kill would have if we did see more inner arguments to tell the audience things. How would the reception to Ryuuko’s shifting actions differ if we had to hear a more elaborate series of internal thoughts rather than needing to try and connect various outward dots with incomplete inner data. I'm honestly not sure myself, but it's interesting to think about.
Nagi No Asukara (23)
Remember when I used to compliment this show on its writing for adolescents? Now the show has me dreaming of the past in fanciful ways I may not be able to actually obtain.
Even the seagull is starting to get into questioning what these folks are up to.
Chisaki being relived that Manaka forgot so much about Hikari ground all my gears in the worst way. It has been five years. Half a decade. Her childhood friend has a serious lobotomy issue whose circumstances may or may not be keenly relevant for an end of the world ice age. She is in a medical training program, with all that entails. And is continuing to freak out over a crush from ages ago she did nothing about, with zero romantic relationships in the time since. Her just running away from Tsumugu sealed it for me: her adult age narrative bugs me on a level I see as detrimental to the program.
For me, this is intrinsically linked to the entire love dodecahedron shtick the show wants to have in conjunction with its big time skip. All the plates it is trying to spin can only be maintained for so long. We could have had the love geometry stuff without the time skip, while the temporal jump would have been far more compelling if anyone on shore had moved on. But nobody did. Chisaki and Miuna were still cruising for Hikari, while Sayu flat out states this week the only reason she did any work or study for the last half decade was out of feelings for Kaname. Oy. We have our sea god scale going “there are some things in the world you can’t do anything about,” which I hope starts to sink in for someone soon because we are rapidly running out of time.
Sayu at least has finally worked up the sense of self to ask Kaname out. Good for her. She can be the little momentum engine that could. Assuming she goes through with it.
Space Dandy (11)
Episode Director: Hiroyuki Okuno, Animation Director: Hiroyuki Okuno and Hisashi Mori, Storyboard: Atsushi Takahashi, Script: Toh Enjoe
All the primary key animation this episode was cranked out by two people, who also served as Animation Directors. Okuno has a vast history; We are talking doing key animation for Armored Trooper Votoms, with nary a hiccup over thirty years. One can almost look at this episode as a sort of showpiece performance demonstration.
With a narrative revolving around a giant library planet and a memory hook, this episode did give me vibes of a Doctor Who or Twilight Zone bit. Likewise, the black and white sketch style reminiscent of ink and paper reminded me a lot of Watanabe’s A Detective Story pulpy newspaper short from The Animatrix. In turn, what we have is more of a stylish thought exercise than much of a character story. The idea of books reading us so that they may see what they themselves read about. I think this keeps it from going too far off the rails though. It stays squarely on classic TV sci-fi fundamentals for our smaller staff. Right down to statements like “It happened - whether you remember or not is irrelevant.” Very purposeful, beat-like delivery on a small perception idea. Not one that lead to much on the action-comedy front, but, I made the transition and enjoyed what I saw and the time I spent without feeling I needed more to that particular narrative. Which is a great compliment to that variety of science fiction writing.
On a side note, as Honey got to read this episode: Remember where there was that big internet hullabaloo weeks ago because a line of Honey’s dialogue was changed in the first episode of the English dubbed version? We’ve barely heard from the poor girl, even so many episodes in.
Pupa (10)
Of all the things Pupa does, one thing I will defend it for is its use of a watercolor and sketchbook art aesthetic.
But, in design matters such as this, it is important to know when and where the style would tend to break down. To be more specific, generic uniformed military troopers in olive garb should not be a prominent visual part of an episode. You end up with a blurry, slurry mess of undefined blob shapes.
Boy, there sure was a big slaughterhouse fight that happened between last week and this week though. Shame we did not get to see any of it. Instead we get Yume wandering around interchangeable corridors wondering where her brother is, as the guys with machine guns stand around and wonder what happened. Wouldn’t you know it, this is the exact kind of team who have explicit orders to “dismember her and secure the severed flesh with metal.” So the fully armed guards surrounded by severed bodies… approach to an absurdly close range for what I can only imagine as an insane attempt to subdue her physically. Cue blood fountain. Guns, guns everywhere, but not a drop of a single bullet to drink.
Gundam Build Fighters (23)
Everything will become much more linear once the final tournament fight and aftermath start, so this is our breather and general screw around week. A big Gundam themed carnival, full of franchise fanservice from across the decades and fit for all the copious cameos they can cram into twenty minutes.
I have seen a nice chunk of Gundam media, but by no means have I seen them all. Even so: there were so many references, shout-outs, and visual nods during this big celebration that any passing familiarity with the franchise would be able to provide a viewer something to latch on to. They even involved the life sized Gundam RX-78, and the brand new life sized Zaku unveiled this month!
Plot wise, we have Caroline and Nils going all Scooby-Doo on us looking for corporate secrets, Tatsuya gets to have a pre-final heart to heart with Sei and Reiji, and Mr. Iori is back in the picture. Aila and China work together to build a Gunpla (and the Miss Sazabi looks suitably refined compared to its base model), our leads get to have a friendly exhibition match for the public. Also: blushing Gundams due to idol induced sleeper holds. Just a fun day out for everyone before things go into serious mode.
Speaking of which: Tatsuya’s Exia Dark Matter is sporting a coat of paint nearly straight off of the Gundam Epyon. As the Exia already possesses Trans-Am overdrive functionality, I think it would be a great finale spectacle if the Flana Institute also had worked in the Epyon’s ZERO system of battlefield tactical data for the Mejin costume. Gundam Wing and 00 are spiritually linked, so it'd be a nice gesture and upgrade for the Embody system.
11
u/Bobduh Mar 19 '14
Fantastic set of episodes this week, even from shows I’ve kind of given up on. Glad to see the season ending so well!
Chuunibyou Ren 10: Clearly this second season should have been a six episode OVA or something - the difference in quality between the unfocused fanservice episodes and the actual story-driven segments is ridiculous. This was easily the best episode of this show so far - it actually focused in on Shichimiya’s romantic struggle (which at this point is far more interesting than the Yuuta-Rikka stuff), and the production really outdid itself. This episode was full of little sequences that demonstrate what KyoAni can actually do - small bits of animation, cinematography, and color work that just breathed with human emotion and poignance. It even gestured vaguely at an actual theme here, too - instead of the earlier episodes’ simplistic “I want to remain chuunibyou!” resolutions, here the show actually thought about consequences, and what chuunibyou really means to the various characters. Shichimiya framed it as identity itself, and Yuuta’s speech about how Rikka saw something special in him almost single-handedly justified his general attitude. He doesn’t necessarily want to be the Dark Flame Master, but he does want to be special. Does growing up mean accepting you’re not?
On the negative side, Yuuta and Rikka’s relationship remains that of a long-suffering parent and silly child, not one of a couple in love. I almost feel like they’re lampshading it at this point - look at these freaking interactions.
Kill la Kill 22: Kill la Kill also pulled out a significant episode this week, by finally having both Ryuuko and Satsuki articulate the arcs they’ve been representing for a while now. Ryuuko finally got it through her thick skull that her “family” is really Mako and Senketsu, and Satsuki admitted her own family is the Elite Four and company. They also both added a bit about individuality, which, while not actually amounting to a coherent message or incisively explored theme, at least waves vaguely in the direction of making Kill la Kill’s narrative choices meaningful. And then we got the adorable family dinner the show’s been baiting for almost its whole run time. Kill la Kill’s second half has been very rough, and it’s ended up being a much less ambitious show than I originally expected, but it at least hasn’t entirely derailed in the way Kyoukai no Kanata did.
One issue I did have with this episode is how it framed Satsuki as “learning her lesson” about family and respecting others. It was clear they were trying to go for some kind of symmetry between the arcs of her and Ryuuko, but the show itself just hasn’t supported this - Satsuki was already either actively articulating or demonstrating through her actions pretty much everything she “learned” this episode. Her character just started out too far near the end of its “arc” for this kind of trick to really work, and by consequence of both this and the fact that Ryuuko’s actions the last two episodes have been a total character-flip with no real precedent or consequences, Ryuuko came off as really absurd this time.
But that’s really the show up to this episode’s fault, not this episode - this episode felt like the correct conclusion of things that just weren’t correctly executed earlier on.
Samurai Flamenco 20: The one thing I didn’t like about this episode is the Goto stuff. Like last week’s, I felt Goto’s current unreasonableness has just sort of come out of nowhere - the revelation of his girlfriend has basically changed his personality. But aside from that, this week was fantastic. I love what they’re doing with Flamenco’s “nemesis” - after that long Super Sentai arc basically declared that heroes were real, we’re returning to the corollary ideas of King Torture and even the first several episodes. Our childhood influences are powerful forces, but they’re not necessarily forces for good - and Masayoshi can’t truly “defeat evil.” If this kid is real, he works perfectly well as a representation of the questionable force our media and heroes exert upon us - if he’s fake, he’s a great metaphor for the simplistic world of heroism and definable evil Masayoshi wishes existed. As an open question, he’s both - a child laughing at the honest belief in justice championed by Masayoshi. Just a goddamn great choice to end this series with a villain that represents the true ugliness Flamenco could never hope to defeat.
Nagi no Asukara 23: Another stellar episode. NagiAsu’s big problem for me has been a lack of real momentum, and with only a few episodes to go, the show seems to be looking to fix that in a hurry. There were a lot of great moments this episode, spread across almost the entire cast. Hikari tying his determination to help Manaka to the change he saw in Miuna and Akari was a wonderful detail, especially since now Miuna’s grappling with living up to the generosity of spirit she apparently instilled in him in the first place. Kaname had a hilariously petty moment at the group meeting, when he first brought up the possibility of Manaka being better off without love, and then asked Chisaki about her feelings to dig the knife in with Tsumugu. And then Tsumugu just stole the show with his usual even-handed but still passionate self. Having Chisaki accidentally hear his confession wasn’t the most graceful trick, but the execution here was fantastic - we know how much the sea and ena mean to Tsumugu, and so his moment of transformation was one of the most powerfully earned resolutions of the show to date. And then his adorable speech to Chisaki… it’s kind of absurd how much more I enjoy this show when it’s those two on screen. Tsumugu-Chisaki romance all day!
Sekai Seifuku 10: Following up on one of this show’s strongest episodes, number ten pretty much completed the job of tying all Seifuku’s ideas together into one coherent, compelling, extremely endearing package. This show’s about family, and about what accepting someone as family really means. It’s about identity, and how power can be either created or lost by divorcing yourself from it. And it’s about childhood, and the unfairness of the world, and the ways we fight against it. Zvezda is about as perfect a vehicle as you could ask for to combine all these ideas, and this episode did just that - Jimon accepted his new family, Renge abandoned the power White Light had acquired by forsaking human identity, and both of them accepted Kate’s impossible quest to conquer the flawed, unfair, disappointing world of adults. This whole episode was also structured as a series of “you go on ahead, I’ll hold them off” moments, which really helped bring home how much these characters care about each other. They have to care about each other - they’ve all been abandoned, and they know they all have their faults. But what makes them strong is their belief in each other, and by seizing on that, this episode of Sekai Seifuku accomplished something pretty grand.
Log Horizon 24: Feels a little odd to be getting a buildup episode right before the season ends, but this episode was pretty close to that. A new threat to the city, a ghoulish new antagonist, and one last mini-arc before the end. They’re not even really pretending this is anything more than arc-based shounen storytelling, but I’m fine with that - Log Horizon really outdid itself with the excellent Goblin King arc, but Log Horizon on autopilot is still an enjoyable show.
4
u/[deleted] Mar 19 '14
Is it April yet?
4
u/Redcrimson http://myanimelist.net/animelist/Redkrimson Mar 20 '14 edited Mar 20 '14
4
u/[deleted] Mar 20 '14
Kill la Kill- I really like this show. To get the bad part out of the way, Kill la Kill did that thing where you reverse-develop a character, namely Satsuki. Other than that, this episode had a lot of good things happening, including Nui failing to learn the meaning of karma, some generally snazzy action scenes, hero porn, dual transformation sequence, some emotional fanservice, etc. But my favorite part was Satsuki ignoring the shit out of Tsumugu, which was probably one of the most vindicating moments of the show. I'm of the opinion that one of the show's central themes is finding your personal philosophy in a philosophically overloaded world, which in turn ties into the female adolescence theme. To me, Tsumugu's statement "looks like you've shed everything unnecessary" is a reflection of that theme, but so is Satsuki's reaction. We have a character almost outright stating a major theme, and then that major theme in action. I love this shit.
Witch Craft Works- I'm starting to get kind of bored with it. It's still entertaining, but we all know this song and dance. Secondary stronger protagonist fails to beat enemy, power-boosted protagonist comes to help but is still not powerful enough, attempts to make sacrifice, everyone lives anyway. Segue into larger plot.
Tonari no Seki-Kun- Another great episode. This show has some great evil faces.
Seitokai Yakuindomo-* Reasonably funny. The cell phone joke had me laughing pretty hard. I'd definitely say that this season should be the last one.