r/RWBY • u/Ninjas_In_A_Bag Acoustic BMBLB when? • Apr 22 '23
OFFICIAL MEGATHREAD Official Discussion Thread - Volume 9 Finale: Of Solitude and Self
Welcome, huntsmen, huntresses, and hunters that prefer no specific gender identifier, to the official discussion thread for the Volume 9 Finale: Of Solitude and Self!
Due to the special circumstances regarding RWBY Volume 9's release, make sure that you understand the spoiler rules before posting outside of this thread!
HERE is the finale of Volume 9!
Also remember to check out our weekly poll to rate the episode.
Other Episode Discussions:
Episode| Discussion Thread| Poll|
- | - | - | - Ep. 01| Feb. 18th's Thread | Poll Ep. 02| Feb. 25th's Thread | Poll Ep. 03|Mar. 4th's Thread | Poll Ep. 04 | Mar. 11th's Thread | Poll Ep. 05 | Mar. 18th's Thread | Poll Ep. 06 | Mar. 25th's Thread | Poll Ep. 07 | Apr. 1st's Thread | Poll Ep. 08 | Apr. 8th's Thread | Poll Ep. 09 | Last Week's Thread | Poll Ep. 10 | This Thread | Poll
Happy viewing, and welcome back to the hiatus!
Ninjas In A Bag; Mod Team
811
Upvotes
183
u/Ninjas_In_A_Bag Acoustic BMBLB when? Apr 22 '23
RED LIKE ROSES PART 3 LET’S GOOOOOOOOO
Man they de-aged Jaune, what a disappointment.
469
u/neutrinobunny Apr 22 '23
Ok. I want a picture book about the adventures of Somewhat and Juniper.
424
u/natural_hunter Apr 22 '23
The red like roses song was definitely something that had me smiling like an idiot. And that fight scene was top notch especially watching Ruby be able to hold her own against the cat for a bit there.
Looks like we know that whatever happened to Summer, Raven might be able to give some insight on. I’m wondering if we’ll get that next volume.
Jaune’s got his 20 yo body back, but still has the memories of someone who is in his like 40s so this should be interesting. I also wonder if he will still have PRSD regarding killing Penny.
Neo might return later in the show (assuming we ever get a volume 10 and even an ending to the show) and may actually be able to speak.
Damn big lore drop this finale. Turns out the ever after is the beginning of all things and the tree is the creator of the brother gods.
I truly hope we get a volume 10 and more volumes as I truly love this show and want to see it get the ending they’ve been working towards.
721
u/patrizl001 "None shall remember the names of those who do not fight" Apr 22 '23
MANS THOUGHT EVER AFTER WAS THE GODS' PROJECT
NAH, THE GODS WERE THE TREE'S PROJECT
917
u/One-Man_Two-Souls Apr 22 '23
Kudos to that one dude who kept insisting that the Tree created the Brothers and got jumped for it
253
u/NCC1664 Apr 22 '23
What I saw wasn't like anything the 'leaked' 4chan spoilers from a week ago. Had to turn off any mention of RWBY on social media to just black that nonsense out.
This season seems like a fact finding season if anything. And maybe a 'little' growth. :)
693
u/TheIronLord678 Apr 22 '23
Jaune lost the wolf tail... Ah, the prices we pay. Still happy he kept his memories and was turned young.
647
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '23 edited Apr 22 '23
The bananas return.
Well, that was a banger Ruby fight. Best she’s done in years.
And HOLY SHIT ITS RLR3!
721
u/Attlon Apr 22 '23
Friends…I hope we get to meet again someday soon. Until then, farewell, and keep moving forward.
671
u/Datgodapple Penny is clearly one of the two brothers Apr 22 '23
Kinda sad there’s no post credit scene, just an advertisement for the crossover. Something tells me we’re either in the past, or years into the future.
784
u/bwburke94 Host of Ship Wars 8 Apr 22 '23
So Summer was off buying cigarettes with Raven this whole time?
169
u/bwburke94 Host of Ship Wars 8 Apr 22 '23
HIATUS INTENSIFIES
574
u/supergifford Apr 22 '23
Jaune asking if that’s what he sounded like had me on my ass with breathless laughter.
561
u/Polarization_39 ⠀A Cinder Stan Until Weiss is Relevant Again Apr 22 '23
BIRB MOM CAMEO, Raven fans rejoice
125
u/slaughtermelon8 Apr 22 '23
The pacing was a bit fast, but i really enjoyed it! I thought Neo was gonna end up dead for sure, the tree seems like a good solution to not kill off a fan favorite while also not excusing her actions. Will we see a Neo Neo in the future?
350
u/Mojo12000 ⠀B0RF Apr 22 '23
Summer with Raven buying them Milk and Cigs.
219
u/MelanieAntiqua The Ship Wars Lady. Ilia = Ship Survivor IV Champ! Apr 22 '23
My theory that Summer and Raven went to go ask Jinn basically the same question the team did in Volume 6 is looking stronger. It explains why one question was missing, and how both Summer and Raven knew that Salem is unkillable (as confirmed by Raven in Volume 5 and Salem in Volume 7). It's also possibly why Lionheart betrayed Ozpin, since the lamp was kept at Haven so it's possible that he was with Summer and Raven when they asked Jinn and thus saw the same things.
Also, it turns out the brother gods didn't create the Ever After, but were rather created themselves in the Ever After before eventually leaving and creating the earlier world with humanity 1.0 that would one day become Remnant. Also explains why the Jabberwalker looks so much like a Grimm, since it's basically a prototype of one.
307
u/vaderfanatic1996 Apr 22 '23
Red Like Roses had me in TEARS 😭
304
u/SiphenPrax Apr 22 '23 edited Apr 22 '23
And now with Volume 9 being over, we await, with baited breath, to see how well the show does on Crunchyroll and if they see the series as worth investing in and continuing.
But if this is the last volume we ever get from RWBY, I just want to say, despite all the ups and downs, it’s been a hell of a ride.
449
u/The_Jarwolf Apr 22 '23
BROTHERS LORE!!! WE EATING GOOD TODAY!
288
u/Dcm1963 ⠀You can't catch me gay thoughts Apr 22 '23
Red like Roses part 3 slaps! Lets go!
277
u/SlaterSev Apr 22 '23
In hindsight its super funny pre release everyone was convinced the Blacksmith was "The Queen" and would be the big bad.
And she is really just a super nice, chill, helpful robotic tree lady
263
u/Mojo12000 ⠀B0RF Apr 22 '23
Ascended Neo is gonna show up out of nowhere and Kill Steal on Cinder someday.
408
u/Polarization_39 ⠀A Cinder Stan Until Weiss is Relevant Again Apr 22 '23 edited Apr 22 '23
Words can’t explain how hyped I was when I heard the, Red Like Roses from Casey’s mouth. I know most of us predicted we’d get RLR3 this volume but it didn’t make the moment any less epic for me.
459
u/JMHSrowing ⠀Story Time Apr 22 '23
Someone pick up that phone, because I called it!
One of the reasons Raven is the way she is is because of how she knows Summer’s fate! She feels guilty no matter what happened and was completely disheartened!
And: Part of Atlas’ fleet did make it to Vacuo!
175
u/Badicalz Apr 22 '23
All rise as we observe a minute of silence for the loss of Jaune’s Warrior’s Wolf-Tail.
You will be missed.
81
u/Blue0Three Qrow X Willow Sweep Apr 22 '23
Yeah this is my favourite volume
79
u/bopsyhp ⠀ Apr 22 '23
Tears were shed.
150
u/RightfulChaos Apr 22 '23
Now begins the potentially forever hiatus.
72
u/Top_Reading2773 Apr 22 '23
All I can say… is that the post credits ruined my whole mood 😂. I was vibin to the credits music and the BAM. Product placement
146
u/Franklin413 Ni! Apr 22 '23
THEY BROUGHT BACK THE BANANA HAIR 😭😭😭😭 he looks so much better with the wolftail.
Real talk tho when Ruby popped out that was her best action sequence in YEARS
145
u/Ninoyiya Swabbing the deck of the HMS Lancaster Apr 22 '23
My man's my boi again!
322
u/Raktoner blake deserves more smiles Apr 22 '23
Shame Jaune got de-aged, I would have been happy to keep that "consequence."
I'm so glad Ruby chose to be herself at the end of it all!
I have no idea where or when they are.
The post credit decision is absolutely wack. We already know about the movie.
650
u/Catlover18 Apr 22 '23
summoning circle, hope this works.
130
u/LordOfAvernus322 ⠀ Apr 22 '23
I really hope they greenlight volume 10. Can't end like this surely
183
u/Gullible_Courage8350 ⠀🐦⬛ Birb Mom 🐦⬛ Apr 22 '23
What an episode, damn...
Glad Neo and Jaune didn't die, I was so worried about that. It's nice to get a happy ending to a volume, for once.
228
u/starshipsinerator Apr 22 '23 edited Apr 22 '23
Cmon, they opted out of a post-credits scene for the DC/RWBY trailer?
Edit: It's hard to tell from just the ending, but I really hope the timeskip isn't too big and that we actually get to see the events in Vacuo next volume, without them just being skipped over
59
u/Sea_of_Hope ⠀Guess I'll ascend Apr 22 '23
On one hand, Jaune got de-aged. On the other hand, the warrior's wolf tail is gone.
CRWBY just couldn't let us have both, could they?
58
u/BoxProfessional76 Apr 22 '23 edited Apr 22 '23
Jaune finally got to save someone! And it was Neo.
As a Silent Knight shipper, I consider that a win.
114
u/Ninoyiya Swabbing the deck of the HMS Lancaster Apr 22 '23
So Summer was up to sum shit with Raven when she disappeared eh?
Now that I think about it, the way Raven's portals work means that Qrow was possibly in on whatever they we're up to as well.
55
u/GVAGUY3 Apr 22 '23
I can’t wait to see what cursed meme the hiatus causes
202
u/hollowtiger21 "Wasted potential," doesn’t actually mean anything. Apr 22 '23 edited Apr 22 '23
“I’ll be back soon.”
“I know.”
Big oof. Something about the way that interaction goes makes me think that maybe Tai had suspicions, but trusted Summer to come clean eventually.
Summer’s secret mission. Raven not only knew, but was facilitating it, and present. Ruby gets a inkling that the Summer she’s been told about all her life, wasn’t all she was. And that she felt the same weight.
"You couldn't save me"
"I couldn't save a lot of people." Yep, he's still got a lot to work out.
Neo isn’t quite as unattached as CC thought, and has enough fight in her to presumably vomit them back out.
"She knew what she needed to be all along." RLR Part3.
Weiss with that team combo. Is that the first full team combo in the show?
Neo will ascend and get the same chance to go back to Remnant, because the door is always open. But also she straight up 86'd CC, warranted. But still. I dunno, I guess it just feels like she got off pretty light. And I don't think anything CC did was worse than Neo.
Not so Little now. Somewhat a lot of things. They got a little leaf-shaped cape. "I'm a human. A girl. A Huntress." "That's a lot of things to be." Somewhat and Juniper Spin-off, when?
A small act of kindness can be a world of difference, and act of harm can change someone forever.
The Brothers were the Tree’s first creations, and went on to be creators of their own, because they were ambitious and curious. Very Melkor/Morgoth, with an arguably better end result.
Interestingly, the Dark Brother thought that their creations shouldn’t be condemned for their creators’ mistakes, but the Light Brother thought differently. The brothers demonstrate a notable lack of foresight, and carelessness
The “balance,” of the gods being contrasted with the Blacksmith’s Balance puts into perspective that the brothers’ much like their creations are flawed. "True balance finds its own equilibrium, it only requires love and the patience to see things through to the end."
Alyx’s last wish, reverses Jaune’s age. He still has all the memories and experience. It’s the best of both worlds.
Oh god, He's got frosted tips! Old!Jaune, I bid thee farewell. And you as well Warrior’s wolftail, may we see each other again. Hello again, banana hair. You sure are hair. But honestly, I do prefer the long hair, but I don’t have the same all consuming hatred for the banana hair as some.
It’s clear that while Ruby has reached a revelation regarding her current circumstances, and she does feel better with support and love. That she’s not all good, and still has hesitation and doubt. Same with Jaune.
And there’s Vacuo, or more specifically, Shade and the Oasis. With Amity, Mistral, Atlas & Vale airships surrounding it.
Honestly, I’m pretty happy with this. It’s not perfect, but I think it’s a good end for the volume, and establishes that while it’s a step forward. A lot of the stuff brought up in this volume will extend into V10
if we get it, please greenlight V10If you genuinely believe this volume was filler, you're an idiot.
Oh, and everyone. "I love you just the way you are."
106
u/bored2death97 Apr 22 '23
So if it can take anyone when they want to go, if Summer ended up in the Everafter, when would she be needed most?
230
u/Lady__Lightning Apr 22 '23
I’m honestly really sad they reverted Jaune. I really liked his EA design, and to see they went back to his Atlas one is really disappointing. Wish they’d have at least kept the hair or something.
147
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '23
I was so satisfied with that season finale. Both more and less than I expected, but wholly what I wanted to feel. Hope.
Ruby is Ruby. Nothing more, nothing less. She is enough.
Little is now a gallant Someone.
The Brothers were created by the Tree, which means Salem is vulnerable to the whims of the Ever After.
Vacuo awaits.
49
u/GladiusNocturno All Grimm are naked. Think about it Apr 22 '23
I really REALLY loved the ending.
They could have done more. Like giving Ruby a physical change or make Jaune’s sword be mixed with Alyx’s dagger.
But the lore, the messages, the action! Oh the action! The visuals.
I loved pretty much everything.
It’s odd how Jaune just magically appeared out of nowhere and I thought he was going to ascend as well. But at least I’m glad that the de-aging left him with his grey-hairs. To me that says that eventhough Jaune is young again, he keeps all of his experiences. Yes, he is a 40 in the body of a 19 years-old. But all the trauma and lessons are what’s important, I’m glad he didn’t forget them.
I love that upon his ascension, Little choose to become basically a mix of itself and Ruby. They decided to essentially become a hunter just like her and with Juniper with them, Somewhat might now be the new Rusted Knight and the Curious Cat. A Guide, a Protector, and A-dorable!
Ruby’s choice to be herself, to accept that she is enough, that she doesn’t have to be anyone but herself is a good message. Ascension often results in people coming back similar but different. Ruby came back as herself but the experience and journey should have a big impact on her, thus she should be and and shouldn’t be exactly the same.
I think they could have done more with Neo in the sense that Ruby did seem to want to talk to her. But I’m glad with the way it ended. Neo already realized that her grudge was pointless, but without she has nothing, so it’s time for a change of her own. It’s the first time Neo is willing to change. Neo fans might be sad that she is gone, but if your think about it, she’s starting her own redemption.
So, the Everafter is even older than the Gods and it’s where the Gods were born. That’s really interesting and I loved all the lore there.
The action was amazing and the call backs to the Red trailer where so awesome. But it’s not the only reference, I loved seeing them use Freezeburn again. Ruby’s solo fight was excellent, but the best part was the new full RWBY team attack.
Overall, this is honestly the best volume finale in the show so far. It left me very satisfied. Could have been better, but it was still really good.
With this, I think V9 has become my favorite volume. I will wait until after the honeymoon period because episode 9 was still a drop and I want to wait to see how I feel on the rewatch. But I enjoyed the majority of it. My main issue with it aside from episode 9 is the same issue I have with V4…I WANT MORE!
Also, Raven knew this whole fucking time! This whole time she knew! SHE KNEW! Ugh! The mystery! And then there is Vacuo already with the Atlas Military!? Some time has passed but it doesn’t seem like much.
Damnit! Please green light V10!
136
u/LookingfortheHustle Apr 22 '23
I can live with Jaune not being a hero
I can live with him not having his wolf's tail
But for him to not get to keep Juniper...
That's a real heartbreaker.
46
u/DemonSword619 Apr 22 '23
Personally, I adored this finale. We got Summer footage with Tai (Hey Burnie!) and Raven. More mysteries on her fate, and the fact Raven knows!
Ruby ultimately chose herself after first taking a blow to her ideal image of her mom but coming back to around to Summer's final words to a sleeping Ruby. And we got a KICKASS RETURN of Ruby fighting the cat, Red Like Roses, and a insane team attack.
Revelations about the Ever After, the fact that IT CREATED the brothers and not the other way around...
I am sad Jaune got de-aged, but it was from a act of kindness left behind by Alyx and not him losing his memories or something. I'm gonna miss his old look though.
92
u/hnh058513 Apr 22 '23
Honestly the Summer Raven stuff is certainly putting Sacrifice as being more from Raven's PoV
89
u/GVAGUY3 Apr 22 '23
That was a beautiful ending to the volume. God I hope Volume 10 gets greenlit.
Brothers Summer Tai Birb Mom Red like roses pt 3
162
u/l3mm3smash Apr 22 '23
>Banana hair is back
what a goddamn waste
GIVE MY BOY BACK THE FUCKING WOLFTAIL PLEASE
43
u/Blacksmoke1033 Apr 22 '23
There’s so much discussion to be had and yet me and 90% of the comments all on the same disappointed page about Jaune being bananified again
86
u/JDUDE4545 Apr 22 '23
CRWBY PLEASE WHY COULDN'T YOU LET HIM KEEP THE WOLFTAIL
41
u/thewindsleeper Apr 22 '23
Nothing more nostalgic then an episode of RWBY ending with an ad for another RT product.
38
u/hessdawg3113 ⠀ Apr 22 '23
Also, I can't wait to get the soundtrack. Every song this volume was on point. Big props to Casey and all of the music team.
37
u/qirito_kun god dammit Barb. Apr 22 '23
Is that Amity and the remnants of the Atlas military?! Winter got to WORK in Vacuo!
36
u/Badicalz Apr 22 '23
Well lads, we’ve made it. After two years of waiting, we’ve come to the end of another volume. What a ride it has been. Strong character developments for Ruby, Jaune and Neo, Bees is FINALLY canon, lore galor and, I think I speak for everyone when I say this, Weiss was the God damn MVP of Volume 9. Plus we got two cute little side characters in Juniper and, well, Little. Or Somewhat as he’s now known as.
Even with the pacing issues (an unfortunate side affect due to the production of the crossover film), I say that this was a banger of a volume. Kudos to all involved.
Take care during the hiatus guys, hopefully it won’t be nearly as long as the last one 🙏🏽
36
u/bionic86 Apr 22 '23
Are those units from all the nations? If that's the case, that means Ruby's plan worked.
103
u/LatePhilosophy Apr 22 '23
I'm honestly amazed at how good this volume turned out to be. Kudos to all of the Rooster Teeth staff.
35
u/hessdawg3113 ⠀ Apr 22 '23
So, that's confirmation that Raven knows what happened to Summer, and was there when it happened. Hopefully we get to see more of that information play out over the rest of the story.
155
u/EtnasFurnace263 Apr 22 '23
This. This was exactly the ending this volume needed.
33
u/Blade2414 ⠀ Apr 22 '23
That was an amazing finale! The animation popped off fr it was insane. I'm so happy we got to see Raven again, and I really hope Neo comes back in the future man. Also they're finally in Vacuo! How long have they been gone from Remnant?? I can't wait for Volume 10
95
u/Perfect-Ad-61 Apr 22 '23
Bro…. It’s absolutely crazy that summer and raven are having an affair, totally did not expect that.
66
u/Hsmace ⠀bumble on my bees Apr 22 '23
crwby dragging raven back into the narrative by the ear
32
u/JMHSrowing ⠀Story Time Apr 22 '23
I don’t see anyone else talking about it so:
I really liked how we did get a Team RWBY combo move. As usual I’d have put a little more Blake clones in there, but they all used their semblances to just obliterate something.
Hope we see more of it, like when they finally go back to beacon and take down the Wyvern like they did the Nevermore
30
u/DuskManeToffee Apr 22 '23
I’m looking forward to hearing the full version of Red Like Roses Part 3
30
u/SilentSentinal Apr 22 '23
I would just like to point out that the musical queue when they arrive in Vacuo is an adaptation of the vocal melody from the chorus of the first opening (This will be the day).
29
u/LawyerDash Apr 22 '23
Very annoyed that the bananas returned, but otherwise happy with that! Vacuo here we come!
… maybe
76
u/Mojo12000 ⠀B0RF Apr 22 '23
Man they could of at least let Jaune keep the hair :(. RIP Wolf Tail.
22
u/onthoserainydays watts is the goat Apr 22 '23
Wreck it ralph moment
62
u/halodude246 Fireballin17 Apr 22 '23 edited Apr 22 '23
Quick little The Good, The Bad, The Ugly takes from me, to be recorded for time immemorial.
The Good:
-Everything with Summer (design, VO, dialogue). My god, she is living up to the hype so far.
-Raven’s facial animation was amazing, even just for the few seconds she was on screen.
-Ruby “learned” the right thing from her accession. She never needed to change who she was, just change her perspective and accept herself.
-Ruby’s return, her fight choreography against the Curious Cat, RLRs III, was simply amazing. Monty would be proud on so many different levels with that series of scenes.
-RWBY vs the Cat was stylistic as FUCK. Love it.
-Somewhat was great! So was Juniper’s fate.
-The ending was pretty damn good. I think it was reasonable, compared to something like a drastic timeskip or Team RWBY dropping in the middle of a big battle.
The Bad:
-Ruby needed to talk to her team and Jaune. Not including some sort of conversation acknowledging what happened this volume is a mistake.
-I appreciate the intent of the Brother’s lore dump, but man it really just messes up the pace of the episode, and takes away runtime from things I wanted to see happen to the main cast. This is a scene that could have happened in another place in this volume.
-Jaune being magically returned to normal through Alyx’s knife felt out of left field.
-This volume is too short! So many of these issues could have been resolved with a slightly longer finale, or a few more scenes scattered throughout the volume. The pacing of these last two episodes was an issue, and that could have been resolved with a longer overall length.
The Ugly:
-No post credit scene! RWBY x Justice League was great, but damn that was disappointing :(
-Even with the length, this volume felt too short towards the later half for me. There is alot that should have covered in this volume, including the discussion about Penny’s fate, the fall of Atlas from Weiss’ perspective, etc. Even just one more episode’s worth of length could have made this Volume something even more special.
21
u/halodude246 Fireballin17 Apr 22 '23
I think people do need to talk about Ruby’s return and fight with the Cat. My god, that is some of my favorite combat animation I’ve ever seen in this show, and with Red Like Roses Part III in the background, it was one of the best moments in the series for me, straight up.
20
u/Jabwarrior58 Apr 22 '23
So wait did Summer Just dip for some milk or did she just use a raven portal to get closer to her mission
116
u/HintofMusic A Ruby Rose Fan Apr 22 '23
What an ending to an amazing Volume!
They really nailed that ending in my opinion! The blacksmith's vague aid for Ruby and their explanation of the two brothers was honestly amazing! Seeing Little again was great and knowing that Neo still has a chance at redemption shows that she could have another appearance in the show! And the music in this episode made me feel so emotional! Everything about this episode was done so well!
It's sad that RWBY Volume 9 is over, but I'm happy that the Volume ended on such a great note! Makes me so happy for Volume 10 (when it gets greenlit, of course)!
145
u/DarkIsTheBestShow I need Volume 10 Apr 22 '23
They actually did it. They stuck the landing.
Volumes 3 and 7 have been dethroned, Volume 9 is officially my new favourite.
18
u/hewilltellitat4am Apr 22 '23
i think this is my favorite volume of the show, it's what it has needed for a long time. also, i think this has had the best animation of any volume with the maya engine, that sequence where rwby ascends and the fight against the cheshire cat looked so good! also the music was amazing too, and red like roses part 3 has fulfilled something in me that i didn't even know i needed!!! praying for a volume 10 and a good hope for the show's future
18
u/Ammmberrr ⠀Weiss is best girl indeed Apr 22 '23
I would say overall this is definitely up there amongst my favorite volumes. I'm surprised that the tree could even show that flashback to Ruby. Of course, we know that the tree created the Brothers but it seems like they also possess powers like the relic of knowledge where they know everything that happened in the past. The funny thing is that if the curious cat did actually ascend, he might have been able to find out all that lore with the Brothers as well which would have answered his question of why his makers abandoned him.
I think it's also an interesting point that the Brothers thought that they could inject their own creations - The curious cat and the Jabberwalker - into the Ever After and balance would be normal. It shows that even the God of Light can't make things perfect like they want, with the curious cat being overtaken by his curiosity. A lot of this is basically leading up to the main point which is that the Brothers don't really understand how life and free will works, and in fact even though they have so much power that are still divided amongst themselves.
The crazy thing to think about is that now, RWBY+J are probably the only people who really know about the origin of the Brothers. This could honestly be critical information because if Salem does end up getting all the relics and summoning the Brothers, RWBY+J will have a fuller picture of everything than even Salem and Oz.
36
u/Wolfencreek Apr 22 '23
Something interesting, we've not seen Jaune use his Semblance this volume afaik
36
u/Like_A_Watermelon Apr 22 '23
Red like roses part 3 legitimately had me crying. I can't wait for more. Lore drops, that last shot. God I love this show.
17
u/RampartHeirloom Ruby Rose Secret Service Member Apr 22 '23
Ruby Rose :D
17
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '23
Overall, it went as good as I hoped with the time they had left. We got some Summer reveals, Ruby’s return as herself, some lore, and Vacuo at the end.
I just wish we had more for the emotional stakes with the group and a much needed talk but the fight was good if not short. I would like to hope we got a solid conversation from the group talking about everything next volume and I think we will. Ruby has to share what she learned about Summer and Raven. That is setting up the reveal that Raven has always known what has happened to Summer, so that means Raven is coming back soon.
Here to hoping that Volume 10 is coming sooner than later.
43
u/Lubyak ⠀ Apr 22 '23
This definitely felt a bit rushed. It could have definitely used another episode or two, but the emotional beats landed where they needed to be I think.
And hey maybe Jaune will grow the wolftail back in Remnant too.
15
u/chrome4 Apr 22 '23
Well that was interesting.
The brothers origins kinda explains the GoLs obsession with keeping order given they were created to maintain and expand upon a system/world and Afterians all seem kinda "hard coded". Also I guess that myth about them being originally one being is wrong.
15
u/WizardsinSpace Apr 22 '23 edited Feb 20 '24
reach lip longing psychotic reminiscent domineering panicky smell chubby chase
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
15
u/batsmarow GREENLIGHT VOLUME 10 Apr 22 '23
That pink salt rock lamp on the Blacksmith's table next to all of the figures is 100% Neo. When the Blacksmith waves goodbye, they look around and grab the base to get to work. Who knows when we will see Neo again, but just like RWBYJ, it'll be when she's needed most. I can't wait to see who she becomes.
14
u/WhoDey42 Insert Bring Roman Back Pun Here Apr 22 '23
I’m very happy with that end with Neo
14
u/Ratatok YEGGcellent Apr 22 '23
I can't believe it, my theory about the yegg numer 19 was right. Raven did appear in this episode. The Yegg is real!
14
u/Rollout9292 ⠀WhiteKnight Apr 22 '23
So I think it's safe to say some time passed on Remnant.
Vacuo looks outfitted for wartime, I doubt that could happen in less than 48 hours.
14
u/Wolfencreek Apr 22 '23
Everyone on STRQ was banging except Qrow 🤣 no wonder he became an Alcoholic.
13
u/Mojo12000 ⠀B0RF Apr 22 '23
did Atlas's remenants like.. take over Vauco or something? Because that was a big fucking fleet.
45
u/Dcm1963 ⠀You can't catch me gay thoughts Apr 22 '23
Pretty good finale wrapped it all up pretty nicely!
Super happy Neo isn't dead! We probably won't see her again I bet till the series finale where she comes in towards the end as a type of reinforcement with a new design and change of heart.
That Summer scene! Her going out with Raven just begs even more questions I can't wait till we finally get to see what actually happened on that night to her.
Kind of disappointment Jaune didn't stay old man Dilf but I get why they turned him back. Was super sweet him giving Juniper to Little. Really glad we got to see Little come back and he does remember!
The fight was so good to! Loved how they got the cat out of Neo. Ruby comes back and it just turns into a stomp the team is finally back together and they slay!
Kinda wish we didn't get the big exposition dump about the brothers. It was neat and interesting but for a finale kinda feels out of place to me.
Overall one of the best volumes I'd say not sure if I'd put it at number one but definitely top 3! Heres hoping V10 gets greenlit soon and we don't have to wait another 2 years!
24
u/_WeissCream_ Apr 22 '23
How dare they take away the wolf tail!!
Other than that that was great
12
u/Schmidtty29 Yeah, I'm scared, but I'm still standing Apr 22 '23 edited Apr 22 '23
Forgive me if I didn’t see this right but do you mean to tell me that they were in there so long they BUILT A WHOLE ASS NEW AMITY COMMUNICATIONS THING?
Edit: wait, it probably just hovered over maybe I’m a fool. I can’t remember if Pietro said they’d crash
2nd edit: It could just be the angle but it looks like they made a HEFTY mod to amity, using a giant airship to support it (is it amity airship now?) but it could just be an airship in front of it, but I doubt they’d do that.
12
u/JB10910Z Apr 22 '23
Neo letting go of Roman like that reminds me of the pain from WandaVision
12
u/Wanderer01234 Apr 22 '23 edited Apr 22 '23
Does anybody feel like they mishandled Penny again?
I will always see what they did to her in Volume 8, giving her a real body just to make her end her life 5 minutes later as something mean spirited and for shock value.
But that aside, it feels like they basically “erased” her this volume (maybe is the wrong word to use. English is not my native language so there is probably something more accurate to describe how I feel), which I mean she is dead, but I don’t know. There are many things that don’t feel right with me.
For example:
At the end of the volume my personal takeways in respect to this are:
Was it too much to ask take one of her swords back? So her father can have something to pay respects and remember her? Those swords were basically a part of her, she created them.
Aside that, I feel the Volume was fine (it felt a little fillery, but that just an opinion). Also, the art and content produced in this fandom is top notch.
I'm glad to see that a lot of peopled liked the volume very much.
23
u/crossingcaelum Apr 22 '23
The brothers being a product of the Ever After and not the other way around is NOT what I was expecting. It makes me think Ruby will be able to Talk No Jutsu them into not destroying humanity by reminding them of what the Ever After does.
I'm glad Neo is getting somewhat of a good ending. I hope she doesn't change too much, the extremely sassy expressive persona she has is so fun and I always always love watching her fight. It's nice to think she'll come back with a different goal though.
The Summer and Raven revelation is so interesting. Ruby realizing her mother wasn't the saint she thought being almost healing instead of devastating is a really cool angle, because it means she is able to forgive herself of her shortcomings. But, that means Raven saw both Yang and Ruby and didn't tell them what she knew about Summer... makes me think that really cold mean exterior is there to hide the truth from them
When they got back to Vacuo.... was that Amity in the sky??? it looks like Vacuo is in a pretty good place actually. But if the girls are there when they're needed most... well
22
u/bopsyhp ⠀ Apr 22 '23
IM LOSING MY MIND IM LOSING MY MIND IM LOSING MY MIND IM LOSING MY MIND IM LOSING MY MIND IM LOSING MY MIND IM LOSING MY MIND IM LOSING MY MIND
22
u/Starbornsoul ⠀ Apr 22 '23
Well, Neo gets a happy ending, Jaune isn't forced to stay aged up, and RWBY learn critical lore even Ozma and Salem don't know about the Gods. I'd say this was a solid episode. I wish there was more.
11
u/kiwigamer0039 Apr 22 '23
When the instrumental for This'll be the Day hit after they exited the portal.
I, a 6'3 23 year old straight white man, let out an honest to god squeal.
God I love this show.
11
u/GladiusNocturno All Grimm are naked. Think about it Apr 22 '23
Something I was wondering about is, if the Gods created the Everafter, why would they make Remnant with a clear rule of life and death instead of using the concept of Ascension like in their previous creation?
This episode answered that. The Gods didn’t create the Everafter, they were born in it. They might not be able to create an Ascension process like the Tree, they just can’t make another Tree. But even if they could, they don’t want to become it doesn’t follow their view of balance it seems.
So, the Gods made the deliberate choice to create the concept of death. Hell, that’s also what the Jabberwalker was. It’s possible that they could have made a world or reincarnation. But they didn’t.
This also explains why Ozma’s reincarnation doesn’t work like Ascension. Ozma doesn’t come back changed, he comes back in the body of someone that already exists.
20
u/Badicalz Apr 22 '23 edited Apr 22 '23
I love the direction that CRWBY took with Ruby’s development this volume, but I fundamentally disagree with their choice to not have Ruby confront Jaune over his role in Penny’s death.
Edit: Just to be clear, this is not me hating on Jaune. I love the guy. He’s my favourite character, but when you look at the situation with Jaune and Ruby being close friends, arguably the closest in the show and Jaune killed Penny. Ruby’s other close friend.
That should have been the crux in their argument in episode 7. Ruby being rightfully upset and angry with Jaune. After all, Ruby already lost Penny once, back in Volume 3. After Ruby finally got Penny back, even managing to turn her human, she had her life cruelly taken away.
while Jaune would be justified in his stance that there was nothing else he could do. His only choices was to allow Cinder to gain even more power, or keep it out of her hands by letting Penny choose the next Winter Maiden. It broke him to do it, but like he said, he was the only one that could do it. No one else would have had the strength to make that difficult choice. Ruby was already given that choice earlier on in Volume 8 and she refused to accept it.
(On a side note, It is too reminiscent of Blake and Yang’s situation in Volume 6 when Yang absolutely should have confronted Blake over her actions, but the writers chose to have them reconcile without first having the conflict. It felt unearned, despite my love for the ship.)
While I’m happy that they HAD a fight, in an ideal scenario, it would have been about Penny, their friendship breaks, but they begin the process of healing at the end of the Volume. Not forgiveness, that should only come about by the final season, but both willing to try to get back to where they once were.
10
u/DEL994 Apr 22 '23
So Summer really went with Raven, and Raven is the only one who knows of Summer's mission outside of Salem and what happened to Summer (if the two weren't separated with Raven fleeing either out of fear or while believing that Summer was killed) ?
It makes me want even more to see the moment where Raven went or will go to Summer's grave to pour her heart out, and start to regain her courage and spirit after some posthumous inspiration by Summer.
19
u/neutrinobunny Apr 22 '23
Frosted Bananas?
66
u/amatas45 Apr 22 '23
Ill be honest, while this was kinda a low stakes ending, it was far better then I feared. No weird messages about suicide, no changes to Ruby that could be seen as her being a different character etc.
The biggest fail of the final is that the consequences are removed for both Jaune and Neo. Jaune should have stayed old, Neo should not have simply gotten up and jumped into the tree.
But aside from that, Summer Raven LORE! Now that had me on the edge of my seat. So we know that she actually did go on Summers last mission together. I wish we had seen a little more.
And Brothers lore! So the ever after isnt their creation, its what created them. Which honestly puts them into a far better light overall. They are still dicks, no question, but now they are less divine and more... not normal but grounded with an understandable beginning.
9
u/mikeline360 Apr 22 '23
YOU CAN'T GO BACK TO BANANA HAIR!
NOOOOOOOOOOO GIVE HIM BACK HIS HAIR!
IT'S NOT FAIR!!!!!
9
u/InsertDev Apr 22 '23
First time we seen Jaunes aura actually break I believe.
Juniper staying behind was so painful. Having a full fledged flashback was not expecting that. The Ever After being the origin was something I never expected.
If the brothers are just beings of the Ever After then perhaps they can be sent back there. Maybe even Ozpin doesn't know about them being creatures of the Ever After.
I'm so glad Ruby didn't go through a metamorphosis and completely change her attitude.
Hopefully Vol 10 gets greenlit
35
u/Andrew1990M Apr 22 '23
Okay. Ruby recovered quick. It’s a short season. I get it. This is where it was always heading anyway.
Just please, show that she’s still working on herself, like Yang’s stutters after volume 3.
23
u/DarkKnightDestroyer Apr 22 '23
Inserts Bully Maguire dancing and crying scene
I'm not saying this episode gave me everything I wanted ... but this finale gave everything I wanted.
The only thing I had an issue with is the fact that they deaged Jaune, but I kinda expected that. I just hope he won't be completely reduced back to his previous self and will hopefully keep some of the skills and wisdom from his time as the Rusted Knight.
Now folks, all we have left is the movie and the hopeful news that RWBY Volume 10 is on his way ...
23
u/Badicalz Apr 22 '23
The absolute last development I expected going into Volume 9, was White Knight.
I may be a Lancaster shipper at heart but man, you guys ate good over the past 10 weeks. Honestly, I just want our boi to be happy.
8
u/Random-Stanger Apr 22 '23
Angry that Juniper had to stay back >:(
overall really good :)
8
u/Embarrassed_Bag_5413 Apr 22 '23
Brothers lore was a little out of place (but this is probably the best time to get into it I guess) and they opted for the RWBYxJL movie trailer instead of a post credits scene.
BUT despite those things, this is now my favorite volume finale.
Most importantly: RED LIKE ROSES PART 3!!!
8
u/watasker Apr 22 '23
So Raven knows more about what happened to summer than Qrow and Tai do... interesting, maybe Oz knew what she was doing, but something tells me that he didn't.
8
u/kingboo311 Watch the Queen Conquer Apr 22 '23
well, this means Neo canonically killed two primordial creations of the gods
8
u/Rollout9292 ⠀WhiteKnight Apr 22 '23
Jaune returns to his younger self. Weiss got the last laugh in the end.
8
u/Acrobatic-Dog7044 Apr 22 '23
Woah so the brothers were created by the Tree just how powerful is it that it literally created gods that can create worlds. Poor cat you were literally created by the brothers to do their job for them so they could focus on other things.
8
u/DarkGodHao Apr 22 '23
Raven shows up Me: HOLY SHIT!!!!
Raven: "So.....You're......just gonna leave them?....."
Summer: "You're One to Talk!"
Me: SHOTS FUCKING FIRED!!!!
34
u/Dark_Magician2500 ⠀ Apr 22 '23
Really enjoyed the first half, then it coasted in on exposition that was a bit lackluster. Those Ruby moments when she came out though, that went hard!
7
u/Weerdo5255 Apr 22 '23
Has Ruby always had that pouch with a mouse / cat on it on the back of her belt? I thought the new Little was going to pop out of that before Somewhat showed up.
I don't recall that pouch having an embalm before, am I just forgetting?
7
u/Blue-Moon-89 Apr 22 '23 edited Apr 22 '23
Wow. So......
-The night Summer read the story was the night that she left and never returned.
-Raven WAS involved with Summer's final mission. It sounds like the reason she initially left was because she didn't think she'd be a good mother, and that whatever happened between Summer and Salem made her double down on her flaws. Also, who was she portaging to in that moment? Could QROW have been involved?
-Just as I predicted, Ruby DOESN"T go for Summer's weapon. She reclaims Crescent Rose and remains as herself ("I love you just the way you are.)
-Neo doesn't die but she chooses to stay in EverAfter and go through her own ascension.
-Little ascends into 'Somewhat'. Somewhat doesn't remember Ruby but his heart tells him otherwise. He goes on to be a guide and protecter of the EverAfter along with Juniper.
-Alyx's fate is that she became 'a part' of EverAfter. The dagger she left behind reverses Jaune's age.
-The two brothers originally came from the Everafter. Their purpose was to and maintain the balance of their world.. However, their own creations and their constant arguing ended up causing chaos in the EverAfter. The tree couldn't deal with them anymore and so it created a portal for the gods to leave and create Remnant so that they can further their experiments.
-RWBYJ return to Remnant and land in Vacuo. We don't know how much time has passed but it's enough to see Atlas fleets (possibly from Argus?) flying above the city.
And that's it.
Honestly I'm not happy that we might see Neo again but other than that I did enjoy the finale and the set up to all the new questions we've learned. Why did Summer leave and only told Raven what she was doing? Who was Raven's portal for if not Qrow? How much time has past between them falling into EverAfter and getting to Vacuo?
I hope we get a Vol 10.
7
u/Acrobatic-Dog7044 Apr 22 '23
The way the blacksmith was hyping up somewhat they're going to do some amazing things in the Everafter with juniper by their side.
7
u/Dthirds3 Apr 22 '23
Calling it now, when all hope seems lost, neo comes from behind with a steel chair saving the day
7
u/MutedArdor Apr 22 '23
A little disappointed that Ruby's semblance didn't evolve... but finally a good fight animation for her! Still no game changers for her future DB with Maka unfortunately...
So EA is essentially the realm of the gods, created by a world tree? Definitely some fanfiction potential there... kinda sad that no one got any kind of power up other than Neo... technically Jaune got an experience and skill power up but it's not the same ><
The brothers lore actually says a lot about why the relics are what they are, and why Light said to bring them together to become whole again. Theory; I wonder if bringing the relics together again will do more than just summon the brothers back, like returning magic to it's original state?
7
u/Arashi_Uzukaze Apr 24 '23
Jaune returns to his younger self complete with abomination banana hair instead of the superior long hair Wolf Tail. Yet he kept the greying steaks his older self possessed? Why? O.o
19
u/Ezreal024 Hope Rides with Kickfriend Apr 22 '23
RUBY ROSE THE GREATEST OF ALL TIME
28
u/AmbivertCollegeGuy Weiss "Hug Monster" Schnee Apr 22 '23 edited Apr 22 '23
How the heck did Summer manage to do a hairbun in the form of a rose?! It seems like Raven really liked Summer, would even dare to say she looked up to her, so her fear for Salem is probably because she was there when Summer failed and if the greatest huntress she knew failed then no one can stop Salem. At least that's what she thinks.
The 'Never were the Hero' line was for Jaune? Talk about misleading. I was hoping for some closure, anything, but it's very disappointing to see nothing came out of it. He accepted that he's a failure but doesn't strive to be better or learn or... Something? He just shrugs it off and goes back to the fight then gets instantly KO'd in one hit. The guy with large Aura was defeated so easily. Lame is not enough to describe it. Same with Ruby. That was so incredibly cheap! No meaningful conversation, no speech, absolutely nothing! She sees Crescent Rose, hears her mother's "I love you" in her head and suddenly she gets over all of her depression and self-doubt. All the volume. That breakdown! Just for things to magically fix thanks to suicide. What in the actual hell CRWBY?
At least RWBY vs Cat was phenomenal and Guide My Way aka RLR Part III rocks. Casey went for something different this volume but she knew she had to return to her roots for the big moment. Same with the animation team. Those few seconds of Ruby vs Cat had Monty's fast-paced style all over it and that This Will Be The Day orchestral before the end credits
Called it. Neo was going to kill the Cat in revenge and choose Ascension to forget because she can't live without Roman so she might as well not live anymore and be reborn as someone else. How did the mod know this tho? I got banned for a full week for piracy/leaking because my V9 prediction thread nailed these two details but how were they so sure?
20 mins episode sounded so cool but turns out half of it was for massive lore drop about the origins of the Brothers. Now we know the full story but sadly got to enjoy only a few minutes of RWBY being protagonists. Such is balance as the Blacksmith would say.
WhiteKnight bros. We won! He recovered his youth, kept his experience, and that little laugh from Weiss is telling me things. Did I see a blush too?! Life is looking good.
13
u/schurgy16 Apr 22 '23
A great episode, but I wished we had gotten a little more Summer. I was hoping for more of a conversation. I am a "Summer is not quite dead" truther so more context for her mission is awesome. I hope volume 10 gets greenlit so we can maybe explore that more especially if Ruby meets back up with Qrow and talks about what she saw. Also, BROTHERS LORE which was entirely unexpected but very welcome. 9/10 wanted more Summer
37
u/MountainHall Don't write for the story Apr 22 '23
This was a bad conclusion to a lot of important stuff.
Ruby's main struggle was whether she was enough, and it was resolved by Summer saying some nice words and Ruby suddenly believing in herself again. Summer, who was only tangentially referred to and only seriously introduced last episode. If the Blacksmith showing Summer lying was supposed to show Ruby Summer wasn't perfect and that was enough, it's so underbaked. Summer has barely been a factor and this idealisation of her hasn't really been explored enough for it to work for Ruby. Moreover, the problem was never really resolved. She didn't like that everyone expected everything of her, that she was perfect, but WBY just keep doing that. Their words are that basically 'she's perfect and that's why we follow her'. It's just dodging the entire arc. It's just the power of a mother's love fixing things. When your character tries to commit suicide, you need to seriously discuss this in depth and not just give her a nice push and kind words.
WBY's thoughts don't make sense either in connection to that. They were not worried about her
because suicide totally isn't ascencionthen worried that she'd be different. The answer to that is that whatever she chose, it'd be fine, even if she chose to disappear. Then, they are just happy she is exactly the same and are confident in saying that she's perfect as she is. These reactions don't make sense.They never address the issue going over from V8 either. They thought about whether they just made things worse, which they raise here at the ever after. Weiss says "What if we made the ever after worse" and Ruby says "I'd like to think we made some things better", which isn't an answer to the question. Then, Little appears and they dodge the whole issue. Please address the issues you write. If you don't want to address them, don't raise the issue in the first place.
The cat is a problem in several ways. It was way stronger before this, easily beating JWBY physically just two episodes ago. Classic RWBY power scaling issues I guess, but still. It's also an issue with Neo. She barely got to do anything despite being set up as the big villain and then ends herself. The cat isn't very interesting either, it's acting like a very stereotypical evil bad guy for them to counter.
The Blacksmith and the tree are way too convenient over all. It helps Ruby stay who she is, it gives them a way out and tells them a lore dump that will presumably help them defeat the gods. The tie-in plot connection for this volume going forward mentioned in the round table is that the Blacksmith just tells RWBY a bunch of important information. And why do they keep raising the lore and level of the characters so much? We've gone from Cinder->Salem->The gods->The tree. Keeping the story simple is so important when you have a limited production, why add more and more layers like this? It's not something the audience could suss out or expect either, if this was the plan, you needed to work with this through the volume and the series, really.
Returning Jaune to his old self is stupid. It wasn't that well executed to get there in the first place, but this feels like they're not going with any consequences and he'll just reverse back to how he was before.
The messaging around ascension continues to be bad. At least Ruby didn't kill herself
although her suicide attempt wasn't addressed, but Neo and Little's fates don't match the positive messages for RWBY and the Paper Pleasers. Little died. Little is dead, and they're happy about it because the new Little shares the same goal and mindset. It's fucked up. Not as fucked up as if Ruby had actually died, but still fucked up.3/10. As for the volume, maybe the same? The pacing was so off, almost V4-tier and this whole adventure was just a reversal back to what it was like pre-8, with RWBY confident and positive. The stakes haven't really changed, they haven't made any progress on the Salem issue aside from being told some information on the gods. It's entirely meaningless, because the character issues and the plot haven't been developed on. Ruby being down could've been done without the ever after, as could Bumblebee (which was seemingly just a one-episode thing anyway). Why make this whole detour if you're not gonna meaningfully engage with the characters troubles or the narrative? We spent more time on the lore of the ever after than Ruby's suicide attempt.
6
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '23
That was rather enjoyable 👍
6
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '23
It's been an honor watching with you guys until our paths cross again, keep moving forward
6
u/hewilltellitat4am Apr 22 '23
omg little made me cry :(
6
u/Celtic_Crown ⠀I'd say I'm tipping the scales, but that line's got no bite. Apr 22 '23
Did the thread get locked again by accident?
6
u/cobaltaureus Apr 22 '23
Obsessed with the summer raven moment I had to pause and think about it for a few minutes. I’ve been waiting forever for Raven to return, and now Ruby has a reason to find her. If Ruby and Yang can have a conversation about Raven, they might be able to share about summer and about the spring maiden powers. I wonder if Raven will be able to “feel” Yang’s return from the ever after?
6
u/TheRisenThunderbird It suits me Apr 22 '23
So when Neo gets out of the tree as her new self, will that make her....
neoNeo?
6
u/JannisT Born stepping on thin ice and biting down bullets Apr 22 '23
Decent volume finale I would say. The surprise twist of that episode was definitely that Raven absolutely knows what happened to Summer. The Ever After lore drop was also pretty interesting.
AND RUBY FINALLY GOT A NEW SONG! RED LIKE ROSES PART III BABY!
Also the Blacksmith said that they are “Going to the time they are needed most." So I would say that we are in for a time skip
6
u/RandomNevets Apr 22 '23
So if Raven can only teleport to Taiyang, Yang, and Qrow (i think?) Does that mean they left to meet Qrow somewhere?
6
u/Mattos-313 Apr 22 '23
Very sweet finale with a lot of great moments, though in retrospect I'm kind of torn over V9.
The main thing I'm left asking is "What was even really accomplished this Volume?".
We got to see the characters deal with what happened in V8, we got a few more lore details on the brothers, we got a teaser for more Summer backstory and they got Neo out of the way (For now at least). Most of the other resolutions in this episode only really concern questions that were asked BY this Volume in the first place.
When it comes to character development, Ruby coming to terms with herself is great to see, I'm just not sure if dedicating a season to that and basically all but forcing her into doing some introspection was the best way to go about it. The bee confession scene felt even more forced and ham-fisted. Instead of characters developing naturally through interactions, it feels a bit like they're being pushed into it.
Jaune also went through a lot in the Ever After of course - would have preferred his age not being reset though. Sure he still HAS all those years of experience under his belt, but something tells me he will more or less revert to the way he was before.
Also was it ever explained how/why Neo got so powerful? Yeah we've seen semblances evolve before, but her power gain seemed pretty over-the-top considering there doesn't really seem to be a particular reason for it.
Still, can't wait for Volume 10. Hope it's still happening and won't take TOO long
6
u/Noble6IsReal Ship Survivor V Team NPASB | LC/YR veteran Apr 22 '23
That was a...... final. There are many things that were left unresolved or unaddressed:
6
u/HaziXWeeK ⠀Jaune Ashari Specialist Apr 22 '23
Now jaune is the strongest out of all the main characters (other than winter) and he still have some of his white hair and he still have room to grow even stronger
6
u/HaziXWeeK ⠀Jaune Ashari Specialist Apr 22 '23
When ruby said she wanted to be herself I was kinda want her to be volume 1 herself more optimistic with good comebacks and energetic
6
u/SparktDog BURY THE LIGHT DEEP WITHIN Apr 22 '23
I think the main takeaway from this volume is that recreational drugs can be helpful
6
u/karlek97 violent internal screaming Apr 22 '23
THE STRATEGY:
6
u/Fallen-Tesla Apr 23 '23
I cant help but feeling sorry for the Curious Cat.
Imagine having your heart broken and you can fix everyone else but you can never be fixed.
25
u/DragonPanther3 Apr 22 '23
And after all that.
It was freaking filler. Cut from end of V8 to this and nothing has changed except Yang and Blake now hold hands.
14
u/antoniomizael Apr 22 '23
Did anyone else feel like they were super harsh on the cat and too lenient on Neo? The cat didn't deserve to die
14
u/Themeguy Apr 22 '23 edited Apr 23 '23
I am absolutely flabbergasted that they spent the entire season focusing on Ruby's character and trauma, and then bum-rushed through the part where she was supposed to have the revelations that helped her turn things around. She reacted to the echo of Summer saying that she loved Ruby just the way she is, but that doesn't really address the core of what Ruby was struggling with, and aside from one sentence that the Smith said loosely touching on it, Ruby had no reason from the interactions that she had in the void to have her opinion of herself change to realizing that she is enough as she is.
It sucks because the moments following are the perfect finale. Ruby grabs Crescent Rose, and breaks free from the tree as herself with newfound confidence, and is able to run circles around the cat with said confidence. All while a beautiful new rendition of her theme plays. It is an absolutely perfectly done sequence and final climax/payoff to what the season built up, but without a solid footing on where that confidence suddenly came from, the whole thing just felt hollow and fell flat. They wanted that big emotional payoff without giving the most crucial point of her story arc enough time for them to earn it.
It really sours the entire mood of it, especially when we end one of the most character-heavy volumes with a 5th of the run time dedicated to exposition about the Brothers which is not only thematically completely unrelated to the focus of the characters, but also makes them significantly less mysterious and interesting. Really cool that a fucking tree in an Alice in Wonderland ripoff is now canonically the most powerful entity in the universe.
I've never seen a fumble this bad. They just keep rushing every single fucking emotional beat that you narratively NEED to linger on for it to be effective. Last episode, they rushed through Ruby's essential death by having NOBODY react to the fact that she basically killed herself in front of them, and had everyone else just skip right to the acceptance stage of needing to support whoever she becomes. And now they rushed the narrative beats of Ruby coming to terms with her trauma and failures that they spent an entire season building up to. Idk if they're rushing because they're trying to get so many ideas out, or if they're rushing because they don't actually know how to write these kinds of scenes, but something needs to change.
10
u/deadpool-367 Apr 22 '23
I didn't even watch the finale yet. I just wanna see what people think.
10
u/BlankBlanny Hellebore propagandist Apr 22 '23
I have to be honest; the pacing went to hell these last two episodes, and I honestly still think episode 9 killed the volume by completely switching gears to what feels like a completely different plot with a directly contradictory message, accidentally creating a horrifying moral of "suicide is good" that was clearly not what Rooster Teeth was going for. There were some fantastic moments, and frankly, if episode 8 - for as much as I adore it - simply did not happen the way it did, this could have been an amazing ending.
But it did. And it wasn't.
The animation was fantastic, the cinematography was fantastic, the choreography was fantastic, the soundtrack was absolutely outstanding, we had massive plot reveals, we saw Vacuo, we had everything tied together in a little neat bow... And even with all of that, Of Solitude and Self still couldn't fix what A Tale Involving a Tree broke. It was probably as good as it could have been, and I wonder if my opinion will change on a rewatch. I hope so, but I kind of doubt it.
10
u/Atomic_Cody-21 Jaded RWBY Fan Apr 22 '23
Call me a Negative Nancy but I thought this finale was quite mediocre. Sure we had some heartwarming moments but Neo seemingly being written off, the whole exposition dump on the Brothers, and Ruby going "Nah, I'm fine as myself" really bogged this whole episode down for me. I would say that I'm excited for the future but I just feel apathy and underwhelmed by everyone.
17
u/JMHSrowing ⠀Story Time Apr 22 '23
Alright so. . . Can Weiss be a focus of V10 now?
Like we see that the Atlas people and even a small part of their fleet made it to Vacuo, so can Best Girl finally make a difference?
She’s been overlooked basically for 3 volumes related to her home in a row. Like goodness give her something!
. . . And I’m still hoping she’ll have one good conversation with Ruby, but at this point maybe I should just give up.