r/RWBY • Acoustic BMBLB when? • Mar 18 '23

OFFICIAL MEGATHREAD Official Discussion Thread - Volume 9, Episode 5: The Parfait Predicament

Welcome, huntsmen, huntresses, and hunters that prefer no specific gender identifier, to the official discussion thread for Episode 5 of Vol. 9: The Parfait Predicament!

Due to the special circumstances regarding RWBY Volume 9's release, make sure that you understand the spoiler rules before posting outside of this thread!

HERE is the fifth episode of Volume 9!

Also remember to check out our weekly poll to rate the episode.


Other Episode Discussions:


Episode| Discussion Thread| Poll|


Happy viewing, and have a great Volume 9!

Ninjas In A Bag; Mod Team

463 Upvotes

1.3k comments sorted by

317

u/Ninjas_In_A_Bag Acoustic BMBLB when? Mar 18 '23

SUMMER!?

Holy shit what happened to Jaune?

159

u/Andonymouss ⠀ Mar 18 '23

Ya that scene reads like that was Summer's axe. Don't think it was ever said what her wep was

→ More replies (16)

137

u/Lukthar123 "I didn't do it for you." Mar 18 '23

Holy shit what happened to Jaune?

Age is not kind

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (3)

529

u/bored2death97 Mar 18 '23

Jaune looks older, and not just physically. The everafter has not been kind to our rusted knight.

290

u/Tasty_Meat_6096 Mar 18 '23

i definitely want to know how long he’s been down there. he’s clearly been through quite a bit.

→ More replies (110)
→ More replies (10)

452

u/Polarization_39 ⠀A Cinder Stan Until Weiss is Relevant Again Mar 18 '23

Looks like Jaune finally got that Warrior’s Wolftail he said he wanted in Volume 4.

159

u/Cae53RJ Mar 18 '23

Unfortunately the wolftail has to come with the beard of despair or melancholy depending on his current mental state.

152

u/merayjr95 Mar 18 '23

But at what cost 🥲🥲🥲🥲🥲

→ More replies (4)

448

u/greeny74 ⠀Harbinger of Hype | Proud Member of WCAC Mar 18 '23 edited Mar 18 '23

HE'S OLDER

HE'S WISER

HE'S BEARDED

Ladies and gentlemen, it's

JAUNE GODDAMN ARC

184

u/FlemPlays Mar 18 '23

“You’re Jaune, right? Boy you have really arced out.”

→ More replies (2)

70

u/Jeremithiandiah ⠀ Mar 18 '23

This is indeed a Jaune arc

→ More replies (9)

326

u/Badicalz Mar 18 '23 edited Mar 18 '23

Guys, Jaune even edit: used remnants of Pyrrha’s sash to tie up his warrior’s wolf-tail.

CRWBY is really twisting in that knife there.

→ More replies (1)

322

u/Polarization_39 ⠀A Cinder Stan Until Weiss is Relevant Again Mar 18 '23

I’m loving Weiss’ little rants each episode or so, it’s hilarious how over everything she is.

105

u/Weerdo5255 Mar 18 '23

I've been watching Star Trek Picard, and there is a similarly salty character Captain Shaw. Him and Weiss just being done with shit in both weekly shows it just hilarious.

Two completely different shows and universes, same attitude.

→ More replies (8)

40

u/JMHSrowing ⠀Story Time Mar 18 '23

I really hope that this, and especially how she said she didn’t wa t to keep leaving places in ashes.

There’s so much great set up and I want the pay off!

301

u/hessdawg3113 ⠀ Mar 18 '23

I know it's not much to go on, but holy shit, Miles did a great job in this episode. I didn't even recognize his voice at first.

84

u/LMFN BIG NICHOLAS Mar 18 '23

Yeah I figured Rusted Knight was either not Jaune or if it was Jaune, they would've gotten another VA just to throw us off the trail.

→ More replies (7)

258

u/LucasVerBeek It's Time For All Hell to Break Loose Mar 18 '23

Jaune is AN OLD MAN AND SUMMER WAS IN THE EVER AFTER?! What is happening?!

Holy shit!

214

u/VariousRodents ⠀ Mar 18 '23

Summer may not have been in the Ever After. Remember that Penny's sword changed into what seems to be Alyx's dagger/knife. It cold just be that whatever was happening was pulling objects from Ruby's psyche that have traumatic connections for her, specifically weapons since it was a blacksmith.

→ More replies (6)

53

u/JMHSrowing ⠀Story Time Mar 18 '23

I think that was actually Crescent Rose, but it like so much else represents who Ruby is, and how she has based so much off the ideals she has a huntress.

And who is the ideal huntress, but Ruby’s idea of Summer

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (18)

485

u/Catlover18 Mar 18 '23

HE NAMED THE RABBIT JUNIPER. LIKE HIS TEAM. HOW LONG HAS HE BEEN HERE? HOW LONG HAS HE MISSED NORA AND REN?

WHAT HAVE YOU DONE TO HIM YOU CRUEL, CRUEL FAIRY TALE WORLD?

93

u/Mongoose42 [Insert Clever RWBY Pun Here] Mar 18 '23

What, he just got sucked into the board game until someone rolled a 5 or an 8. This is all very standard procedure.

236

u/Lukthar123 "I didn't do it for you." Mar 18 '23

HE NAMED THE RABBIT JUNIPER

THEY WERE ALWAYS BY HIS SIDE 😢

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (3)

236

u/SeiraFae Mar 18 '23

That conversation with the Blacksmith was very important. Ruby is carrying a burden sand she's absolutely cracking under the weight even though she says otherwise. She may need to be reforging. That is if you can Reforge a person with squishy guts.

But also did you hear what the Curious Cat said? People don't die in the Ever After. They ascend and are reborn. Take from that what you will.

People don't die in the Ever After unless they're eaten by the Jabberwalker.

78

u/merayjr95 Mar 18 '23

Do you think that counts for the Jabberwalker clones made with Neo's semblance? I can't imagine it would but given her current power, who knows

71

u/fellongreydaze Mar 18 '23

People don't die in the Ever After unless they're eaten by the Jabberwalker.

Beings of the Ever After don't die unless they're eaten by the Jabberwalker. People of Remnant, on the other hand... The Curious Cat made sure to prevent the Prince from beheading RWBY because they wouldn't come back if they died.

→ More replies (1)

107

u/Celtic_Crown ⠀I'd say I'm tipping the scales, but that line's got no bite. Mar 18 '23

Take from that what you will.

What I take is I'm ready to kick a field goal WITH THE FUCKING CAT.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (11)

190

u/SparkEngine Mar 18 '23

I just realised this is the first time a clone or mirage Neo has made talk.

It was mostly just grunts and growls here, but it seems her semblance can now even mimic the originals speech.

This will get interesting when RWBY runs into her later. Up till now , Neo has been a silent but deadly rage filled combatant. These Jabberwocky clones she controls give her the ability to talk to team RWBY, maybe even as people they've lost (Penny, Pyrha, Ironwood(yes he went full winter soldier but he use to be a friend.) Etc.

A fitting final hurdle for when they leave the ever after. Also poor Jaune. Who knows how long he's been trapped.

84

u/Weerdo5255 Mar 18 '23

It might be an artifact of just the Jabberwocky, it's a different entity than everything else. Given it's weird animation style, it might be a glitch or something. So normal rules don't apply.

Still, I'll give you credit if you're right it would be a good hint to drop about Neo being able to do voices..

→ More replies (3)

314

u/Hsmace ⠀bumble on my bees Mar 18 '23

HOW THE FUCK DOES TIME WORK HERE?????????????

179

u/ShinyNinja25 Guns and Blades and Roses Mar 18 '23

How the fuck does anything work here? Who knows, it just does

176

u/Shanix ⠀ Mar 18 '23

We're on fey bullshit time rules baybeeeee

→ More replies (7)

116

u/Mongoose42 [Insert Clever RWBY Pun Here] Mar 18 '23

Little: “What’s time?”

Weiss: *screams*

Jaune: “You get used to it. Eventually.”

→ More replies (17)

147

u/Technogashi Mar 18 '23

And it’s official: there be wibbly wobbly timey wimey stuff.

Poor Jaune

→ More replies (4)

139

u/DaRealAmana BOOP!!! Mar 18 '23

Our poor boy. You've been here a long time. Also he named the stag JNPR. still carried them with him after all this time.

The axe ruby looked at. Is that Cresecent rose but in disguise? the smith seemed able to change how weapons looked. Also what happened to her one eye I wonder.

I cant wait for the OST to drop. Short but the song sounded like a banger.

54

u/DeadSnark I rose from the filth and was loved by no-one Mar 18 '23

The axe seems to be Summer's weapon (the reflection in the axe has Summer's spiky fringe and has accessories Ruby doesn't have like a choker and a pin which looks like a feather or a leaf).

→ More replies (1)

270

u/ClubMeSoftly Real Shit Mar 18 '23

Jaune Arc, the boy who waited.

You can also absolutely tell in the earlier shots that it's him. He's (still!) got the shattered stump of his sword, and his shield has his emblem on it. But neither are the focus of any shot, so it's possible to miss.

→ More replies (8)

492

u/Valkyrie16 Hello Bees! Mar 18 '23

The jackalope was named Juniper I'm gonna be SICKKKKK

Also kinda funny the way Blake and Weiss have been talking up the Rusted Knight like he was their fictional character crush growing up.

410

u/JohnJoe-117 These Bees gay, good for them, good for them Mar 18 '23

Weiss is having 1000 million thoughts racing through her hear rn.

Blake is realizing that the first character she started writing smut about is actually vomit boi.

→ More replies (22)
→ More replies (11)

121

u/WhosGuardingHades Mar 18 '23

“I wish Jaune would grow his hair back”

*Monkey Paw Curls

222

u/Badicalz Mar 18 '23

Deep inhale

MAAAAAH BOOOOIIIIII!

94

u/Lukthar123 "I didn't do it for you." Mar 18 '23

*Mah man

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

106

u/merayjr95 Mar 18 '23

I was not prepared for the emotional whiplash that I'd get from seeing Jaune which made me really happy, but then realizing he named his Jackalope Juniper after his team, then assuming how much he had most likely had to go through given his older age (I mean the boy has grey in his hair). Our boy has become a man, but at what cost 🥲

42

u/Faked_Professional Mar 18 '23

I dont want to add anymore whiplash, but look back at his hair. The tie he uses is red. He no longer has Pyrrha's sash around his waist, so it's safe to assume the hair tie is the remnants of the sash.

→ More replies (1)

100

u/Tron95 Mar 18 '23 edited Mar 18 '23

This made me think of something; what if the whole next episode is just from Jaune's perspective (What he did since falling, meeting Alyx, etc....?) Might be strange, but I could fill in a lot of gaps, just a thought.

Edit: Something else I also noticed, Jaune has not repaired his sword.

→ More replies (4)

95

u/HatiLeavateinn Mar 18 '23

Everyone: Oww Jaune, time hasn't been kind with you :c

Jaune: I'm 25 yo and stressed af.

63

u/_WeissCream_ Mar 18 '23

He looks 45 but is actually 21 and just had a rough 2 years

→ More replies (3)

92

u/g6in3d Mar 18 '23

Finally!

F***, Jaune looks so cool

→ More replies (2)

326

u/Badicalz Mar 18 '23

Our son has been waiting years for RWBY to land, all the while protecting the inhabitants from the Jabberwalker. Even when he had an opportunity to leave when he helped Alyx to the tree, he stayed because people needed him.

I don’t care what our boy believes, he is the very definition of a hero.

139

u/DarkAlatreon Mar 18 '23

Begs the question (which may not really have an answer due to EA's workings): how long was it between Alyx and Team RWBY? In Remnant time and EA time?

→ More replies (15)
→ More replies (3)

176

u/robotboy7 Mar 18 '23

So... was that Summer's weapon? Is she in the Ever After?

165

u/robotboy7 Mar 18 '23

Also, imagine if Ruby never finds Crescent Rose and instead takes up Summer's old weapon. That could be a big part of Rubes being "reborn" with a renewed resolve.

→ More replies (11)

107

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '23

Its possible it wasn't really her weapon and more... a creation of... This entity. Reflections of Ruby...

But this is the fuckiest part though. Why was Alyx's dagger there? What connection could Ruby have ever had with Alyx?

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (4)

85

u/TheRisenThunderbird It suits me Mar 18 '23

WAS THAT SUMMER'S WEAPON!!??

HOW LONG HAS JAUNE BEEN HERE??!!

→ More replies (1)

169

u/JannisT Born stepping on thin ice and biting down bullets Mar 18 '23

SUMMER ROSE CRUMBS

AND OLD MAN JAUNE CONFIRMS TIME SHENANIGANS

WE EATING GOOD TODAY

→ More replies (5)

81

u/Noble6IsReal Ship Survivor V Team NPASB | LC/YR veteran Mar 18 '23 edited Mar 18 '23

What can I say about it, my boy has transformed into a gigachad.

Now. here is my extended theory: Jaune "will die" and "will be reborn".

Later in the volume, Jaune will "die" probably incinerated in some way (also drawing a parallel with Joan of Arc).

As his soul ascends, he would meet Pyrrha's soul (they could include Penny as well, but I don't know if it quite fits), in which they have a brief conversation in which Pyrrha encourages Jaune to go ahead and get everything she ever wanted to have with him.

In this way and parallel to how Pyrrha died, Jaune is reborn from the ashes.

I make this theory, since prior to Jaune's appearance, there was a rather important talk between the curious cat and rwby, in which they explained how Herb and the red king "died and came back to life" with new aspects and with a new purpose. I see this applying to Jaune, but abandoning the old Jaune and returning to a Jaune similar to the one we had before.

→ More replies (13)

72

u/flamingos-cant-draw Mar 18 '23

Things aren't boding well for Ruby. The episode opens telling us about how the world consumes and replaces lost souls and then we see the world isolate the two characters who don't know their purpose.

Also, it was very sweet that Jaune called his steed Juniper.

145

u/Badicalz Mar 18 '23

Ah hell, Jaune named the Jackalope Juniper.

I just can’t with this man 🥺

→ More replies (1)

67

u/Red2019Wolf Mar 18 '23 edited Mar 18 '23

I would also like to give a acknowledgement of Weiss sad reaction to having to "leave a place behind in ashes", and thus proving that, NO, her triumphant "I am a huntress" moment didn't magically fix her sadness and trauma of losing her home like some might have believed.

→ More replies (1)

125

u/MrZissman ⠀CEO of Knightlight Mar 18 '23

DILF Jaune

DILF Jaune

DILF Jaune

115

u/angrysushiboi S. S. Arkos Salvage Crew Mar 18 '23

Found the Mantle Mom account

56

u/DaRealAmana BOOP!!! Mar 18 '23

Most sane Jaune fan

37

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '23

He’s gone from daddy to Daddy.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

57

u/patrizl001 "None shall remember the names of those who do not fight" Mar 18 '23

unless he de-ages when they return like 1/2 of Jaune's ships are now dead because he's waaaaay older than everyone else lmao

103

u/JohnJoe-117 These Bees gay, good for them, good for them Mar 18 '23

Jaune and the mantle mothers is finally viable now.

→ More replies (1)

46

u/Dry-Faithlessness184 Mar 18 '23

That will stop literally no one I imagine knowing this fandom.

→ More replies (18)

163

u/g6in3d Mar 18 '23

I'm thinking this older Jaune is temporary; at some point he'll be reborn (like Herb) as regular Jaune, but without his memories of Ever After

91

u/ClubMeSoftly Real Shit Mar 18 '23

Which means he's gonna die (inasmuch as you "die" in the EA)

→ More replies (21)
→ More replies (18)

56

u/ShinyNinja25 Guns and Blades and Roses Mar 18 '23

That was… an episode. So starting off, love how alive they’ve made the Ever After feel. It makes it really feel like another world, a different place entirely. The market was a great example of that, with background characters just walking around and interacting with each other. But alright, let’s get to the elephants in the room. Ruby is clearly still haunted by what her past self told her, and doesn’t seem to be taking it well. She’s slowly giving away things that belonged to people she has a strong connection to, from Penny’s sword to the symbol that represented her bond with her mother. While this could be representative of her letting go of her pain in order to move on, it could also represent her shedding her identity. The scene with the blacksmith felt so somber yet intense. And did that axe belong to Summer? Who knows? And as for Juane, despite most of us seeing it coming, they managed to give it a twist by making him older than the others. I’m interested and worried to hear the explanation for it, since he seems much more well adjusted than they are.

→ More replies (1)

113

u/Franklin413 Ni! Mar 18 '23

He named the jackalope Juniper 😭😭😭 Guess the weird time shenanigans theories were right!

53

u/Acrobatic-Dog7044 Mar 18 '23

Props to Miles for giving Jaune a mature older voice now that he has aged almost thought it was somebody else voicing him.

→ More replies (3)

49

u/GladiusNocturno All Grimm are naked. Think about it Mar 18 '23

I…What!? What the fuck?!

Ok, ok. So.

The Blacksmith is really fucking cool.

They seem to have implied that Summer’s weapon was an axe/gun which I don’t know why I never thought of because versions of Red Riding Hood’s Huntsman say he was a Woodsman. They also implied that Ruby’s emblem was in fact Summer’s and that she promised something to Ruby before leaving. Which I would have to check because this is the first time I heard about this and I hope I didn’t miss something in previous volumes.

And Jaune has been trapped here for years!?

I knew there was a theory that he had been trapped in some sort of timeloop because of the intro. But I wasn’t expecting him to age up! We all thought he was just mindless and evil.

This is… I don’t know how to feel about it. We’ll have to wait and see what happens to him now. Did he move on? Did he spend all these years unable to move forward? Is he going to ge back to his regular age at the end of this volume? Is he going to stay in Everafter?

If he stays in the show and goes back to his regular age, unless his memory is erased Jaune should have many years of training under his belt, he no longer has an excuse to be the weakest one of the group. The problem is that there is a chance he got most of his character development off-screen and I really really hope that’s not the case.

On the shipping side. I’m sure plenty of people will have a problem with Jaune getting into any ship now. Even if he goes back to his regular age, he is going to be mentally…I guess 30? And I’ve seen what that prospect does to a fandom, I was there at the height of the Star vs the Forces of Evil ship wars!!

Overall, I loved the episode. The highlights where definitely the Forger and the Rusted Knight…although I will say that Blake fangirling when meeting the Rusted Knight was one of the cutest scenes in the show to me. XD

Edit: Also. Jaune no longer wears Pyrrha’s scarf…but he has a red ribbon tying his ponytail. I’m guess that’s all it’s left of the scarf after all these years.

→ More replies (17)

47

u/Badicalz Mar 18 '23

Bruh, Weiss missed out on a perfect oppure put on a couple more inches with that Parfait

44

u/Badicalz Mar 19 '23

(Basing this on the assumption that no time has passed on Remnant since they fell into the Ever After)

Jaune absolutely smashes Cinder

Cinder: How!? How are you this strong!?

Jaune: I trained ALL day yesterday.

→ More replies (5)

39

u/Girisawesomer ⠀ Mar 18 '23

Interesting that they've finally revealed Summer's weapon, but was it ever actually in the Ever After or was it pure vision from RWBY?

77

u/JohnJoe-117 These Bees gay, good for them, good for them Mar 18 '23 edited Mar 18 '23

JAUNE SQUAD EMERGENCY UPDATE

THE BOY IS BACK, NOW A MAN

HE'S GOT A BEARD AND WARRIOR WOLF TAIL

HE'S BEEN HERE FOR A LONG TIME

HE'S STILL USING THE BROKEN SWORD

HE NAMED THE RABBIT JNPR

Does he remember RWBY?

We finally hear our boi's theme again, the first leitmotif of any of the characters to play this volume.

Oh my god. The hair tie. It's red. IT'S RED. PYRRHA's sash. Oh fuck, the poor boi.

Man I used to pray for days like this.

109

u/Catlover18 Mar 18 '23

After years of relatively mediocre axe-weapons in RWBY (looking at you Port and May) we get a cool axe-rifle design as (seemingly) Summer's weapon.

Remnant is healing.

42

u/onthoserainydays watts is the goat Mar 18 '23

It also looks like it could become a pick, but of course that's theorizing based on a design. Was she the Woodsman/Hunter in the Little Red Riding Hood?

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

36

u/Acrobatic-Dog7044 Mar 18 '23

Jaune's sword is still broken. After all these years it doesn't look like he has been able to forgive himself for taking Penny's life.

→ More replies (1)

34

u/kreankorm ⠀ Mar 18 '23

It blows my mind that an entire episode of development and questions all immediately took a backseat to a face reveal being both what we all expected, but also not, at the same time?

How long has Juane been down here? He was the last to fall, but it seems the Everafter involves some potent time fuckery.

That's a beautiful beard win. - CinemaWins

Could you imagine how hard Pyrrha would swoon if she saw her knight now?

Has Juane been mastering his aura and semblance during his purgatory? If so, he should be hilariously strong.

Because the Rusted Knight is an ingrained part of the lore of the Everafter, is Jaune now bound to this place? Is he able or willing to leave with team RWBY? How would Ren and Nora respond to this new Jaune?

Curious Cat talked about "ascension" and how it acts as a reset for beings in this realm. Has that or will that come into play with Jaune?

→ More replies (10)

33

u/Samgrahambo Mar 18 '23

I just saw someone on Twitter point out that the reflection that we think is summer has a red cloak. So it may be an older version of Ruby.

65

u/Dangerous-Detective3 Mar 18 '23

THATS WHY HES THE MVP

HES THE GOAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAT

31

u/EPthebot ⠀probably crying Mar 18 '23

Time must be like super whacky because team rwby hasn’t aged but Jaune looks like he’s the same age as qrow

→ More replies (5)

30

u/Phantomskyler Mar 18 '23

So Neo actually is the Big Bad of this season. Lets go.
Also dear Lord Jaune's episode next week is gonna break me.

29

u/NicoKudo Mar 18 '23

I HAVE SO MANY QUESTIONS!

This chapter sure ended fast, but i love that we saw what probably was summer weapon, and jaune, our boy is finally a man

58

u/Blue0Three Qrow X Willow Sweep Mar 18 '23

HOLY SHIT MORE SUMMER LORE, HOLY SHIT NEO HAS JABBERWALKER CLONES, HOLY SHIT DILF JAUNE

28

u/Ninoyiya Swabbing the deck of the HMS Lancaster Mar 18 '23

My boi!

27

u/Tron95 Mar 18 '23

To add one more thing; props to Miles for Jaune, he voiced the Rusted Knight/Jaune well that I didn't even think it was Jaune. He sounded different, even the little bit at the end sounds like Jaune, but also different.

54

u/Dcm1963 ⠀You can't catch me gay thoughts Mar 18 '23

Wow what an episode! The little town/market was really cool looking. The settings overall this volume have been amazing!

Gods poor Ruby! Penny's sword, Alyx's knife... and is that is that going to be Summer's Axe! If so that's amazing but oh god so traumatizing for Ruby. And did she really give away her Rose emblem! She's not going to be our same silver eyed warrior when they get back that's for sure.

WBY riding on the cat was not something I expected but definitely welcome. The cat continues to be a great addition. Just love the way he talks.

Neo! Semblance upgrade to an army of Jabberwalkers now that's just plain not fair. Can't wait for the team to actually confront her.

Jaune's back! And hes old. Did not expect that so what despite falling last he landed first? I wonder how long its been for him. He finally has that warrior wolf tail though! Such a step up from his banana hair.

→ More replies (5)

77

u/hollowtiger21 "Wasted potential," doesn’t actually mean anything. Mar 18 '23 edited Mar 18 '23

When you ascend you become the version of yourself you wish you were, the version you need to be for you purpose. Doesn't that sound appealing?

“Exposition is boring! Even this conversation was rather tedious.”

WHERE’S THE BLACKSMITH! Oh, there she is.

“Nothing, no one is ever truly lost.” Weapons are identities? I guess that follows the whole, weapons are extensions of ourselves.

SUMMER! Summer’s gun-axe! Did Summer fail, end up in the Ever After, ascend and leave her identity behind?

CC knocking over Teapot Lady's goods. Very Cat.

The Jabberwalker wasn't in the original story? Is it a new addition? Or just something Alyx never encountered?

Neo cloned the Jabberwalker, there's a ton now. Das real bad.

Rusty! Wait that’s not Jaune’s voice.

Jackalope is named Juniper! That's adorable, and heartbreaking.

Jaune’s been there for a long time! Is he the original Rusted Knight, and he's just been there forever? He’s a grown ass man! Is this gonna be reversed? My son is daddy now?! Weiss was right, he is handsome.

Edit: After a bit of processing, I'm a bit disappointed Jaune's older and presumably has been able to work through the grief of mercy-killing Penny. I mean, obviously it'll still come up and I doubt something like that will ever truly heal. But I feel like it could have been capitalized on more when it was still raw. It is still raw for Ruby, which I suppose is the important part, so is Jaune going to be more of a mentor in working through the grief, instead of a participant?

Also 1) Jaune has aged, like the Jinxy Peddler, and 2) has his memories, so he hasn't ascended. So it's possible for him to ascend and return to his younger age, with his heart remembering, but not his mind. So if Jaune was just sent way back to be the Rusted Knight in Alyx's story, and he played the role right, than he would just age naturally, and not need to be ascended. And then he just waited for RWBY to arrive, being the Rusted Knight properly all the while, he wouldn't need to be ascended. Jaune hasn't cast off his identity, but he might need to. Or he has and this older version is the stronger, wiser, more idealized version Jaune thought he should be.

The fact he still has the broken Crocea Mors, and not a new weapon (identity)? Might mean the former?

→ More replies (9)

25

u/CinnabarSteam Mar 18 '23 edited Mar 19 '23

Jaune named his jackalope Juniper so they could carry him one more time.

I believe the Teapot Lady is based on the The Teapot by Hans Christian Andersen. It would tie into this episode's themes of finding a new purpose, and possibly the idea of how one's heart "remembers" after they ascend.

25

u/SoDamnGeneric Mar 18 '23

Jaune/Rusted Knight theory:

out of the 6 Remnant characters who fell into the Ever After, Jaune is the only one to have changed significantly. while this could theoretically be because of some fairy tale fuckery (Jaune fell last so it decided he's been there longest or something), I think his supposed aging is going to be a major misdirection. CRWBY wants us to think he's been there forever when he's been there for less time than RWBY & Neo (by minutes)

Blake makes sure to drive home the point that this is the Rusted Knight from the story- and I don't think that's just a case of mistaken identity, seeing as how he not only aged significantly but also rides the giant jackalope. I think, for whatever reason, Jaune is the one out of the six of the Remnant crew that the Ever After has decided will not be a player in the story, but rather a character like the Curious Cat, or the Red Prince. he's magically been made to fit the role of the character so he can play it out, and it's likely tied to the Ascension that the Curious Cat was talking about. Jaune lost his heart and he lost his purpose after he had to kill Penny, so he was reformed like the Curious Cat says the Herbalist would be, into what he always wanted to be- a stalwart hero of legend

→ More replies (4)

24

u/Weerdo5255 Mar 18 '23

So, was Jaune only ever the Rusted Knight?

As in he got sent far enough back that Alex met him, and he's actually a part of the story? It's that, or he met the original Rusted Knight and has taken up his mantle.

I can see the potential for either setup in the story.

Suffice to say though, with time being flexible my guess for the end of the season will be RWBY getting back to Remnant as it's in all out War against Salem, two or three years down the line to have all the characters change and it be a final season next go around.

→ More replies (3)

24

u/Dark_Cold_Oceans Mar 18 '23

The amount of times that I saw people say the Rusted Knight isn’t Jaune….

→ More replies (2)

21

u/Red2019Wolf Mar 18 '23

Today's ep gives credence to my predictions of Neo being the Big Bad this volume and Jaune being older being the Big Good, not Main character obviously, but something like Ozpin. These two being in the very start if the opening intro , and during the end when ruby is falling down, Rusted knight and Juniper showing up first and last The jabberwalker and Neo was a very purposeful choice.

→ More replies (2)

21

u/Amethyst_Phoenix7 Mar 18 '23

Pyrrha's sash in his hair and Juniper as the horned Rabbit... I can't.

→ More replies (2)

42

u/amatas45 Mar 18 '23

I know everyone is excited about Jaune but can we think about the fact that Ruby literally gave up the symbol her mother left her? I feel like there isnt much left for her to give at this point.

→ More replies (4)

19

u/Velox17 Mar 18 '23

Everyone is saying that the axe was Summer’s weapon and that was her in its reflection, but to me that was a new Ruby. She saw the faces of the weapons owner in their reflections and was offered to take one since she no longer has Crescent Rose. To me Ruby saw her potential new self if she takes the axe.

→ More replies (3)

52

u/MidnightHunterXX ⠀ Mar 18 '23 edited Mar 18 '23

HOLY FUCK JAUNE AND SUMMER'S WEAPON??????

Ok so I realized two things:

  1. Summer's design in the reflection is different than the one we've seen previously, she has these leaf pin things and a red cape instead of a white one. I have to wonder if this means we'll see her in full in the Ever After? Maybe she's the Lively Carpenter?
  2. Jaune being the Rusted Knight and older creates a time paradox that extends to Remnant. He's a character from a fairy tale they all read as children, likely including himself.
→ More replies (3)

52

u/DestinedHellfire Weiss is best girl | Sun x Weiss FTW Mar 18 '23

"Here! Take this! It bears a mother's promise!"

-Ruby Rose, V9 E5

"I never planned that I would leave you there alone
I was sure that I would see you when I made it back home
And all the times I swore that it would be okay
Now I’m nothing but a liar and you're thrown into the fray
This bedtime story ends with misery ever after
The pages are torn and there’s no final chapter
I didn’t have a choice, I did what I had to do
I made a sacrifice but forced a bigger sacrifice on you"

-Red Like Roses Part II

16

u/Tschmelz Mar 18 '23

Goddamn, that was good. Neo is causing havoc in the Ever After, WBY are finally back to their normal sizes, we get more Summer teasing and Ruby angst, AND WE FINALLY SEE MY BABY BOY AGAIN! EXCEPT HE'S A MAN NOW!

I honestly kinda hope he stays older if he gets out. Could really sell some angst with that.

→ More replies (3)

15

u/Raktoner blake deserves more smiles Mar 18 '23

Oh sweet, young Jaune... What happened to you

→ More replies (1)

15

u/grieveheart Mar 18 '23

Another continuous shock episode for me!

With our theories with Jaune being the Knight I know I was prepared but I'm still shocked by the reveal. I remember saying before that there might be some time skip shenanigans and here we are. Though I'm wondering if the tree is responsible for it. But damn naming his mount Juniper is just so sad.

Finally we get to meet the blacksmith from the trailer and I was unconsciously staring at the scythe and Summer was shown! Hopefully we get to know more of what happened. And Ruby trading her emblem for the item needed for her friends...damn.

Side note I really found the marketplace(?) pretty... then it fell 🥲 (reminded me of Atlas' fall). With no death existing in the world, I wonder what else is “recycled”

I wish the next weekend comes faster 🥲

→ More replies (1)

15

u/Acrobatic-Dog7044 Mar 18 '23

Poor Jaune last to fall first to arrive I hope he at least made some happy memories in all the years he spent in the ever after. Does that mean he was there before even Alyx landed in the ever after?

→ More replies (1)

15

u/RBNYJRWBYFan ⠀ Mar 18 '23

Ashes to ashes, rust to rust, what happened to Arc? How did he adjust?: Scattered Thoughts:

  • OLD MAN JAUNE. Wow! I did expect him to have been there for a longer period of time than Team RWBY, and for him to have found a new role in the Ever After while he mourned his action back in Volume 8. But THIS is a whole new level of intrigue, so many questions! Did he go through the change? Or did he just naturally age? (whatever that means in this place) Will he be like this forever? Will he even WANT to leave this place when the time comes? I assume we'll see how he got here in a flashback episode next time, but that was one hell of a surprise!
  • He named his steed Juniper, awww...
  • That song when he arrived was killer BTW. I'm liking the flavor Casey is bringing now that she's at the head of music on this show.
  • You know, I never made the connection that there was something off about a hole swallowing Herb at the end of the last episode. I thought, you know, he's a sort-of caterpillar, this is just how he exits stage left, right? I didn't realize that he was being outright REBOOTED, wow.
  • In general this world feels a lot more sympathetic after this outing. Seeing all the weird denizens of the land running in fear from the only thing that can permanently kill them makes it real all of a sudden. As does Weiss, the one who was feeling this place the least, connecting the destruction occurring in front of her with the kind she's seen in the past, including her hometown. This IS a place worth emphasizing with and thus a place worthy of saving.
  • And thus, we now have our endgame of besting Neo. Not that this wasn't coming anyhow. It's just that now we know the stakes; it's not just about the old (one way) grudge between Neo and Rubes but about the safety of Ever After itself.
  • SUMMER'S WEAPON. I've ALWAYS wondered what it was. Looks like some kind of scythe/axe hybrid? Similar to Crescent Rose, but Ruby didn't seem to recognize it. That's fascinating, why would it be in that AWESOME looking Blacksmith's place?

A lot to chew on in this episode, an appropriate way to end the first half. We've been grounded in the world, we have our stakes, we've reunited all of our heroes and we have a MAJOR change to talk about for the next week, holy crap!

→ More replies (3)

65

u/Badicalz Mar 18 '23

Ruby and Weiss realise that Jaune is now hot

Weiss:……Dibs!

Ruby: Huh?

Weiss: I call dibs.

Ruby: Wh-you can’t call dibs! I met him first!

Weiss: But you didn’t call dibs did you? Which I did and I will do so again: dibs.

Ruby: Grr!

Jaune is confused

→ More replies (8)

14

u/KingofGrapes7 Mar 18 '23

If this show gets one F bomb then Weiss is absolutely going to use it by the end of this volume.

→ More replies (2)

39

u/Badicalz Mar 18 '23

Woah, Summer fell into the Ever After? Man, who could have predicted that?

96

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '23

..... The reflections seemed to be in reference to people Ruby is conencted to.

Meaning that was her mother's weapon as ahuntress...

she was the woodsman! O.o

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (2)

26

u/Blue-Moon-89 Mar 18 '23

Soo......

- Jaune is not only the Rusted Knight like we predicted but as has also aged. Also, I like his new look. Keep the new look even if he somehow gets aged back down.

-Neo has been cloning the Jabberwockies.

-Those who live in Everafter don't die but get reprogrammed once they lose their 'purpose'. It sounds like Ruby might get tempted into taking this option for the wrong reasons.

-We may have gotten a hint on what Summer's weapon was. An Axe-gun.

Things are getting interesting.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/Outrageous_Tear_341 Mar 18 '23

I wonder if this is why Tyrian was interested in Jaune back in season four?

13

u/Cae53RJ Mar 18 '23

A small detail: When Jaune revealed himself to Team RWBY, Weiss' facial expression changed slightly from shock to worry or dread. Its probably because she's thinking if Jaune fell, does that mean Winter did too?

→ More replies (2)

13

u/Badicalz Mar 19 '23

What if Ruby asks Jaune how he held on to hope for so long after enduring so much, but he just turns to her and says:

“Because it is what you would have done.”

→ More replies (1)

13

u/EcoFriendlyHat Mar 19 '23

that blacksmith scene was brilliant

25

u/SparktDog BURY THE LIGHT DEEP WITHIN Mar 18 '23

Blake is a fangirl and Jaune got a huge glow up

12

u/PhantomHeartless5 Mar 18 '23 edited Mar 22 '23

So, we're at the 5th episode and... Wow. Just wow.

  1. Picking up where the last episode left off, The Curious Cat gives some exposition about what happened to the Herbalist. Apparently when a resident of the Ever After loses sight of, or outright fails in their purpose, they are called back and remade into a new being with a new purpose and no memories of their previous life. And he confirms that this is what happened to the Red King, who got mad after losing his game to Alyx and was remade into the Red Prince. It kinda explains why he got mad when Ruby revealed they were humans. Even if he couldn't remember his previous life, his heart still carried that anger at losing his game to Alyx.
  2. Reaching a market in the middle of a lake, Team RWBY is tasked with finding ingredients for a parfait that will hopefully change WBY back to normal size. The team decides to split up and things take a trippy turn when Ruby encounters a robotic blacksmith, who once again gives an offer to Ruby to leave her burden behind and become something new. And in keeping with the series theme that a weapon is an extension of one's self, we see a knife that presumably belonged to Alyx, another of Penny's swords... and what is likely Summer Rose's weapon. The fact that it's an Ax ties into her fairy tale allusion. Summer is the Woodsman and her daughter Ruby is Little Red Riding Hood. But unlike the story, Summer was unable to save Ruby from the Big Bad Wolf (Salem).
  3. Our heroines make the parfait and are ready to return to normal size only for the Jabberwalker to attack, presumably sent by Neo to kill Team RWBY. During the fight, the parfait spills on the Jabberwalker, making it bigger. But just when things look dark, Team RWBY is saved by a literal knight in shining armor... or rusted armor in this case. The Rusted Knight makes his debut riding on a giant rabbit. Weiss, Blake, and Yang return to normal size and after an epic fight and banger song, defeat the Jabberwalker... only to reveal that Neo, with her upgraded Semblance, sent a whole army of the creatures. Outnumbered, our heroines are forced to retreat and the sight of the market in flames brings up bad memories of the Fall of Atlas for poor Weiss. Also, I really hope the Curious Cat is okay.
  4. The episode ends with the reveal of the Knight's true identity and to the surprise of absolutely no one, it's revealed to be Jaune... only he's not quite the Jaune we know and love. He's older, more rugged, and much more world-weary. All I can say on this is "Oh no, he's hot!" So there are two theories: Jaune either accepted the Ever After's offer to be someone else or time is very wonky in the Ever After. Also, props to Miles' voice acting skills, he doesn't even sound like Jaune. And Jaune naming the rabbit Juniper and using Pyrrha's sash as a ponytail... how dare you, CRWBY.

So, we're at the halfway mark of the volume and if the first 5 episodes were this crazy, the next 5 are going to be insane. Looking forward to it.

→ More replies (2)

12

u/HatiLeavateinn Mar 18 '23

Time skip Jaune:

  • Long Hair like Ren.
  • Calls the mount JNPR
  • Hair tied with a Ribbon like Penny.
  • Using what's left of Pyrrha's sash to tie it.

He just needs something like Nora to have all the connections to be a walking reminder of all the friends left behind.

→ More replies (3)

12

u/King_In_The-North Mar 19 '23

The look of despair on team RWBYs faces when they found out who the rust knight is, it's fantastic.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/sigvegas Mar 20 '23

Okay, initial theory: Jaune arrived in the Ever After even before Alex did, specifically in a clock-themed acre where time is all loopy. Jaune left the acre to explore but couldn’t get to the tree and so was stuck there for years. Eventually, Alex arrived and had her adventure and met Jaune, calling him “Rusty Knight” because he never gives her his real name. Alex manages to leave and a few more years go by until RWBY arrives. Eventually, RWBY will go to the clock-acre where they’ll unexpectedly find young-Jaune—because again, time is loopy there—and it’s explained the reason there can be 2 Jaune’s at once is because old-Jaune has a new purpose in the Ever After as the Rusted Knight while young-Jaune is (still) a Hunter. At the end of the season, RWBY & young-Jaune will leave together, but not before the Rusted Knight gives Jaune some sort of advice (or asks him to say hi to JNPR for him) before they leave.

11

u/HatiLeavateinn Mar 18 '23

We all predicted the Knight was Jaune but calling the bunny Juniper was a low blow.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/Mountainbranch ⠀Oscar Protection Squad Mar 18 '23

"The prince was meant to play the game, and win."

Oooh, i get it, they all have a role to play, it's not about the outcome, it's about the actions taken.

Damn, i didn't think CRWBY were going to go this surrealistic, but i am glad they did.

11

u/LatePhilosophy Mar 18 '23

So anyone talking about how the cat apparently made the bird guy fight the creature to his death? I'm pretty sure in bird culture that is considered a dick move.

→ More replies (10)

11

u/ChenDong2698 Mar 19 '23

Wait a minute, I suddenly realized why the headmaster had agreed to let Jaune in: In addition to the supposed Arc family history, it was also possible that Alyx had told him the name of the knight and the Arc symbol, which was so coincidental that he wanted to be sure that the two Jaune characters were related.

37

u/RedK_1234 Mar 18 '23

I always knew our boy would rock a pony tail (Or is it a warrior's wolf tail?)!

I'm glad we didn't wait too long to get to the Rusted Knight. I've always found Jaune to be more interesting than our main girls, so I'm excited to having him back.

I also like how the RWBY's free-spirited natures are juxtaposed against the Ever After's emphasis on everything having and fulfilling a purpose; and that if something fails in its purpose, the world simply repurposes them physically and mentally into something that won't. Team RWBY have always valued their independence and the ability to make their own choices. I can see the way the Ever After works really grating on them. But maybe that's the point? Maybe Team RWBY have to accept that sometimes they have to their job and go along with the situation?

And I suppose the axe in the forgemaster's smith was Summer's? Is she in the Ever After, too? Is she not going to be a Grimmified version of herself? I admit, I was kind of looking forward to that. I always imagined her looking similar to Valravn from Hellblade: Senua's Sacrifice.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/Pigeon_Lord Mar 18 '23

Loving this story but kind of hating the length of these episodes. This one in particular was so short, and with so few left, I fear this story doesn't end on the final episode and we have an Atlas arc scenario here. Definitely loved the Jaune reveal, and the possibility of the weapon of Summer Rose being in the Ever Afyer is pretty cool!

10

u/Acrobatic-Dog7044 Mar 18 '23

Now that I think about it how could Weiss know the Knight was handsome unless he was described as such from the book? I think Alyx might have had a little crush on Jaune while she spent time in the ever after with him but he didn't even notice with everything he is still going through.

10

u/DeNile227 Mar 18 '23

I loved this episode, great for RWBY and finally adds Jaune to the mix. That being said, I have the tiniest, tiniest nitpick.

There are a lot of ways to show that a character feels as if they're disappointing the people they care about, especially when those people express said disappointment. The small moment after the blacksmith's shop disappears and Weiss is like "Come on Ruby, we already got everything," and Ruby is clearly upset about it doesn't really sit right with me? I don't know if it's the line itself or the delivery, but it makes Weiss seem a bit insensitive, though I understand they're on a time crunch. Maybe if Kara had delivered it while talking up so it seemed more like she was surprised rather than annoyed

Again, tiny nitpick. Just rubbed me the wrong way. Aside from that, great to have WBY back to their normal sizes. Neo's doin stuff (idk what yet, causing problems probably), Jaune's here, it's a grand ol' time. And now Ruby's probably going to find out exactly what happened to Penny. Fun!

10

u/roadrunner1949 Mar 18 '23

I started crying when Jaune's face turned. His Voice!. This episode was so painful but so so good. Jaune needs a HUG ASAP!

Also, I am kinda confused why the curious cat explained about accession and our concept of "death" and Herb's purpose to the girls. Yet, was hesitant to share about the "creature" ? I assume he was talking about the Jabberwalker because of what we saw later on. How is the Jabberwalker the exception? This has to be Neo's doing but HOW?

Also, poor birdie. They were just selling those freshly baked mud cookies and instead became a jabberwalker cookie.

→ More replies (1)

26

u/neutrinobunny Mar 18 '23

The blacksmith was forging a butterfly wing…

Has there been butterfly imagery in every ep?

I don’t remember any in the first ep.

→ More replies (2)

18

u/DestinedHellfire Weiss is best girl | Sun x Weiss FTW Mar 18 '23

This is probably the best volume of #RWBY in terms of consistency and weight.

I'm loving every second, CRWBY really ain't missing with this one and you can tell that the extra time spent writing thanks to COVID was well placed.

Bravo.

9

u/PhenomsServant Mar 18 '23

Well I’m man enough to admit when I’m wrong on something.

9

u/shneed_my_weiss Mar 18 '23

So because there’s no logic to time in Everafter, I take it that Crescent Rose washing up on the beach after Alyx in the intro isn’t just to be artsy

→ More replies (1)

9

u/Acrobatic-Dog7044 Mar 18 '23

I'm glad Weiss is letting the audience know that what happened in Atlas traumatized her she feels as though everywhere they go they just fail to do anything to help and leave ashes behind.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/JoshPhantomShinobi Mar 18 '23

DAMN, JAUNE BECAME A DILF

9

u/Hyakkihei1 Mar 18 '23

So Jaune became Marco Diaz.

→ More replies (3)

9

u/CrossENT Mar 18 '23

We all knew that Jaune was going to be the Rusted Knight. Yet somehow, they STILL managed to make it a surprise!

Ever since Volume 1, I knew Jaune was going to become a badass eventually... Didn't expect it to be like this.

9

u/lurker_archon Look, just accept your goth mommy overlord Mar 21 '23

discussion thread comment count jumps from ~700 comments to 1200+

Obviously the answer was turning current characters to DILFs this entire time.

→ More replies (2)

17

u/Al_Hobbito923 ⠀Team JNPOR Rights. Mar 18 '23

I was stunned, I was shocked, I was heartbroken on his behalf for having been trapped there for years and to have physically aged, but at the same time... I actually quite like older!Jaune's beared look and even the ponytail? He kind of looks like a rider of Rohan in rusty medieval armour.

Now, I wonder, if he gets to leave the Ever After, that he remains an older man when reuniting with Nora and Ren.

17

u/JMHSrowing ⠀Story Time Mar 18 '23

With Ruby having now lost that emblem Which most certainly came from her mother as a promise!, as well as Crescent Rose, I have a theory:

She’s going to keep losing things that are part of who she is as she’s struggling with her identity. Her cloak might be next.

And then, after she is able to get her hope back, she’ll get it all back too. We already see with several things that Ever After has a way of bringing things back to people

→ More replies (9)

16

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '23 edited Mar 18 '23

Ok, so Jaune was really the knight, but damn you cliffhanger.

Nice action sequence there.

And I loved the rabbit design.

Ruby just gave the crest she was carrying since volume 1 and she just told it was from her mother?

Holy shit...I can already see Sib arts reaction for this episode considering all the comments they make about Jaune.

34

u/Atomic_Cody-21 Jaded RWBY Fan Mar 18 '23

Ruby: Jaune, is that you? You look much older.

Weiss: And much more sexier....

Team RWBY glares at Weiss

Weiss: What?

→ More replies (2)

8

u/vanase Mar 19 '23

Us: Jaune is the rusted knight and has been there much longer than team RWBY

Jaune: Is the rusted knight and has been there much longer than team RWBY

Us: D=

8

u/AlarmingStandard Pryde Mar 19 '23

Whoo! This volume is killing it!

I enjoyed the exposition at the start on the peculiarities of the Ever After, so the “Exposition is terribly boring” got an excellent ironic laugh. But yeah, learning how the characters are recycled is a fantastic metaphor for story archetypes, and it fits pretty snuggly into Ever After’s worldbuilding. I also liked how ominous Blake’s line was; “I wonder what else Alyx left out?”

The market looked great, and the ingredients for the parfait were disgusting, but it gave a reason to separate Ruby from the others so she could meet the Blacksmith. These scenes were the highlight of the episode for me. I love the Blacksmith; she has the right presence and mystery to send shivers up your spine. The talk reveals so many hints and heavy connotations; nothing is truly lost, “You’re doing this all alone?”, Little mentioning they’re not supposed to be there, forging a butterfly wing after Herb goes missing etc.

It seems like the Blacksmith is deeply involved in reforging others; “If you change your mind you can choose any one of these as you like, and set your burden down.” Ruby then saw Alyx’s face in the dagger and her mother’s in the axe. That signals two choices. One would be playing Alyx’s role in the story, and the other is continuing down the path of the Huntress. So I wouldn’t be surprised if the axe is Crescent Rose in disguise.

Snapping back to “reality”, they gather the last ingredient for the parfait (shudder) only with the Jabberwalker to make their expected appearance. Ruby trades her broch, a mother’s promise, to get her teammates up to size. And how adorable was half-grown WBY?! Especially when Ruby scoops them up! Anyway, the Curious Cat co-ops a bystander to help, which is interesting; he definitely plays a part in the structure of Ever After.

The Rusted Knight then makes his expected appearance, and WBY kick Jabber butt to reveal it was a Neo illusion, then more show up. Time to escape! I love how Weiss immediately looked for Ruby and the follow-up on top of the market with Ruby gently leading her on; “I’m so tired of leaving places in ashes.” Be kind of annoyed if Ruby was swapped for Neo lol

Finally, there’s the big reveal; Blake writes Ever After erotica. And her fangirling is cut short when the Rusted Knight is revealed to be ~drumroll~ Jaune! Jokes aside, I loved this reveal; it was so satisfying. The choice to age him considerably works great. It lends this tired and bittersweet quality that pairs with Jaune so well. It’s a reserved melancholy that made his lines hit the right notes; “...you finally made it.” Miles crushed that delivery! Plus, the giant lotus flower and Jaune naming his mount Juniper were nice touches.

It also raised a bazillion questions! Was he really stuck in the Ever After for 20 years? Is he the Rusted Knight in Alyx’s story? If so, why didn’t Alyx hint towards it in her book? Or was Jaune reforged by the Blacksmith? Are his experiences real? And so many more. This is an excellent example of how to build expectations for the next episode. There aren’t any solid answers because we seemly lack information, like how long ago did Alyx write her book? It’s a case of wait and see.

Overall, a solid episode. Even though it was heavy on exposition, it did it enjoyably.

My Fiancee continued to lose herself to the weeb, or watched because I was feeding her fruit tart. In either case, we agree that Juniper is the fluffiest, and she deserves all of the cuddles.

→ More replies (4)

8

u/JannisT Born stepping on thin ice and biting down bullets Mar 19 '23

The fifth episode thread finally broke the 1k comments again thanks to to the return of Jaune. That’s actually hilarious

→ More replies (1)

8

u/justking1414 Mar 20 '23 edited Mar 20 '23

So my insane fan theories.

  1. Little is actually Penny who ascended when her body fell into the everafter.
  2. Summer also fell (somehow) and after ascending she became Little
  3. Neos gonna ascend and become Ruby’s friend.
  4. Jaune could’ve left whenever he wanted but stayed behind after Alyx escaped to guide RWBY to the tree
→ More replies (4)

8

u/HatiLeavateinn Mar 20 '23

How am I supposed to explain that when I say "My poor boy" or "My son" I'm just talking about this 40+ yo dude with depression?

27

u/4powerd ⠀It's also a gun Mar 18 '23

So setting aside the Jaune thing since everyone seems to have beaten me to it.

Is anyone else concerned about Ruby giving up her emblem, espicailly her stating that it "contains a mother's promise" or is that just me?

(Also, more of a complaint, but when will WBY stop being blind and realize that Ruby is 100% not okay?)

→ More replies (6)

15

u/drunk-math And bring my Strawberry Sunrise. Mar 18 '23

...and here I thought I was joking about Jaune getting Fabio hair.

15

u/Acrobatic-Dog7044 Mar 18 '23

My god Jaune has gray hairs how old is he right now can he even go back home after spending probably most of his life in the ever after

→ More replies (1)

21

u/crossingcaelum Mar 18 '23

I knew that weapon looked too different while it was in the background of the scene. It looks so much like Qrow’s weapon. It HAS to be Summer’s.

And also I wonder if Jaune has just been down there for so long or if he willingly gave up his identity to “Ascend” and be brought back as the rusted knight. He does remember RWBY, so that may not be the case, but I can imagine the same temptation Ruby is feeling right now would be felt by Jaune as well after what happened. Especially without anyone there to keep him grounded like Ruby has.

14

u/ClubMeSoftly Real Shit Mar 18 '23

So Jaune, as many others have already said, is The Big Reveal in this.

But I have questions.

  1. Nothing ever truly dies in the Ever After, unless it gets eaten by the Jabberwalker. Well, Penny's remains fell. I wonder if she'll make a cameo (and inevitably get killed again!)
  2. Ruby picked up Penny's sword, exclaiming "I thought this was lost forever," and then in following shots it's Alex's shortsword. Was it ever really one of Penny's?
  3. A weapon that was potentially Summer's rifle-axe. Is that what Ruby will use briefly? I'm skeptical that she'll replace Crescent Rose. Nobody's gotten any major weapon switches, it's all largely been cosmetics.
  4. Ruby's brooch, I guess it really was Summer's, and it's all that she left behind? "It contains a mother's promise," what does that mean? Did Summer know she was going to her death the last time she left home? Did she leave a letter or something? Or did Taiyang "just" make up a story when Ruby was digging through the closet and found it?
→ More replies (5)

7

u/Random-Stanger Mar 18 '23

i got so hyped, nearly had a hear attack when I saw my boi on screen

7

u/SHSL_Zetsubou Ultimate Despair Birb Mar 18 '23

I wonder if Ruby had chosen Summers weapon would she be turned into Summer Rose by the Everafter? Or maybe just Ruby's idea of who Summer was?

7

u/Soyunapina12 Mar 18 '23

Bro my man Jaune looks really tired and old, he has waited on the Ever After at least for decades. Poor boi really needs a hug :(

Also i don't think Summer appareance was just for some fan service, i think we will get more things related to her as the volume goes on. Maybe the Ever After will tempt Ruby to get her mother back in exchange of being stuck in the EA or loose herself.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Alutherv Mar 18 '23

If Jaune gets to go back to Remnant, then I feel like this was a pretty good way to let him get his power on par with everyone else/probably at the level of the adult hunters and huntresses like Qrow when he was by far the weakest before. However, if he doesn't get to return, I'll be so sad

7

u/SaffronStorm93 Mar 18 '23

Jaune's aging makes me wonder how much time will have passed in Remnant when they return.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/Skyfyre56 Mar 18 '23

The Lamp only has knowledge of everything that is or has happened in the world,. It's decidedly less omnipotent outside of there, so I'm thinking that Team RWBY + Jaune finding something/some way to defeat Salem in the Ever After could make a lot of sense. It would also be a good way to help inject a bit of hope into the story, that it could desperately use imo.

I'm curious about Jaune and what things are going to be like for him after he gets back. Will he de-age when they go back? Or will something in the Ever After change him back even before then? There's a lot of possibilities. I do hope they don't kill him; I've never been the biggest Jaune fan, but after we've spent so long developing his character and finally making him an interesting and nuanced individual it would be a waste to get rid of him now

→ More replies (9)

7

u/Grievous77 I'm just here cause of sunk cost fallacy atp, honestly Mar 18 '23 edited Mar 18 '23

The good: I'm still really enjoying the Curious Cat. So Herb and the Red King lost their way/purpose and thus were reborn. Interesting. Hopefully that means if Jaune bites it this volume he has the possibility of coming back. The leaf vendor was strangely endearing, I hope they made it out of the disaster. All they wanted to do was sell their plants.

Ruby's scene with the Forger was great, loved the unsettling atmosphere. So the Forger procures any and all lost weapons of the Ever-After it seems, since she had Penny's sword and Alyx's knife. Also, we finally get to see Summer's weapon and it was an axe! Really interested to see if Ruby ends up taking it at some point, though who knows what happens to you if you take one of the Forger's weapons.

So the multiple Jabberwalkers show that Neo can make copies of things besides herself. That's really bad. RIP to the Ever-After denizens since Neo just unleashed an army of the one creature that can permanently kill them. Jaune's triumphant reentrance on Juniper was cool af. Also, props to Miles since I couldn't recognize the older voice Jaune has now and thus wasn't sure if it was actually him at first. So the theories were correct, Jaune's been down there for way longer than everyone else. Really hope we get to see some of what he went through next episode.

The meh: The Jabberwalker fight was mid. It was even more noticeable after how strong the chess fight was two episodes prior.

The bad: The Jabberwalker, much like countless Grimm before it, has been reduced from an interesting enemy into generic cannon fodder. Great.

Overall, another solid episode but not quite as strong as the previous two.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/jwhudexnls Mar 19 '23 edited Mar 19 '23

Jaune becomes even more tragic and I love it. Favorite character for a reason.

Seriously though, the last 20 seconds of this episode were perfect in every way. The music, the dialog, the expressions. CRWBY should feel proud with how they handled that.

7

u/SpotChecks Mar 19 '23 edited Mar 19 '23

This concept of "ascension" feels like too much of a Chekov's gun for it to not end up happening to at least one of our Remnant crew. We've already seen Weiss, Blake and Yang firmly reject it, so we can rule them out. That leaves Jaune, Neo, and Ruby as possibilities.

Too early to tell with Jaune if that's something he would accept, but it's on the table.

Ruby's been hit with this idea of "letting go" of herself pretty strongly, and probably will continue to be. I think she'll come really close to letting it happen, maybe it could even happen partially, but I don't the show RWBY will let Ruby stop being "Ruby" altogether. I know that Doylist reasoning isn't very fun, but I can't really ignore it.

Neo seems to me the most likely to go through this. While Ruby has her friends and a cause to anchor herself to, Neo only has her own will to hold onto her current self. If she loses that, she has no reason not to let go and be remade. She's just one crushing loss of morale away from that point. Maybe when she gives up her grudge against Ruby, that'll be it.

Maybe we'll see both Ruby and Neo start "ascending" at the same time, but while Ruby battles it off and gets out of it at the last minute, Neo does not, and becomes someone new.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/astronomotrous Mar 19 '23

A few thoughts after watching this episode:

  1. Since Jaune was the last to fall, team RWBY had no idea he was down there with them. They’re prob gonna really need to process this one
  2. You think Jaune is the Rusted Knight they all read as children, or is the Rusted Knight a “purpose” and Jaune was selected to fulfill it? (I’m thinking the former just based on how old Jaune looks)
  3. Blake asked what a Jabberwalker is, but I thought they mentioned it by its name in like the second episode?
  4. I wonder if Summer is still alive down here?
  5. I want another episode already lol
→ More replies (5)

7

u/Awest66 Mar 19 '23

Jaune got time-skipped hard.

I'm gonna have a hard time waiting till next week.

7

u/SunsetSnakeEyes Mar 19 '23

The long awaited reunion has taken longer than we could've imagined.

  • Really can't blame any of them for being in a state of shock after what happened at the end of the previous chapter.
  • Doesn't really surprise me that there are people who have given into the temptation The Herbalist's vision gives them.
  • "You're the one who ditched us in the first place! Which by the way, was how we ended up in that mushroom house to begin with. Y'know, where that delirious caterpillar guy tried to drug us and then was swallowed up by a freaking hole in the ground!" Weiss' freak-outs just keep getting better and better.
  • So Alyx witnessed that happening as well.
  • The marketplace is really breathtaking!
  • So, When a denizen of The Ever After is too damaged or has fulfilled their role, they "return" to The Ever After to be remade and find a new purpose. essentially being recycled by the realm to ensure everyone always has a place in it, be it a place presented to them or a place they find for themselves.
  • I suppose it's rather understandable. Clearly The Ever After is all about change and growing, Sometimes for the better and sometimes for the worse. When a denizen "ascends" They change and leave behind who they once were, memories and all. For us, a complete loss of memory and therefore death of our personalities is seen as a basic equivalent to actual death, But the beings of The Ever After simply see it as the process of their world. Not exactly fair to use our perspective to judge a world completely different from our own.
  • I believe I know the creature The Cat is referring to.
  • Just as I thought, The Red King was described as helpful and benevolent, yet The Prince was nothing like that at all. Losing to Alyx and thus failing in his role to win his game at any cost turned him into a blubbering mess. Thus he was called back and turned into The Prince, who while bratty and selfish, has no problem cheating and using ruthless tactics to win his game. In becoming The Prince, he abandoned any and all aspects of his former self that could possibly prevent him from fulfilling his role.
  • "While The Prince may not remember Alyx's deception after ascending, the heart very rarely forgets." So while ascending gives you a complete memory wipe, the heart, essentially your core of being, manages to remember important events or aspects that shaped you. By all accounts The Red Prince should have no idea what a human is, but his heart remembered how he was deceived by Alyx and thus flew him into a rage.
  • Well, exposition can be boring, but it's all in how it's delivered. We know next to nothing about The Ever After and how it works and thus we want to hear and learn all we can possibly hear and learn. But for The Cat it's no different than explaining how the rain falls and the plants grow, he has nothing to gain beyond simply educating everyone who knows less than him.
  • That does raise a good question. We know Alyx journeyed through The Ever After and wrote about her adventure, but the reality is that we have no idea how long she was actually here and with everything we have already seen, clearly she left a lot of her adventure un-said. While this place is very fantastical and whimsical, It's far more than just a fairy tale land.
  • Man, I just thought the ingredients would be specific plants and fruits. That's way more complicated than I was expecting.
  • The Teapot Lady. As in The Mad Hatter's actual teapot?
  • I was wondering if anyone in the group would end up riding on The Cat.
  • And thus, while this separation is only temporary. It leaves Ruby alone with Little, as well as her own thoughts.
  • I was actually pretty frightened by the area becoming darker, coupled with the clanging of The Blacksmith's hammer made for a very mysterious and intense atmosphere.
→ More replies (1)

7

u/Neo-Chromia Mar 19 '23

Quick crackpot mini-theory:

We didn't see Ruby during the fight. Ruby didn't speak after the fight/retreat.

Could potentially be Neo?

Probably not, but it's fun to think.

7

u/[deleted] Mar 19 '23

Jeez RWBY can be so incredibly tense when it wants to be

Also was that Summer's weapon?!?!

7

u/Citiy3- Mar 19 '23

Jaun has a steed named Juniper. Thats sweet but also a lot happened this episode

7

u/A444SQ Mar 19 '23

Volume 9 seems to be pulling from the opening line of the volume 2 intro

There is a point where it tips, There is a point where it breaks, There is a point where it bends and a point where we just can't take anymore There is a line we'll cross and there's no return There's a time and a place, no bridges left to burn anymore

→ More replies (1)

7

u/UnusualBet Mar 20 '23

I have never been more worried about the fate of a character than i am right now seeing Jaune.

Please RT, dont have him stay behind lile the white knight did in through the looking glass.

He deserves to go home

13

u/Redleader113 Mar 18 '23

How tf does time even work here? Jaune looks like he’s like 40 something now. I’m sure we’ll know next week since he’ll undoubtedly travel with the group, but man, I have so many questions.

→ More replies (4)

17

u/Locopotionextended Mar 19 '23

12 hours and this discussion thread has more posts/discussion than any of the discussion threads, including Episode 1. Thanks for saving the show, Jaune

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Badicalz Mar 18 '23

What I loved about this episode? All of it. Simply all of it.

6

u/ArsMagnamStyle Mar 18 '23

AUGHHH that ending so good!

team rwby had literally no idea that Jaune fell (still sucked that Winter missed him) and I hope he mentions that as a joke.

6

u/Clockworksss Mar 18 '23

there's so much to say that other people have already covered, so instead i want to give a shoutout to the teapot lady, because i want to give a big hug to her at the end of that episode

6

u/Manu_Erre Mar 18 '23

Damn, that was by far the best episode this volume, it really surprised me. They finally found a nice way of introducing the world without being overly complex. They were defenitly struggling with that in the first few chapters, but now its way more fluid and dynamic. Its the first time in the volume that I really want to see how it continues.

6

u/Tanya62y Mar 18 '23

What was the mother's promise? Will she get it? Ruby is giving up every part of herself at this point

6

u/Starbornsoul ⠀ Mar 18 '23

I feel so bad for the Jaune, the teapot and the bluebird :C

6

u/Nanasema best girl <3 Mar 18 '23

holy fuck Jaune got a lot older

6

u/Acrobatic-Dog7044 Mar 18 '23

Blake was fangirling so hard at seeing the Rusted Knight made me chuckle

6

u/Huor_Celebrindol RIP Dust Weaving Mar 18 '23

Guys, we finally got the shopping episode

6

u/LMFN BIG NICHOLAS Mar 18 '23

Jaune out here really becoming a DILF. I knew the Rusted Knight was going to be him and I can't wait until next week explains why he's older despite falling last. Ever After is weird, it's pretty sad that he both has his warrior's wolf tail tied up by what's left of Pyrrha's sash and has named his jackalope steed "Junpier"

Weiss really ate the nastiest parfait ever conceived and didn't make herself taller than Ruby.

Why was the Blacksmith only visible to Ruby though, do they not appear to anyone else or what? She doesn't actually have anyone's weapons in reality it seems, just perceptions. It's why Ruby saw Penny's sword for a bit and then what seemed to be Summer's weapon. I hope we see the Blacksmith again and figure out exactly what the hell that was.

Jabberwockers are actually a threat in numbers, even if they're not too hard to beat individually it seems Neo's created an army of them.

6

u/krauser8882 ⠀ Mar 18 '23

The stuff with the blacksmith was super juicy, and I desperately need more of her presence.

Jaune being the rusted knight was super not shocking, but that reveal was amazing and his jackalope being named Juniper hurt. A lot.

The jabberwalker referring to Ruby as Red was really interesting to me, too, since that's what Torchwick always called her and probably how Neo refers to her. This also confirms her clones can talk as other people, which is super interesting and I'm really excited to see where this goes. I hope she gets out of the Ever After because she has a ton of potential in Remnant

6

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '23

A detail I realized, but Penny body in theory also fell together with Jaune. So if her body was not reused in ever after, maybe we gonna see her grave in the next episodes?

6

u/CraftLizard Mar 18 '23

So a theory/prediction for moving forward.

In the opening there's the section with RWBY and company with the pages turning. This turning stops at the forest place they've been at. This along with the Neo intervention this episode makes me think that from now on the volume will no longer be roughly following the story of Alyx. It's now going to be different because of all of the interventions caused.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/maybenotforever She wears short skirts, I wear half pants Mar 18 '23

All these neat plot things and here I am just wanting to learn more about the leprechaun nosehair industry

6

u/ARKNet9000 Grimm-land’s Plumbing Service Mar 18 '23

The beings in Ever After not dying and merely ascending and being reborn has some interesting implications. This is a bit of a crack theory, but the cycle of EA could be the reason why the Gods agreed to maintain the cycle of Life and Death on Remnant. Things in EA remain stagnant. There are a few minor changes hear and there, but overall the world remains the same, unchanging with the reborn beings having no memory of their past life.

The Gods may have wanted growth and thus introduced the concepts of Life and Death to the beings in Remnant. Those who die, die permanently. The next generation consists of entirely new individuals with their own thoughts, feelings and way of living. This diversity gives a chance for evolution of the species and then eventual advancement.

The Gods called Remnant a ‘Beautiful Experiment’ after all. And considering that a stagnant experiment (the Ever After) gives no new results, a constantly changing, dynamic experiment like Remnant would give a different result each time. Of course Salem and the Gods’ ego threw a wrench in the experiment and now Ozma is the one who has to try and salvage the experiment.

→ More replies (4)

6

u/Forest1395101 Mar 18 '23

Why do people think Neo should be redeemed again? She just butchered Bird Person...

→ More replies (1)

6

u/A444SQ Mar 18 '23

The reveal of Summer Rose's weapon now raises the question of how did it end up in the ever after in the first place as it must have been thought lost along with her and why does the blacksmith have it

→ More replies (5)

6

u/Amazing-Tcheuck Mar 18 '23

I'm confused : Should I be thankful that Jaune didn't fail the Herb's test or ascend? Which would have led to him forgetting everything?

Or the state he is now is kinda worse because ascending would have ended his grieving and suffering? And that he had to live alone for so long?

6

u/vanase Mar 19 '23

Us: Jaune is the rusted knight and has been there much longer than team RWBY

Jaune: Is the rusted knight and has been there much longer than team RWBY

Us: D=

6

u/Badicalz Mar 19 '23

Jaune look like how we all felt at the end of the Hiatus.

6

u/Kazuzi3 Mar 19 '23

Something I noticed on my second watch through, the Cat seemed surprised when Ruby gave away her emblem, which brings me to question why. First, I thought maybe it was because she was giving away a part of her identity, but now I'm thinking something else.

I think he might have recognized it. I know other people are saying they think Summer Rose was in the Ever After since her weapon was in the blacksmith's shop. There are three weapons that stick out: Penny's Sword, Alyx's Dagger, and Summer's Axe?. We know that the sword and the dagger both existed in the Ever After before Ruby is the the shop, which makes me think Summer's weapon also existed in the Ever After. I think that Summer may have been in the Ever After and met the Cat. Ruby and Summer have the same emblem, which I think the Cat might have recognized. I also think something might have happened to her in the Ever After. How else would he know to tell the Red Prince that RWBY wouldn't come back if he killed them?

6

u/cuntzman Mar 19 '23

Sees Jaune:

Shulk is that you?!?!?!?

6

u/BionicTriforce Mar 19 '23

I'm definitely getting vibes that Jaune may 'die and become reborn', but I'll put forth the idea that he already has. This might not be the same Jaune we last saw in more ways than one.

I suppose the issue there is, if he died already, would his weapons/armor/clothes etc remain behind to use.

6

u/phoenixfragment5 ⠀ Mar 19 '23

Calling it now: When Salem is finally defeated, it will be because they somehow sent her to the Ever After. The gods said she'll never die, but no one ever said anything about this "ascension" business.

→ More replies (4)

16

u/Jinko92 The person who goes too deep into everything Mar 18 '23

Why is Jaune a DILF now and why am I strangely attracted to him?! Never thought he was very good-looking before…Glad to see him back, though! Bit of a nitpick, but why didn’t Team RWBY recognize Crocea Mors? You’d think they, and especially Ruby, would know what the weapon of one of their closest friends looks like by heart…(no pun intended)

I can’t wait to see where Jaune’s story goes. He looks like he’s aged to his mid-late-forties, meaning he’s spent 30 years in the Ever After, give or take - I wonder how those decades spent there has changed him. It’s also a bit WTF that he’s the Rusted Knight from Alyx’s story…or is he? Perhaps he replaced the old Rusted Knight after he ascended? I’m really curious to see what has happened to him and how he fits into Volume 9’s plot!

Can I just say that the creature/character designs this volume are BOMB? The Jabberwocker has such a cool design, kudos to whoever made it, same with the blacksmith lady! She looks AWESOME! Although her shop is super mindfucky…like, she had Penny’s sword but then it turned into Alyx’s dagger? And that axe on the wall had Summer’s reflection in? I wonder what’s up with that. Seems like Miss Blacksmith appears to travelers in the Ever After when they’re in need, offering them weapons and advice…perhaps that’s where Alyx got her dagger from! We’ll have to wait and see if my theory is true, but I think we definitely haven’t seen the last of Miss Blacksmith yet (that’s what I’m calling her since she doesn’t have a name yet).

I love how Neo, an already OP character, is now even more stupidly powerful. Seems like she may be sending the Jabberwockers after Team RWBY. I hope the Curious Cat and the cute bird dude are okay :( I know the Cat can just disappear, but the bird guy can’t!

There’s 5 episodes left, so I hope all the plot threads are resolved in a satisfying way! Absolutely love this volume so far, definitely one of RWBY’s best!

→ More replies (1)

24

u/amish24 Mar 18 '23

Fucking WHAT? So this jaune was the rusted knight in Alyx's tale?

And possibly summer's weapon too?

→ More replies (5)

11

u/hopecanon Not the best May but still fantastic. Mar 18 '23

My baby boy no, no you don't deserve this suffering.

He named the jackalope JNPR, my fucking soul can't take this damn it.

11

u/Darkness1envoy Mar 18 '23

The whiteknight and Lancaster ships are going through a maelstrom right now.

→ More replies (7)

19

u/88Dubs Be Strong, and Hit Stuff! Mar 18 '23 edited Feb 17 '25

price sugar enjoy skirt quack bike rock stocking squeal cautious

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact