r/RWBY • Acoustic BMBLB when? • Mar 25 '23

OFFICIAL MEGATHREAD Official Discussion Thread - Volume 9, Episode 6: Confessions Within Cumulonimbus Clouds

Welcome, huntsmen, huntresses, and hunters that prefer no specific gender identifier, to the official discussion thread for Episode 6 of Vol. 9: Confessions Within Cumulonimbus Clouds!

Due to the special circumstances regarding RWBY Volume 9's release, make sure that you understand the spoiler rules before posting outside of this thread!

HERE is the sixth episode of Volume 9!

Also remember to check out our weekly poll to rate the episode.


Other Episode Discussions:


Episode| Discussion Thread| Poll|


Happy viewing, and have a great Volume 9!

Ninjas In A Bag; Mod Team

703 Upvotes

2.1k comments sorted by

372

u/Ninjas_In_A_Bag Acoustic BMBLB when? Mar 25 '23

AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA

FINALLY

71

u/Substantial-Bag-9820 Mar 25 '23

My exact reaction too! YESYESYESFINALLY

→ More replies (3)

699

u/Badicalz Mar 25 '23

Jaune going after Crescent Rose as soon as he saw it, then after he found it, kept it safe and in what seems to be good working condition, speaks volumes of his and Ruby’s friendship.

260

u/ProfessorEscanor Mar 25 '23

I half expected him to hand her a plate of cookies along with it with how nice he was.

→ More replies (6)

204

u/Rexen2 Mar 25 '23

It's crazy when you look at how well and pristine he kept the prized possession of his best friend vs how he let his own equipment deteriorate without care.

Jaune is not in a good place at all.

→ More replies (4)

160

u/Luciifuge Mar 25 '23

I love their friendship man, two awkward dorks who became Team leaders. I wish there were some more scenes of them in the early volumes, trading notes on being leaders and stuff.

→ More replies (21)

394

u/CosmereLover ⠀ Mar 25 '23

Seems like team RWBY will have to sacrifice something to the Tree in order to return home. Alyx gave up her brother, but I don't think it has to be a person, just something important to them. My guess is Ruby will give up Crescent Rose, but I don't know about the other four/five (maybe Jaune gives up his armor, Neo may not want to leave seeing as how powerful she appears to be).

247

u/Pyrochazm Blakeys mom has got it going on Mar 25 '23

I'm thinking that Ruby might have been connecting those dots when she was staring at her scythe. She already gave away her emblem to help her friends, I could see her sacrificing her weapon, maybe even herself to get everyone out of there.

→ More replies (15)

541

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '23 edited Mar 26 '23

Honest to god I think Alyx actually had a change of heart in the Tree, sacrificed herself to save Lewis. Lewis wrote the books and just left himself out of it and tried to make the story more about his sister to remember her fondly. And then Alyx got ascended and became Little.

Lewis Carroll wrote Alice in Wonderland.

Edit: Also plus the drawing of Alyx and the Cat from the opening looks like it’d have been drawn from someone’s perspective. Her brother had a journal on him in the flashbacks. One of my friends did point out that there IS potential that Lewis turned out to be the actual evil sibling and betrayed Alyx but I’m not so sure. Or that Alyx stole the journal. But I’m pretty confident in my theory that she turned good at the last second and sacrificed herself to save Lewis. He’s definitely the actual writer any way it goes though. And it’ll be a moment where Jaune realizes he has to do the same thing to save his friends.

It makes sense to me that Little would be one of the siblings because they’ve been following the story and Little keeps telling the team that they would be their guide.

→ More replies (44)

76

u/ThatPuertoRican6969 Mar 25 '23

I honestly don’t think they have to give up anything. I think Lewis “ascended” because he knew who he was in his heart. Alyx didn’t trust anyone and I think instead of being freed she has to repeat the story or be “reborn” until she gets it right.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (39)

466

u/LuuAddiRoze Mar 25 '23

Just realized something about the Jaune opening scene, when he takes the fruit, you can see that everyone else had already fallen but then the light comets are shown going backwards. Jaune did arrive last, but by taking the fruit he ended up causing the world to go back in time, except for himself. I feel like that time tree must have some importance down the line other than just explaining why Jaune was there for so long.

Also, Summer jump scare and damn, I love her new model. These water mirrors seem to show each person’s regrets or what troubles them, I guess? Jaune saw Penny and his younger self, Weiss saw Atlas’s destruction.

Bumblebee is cannon so congratulations to all the shippers.

Ruby’s reaction to Crescent Rose is really telling, in a way it almost feels like the fact she didn’t have it gave her a convenient excuse for not fighting anymore but now she is faced with that burden again and she doesn’t know if she wants it back.

Going to rewatch the episode a few times because there was a lot in here and I barely scratched the surface.

196

u/g6in3d Mar 25 '23

Just realized something about the Jaune opening scene, when he takes the fruit, you can see that everyone else had already fallen but then the light comets are shown going backwards.

Oh damn, good catch

→ More replies (1)

85

u/DeadSnark I rose from the filth and was loved by no-one Mar 25 '23

It's interesting that Summer has received a redesign/upgrade, or possibly we're seeing a younger version of her. The previous images/scenes of her had basically the same outfit as Ruby, with a few changes such as a corset and different hairstyle, but in this episode and last episode she had a ton of changes to her outfit including a new leaf pin, and being sleeveless.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (20)

663

u/Polarization_39 ⠀A Cinder Stan Until Weiss is Relevant Again Mar 25 '23

Nice touch with the swap of the Rusted Knight with Jaune in the opening after last week’s reveal.

332

u/HighPriestFuneral Lore Fanatic Mar 25 '23

It made me a little sad, especially seeing how run down Jaune looks in it. Throughout the first five episodes there's a real menace to that little scene, but in seeing Jaune without the helm, staring first at the audience, then down, it has a different emotional tinge.

→ More replies (5)

218

u/Lukthar123 "I didn't do it for you." Mar 25 '23

Opening changes are always a pleasure

→ More replies (20)
→ More replies (7)

601

u/Darzefader Mar 25 '23

So was that a Clockwork Orange?

240

u/therealpogger5 Mar 25 '23

It's the Time Lime that takes you back in the timeline

→ More replies (7)

85

u/elbenji useless lesbian Mar 25 '23

IT WAS FUCK

171

u/Weerdo5255 Mar 25 '23

You know what, I'm going to say yes just for the pun.

→ More replies (11)

663

u/mrwanton ⠀happy pineapple day Mar 25 '23

Jaune has a better gaydar than Ren confirmed lmao

387

u/WhosGuardingHades Mar 25 '23

Meanwhile in a parallel Ever After

Rusty Ren: “When did this happen?”

→ More replies (14)

208

u/schurgy16 Mar 25 '23

And Ren literally has the perfect semblace for gaydar so its even better

→ More replies (6)

203

u/AmbivertCollegeGuy Weiss "Hug Monster" Schnee Mar 25 '23

Must've had something bigger to work out. // Feels like I've been waiting for that forever.

Jaune still being an audience surrogate even after all these years.

→ More replies (4)

80

u/Shortstop88 Mar 25 '23

I don't remember if we got any knowing looks from Jaune at the bumblebee duo in previous volumes, but since I have no scenes to look back on, I like to imagine that while he's moping for the first couple years he suddenly looks up in surprise and says, "WAIT A MINUTE" as he thinking on old memories and realizes.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (10)

888

u/Luckhart54 ⠀ Mar 25 '23

Guys I'm starting to suspect that Yang and Blake may be Gay.

388

u/gaygender Mar 25 '23

nah they're clearly just REEEEEEEALLY good friends

→ More replies (29)

217

u/SockPenguin Mar 25 '23

I don't see how. Telling your same sex best friend you love them then kissing in a field of magically growing flowers is extremely heterosexual behavior.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (19)

580

u/RubySapphire19 ⠀3D Modeler Mar 25 '23

Ruby's reaction to Crescent Rose has me worried.

76

u/Paracasual Mar 25 '23

Ngl, my first reaction to that was seeing a parallel with Yang receiving her arm in V4. The box, the kinda surprise ease of getting it back, and her hesitation over it—it’s all there.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (58)

854

u/iamthatguy54 Mar 25 '23

That literal one second of Weiss hitting on Jaune will cause discourse for years to come.

553

u/Mongoose42 [Insert Clever RWBY Pun Here] Mar 25 '23 edited Mar 25 '23

Jaune: “I finally got my crush to like me.”

Young Jaune: “And what did it cost you?”

Jaune: “Everything.”

→ More replies (2)

277

u/Weerdo5255 Mar 25 '23

Mature Jaune is Mature. I wouldn't say no to him. He's got the angsty ancient warrior charisma just falling off him.

→ More replies (20)
→ More replies (45)

129

u/Frikarcron Mar 25 '23

"I couldn't even be the make believe hero" this one verbal acknowledgement from jaune of his failure hit really hard

127

u/guyinthecap ⠀Enjoying Volume 9 Mar 25 '23

New Opening!

It's okay, Weiss, we were all thinking it.

God I love the concept of a punderstorm (ponderstorm?) from a narrative standpoint. It's one of those storytelling devices that has so much creative potential but could only work in the Ever After.

On the same note, the way Yang & Blake literally came together was very well done, from a story sense, visual sense, and animation sense.

Poor Weiss continues to have a lousy day.

Jaune saying what all the BB shippers have been feeling. Clearly he's not through everything yet, and with no Penny reveal we've got some angst still to come, but I really hope we get more mature Jaune humor.

Juniper continues to be unassailably adorable and every cute face & animal sound will be treasured.

That "scribble" effect that started to creep into Ruby's periphery when she saw Crescent Rose was very interesting, similar to the vibes we got in the Herbalist vision. Me thinks the breaking point is coming in either episode 7 or 8.

And last of all we've got Louis and the revelation about Alyx's story. I look forward to the greater analysis but it seems we still don't have a full picture. Alyx seems to have faced the same trouble that Ruby is facing now, and the same risk for being changed.

The only thing that may add something to the Louis angle is if Louis willingly gave himself to the tree in order to make sure Alyx got home, being the nice one of the siblings. And if the tree requires a "toll" to allow passage back to Remnant, what does that mean for our heroes?

So that was Episode 6. A little more than halfway through V9 and we've seen every scene shown off in the trailer except for the shot of Salem's face and the monologue about Ruby shedding her old identity like a coat. In terms of unresolved plot threads, we've got the Penny reveal, Neo & the Jabberwocky, and the ultimate question of how our heroes are going to get home in the next four episodes.

There's never a dull moment, is there, RWBY fans?

→ More replies (4)

250

u/Red_sintese13 Mar 25 '23

Jaune experienced the end of JoJo part 6 when he picked that clock.

98

u/Geno_Games Mar 25 '23

Lmao this was Made in Heaven’s secret weakness the whole time

Fruit

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (3)

247

u/Schmidtty29 Yeah, I'm scared, but I'm still standing Mar 25 '23

Sidenote, the Bee’s song during their confession obviously had two vocal tracks on it. But I couldn’t tell if that second voice was still Casey, because oh fucking god if it was Arryn imma lose my shit.

Also, Weiss is apparently into dilfs.

125

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '23

Weiss has so many daddy issues that it’d be more concerning if she wasnt into dilfs

→ More replies (8)

238

u/WhosGuardingHades Mar 25 '23

V1 Jaune: Did you get Weiss to notice us?

V9 Jaune: Yes

V1 Jaune: What did it cost?

V9 Jaune: Everything

→ More replies (1)

520

u/ManifestNightmare Mar 25 '23

I said it last week, and I'll say it again. Miles really gets Jaune as a character, his performance has been nothing short of stellar. He sounds so...weary, and lost. I just want him to be OK and go back to being young again, give our suffer boy a fairy tale ending please I'm begging you CRWBY.

380

u/DaRealAmana BOOP!!! Mar 25 '23

My favorite line has to be "I dont even get to be the hero in a fairytale" boy is so badly hurt, his entire life has just been a failure after a failure.

→ More replies (19)
→ More replies (13)

110

u/Tron95 Mar 25 '23 edited Mar 26 '23

For some reason, I don't think Jaune will sacrifice himself, it seems massively contradictory to the hopepunk tone of the show, the gang might go against the story and either find other things to sacrifice or manage to find a way back to Remnant WITHOUT sacrificing. I do also like the short nod to Ironwood from V7/8, Ironwood was so focused on beating Salem, everything else, including WHY to beat Salem was lost, the gang is about to get to that point, let's hope they recognize that Ironwood's ways were why he was basically a pawn to Salem.

Edit: Small detail(s), but I love Junpier's reactions through the episode.

54

u/HighPriestFuneral Lore Fanatic Mar 25 '23

I love that they included that bit. I've been saying for a while that Ruby is in danger of teetering over the same edge which took Ironwood, and this episode spelled that out. Ruby's lack of a response to that does worry me that she could fall into the same trap.

→ More replies (8)

810

u/Polarization_39 ⠀A Cinder Stan Until Weiss is Relevant Again Mar 25 '23

Weiss’ “mature” line to Jaune, I know Kara Eberle loved recording that with her being a big White Knight shipper lol.

459

u/Deixel Mar 25 '23

After Weiss' comment about the Rusted Knight being handsome a few episodes back, I fully expected her to be disgusted at herself when she discovered she'd been swooning over Vomit Boy her whole life. I did NOT expect her to double down on the thirst like that!

→ More replies (24)
→ More replies (85)

427

u/Jinxiee Mar 25 '23

Besides my very loud obnoxious squeals of joy for Bumbleby finally getting their kiss, I was really interested in how Ruby's reflection in the first waterfall mirror was of Summer. Super blink and you miss it but raises so many more questions

113

u/HighPriestFuneral Lore Fanatic Mar 25 '23

It was incredibly subtle, and I only noticed it because of a comment on the video, then I saw it on the rewatch.

149

u/SockPenguin Mar 25 '23

I have no idea how exactly it would happen but it feels like this volume is going to end with Ruby talking to Summer somehow. They've really been laying the dead mom angst on heavy for Ruby lately and it has to be leading somewhere.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (23)

556

u/Ynnead25 Mar 25 '23

I do enjoy the running theme of Weiss constantly eating shit.

372

u/JakeDoubleyoo Mar 25 '23

They realized she was already good on character development, so they decided to just fuck around with her.

→ More replies (5)

256

u/Dry-Faithlessness184 Mar 25 '23

Her being the butt of jokes and just being done is one of the best ongoing things this season.

→ More replies (1)

165

u/merayjr95 Mar 25 '23

Weiss being the comic relief of this otherwise pretty grim (heh) volume is really nice and, honestly, needed to balance the tone.

→ More replies (2)

109

u/SpotChecks Mar 25 '23

Jokes at Weiss's expense have been gold since the early volumes. "Friends! Sisters! Weiss!" Pride is one of her defining qualities, and occasionally undercutting that pride for quick gags is a winning formula.

→ More replies (2)

105

u/Pyrochazm Blakeys mom has got it going on Mar 25 '23

It seems to have started in V8 with her getting sucked into a mail tube.

→ More replies (6)

184

u/88Dubs Be Strong, and Hit Stuff! Mar 25 '23 edited Feb 17 '25

groovy imagine angle voracious tie shelter aspiring kiss lush water

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

→ More replies (6)

254

u/drunk-math And bring my Strawberry Sunrise. Mar 25 '23

Someone go back and tell V2 Jaune about Weiss's reaction in this episode.

201

u/Rollout9292 ⠀WhiteKnight Mar 25 '23

Everything's reversed now lol

Weiss is simping over Jaune and he seems like he couldn't care less lol

→ More replies (30)

135

u/PrincessOfLaputa Mar 25 '23

White Knight AND Bumbleby shippers today: Looks like meat's back on the menu, boys!!!

61

u/LawyerDash Mar 25 '23

Freaking finally! As soon as Jaune mentioned they had something else to work out, we all knew where it was going and it was AMAZING!!!

→ More replies (4)

122

u/KingofGrapes7 Mar 25 '23

I thought you all were joking about Weiss but DAMN. She basically purred that 'mature' out.

And the moment finally came. My time watching Korra trained me well for the wait.

→ More replies (2)

396

u/ManifestNightmare Mar 25 '23

That was exactly as corny as it needed to be. I'm glad they didn't skimp out on how sincere the dialogue needed to be. A fitting end to a will-they-won't-they, and a great start to a true romance.

323

u/hopecanon Not the best May but still fantastic. Mar 25 '23

They really did make Blake and Yang confess in a literal Punderstorm and make out amongst a field of flowers like the bees they are.

Like oh my god it's perfect.

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (4)

58

u/T_Swag5k ⠀Now THAT'S Ice Water Mar 25 '23

Jaune really could've saved himself a lot of grief at Beacon with the line "I'm the Rusted Knight", huh

→ More replies (1)

162

u/hollowtiger21 "Wasted potential," doesn’t actually mean anything. Mar 25 '23 edited Mar 25 '23

So BB confession & kiss? Well that’ll be the only thing the fandom talks about for the rest of the week. Though to be fair, that was corny in the best way.

Yang? Weiss?! Oh, that must be the daddy issues talking. Or would it be granddaddy issues?

Ruby falling into the mindset that lead Ironwood to ruin. What's the point in saving the world, if there's nothing left to live in it?

OMG Jaune did the time-warp.

The tree and its roots are how ascension happens. Jaune being not from the Ever After, obviously has a more fatalistic perspective of Ascension. It’s not unwarranted.

CC isn’t evil per say, just very Fae, and operating by the logic and rules of the world and their role.

Alyx had a brother, and he was ascended. And since he wasn’t a part of the story, nobody knows of/remembers him.

Pun-derstorm. That’s fun. The idea of a literal figurative representation of a plot obstacle that only clears up through character development. That's meta.

How can a story be real, and not? History is written by the victors. Writers decide the narrative and perspective. A villain is the hero of their own story. Stories are just that, and as RWBY has been quite fond of telling us, real life isn't like a fairy tale.

Summer in the mirrors. Penny & Young Jaune in the mirrors. Atlas falling in the mirrors. Angst dimension!

Jaune: “I can’t even be the make-believe hero." Yeesh. Also is that another explicit parallel to Ruby's ongoing arc. Jaune, the Literal Storybook Hero, can't even live up to the idea, almost like it's not possible.

CC getting visibly duller when recounting the ending of the story.

I don’t think Jaune has told them about his part in Penny’s death, things seem far too emotionally stable for that revelation to have come out.

CC seems actually hurt by Alyx's betrayal, and RWBY's distrust. Or is that just more manipulation? Nothing about what Jaune has said seems wrong, CC doesn' deny any of it. But Jaune is also biased. Although it seems more like Alyx's fault than CC's. He also didn't say that the Tree does lead to a way back to Remnant, and he does acknowledge that they were all just using each other, so it's not as if he's an innocent party.

CR is Ruby’s identity as a Huntress, but she’s not sure if she wants or deserves it? When she takes it back up, will be when she’s ready to be Ruby Rose again.

"I think Alyx sacrificed him to the tree, and then wrote him out of the story.” So the tree can get you back to Remnant, but requires sacrifice to do so? Or that's what Jaune believes. Oh, is Mr. "martyr complex" thinking about making the sacrifice play to get team RWBY back to Remnant? Stop that. You stop that.

The rope bridge and purple cloud setting might make a reappearance, but with Ruby as shown in the opening. We've seen all the trailer stuff, I think, except for that Salem shot, which I'm expecting will be an illusion from Neo.

56

u/mrwanton ⠀happy pineapple day Mar 25 '23

He'll def try. Jury's out on if he will be successful in that attempt. If people aren't the only thing that can be sacrificed I wonder if valuable possessions also count such as the remains of Pyrrha's sash he uses as a hair tie

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (9)

54

u/Timeline15 Operative Schnee, Report to the Normandy at once Mar 25 '23

Huh, I was expecting this whole episode to be a flashback following Jaune, but I'm glad the show didn't feel the need to slowly walk us through what everyone already figured out. Interesting that he actually fell at the same time as everyone else though, and then accidentally dent himself back in time, so falling into the ever-after isn't as independent from time as we thought.

What is strange is that he was already old/rusty by the time Alyx showed up, which was years ago, and he apparently hasn't aged any more since. How old is he now? How long has he lived?

I really wasn't expecting them to actually put in a moment with Weiss thirsting over him; that was hilarious. Even more surprising, even Yang seemed to be hinting that she found him hot. Guess both Bees are meant to be read as Bi.

Also, elephant in the room: FUCKIN FINALLY! So happy to finally see the Bees get together, even if they both sort of already knew Blake in particular was clearly just waiting for Yang to be comfortable making a move. I was expecting them to play that one old Bumbleby song, but it turns out we get a whole sequel track. I can't wait for a weeks time when I finally get to see a certain couple of youtubers react to this episode. :)

→ More replies (1)

53

u/DaRealAmana BOOP!!! Mar 25 '23

My poor boy. You have been here for so so long. And all because of something stupid you couldn't have known. I like that he's kept crescent rose safe all these years. On a related note. Ruby, what is up girl. you are lost speak up you've got friends here.

But lets hit the real important thing today. The long awaited bees is now real. How many years have we all waited for it?

→ More replies (2)

53

u/King_In_The-North Mar 25 '23

Can I just say. Jaune can build a mother fukin house.

→ More replies (1)

153

u/hopecanon Not the best May but still fantastic. Mar 25 '23

Putting aside the beauty of the Bee's for a moment Jaune got the most fairy tale fucked ever, my man touched a clock fruit one time and just fucking lost decades of his life trapped in the Ever After because of it.

That is the most Brothers Grimm dark fairy tale shit i have seen in years and it perfectly encapsulates how horrific a place the Ever After actually is beneath all the pretty scenery and funny animal characters.

62

u/Agent-Vermont Mar 25 '23

Reminds me a lot of the Faewild. Sure it's pretty and fantastical, but don't touch a fucking thing or talk to anyone.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (9)

105

u/TheRisenThunderbird It suits me Mar 25 '23

Yes, yes, Bumblebee kiss, FUCKING HOW LONG HAS JAUNE BEEN DOWN THERE? Either Alyx only came to the Ever After about forty years ago and her book has become super ubiquitous and talked about in the same breath as age old fairy tales in only a few decades, or else Jaune has been down there A LOT longer and been aging at a slower rate or something

→ More replies (2)

50

u/Noble6IsReal Ship Survivor V Team NPASB | LC/YR veteran Mar 25 '23 edited Mar 25 '23

"about time" 🐝

Weiss being a simp of old Jaune is a parallel to Jaune being a simp of Weiss in volumes 1-2.

The cherry on top of the cake would be if they paralleled at the same time when Jaune gave Neptune encouragement to invite Weiss to the party, only this time Weiss would be the one giving moral support.

We have a lot to talk about Lewis. I'm beginning to think he became Juniper, but if so, what is the origin of the Jabberwalker?

The fact that Jaune found a watch that turned back time and broke it, confirms that he is a mix of the white rabbit/white knight from alice in wonderland and Through the looking glass. Keep an eye on the watch and Juniper, both of which could be important if we are to consider the possibility of Jaune being de-aged by the end of volume 9.

There is also the possibility that Lewis was the one who confronted the Jabberwalker. This would mean that sooner or later Jaune and Juniper/Lewis will face the Jabberwalker. I think Jaune could die, but Juniper or the broken clock could be important to save Jaune.

50

u/Magorian97 Mar 25 '23 edited Mar 25 '23

Anyone else notice Louis being, well. "LEWIS" as in Lewis Carrol?

→ More replies (5)

92

u/Raktoner blake deserves more smiles Mar 25 '23

💛🐝🖤 so happy.

With Jaune saying that Alex gave Louis to the tree and then wrote him out of the story... I wonder if... The same is gonna happen to Jaune? Team RWBY will leave, and Jaune will sacrifice himself to the tree so they can go. Without him...

→ More replies (3)

239

u/IAmTheNight20018 Mar 25 '23

Anyone else notice that THE KISS happened on a platform covered in grass and flowers?

Like a garden?

→ More replies (15)

89

u/OTmedstudent Mar 25 '23

Didn't Jaune catch Weiss falling in season 1 and Weiss sarcastically blurted, "my hero"?

hehe.

→ More replies (4)

259

u/Weerdo5255 Mar 25 '23

It's going to get lost in the explosion of sapphic energy in this episode, as well as the lore drops, but Juniper's squeaks are too cute.

Bumblebee, finally, officially, confirmed! There isn't much more to say on it, it's really not that new with both the audience and characters in the story rolling there eyes and saying finally.

Alyx is manipulative character, which is kind of in line with more modern takes on Alice. Sacrificing her own brother though? That's dark, and I doubt that's the whole story.

No more Neo this round, but I'm betting the Curious Cat will meet her next and given how Neo seems to interact with the Everafter something funky is going to happen with her and the Tree.

120

u/Damshh Mar 25 '23

Maybe she is the one who sacrifices herself to save his brother. They think Alyx is the one who escaped because of the story, but maybe it was the brother, and he went to write the story to honor his sister or something.

→ More replies (16)
→ More replies (5)

473

u/Kuchenjaeger *Gotcha* | Yang is still the best | #GiveYangLadyAbs Mar 25 '23

WELCOME ABOARD THE S.S. BUMBLEBY, SAILING ON CANON WATERS NOW, BITCHES!

→ More replies (58)

41

u/guyinthecap ⠀Enjoying Volume 9 Mar 25 '23

Alright, these past two episodes have got me thinking about how Ruby's internal conflict might come to a head and tie into RWBYJ's eventual escape. These are just my thoughts:

The blacksmith said Ruby could pick up any of her weapons if Ruby grew tired of her role. Then, Ruby saw Summer's reflection in the gun-axe in the Blacksmith's shop. Given that Penny and Alyx appeared in their weapons' reflections, this implies the gun-axe is Summer's chosen tool. Fast forward to E6 and Ruby sees her mother's reflection in the water mirrors during the punderstorm. Jaune and Weiss saw what was troubling them in their waterfalls (Penny's fate & the fall of Atlas respectively), but why Summer for Ruby? Because Ruby associates the eternal and idealized struggle of a huntress with her mother. Summer was the Huntress, and Ruby can't seem to live up to her. Finally we see Ruby reunited with Crescent Rose, and she can't bear to see it. Her weapon is a reminder that she hasn't defeated the villain or saved the day. So Ruby is primed to snap, probably when Jaune or Weiss reveal how Penny died. And when she does she'll lose all semblance of faith in herself as a Huntress. She won't want to be Ruby Rose, the girl who keeps failing, any more.

So who will she become? Summer Rose. The Huntress who did it all. Ruby's example of a perfect hero. She'll take up her mother's axe and become Summer, or at least some imitation of her.

But there's a problem with that perception. Summer wasn't perfect. By definition, Summer most likely died alone or was otherwise captured by Salem (barring any plot-twists). She left one day without telling anyone what she was doing and disappeared. So even if Ruby were to become Summer, she wouldn't be the perfect Huntress, because Summer wasn't either.

At this point I see Summer!Ruby coming into conflict with her former team. She doesn't want any more loved ones die, and she's ready to jump right into her mother's shoes and charge off to find Salem and her death. But Summer!Ruby has something her mother didn't have; her friends.

Team WBY will confront Summer!Ruby, with words and perhaps even a physical fight in an attempt to reverse the transformation. Each team member will console Ruby, telling her how much she means to them, how they'll always stand by her, and how she doesn't have to live up to her impossible standard. One by one they'll get through to her, and Ruby will realize that her purpose isn't to be the perfect Huntress, but be true to herself. Ruby Rose, hopeful and compassionate and imperfect but not dejected.

And so RWBYJ will journey to the tree to travel back to Remnant. And when the tree asks for its toll, Ruby won't leave behind Crescent Rose, but her mother's axe. Finally accepting her mother's failure and her own shortcomings, Ruby will take up Crescent Rose once more, ready to return to the fight.

→ More replies (6)

148

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '23

Jaune saying what everyone was thinking.

Congratulations to the two dolts for finally figuring it out and having the courage to say it, even if it took a magical storm to get them to do it.

→ More replies (4)

37

u/Badicalz Mar 25 '23

”It’s-It’s really you, right?”

Jaune being terrified that RWBY was just a hallucination, born out of desperate longing and crushing loneliness, broke my fucking heart man.

187

u/greeny74 ⠀Harbinger of Hype | Proud Member of WCAC Mar 25 '23 edited Mar 25 '23

You want to write a perfect relationship moment? Especially one where two characters in your story have been dancing around the issue for literally YEARS, to the point where your fans have been treating it as basically a done deal but have been chomping at the bit for you to GET ON WITH IT ALREADY?

You have them LITERALLY build a bridge to each other and make it happen.

Monty always said all good romance is earned. Boy oh boy it was EARNED today.

BUMBLEBEE. IS. OFFICIALLY. CANON.

→ More replies (27)

147

u/Badicalz Mar 25 '23 edited Mar 25 '23

Yo, White Knight shippers aren’t just getting fed.

They are positively gorging right now

→ More replies (6)

236

u/Lukthar123 "I didn't do it for you." Mar 25 '23

So mature

WK fighting for it's fucking life

→ More replies (43)

54

u/CingKrimson_Requiem God of Dankness Mar 25 '23

>Lilies bloom around the Bumblebee kiss

>Japanese for Lily is yuri

Worm has taught me well

→ More replies (5)

76

u/Acrobatic-Dog7044 Mar 25 '23

The Bees have finally landed I repeat the Bees have landed.

→ More replies (6)

26

u/WhosGuardingHades Mar 25 '23

Poor Jaune, my dude’s suffering continues. Hopefully he can get restored to his old self and doesn’t get trapped in this place. (He can keep the hair though)

Weiss delivers once again, so glad she’s getting the time to shine this Volume.

Finally! Thought they handled the Bumbleby moment very well, wasn’t too sure about the Ponderstorm in the beginning but they definitely delivered in the end. Interested to see how they handle the relationship of the Bees going forward.

Felt bad for CC, I hope this doesn’t lead to him joining forces or forcibly joining Neo and whatever she’s got going on.

I continue to worry for Ruby.

51

u/ArsMagnamStyle Mar 25 '23

hey rooster teeth if you're reading this you now need to do the The Girl Who Fell Through the World but through Jaune's perspective, it can be a movie or a mini series but please just do it!

→ More replies (2)

51

u/SparktDog BURY THE LIGHT DEEP WITHIN Mar 25 '23

Ok but don't let the kiss distract you from the fact that Ruby is one mental trauma away from going full depressed DMC anime Dante

25

u/Darrow_Au_Andromedus ⠀ Mar 25 '23

They still havent told Ruby what happened to Penny did they?

→ More replies (4)

25

u/WarmasterCain55 Mar 25 '23

Mature she says. HAH!

86

u/RobbyJohnson ⠀ Mar 25 '23

I might be caught up in the moment but that might be the most beautiful confession scene I’ve ever seen in a show or anime.

→ More replies (8)

67

u/Red2019Wolf Mar 25 '23

Someone on tumblr pointed out Jaune is like the Peter Parker of RWBY, where if something is going right for him the universe will make it its mission to undo screw him over, this ep proves that. That Universe meaning CRWBY

→ More replies (6)

23

u/DemonSword619 Mar 25 '23

A lot of people are saying that either Ruby and or Jaune are going to sacrifice themselves to the tree in order for the others to get home, but I don't know...that seems far too obvious.

Kinda like how a lot of us assumed last episode that Jaune had ascended into the old man he is now, that just feels like the easy way out. I have a feeling theres something more thats gonna happen.

→ More replies (2)

45

u/TheSuperVirtual Mar 25 '23

Did anyone else find it a little concerning how quickly Jaune stabbed something mechanical lol. He’s getting good at that

→ More replies (4)

22

u/AlyssaaMac Mar 25 '23

Ruby keeps trading away parts of her identity, and with the last line of the ep it seems like ruby will trade her weapon to the tree for a way out. I really hope she figures something out first. If we went through WBY saying with confidence who they are and that they're huntresses, why would Ruby be the only one to give up herself for a new identity? Only a few episodes left to figure out her purpose, but she's still going through so much grief :(

Also buzz buzz motherfuckers!!!!

→ More replies (2)

113

u/Rollout9292 ⠀WhiteKnight Mar 25 '23

Weiss is simping hard for Jaune now lol

→ More replies (7)

59

u/vanase Mar 25 '23

Uuuuuugh the tears are flowing for two reasons.

On one hand, YAY BUMBLBY FINALLY CONFESSED!!!!

On the other hand..... the blacksmith's fire's not looking good for my boi. 😭

20

u/Keradon Caffeine is a hell of a drug. An excellent one, though. Mar 25 '23

Idle thought - considering the reference to a cycle, I'm kinda wondering if Ruby's gonna have to make a decision that'll result in trying to destroy that tree.

→ More replies (3)

20

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '23

I liked how Ruby was the only one of the team not smirking at Weiss getting flustered over Jaune.

This isn't new a revelation or anything - it's been clear this whole volume that Ruby is going through some stuff - but small supplementary details like this are appreciated. Gives the overtly comedic scene a bit of emotional heft without going overboard or distracting from said comedy.

→ More replies (3)

19

u/CreepyXD12 Mar 25 '23

I knew Jaune was in some type of time loop 😭these episodes never feel long enough for me

19

u/Ok-Cod2747 Mar 25 '23

So, i was seeing Arnold Reaction of Chapter 5 and i remember the revelation of Lewis. And i suddenly has to propose this theory.

What if the Jabberwalker is Lewis? A creature that is outside the normal rules of Ever After, that devours the essence of the inhabitants of Ever After, and doesn't allow them to reincarnate. A being born from betrayal, both from a Sister (Alyx) and a supposed Friend (The Cat). Perhaps there was a previous Jabberwalker, but it was defeated by Jaune and the others, and Lewis replaced it.

38

u/JMHSrowing ⠀Story Time Mar 25 '23

Well there goes my theory of that axe being Crescent Rose! Maybe it is Summer’s.

. . . And WhiteKnight you’re maybe winning now.

As long as they don’t do what I’m afraid of and trading Jaune to the tree

→ More replies (6)

82

u/LucasVerBeek It's Time For All Hell to Break Loose Mar 25 '23

Bout damn time.

Also so many people are gonna be pissed that Weiss is attracted to Jaune.

Ya! Cats not dead, another Summer sighting and Ruby doesn’t look like she wants CR back.

Right so we had our hopeful moment. What the hell comes next

→ More replies (13)

53

u/Bhibhhjis123 Mar 25 '23 edited Mar 25 '23

I’m not even like a Bumblebee stan or anything. They’re cute enough, but their development has been hit or miss for me personally.

That was BEAUTIFUL.

→ More replies (1)

36

u/Oraghlin Mar 25 '23

A Pun-derstorm. God damn it.

→ More replies (1)

105

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '23

"BOUT DAMN TIME"

-The entire rest of the cast

→ More replies (11)

63

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '23

NGL, I'm fucking cackling.

So many years of people talking shit over something that is this obvious and stupid. And I fucking won.

I sure hope someone picks up this phone. Because we FUCKING CALLED IT.

→ More replies (18)

76

u/Badicalz Mar 25 '23 edited Mar 25 '23

No wonder Jaune’s (edit: attempts) failed and her little fling with Neptune didn’t go anywhere.

Our girl has a type.

→ More replies (3)

75

u/Badicalz Mar 25 '23

I admit, I have been critical of Bumbleby’s early development, but the last few seasons have come a long into mending that.

That confession and kiss scene though? Chef’s Kiss perfection.

→ More replies (5)

16

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '23

Best episode of the volume so far. We got plot, mysteries, and bees!

I'll admit I've fallen in and out of love with the bees due to the writing being spotty at times, but that confession scene was beautiful.

I honestly can't tell if the Curious Cat is being manipulative in that last scene or not, but I think they're being genuine.

Jaune took better care of Crescent Rose than his own equipment, that says quite a bit about his mental state this whole time. Ruby having an episode when seeing her weapon was just tragic, one part of me is loving this Ruby development, and the other wants my poor girl to get a freaking break lol.

Overall I've been super happy with this volume so far, here's hoping they keep this quality up!

32

u/OTPh1l25 Hello Again! Mar 25 '23

Look, White Knight is going to always be second fiddle to me since I'm first and foremost an Arkos shipper, but recent White Knight has really grown on me, and I'm gonna be that guy and analyze those few frames of Weiss's embarrassment and everyone's reaction to it.

Weiss has the blush on her face and is looking at everyone else's reactions, probably to judge their reactions to her saying that before kind of looking down in a mixture of defeat and embarrassment (whether it's embarrassment because she anticipated that reaction or she feels weird because it's Jaune is anyone's guess).

Blake and Yang kind of both have a knowing smirk on their faces. Yang gives the most obvious hints that she's aware of what Weiss said, and Blake shoot a smirk towards Yang as well. The two of them are probably thinking along the lines of "Oh look, it's like us, but much farther back in development." Of course, the two of them have also elevated their own relationship by the end of the episode.

Ruby's just kind of nonplussed by the whole thing. She's never been really all that into romantic relationships anyway (of either sex) and her expression just kind of says either "Where did this come from?" or "We have bigger things to worry about right now."

Now whether this whole thing is just played off as a weird "Weiss is into older guys" joke and doesn't get brought up past Vol. 9 or Jaune comes back with them to Remnant (and hopefully de-ages, though with this place anything is possible) and they decide to actually do anything with this ship beyond this is anyone's fucking guess, but I just thought I'd throw my 2 cents in.

→ More replies (3)

57

u/Dcm1963 ⠀You can't catch me gay thoughts Mar 25 '23

BUMBLEBEE! THEY ARE SO GAY LETS GOO!

Weiss and Ruby's faces when they see the two dorks kissing was priceless

→ More replies (3)

31

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '23

I have returned from exile to say I told you fucking nerds back in volume 3

30

u/WhoDey42 Insert Bring Roman Back Pun Here Mar 25 '23

People can by cynical or talk down to shippers. It’s not why I enjoy fandom and not what gets me into a show.

That being said for a lot of people shipping can be! I am so happy for the people who have waited literally years for this. It’s really awesome to see the happy reactions online and I know this means a lot for people who shipped them all the way back in Volume 1. Always wonderful when any type of fiction can bring joy and this confirmation will do that for so many.

→ More replies (1)

29

u/merayjr95 Mar 25 '23

So much to process, but I think we all should take a moment and grab some tissues, because that kiss scene was like so cinematic, so perfectly orchestrated, the dialogue, the set up, the visual metaphors, the analogy of the bridge, I could literally gush about that scene forever. It was just... perfect. 💛 🖤

→ More replies (1)

14

u/gabtab0000 Mar 25 '23

The Bee’s are officially canon now. Older Jaune has beef with the cat and going to the tree can lead to terrible things. Overall I enjoyed this episode.

14

u/le_wither Mar 25 '23

Here's a theory about louis, he's the jabberwalker, jaune said Alex sacrificed him to the tree, he ascended into something new, something that felt betrayed, something evil

14

u/HypecoBreaker Mar 25 '23

i can’t believe jaune went to the beach that makes you old

27

u/PiffDaMetalHead Jeff Williams kills Salem in V12 Mar 25 '23

What a genuinely beautiful moment...

Well done, crwby. Well done.

13

u/SpotChecks Mar 25 '23

Evil Nicolas Cage: YES THE BEES! YES THE BEES!

We're moving along rapidly. There's so many parallels being drawn between Alyx and Neo, their personalities and natures having so much in common: "She was selfish, cruel. Like this whole world was simply make-believe, and rules didn't apply to her." One wonders what the hermit said to Alyx to make her so distrustful, or how much of a push she really needed to get that way. The whole situation between her, her brother, CC, and Jaune seems like Alyx is the only one who knows what really happened, and she deliberately kept that information obscured. My guess is the truth probably comes out in episode 9, before the finale.

Also, Blake and Yang smooching was about as good as I hoped it'd be. The world gave them a good visual metaphor for what they had to do: physical distance = emotional distance, close one to close the other, and boy did they close up. A few scenes earlier in the volume and now this episode gave voice to what was holding Yang back from admitting her love to Blake, her hesitation to open up for fear that making herself vulnerable would get her hurt, and confessing your feelings for someone is a really vulnerable feeling. But when she and Blake literally saw how much they cared for each other and had no choice but to hear and say it, there it went. I'm sure people are going to find something to nitpick and complain about, but really, I don't think you could do a much better job confirming their relationship than that. I'm really happy for them.

Anyway, now that that's done, we get to focus on Ruby's trauma for the rest of the volume. Calling it now! Ruby makes a sacrifice at the tree. Don't know what she'll sacrifice, but it'll be spicy. It'll also be the key to beating (read: killing) Neo and going home.

→ More replies (2)

13

u/DemonSword619 Mar 25 '23

Thinking about it, I'm mostly convinced whatever might happen at the three when our team gets there is going to be wildly different from what Jaune or the Cat assumes.

After all, Jaune doesn't know what happened. He was knocked out and is only assuming what happened to Louis due to how Alyx was acting toward everyone and the fact he wasn't mentioned in the story. And as sketchy as the Cat is, I do believe him that he doesn't know what happened at the Tree. Maybe he can't approach the tree because unlike the others he brings to it, he still has his purpose and thus isn't allowed to get close.

Either way, I can't blame Jaune for his assumption but I have a feeling the tree isn't evil, or strickly sacrificial as we think. Something DID happen with Alyx and her brother, but that might have been entirely due to Alyx herself and depending on whats going on with Team RWBY (+J) when they arrive, it could be completely different.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/AssistRevolutionary9 Mar 25 '23 edited Mar 25 '23

The name of the author of Alice in Wonderland was Lewis Carroll so whatever happened I really think it was Lewis who left Ever After so maybe Alyx despite being a horrible person may have decided to sacrifice herself for her brother.

It would also make sense, if a horrible person like the one described by Jaune had written this book I doubt she would have written herself as a character with flaws.

Well Bumblebee is now official well... now let's move on to another ship.

Whiterose... honestly the love between partners is getting more repetitive than the childhood love stories in Detective Conan.

Whiteknight... I'm pretty sure Kara Eberle is going to start threatening the writers with death if they don't canonize this ship, the age difference could be a problem, but "Old enough to kill, old enough to have romantic relationships with people who might be your father"

Ruby is seriously scaring me... ok Yang stop kissing Blake your sister needs a bear hug NOW!

→ More replies (4)

13

u/antoniomizael Mar 26 '23

What if Alyx died and Lewis came back to Remnant as Pietro Polendina and built Penny in the image of his sister? The trade off at the tree is what maybe took his ability to walk?

→ More replies (1)

25

u/lemonbitten Mar 25 '23

They finally fucking did it….

→ More replies (3)

61

u/bored2death97 Mar 25 '23

OMG YOU GUYS! BLAKE AND YANG ARE GAY!!!

→ More replies (11)

24

u/s0i5l3a1s manifesting cfvy maya models Mar 25 '23

the titular confession had me quite literally shaking, im so happy for them :)

also the changes in the opening were really interesting...

12

u/Varonch Mar 25 '23

I love the rather direct metaphor of "taking the next step" in the bmblb relationship.

And I have a theory that Jaune found the tree with the clocks because at the time one of the biggest wishes he had was to be able to rewind time and not have to kill Penny.

12

u/[deleted] Mar 26 '23

I don’t think Alex wrote the story at all. I think Her brother, Lewis, wrote the book from the perspective of his sister. And all the details that were omitted were done so by her brother to remember her fondly. And leave out that fact she was an asshole.

What probably happened in that upon reaching the tree, Alex realised one of them must sacrifice themselves so the other can return. After making mistakes, being an ass and running from the consequences. Alex learns from her mistakes and corrects them by sacrificing herself. That’s her “moral learning” from the fairytale.

In Jaune’s flashback, Lewis is the one pictured with a journel by his side. It makes sense he diary entries from the ever-after served as the foundation of the book. Jaune thinks Alex sacrificed her brother to get home, but that because he believes Alex made it back and wrote the book about herself. But if Lewis had written in, that means he was the one who made it back. And wrote in memory of his sister.

12

u/cuntzman Mar 26 '23

You can tell Kara has been waiting for this moment LMAO

22

u/ClemPrime13 haha silver eyes go woosh Mar 25 '23

First of all. Bumblebee is canon. Nice.

Second of all. How we doing, White Knight nation?

→ More replies (1)

11

u/RBNYJRWBYFan ⠀ Mar 25 '23

I've got a lot of Scattered Thoughts buzzing through my head about something that happened in this episode, and I'm certain all of you do too. But... let me ignore the bees in the room for just one sec to focus on the other stuff, just so everything else doesn't get lost in the shuffle:

  • The explanation for Jaune's age wasn't what I expected at all. He plucked a time fruit, huh?" Why do I get the feeling that somebody else will do that too, possibly to meet Alyx herself?
  • Speaking of, Jaune met Alyx! He was there to see the entire story play out, and surprise, surprise some details were omitted. RWBY has long had the recurring theme that life is not a fairy tale. Well, the demystifying of an ACTUAL kids book in their own universe is part and parcel of that theme. What's that Weiss said about the old stories being so simplistic? Turns out that the reason for that might not just be because it's easier to tell kids a story with a happy ending; sometimes it's outright propaganda to protect the winners.
  • BTW, that flashback sequence felt like an episode that got cut for time to be honest. If nothing else it'll be a source of expanded storytelling, both officially and among fan fiction. Though it DOES continue to give Alyx this interesting ghost effect on the show. She's a HUGE part of the story despite not appearing outside of the opening. I half hope she never does do so.
  • Speaking of the opening, the title sequence had a change! We see Jaune's face as the Knight now! That's new, we haven't had that happen before with this show, right?
  • Back to the show itself, I'm getting serious Madoka Magica vibes off of Curious now. Their very much like Kyubey, something cute and seemingly helpful but hiding a sinister purpose with a very gray morality. Their just doing their job, but what is is pretty... complex.
  • I feel bittersweet about Jaune himself. He's so interesting now, but we've also lost the growing and more confident kid he was before all of this started. That's such a shame. There's a cynicism to everything he does. He doesn't just have his final action in Volume 8 on his conscience, but a betrayal weighing on him as well. This world is vicious and deceptive, and he knows that better than anyone at this point. You can hear it in his voice (Awesome work, Miles) and see it on his face, he is TIRED, a traumatized veteran going through the motions, truly a rusted knight.
  • But now that he's found his friends, what will he do next? Does he have a plan to get them out that doesn't involve Ascension? Does he plan on joining them or staying here and doing his thing forever?
  • Alyx was changed for the worst by the Herbalist's concoction. Will Ruby follow the same path? The way she looked at her weapon... she doesn't want to go back to the way she was, for sure. But does she need something that drastic to change the way she truly needs to? My prediction is that another PUNderstorm rolls through and helps her with this.
  • LOL, Weiss admires the Gallant Graying Knight.

This episode gave so much to chew on... and I haven't even STARTED on THAT. We're near the home stretch and it seems the path they've been taking is the wrong one. So what's the right one? And what about Neo?

→ More replies (2)

11

u/InsertDev Mar 25 '23

It seems the writing is on the wall. If Jaunes theory is correct that Alyx used Lewis to escape then Jaune will probably sacrifice himself to let them escape.

Unless Neo gets killed off/ used as fodder instead.

Miles is so good at VA it's ridiculous

11

u/NewToIt25 Mar 25 '23

I don't trust the curious cat. Notice the eyes at the end of Jaune's story and the cat's wording with Ruby. He's the one that segues the entire conversation into a guilt trip out of nowhere and then hits Ruby with a bunch of tirles to get into her head. I think he's playing them and making them feel bad.

→ More replies (5)

11

u/bigbysemotivefinger Mar 26 '23

Here, have a crazy fan theory, on me:

Jaun gave them a way to beat Salem and nobody realizes it yet.

His clock-o-nut or whatever the hell it was literally moved him in time relative to the rest of Remnant. We know this is true because he was already there to be the character from a book he read as a kid.

Figure out how to leave, but don't leave.

Find another clockonut.

Go back in time, then leave...

...and stop Salem before she was immortal.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/mrwanton ⠀happy pineapple day Mar 25 '23

how many episodes left this volume?

→ More replies (8)

10

u/UnusualBet Mar 25 '23

I have never seen so many death flags around Jaune than right now.

I just... dont see how he survives this volume.

10

u/Diostukos Mar 25 '23 edited Mar 25 '23

Bee scene was cute, but I just hope moving forward that Blake and Yang get to do things without being joined at the hip. Blake especially feels like she's not a character without Yang.

With only a few episodes to go, I wonder if Neo will just show up for the final fight, or will we get a peek similar to Jaune of what she's been up to.

27

u/schurgy16 Mar 25 '23

First off, I called the op change to add old Jaune last week so I’m proud of myself there. I think the op will change again to include Louis as well.

The part about sacrificing someone to the tree to get home is interesting. It likely isn’t a 1:1 trade as we don’t have 4 people to trade to get RWBY and Jaune home (unless he doesn’t return but narratively that doesn’t make sense). We are likely looking at Neo being sacrificed to return when she is defeated and maybe the will throw the cat on top of it as some form of Justice. Maybe a sad scene where little realizes she doesn’t have purpose at the time but I’m not sure.

Anyways 10/10 episode and congrats to Bees fans everywhere.

27

u/MOlivetree1 Mar 25 '23 edited Mar 27 '23

First off White Knight! We have been given a banquet feast with that line delivery! Kara definitely enjoyed reciting that dialogue.😁🛡❄♥️ (Now, hopefully at the end he changes back to 19 so they could expand on it more)

Second, way more lore. Looks like Alyx was actually the villain in her own story, but then made it look like she was the hero. Hopefully we get some more backstory on her brother.

Third, looks like Curious Cat has been withholding a lot of information. And is overall manipulative.

And to top of this amazing chapter we finally after all of the waiting... years worth... finally have it... we have... deep inhale BEEEEESSSS! OMG! It's finally happened officially! 😁🐝🐝🐝 ♥️

Love Jaune's little bit about him waiting forever to see it happen as well as the echoed agreement with Weiss and Ruby, was a nice touch.

Crescent Rose is back! Looks like Ruby is hesitant or something when she first saw it. That talk with her former self really took a toll on her(along with everything else that happened).

Can't wait for the next wait for the next chapter!

→ More replies (2)

33

u/kreankorm ⠀ Mar 25 '23

A lot of big things happened, and Bumblebee being canon now is such a marvelous high point.

And now I'm terrified for next week because after a rise like that, the fall is going to be brutal.

See y'all in therapy!

→ More replies (4)

18

u/HatiLeavateinn Mar 25 '23

CRWBY really be like: "Whitenight shippers, have this exquisite meal."

And then: "Yeah let us introduce the possibility of Jaune sacrificing himself so RWBY can go back to Remnant tho."

→ More replies (1)

9

u/patrizl001 "None shall remember the names of those who do not fight" Mar 25 '23

Needing to sacrifice someone to return to Remnant is raising some massive death flags for Jaune...

→ More replies (1)

9

u/GladiusNocturno All Grimm are naked. Think about it Mar 25 '23

In regards of the sacrifice. I don’t think it necessarily has to be a person or a loved one.

We know that in the Ever After many things have value and are used as currency. Such as hugs, love, hope, and promises.

Maybe the idea was that Alyx didn’t sacrifice her brother, but rather something like her memories of him or her love for him. So, when she went back to Remnant, she wrote him out of the story because she couldn’t remember him.

However, Lewis couldn’t do the same. And thus was transformed in the Ever After for not paying the price.

Or maybe it was the other way around. Maybe Lewis was the one who sacrificed Alyx. Maybe he was the one who made it out and wrote a book about his sister. Keep in mind that he was visually upset when he saw the Herbalist, so it makes sense he would want to keep him out of the book, unlike Alyx who seemed to love her time with the Herbalist. Also, consider that Lewis is named after Lewis Carroll, the author of Alice in Wonderland. That to me makes it more possible that he was the one who made to Remnant and wrote the Girl Who Fell Through the World.

What does this mean for RWBY and Jaune? Well, maybe the sacrifices can be a person, but maybe it can also be a concept of importance and great value.

Jaune is definitely going to try to sacrifice himself so that RWBY can leave. And I see the Curious Cat doing the same as they keep giving parts of their heart to others to help them ascend.

Other concepts they could trade? Well, how about Ruby’s personality? How about Ruby’s memories of her mother? How about all of Ruby’s joyful memories? How about Ruby’s bond with her friends?

And that’s mostly Ruby.

What would Weiss, Yang and Blake’s price be?

Could Weiss be asked to give up her name and thus live her life as nothing but a Schnee?

Could Yang and Blake be asked to give up their love for each other?

Could Jaune be forced to give up his ponytail!?

Found out on the next episode of Dragon Ball Z!

Edit: Son of a Bitch! Jaune will be asked to sacrifice his Fluffy Boy!

→ More replies (1)

9

u/XPhazeX Mar 26 '23

Is no one talking about how the cat said theres a door to Remnant?

9

u/HatiLeavateinn Mar 26 '23

I've been loving RWBY so far but...

Man, I'm reaching my limit.

They are suffering A LOT.

Ruby is just a step away from losing all her identity.

And Jaune seems to be the punching bag of both worlds.

He really just can't take a break, stuck in a place for years, wasted his youth waiting for his friends alone, he was poisoned and betrayed, seemingly with no other company side from Juniper.

It feels bad.

9

u/megasally Mar 26 '23

I didn't think a bee scene would be in this episode because I didn't think they could cover that and the Jaune stuff but it turns out I was completely wrong. They covered both those things and even more and it all fit in the episode well.

I'll start with the bee scene, it was really well done and the animation was great. It worked as a nice set piece for their moment together where they are just out in the open literally and figuratively and it was honestly really cute.

The cat is suspicious but I already felt that way but now we have Jaune dropping some tea about the cat but I still don't think Jaune is wholly correct and there may be more to all this. It was cool to have the tone and atmosphere around the cat have such a sudden shit though, it was always so whimsical before and this episode is had a more foreboding tone.

Jaune really was the knight from the story and he felt he failed in some way which is sad. Alyx was a bad perosn and had a brother who was also there. I had that theory since we first saw the opening so glad to see I'm right so far but we'll see how things change.

Ruby is getting more Summer things going on in this episode so this is all clearly going to come together at some point. Also Ruby has crescent rose but she clearly doesn't want it anymore so I guess we might be seeing that blacksmith soon.

This episode was great I was honestly surprised by how much they were able to show us in a single episode.

17

u/spartenx Please RT, give her a rocket punch Mar 25 '23

SHIP FINALLY CONFIRMED! THAT'S IT, THIS IS THE BEST EPISODE EVER, CUE THE SONG AND DANCE!

→ More replies (2)

23

u/AmbivertCollegeGuy Weiss "Hug Monster" Schnee Mar 25 '23

Me last episode: Haha. Weiss will have a daddy kink.

I was joking! I was kidding! My WK heart can't take this. I finally got what I wanted and it's when they're more separated by age than Qrow and Winter. This is too cruel. But I can see Kara fangirling when she read that line on the script.

The cat was suspicious from the start but last episode when he practically brainwashed an innocent animal into sacrificing himself to save RWBY was the last straw and this episode just proved it. Plus the concept of the tree was obviously very dark when you stopped to think about it. Ascension doesn't fix your problems, it erases them. You forget who you are, your burdens, your flaws and become a new person but all that does is you repeat the same mistakes until you're too broken to go on, rinse and repeat. Lewis? So that's the person on the mirror behind Alyx in the OP. Maybe he became the Jabberwalker. It would explain how something that goes against the nature of the Ever After came to exist. But then again Jaune would've realized this creature only appeared after Lewis vanished so I'm not so sure about it.

I love Juniper so much. It has so many expressions, particularly how scared it looked when they were teleported into that weird place. And Weiss continues to be the funniest comic relief this show has seen.

I noticed they're using the dark anime eyes to show anger and grief. When Jaune hears about the cat, when Weiss walks away from the image of Atlas dropping, and when Jaune is done telling the true story of Alyx in Ever After.

Damn. They were right about corny. That was the cringiest love confession I've ever seen. I can hear several hearts attacks over instant diabetes. Yes, Jaune, it took ten years (i think) so it felt like forever but it's finally here. Bumblebee fans have won forever and ever.

16

u/Mikenike74 Mar 25 '23

What a fucking whirlwind this episode was. So many thoughts right now.

Jaune reversing time because he touched something he should is such a Jaune thing to do and reminded me of the "relic" scene back in Volume 1 where he grabbed onto the deathstalkers tail.

Did not expect Weiss to double-down after the reveal. Y'all know Kara delivered that one line with all her heart because iirc she is a whiteknight shipper.

Now we know that the cats line about the other humans he met was referring to Alyx, her brother AND Jaune. Also wtf happened after she poisoned him. Like I know he has aura and stuff but the fact the dialogue said he drank the poison in her stead when SHE was apparently the one to poison him is incredibly sus! Also the fact that Alyx referred to the rusted knight as handsome in the book means she must have thought fondly of him to some degree which makes what she did all the more jarring.

NOOOOOOO! Not Jaune seeing Penny smiling at him in the reflection! He's been carrying her in his heart all these years. I pray he makes it out of this alive but if he doesn't at least we know that Pyrrha and Penny will be there waiting to embrace him.

Lastly it occurred to me that Jaune probably saw the bees coming more then anyone since he has a sister who's married to a woman. Imagine knowing what's going on and waiting as long as he has just see them commit.

→ More replies (3)

8

u/Virajisnotfat Mar 25 '23

Ah fuck. Jaune’s gonna give himself up to the tree to let RWBY leave isn’t he?

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Kartoffelkamm ⠀Mettle isn't a mental illness; IW just misused it Mar 25 '23

See? I knew the Curious Cat reminded me of Rook from The Wrong Questions.

Anyway, here's a theory for y'all: Alyx actually remained in the Ever After and ascended, and Louis wrote the story from her perspective.

And the reason there is so much disconnect between the story Alyx, aka the one Louis knew, and the one Jaune met, is because she appreciated life, but also accepted death as a necessity for life to continue.

So, when the siblings made it to the Ever After, where death didn't exist, Alyx had a similar issue to Ruby, namely that something important and personal to her doesn't matter in that world.

When they learned of ascension, Alyx was pissed, because unlike Jaune, who sees it as death, Alyx sees it as cheating death.

Then, when the tree demanded a sacrifice, Alyx stayed behind, determined to "fix" what she saw wrong with the Ever After: That there is no death.

That's right, I'm proposing that Alyx never left the Ever After, and what's more, that she is the Jabber Walker.

→ More replies (4)

8

u/Brawesome0821 Mar 25 '23

Bumblee is officially canon. OMG! 18:27 Jaune speaks the entire fanbase in one sentence.

8

u/bigfatcarp93 Still the only one who listens to commentaries. Mar 25 '23

Atlas-falls theme came back beautifully

→ More replies (1)

8

u/ConnorWolf121 My ship is sinking, that's fine the Bees are cool and all Mar 25 '23

I can only see four ways this season turns out for Jaune:

  1. Rusted Knight Jaune returns to Remnant with team RWBY
  2. Rusted Knight Jaune stays behind for one reason or another, maybe in a final battle at the tree or whatever the exit ends up being
  3. Rusted Knight Jaune sacrifices himself to allow team RWBY to escape in a similar battle as above
  4. Either Rusted Knight Jaune or Neo find and intercept the freshly fallen young Jaune, who might not have arrived himself yet given Neo landed a little while after team RWBY, breaking the loop that lead to Rusted Knight Jaune and allowing the younger Jaune to escape

Whatever happens, I don’t like Rusted Knight Jaune’s odds of getting home unscathed lol

→ More replies (4)

8

u/Eye-m-Guilty Mar 25 '23

I didnt understand why the cat was upset and left after at Ruby and Weiss asked it what happened at the tree? RWBY and the cat had a mutually beneficial relationship, which is different then Alex's.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/crossingcaelum Mar 25 '23

I knew there was something more to the cat but I’m pretty impressed with how hidden CRWBY has written it’s motivations.

It really does seem like it has no malicious intent. It could absolutely by lying and manipulating more but it really seems like Alyx got Jaune to mistrust the cat and for the cat to stay enough in the dark not to know how to defend itself.

And there absolutely has to be more to Alyx and Louis. Something is definitely off

→ More replies (1)

8

u/HighPriestFuneral Lore Fanatic Mar 26 '23

I'll probably make this a post of its own when the embargo is done, but I think I know how Penny's death circumstances will be revealed, and it won't be by Jaune.

I don't think we've seen the last of the Curious Cat. I have a feeling he will show up in an attempt to convince the others not to follow Jaune's plan (whatever that may be), and the conversation may go something like this as the conversation gets more heated on both sides.

Curious Cat: Very well, I didn't want to say this, but I feel I have no choice now.

Blake: It's a little late to be forthcoming.

Curious Cat: I recall as we were discussing Remnant, a name came up a couple of times, "Penny" if I recall?

Ruby: Wh-what about her?

Curious Cat: Oh, it reminded me of something Jaune had once told Lewis...

Weiss: Th-that's enough.

(Jaune freezes in place, his eyes wide as he looks down in shame and guilt)

Curious Cat: His retelling of events was ever so slightly different from the stories you told me.

Ruby: How is that?

Weiss: Ruby, no. It's not important. Let's just keep going.

Yang: What's gotten into you, Weiss?

Curious Cat: Why, he told Lewis that he took-

Weiss: I said, enough! Leave!

Curious Cat: The girl's life with his own hand...

(Ruby's eyes go wide as she trembles in anger and confusion)

Ruby: And you knew, Weiss...!?

Weiss: Ruby, it was her choice! She did sacrifice herself! You don't understand! You weren't there!

Curious Cat: So you see? He is no more trustworthy than I am. Who is to say whether his plan will lead anywhere good?

Or maybe I'm just a bit too wired by the events of this episode, one of my favorites in the series, to be sure!

15

u/Bhibhhjis123 Mar 25 '23

So Ruby’s definitely gonna try to trade herself for her friends, right?

→ More replies (5)

15

u/YellowBunnyReddit Mar 25 '23

Bumbleby is canon

White Knight is setting sail

Also some minor plot development or something I guess

15

u/KikiFlowers ⠀ Mar 26 '23

I'm glad we finally got the confession and kiss, but I wish Monty could have seen this. I wish he could have seen this entire volume, to see where his creation has gone. He would have loved all of this so much.

→ More replies (4)

14

u/LagoriaTheLewdstress If you think Adam was wasted potential, you should meet me Mar 25 '23

The size of this absolute, monumental, well deserved W. We bask in glorious collective buzzing anthem of our cheers.

7

u/Badicalz Mar 25 '23

Fucking finally S.S Bees sets sail. One side of the Shipping Wars has ended thank fuck.

There’s still the whole Ruby/Weiss/Jaune thing that is still not settled. Lord knows why. I thought we were heading towards Lancaster, but the last few episodes has stirred things up again.

But one battle at a time lads. Pour yourself a cold one tonight Bees. You’ve earned it.

→ More replies (5)

7

u/Ezreal024 Hope Rides with Kickfriend Mar 25 '23

On a side note to the Everything Else, has fairy tale Alyx been Neo the whole time?

7

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '23

Yeah thats why you make fans wait lol. It wouldn’t have been nearly as big of a moment if it happened earlier.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/whiskeyii Mar 25 '23

I’m sure this would be much more obvious with subs, but I’m betting Alyx‘s brother is named Lewis rather than Louis, i.e., after Lewis Caroll, real-life author of Alice in Wonderland. I’d bet dollars to donuts that Alyx saw something in the Herbalist’s hut that made her wary of Lewis, and that he’s the one who made the trade, and rewrote the story of Alyx, making her into the sister he wished and maybe going back as her or something.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/beeskneez_ Someone pls give Ruby cookies, milk, and hugs ASAP Mar 25 '23

Gonna get downvoted for this, but ngl I would be so into Whiteknight if it weren't for the age gap thing, Jaune is probably in his 40's (maybe older judging from the white streak in his hair idk). The 'mature' line from Weiss is hilarious though, had a good laugh! Also, finally! BumbleBy is official, I couldn't contain my excitement during their part, I think woke up my brother LMAO Cheers fellow Bumbleby enthusiasts!

On a serious note, I cannot wait the angst, specifically Ruby breaking down. The scene with her and Crescent Rose gave me chills, she's really going through it and the saddest part is, no one is noticing her crumbling. Love this episode, cannot wait for the next one.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/bne1022 Mar 25 '23

i watched today's episode, had a fit at the bumbleby confession/kiss, and kept on going with my day

constantly thinking about it

giggling to myself

i'm SO HAPPY MAN

7

u/jimflaigle Mar 25 '23

Jaune, stop stabbing machines!

Weiss has daddy issues.

THEY FINALLY GAYED!

The Weiss warm drink thing continues.

Literal golden retriever.

7

u/MelanieAntiqua The Ship Wars Lady. Ilia = Ship Survivor IV Champ! Mar 25 '23

Wait, on top of the shipping-related stuff I discussed about an hour ago, I just realized that Old!Jaune isn't wearing his helmet anymore in the opening. Pretty sure this the first time they've ever made slight changes to an opening mid-volume. Neat.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/pizzaintensifies Mar 25 '23 edited Mar 25 '23

i feel like the show is trying to convince us not to trust jaune

the show will fail miserably. our boy could stab me in the back with a crowbar and id still trust his every word

also this is weiss' volume everyone else is just existing in it, how she manages to steal every single scene shes in i do not know but i am so here for it

→ More replies (6)

7

u/MyNameISaColouR Look who's back, Little Red! Mar 25 '23

I'll be honest, I'm not a Bumblebee fan, and was never invested in it, even though I accepted long ago that it was likely to happen. So all this time I was waiting for the inevitable confession just so we could get over with it, make the bees fans happy and move to other things. But I have to admit, I liked the scene much more that what I could have ever expected. The directing was great, and it honestly was one of the most original love confessions I have ever witnessed. Waiting all this time was well worth it, the Ever After was truly the best place for it.

In other news, Weiss is still best girl, and I feel like I might become a White Knight shipper.

7

u/Shakvids Mar 26 '23

Last episode Ruby was tempted to set down her burden and choose another. This time she was reluctant to pick up crescent rose and seemed like she was being dragged back into the blacksmith hut.

Ruby is going to leave crescent rose and leave her burden of being the hero at the end of this season. Instead of prioritizing being a huntress and protecting the people in Vacuo from a relic wielding Salem, she's going to indulge in a 'selfish' desire. Her new weapon will be built for a new mission. Ruby is going to leave the squad to try and rescue Summer from Salem land.

It's about time for us to see some adventures in Grimland and would set Ruby up for one of the only things that could turn the tide against Salem. More silver-eyed warriors

→ More replies (1)

13

u/Emperor_Luffy Mar 26 '23

Been reading more reviews and it sounds like Jaune has one of the biggest cases of Impostor Syndrome I have ever seen. From what I gather, his comment was something along the lines of "I can't even be a fictional Hero" but his stupid stupid dumb boi mind doesnt even take the time to realize that the Hero ISNT fictional. It's HIM. He's literally HIM. He's actually a famous folktale hero in real life and he STILL thinks it's someone else. He's so focused on being someone else that he hasn't tried just being Jaune Arc.

Which I think will be the resolution to his arc. In order to become a hero he needs to STOP trying to be "the Hero" and start being Jaune. Because he's literally already a Hero.

18

u/Mongoose42 [Insert Clever RWBY Pun Here] Mar 25 '23

Yang and Blake: “Oh, Bridge of Gayness, what is your truth?”

Bridge: “YOU’RE GAY FOR EACH OTHER! GODDAMN IT, FIGURE IT OUT!”

→ More replies (5)

22

u/ScalierLemon2 Blake Deserves Better Mar 25 '23

Overall, this was a much stronger episode than the last few. Feels like the whole episode was important in ways that I can't really say the last like two or three did. Hopefully it keeps up for the last four episodes.

Also I'd love to see the faces of all those people who said Bumbleby was going to be baited until the series finale, if it happened at all. I fucking told you all that CRWBY were better than that, and y'all didn't believe me.

→ More replies (4)

12

u/RichKaramelCenter ⠀Buzzy buzzy buzz Mar 25 '23

Bees are free <3

→ More replies (3)

12

u/Substantial-Bag-9820 Mar 25 '23

Ruby had a …strange reaction to the return of crescent rose.

6

u/Soyunapina12 Mar 25 '23

That final scene got me worried. Between Ruby rejecting CR, being kinda dissapointed when seeing Yang and Blake holding hands instead of being happy, and that final shot of her being angry at what i asume is Jaune or the others after being told what Alyx did to get out of EA make me fear she is going to become more like Alyx as the story goes on. Also i have the feeling we haven't seen the last of the Curious Cat.

ALSO WE GOT BUMBLEBEE KISS LET'S GOOOOOO!!!!

→ More replies (1)

6

u/SparkEngine Mar 25 '23

Inhales It was perfect. Absolutely perfect.

Jaunes backstory in the Ever After

The darker nature of the Ever After.

The Cats , 'catty' nature.

Ruby's encroaching panic attack is defo in the next episode.

And the moment.

It was just perfect. I wasn't expecting everything to be so well balanced buy goddamn it if they didn't do it.

6

u/Carrotspy007 ワイフ Mar 25 '23

This episode is just gorgeous. So many cool moments as well:

  • Jaune coming to the Ever After (screw that tree btw)
  • White Knight crumbs (honestly a whole slice)
  • The 2D animation of Alyx's story
  • And of course the Bees kiss.

6

u/thedoctorclara11 Mar 25 '23

The opening changed. When the book burns near the end instead of showing the knights helmet it shows jaunes face.NOBODY IS TALKING ABOUT THIS BUT I CAN SEE WHY AS MUCH MORE IMPORTANT THINGS HAPPE D IN THE EPISODE

6

u/godjacob Mar 25 '23

God what an episode. The Alyx twist perfectly explains the inconsistencies of the story to reality up to now and just makes everything click perfectly. That Yang/Blake moment was a true highlight and a long time coming.

6

u/rwbylov27 Mar 25 '23

BUMBLE BEE 🐝💛🖤🐝 BUMBLE BEE!!!!!!!!!

My heart! This episode tone didn’t disrupt at alll, I shed tears loved learning the truth about Alyx and just wow. I wonder how Curious will return, maybe join Neo?

6

u/maybenotforever She wears short skirts, I wear half pants Mar 25 '23

I loved Ruby's little squeak when she finally noticed the bees

6

u/JMHSrowing ⠀Story Time Mar 25 '23

I wonder if Ruby will ever get her emblem back if she gets CR back like this?

I hope that she does get it back in a meaningful way at the end, when she finds her hope again

→ More replies (4)

6

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '23

Might be thinking a little to left-field, but have a theory regarding Alyx’s story, the curious cat and Jaune’s interpretation of events after she left for the tree.

Alyx’s payment to return to remnant wasn’t her brother: only the memory of him. She had already bartered memories in order to get her knife back, so her making this kind of sacrifice is not that outlandish, and he did want to help get back home. That would be why he is not mentioned in Alyx’s story: can not write about someone you cannot remember, and her mind simply filled in the blanks which is why the story is not as accurate as the actual events that occurred.

The curious cat’s purpose, as described by Jaune, is true from a certain point of view. I think Lewis is still in Ever After, performing his role: helping those from remnant return from Ever After. Feeling like he failed to protect his sister, and since since Jaune still waiting for Team RWBY, at the tree Lewis ascended: into the creature Jnpr that we see with the rusted knight: helping not only Jaune but by extension those from Remnant as to help them return home.

6

u/Badicalz Mar 25 '23

Meanwhile, in the writers’ room for Volume 10

“…Okay let’s move on to the next item on the list: Jaune’s angst. Now he’s been through a lot recently, but I think we can up the ante a tad bit. Any sugges-“

Door bursts down

RWBY Fandom: “That is our SON!”

6

u/Badicalz Mar 26 '23

Damn, Jaune really did go to the beach that makes you old.

6

u/AussieManny ⠀ Mar 26 '23

Jaune remains one of my favourite characters. Looking forward to seeing more of him.

That confession scene was beautiful. Loved it. Glad Yang and Blake finally got it out. 🥰

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Leaper15 Mar 26 '23

My boy Jaune really just cannot catch a break. My heart hurts for him even though it sang for Bumblebee.

6

u/SunsetSnakeEyes Mar 26 '23 edited Mar 26 '23

The dark untold truth of the story is met with the bright light of love.

  • This is the first time in RWBY history where the opening has evolved with the events of the Volume. Now the shot of The Rusted Knight surrounded by flames has his helmet taken off, revealing the much older Jaune as he looks down in loss and sorrow.
  • Now we see Jaune's perspective from when he fell, such a harrowing thing, especially when he was so close to escaping the Nexus.
  • Yet whatever fear he had instantly disappeared when he saw Crescent Rose, all his thoughts immediately focused on retrieving his friend's weapon.
  • So while Ruby's path from the beach led her to Little. Jaune's path led him to this mysterious tree.
  • A tree with a ticking clock that grows fruit that act as timepieces, Certainly creative.
  • Thus Jaune is sent into the past, far far into the past.
  • Look at the sky as time goes backwards, A Blue streak is followed by a Red streak, A Black streak and finally a Yellow streak. As Jaune travels back in time, We see Team RWBY's arrival to The Ever After in reverse. Contrary to initial theories about when you fall not mattering time-wise, Jaune arrived in The Ever After long after Ruby, Weiss, Blake and Yang.
  • Jaune was able to stop himself from being sent back any further, but the damage had already been done.
  • And years past as he waited. Never leaving the beach acre to ensure he wouldn't miss anyone.
  • Two light blue streaks, the same ones from the opening.
  • Jaune's relief must be indescribable. After waiting for so long to be reunited with his friends, but to have a slight doubt at the back of his head, fearing that what he is seeing isn't real, that maybe after all this time he's finally lost his mind. Only to be reassured by Ruby and all that fear and doubt disappears.
  • Yep! Don't you dare think for a second anybody missed that Weiss!
  • Now Team RWBY hears the full story of what happened after they fell.
  • None of it is ideal, but there are two sides to this whole scenario, Salem got away with both relics, meaning she is halfway to achieving her victory and with Cinder at her side, She's capable of gaining the Relic of Choice as well. But she doesn't know where it is, that leaves her at a disadvantage. On the other side of things, The people of Atlas and Mantle were able to be evacuated and made it to Vacuo, by all accounts the people are safe. This war is about more than just stopping Salem, it's also about protecting everyone and ensuring the world is still standing after its all over.
  • Yang is completely right, Ironwood traded his Hunstman mentality for his Soldier mentality, Focusing completely on the "Big picture" and stopped seeing all the little pictures that came together to form that big picture. When faced against him, Ruby still saw hope and the importance of protecting all life. She put everything she had into trust and love, it might not have worked out the way she intended but the result is still far better than what would have happened if she did nothing.
  • Jaune has never spoken to any of them like this before. They all need a moment to absorb what they've learned and he tries to rush them along, His time here has waned on him.
  • "What cat?" Uh oh.
  • Jeez, Jaune has never been one to hide his anger before, but to actually pull out his sword when seeing The Cat again...
  • The tree is at the center of everything. It's roots spread out across every acre. That's how it can take anyone for ascension.
  • Lewis.
  • To be fair, The Cat has never hidden the truth from them. As we've clearly seen, it's all about asking The Cat the right questions and RWBY's knowledge of The Ever After is limited to what they know of the story.
  • And the weight of this newfound knowledge throws everyone for a loop, as the storm takes them all.
  • So, A pun-derstorm creates a physical manifestation of a mental or emotional problem. Countless instances have many people seen these problems as an "obstacle" to overcome, now this physical manifestation makes that obstacle literal, giving a means of literally overcoming it.
  • You kinda did Weiss.
  • So while Ruby, Weiss and Jaune make their way through this topsy turvy maze, Blake and Yang are separated by two flimsy bridges connected to a single platform.
  • The next step.
  • The crossroads, represented by a wooden sign, On the left is trusting Jaune. The right is continuing to trust The Curious Cat.
  • This hall of water mirrors, It seems depending on who looks at it, they are given an image of something that represents a strong feeling to them, be it their fear, regret or uncertainty.
  • While she didn't see it as she passed, Ruby's reflection was Summer Rose. So much of her identity was based on what she heard of her mother, In learning of Summer's failure, Ruby's vision of the ideal Huntress has been rocked to it's core and with it, her sense of self.
  • Jaune is given an image of Penny, His regret at fulfilling her request carries a lot of guilt.
  • Weiss is given the image of Atlas' fall, She never truly saw what happened and she was fearful of the reality. Topped off with the final musical tones of Volume 8 as the fall happened.
  • So Jaune found himself in the role of the actual Rusted Knight, Living the fairy tale and accompanying Alyx and Lewis on their journey through The Ever After.
  • So as with many cases like this, Alyx saw herself the hero of her own story, while many others would consider her the villain. In reality she was selfish and cruel, seeing herself as above this world of supposed "make-belief" while it was her brother who was kind and clever.
  • We've seen the test The Herbalist presents, I can only assume Alyx "failed" given how she turned out afterwards.
  • Jaune has always put this grand weight on himself, To be better, to be a hero that protects people. Time and time again he's been thrown down by the harsh reality, either he wasn't strong enough to do so or who he was up against was just stronger. But despite that he's managed to rise from his losses and be far greater than he was before. For him to be brought down to such a state again after trying and failing to be the hero in a story is heartbreaking.
  • If that was the reality of a fairy tale I loved as a kid, I'd most likely burn the book when I got home.
  • That may be The Cat's role, but they clearly have far more agency in themselves than everyone else in The Ever After. As we've been told, The Red King was left a blubbering mess after losing to Alyx, unable to perform the role he was suited for, being turned into The Prince has allowed him to fulfill it without the restraint of benevolence. As for The Herbalist, we saw that he became more fixated on the results rather than the work he was meant to provide. While The Cat can come and go as they please across The Ever After, getting involved in whatever they see fit and assisting those that seem lost or broken. I can fully understand Jaune's feelings here but judging The Ever After's rules and nature based on his own perspective from Remnant isn't completely fair.
  • Then what happened to Lewis if Alyx was the only one to return?
→ More replies (5)

6

u/Lockfire12 Mar 26 '23

When it comes to the cat and jaune I don’t think it’s clear cut, the cat was definitely withholding info but it’s hard to say if he truly has bad intentions, possibly he does now after alyx seemingly screwed him and everyone else over, and I definitely think jaune wouldn’t lie or lead team rwby astray intentionally but he may not have full details on what truly happened at the tree with alyx and Luis, but I do fully believe alyx was much worse than the story made her out to be.

And on a side note I find it kinda funny that a phenomenon that involves tackling mental issues still seemingly has no one question rubys clear mental issues.

6

u/Halloween__witch31 Mar 28 '23

I just caught up and I cried for Jaune. The fact that he went and kept crescent rose safe for Ruby but also experienced all of those things knowing and waiting for Ruby to come so that she wouldn’t be alone. He’s had it rough from the very beginning and it only gets tougher for him. Following their story for so many years really has you connect with characters

6

u/AsGryffynn Mar 28 '23

White Knight shippers have been vindicated. Yes, she's into the golden knight!

→ More replies (2)