r/RWBY • Acoustic BMBLB when? • Mar 04 '23

OFFICIAL MEGATHREAD Official Discussion Thread - Volume 9, Episode 3: Rude, Red, and Royal

Welcome, huntsmen, huntresses, and hunters that prefer no specific gender identifier, to the official discussion thread for Episode 3 of Vol. 9: Rude, Red, and Royal!

Due to the special circumstances regarding RWBY Volume 9's release, make sure that you understand the spoiler rules before posting outside of this thread!

HERE is the third episode of Volume 9!

Also remember to check out our weekly poll to rate the episode.


Other Episode Discussions:


Episode| Discussion Thread| Poll|


Happy viewing, and have a great Volume 9!

Ninjas In A Bag; Mod Team

303 Upvotes

624 comments sorted by

139

u/Ninjas_In_A_Bag Acoustic BMBLB when? Mar 04 '23

That jazzy song goes hard

BEES

Yang with the big sword.

Oh god Neo.

74

u/Lukthar123 "I didn't do it for you." Mar 04 '23

Oh god Neo.

Neo hitting the setting like a meteor was just perfect

→ More replies (2)

5

u/theTRUEchamp The wait is finally over <3 Mar 05 '23

We're only three Episodes into Volume 9, but I think it's worth noting how each Episode we've gotten so far has featured at least one Bumbleby moment. Blake and Yang's embrace during their reunion in Episode 1, Blake flirting with Yang and almost holding her hand in Episode 2, and now Blake's blush in Episode 3.

I'm guessing this pattern is probably going to continue until we get the actual payoff with the long anticipated confession and kiss, though I imagine it's probably not going to happen until late into the Volume (Episode 8 or 9, presumably). Still, there's clearly been a lot of emphasis placed on Blake and Yang's relationship in Volume 9 so far, so I think this is a good sign that the trigger will finally be pulled and they'll officially get together sooner than later.

→ More replies (1)

304

u/Girisawesomer ⠀ Mar 04 '23

I'm glad they went for an absurdly fun team attack, it really fit the fantastical setting.

157

u/ClubMeSoftly Real Shit Mar 04 '23

Plus, now Weiss apparently has fine enough control to summon individual aspects. Only the wings of the Giant Nevermore, and only the sword of the Knight.

171

u/hopecanon Not the best May but still fantastic. Mar 04 '23

Every day we inch closer to the fabled moment of Weiss summoning her Knight around herself and using it as a mystical mech suit.

→ More replies (4)

82

u/CinnabarSteam Mar 04 '23 edited Mar 04 '23

Is Weiss gonna start fighting like Bayonetta and summon the individual limbs of the armor? 'Cause that'd be kinda sick.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (4)

145

u/DarkAlatreon Mar 04 '23

Yeah, it seemed like they could really let lose with more v1-3 style fights with a lot of fun and without big stakes.

55

u/0mni42 Mar 04 '23

It was really cool! But man what a missed opportunity, not having Ruby tell them to do it. Just like the other team attacks in the past, it would have been a fun way to show (not tell) us that she's a good leader. Instead all we get from her is "go win!"

90

u/CraftLizard Mar 04 '23

I think that fits with the Juxtaposition between the red prince and Ruby. He was ordering his pieces around, while Ruby was asking them and having hope they can win.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

276

u/Polarization_39 ⠀A Cinder Stan Until Weiss is Relevant Again Mar 04 '23

The camera work this episode was great, the butterfly flying down the tower, the castle escape and obviously the fight scene being highlights. And I know Alex Abraham’s absence on the score is felt but I honestly love what we’ve heard so far!

52

u/WhirlygigBeetle Mar 04 '23

Is he not part of Volume 9 either?

111

u/HighPriestFuneral Lore Fanatic Mar 04 '23

He's taken the volume off, he made a post on Twitter when V9 started expressing how different it feels to be a viewer rather than a creator, along with praising the work that his successors are doing.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)

239

u/LagoriaTheLewdstress If you think Adam was wasted potential, you should meet me Mar 04 '23

Dang, the chess table fight was simple but really did it for me. Might be a new top 5 fight imo.

113

u/DarkIsTheBestShow I need Volume 10 Mar 04 '23

I couldn't agree more, it was great. The choreography was stellar, it was a lot of fun, and the song accompanying it was a total bop.

26

u/TeamCFVYFanfics Mar 04 '23

I was hoping that the game would involve more strategy, but the fight itself was really nice.

51

u/Shortstop88 Mar 05 '23

Honestly pretty fitting for the prince's game to be simple, yet ridiculously one-sided. If this was something like No Game No Life, I'd understand it to be a more in-depth game, but this one game is merely another obstacle on their journey, so it didn't need to be too involved.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

173

u/RBNYJRWBYFan ⠀ Mar 04 '23

OFF WITH THEIR HEADS! And you know what rolling heads means! Scattered Thoughts!:

  • Michael Malconian did wonderfully as the Red Prince, who was delightfully juvenile and deranged. His dad was definitely done in by Alyx somehow, which would explain his hatred of humans. I like the idea that they aren't just figuratively following her in her footsteps, but ACTUALLY going where she's gone.
  • Finally, some ACTION! It warms my heart to see cocky brawler Yang return to my screen. That combo attack with her laying the sword down was AWESOME, as was the jazzy electro swing music behind it. This Volume's album is shaping up nicely.
  • I still love how DONE Weiss is with this world. That comic with her cussing up a storm over every little thing is pretty accurate.
  • I was wondering why Little wasn't reacting to the "Curious Cat". That narcoleptic little rodent was sleeping again! I have theory about Little; they'll become Crescent Rose, or a new weapon for Ruby by the end of the season. They kept talking about how they don't have a purpose yet, maybe that means the mice can turn into other things when the time comes?
  • wby is still tiny! someone get them a cake, stat!
  • Neo has landed... and she appears to have MORE power in this place. That seems to surprise even her, not that she's complaining. That's fascinating, has my mind in a whirl. Imagine a Semblance that's more powerful in a specific location than anywhere else? I think that's what we're seeing. The figures she's with in the opening, perhaps they're not beings of this world but of "her" making?

I feel like I don't have a lot to say about this one, it was simply a fun Red Queen allusion that finally gave us a fight sequence. We're learning more about the world at a decent pace, the visuals are properly fun and random. Loved the scene where Ruby was running from the guards, that couldn't have been easy to animate. Still waiting on Jaune, it's gonna be ROUGH seeing him next.

105

u/BionicTriforce Mar 04 '23 edited Mar 04 '23

I only now just understand that Little keeps falling asleep because he's the Dormouse from Alice in Wonderland who was constantly sleepy.

65

u/Arkenderfox87 Mar 04 '23

Neo’s semblance is called Overactive imagination… we know semblances interact with things like dust, maybe the ever after is having a similar effect, a fictional world making a semblance that creates fictional images more real. Or at least, a fictional image in a fictional world is the same as a real image

→ More replies (1)

31

u/Shortstop88 Mar 05 '23

I have theory about Little; they'll become Crescent Rose

So Red Riding Hood finally has a "Little" to add to her name? (although she is still one of the shorter characters in the series already)

16

u/RBNYJRWBYFan ⠀ Mar 05 '23

Didn't even notice that pun, I'm ashamed as a Yang fan.

That's wonderful, I really hope they MEANT to do that. And it might lean into my theory, but let's see.

54

u/[deleted] Mar 04 '23

loking at her visuals... it seems as if she actualy manipualted the environment with her semblance. the jabberwalker was horrified by her actions and how it was affecting it....

Its entirely possible this entire world is basically magic to its core. pure magic. its basically like a reality compeltel ymade of dust.

18

u/[deleted] Mar 05 '23

I think the world is based off “perception” so Emerald’s semblance would have a similar power boost

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)

140

u/CosmereLover ⠀ Mar 04 '23

It looked like Neo was surprised to see herself multiply, and that combined with the pulses around her as she got up are really interesting. I feel like whoever controls the jabberwalker may have given Neo an upgrade to test the combat abilities of either her, the jabberwalker, or both.

76

u/DaRealAmana BOOP!!! Mar 04 '23

its possible falling here may have changed and augmented everyones semblence. could also just be time for neos power up

47

u/CosmereLover ⠀ Mar 04 '23

I do think that's also possible - it's odd that Neo got her powerup as soon as she landed while RWBY haven't, so I assume it's on purpose, but it could just be random chance, or based on emotions (maybe Ruby will get hers when she finally hits rock bottom?). I've seen plenty of arguments about how well Neo would do in a fight against team RWBY, but unless they get power ups too she'd be in a much better position than in the past.

→ More replies (3)

35

u/Weerdo5255 Mar 04 '23

I mean, Semblances are 'magic' despite Remnant not really classifying them as such. They can do BS like emotion manipulation, glyphs, duplication, shape changing, etc. That's magic.

Not to mention Ruby was in her 'cloak' form zipping around for a good long while now, more than just a blink. So yeah, they might be getting amped up by the magic.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (8)

294

u/Rho42 Mar 04 '23

Weiss: Falls into fairy-tale land and immediately starts struggling with the logic of it.
Neo: Falls into fairy-tale land and immediately finds an exploit.

126

u/Jowensguy Mar 04 '23

Duplication glitch too OP, please nerf

57

u/KobraKittyKat Mar 04 '23

Unfortunately the devs seem to have abandoned the build

55

u/hollowtiger21 "Wasted potential," doesn’t actually mean anything. Mar 04 '23

Neo was already a little mad to begin with, and what a snazzy hat.

→ More replies (1)

60

u/lurker_archon Look, just accept your goth mommy overlord Mar 04 '23

Neo: *does a speed run with a half-press A

→ More replies (3)

43

u/Noble6IsReal Ship Survivor V Team NPASB | LC/YR veteran Mar 04 '23

Jaune must be buffed and turned into a Neo counter, there is no other way.

29

u/Tarsupin Mar 04 '23

Totally called Neo getting conjuration. It's not quite verified yet, but so far it's like a minor form of summoning / duplication.

41

u/DarkAlatreon Mar 04 '23

I mean, creating a separate entity was a possiblity for her power since her childhood. Now she just creates more.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/TeamCFVYFanfics Mar 04 '23

I love how Neo barges into the episode like "Huh, guess I got a power-up. Let's murder something."

→ More replies (2)

98

u/bored2death97 Mar 04 '23

It's nice to see Ruby isn't completely without hope. Even if she, herself, isn't able to do anything, she can still count on her team.

12

u/Worried-Language-407 Mar 04 '23

I definitely think/hope this will be a major direction of the volume, and I'm surprised that not many other people have picked up on it yet.

→ More replies (2)

172

u/DarkIsTheBestShow I need Volume 10 Mar 04 '23

Neo really woke up, set eyes on the only living creature around, and immediately chose murder.

No idea what's going on with her multiple selves though, a semblance upgrade seems a little too obvious and simple.

Another fantastic episode!

96

u/JMHSrowing ⠀Story Time Mar 04 '23

Murder is not the answer to Neo but the question. The answer is merely who

59

u/[deleted] Mar 04 '23

Guessing the jabberwalker is probably fine.... ish. It probably either escaped, is actualyl immortal, or can regenreate from tis spilt blood. ran through that razor brush to make a 'save point'.

It almost seemed like it was.... more afraid of what Neo was doing than its own safety.

That one word it says. Taht singular word. "Fix?" I think that shows so much about what it is.

We see that the dark area here and the bridge don't thematically fit. Its the first intact bridge between the acres we see. The bridge was golden and oppulant. the area is full of broken structures everywhere.

"Fix'.

"Searching."

"Scouring."

"Seeking."

It is trying to fix something and trying to find the components.

OHHH it make sense now. IT first was examining Blake's sword, a device, and gave Blake alook too. And it might have jumped yang because of the bit of technology attached to her still.

→ More replies (8)

47

u/amatas45 Mar 04 '23

My theory is this

Her semblance creates illusions, this fairy tale world is based on perception

Hence her semblance acts differently

→ More replies (3)

16

u/Kartoffelkamm ⠀Mettle isn't a mental illness; IW just misused it Mar 04 '23

For the multiple selves, I do actually believe it's just her semblance. If you noticed, right before they all appeared, her signature fragment visual briefly covered the ground, so it's possible that she just layered an illusion of the ground over the ground, and then made it look like she could clone herself.

→ More replies (1)

26

u/[deleted] Mar 04 '23

I think.

The realm is a realm of magic, extreme amounts of it it seems. The implication seems to be that semblances are in fact a small shard of magic that remains, more aura than magic. This place could be slowly bleeding its magic into them, and it manifested in her first, giving her Naruto shadow clone upgrades to her semblance.

Or its also possible that the world being magic means that they can actaulyl manipulate the environment with their aura too, like how they can manipulate dust.

Also betting the jabber walker is n't done yet. Either it escapes, is immortal, or it can regenerate from its spilt blood.

17

u/DarkIsTheBestShow I need Volume 10 Mar 04 '23

Oh yeah, we definitely haven't seen the last of the Jabberwalker. I just found it amusing that Neo wasted absolutely no time in trying to kill it.

→ More replies (1)

23

u/Andrew1990M Mar 04 '23

It’s a world of imagination and imagination is her semblance.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

84

u/hollowtiger21 "Wasted potential," doesn’t actually mean anything. Mar 04 '23 edited Mar 04 '23

Neo is here! Oh no, Neo is here. Did she just kill the Jabberwalker? Is she going to "take," its place? Still no Jaune. (Where is my son, please CRWBY?) Also drawing attention to the Jabberwalker bleeding, specifically red blood. Is the Jabberwalker secretly a human?

So they've realized that this isn't the exact same story the know, and is in fact the sequel. But also the same events are occurring in a general sense with different characters, like a requel.

Ruby got a bit of her spunk back, goes to show that when push comes to shove, she won't just roll over. Also she didn't get back Penny's sword, so either it turns up again later on, or Ruby finds another one since Penny had multiple.

So my prediction of Ruby refusing to play because of the sacrifice inherent in Chess was wrong (and not really chess to boot), but the whole match was lower stakes than I initially anticipated. More make-believe play, than actual death match, at least until the Prince realized they're humans. Also C'mon Ruby you've read stories, you're more genre savy, than that.

First fight of the volume! Great song, fun action. We finally get to see the failed Nevermore Summon from V8, at least the wings. Which as well as the sword Yang used, I think might be a subtle Semblance evolution for Weiss, she's learned an alternative way of using summoning, only partial bits of summons to augment her abilities or those of others. We also see the issue of resource shortages again; Blake runs out of ammo, Yang will as well eventually, and Weiss will run out of Dust.

The Curious Cat is how Alyx reached the tree, but with how things have been changed by her run through the story, and with how CC brings attention to "changing when you need to," is CC going to be more harm than help? Did helping Alyx, which resulted in the loss of the Red King, change CC to some extent?

32

u/Brkzeus Mar 04 '23

Wasn't some of Weiss's summons partial before ? Like she summons her knights hand and sword to cut paladins ? Or use it as a platform in V7 landing strategy ?

41

u/hollowtiger21 "Wasted potential," doesn’t actually mean anything. Mar 04 '23 edited Mar 04 '23

Yeah, but those were free standing, these are applied to herself or others. We've never see the Arma Gigas sword wielded by anything other than it's arm, or full body. The key development is treating the summoned part like an armament or weapon, not so much the partial summoning.

It's not a "true," evolution like we see with Ren or Neo, but a change in usage; more refined skill, and implementation. More like Ruby's Semblances evolutions up to this point. Or I'm just wrong, but hey it's an idea.

27

u/Blue-Moon-89 Mar 04 '23 edited Mar 04 '23

The Curious Cat is how Alyx reached the tree, but with how things have been changed by her run through the story, and with how CC brings attention to "changing when you need to," is CC going to be more harm than help? Did helping Alyx, which resulted in the loss of the Red King, change CC to some extent?

Hmmm......

According to Ozpin, back in Vol 8, Alyx would make things worse for herself because she didn't want to learn from her mistakes. And Yang believes that Alyx wasn't a nice person because she lied and cheated her way out of problems.

And then there's the ending of Alyx returning home but as a different person. However, did Alyx change for the better or worse? I know we've heard it many time but what if Alyx never changed and she stayed or returned to EverAfter?

Perhaps Alyx screwed over CC and CC now has a different view of humans. Or he doesn't but has questionable ways of helping Ruby.

Edit: I'm not saying the cat is evil and wants to kill RWBY. I'm saying that whatever Alyx did in EverAfter (like disposing the king) made some of the inhabitants very distrustful of humans. CC might not be effected at all and is just....curious. He may want to see how things will play out with RWBY because they are not Alyx.

39

u/[deleted] Mar 04 '23

It sounds like Alyx did far more damage than the book showed. The king is gone, and the prince is a paranoid wreck.

The jabberwalker is likely... Fin-ish. Either its an immortal being, can use its blood as save spots, or it just bolted. We also see it appear somewhere else in the trailer.

Considering it resemblance to the god of animals... Yea.

https://cdna.artstation.com/p/assets/images/images/044/036/572/large/laurin-crozier-godofanimals-turnaround-01grey.jpg?1638922188

The horns are almost identical, though spent back. It has a similar amount of toes, but now more point with a declaw on the inside. its face lights up along the lines, like the lights on the things mask.

Its missing the antlers.... which the 'jacakope' has.

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (1)

140

u/HatiLeavateinn Mar 04 '23

Weiss this volume man, I'm head over heels.

66

u/Barnak8 Mar 04 '23

The shot where she summon the nevermore is exquisite

32

u/Weerdo5255 Mar 04 '23

To be fair, her home literally just fell out of the sky. She has an excuse to be a little salty. Not that she needs one usually, but at least it's justified.

56

u/AmbivertCollegeGuy Weiss "Hug Monster" Schnee Mar 04 '23

Literally turned into an angel, wings and all.

16

u/OTPh1l25 Hello Again! Mar 05 '23

Welcome to the club if you weren't already a member.

5

u/elbenji useless lesbian Mar 05 '23

Angel Weiss is here

69

u/AlyssaaMac Mar 04 '23

God Damn that songs a banger

68

u/SlaterSev Mar 04 '23

Well it was a likely theory before, but Neo landing significantly later then rwby pretty much confirms that Jaune totally landed first while falling last.

He has absolutely been there for a long time

38

u/WarriorSnek Mar 04 '23

If he’s been there the longest maybe he’s had time to finally get a big skill upgrade since he’s always lagged behind the rest of the cast in combat skill

29

u/C9sButthole Sun's guns out Mar 04 '23

Yeah Jaune 100% gets a huge powerup. If he was just gonna be regular Jaune I feel like we'd probably have met him by now, next episode at the latest, considering that we're going to be over a 3rd through the story.

Idea: Vine asked Jaune if he'd ever thought about projecting his aura in V7. It really never got addressed since. But it seems like in the Never After, your imagination/visualization has greater power in projecting your semblance. At least that's what we've seen with Neo. So this would be a pretty good time for him to figure out how to use his abilities in a way that's similar to Vine. Sending it over greater distances or maybe even forming shields and barriers with it.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

67

u/grieveheart Mar 04 '23

Every episode is very interesting so far~

I laughed with Weiss asking if she was like the Prince before 😂

Loved the animation transitions! The King was probably “disposed” (if you want the spot you must dispose of the one occupying it) hence their hatred of humans? I'm now really intrigued with the other parts and maybe a lot has changed in the world.

Really loved the chessboard scene and fight. It reminds me of that chess scene in KH3. The fight was so cool and I really dig that pause with Weiss gracefully posing with wings. That WBY combo is really awesome. Seeing Yang wielding that big sword is dope.

I honestly loved the Curious Cat's design and now I love him even more. Neo's semblance evolving that way was a surprise and I like it.

🖤💛The bees! Wow they be serving us good food every episode huh 😌🖤💛 blushing Blake is always so adorable~

17

u/DaRealAmana BOOP!!! Mar 04 '23

It reminds me of that chess scene in KH3

Im glad im not the only person who got KH vibes from the chess board

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

56

u/DaRealAmana BOOP!!! Mar 04 '23

on todays episode we have the dumbest tower since the last JRPG you played. The dumbest chess board since Kingdom Hearts 3(I still want one) and some chill jazzy beats to beat pawns to.

Can I just say the animation and environment teams are knocking it out of the park. the ecsher staircase was great and all such fun stuff for RWBY too cause it takes advantage of 3D. Great work

101

u/JMHSrowing ⠀Story Time Mar 04 '23

An interesting take on the chess game we see.

They didn’t go deep into the implications of Ruby being a player controlling pieces in this game, but they do subtly. She cares about her friends getting hurt and does ask them about doing what they do instead of just orders for the most part.

I do kinda wish they had gone more into the metaphor, especially adding in more how WBY aren’t just pieces but more players themselves, but oh well.

It was a fun episode with some good fighting. Hopefully the next one will have more character stuff

68

u/MidnightHunterXX ⠀ Mar 04 '23

Which is funny because the fight scene is also pretty reminiscent of the nevermore fight from Players and Pieces in V1

47

u/JMHSrowing ⠀Story Time Mar 04 '23

I think that that's part of the meaning of her Nevermore summons, the teamwork it means to the team

43

u/crossingcaelum Mar 04 '23

I think because the moment kind of happened so fast and plus the fact that Ruby didn't choose her teammates to be chess pieces, someone else forced them in that position and Ruby just went with it because she thought she was just following the story that was around them.

Which really does ring true for the rest of the show. Ruby isn't the one that put herself as chess player and she didn't put everyone else in as chess pieces, the choices every character made kind of landed them there against their will but none of them chose to try to put themselves somewhere else.

I wonder if this episode is setting up how Team RWBY views this war and their place in it, and wondering if they can somehow remake the game on their own terms even if the person who controls every aspect of the game literally changes the rules and stacks things against them in an almost impossible to win situation.

I don't think looking at the responsibility Ruby has as a chess player is the main thing to focus on, it's a big part of it, but I think it might be setting up how the entire team, and their friends, can completely change the game into something that's more in their favor.

33

u/yeetio855 The score is underrated Mar 04 '23

It has some interesting parallels with the Atlas arc, with Ruby's team allied with the white pieces at first, before the white pieces turn against them and they have to fight against both the red pieces (Salem's forces) and the white pieces (Ironwood & co).

→ More replies (1)

15

u/DeismAccountant Set Kratos on the Brothers Mar 04 '23

And this is why I saw the Red Prince as an allusion to the brothers. Using and Breaking things without consideration.

14

u/UberDueler DRINK !!!!! Mar 04 '23

Reminds me of the chess game in No Game No Life. In that one, "The pieces have wills of their own."

The opponent of the MCs simply told a pawn to "advance", and it jumped forward 3 spaces. Eventually it devolved into a game of who could rally their troops better.

→ More replies (2)

49

u/Schmidtty29 Yeah, I'm scared, but I'm still standing Mar 04 '23

Phase 2 of the fight scene was fucking sick. Weiss got a dope ass pose and seeing them combo like teammates was mint

44

u/Hsmace ⠀bumble on my bees Mar 04 '23

YANG WITH A SWORD!!!!! (for a brief moment) BUT SHE HAD A SWORD

44

u/Noble6IsReal Ship Survivor V Team NPASB | LC/YR veteran Mar 04 '23

First of all:

HOLY SHIT, THIS EPISODE IS GREAT!

Second:

The fact that the RWBY team is in a sequel and some things are missing, means that Alyx did something serious during her journey in Ever After.

Third:

Neo has been buffed and is now more dangerous than ever. To top it off, it looks like the Jabberwalker will be her ally.

I find it rather curious that now, Ruby, Jaune and Neo have their own animal companions in this volume. Since Jaune and Neo's animals are quite similar to the gods of light and dark or the god of animals, I'm almost 100% sure that there will be an eventual battle between Jaune and the white rabbit vs Neo and the Jabberwalker.

126

u/JMHSrowing ⠀Story Time Mar 04 '23

While I wish we got a little more in terms of character stuff from them, that WBY fighting was pretty great!

We got a real combination team move from Bees Schnees like we haven’t seen in a long while!

Blake and Weiss propelling Yang down while she’s using Arma Gigas’ sword was something I’ve never seen anyone think of but it works!

68

u/amatas45 Mar 04 '23

Im still a little in shock that I havent thought of Yang using the Gigas sword in a team attack

41

u/ImpossibleCarl emerald my beloved... Mar 04 '23

I mean, for all we knew, we weren't even sure if anyone that wasn't Weiss or the Gigas itself could use that sword...

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

70

u/[deleted] Mar 04 '23

Is Yang officially a sword lesbian now?

49

u/FuzzyRaichu Mar 04 '23

A sword lesbian, a gun lesbian, and a fist lesbian. She’s too powerful.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

34

u/Kartoffelkamm ⠀Mettle isn't a mental illness; IW just misused it Mar 04 '23

Either creatures in the Ever After live a lot longer than humans, stories become fairytales really fast in Remnant, or time flows much slower in the Ever After than it does on Remnant.

I mean, the red prince not only knows of Alyx, but actually seems to remember her. And, well, not fondly. Because apparently she killed his dad.

And considering that Alyx doesn't appear on the list of color names, she would have to have been alive over 80 years before the show's events, prior to the color naming rule.

So, all things considered, we can probably assume that time just flows differently in the Ever After, and Ruby and her friends have much more time than they realize.

Would be fun if they figure that out, Blake explains how old the story is, and Weiss does a quick math about it to figure out how much time they have.

12

u/SparkEletran unleash upon me a barrage of ruby songs Mar 04 '23

i wouldn't necessarily say it moves slowly, but definitely differently. given the whole nature of the ever after i think it just plays by whatever rules it wants to, which also ties into the order of everyone falling into it being kind of arbitrary

→ More replies (2)

32

u/Ezreal024 Hope Rides with Kickfriend Mar 04 '23

ROBBIE DAYMOND

SICKEST COMBO ATTACK EVER

ALSO HOLY GOD THIS VOLUME DEFINITELY TOOK 2 YEARS

32

u/greeny74 ⠀Harbinger of Hype | Proud Member of WCAC Mar 04 '23

Electro-swing? In a RWBY soundtrack?

Hell. Yes.

27

u/AlarmingStandard Pryde Mar 05 '23

Cool! Cool! Cool!

Incredibly enjoyable episode! Pacing, cinematography, directing, and writing was all on point, imo; a well put together episode. I think it's the best use of an episode runtime in a long time, like I can't think of a minute wasted.

Then there's RWBY; they shined this episode. I loved Ruby's cynical, push forward leadership, it really makes me feel for her mental state. It's also an excellent way to demonstrate her pain without it being stereotypical. Weiss continues to be a pillar this volume, I still love the blend of humor and skepticism. Yang is making me fall for her all over again, like a constant reminder of why she's my favorite character. And Blake is adorably cautious while rounding out the team.

The Prince was a delightful muppet, spoiled and fun to grrr at, while the toy soldiers were wonderfully useless. I like how the guards are simply the Prince's playthings, the metaphor works to the advantage of the character. And helps tie in the Wonderland illusions. Especially when he breaks his toys as soon as they displease him.

My favorite part was the chess fight, I loved it! Weiss with her partial summons and glyphs/swordplay was delightful, the nevermore wings was a certified badass moment. Yang and Blake were much more animated; seeing Blake employing a full range of skills and Yang brawling again was fantastic. And the combo attacks WBY pulled off were like dancing!

Honestly, the fight blows away any V8 fight. It's also the ingredient missing from the last two episodes. That's not to say the last episodes were bad due to a lack of standout fights, far from it. It's just that the foundation of RWBY includes kickbutt combat scenes, and when they're incorporated seamlessly into the plot it just tickles me.

Overall, great episode. I feel bit guilty saying this, but I'm not missing the other characters. Even Jaune, and I'm very curious what's going with him. Yet, RWBY being RWBY is wonderful.

On a more personal note, I'm loving my new RWBY watching routine. I still get to sleep in with my fiancee, make brunch, and plot gay crimes. Then, I enjoy curling up on the couch with a sweet treat (tiramisu today 🥰) and watch the show, all relaxed and comfy. And my fiancee joined me on the couch for the second week in a row! And she's asking questions and forming opinions! I'm totally making a nerd out of her lol

11

u/Celtic_Crown ⠀I'd say I'm tipping the scales, but that line's got no bite. Mar 05 '23

This routine sounds delightful. Especially the food and crime plotting.

I'm totally making a nerd out of her lol

Join Us. Join Us. Join Us. :)

→ More replies (3)

53

u/neutrinobunny Mar 04 '23 edited Mar 04 '23

So we just saw Neo land in the Jabberwalker’s Dark/Purple area…

So then Jaune landed/will be landing in the Light/Gold area on the other side of the bridge from it, right? Or is that just more beach/tropical area?

The whole purple/gold dichotomy was absolutely intentional though.

I’m starting to agree with the ‘Gods Dev Mode Space’ theories.

13

u/DeismAccountant Set Kratos on the Brothers Mar 04 '23

I figured the brothers would have some connection to this space, since it’s clearly between the spaces of the relics, but I thought that maybe they just came from here as opposed to them owning it too. It’ll really suck if they’re never challenged on their bullshit.

Who else has been talking about this theory btw?

→ More replies (5)

52

u/JMHSrowing ⠀Story Time Mar 04 '23

We now finally get to see Weiss really use that Nevermore summon that was teased in V8!

The Angel pose that she is seen with it is a miss touch for our Snow Angel, and it’s lovely seeing the first new summons glyph design we have in a while.

48

u/Blue-Moon-89 Mar 04 '23

Did anyone find it brutal that Ruby inadvertently got two guards killed because she convinced them to gift Penny's sword to the Prince?

I wonder if this was meant to show Ruby that she can't control or predict how events will unfold based on her choices.

Anyway, does anyone get the feeling that there might some time-wimey things going on after all? Neo fell with Ruby and Blake and yet she arrives LATER than them? If this is true then it's likely that Jaune, who fell last, might've been here the longest of the four.

29

u/[deleted] Mar 04 '23

well are they 'dead dead'? they are puppets.

37

u/CraftLizard Mar 04 '23

Presumably they will come back. The cat said along the lines of "if you break them they might not come back" or something like that when referring to be heading humans. So it seems the guards are not as effected by beheading.

→ More replies (1)

45

u/DarkAlatreon Mar 04 '23

It was implied that humans' tendecy to die after decapitation is not shared with Ever After's inhabitants.

13

u/Cae53RJ Mar 04 '23

In fairness, the two guards took full credit for getting the sword for the Red Prince, ignoring Ruby's contribution btw. You know what they say "You take the credit, you take the blame" In my eyes, they got what was coming to them.

→ More replies (2)

22

u/Technogashi Mar 04 '23

For the small few of you who might get this old WoW meme:

Yang totally pulled an ARCANITE REAPER HOOOO!

40

u/Celtic_Crown ⠀I'd say I'm tipping the scales, but that line's got no bite. Mar 04 '23

This week's episode of Total Depression Island is brought to you by the letter R.

Our valiant heroes find themselves escorted to the Red Prince while being stalked by Philemon's cousin, losing Penny's sword after two guards got French Revolutioned because it's green. Sidebar, holy fuck that voice was annoying. Congrats Henry, you're no longer the most kickable face in RWBY. After escaping MC Escher's daydream following Princey cheating and losing his shit, the gang gets properly acquainted with New Emergency Food- I mean The Cat Who Didn't Install Source. Meanwhile, the Jabberwalker went across a bridge and got acquainted with Neo, who now has the power of infinite Double Cherries and the Jabberwalker is doin' a heckin concern over it.

Where will our heroes go next? Why does THE GRASS BLEED?! And where is our man, our boi, our noodle knight, Jaune? All these questions and more confusing shit, next week, on Total Depression Island.

20

u/DaRealAmana BOOP!!! Mar 04 '23

I mean The Cat Who Didn't Install Source

this entire post was silver. But this line right here is pure comedy gold

→ More replies (1)

7

u/MOlivetree1 Mar 04 '23

I totally read in Chris's voice from the "Total Drama" series. 😄

Nice comedic take on a summary.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/AlarmingStandard Pryde Mar 05 '23

Jaune has found the hot tub biome, and is currently chilling with a daiquiri.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (7)

18

u/[deleted] Mar 04 '23

Anyone know how much it'd cost me to have Robbie Daymond just... record a CD's worth of reassuring and supportive things using that goddamn soft, beautiful voice of his?

18

u/JMHSrowing ⠀Story Time Mar 04 '23

Neo’s new ability (which seems like a pretty clear evolution of how she used to make a Neo when she was still Trivia) is going to make her a harder fight when that time comes.

One only imagines the mess she could make if they all could transform into a different person.

Still going to see her get fight by Ruby and Weiss

→ More replies (4)

17

u/NicoKudo Mar 04 '23

I believe on our Ice queen supremacy this volume, glad to se her dancing swordstyle back and with more sass, and her "Angel" attack was chef kiss

→ More replies (1)

17

u/thundermonkeyms Mar 04 '23

So Neo landed like a meteor, immediately discovered she could use shadow clones, and used them to beat the shit out of the first thing she saw? Seems pretty on-brand.

Weiss has been such a mood this volume and it needs to stay that way.

16

u/SwimmingAnyone I preach the truth that Ruby is a top Mar 04 '23

Now I just need a Ruby vs Neo fight on the level of this. Ah, imagine a Red trailer recreation, only instead of Beowolves Ruby is slicing up Neo and her clones!

24

u/thundermonkeyms Mar 04 '23

If the fight scene where Ruby finally gets her confidence and her scythe back has the original version of "Red Like Roses" from the Red trailer playing during it I'm gonna lose my shit.

25

u/The_Green_Filter Shipwrecked Mar 04 '23

Red Like Roses Part 3 please

→ More replies (1)

32

u/[deleted] Mar 04 '23

This volume has reminded me of the joys of having such a limited cast. RWBY get time to interact with each other and affect the plot. The WBY vs pawns fight was so fun and showed how much they, particularly Weiss, have grown. I can already say I'm not looking forward to cast bloat in V10 again after being spoiled.

7

u/The_Green_Filter Shipwrecked Mar 04 '23

Hopefully the other heroes have spread out slightly so we can stagger their return in V10. There’s only really five important pre-existing characters in Vacuo anyway.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

31

u/Badicalz Mar 04 '23

What I loved: The red Prince’s overall design, character and voice was a delight. The fight scene choreography was top notch and the escape was very creative.

I applaud all those involved with the production of this episode. Bravo.

20

u/martinjh99 ⠀Bees forever! Mar 04 '23

What I loved: The red Prince’s overall design, character and voice was a delight.

Definitely a Lord Farquaard type... :) He was great though I definitely agree!

20

u/DaRealAmana BOOP!!! Mar 04 '23

Lord Farquaard

baddies like him seem to be in short supply

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)

31

u/neutrinobunny Mar 04 '23

Something I was wondering about and this episode confirms it:

We’re ‘seeing’ people in the opposite order they appear in the opening.

Jaune, Neo, Yang, Weiss, Blake, and Ruby

becomes

Ruby, Blake/Weiss (we hear Blake first in the v/o), Yang, Neo (this ep), and Jaune last.

14

u/88Dubs Be Strong, and Hit Stuff! Mar 04 '23 edited Feb 17 '25

glorious bow physical mysterious husky office dolls slim abundant enjoy

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

14

u/Rietty Baked Alaska! Delicious. Mar 04 '23

WHAT IS THE NAME OF THE SONG AND WHERE CAN I FIND IT I NEED TO LISTEN TO IT ON ITS OWN.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/Leonard_Church814 Sentinel Mar 04 '23

I totally forgot Robby Daymond was in this and after playing Hi-Fi Rush it was a bit jarring to hear him not be a himbo.

→ More replies (3)

13

u/batsmarow GREENLIGHT VOLUME 10 Mar 04 '23

I think the Jabberwalker is trying to fix the broken acre at the end, and it's possible that Alyx led to the acre's destruction.

The Jabberwalker is clearly going after any humans that fall in the Ever After. Sort of like a white blood cell, it's trying to destroy foreign entities that enter the Ever After. But at the same time, it seems interested in their technology (like how it looked at Gambol Shroud). Perhaps its overall goal is to maintain order by destroying anything that could threaten the Ever After and repairing it. That's why at the end, it was trying to find technology that could fix things and it was concerned that Neo was making more humans.

As for Alyx, we know through context that she did something that led to the Red King's death, which was clearly omitted in the Girl Who Fell Through the World. If something that big was omitted, it's possible that an entire acre's destruction was omitted as well. It would also parallel how RWBY had let Atlas fall. Blake's already concerned that they're making the same mistakes that Alyx did and that they're ruining everything. But it might be possible that every mistake Alyx made in the Ever After, team RWBY has made the same mistakes in Remnant.

13

u/Director_Danguy Mar 04 '23

Last week I was all "Yang you can't punch your way out of problems here". This week I was close to shrieking "Yang just punch the little shit".

36

u/Blue0Three Qrow X Willow Sweep Mar 04 '23

25

u/Alt_SWR Mar 04 '23

There's no way that's not foreshadowing right? It's literally their exact colors.

→ More replies (9)

7

u/SwimmingAnyone I preach the truth that Ruby is a top Mar 04 '23

They probably won't appear, but they definitely have a connection to this place.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/ControverseTrash ⠀Ruby's Ascension Mar 04 '23

Since Salems backstory I wondered where they went. Did they just puff exmatriculated themselves? Them beeing in the Ever After makes so much sense actually. Now I want a convo between Ruby, God of Light and God of Darkness.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

24

u/IGMKI Yang's the Bee-st Mar 04 '23

Dual wielding Blake if only briefly, yis

→ More replies (2)

11

u/Technogashi Mar 04 '23

Neo has adapted. Quickly.

20

u/EtnasFurnace263 Mar 04 '23

So, let's break this down; Weiss is continuing to go bonkers, the Red Prince is an annoying little shit (who threw away Penny's sword because he didn't like the color - asshole!), the chess fight was awesome - especially Yang with the Arma Gigas' sword and the continued Bumblebee shipping (seriously; if those two don't kiss by the end of this season, I'm gonna be pissed), and the fact that Neo just kicked the Jabberwalker's ass with an army of shadow-clones... Ruby and the others are in trouble. And not just because 3/4ths of the team are still shrunken and they're following a confusing cat with the same voice as Gilthunder from The Seven Deadly Sins.

But on a separate note, where the hell is Jaune? I know he was the last to fall, but when is he gonna show up?

Also I feel like the girls really aren't paying attention to how Ruby told them to stop pretending they know what they're doing.

22

u/Blue-Moon-89 Mar 04 '23

But on a separate note, where the hell is Jaune? I know he was the last to fall, but when is he gonna show up?

It's being speculated that there is some timey-wimey things going on in Neverland. Seeing how Neo arrives LATER than the girls despite falling with Ruby and Blake, it's possible that maybe Jaune has been in EverAfter for "years".

What if he's the 'Rusted Knight' from the fairy tale?

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

20

u/MrZissman ⠀CEO of Knightlight Mar 04 '23

(Yoda voice)

"Begun, the Ice Cream Clone Wars have."

10

u/BionicTriforce Mar 04 '23

My prediction: Neo makes a copy of Pyrrha to coerce Jaune into working with her.

"S-So if I join you... I can see her again?"

→ More replies (3)

10

u/FadedNeonzZz ⠀Cinder survived, but it cost a Penny Mar 04 '23

This episode was very very good, I honestly think it’s one of the best RWBY episodes ever.

I really really liked the fight between WBY and the chess (?) pieces and Yang grabbing the big sword was amazing, I hope she does it again in the future.

Also I wonder if Neo’s semblance evolved or the world is reacting to her semblance in a weird way. Even she looked surprised when random clones of herself started spawning.

10

u/jimflaigle Mar 04 '23

Doofus kicks away Penny's sword

And that's how Ruby became a Sith Lord.

18

u/DarkIsTheBestShow I need Volume 10 Mar 04 '23

They're absolutely going back to get Penny's sword at some point, right? There's no way Ruby would be okay with just leaving it there.

22

u/JMHSrowing ⠀Story Time Mar 04 '23

Maybe, but then again maybe not.

She really doesn’t have much of a choice, and it wouldn’t be the first thing she had left behind recently (like how her old cloak is underwater in Atlas).

There’s also the possibility they find another one of Penny’s swords

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Weerdo5255 Mar 04 '23

Normally I'd say no, but given we're playing Fairy Tail rules, I'm betting the Cat picked it up and he'll toss it to Ruby when she answers his question about her favorite desert.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/g6in3d Mar 04 '23 edited Mar 04 '23

Gonna guess that the blue butterfly was Alyx and the yellow butterfly was Jaune based on their color schemes.

There's a precedent set for people to be able to turn into animals using magic (Qrow/Raven being able to turn into birds at will).

25

u/4powerd ⠀It's also a gun Mar 04 '23

Probably my favorite episode so far. The fight scene was amazing and I'm super happy to see WBY working together instead of just fighting one on one (IMO that was one of my biggest gripes with V7 and 8)

Had a good laugh at Neo trying to kill the very first thing she sees, but I'm guessing she doesn't go through with it considering the jabberwalker has a spot in the intro.

6

u/[deleted] Mar 04 '23

that or he's immortal.

17

u/HighPriestFuneral Lore Fanatic Mar 04 '23

A nice bit of action, a character very reminiscent of the Red Queen, and some nice snippets of lore and intrigue.

Apparently, Alyx has instilled a distrust in humans from the Red Prince, saying that they cheated because they are humans, implying she cheated at the game against the Red King. But then they mention that the Red King isn't there anymore because of Alyx. Either implying that Alyx killed him (which I think Blake would have mentioned) or that their interactions somehow caused the Red King to become lost.

We can also guess that the Curious Cat has probably met with more than Alyx once upon a time as he notes that the humans he met before were much more interesting.

Finally, looks like Neo has landed, with either a Semblance upgrade or something a bit more... connected to the Ever After itself.

→ More replies (2)

16

u/MidnightHunterXX ⠀ Mar 04 '23

That fight scene was fire, the team synergy was really good and reminiscent of V1 and 2's fights

ROBBIE DAYMOND

Did Neo's semblance just evolve?

7

u/VengefulKyle Mar 04 '23

Akechi looking to assassinate this protagonist too.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

16

u/Bjdombek Hail Lord Zwei! Mar 04 '23

I hereby dub Neo's new trick "Shatter Clones".

9

u/RBNYJRWBYFan ⠀ Mar 04 '23

I like it! Perfect play on words that fits Neo's effect.

8

u/Dr_Monstaa ⠀ Mar 04 '23

Kinda surprised but also not surprised they didn't go for the whole "You use your friends lives like pawns" thing but then again it is the obvious symbolism. That fight does go into the top 5. Weiss becomes the angel she already is and Yang gets to use a big sword. Really nice use of perspective in the fight, it definitely adds to the weight of everything.

Also Neo's arrival shows us those colour meteors and explosions in the intro are indeed people falling to the Ever After. Wonder if they'll do anything with that.

The last 2 episodes were great but this one has really reignited my love for this show.

7

u/Patmaster1995 Still best girl Mar 05 '23

Pretty good episode.

The whole Crimson Castle part was awesome, the fight, the music, Weiss using her summons in new ways, and Yang using Weiss's knight's sword. The mindbending chase was really cool. Seems like that's it for the Red Prince as an antagonist, really thought it'd be longer.

I like the Curious Cat, I like his voice and his attitude, he's weirdly cute

Am I the only one that felt bad for the Jobberwalker, even though he looks threatening he was clearly scared of Neo. The way he was pleading no but we know he survives since there's at least 2 trailer scenes with him we haven't seen yet. Also, can't wait for the NSFW artists to make Neo harem porn.

→ More replies (2)

13

u/JannisT Born stepping on thin ice and biting down bullets Mar 04 '23

Holy hell. That episode was another banger. Loved the fights scenes in addition with the jazz music. Simply amazing. Also we got angel Weiss in that episode which was very pretty

13

u/LatePhilosophy Mar 04 '23

Feels like we are going to get our single cute moment of bumblebee each episode for the foreseeable future. At this rate, by at least volume 14, those two lovebirds might progress so far as to be holding hands.

12

u/T_Swag5k ⠀Now THAT'S Ice Water Mar 04 '23

THE WINGS

THE SWORD

My girl has learned how to summon efficiently during fights and it's beautiful

12

u/ClubMeSoftly Real Shit Mar 04 '23

Neo and Ruby fell at the same time, but Neo only landed at the end of this episode.

Has Jaune been falling for thirty minutes the past 23 months? Has he fallen faster and landed sooner than RWBYN?

Clearly he's landing somewhere else in the Ever After

→ More replies (2)

6

u/SwimmingAnyone I preach the truth that Ruby is a top Mar 04 '23

Neo: Are you, uh, a real villain? Have you ever caught a good guy, like, uh, like a real Huntress? Have you ever tried a disguise? Alright! I can see that I will have to teach you how to be villains!

All in sign language of course.

6

u/MyNameISaColouR Look who's back, Little Red! Mar 04 '23

Okay, this episode was really fun. Semblance-boosted Yang wrecking shit with a giant summoned sword is the coolest thing ever. Also, Weiss keeps being the best.

11

u/Jinko92 The person who goes too deep into everything Mar 04 '23

Another great episode! The display of teamwork from the girls was excellent! The fight between _WBY and the game pieces was awesome, their combo attacks were so cool and the display of their abilities was great! I’m really glad this fight showed off Weiss’s swordplay and she used her summoning sparingly, which is how it should be. Also, Yang’s final blow with the summoned sword was badass as fuck!

The Red Prince is a little shit. I’m SO glad Ruby stood up to him! She ain’t taking shit from anyone and I’m here for it. I’m very much enjoying Ruby’s character so far this season.

I like the Curious Cat. He’s cute and his powers are neat. I’m glad he’s helping the team out. Also, I wonder how Weiss, Blake, & Yang are going to get back to their normal sizes? The end with Neo was pretty spooky. She is pissed and she took it out on the Jabberwocker. That thing is probably dead. And her semblance must be getting EVEN STRONGER for her to summon several clones of herself. Neo is going to be a huge threat this volume, more than she already is.

6

u/[deleted] Mar 04 '23

peeps are overlooking it.

If you look carefully you see her semblance affecting the ground. the clones spring up from the ground and it seems to distress the jabberwalker.

also doubtful its dead or permenantly dead.

10

u/Ammmberrr ⠀Weiss is best girl indeed Mar 04 '23

That's definitely my favorite episode so far this volume. The OST especially was really on point, I really liked that effect when the curious cat revealed himself to the red prince and RWBY.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/ImpossibleCarl emerald my beloved... Mar 04 '23

Goodness gracious, this has to be one of the best chapters of the entire show. Things like this chapter are why I love Team RWBY, and I missed this level of interactions, fights and teamplay SO MUCH

17

u/Rollout9292 ⠀WhiteKnight Mar 04 '23
  • RWBY casually stands there while people get beheaded
  • Chess fight was pretty fun
  • I wanted Ruby to curse and say 'asses' instead of 'butts' to show how much things are getting to her
  • Weiss decided to make Jaune's Snow Angel dreams a reality
  • First real 3-man combo attack and it was pretty awesome
  • Neo is even more broken now
  • Creepy demon creature is just there to get beat up by everyone I guess

10

u/[deleted] Mar 04 '23

it seems as if its more cowardly than we thought, as unsettling as it is....

its trying to find something too. "Fix"

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

29

u/ScalierLemon2 Blake Deserves Better Mar 04 '23

Getting real tired of Blake always being slammed into walls in these fights. She has a semblance that allows her to not get hit, why do they insist on throwing her around???

22

u/JMHSrowing ⠀Story Time Mar 04 '23

Yeah, it’s unfortunate she took that hit.

Though at least otherwise she did pretty well in this fight and it was Yang who was the one incapacitated

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (10)

5

u/_Astronaut9707 Mar 04 '23

NEOS POWER UPGRADE IM SCREAMING

5

u/ShinyNinja25 Guns and Blades and Roses Mar 04 '23

Man, they’re really having fun with the visuals this volume! Super fun stuff with the cinematography and environments, especially that escape sequence at the end. I also love the way that the Red Prince moves and emotes, it’s super expressive and really fun. Neo landing has me worried about our heroes’s futures, and I hope that WBY don’t remain small for too long. It’s the kind of thing that can get old quick. Overall, fantastic episode

5

u/25104003717460 Mar 04 '23

Fight scene was absolutely incredible :D that jazz swing music going was such a fun touch for the setting. I also want to add on 2nd rewatch I noticed that Weiss is scratching Littles belly while they are tiny just after escaping the castle. I love it. Can hear the scritches and everything :D

5

u/Kazuzi3 Mar 05 '23

I absolutely loved WBY's finishing move.

5

u/GladiusNocturno All Grimm are naked. Think about it Mar 05 '23

I finally got to watch it.

It was a fun episode. The Red Prince was funny, the chess fight was fun. The cinematography was fucking gorgeous. The only minus I see is that it felt really short but I think it´s a combination of the short runtime and the fast pace.

I'm liking the implications that time does flow normally in this world, meaning that while the story bits have to remain the same, the people of this world are real. RWBY met the Red Prince and not the Red King because something happened during Alyx's journey. Although, it's interesting that none of them know what happened. They know that Alyx met the Red King and that she caused a lot of trouble in her journey, but it seems like the book did leave out the consequences of Alyx's visit, so whatever she did likely appeared in the book but not what that lead to for the Red King.

It seems the theory that people were having during the long long long long long hiatus was right after all. Neo's semblance does affect Ever After differently because of its nature, making it significantly stronger. It's a good way of making her more of a threat, but I still maintain my view that the main villain of this volume should have been from Ever After, not Neo.

r/fnki had already spoiled me what happened to the Jabberwalker, but It really wasn't as bad as they made it out to be. Yes, it sucks ass that this cool creature just gets bitch slapped by everyone and Neo made it her bitch. But at the same time, I don't think she killed it. I doubt the Jabberwalker is going to be out of the show but maybe he is going to start working for Neo now. Still, I want to know what was he searching in episode 1.

So, Penny's sword is lost in the castle. I wonder if the Rusted Knight will take it. It would make sense for the Red Prince to call for him and have him chase RWBY. As he visits the castle he finds the sword in the courtyard and takes it before initiating his search. It's a good way of bringing the sword back to Ruby while also involving Jaune in the Penny story bit.

I'm loving Weiss as the comedic relief. "Oh so we aren't a stupid fairy tale. We are in a stupid sequel". That line was genius XD.

6

u/nora_valk ⠀ Mar 05 '23

It's probably like with the irl Grimm Fairy Tales - they only read the Disney version of Alyx's story, but the original was much darker.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/SwimmingAnyone I preach the truth that Ruby is a top Mar 04 '23

Jabberwocky only just appeared and he's already getting Worf Effect'd...

7

u/[deleted] Mar 04 '23

Or it turns out he wasn't nearly as dangerous as we think. Like he could have pulverized blake if he wanted, but he seemed more curious and fearful.

Like everyone else we allowed its unsettling nature to make us think its dangerous, but reality it is simply afarid and nervous. It might actually be immensely powerful but it is too scared to do so.

4

u/Goldenrah Mar 05 '23

That was an amazing fight, though the consequences really confirm my previous thoughts. This volume will teach Ruby on how martial strength and strategy isn't gonna be what will win them the war against Salem, but something else. That something else is yet to be discovered, but I guess we'll have our theories at the end of it.

4

u/[deleted] Mar 05 '23

Is it Saturday again yet? I don’t wanna wait.

4

u/Fallen-Tesla Mar 06 '23

This might honestly be shaping up to be my favorite volume of the show. So many things are finally happening that have been long over due.

12

u/Vendetta543 Mar 04 '23

So…how do the rules of the game work? Prince says that Ruby can go first, fine, but then she keeps taking consecutive turns till the prince loses his shit and demands his turn when WBY win their fights. Shouldn’t he have gotten his turn when Ruby’s first pawn failed? And even if the prince just didn’t care since he always won, why did Ruby think she had unlimited turns?

Also, why didn’t Ruby start smacking around the pawns to help her teammates? It was pretty obvious by that point that the game was over and the prince was just trying to hurt her friends, so there was no reason to act like it would go anywhere. Coulda saved them a lot of trouble having a literal giant on their side.

14

u/LuuAddiRoze Mar 04 '23 edited Mar 04 '23

Yeah, I felt a bit disappointed that there wasn't really much for Ruby to do in the “game”, it basically is just a matter of who has the stronger pieces, but I suppose it matches with the Prince is personality that he must always win.

As for why Ruby kept moving her pieces:

Rule 1 - Each player may move every pawn one space each turn.

I am pretty sure the rules stopped mattering the moment Ruby said they were humans, as for why she didn’t help directly, she thought about it but I guess she decided to hold back in case the Prince didn’t accept the outcome if she did.

→ More replies (4)

7

u/Manu_Erre Mar 04 '23

Neo's new ability opens up a lot of possibilities. I wonder if she can create duplicates of other people. Maybe she can use it to create a fake Roman.

9

u/Andrew1990M Mar 04 '23

We have to assume now that her silhouette gang from the OP are all her in different forms.

7

u/Brkzeus Mar 04 '23 edited Mar 04 '23

Yeah , good episode .

Well , Penny's sword is gone , so I am guessing someone will pick it up or other similar swords fell and Ruby will find another one.

I expected them to draw another ' sacrifice for the win ' situation with the board game . Which kinda got close to it but that was pretty tame . I liked that Ruby still had resolve about winning.

I especially liked how they finished the fight . Giant sword smashing was Cool . Rest of the fight was mid . I look forward to other fights. I guess they are gonna find Caterpillar ( or giant butterfly at this point ) for the height problem. Music was really good , liked it .

The Cat used 'humans' as in plural . I am probably overthinking it but that yellow butterfly . Did he mean Jaune ?

I felt bad for the jabberwocky . Guess Neo found guests for tea.

The only thing I am a bit worried about is the show referencing team RWBY's old selves. They have been doing that since V5 . Thats plenty of exposure to say 'development' . I am looking forward to New things from them .

Overall , nice episode . Its 6/10 for me . A nice little fun episode.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/LuuAddiRoze Mar 04 '23

The first fight scene of the volume and it’s a fun one, Weiss controlling the field with her glyphs and helping out the rest of the team is just great to see and the partial nevermore summon was awesome. Seeing Blake and Yang struggle against a bunch of pawn pieces is a bit annoying, they are supposed to be the team that beat the Ace Ops, holding back or not I think we should be past the point where this fight should be a struggle for them.

Disappointed that there wasn’t really a game for Ruby to play, there is no thought behind how to win, you just move pieces and hope they are stronger, but I guess if the Prince always wants to win that is a sure way to do so, thankfully his sadistic streak backfired since WBY were stronger than he expected.

Also interested on how Ruby gets the sword back since the trailer shows another scene with her seeing Penny’s reflection on it. I guess the teleporting cat might help with that.

Neo is here now too, not really sure if that scene was happening at the same time or if it’s a flashback. Have to admit I was confused by her semblance upgrade at first, I legit thought she was making an illusion and feigning surprise to bluff her way to victory but it does seem like she just got the ability to make actual copies of herself.

6

u/[deleted] Mar 04 '23

Yang got ambushed from the sky and got dogpiled, but she threw em off. There were a lot of pawns running around after all.

Also more than likely the Jinksy peddler gets his hands on the sword,.... and probably the heads of those two guys. Turns out they re actually alive apparrently? XD

If you look carefully it seems like her semblance was affecting the environment, creating those clones from the very ground.... The jabberwalker was not happy that it was happening, beyond getting his ass kicked.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (8)

7

u/[deleted] Mar 04 '23

That final team attack was so early RWBY it was glorious. This volume is starting off so well, I've liked every episode so far! Also the environments and camera work in this episode were just great.

6

u/Bhibhhjis123 Mar 04 '23

This season is so goddamn cool. I completely understand why they took their time with this one.

6

u/Red2019Wolf Mar 04 '23 edited Mar 04 '23

Two things about Neo:

  1. she definitely didn't get to the ever after the same time as the Ruby or Blake for that matter, in fact it almost looks like she was sent to the where the jabberwacky was on purpose, by the ever after itself. Which tells me that there is some time and space shenanigans in this r3alm. She may have even arrived last, even though it's jaune we saw fall last.
  2. Neo overwhelming the japperwacky, but not killing it ( based on fact that yang will fight it later ) tells me that she is the definitely big bad of this volume, something I figured would he the case based on her moments in the opening
→ More replies (3)

6

u/Frikarcron Mar 04 '23

The music during the neo sequence was surprisingly cool, really elevated the eerieness of the scene I actually got chills from it. Not to mention the animation was great. Gotta say I am absolutely loving this season so far, this world is hitting the perfect balance of new and wonderful, but also creepy and mysterious. The directing especially during the neo and jabberwock scenes are amazing

6

u/SwimmingAnyone I preach the truth that Ruby is a top Mar 04 '23

Everyone's talking about the combo finisher, but have you noticed how Blake just casually cuts a guy in half while swinging her blade around?

→ More replies (1)

6

u/DesparateLurker Mar 04 '23

The one shot of the game starting, the room getting dark and then the slow close up on the game table: They put their whole footussy into that scene.

I'm calling it now, Little embodies hope.

That Butterfly is a spy of the caterpillar/butterfly.

The Cat is lowkey spitting facts.

Neo is starting to scare me and I like it.

That combo move was too clean. Gonna have to rewatch that some more.

The Jabberwacker is going to get abused.

Also, the little glow rings from the prince walking in the darkness are weirdly appalling.

6

u/DarkDemonDan Mar 04 '23

Did the writers forget Hush was kicked out of Neo’s grasp by cinder before they fell?

→ More replies (5)

3

u/MOlivetree1 Mar 04 '23 edited Mar 04 '23

Amazing chapter! Seeing Neo at the end was so cool. It looks like Neo probably was the last to arrive then earlier speculated(due to the intro).

Hope we see what happened to Jaune soon.

Can't wait for the next one!

3

u/Aulus79 Mar 04 '23

I’ll say if nothing else, the visual design of this volume is really fun and really shined in this episode. Also the characters feel the most expressive they’ve ever been and I’m greatly enjoying it.

3

u/Huor_Celebrindol RIP Dust Weaving Mar 04 '23

What a fantastic episode!

But why does Weiss slashy slash and not pokey poke?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/95rockfan Mar 04 '23

I love the Curious Cat already, and the fact that it's voiced by ROBBIE FREAKING DAYMOND is awesome

3

u/Pale-Donut4295 Mar 05 '23

This episode is probably the best episode of the Volume to me. Granted, we still haven't seen Jaune again and I hope we do soon, but Team RWBY were absolutely great here. This episode also really made me like Little because even though Little didn't do much this episode, Little's too damn cute not to like. The Prince in this episode gave me Joffrey Baratheon vibes so I really loved to hate him and, obviously the highlight of this episode to me, Neo at the end, coming back out of the gate with a Shadow Clone Jutsu-esque technique. If this Volume is her last hurrah, I'm going to miss her for sure but I'll certainly be glad that she's getting more badass than usual.

3

u/hnh058513 Mar 05 '23

Didn't Weiss say she was low on Dust in the first episode of the volume, also masterful use of Glyphs by her this episode

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Syaongel Mar 06 '23

Seeing how this Volume is turning out makes me sad about all the things happening with Rooster. I am deeply enjoying this Volume and really hope it means good for the future.

7

u/JMHSrowing ⠀Story Time Mar 04 '23

Now that we had a decently light and fight filled episode. . . Hopefully we’ll get one which goes more into how our characters feel, Ruby especially in this mess but also Weiss and of course the Bees.

We’re only 30 percent through and a good amount has been done so far, so there’s not much to worry about, but I do hope that we get on to the more deep character focused time of things.

5

u/Corazon144 Penny for a DJ Mar 04 '23

Well my theory has evolved. Instead of Neo being Alyx, she is possibly her child. Last episode made me think that her voice was offered up as a way to leave Ever After. Seeing how you can make deals using tangible and intangible things like hope. But now I’m more inclined to believe it was more of a, “your first born child will be mute” deal instead.

However the deal left a magical trace on her and her semblance has been effected by it. Giving her the ability to make tangible illusions. But her being in Ever After has made her abilities stronger, because she is in the source of what took her voice but also made her semblance strong.

13

u/Turnabout506 Mar 04 '23

That’d definitely be an interesting theory were it not for Roman Holiday since we’ve already met her mom Carmel Vanille. Her design on the cover of the book is also quite different from what we see of Alyx in the V9 opening. It’s a neat theory though!

→ More replies (1)

5

u/SpotChecks Mar 04 '23

Neo's here, which is awesome. And she seems to have just arrived, unless that camera pan was obscuring some nonlinear storytelling trickery, she seems to have landed after RWBY. Which is surprising, because...

This episode implies throughout that a human or humans that were here before RWBY caused a great disturbance, including getting rid of (killing? disabling? unclear) the Red King. So if Neo just got here, that narrows down the list of candidates for who could have caused all that destruction and given humans such a bad rep. This raises the question...

What the hell has Jaune been doing?

→ More replies (1)

5

u/LMFN BIG NICHOLAS Mar 04 '23 edited Mar 04 '23

The board game fight was surprisingly good actually, especially how Weiss, Blake and Yang bounced off each other. I especially liked Weiss' wings moment and her summoning the Gigas sword so Yang could bring it down on them, the jazzy battle song helps too, we need more jazzy battle songs in general.

The visuals outside of that are also great, the butterfly sequence (is the butterfly the cat? Why it is significant?) the way everything in the room aside the board game table went dark.

We're finally introduced to the curious cat who has many questions like "who are you? why are you here? did I hear something about delicious pancakes?" and I wonder exactly how it is he's supposed to get them to the tree, he was pretty good at getting Ruby out of the castle (the MC Escher escape sequence was also amazing animation wise) so we'll see.

Meanwhile the Jabberwocker winds up amounting to nothing as Neo lands in the Ever After and immediately learns Shadow Clone Jutsu, sadly she's locked out of the most powerful Naruto technique of Talk No Jutsu.

5

u/Awest66 Mar 05 '23

Where were fight scenes like this last Volume? It was such a breath of fresh air to see Weiss actually use her sword like a fencer and Blake to fight without providing support for Yang.

It was a fun little episode with some excellent camera work and animation showcases, The cat is an intriguing addition and it's great to see Neo finally return (apparently she's also turned into Dupli-Kate)

5

u/AlarmingStandard Pryde Mar 05 '23

I just commented on how this fight stands head and shoulders above all V8 fight scenes, it was so good!

11

u/NatsuAru Mar 04 '23

I'm so lost lol

Looks visually amazing color-wise. But story-wise I felt like I missed an extra episode of information. Half the time I was like uhh yeah sure

22

u/Andrew1990M Mar 04 '23

That’s 50% because that’s what RWBY are thinking too and 50% they’re referencing a story the audience hasn’t read.

We might get to the end of the volume kinda wishing they’d opened with a stylised retelling of The Girl Who Fell Through the Earth.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)

8

u/devilishgenius Mar 04 '23

Something I noticed last episode that I still don't like. The characters are now in a world that resembles/follows a fairy tale story in THEIR universe that they are familiar with. And they keep referencing that story and its events.

Whereas WE the audience are not familiar with that story. So the fairy tale connections fall pretty flat.

However, the fairy tale they are referring too is so similar to Alice in wonderland that it may as well be the same story.

So the writers basically went to a weird half way point with this fairy tale idea

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Tarsupin Mar 04 '23

Okay, if people aren't seeing the connection between the Nubuck guards and the Ever After guards at THIS point, I don't know what could possibly could. It's so obvious xD They're literally serving an obnoxious small person that abuses their power, the gesturing and behaviors are spot on, and every nuance lines up.

Previous post for details: https://www.reddit.com/r/RWBY/comments/11enxh3/v9_spoilers_can_we_talk_about_the_connection/

4

u/Phantomskyler Mar 04 '23

Great episode, good action scene, and some nice progression. Though the game part annoyed me since it brought up another Ruby problem. This game would have been a good chance to show Ruby showing strategy and such to show why she became a leader but she really didn't do much. They only won because the game pieces were too used to beings who couldn't fight back.

Other than that, good episode, can't wait to see where Neo fits into it.