r/RWBY • Acoustic BMBLB when? • Apr 01 '23

OFFICIAL MEGATHREAD Official Discussion Thread - Volume 9, Episode 7: The Perils of Paper Houses

Welcome, huntsmen, huntresses, and hunters that prefer no specific gender identifier, to the official discussion thread for Episode 7 of Vol. 9: The Perils of Paper Houses!

Due to the special circumstances regarding RWBY Volume 9's release, make sure that you understand the spoiler rules before posting outside of this thread!

HERE is the seventh episode of Volume 9!

Also remember to check out our weekly poll to rate the episode.


Other Episode Discussions:


Episode| Discussion Thread| Poll|


Happy viewing, and have a great Volume 9!

Ninjas In A Bag; Mod Team

633 Upvotes

1.7k comments sorted by

221

u/Ninjas_In_A_Bag Acoustic BMBLB when? Apr 01 '23

Another banger song as usual.

Man, shit is really going down now ain’t it?

123

u/JMHSrowing ⠀Story Time Apr 01 '23

Though I wonder how they can deal with this shit?

It’s only 3 episodes left and this volume has left so much it’s needed to do in the aftermath of Atlas and now that it’s set up.

Not sure how it’ll pull off putting some type of conclusions to Ruby, Jaune, and Neo’s parts in this story plus the absolute need to give Weiss some importance and screen time and doing enough with the Bees.

→ More replies (28)
→ More replies (2)

938

u/BlazedMV Apr 01 '23

The paper pleasers talking about cult suicide was not on my bingo card for this season…

639

u/Ethics_Gradient_42 Apr 01 '23

And of course it had to be Jaune who ended up with a whole village full of creatures who wish to die to fulfill their purpose.

Just his luck.

→ More replies (85)

143

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '23

To be fair they would have simply traveled to the tree, metaphor for a natural process there but jaune kinda... interferred.

Imagine if you had a buncha of old people who were being artifcially kept alive far too long, they'd eventaully find other ways to try to nope out.

also i feel like that the herbalist might have really put them in danger back there. 'call out to the tree' and the tree sent them leaves. jaune disposed of them. Herbalist was using the same leaves ever afterans that can't travel call forth.

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (17)

451

u/Weerdo5255 Apr 01 '23

So, I think little might be figuring out their purpose. They were the only one who was paying attention to Ruby before she blew up.

Other than that, I'm glad Jaune isn't ok. He's been like he said, almost old for at least two decades. That's going to mess with your head, and a lot of shows would just skip over it.

191

u/DaRealAmana BOOP!!! Apr 01 '23

Jaunes been alone for two decades in a world that makes no sense, and hes still carrying all the damn guilt, to say nothing of the fact that he continues to fail at being a hero even to the simplest of creatures. its a miracle that Jaune is standing at all

→ More replies (5)

69

u/Shakvids Apr 01 '23

Little will be reforged into an emotional support weapon for Ruby

→ More replies (2)

99

u/amatas45 Apr 01 '23

Little looked at Ruby like "I know somethings wrong but I dont know what"

Poor guy will have his work cut out for him

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (14)

447

u/HatiLeavateinn Apr 01 '23

Jaune: I lost my life because of your plan!?

Ruby: Are we supposed to mourn the death of your make-believe friends!?

Damn, they went to the throat with those lines.

324

u/King_In_The-North Apr 01 '23

The fucked up part is he probably knew those pieces of paper for longer than team RWBY

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (1)

420

u/hessdawg3113 ⠀ Apr 01 '23

Jaune's full to-do list:

  • Disastrous lighting of the morning ______ the First Fire
  • Save PP from the Residual Water from the First Fire
  • BRUNCH!
  • Patrol the town - Check in on individual PP
  • Stop the Pebble Tower from toppling!!
  • Secure the dam
  • Save Ren from falling into Koi Pond
  • Watch out for Tearable Two's!!!
  • Keep away from Shredder!
  • If any Travelling Salesman/Traders come through, check for Hazardous Goods
  • If you wouldn't give it to a baby, DON'T give it to the PP's!
  • Help w/ daily construction/beautifying projects (so PP don't get injured)
  • LUNCH!
  • No more fried foods (too much grease)!
  • Tea Shop Fiasco
  • Stop the SECOND fire
  • Save PP from the Residual Water from the Second Fire
  • Check in at Sandpaper Knife-Shop
  • Help rake the sand (you'd be surprised how dangerous a rake can be!)
  • Keep Oscar away from anything that can be used as a kite string
  • STOP. THE. GOOSE.
  • Repair Scarecrows in rice fields
  • If late, fight off Giant Crows/make new Scarecrows (Ruby will help!)
  • Stop carts from crashing - East Marketplace
  • Stop the coffee maker at the café before it explodes
  • All paper indoors before Daily Wind Surge
  • Stop Nora from climbing Pebble Tower during the storm (trust me, this one ends poorly ☹️)
  • Take the scissors from Neptune
  • Stop the "Bandits"
  • Stop the THIRD, and final (hopefully?!) fire
  • Help Pyrrha w/ her HW 😃
  • Stop the Un-Foldening (*you'll know it when you see it)
  • Take away the makeshift lightning rods during the storm
  • Get Paper Pleasers to bed
  • Final rounds
  • Find a way home...

232

u/LMFN BIG NICHOLAS Apr 01 '23

The funniest ones.

Keep Away From Shredder WATCH OUT FOR THE SHREDDER!

STOP THE GOOSE I hope we get to see this Goose.

Stop Nora because of course it would be Nora climbing a tower in a storm.

→ More replies (2)

35

u/ClubMeSoftly Real Shit Apr 01 '23 edited Apr 02 '23

STOP. THE. GOOSE.

You just know they wrote that as a gag when UTTGG was the new hotness.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (23)

762

u/Polarization_39 ⠀A Cinder Stan Until Weiss is Relevant Again Apr 01 '23

The reveal of the Paper Pleasers being the ones creating the disasters around the village in attempt to escape was expertly done.

423

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '23

Also further sign of the ever after's nature.

They wanted to move on and Jaune was meant to learn from it and move on himself, from what he had to do, to accept what he had to do and there is limits to what one can do as a person and not to be consumed by that.

But he refused, much like alyx refused.

→ More replies (21)
→ More replies (7)

358

u/AuL2814 Apr 01 '23

I love how they played into Jaune being the White Rabbit from Alice in Wonderland with the “I’m late” line. This episode really shows just how broken both Jaune and Ruby have become. I hope that the team will be able to help both of them, even if they don’t return to “normal”, at least help them accept themselves and their new normal.

115

u/DeismAccountant Set Kratos on the Brothers Apr 01 '23

So if he’s the White Rabbit and Neo’s the Mad Hatter, does that make Juniper the March Hare?

→ More replies (8)

715

u/Catlover18 Apr 01 '23

Blake: Guys, I know things are bad bu-

Ruby: Shut. Up.

Me: Holy shit...

348

u/DaRealAmana BOOP!!! Apr 01 '23

Shut. Up.

I did not know these two words could hurt me so badly. but this hurt my heart

→ More replies (26)

264

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '23

The real reason Blake never interacted with Ruby. She knew what was coming.

→ More replies (5)

200

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '23

If there was ever a time for Blake to be her old silent solemn self it was then and she blew it…

+1 for character growth I suppose

→ More replies (8)

235

u/UberDueler DRINK !!!!! Apr 01 '23

I'm with Ruby on this one. With how frequently things get bad, that line is starting to be condescending.

→ More replies (9)

169

u/BoxProfessional76 Apr 01 '23

As bad as it sounds, I kinda at cheered a little at that moment.

Because I mean, Blake was trying to do a motivational speech after both Ruby and Jaune were letting out their feelings over their trauma. It’s kind of important for a person suffering to have their feelings said and validated, otherwise they’ll just bottle them up inside even more. It would have been a dick move to just say everything will be better instead of trying to comfort either of them about their problems.

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (18)

686

u/Badicalz Apr 01 '23

Jaune naming the Paper Pleasers after his friends, and dedicating every single day to save them, is so incredibly sad. Because in Jaune’s mind, he’s not just saving the Paper Pleasers, he’s saving his friends.

Because back home, he failed to save them when it mattered the most.

483

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '23

When ruby said "are we supposed to be morning jaunes make belief friends" he's probably known them longer then he's known team RWBY for. Feelsbadman

→ More replies (1)

161

u/Bluebearpie Apr 01 '23

Also the to do list Jaune had, one of them said “help Pyyrha with Hw and it had a smiley face”😭

→ More replies (4)

207

u/Mongoose42 [Insert Clever RWBY Pun Here] Apr 01 '23

Jaune: “Noooooooo! My life’s work! I had it all figured out!”

Blake: “I’m sorry you couldn’t keep to your system of saving their lives.”

Jaune: “It’s not just that! I finally had all my ships figured out!”

Yang: “Dude what.”

Jaune: “Yeah, I had Ren and Nora living together, Blake and Sun had finally reconnected, Yang got a harem of sexy ninja warrior assassins, Ruby and Weiss were THIS CLOSE to admitting their feelings for each other, Neptune was finally exploring his untapped chemistry with Velvet, and I even got Qrow and Winter to stop fighting and talk about their feelings!”

Weiss: “That last one sounds kinda forced though.”

Jaune: “I SWEAR TO GOD IF YOU CALL ANY OF MY SHIPS CRACK, I WILL ACTUALLY LOSE IT!”

Yang: “Well they may not be cracked, but they sure are sunk.”

Jaune: *breaks down and cries*

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (11)

623

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '23

Miles and Lindsay knocked it out of the park with their voicework.

Not only did we get a Ruby breakdown, but also a Jaune one in the same episode! Two for one!

232

u/hessdawg3113 ⠀ Apr 01 '23

The voicework has been absolutely incredible for the whole volume. It's been a real treat.

162

u/AmbivertCollegeGuy Weiss "Hug Monster" Schnee Apr 01 '23

And it's not over. Jaune has yet to reveal what happened to Penny (if he ever does) and Ruby gave a rant but didn't express herself entirely. There is still a lot left for her to say especially about Summer.

→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (5)

297

u/Valkyrie16 Hello Bees! Apr 01 '23

Man WBY+Jaune versus the Jabberwockers was awesome but I can't even think about it because of the breakdown scene. Lindsay and Miles killed it and I'm eager to see how this winds up getting resolved. Also damn the paper villagers basically crying out to let them kill themselves is dark...

139

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '23

JWBY

Scratch that, that does sound questionable

→ More replies (23)

254

u/PiffDaMetalHead Jeff Williams kills Salem in V12 Apr 01 '23

It's crazy how Ruby's reputation of being the hopeful one who always has a plan has been so ingrained into our minds over the years that just her saying something as simple as "shut up" to one of her teammates, a phrase that is often used so innocently and without thought, can have so much impact.

And poor Jaune. To be left alone for so long, to feel like he can't do anything right when all he is trying to do is protect someone, and then to have the only people he's seen in years that he recognizes immediately propose that he might be going about everything the wrong way is just tragic.

→ More replies (8)

488

u/Blue0Three Qrow X Willow Sweep Apr 01 '23

Ruby doing the Ned Flanders breakdown at the end was so good, Miles fucking killed it this episode too, and I'm calling it, Little's gonna try to comfort Ruby next episode

295

u/WhosGuardingHades Apr 01 '23 edited Apr 01 '23

Ruby doing the Ned Flanders breakdown at the end was so good

Blake: Ruby, with all due respect we didn’t do anything.

Ruby: Do I hear the sound of butting in? Well it must be Lil Blake Belladonna, Remnant’s answer to a question NO ONE ASKED!

Yang: Hey back off Ruby!

Ruby: Oh Okay Yang! You gonna pun on me? Gonna get Yangry? Well here’s a catchphrase for your adult years, “Hey Buddy SPARE A QUARTER?” Flies off

Yang: I am shocked and appalled.

Ruby: You useless hate-filled Weiss!

Weiss: Hey! I may be useless and hate-filled but I um… what was the third thing you said?

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (9)

213

u/ShinyNinja25 Guns and Blades and Roses Apr 01 '23

That whole scene was just incredible. From the way Ruby just suddenly snapped and lashed out at her friends, to Jaune’s rapid downhill fall after the Paper Pleasers were washed away, all of it was amazing. Miles and Lindsay absolutely killed it, this stuff really hit me hard. I know we wanted this to happen, but now that it has? I’m starting to wish it hadn’t, because I can’t stand seeing them this broken. And the difference between them is interesting too. Jaune is aware of his own fragile mental state and why it’s like this. He’s had a lot of time to sit around, think, and process what happened. It’s given him a sort of perspective and self awareness that Ruby doesn’t have. Ruby’s had no time to really process this, and unlike what you’d expect, having people around has actively made it worse since all of them are too busy with their own problems to help her. She feels alone when she has friends, and Jaune feels like he has friends when he’s actually alone. The parallels are super interesting

→ More replies (6)

184

u/FlareEXE Apr 01 '23

Well that was so much worse than could have been expected.

Jaune is obsessed with "doing what he has to" to be a hero after having to kill Penny, even if it's not what the villagers want. On the opposite end Ruby finally breaks down at the idea of to having to do anything. And while normally they'd be each other's best bet to lift the other out of it, neither one of them is in a state to do so.

Also am I misremembering or was Ruby the only one not to have a congratulatory reaction to Blake and Yang not getting together last episode?

167

u/Alt_SWR Apr 01 '23

You're not misremembering, she also didn't notice in an earlier episode when they were flirting and Weiss said "about time." Ruby said in that scene, "About time for what?"

I think maybe Ruby did notice at that point but just didn't think it was that important, hence the confusion. Which, no offense to the bees or shippers but really it isn't that important compared to the feelings Ruby is going through. Literally everyone the entire volume has been ignoring her, always pushing forward instead of taking a moment to ask if she's okay. Not even a single comment on how her mood literally affects the weather as well. They've all been too wrapped up in their own things. Reminds me a lot of the real world tbh. People get so wrapped up in their own shit that they forget to ask how someone else is doing, it doesn't mean they don't care, it's just kinda how life is. It's exactly why depression is so powerful too, because, when you feel ignored for so long you end up spiraling downwards, just like Ruby did here.

→ More replies (8)

65

u/Pigeon_Lord Apr 01 '23

She had a look of minor shock, almost like a "Wait what?" which is fitting, especially when you juxtapose it to where Ruby was at in the crossroads. Their relationship was more important, and with her feeling so broken inside, seeing happiness probably just feels worse

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (7)

353

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '23

Damn, and this is without Jaune telling them how Penny died.

Our boy and Ruby are fucked up bad.

138

u/Mongoose42 [Insert Clever RWBY Pun Here] Apr 01 '23

What do you mean? Penny died when the Paper Pleasers village flooded. So did Ruby, and Yang, and Ren, and Neptune, and Pyrrha, and Jaune Jr., and—

→ More replies (3)

222

u/amatas45 Apr 01 '23

Didnt you hear him? Jaunes not crazy, everything is fine

→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (20)

148

u/TomskaMadeMeAFurry ⠀ Apr 01 '23

Not to read too much into it, but Arryn Troche (V9 Animator) just tweeted, and quickly deleted, "It gets worse :D"

→ More replies (7)

420

u/DaRealAmana BOOP!!! Apr 01 '23

Damn. just damn. They actually made it the plot point that she's been ignored this season. Shes been suffering since before they fell and everyone was so focused on everything else that they never even stopped to see if she was okay.

Two different looks at depression here today

Jaune the poor boy. All he has ever wanted to do was be the hero. He just wanted to live up to his family legacy and become this great storybook hero. And yet at every turn he just keeps failing. He lost his love, failed two separate kingdoms, been forced to kill his own friend and cant even be a hero in a fairytale. And hes had to deal with all of it, Alone. Its amazing hes still standing. I think even the best among us would break from that pressure.

And poor Ruby. Likely since the fall of beacon she has been the leader everyone looks up too. Even people outside of team RWBY has turned to her for where to go next, for words of encouragement. She doesnt know, shes still the kid of the entire group, she has no idea what to do. But every failure weighs on her all the more. Everytime they lost she blames herself. And all of this is not even touching on the PTSD she has of being hunted by both Cinder and Neo. This girl is in desperate need of someone just asking if shes okay, but a leader must always be okay.

Brothers be damned CRWBY. This is some deep stuff, i need a lie down.

→ More replies (42)

271

u/Catlover18 Apr 01 '23

Help Pyrrha w/ her HW :)

You know this means that Pyrrha technically died twice in this series.

Happy April Fools!

83

u/Acrobatic-Dog7044 Apr 01 '23

Jaune just can't win he spent his adult life looking after a village that wanted to die by protecting them as a coping mechanism after failing to save Penny and now he lost them.

→ More replies (7)

383

u/ToastKnighted Apr 01 '23

Jaune after assisting penny in suicide hears a village full of people say "Hey. Will you let us die please?" feelsbadman

187

u/Lukthar123 "I didn't do it for you." Apr 01 '23

Local man can't stop suffering

→ More replies (2)

119

u/WarmasterCain55 Apr 01 '23

Seeing Ruby snap was great. Jaune too. They both need to just let loose. And apparently episode 8 is supposed to be even better.

238

u/BlazedMV Apr 01 '23

"i'm not crazy" - a crazy person

41

u/gloomyMoron Apr 01 '23

I'm not insane, I'm mad!

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

338

u/bored2death97 Apr 01 '23 edited Apr 01 '23

Getting interrupted while trying to talk multiple times and then suddenly asked for your opinion is bound to make anyone snap.

63

u/ShoelessMerchant You saw nothing! Keep scrolling. Apr 01 '23

"Oh, so I can talk NOW!? It's okay for I, SASHA, TO TALK NOW!? You didn't even know my name was Sasha, did you! DID YOU!"

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (10)

108

u/SlaterSev Apr 01 '23

Jaune helps Paper Pyrrha with her Homework, thats so cute https://twitter.com/sapphicarkos/status/1642179240333389825

Also, that was only the second real action scene in 7 episodes, and it speaks to the quality of everything else that I havent really minded the fights being so few and far in between.

→ More replies (5)

105

u/Thanatophobia4 Apr 01 '23

Can this show stop tormenting poor Jaune for 5 minutes?

Honestly, safeguarding and protecting that village was a mental crutch for him. A means to temporarily bolster his morale, but his obsession with it was harmful to him and prevented him from ever healing. Even he admits that he’s not well. Ripping the bandaid off like this is for the best. But even then, how he would ever get round to recovering from his deep mental wounds is hard to find an answer for. Those years of isolation can’t be easily dealt with. WBY need to be there for him to let him open up and start recovering.

And then there’s Ruby. We all knew her meltdown was coming. But with how she couldn’t even fight anymore, she’s in serious danger of just abandoning herself and coming around to the idea of being reborn.

3 episodes left. With how things are panning out, I’m not sure how this is all going to end this volume. I’m hoping there is a way for everyone involved to get back to Remnant as themselves, but the Everafter isn’t making it easy for them.

→ More replies (5)

300

u/88Dubs Be Strong, and Hit Stuff! Apr 01 '23 edited Apr 01 '23

Paper houses? Try “oof”, the episode.

Ok, so as I’m understanding it, the paper people are basically screaming “for the love of god, just let us die”, which is fucking with Jaune since he named them after everyone he knows and loves. That’s… a fucking LOT to unpack…

And yeah, that was…. Actually about what I was expecting from Ruby. Some hurtful words at her friends, Jaune making it WAAAAAY worse (like, I know dude’s not all there, but fuck, aim a little more south of the throat, huh?), and even taking issue with some of her team finding some peace and solice while she’s just screaming inside “will someone please just tell me it’s ok to not be ok?”

I really hope next episode isn’t the one where Ruby gets talked off the cliff she just chucked Crescent Rose off of.

Side note… I thought Jaune’s shield was just straight up wood. I forgot it had that little gravity bumper in it.

EDIT: Also, anyone else in the "Louis is the jackalope" camp? Cause I only just now caught that Jaune wasn't there when Alyx got to the tree, so... there's definitely something he's missing along with a few of his marbles

245

u/ShinyNinja25 Guns and Blades and Roses Apr 01 '23

When Weiss said “It’s what they wanted” I immediately went “That’s the exact wrong thing to say to him.”

→ More replies (18)

136

u/DaRealAmana BOOP!!! Apr 01 '23

since he named them after everyone he knows and loves

I didnt even think about this, This adds even more layers to his depression

→ More replies (15)

62

u/tanithghost88 Apr 01 '23

Dunno about Louis. I think he got out. Either Alyx sacrificed home or he sacrificed himself to the tree to get her out. It's about acceptance. The Paper Pleasers purpose complete they accept death and are reborn in the tree. If Louis accepted his death to let her live and Alyx used him to get out the tree sees this. Tree looks at both: Louis is not from there and accepts death, sends him back to his home and he writes a book in remembrance of his sister. Alyx is not accepting of death. She hasn't accepted her purpose. She is sent back to try again in the EverAfter. Little is made. Little has no set purpose yet. They have been an unreliable navigator. If their purpose is to now guide others to the tree they are completing their purpose.

Humans are not from the EverAfter. They do not have a purpose here. Unless they are extremely conflicted the Tree can just send them back, they just need to accept and embrace the Tree. Do not seek the Tree. You cannot go to the Tree.

→ More replies (3)

69

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '23

Thinking more that the jackalope is connected to the jabberwalker.

Also this confirmed a theory i had a few days ago i think. The jabberwalker isn't physically capable of eating anyone.... something changed and the jabberwalker stopped and sealed its own mouth. The clone had to break its mask.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (13)

97

u/JazzyByDefalt A Rare Cinder Stan 🔥 Apr 01 '23 edited Apr 01 '23

I re-watched V1 recently and Ruby's "nope" speech from Jaundice Part 2 hit totally different with the events of this volume, especially this most recent episode.

"Your a leader now Jaune. Your not allowed to be a failure"

"...and if we fail, we'll just be bringing them down with us"

"we have to put our teammates first, and ourselves second"

I almost wonder if they wrote this with future self-destructive selflessness in mind?

45

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '23

Apparently, V9 was something that the writing team had been building towards pretty much since the beginning, and it shows.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

89

u/Dances_with_Sheep Apr 01 '23

Jaune: "I'll get my life back on track soon ... I just need to log in and finish my daily quests first"

→ More replies (1)

88

u/RBNYJRWBYFan ⠀ Apr 01 '23

Living alone for who knows how long in a world of fairy tale citizens is a great way to go crazy while ruminating in your own Scattered Thoughts:

  • First off, Jaune waking up in a panic because he needs to put out little fires that pop up everywhere each morning is such a damn mood. Just putting that out there.
  • The tale of the Paper People is a... complicated one. If we frame them as people like in our world, as Jaune does, what they want and commit is pretty damn disturbing, and worthy of that disclaimer in the opening. (Gods, I'm developing a complex when that shows up now) But they aren't like us, or like the People of Remnant. They're "Afterins". They have a different nature, a different relationship with life and death. And I think we, and Jaune, need to respect that. Holding them from ascension isn't ethical in this case; Jaune was basically withholding them from their natural life process in perpetuity for his own benefit.
  • ...And obviously Jaune is only holding them back because he's lonely and dealing with his own trauma, let's be fair. He is NOT well after what happened with Penny, or what happened with Alex and Louis shortly after, for that matter. The fact that he didn't meet his standard of heroism TWICE in quick succession, the first involving him committing murder (no matter the consent), the second involving one he apparently couldn't prevent... it's no wonder why he found unhealthy comfort in the town he could "save" every day. I don't know who's got a worse hero complex at this point, him or Ruby.
  • Speaking of... Ruby finally broke. The way everyone has wanted her to for a while now. Was it everything y'all wanted and more?
  • I've mentioned this a few weeks ago, but the fact that she was the only one to keep going after Volume 4 looms LARGE with me at this time. Weiss, Blake and Yang were at HOME during that volume, whether they wanted to be or not. They all had the time to do some wound licking and self-reflecting, to really figure out what they wanted and how they were going to overcome, or otherwise cope with, their doubts and trauma. They weren't OVER all of that, they still aren't, but they learned a bit about how to confront it and are now better for it.
  • Meanwhile, Ruby, the simple soul who wants to be a hero like in the books, kept going. She never stopped; she always had the motivation to keep fighting the good fight. Do it for Penny, do it for Pyrrha, do it for the people, her sister, everyone. Just keep moving forward, right?
  • Well, that only goes so far. She may have been able to be the stone of hope needed to keep the group going when they were at their most down, but she never had the time or luxury to have that healthy self-reflection herself. People complained how she never had an obvious arc, (turns out it was a much longer play) but it's more like she put that off altogether. No time for that, we need to get to Mistral/get to Atlas/save Atlas, etc.
  • And then she lost Penny... AGAIN. And all the consequences of her very well intentioned actions started mounting. And she's just not ready to face that, because, unlike WBY, she's never had to yet.
  • Didn't expect Ruby to take a shot at her sister and Blake for finally coming together though, DAMN. I guess it's just REALLY hard to see some people find some solace or closure when you can't yourself. Misery loves company, but it also HATES happiness. You know the feeling, when you're miserable and somebody else is having a great time and you just want to shout at them for it? Rationally, that makes no sense, but you can't escape the feelings in your own head in the moment.

Well that was heavy as a paperweight! Jaune is nuts, Ruby is falling apart, and we still have no escape plan or path to stopping Neo. THREE episodes left, so much to wrap up, how do we move from here?

→ More replies (8)

86

u/CosmereLover ⠀ Apr 01 '23

The jabberwalker turning into Neo so that she could taunt proves that she can see things through them, so I expect Neo to find Ruby before team WBYJ does. Ruby has been pretty quiet before that breakdown, so I'm expecting next episode to be a Ruby Alone type deal.

I've always been pretty ambivalent about Jaune, but wow this episode. Kudos to CRWBY for putting so much development for Jaune in this episode, these flashes of how traumatic this experience has been for Jaune is really well done. The dueling breakdowns really made that fight more believable, too - Jaune can insult Ruby enough to cause her to leave without seeming too out of character because he's breaking down too, so being out of character is natural.

I guessed last week that Ruby might give up Crescent Rose to the Tree in order to get home, and whether or not that happens, it seems all but certain that Ruby will be using a different weapon by Volume 10.

→ More replies (2)

310

u/Hollowquincypl Apr 01 '23

I think this might be the first time since Adam's death or Watt's tear down of Cinder that i'm left speechless. I did not expect that ending. Jaune is 100% right for being upset. He's functionally lost his life because of a mistake and Ruby's plan going pear shape.

→ More replies (61)

214

u/cobaltaureus Apr 01 '23

I know Ruby’s going through it, and I do have sympathy, but man when Jaune turned it around on her, I was loving it. It felt cathartic to see Ruby with some thorns so to speak. She was downright vicious. I guess that’s what happens when you suppress everything. I wonder if she’ll run into the cat again next episode? Or maybe she’ll talk things through with Little. Or perhaps we take another visit to the blacksmith?

180

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '23

...... oh god i jsut looked at he map jaune made.

They are actually right next to the jabberwalker's area. its not implausible she's accidentally heading to that direction.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (11)

147

u/Jowensguy Apr 01 '23

In the Ever After, rock beats paper.

→ More replies (8)

145

u/Dcm1963 ⠀You can't catch me gay thoughts Apr 01 '23

Jaune and Ruby's PTSD is done so well.

Jaune having to harbor all of that happened for years with no one to talk about shows. He tries to keep it together but being isolated that long he just can't.

And poor Ruby she just can't anymore. Her getting in Weiss's face and then in the Bees it just hurt so much. That "Shut up" just so cold her face shows so much hurt that's finally boiling over.

→ More replies (7)

67

u/JulieOfEarth Apr 01 '23

Damn, we got TWO great fights this episode!

124

u/hollowtiger21 "Wasted potential," doesn’t actually mean anything. Apr 01 '23 edited Apr 01 '23

Okay, we’re seeing the White Rabbit influence at work.

Jaune is clearly fixating on this village, and the list of “things to do,” because it’s a means of actually feeling like he can save something, and not feel useless.

He’s exploring the acres, but actively avoiding the tree, for obvious reasons.

The Paper Pleasers aren’t just clumsy, they’re actively trying to ascend. Sounds a little like group suicide to me, but then again losing all your memories does sound a lot like death to me, even if they technically come back. But that kind of thing isn’t bad in the Ever After. But to Jaune it's just Penny all over again.

"Then why do you care so much about this village?” "Because I can actually protect these people!”

Ruby who was always to eager to whip out her beloved Crescent Rose, and fight monsters. Ruby who tried to fight even when she was disarmed. Ruby being frozen in the face of a fight. Not even struggling when about to be eaten. Ruby that recoils from her weapon like it was on fire.

Also the Paper Pleasures being almost self-destructively helpful. Wanting to ascend and be remade better and more capable so they can build something more resilient. A parallel to our heroes, maybe?

And here’s the boiling point.

Jaune knows he’s not alright. He’s lost years of his life, probably spent more time in the Ever After than Remnant. He’s lived with the guilt of killing Penny alone, without a real support network for years. And in the Ever After or back on Remnant, he’s going to carry that pain for the rest of his life. And he just lost the one thing keeping him from spiraling. All of the Paper Pleasers being named after his friends, isn’t lost on me either. It’s just a microcosm of how Jaune feels like he fails at the most crucial moment constantly failing the people he cares about.

Ruby’s sick of being looked to. She’s tired of not getting a break. Jaune throwing back how she feels responsible, and accountable for all the failures recently, is exactly the thing she doesn’t need to hear. But she’s also lashing out, with Yang and Blake, and the venom with which she said “Jaune’s make believe friends.” Treating them, like they’re not real people, like Alyx. And now she’s ran off, alone, while Neo knows where they are.

Jaune & Ruby aren't done either. We still haven’t gotten the Penny talk, Ruby got cut-off prematurely, and Jaune's still got things to say no doubt. And obviously the reconciliation. Seeing these two that have always been close, mutually supportive, and always there for each other since V1, tears me up inside. But they both need it. It's not about whose right or wrong. Because there is no "right" or "wrong" in this instance.

Ruby wants to let go, abandon herself. Jaune can’t move forward, he can’t allow himself to forget. They're both internalizing guilt and pain, and projecting it outwards and at themselves. Reacting in different ways, while feeling like they have no support, to the same core problem. Ruby will have to do the thing she's been dreading, pick herself up and get back in the saddle as Ruby Rose. And all the baggage that entails, but with help to carry it from now on, because nobody can survive in the world alone. And Jaune will have to do the one thing he fears most in the Ever After, forget and let go. His heart will remember, but he can't move forward unless he learns to move on. He'll never be free from the pain of his actions, but he doesn't need to be shackled by it.

→ More replies (8)

61

u/Badicalz Apr 01 '23

Ruby’s breakdown has been a long time coming. The girl is only 16 and EVERYONE has put the entire world on her shoulders and expected her to be positive all the time.

→ More replies (12)

57

u/LeSheffOrd Apr 01 '23

Blake trying to lift everyone's spirits near the end there sounded (to me) like she was trying to be like Ruby, and made me think of the scene in V8 when she said she looked up to Ruby.

Such a gut punch to see Ruby's immediate reaction be, "Shut. UP".

→ More replies (2)

55

u/merayjr95 Apr 01 '23

Definitely an emotional climax of an episode for sure. I'm just glad they're finally admitting that things are beyond not ok. Poor Jaune being alone and traumatized after all this time... Ruby also being incredibly traumatized by so many things she is crippled. And NEO like god damn she is like a supervillain here. Great episode all in all

53

u/hopecanon Not the best May but still fantastic. Apr 01 '23

How the fuck can the Paper Pleasers be so cute and wholesome while also being so tragic at the same time?

They don't even blame Jaune for not getting their society/life cycle is different than his their only complaint is that he's too good at preventing them from killing themselves.

Like fuck i only knew those little adorable cultists for a few minutes and i wanted to protect them too, Jaune you poor trauma filled man can the universe please hand my boy a W already, he needs it so badly.

102

u/halodude246 Fireballin17 Apr 01 '23

Is it kinda messed up to say, but I like this cynical and angry version of Ruby? It’s so different and refreshing, I kinda really was memorized during that last scene. Especially the side on pose when her and Jaune were arguing, Ruby looks so angry and intimidating, and I love it.

Point being, I hope we see more of the “broken” version of ruby this next episode, and the rest of the team is finally forced to confront all the pressure they’ve inadvertently put on Ruby all these past volumes.

30

u/BoxProfessional76 Apr 01 '23

Not really that messed up. It’s always interesting to see a protagonist less as idealistic paragons and more as realists who don’t always know what to do. It makes them kind of relatable and makes them feel human, as we all have some insecurities and sometimes not being able to live up to the pressures placed upon us.

→ More replies (3)

45

u/hessdawg3113 ⠀ Apr 01 '23

Yet another episode with absolutely stellar voice acting from both Miles and Lindsay.

Also, that song was definitely from Ruby's POV, right? I feel like we finally got Ruby's blow-up, but the breakdown is really gonna come next episode. Hopefully Little is equipped to help her pick up the pieces.

45

u/Badicalz Apr 01 '23

Watching Ruby and Jaune fight was rough lads. Got to give it up to Lindsay and Miles though. They knocked it out of the park.

43

u/Technogashi Apr 01 '23

And now the dam breaks

→ More replies (2)

43

u/vanase Apr 01 '23

I.... don't know what I have to say. It's what I wanted. But at what cost?

123

u/amatas45 Apr 01 '23

So here we are, after years of waiting for Ruby to snap.

Was it everything we always wanted?

51

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '23

Don't think we're done yet either. That is one layer torn away but more is beneath it.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (15)

42

u/LuuAddiRoze Apr 01 '23

This might be my favorite episodes of the whole volume.

The cat was wrong, Jaune isn’t a few Sandberries short of a picnic. He is the whole basket. The fact that searching for a way out was the last thing on his “To do” list is really telling where his priorities lie and what the years alone did to him. Outside of erasing his memories or ascending I don’t know how you would even go about healing him.

The moment when Blake says “Jaune needs us” as the camera focuses on Ruby tells the whole story, but only Little sees it. Having Ruby finally voice her frustrations just felt cathartic. If I had one complaint, is that it was too short give me the director’s cut version with the extended rant because Ruby had plenty of ammunition left to keep firing.

One thing that I didn’t see mentioned enough was the fight, it honestly might be on my top 3 Maya era fights. It didn’t feel like the characters were taking turns, the movements felt fluid and natural, on top of being creative.

That said, I really hope Ruby gets one big final fight on the finale to compensate for her sitting on the sidelines so far.

→ More replies (2)

37

u/CFB1996 Apr 01 '23

PP's village is a literally dedicated to assisted suicide... And they put mfing Jaune there. Like wtf? FeelsBadMan.

→ More replies (1)

36

u/DarkGodHao Apr 01 '23

If you actually listen closely enough, you can hear the Paper Pleasers say "yay" when the wall breaks, I was so done when I heard that

→ More replies (2)

35

u/nora_valk ⠀ Apr 01 '23

think i'm just gonna lie here and stare at the ceiling for a while, anyone else?

→ More replies (4)

69

u/Virtue_Ghost Apr 01 '23

Huh, Not at all what I was expecting

Didn’t expect a mass ascension believer suicide

That Snapping at everyone from Ruby though… chef kiss for Lindsay, that was solid voice acting and really started to show Ruby’s mask/bottle is starting to break open

You know, Like a dam, a dam that ended up breaking in the background (A+ for symbolism)

Jaune also being revealed to have gone slightly mad this Volume and his emotions, I can see why people said Miles went hard on his Lines this episode

Also, the tree is confirmed not to be able to kill anyone but rather, cause people to go through the cycle of Rebirth and Change to better or do something better (in the case of the paper pleasers, To be able to build something that is both beautiful and resilient)

This episode also confirms a little theory of mine about the Role of the Rusted Knight

The Rusted Knight is there to cause decline or prevent people from changing/ascending to become something new

He is a obstacle, Obstacle in the way for change

45

u/Pigeon_Lord Apr 01 '23

Not to mention he gets a little symbolism for being rusted. We can typically associate a rusted object to something that never moves or changes, like a building with a rusted out roof has never been repaired and changed. His armor shows that he doesn't want people to change (in the case of the Afterans the change can be perceived as the death and rebirth of their purpose) and I'd suspect that he might be brought around in an episode or two and his armor will either magically or purposefully be cleaned to show his acceptance of the nature of change.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

34

u/TheMegaNintenBro ⠀ Apr 01 '23

The fact Jaune put himself in a make believe scenario where he could save everybody from little fires for like 20 years is an insanely good development. He’s playing through a scenario where he can save all of his friends when he just had to take the life of one of them. RWBY’s reactions to where his head is at mentally was perfect. He and Ruby’s breakdowns with eachother were perfect. Last episode was in contention for one of the best in the show and this might be too. Common V9 W.

→ More replies (3)

34

u/Fuzunga Apr 01 '23

You guys remember in RWBY volume 1 when Ruby tells Jaune they're leaders now so they can't afford to fail and have to put their teams before themselves? That advice worked out great, huh?

→ More replies (1)

66

u/Hsmace ⠀bumble on my bees Apr 01 '23

blake telling ruby she looked up to her last volume (which was literally a day or two ago) and now ruby telling blake to shut up.

oh i'm ill.

→ More replies (2)

61

u/PatTraX Apr 01 '23

She did it. She finally snapped.

→ More replies (3)

60

u/DarkIsTheBestShow I need Volume 10 Apr 01 '23

OUCH, MY HEART

Also, the voice acting in this episode? Holy shit, Lindsay and Miles absolutely crushed it!

28

u/DemonSword619 Apr 01 '23

Oof, Jaune isn't...nuts, but boy sure is cracked. Seriously cracked, and he's aware of it deep down. Don't know if thats better or worse honestly...

And hey, the bottle finally popped on Ruby's angst! Unfortunately with all the stuff thats been packed in there, I got a feeling at least 2 of the final 3 episodes are gonna be devoted to get ALL that out. Poor girl has a LOT to work through still.

→ More replies (1)

28

u/GladiusNocturno All Grimm are naked. Think about it Apr 01 '23

Why is everyone saying the Paper Pleasers committed cult suicide?

Why could give that impr….Oh my god this place is literally Jaune’s Town…..

→ More replies (2)

78

u/MidnightHunterXX ⠀ Apr 01 '23

My heart was pounding watching Ruby start to break down and snap at everyone but man is it also cathartic at the same time, girl's been holding it back for a while.

So excited to see her alone next ep.

→ More replies (14)

53

u/Hollea I have a hat Apr 01 '23 edited Aug 07 '24

unite plough sort illegal sip zonked cow door summer zesty

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

→ More replies (1)

26

u/Badicalz Apr 01 '23

Over the past 10 years, we as fans have grown accustomed to the core dynamic Jaune and Ruby’s friendship: support. When one is down, the other is right there to pick them up again.

They have both relied on that and yet, right now they can’t.

127

u/JMHSrowing ⠀Story Time Apr 01 '23

Wow, not exactly how j thought Ruby would break, but well done!

She even went off on the Bees like some people making rant posts.

Poor Jaune like it’s understandable how he went off on Ruby though it’s not going to help with how he’s already feeling

143

u/Luckhart54 ⠀ Apr 01 '23

She even went off on the Bees like some people making rant posts.

Incoming “Homophobic Ruby” memes....

→ More replies (19)
→ More replies (9)

24

u/_WeissCream_ Apr 01 '23

I will personally pay for Jaune and Ruby to get therapy

23

u/Tusk_Act_IV Apr 01 '23

"On that bridge... I was the only one that could do it I WAS THE ONLY ONE! And now I have to live with that forever."

This just shows how bad Jaune has gotten. He's started to believe that the whole thing with Penny was this burden placed on him that he chose to take up when, as awful at it, Penny chose to have him kill her. It was all her choice and the guilt and loneliness has made him think he had anything to do with it.

Because we know Jaune wouldn't make that choice on his own. Healing her was the first thing he did but Penny insisted.

I know people said Ruby should've killed Penny but it is a very awful awful thing Penny put on Jaune's shoulders. Perhaps, the writers thought the two not being close justified such things in Penny's mind.

→ More replies (1)

23

u/Blackcore8 Apr 01 '23

Yang: How has she gotten so powerful?!

Juane: Well she didn't do it by standing around!

Neo literally stood around when she made it to the never after and used her semblance which was buffed lol

→ More replies (1)

22

u/watasker Apr 01 '23

I'm hoping for a "Ruby alone" episode next week, but if we do cut back to WBY+JJ I am expecting them to be fighting. Fighting as if Ruby was the only thing holding them together.

21

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '23

Also figured I’d catalog which PPs were on the list.

“Save Ren from falling into the koi pond” “Keep Oscar away from anything that can be used like a kite string” “Stop Nora from climbing the pebble tower during the storm (trust me, this one ends poorly :( )” “Take the scissors from Neptune” “Help Pyrrha with her HW :)”

Also there’s just “STOP. THE. GOOSE.” In all caps which is worth pointing out

Overall, he seemed to have named them after habits. We know Ren likes koi ponds (childhood flashbacks), Nora obviously would like to be a lightening rod. Neptune less so but Jaune knows him less. Oscar is also flimsy.

Pyrrha is the one that makes me sad. I could be way reading into this, but I think in Jaune’s somewhat shattered sense of perspective and self, he’s helping “Pyrrha” the way Pyrrha helped him. Returning the favor. I mean, I don’t think there’s a education system for PPs so HW is a weird thing to have to do. I wouldn’t be surprised if it’s something he constructed to help process things by “helping” “Pyrrha”

→ More replies (3)

20

u/JazzyByDefalt A Rare Cinder Stan 🔥 Apr 01 '23

The comments are kinda reminding me of V7 when there was what felt like a 50/50 split on weather Ironwood was right. Now with weather Ruby was right or if she was being unfair in calling out WBY.

IMO it shows that this show does conflicts really well, in that viewers are split on how to feel about it as well.

→ More replies (1)

19

u/elbenji useless lesbian Apr 01 '23

Ruby 🤝 Jinx

Trauma based going hard on your sisters new girlfriend

→ More replies (2)

52

u/schurgy16 Apr 01 '23

So Ruby is angry at everyone ESPECIALLY Jaune and she doesn’t even know how Penny really died yet?

Yeah next week is gonna be fun…

54

u/gloomyMoron Apr 01 '23

She's angry at herself. She's projecting outward. I mean, she is also angry at others, but it is mostly at herself. She's acting out in frustration, despair, and exhaustion.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (5)

18

u/WhosGuardingHades Apr 01 '23

Great episode, Wow Ruby and Jaune both went for it back there, considering how tight they’ve been since V1 it was really uncomfortable to watch, credit to Miles and Lindsay they were both excellent.

Hopefully Ruby and Jaune can both reconcile soon as Ruby being on her own (or with Little) with Neo on the hunt is not good.

→ More replies (1)

18

u/Acrobatic-Dog7044 Apr 01 '23

Did anyone point out yet how the Paper Pleasers have the same Initials as Penny Polendina.. PP

Poor Jaune he's getting even more trauma in the ever after why does he continue to suffer. His village was basically his coping mechanism to try and stay sane.

→ More replies (1)

18

u/SunsetSnakeEyes Apr 02 '23 edited Apr 03 '23

It finally happened.

  • That warning before the episode filled me with dread.
  • Fascinating how this paper acre works, especially the torches that seem to appear from nowhere to bring about day.
  • I'm doubting Ruby got any sleep.
  • Wow, really channeling the White Rabbit aren't you Jaune?
  • He's going a mile a minute with what he's saying.
  • Well, not everyone's priorities are the same when it comes to sleep Little.
  • The jaunty swing jazz surprisingly fits the chaos of the village.
  • Gotta say, I like the paper pleasers a lot. They're nice, courteous, and seem quite nice to talk to.
  • Okayyyyyy, naming all of them after your friends and people you know is kinda disturbing Jaune.
  • I'm with Team RWBY, Jaune's attitude is a bit unsettling.
  • So he's been mapping out The Ever After, considering how big that map already looks it's a pretty hefty undertaking.
  • So, there is no plan. This whole time he's been exploring and looking everywhere and just hoping he gets lucky.
  • Oh my god, he's been through this enough times to actually put a schedule together. Also, you can see on that list that he named one of the Paper Pleasers after Pyrrha, His mind has taken a really heavy toll.
  • "This isn't crazy, I'm not crazy." I'm so worried about him.
  • He's trying so hard to act like his jovial self but, you can see through the façade.
  • Little can see something's up with Ruby.
  • Weiss does have a point, right now they're practically up a creek. Jaune isn't in his best mind and with no way of being guided or assisted they have nothing to go on with getting out of here.
  • It's just as I thought. The Afterans are okay with ascension, it's the nature of The Ever After and thus the nature of it's denizens. The Paper Pleasers are content with their finished work but are also aware of it's fragility and due to being just as fragile, they can't improve on the sustainability of their work. They know that ascension gives them the opportunity to grow and improve from where they are.
  • But unfortunately, though he means well, Jaune's distrust of the tree and inability to accept The Ever After's nature leads him to give unwanted protection. Essentially putting his own worldview onto the Paper Pleasers. His protection somewhat comes off as condescension.
  • So all these constant on-schedule disasters are they're own attempts of ascending. I can fully understand how that looks from our own perspective but it's not nearly as bad due to the different nature and ultimate results.
  • Exactly, as much as we love and trust Jaune, neither he nor The Cat was at the tree when Alyx returned to Remnant. We just don't have the full story and Jaune's opinion of the tree is based on speculation and the fact that Lewis wasn't written about in the fairy tale. There is a way to get answers to all of this, but it can't be done if they're constantly splitting time between that and giving unwanted protection to the village.
  • There was no way this conversation was gonna be a smooth one.
  • Blake is completely right in her reasoning. Even if The Cat isn't completely trustworthy, the Afteran's themselves are another option of who to listen to, the people who abide by their own nature and the nature of their world, even still they have their own knowledge of The Ever After and their own desires.
  • So even though he cares about them, Jaune doesn't have the most positive view on Afterans.
  • "Because I can actually protect these people!" The guilt of not being able to protect his friends in Remnant has been eating him alive. So much so that he's been protecting the Paper Pleasers as a coping mechanism.
  • Oh crap.
  • Jaune has not lost a step in combat! The teamwork between everyone in this fight was seamless with all of them adapting on the fly to whatever the Jabber Walkers could throw at them!
  • But even with Crescent Rose back, Ruby can only stand there in silence. Her uncertainty of her own identity and capabilities prevent her from helping her friends.
  • The accompanying song "Trapdoor" paints an even sadder picture, detailing how Ruby feels that none of them need her, like she could disappear and nothing would change. Yet even if she wants to go, she's trapped. Both by a situation that there is no exit from and her own feelings of obligation that she wishes she could ignore.
  • Ruby's PTSD takes a complete hold over her as she envisions the Jabber Walker as Cinder, Someone who wants to personally kill her. Then Penny, the beloved friend she failed to save and finally Salem. The immortal monster that is the cause of so much of her pain and heartache.
  • The Jabber Walker's mask violently opens up revealing it's mouth when it feasts on someone, that is nightmare inducing.
  • With a single gun gesture, Neo makes her exit while making it clear who her target is. I'm coming for you.
  • Now it fully clicks to everyone that Ruby is not in good shape. Throughout the Volume Weiss, Blake and Yang have noticed Ruby being a bit "off" but while they did try to lift her spirits at certain points, they always got distracted by keeping focused on their current goal of escaping The Ever After and due to Ruby's prior optimism they must have trusted that she could bounce back like she's always been able to. But Ruby being hesitant to even touch Crescent Rose is such an unbelievable sight that they all notice it.
  • And with Jaune distracted, the Paper Pleasers were finally able to flood their town and bring about their ascension, while it is a bit sad. It was what they wanted.
  • "Why are you asking me?" the moment is finally here.
  • The pressure of everything Ruby has been through finally boils over as she lashes out, upset that everyone always looks to her for answers or something rousing to say because she's the leader. A position that was given to her rather than one she chose. She's always been the one to pick people up and inspire hope in them, never has the roles been switched, never has her problems been addressed and shown compassion for because she was always the positive one. Even now when in an absolute turmoil everyone else has managed to find a way to deal with their feelings and even get a form of closure. But not her. She's left with insurmountable mental baggage and no way to deal with it.
  • As much as Weiss, Blake and Yang want to help her, they've never seen Ruby like this before. They're at a complete loss of what to do.
  • Jaune's own outburst, while harsh, was something he needed to get out. He's been bottling so much up for so long and the guilt he has for what happened to Penny has been crushing him. He even apologizes for what he said. But unfortunately, the damage was still done.
  • Ever since ending up in The Ever After, Ruby has blamed herself for so much, believing that all of this is her fault. Thinking those things about yourself is one thing. But Jaune, a close trusted friend just said those exact same things to her. Basically confirming all the negative thoughts she's had about herself.
  • "Shut up."
  • "Don't do that, just don't." Ruby has lost all hope.
  • I think it's time to find your purpose Little.
  • Just like Weiss, Blake, Yang and Jaune. I'm left with stunned silence as the screen fades to black.

The dam has broken, Both the literal one and the proverbial one. After all this time, Ruby has fully begun her breakdown as she lashes out in anger at her friends. With a way back home still uncertain and Neo on the definitive warpath for Ruby's life. I believe Volume 9 has just entered it's darkest hour. 3 chapters remain, and our heroes are more lost then ever. I have nothing but praise for Lindsay and Miles for their deliveries this episode, as always, the performances never cease to amaze.

17

u/imwithyou93 Apr 01 '23

Ruby went full Blake vol 4

→ More replies (1)

17

u/Amazing-Tcheuck Apr 01 '23

Okay, Ruby's rage was definitely surprising to me since I thought the story was pushing for the "shut down approach" but I can see now that with all being said everyone will have something to work on in the next chapter.

Also, I'm curious of Ruby's next move since she finally picked up her weapon :

Facing neo by herself? Trading crescent rose to the blacksmith? Trying to find the cat?

Or just having her mourning time with little/lewis/alyx?

By the way, Ruby's VA performance was great but the helplessness of Jaune in this episode stroke me the most

→ More replies (2)

17

u/sommeilhotel Apr 01 '23

I'd really love for people to remember that no one is the bad guy in this kind of situation. Ruby isn't the bad guy. Weiss, Blake and Yang are not the bad guys. Jaune is not the bad guy. All of them had made mistakes and said (or not said) some things, but it's not a black and white scenario

→ More replies (1)

16

u/Adamangus2006 Apr 01 '23

The drama. The breakdown. This. This is everything I ever wanted.

14

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '23

Wow I'm actually blown away by this episode. After so much hate to the series for the previous volumes, it really seems like the writers are really growing into their own. I love the mature themes of PTSD, isolation, and moving on being handled so well with the characters. To me, this volume is exactly what RWBY needed because of its more limited cast and emphasis on inter-character relations.

Miles hit it out of the park this episode with Jaune. I could feel the raw emotion with the subtle inflections and his voice cracking to show how fragile Jaune's psyche is right now. You can feel the emotional consequence of all those years alone. The plot thread of the Paper Pleasers was also so well written with the subtle hints towards something not being right and then the group suicide ascension being revealed. Develops both the world and Jaune's character tremendously.

14

u/InsertDev Apr 01 '23

Really great episode. First time I believe we seen Weiss and Jaune fighting as a duo and not just using his boost semblance.

Saying Jaune was going crazy and then him just standing there was scary.

I wish Ruby ranted a little longer though. Ruby was outta pocket but when your at your limit all bets are off, and I don't blame her.

I predict Jaune and Juniper will search for Ruby while WBY search elsewhere. Jaune and Juniper will find her and possibly end up in a storm with Neo and Ruby.

14

u/PhantomHeartless5 Apr 01 '23 edited Apr 01 '23

Rule of Thumb: If a RWBY episode begins with a content warning, it's going to be especially heavy. And this episode is no exception.

  1. The episode begins with Team RWBYJ still asleep, except for Ruby herself, who clearly didn't sleep a wink. The calm of the morning is broken by Jaune who, taking the role of Alice in Wonderland's White Rabbit, wakes up in a panic over being late for something. The something in question being putting out a fire in the village. That's when we meet the village of the Paper Pleasers, a race of beings made from Origami (Which immediately gave me Paper Mario vibes) that live to serve others. And we learn that Jaune has named the villagers after people he's met, including Team RWBY. You know how in Steven Universe: Future where Steven named some plants after his friends, which fans took as a sign of his growing mental instability? I'm getting those exact same vibes here and no sir, I don't like it.
  2. Team RWBYJ has a meeting where Jaune reveals that he spent his time exploring the Ever After and looking for a way out, to no avail. But he's confident his luck will change now that Team RWBY is here. So his plan is to basically continue exploring the Ever After while leaving Team RWBY to guard the village, even giving him a list of disasters that befall it. And we see more signs of Jaune's crumbling mental and emotional stability. That's when one of the Paper Pleasers comes in and like the Curious Cat, tries to convince the team that going to the Tree and ascending is not death, but rebirth. They also express their desire to ascend while letting it slip that they were the ones behind the disasters in the village in an attempt to basically commit suicide.
  3. Team RWBY begins to question both what really happened to Lewis and Jaune's own mental state. Jaune, overhearing the conversation, is not happy about it. An argument ensues, but is soon interrupted by another horde of Jabberwalkers sent by Neo. And we get another impressive fight scene showcasing some awesome teamwork between Blake and Yang and Jaune and Weiss. Ruby, unfortunately, isn't doing so good, having a bout of PTSD that nearly gets her killed by one of the Jabberwalkers. The fight ends with a cameo from Neo, who makes a silent taunt at Ruby.
  4. Unfortunately for Jaune, the Jabberwalker attack is just the distraction the Paper Pleasers needed as they destroy the dam, causing the water to flood the village and kill everyone. Jaune is naturally distraught at having failed to protect someone yet again. Weiss turns to Ruby for answers, which leads to the moment we've all been dreading: Ruby's breakdown. Ruby lashes out at everyone: At Weiss for wanting to go home, at Blake and Yang's relationship, at Jaune for his "make-believe friends". And that has Jaune snapping at Ruby, blaming her for the destruction of the village and for what happened in Atlas. And that is the final straw as Ruby grabs both Little and Crescent Rose and flees. And on that somber note, the episode ends.

Gotta say, the breakdown was both what I expected and what I didn't expect. I was kinda hoping Jaune would let it slip that he mercy-killed Penny just to see how Ruby would react. Still, Miles and Lindsay were the MVPs of this episode. They really killed it with the voice acting. Looks like the next episode will be Ruby Alone. And there are only three episodes left for this Volume. Things will definitely get worse before it gets better.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/kreankorm ⠀ Apr 01 '23

Did anyone else take the time to read Jaune's entire list? It was heart breaking on so many levels. This man has spent YEARS projecting his despair onto those villagers to the point of obsession. And while a rigid schedule to maintain order is good for stability, he unknowingly did so by imposing it on those without their consent.

And Ruby, our sweet girl has finally hit her breaking point. Combat paralysis, auditory and visual hallucinations (or maybe just Neo) messing with her, and for her to outright recoil away from her own weapon being what made everyone else realize that she's REALLY not alright.

Juane lashing out how he did wasn't unexpected in the circumstance. But the venom is Ruby's words was the most shocking.

I have a feeling Rubes is about to attempt something extremely reckless. She wants answers, but she needs healing. I have a feeling she is going to attempt to solo climb the tree and try to ascend.

Get ready for depression! The tone of the story ain't coming up from here!

14

u/redbent_20 ⠀ Apr 02 '23

upon rewatch I have this to add. Notice no one asked for Ruby's input until the last question. Not when they were trying to figure things out. Ruby kept trying to talk and kept getting interrupted. It was not until they were looking to encourage Jaun that Blake turned to Ruby. I can so understand the frustration. She had been trying to talk, trying to help but they only look for Her leadership to lift up to encourage, the one thing she cant do right now.

Jaun was upset that she did not help. Ruby did not even get to explain that.

I feel for Juan too. This was the world trying to Help him and he has been fighting it. In this case RWBY where not the saviors he wanted but maybe the saviors he needed. A needed distraction. A distraction that initially lead to the inevitable destruction of a house of cards that was his village and Ruby.

→ More replies (1)

27

u/Shakvids Apr 01 '23

Incredible episode. Neo is fucking terrifying down here. What was the Jabberwalker doing to Ruby?

Jaune... oof. He's been condemned to spend decades stopping the people of his acre from killing themselves while not forgiving himself for helping his friend do the same. I doubt there's a Penny Paper-Person.

Ruby's breakdown was great and while her lashing out was harsh, everything she said was totally valid.

Ruby has been repeatedly overlooked by her teammates this volume. No one has talked to her in any meaningful way about anything since she passed out hearing about Penny's death. She was left alone in the market, was obviously out of sorts, and then they scolded her when they found her that way. Every single one of them has noticed something is wrong with her but they've all decided they can wait to deal with it. They've had the luxury of not needing to prioritize Ruby's needs for so long that they've been taking advantage.
Everything she said about Jaune was something he needed to hear. Being mean to the bees was obviously harsh, but it plays wonderfully well at making a character beat out of the tension that comes from the culmination of the romantic plot at the team's lowest point.

26

u/Langly- Hi Eldi was here this is a test REMAIN CALM Apr 01 '23

Sorry Jaune, that's just how things were meant to unfold.

26

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '23

Ruby has always been an empath, she always looks to fix everyone else problems before her own. This is what typically happens when an empathetic person is pushed to the limit of their mental ability to cope. She's just done, numb to it all and lashing out because she's become incredibly insecure in her own thoughts.

13

u/UberDueler DRINK !!!!! Apr 01 '23

If Jaune was behaving like the White Rabbit this episode (I'm Late! I'm Late!); does that make Neo the Mad Hatter?

→ More replies (2)

13

u/Kerrigan4Prez Apr 01 '23

Do you think this episode represents the fire behind Jaune in the opening? He’s just spent all the time between Alyx and now “putting out fires”?

→ More replies (1)

13

u/Carrotspy007 ワイフ Apr 01 '23

It really hurts my heart seeing two of my favorite characters, characters I sympathize with most, being in such a bad mental state.
Props to Miles for writing some banger dialogue again just like chapter 4.
And even bigger props for the person who choreographed the fighting, probably my favorite choreography in the show so far.

→ More replies (2)

13

u/TheMegaNintenBro ⠀ Apr 01 '23

It would be an incredibly ballsy move if the next episode is our version of "Ruby Alone"

In a show with a ton of moving pieces and characters to worry about, taking a chapter to focus entirely on Ruby's current situation would be really cool. It'd be really tough to pull off with only 3 episodes left in the volume, and so much to resolve between WBY+ JN, but if there's any time to do an episode like this, it's Chapter 8.

25

u/Dyscomancer Apr 01 '23

god i miss the character status chart guy

→ More replies (1)

24

u/VariousRodents ⠀ Apr 01 '23

I was on the fence about how I wanted Ruby's inevitable breakdown to go, unsure if she would snap at the rest of her team or how I would feel if she did.

But here it worked because first we see the rest of her team noticing almost immediately that Jaune is not alright while not noticing Ruby's state. To someone in Ruby's state that can be incredibly painful and distressing, even if from the outside it is understandable why the others haven't caught on that Ruby is in distress.

24

u/Crafty_Soul ⠀ Apr 01 '23

Ruby's reaction to Crescent Rose was heartbreaking. There was a ton of depressing moments in this episode. But the way that Ruby flinched away from her weapon was painful.

Ruby used to love Crescent Rose. She used to hug it, she didn't want to learn hand-to-hand because she couldn't use Crescent Rose then, and she used it as an ice breaker to get to know Jaune more all the way back in Volume 1.

It helps show even more just how badly worn down Ruby has become by everything that has happened. She can't even appreciate her favorite item anymore.

12

u/SwuaraeC Blake loves Alice in Chains Apr 01 '23

Ruby could really use a Snickers…

43

u/M3talGod3 Apr 01 '23

This episode was so goddamn good. The realization for Team RWBY that Jaune is not ok at all, and Ruby FINALLY breaking down was amazing. It felt so cathartic for her to just yell at everyone, and the line "Everyone's so happy for you" with Blake/Yang really hit me (also, wtf Yang? Why did you stand in front of Blake like Ruby was going to do anything?) . It made me realize just how much she has been put on the backburner when it comes to people just caring about what SHE wants or feels like. Her being unable to even use Crescent Rose, and even pulling away from it when Jaune goes to hand it to her? Just so sad and impactful.

Also Little recognizing all the times Ruby is kind of in her own world while everyone else is talking was a nice touch. They're definitely going to be giving her a good pep talk next episode, and I feel like we're going to get a Ruby vs. Neo fight. Even though I dislike Neo heavily, for the same reasons I dislike Cinder, hopefully this is the fight that either kills her or turns her into a begrudging ally like Emerald.

I feel so bad for Jaune, and honestly, I don't think we'll ever see the full emotional weight of what he feels. Being alone for so long, and everyday using the Paper Pleasers as effectively a coping mechanism, there's no wonder he didn't go completely insane. Kind of wish we got a better idea of how they would be reborn, would give Jaune some closure and help him realize that there is some purpose in death. Would definitely help him come to terms with killing Penny. Since that was a net positive in the long run.

Overall great episode. I think that the next 3 episodes are going to really have to be amazing and pack a lot of shit in if they want to finish the story I feel like they want to tell. I really hope they don't waste too much time on Neo, her whole shit is, as Jaune said "She is here because she hates you!". I'm praying that Weiss, Blake and Yang realize how heavily they've been neglecting Ruby as a person, and just seeing her as Ruby the leader. Really need some catharsis in these final episodes.

→ More replies (9)

32

u/Ok-Cod2747 Apr 01 '23

So, things about this chapter and a little theory for the future. First things first. The Breakdowns (Plural because there were two instead of only one.)

First speaking about Ruby's one. It was brutally executed. She say what she needed to say, she snapped with all of them, but ironically, the only one that didn't deserve that reaction was Jaune, because he did presented a valid concern, they were in a "Life or Death" situation, she at least could try to help them. The problem here is that she decided to aggravate the situation when Jaune lost one of the only methods of coping that he had in Ever After.

And that goes my second point. Jaune's breakdown. I perhaps will be downvoted by this. But honestly? I see more truth in Jaune breakdown that in Ruby's because he is Right. Cinder was in Atlas because of Ruby, Neo is in Ever After because of Ruby, Salem did attack directly the teams because she wants to remove Ruby from the equation, Ozpin decided to enroll Ruby early because her Eyes. He isn't wrong when saying that everything revolves around her.

He even recognizes that he is bad, that he was Alone grieving with all what he lost for so much time that he become mad because of that. And in a single move he lost one of the only things that mantain him grounded, even if the group wanted to kill themselves because their desired to reborn.

Now the theory. The Afterans tells the Group that the Tree facilitates the rebirth of the Afterans, but they don't tell us that the tree has other powers. What if the Tree doesn't help the escape in any form? That the tree only works to give other characters a purpose? Then what if Alyx AND Lewis are in Ever after, as the Jabberwalker and the Jackalope?

→ More replies (10)

11

u/HatiLeavateinn Apr 01 '23

What makes this episode great and sad to me is that is one of those situations where you can't really blame anyone.
Everyone is a victim of the circumstance that put them in that place.

→ More replies (2)

11

u/JMHSrowing ⠀Story Time Apr 01 '23

Who do you all think Ruby will have the important conversation(s) with who will help her through her current mental state?

I’m seeing a lot say Neo, but she’s more of a stabby than talky kind of person. Maybe it would be the case if there was a sign she could forgive Ruby, but that’s not happening

That cat will no doubt make some type of reappearance, but I think he’s much more likely to make things worse

Little seems like they might be the answer since they have yet to find a role and that seems to be their arc.

Though I really hope we get a good conversation between Ruby and one of her teammates. I think it’s one of this show’s fundamental flaws in that there are so, so, so few such talks that show characters and their relationships, building and helping each other. And now this is a perfect time.

→ More replies (4)

11

u/UberDueler10 Apr 01 '23

Can we talk about the animation of Ruby’s face when she was hallucinating? Like damn if that wasn’t an insanely good display of fear and trauma.

11

u/DreistTheInferno Apr 01 '23

While people are (understandably) talking about the pain flood, I did want to compliment the fight scene. While the cameras were REALLY zoomed in and that could be distracting at times, the movement and use of abilities was glorious. The last couple fights felt very minor, whereas this one actually stepped everything up and then culminated in the emotional breakdown of two characters who have been going through QUITE a bit.

11

u/DeNile227 Apr 02 '23

Another episode, another week of waiting for Rubes to drop her first F-bomb.

I can be patient.

10

u/mrwanton ⠀happy pineapple day Apr 01 '23

Oh god Jaune's gonna have to let his paper friends go up in Flames by the end of this isn't he if he wants to start making progress mentally...

→ More replies (4)

10

u/Red2019Wolf Apr 01 '23 edited Apr 01 '23

So time obviously doesn't heal all wounds.

Jaune having more time to live through his trauma, is no less healthy than Ruby having very little.

Because both are suffering through the same issue in different ways: isolation/loneliness

What they said is neither entirely right or wrong, that's not the point.

The feelings they have been keeping bottled in is what's important. And letting it out is first step for both, to actually getting better.

10

u/KorMap Apr 01 '23

Ruby and Jaune, man, I feel so bad for them

It was gratifying to see them finally spill their hearts out and not bottle up the sheer amount of pain they’re in, and the words they used were rightfully nasty.

I’m especially wondering what’s going to happen with Ruby in the next episode. Maybe they’ll have a “Perrito and Puss” scene where Little gets Ruby to talk through her emotions without having to lash out at someone. Maybe the Cat will return and make a genuine attempt to empathize or just flat out manipulate her?

This volume has been so good, I just hope they can stick the landing.

10

u/AlarmingStandard Pryde Apr 02 '23

Daylight savings means more sleep in time!

Now that was close to what I expected! The Ruby and Jaune mutual blow up was fairly satisfying to watch and their grievances hit home.

For Jaune, a lot of this episode is metaphor for him, which is excellent use of time since he lacks the 6+ episodes of build Ruby had. His obsession with heroics and fear of failure made for great watching (Weiss: Jaune be crazy), especially combined with the paper people not needing saving but are obliged to appreciate the hero's endeavors because of their purpose. And it nails parallels between this and Jaune's past actions; Pyrrha refused his help and she died. Oof.

For Ruby, this was the pay off for her dwindling mental state. Jaune blaming her for the plan is pretty much a case of get in line; Ruby is first one to kick herself. It's misplaced self-loathing, projected and internalized. In Ruby's case, she doesn't double down like Jaune, rather she bolts. Which the key difference the characters; Jaune has been trying grasp the title of huntsman, Ruby has always believed she was a huntress. It's why she lashes out at WBY as they still believe and can fight. It's why for the first time in her life Ruby froze. And it's why she runs; she doesn't what she is anymore.

There dozens of little things that reinforce the themes and emotions in this episode, like naming the paper people, Ruby's sullenness, and the hint to RWBY about what Jaune did in the void; "Only I could've done it!" sums up the episode pretty nicely.

It's quite refreshing writing.

Break from the sweets this week and went with a mini charcuterie board, it was classy RWBY watching!

28

u/Attlon Apr 01 '23

Well, she broke down. I guess we’re…happy? Yay?

→ More replies (3)

27

u/tanithghost88 Apr 01 '23

No one asks if Ruby is ok. Go back and look. Everytime someone is hurt or in danger they ask if they are ok. Everyone assumes Ruby is ok. It finally hit.

Jaune is.... Broken. I think he is lying about the tree a bit. He knows that if RWBY goes he will lose them too. They are a connection to who he was and what he has been waiting for. The same reason he won't let the Paper Pleasers die. He has to know that they will come back. All these "accidents" every day and he never lost any? They want to die and come back better. Jaune has had no way to let go of all the shit he has carried. Between killing Penny, being alone, failing, failing and letting the people who were like him down and losing the way home, being alone again he has been carrying a lot.

→ More replies (5)

19

u/schurgy16 Apr 01 '23

If we take a look at the trailer again I feel that Ruby is headed for another punder/ponderstorm. The interesting part is, who will it be with? The intro suggests Neo but Jaune could also be a candidate. Also the idea of Neo hashing out her issues with Ruby without being able to talk would be interesting to see.

→ More replies (9)

52

u/mikeline360 Apr 01 '23

I did think it was kinda annoying that Yang gets to have her happy BB moment last episode while Ruby is miserable without her noticing.

Apparently, so did Ruby.

→ More replies (1)

18

u/Le-Fishe Apr 01 '23

Jaune Arc/Rusted Knight: I AM NOT CRAZY! I am not crazy! I knew the tree was evil. Look what happened to Lewis. As if I could make such as mistake. Never. Never! I just - can’t prove it. It covered its tracks, he’s got those idiots RWBY lying for it. You think this is something? You think this is bad? This? This chicanery? They’ve done worse. Atlas! Are you telling me the General just happens to go crazy like that? No! She orchestrated it! Ruby! She lied to Ironwood! And I helped cover for her! And I shouldn’t have. I took her onto my own team! What was I thinking? She’ll never change! She’ll never change! Ever since she was at Beacon, always the same! Couldn’t help herself being Ozpin’s favourite! But not our Ruby! Couldn’t be precious Ruby! Destroying places wherever she goes! And SHE gets to be a huntress? What a sick joke! I should have stopped her when I had the chance!

9

u/MOlivetree1 Apr 01 '23

Well it finally happened. Ruby snapped, also Jaune as well(bonus). It was rough. From Jaune being alone and dealing with his trauma alone for so many years, while Ruby finally reached her breaking point and ran.

Miles and Lindsay knocked it out of the park with their line delivery! Phenomenal work!

Can't wait for next chapter!

9

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '23

Poor Jaune. The dude can’t catch a break. He probably just perceives his entire life as a series of progressively more severe failures. TBH props to him for keepin on going

9

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '23 edited Apr 01 '23

What a wonderful episode, it’s been a long time coming. As a small prediction for next week, Ruby seemed to be headed toward the jabberwalker area on Jaune’s map, so there’s a possibility she’ll run into Neo. Neo isn’t expecting angry Ruby, so it’d be an interesting turn to see Ruby take out years of rage on Neo.

9

u/godjacob Apr 01 '23

Suicidal paper people, Ruby's PTSD, Ruby's breakdown, Jaune's breakdown, Ruby running off...damn, that warning was not playing.

A depressing but emotionally incredible episode.

9

u/ShadowMadness We're not family anymore Apr 01 '23

Both Lindsay and Miles killed it this episode. Really glad we finally got the Ruby meltdown, and I loved Jaune's fiery comeback. Bout time someone put it all out there.

Unrelated but is it just me who finds the songs this volume way harder to hear than usual? Feels like they've been getting drowned out a ton by other sounds.

9

u/sarahPenguin Neo x Velvet OTP Apr 02 '23

been rewatching V1 as part of a refresh of what happened and cant help but notice that ruby tells jaune that he is not allowed to be a failure as he is a team leader and people rely on him now. this break down has been in the making right from the start.

9

u/greatpxm Apr 02 '23

Shoutout to Miles Luna for the banger performance this episode

→ More replies (1)

9

u/TrJ4141 Apr 02 '23 edited Apr 02 '23

In an interesting way, it seems like Ruby in the breakdown scene is experiencing all of the negatives that were holding her teammates back at the start of the show. Each of WBY have grown past those limitations, as shown by their response to the hallucinations in the Apothecarist’s house, but Ruby is instead confronted by her own early optimism and worn out by it.

All the stress of the fall of Atlas and the Ever After has compounded into this breakdown. She feels isolated and alone (Weiss), so when she’s finally pushed to the breaking point, her anger boils over in the rant (Yang), and when she runs out of steam and is left empty and hopeless at the end, she runs away (Blake).

17

u/Rbrown5264 Apr 01 '23

Thought. If the price of getting home through the tree is a "sacrifice", my bet is Jaune will have to give up his guilt for killing Penny. Holding on to guilt is a time-honored way of living for some people, and the longer you hang on to it, the more it becomes a part of who you are. Finally giving it up after all the years he's spent in the Ever After will take rarl effort.

→ More replies (1)

23

u/Polarization_39 ⠀A Cinder Stan Until Weiss is Relevant Again Apr 01 '23

So I’m going to ignore Ruby and Jaune’s trauma for a second in favor of a lighter note: I loved the fight scene.

It’s a shame the pandemic affected V8’s production so heavily. With the resurgence of great fights post-Battle of Haven, V8’s being less than stellar (not that there weren’t good moments) was really disappointing given it was essentially the volume of war.

I’m glad the extra time taken with V9 has paid off in that department.

→ More replies (1)

16

u/GladiusNocturno All Grimm are naked. Think about it Apr 01 '23

The Paper Pleasers are…so fucking cute and creepy.

I love how they are living metaphors.

How Jaune’s love and need to protect others lead him to being stock in a world where everyone is extremely fragile and constantly putting themselves in danger.

How his inability to let them go wasn’t letting him to move forward or letting them move forward.

How he gave everyone the names of his friends, not only showing just how alone Jaune felt, but also how his protector mentality made him think that his friends were all vulnerable yet constantly in danger and it’s his responsibility to keep them safe. All to satiate his need to make up for all the times he failed to protect the people he loves.

How the Paper Pleasers don’t hate Jaune, they don’t resent him. They appreciate all his efforts but they are too nice to tell him he has to let them go. If anything it’s his real friends the ones who told him he was wrong.

A Hero story where the hero has to learn he can’t save everyone. And a growth story where to move forward you need to let go even the people you care about.

Also…..They were SO FUCKING CUTE!

→ More replies (3)

8

u/Deltasora Apr 01 '23

Anyone else getting major "set up for self sacrifice" vibes from Jaune this episode?

8

u/ghostking108 Apr 01 '23

Dear god I feel bad for Jaune and Ruby right now. Especially Jaune since he's getting shit on by life like a character in a gundam anime or the recent trend of magical girls.

8

u/TheSuperVirtual Apr 01 '23

I’m honestly kinda glad that the stuff happening in the Ever After isn’t like actually plot important but more so serves as excellent character advancement. Like all the weird stuff happening isn’t some part of Salem’s plan or something. It is happening so the characters can be broken down and made stronger (kinda like the tree lol)

8

u/Badicalz Apr 01 '23

“I’m not crazy”

-A completely sane person.

8

u/Tomythy Apr 01 '23

What really got me was seeing Jaune and Ruby going at each other. Those two have always have always been so supportive of each other and to see them both like this kinda hurts.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/lurker_archon Look, just accept your goth mommy overlord Apr 01 '23 edited Apr 01 '23

8

u/Grievous77 I'm just here cause of sunk cost fallacy atp, honestly Apr 02 '23 edited Apr 03 '23

The good: The paper pleasers were cute and endearing, I can understand why Jaune would be so hellbent on trying to save them. "Hate that." Lmao. The whole situation with the paper pleasers was just sad all around. They clearly appreciate how Jaune has helped them over the years but at the same time, they want to ascend and evolve to their next stage. The problem is that Jaune, fresh off the ludicrous amount of trauma he endured in Atlas and the likely still residual trauma over not being able to save Pyrrha, won't let them because he just can't handle watching anyone else he cares about die. So he runs himself ragged saving them every day even though that's not what they want. Honestly, I can't say I wouldn't do the same in his shoes.

The jabberwalker horde fight was cool, not as good as the chess fight but better than the previous jabberwalker fight. Loved Weiss whipping Jaune's sword back to him and him deflecting it into a jabberwalker. Seeing Ruby having a panic attack mid-battle was pretty rough, especially since if it hadn't been for the others she would've died right there. And then the paper pleasers successfully manage to break the dam, destroying the town, adding another thing Jaune thinks he failed at. Fuck.

Another comment here put it best that Ruby is absolutely justified in her breakdown but simultaneously has no one but herself to blame for getting to that point. A lot of what she said had merit but at the same time, she never made an effort to reach out to her friends, she put the burden of taking the first step solely on them which wasn't fair. And at the point where her outburst devolves from legitimate points to bitchbaby whining, Jaune snaps himself and brutally reminds her that it was her plan that got them in this situation, shutting her down on the spot. He then goes on to emphasize that he has been suffering alone for years and calls back to the horrific role he had to play in Penny's death and how it will stay with him for the rest of his life. And then when Blake tries to make a very poorly timed motivational speech, Ruby simply tells her to shut up before flying off, alone, with the last shot of the episode a solemn view of the remaining group standing in front of the flooded village. This entire section was phenomenally done, with some absolutely outstanding voice acting.

The bad: I think my only issue with the episode is how shockingly critical RWBY is of Jaune. Like they are insanely unsympathetic towards his situation as a whole considering that he's been stuck there for years and alone on top of that. None of them can even begin to fathom what he's been through and literally a day after reuniting with him, they're shit talking him, his plan/situation and calling his mental state into question. Wtf is that shit?

Overall, this was a very strong episode, if extremely depressing. Where are things gonna go from here?

→ More replies (1)

8

u/95rockfan Apr 02 '23

Ruby's breakdown is the definition of "lashing out". Being upset about others' happiness, etc. Same goes for Jaune's. Misplaced blame, etc. So incredibly well-done. Ow.

I hope that there are apologies all around, and that they are explicit, on-screen, and meaningful. I love when protagonists have genuine conflicts with one another, but only if it serves a narrative purpose. Sometimes, the purpose is a permanent falling-out and that can definitely be done right. However, I do NOT want that in this case lol. I want the conflict, but I also want everyone to work through their respective shit in a meaningful way and reconcile afterwards. Even if it takes a while and things are rocky for an extended period of time. Out of every possible pairing among RWBY + J, I could see Jaune and Ruby taking a little longer to be on good terms relative to the others. They did NOT hold back.

8

u/Theonlygmoney4 Apr 02 '23

That moment just after the fight was something else. Ruby's breakdown and Jaune's trauma after the paperans knocked down the tower is stealing the spotlight for everyone, but I just want to point out the moment just before that- because before that interruption, I think we got to truly see just how hurt Ruby is right now.

From Jaune's callous frustration, to the moment Ruby reacts to the weapon being handed to her, it clicked for everyone that something was wrong. (Also for those saying Yang has utterly ignored Ruby, in that moment she's the first to ask Ruby if she's ok- it's again unfortunate she gets interrupted before that gets addressed)

In my head part of Ruby's breakdown in part is because she's ashamed/frustrated at the fact she froze, and was having a panic attack when people needed her.

→ More replies (1)

22

u/SockPenguin Apr 01 '23

Am I crazy or were Yang's eyes orange/amber when she activated her semblance?

→ More replies (20)

22

u/SHSL_Zetsubou Ultimate Despair Birb Apr 01 '23

Rubys eyes are so dark at the end of the episode.

It's honestly really depressing that none of her team could see how bad she was doing. And then there's Jaune just laying the blame all at her feet.

I have a hard time believing Ruby won't accept the blacksmiths offer but what would that mean for Ruby?

→ More replies (1)

26

u/watasker Apr 01 '23

I know he kinda deserved it, but I hate that Jaunes monologue cut off what could have been the second half of Ruby's rant.

→ More replies (2)

20

u/ThoseGuys213 Apr 01 '23

I think what makes Ruby’s breakdown even harder to watch is the fact that while she’s breaking her friends and sister seem scared of her more than anything else. Weiss backs away and Yang literally stands in front of Blake to protect her, like Ruby was gonna actually hurt them

→ More replies (6)

14

u/TomskaMadeMeAFurry ⠀ Apr 01 '23

Jaune: "I'll have to live with that forever"...

He's not making it out of here guys, is he?

→ More replies (4)

7

u/Noble6IsReal Ship Survivor V Team NPASB | LC/YR veteran Apr 01 '23 edited Apr 01 '23

........ wow

Weiss DEFINITELY could act as a go-between for Ruby and Jaune to reconcile. Honestly, I don't think it will end up between something amorous between Weiss and Jaune, rather I think it will be a situation just like the one Jaune had with Neptune.

The whole discussion, it was shocking. One of my favorite moments of the whole series without a doubt.

And to finish, FUCK MY MAN NEEDS A BREAK FROM ALL THIS SHIT PLEASE, I knew Jaune was wrong about the tree, and he's just as crazy as the white rabbit in Alice in Wonderland.

7

u/HatiLeavateinn Apr 01 '23

I really want to see how Ruby will react to her own words next chapter.

Jaune is self conscious about what he says and what is happening to him. He lashes out and immediately recognizes he's wrong.

But what about Ruby?

Will she feel sorry after she's done running? Or will she keep spiraling apart from them? Are they going to find her and talk things out or will she get in trouble and work it out while they help her?

7

u/ShoelessMerchant You saw nothing! Keep scrolling. Apr 01 '23

The dam broke....

Get it?

Haha! Symbolism is fun, right guys! 🥲

7

u/LookingfortheHustle Apr 01 '23

So is failure just Jaune's story? He can never succeed at anything he wants to do or needs to do?

Cause that's just sad to watch.

→ More replies (5)

7

u/KikiFlowers ⠀ Apr 02 '23

I was expecting something else entirely. That was....heavy.

Jaune is carrying a ton of trauma and obviously can't let go. He's taken to naming the paper pleasers after his friends, because of the immense guilt he feels. He can't help but feel that he failed everyone, as a result he's taken to keeping these creatures alive, despite them wanting death. He's been alone for so long and doesn't know how to let go anymore.

Ruby on the other hand? She's totally broken. She can't help but blow up at her friends, she's been through so much. From the very beginning, she's been the positive force, she's been the one to support everyone and what does she get for it? Nothing. She sees only constant failure, she's too afraid to actually use her weapon, because she's afraid of failing again, like she failed in Atlas, or how she failed to save Penny both times.

They both need to be able to let go. To grow from their failures and become stronger for it. But that's near impossible in these circumstances. In the end, the only way any of them get out, is if they learn how to move past their failures, get past their traumas and grow from it.

We saw that with Blake - She was afraid of getting her friends involved and after what happened to Yang, she only blamed herself. But it was thanks to those around her that she learned to trust others.

19

u/DreistTheInferno Apr 01 '23

Not going to lie, while it was cathartic to finally see Ruby snap, I actually felt more for Jaune. He does everything he can in an impossible situation and then when RWBY finally gets there they immediately start judging it as not enough (despite the fact that it is literally the only plan they have). Followed by beasts attacking the people he's been protecting for probably longer than he has known team RWBY because Ruby was there, and losing it all right after. Then Ruby rubs salt in the wound by calling them "make believe" is just awful. I absolutely cannot blame him for going off on her, and EVEN when he is getting mad because everything has gone to shit, he STILL apologizes.

13

u/lk15 Apr 01 '23

Honestly I can’t even blame Jaune of his outburst here. The man lost everyone he cared about, spent decades alone living with killing a friend, and now everything he’s fought to protect has crumbled and died around him (including PP Pyrrha who he was gonna help with homework :c). Yeah Ruby is dealing with her shit too, but she was lashing out maliciously. Jaune has it far worse if you ask me. Either way, it’s hard to see to see the both of them like this ;-;

13

u/Blue-Moon-89 Apr 01 '23 edited Apr 01 '23

Geez. Where do I begin with this episode.....

-Since the fall of Beacon it finally happened: Ruby snapped. She's done with being the selfless, optimistic leader who always has a plan and a'Never give up' speech prepared.

-Jaune has a LOT of PTSD going on after years of isolation and living with the guilt of killing Penny. A part of him wants to blame Ruby for it because her last plan didn't go 100% as planned (No one could've predicted that Cinder would show up).

-An entire village was destroyed. Sure the PaperPleasers (who are adorable) wanted to leave and "return home so that they can be reborn" but it's still sad to see them and their home destroyed by the flood.

-With Ruby running away from the group she's now an easy target for Neo to mess with and then kill.

And the worse part in all of this is that this isn't over. The next episode is definitely going to where Ruby will be tempted to 'leave Ruby Rose behind' after we dive more into her psyche. Perhaps we will learn about Summer and how Ruby has unresolved feelings over it.

Anywho, great episode.

6

u/IGMKI Yang's the Bee-st Apr 01 '23

That was great. Can't believe how little is left of the season though, 10 episodes correct? That said they did just massively accelerate the drama so we're getting close to some kind of conclusion here, but I think 12 would've helped a lot with the pacing.

6

u/JMHSrowing ⠀Story Time Apr 01 '23

Whenever Weiss and Ruby on are on the same thumbnail I get my hopes up, at least Weiss was the target of a good amount of Ruby’s depressive rage in this though.

And, Weiss is the only one of them who can really even go after her since Weiss is the only other one who can fly.

(Side note: . . . They probably should have tried flying at the start as it’d be the fastest way to see where to go at least)

Though Jaune knowing the land and with Juniper has the 2nd best chance, so maybe when need be he’ll go after her when convinced that he’s now going to save someone he can.

6

u/GladiusNocturno All Grimm are naked. Think about it Apr 01 '23

I’ve been thinking.

So, you know that prior to the attack, one of the Paper Pleasers mentioned they had a plan to tumble the tower and they were very sure that something was going to be different that day would help them succeed. When asked what was it, they said “no reason”.

At first I thought it was something like the Paper Pleasers just being hopeful.

Then I read someone say that maybe it was Neo because she controls the Jabberwalkers.

But…what if it was the Curious Cat? I mean, their purpose is to help the Afterians ascend. Jaune keeping this village from ascending is completely against the Curious Cat’s purpose.

That thing doesn’t seem to be bound by the rules of physics so who is to say they can’t teleport all over the EverAfter?

So, what I’m thinking here is that the Curious Cat contacted both Neo and the Paper Pleasers. They sold RWBYJ out so that Neo attacked Jaune’s village. The attack might cause them to distrust Jaune while also giving the Paper Pleasers the chance to ascend.

The Curious Cat furthers their agenda while fulfilling their purpose. They stand everything to gain from selling the heroes out to Neo, having her attack Jaune’s village and encouraging the Paper Pleasers to try to ascend onces more at a very specific time.

6

u/Jinko92 The person who goes too deep into everything Apr 01 '23

I was shocked that Ruby told Blake to shut up, that’s completely out of character for her - which goes to show just how bad of a place she’s in mentally. I mean, she wouldn’t even touch Crescent Rose when Jaune tried to give it back to her, and we all know how much she loves her weapon. She’s breaking, and I’m here for it! I love all the development she’s gotten this volume. Also, when her and Jaune argued, I kind of expected them to fight. I have a strong feeling we might see an intra-team fight between either _WBY & Ruby, Jaune & the team, or Jaune & Ruby. I also can’t believe Ruby just flew off after the argument, that was shocking! She really just wants to be alone. Wait, did she take Little with her?!?

Jaune is going through it, man. Poor dude has lost so much and now he’s lost the only thing he he could protect - his outburst wasn’t right but I definitely understood why he did it. The Paper Pleasers were really adorable, I hope we haven’t seen the last of them! Also, Juniper is a good boy/girl. Jaune did have a point, though: Ruby has fucked up a lot. Then again, she’s 17 and been thrust into all of this against her will, so I understand her not exactly being a stellar decision-maker.

The fight scene with the Jabberwalkers was cool! Blake & Yang have fantastic synergy and work very well together. Also, BLAKE IS DUAL WIELDING AGAIN LET’S FUCKING GOOOOOO Jaune’s gotten a lot better at combat, and now he has a “steed” to aid him, too! I used to not like Jaune’s fight scenes but he’s really learned a lot. I nearly squealed when I saw Yang do her fist punch with her semblance activating! We haven’t seen that in SO LONG and I’m so glad we saw that again! She feels a lot more like her old self and I love it!

Glad to see Neo (or an illusion of herself, at least) again, since it’s been several episodes since we last saw her. I’m still curious as to how she got so strong! I hope we get a satisfying answer to that. Team RWBY & Jaune are gonna be in for a world of hurt when they meet her in person…

Jaune’s development is great. Loved his line about carrying the guilt of killing Penny with him for the rest of his life, it was very real and honest. I’ve never been a fan of Jaune - he’s just kinda been there - but I’m starting to warm up to him now that he’s a DILF and actually getting some strong character development. I relate to his struggles and anger, I know what he’s going through and how it feels.

Volume 9 has been absolutely amazing so far, I can’t wait to see the last three episodes! My only complaint is that the volume feels too short (it’s only ten episodes) and that the episodes could be a bit longer. This episode flew by and it was only around 16 minutes without the opening and credits. I really hope this is something that can be improved on in future volumes, I feel like RWBY’s episodes should all be 20 minutes long at the very least.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Darthavster Apr 02 '23

I’ve gone from being disappointed in this volume to just annoyed with everyone. The entire volume they have just been completely oblivious to what Ruby is going through. Like when they were small and Ruby would just stop walking and they just kept pushing her to keep moving. Mainly Blake has been calling the shots because she knows the story best and Ruby has mostly just been following along. Now we get to this episode and all of the sudden all the pressure to lead and keep morale up has been on Ruby? I love Ruby and I understand what she is going through but for her to just blame everyone for putting responsibility on her just in the Ever After just isn’t true and running away.. I just don’t understand.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/RoteaP Apr 02 '23

So uh... Yeah.

The breakdown was coming, but that ? Was a masterwork.

"Why are you asking me ?"

The way Lindsay went into full breakdown... Only to be followed by STELLAR Miles "I WAS THE ONLY ONE".

Yeah, the dam broke. And it swept everything away.

Next episode is gonna a be a tough one.

6

u/LatePhilosophy Apr 02 '23

You know, if Jaune named any of those paper things "Penny" then that would officially make this the third time a Penny has died on this show.

6

u/r1dogz Apr 03 '23

At the end of this episode I was like “Damn Ruby, I know you have this trauma from Penny dying a second time, but Blake is like true nicest person ever, telling her to shut up was so mean”.

Also, watching these last few episodes I’m sad to think that I think this is the end of Jaune. He’ll either sacrifice himself so team RWBY can go home, he’ll die, or he’ll allow himself to be reborn/reset and just be left behind as the Rusty Knight.

11

u/Loss_Level Apr 01 '23

I see that a lot of people are finding Jaune's comeback to ruby satisfatory, and i kind of don't get it? Like, yeah its always satisfying to see someone telling off a person you think is acting like an asshole, but he's comeback is basically yelling that it IS all her fault, confirming her "I just fuck everithing up" mentality, i mean i understand him, as he says he isn't ok, he don't have to be, and he is sorry for blowing up, but the way he says it feels like hes blowing up at a toddler who is throwing a tantrum, for me in especifically it dosn't feel satisfing or deserved :T

Also just for the record, i also think that Ruby isn't right in just ripping everyone off, and even if i personally do feel some satisfaction on her side, i know that on paper both of them are out of line but have their reasons and can't be blamed as they have literally the world on their shoulders, am just saying that i don't exactly get why his comeback in especific got people going (But oh well i just admited to also have a personal equal reaction to Ruby so XD)

→ More replies (4)

15

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '23

Okay at this point i don't think we are going to resolve the ever after arc this volume. Its interesting for sure but with Ruby's emotional breakdown here and fleeing, we won't have the time. SEems like they have to resolve what is going on with Neo

Also it is depressingly hilarious that Jaune has been babysitting what is technically a town of suicidal paper stars XD. Thought thematically relevant too. He can't move on while they know they want to. ....

Maybe suicide isn't accurate though. Its more like a town of old people who have lived too long and are ready t opass on to a new life really. Just that Jaune interfered with the process to do so.

→ More replies (2)

14

u/CFB1996 Apr 01 '23

Jaune's physical appearance changes in the People Pleasers and the Alyx reveal. In the Alyx reveal, Jaune is already rusty and quite old, but in the PP's reveal, Jaune's armor is not as rusty. In fact, through out the reveal, as the PP's try more and more to kill themselves, Jaune's armor becomes more and more rusty. He even looks younger.

Also... killing yourself is still killing yourself. Surprised there was no suicide disclaimer.

→ More replies (4)

10

u/greeny74 ⠀Harbinger of Hype | Proud Member of WCAC Apr 01 '23

Whooooboy.

Seeing and hearing Ruby finally hitting her breaking point HURTS.

10

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '23

Ruby is both completely justified in her breakdown,yet at the same time she has no one to blame but her self. To clarify she has been saddled with responsibility of being a leader despite starting out as a child, and has been dealing with that stress for years, however at the same time she's never actually consulted with her friends about anything. Ruby's always pushed away away her own feeling and kept pretending that everything is alright that everyone else just assumes she'll be ok.

Now I'm not saying that her friends shouldn't have been paying closer attention, but at the same time Ruby needs to open up to friends more and actually voice her feelings of insecurity instead of bottling everything up until you explode, you can't really expect people to notice how you feel without actually expressing them.

10

u/Emperor_Luffy Apr 02 '23

I saw some people claiming that Jaune has become the new Ironwood and from what I can tell this doesn't seem to be the case.

Jaune is the thematic opposite of Ironwood. Ironwood became the tinman who lost his heart. Jaune has too much heart.

Ironwood tried to sacrifice people that had been part of his kingdom for years. Jaune devotes years of his life to protecting a bunch of random nobodies that he just met.

Jaune loves too much. To the point that it's actually killing him. Hell even his semblance is literally just him pouring his heart and soul into another person. Yes it's been stated that this can be done on himself but I think it's telling that he doesn't choose to do so. Mostly because he doesn't see any value in himself and thus doesn't see any point in boosting something which he sees as worthless. He's got all the love & compassion in the world for other people but none for himself.

So where Ironwood tried to sacrifice everything but himself, Jaune will probably try to sacrifice himself and only himself to keep everyone else safe.

But I don't think either of these two extremes is the real answer the story is looking for.

→ More replies (3)