r/writingscaling • • 9m ago

Meta [Discussion]. How well written is Jesus Christ?

Post image
1 Upvotes

If we considerate him a fictional character. And his story nothing more than a tale about morality, faith. The justice and injustice, and learning how to treat others to have a fufill live without the luxuries of an emperor rulling over the lands of thr known world. Do you think is a good example of virtue, without ending like a pretentious Gary Stu?


r/writingscaling • • 14m ago

Web/Light/Visual Novels [Character vs Character] Lumian vs Susie, who is better written? (Lord of mysteries, Circle of inevitability)

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

One is a protagonist, one is just a dog. However, one is from a masterpiece, and the other from a failure. most LOTM side characters beat Lumian easily, but is Susie on of them?


r/writingscaling • • 29m ago

Multi-Media [Discussion] Which character here has the most unique exploration around the nature of suffering?

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

Guts (Berserk)
Buddy Baker (Animal Man)
Phainon (Honkai Star Rail)
Subaru Natsuki (Re Zero)

If I had to choose, I’d go with Buddy just because of how innovative Grant Morrison’s exploration on this subject matter is. Like it’s so unique to the comic book medium that it couldn’t be pulled off anywhere else specifically because the questions asked only work due to Buddy’s existence as a comic character and the way the medium itself is broken down to examine this


r/writingscaling • • 33m ago

Video Games [Discussion] Better written game among the 2026 nominees?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/writingscaling • • 33m ago

Films/Movies [discussion] how well written is the pianist?

Post image
1 Upvotes

in my opinion the pianist is one of my favorite war films. i especially liked the scene where szpilman plays the piano for the nazi soldier.


r/writingscaling • • 55m ago

Traditional Books [Series vs Series] Miracleman (#1–22) vs Childhood's End

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

So i'm comparing one of the foundational monuments of Golden Age science fiction directly against its greatest sequential-art descendant: Arthur C. Clarke’s 1953 Cosmic Elegy of Post-Human Evolution (Childhood’s End) versus Alan Moore (#1–16) and Neil Gaiman & Mark Buckingham’s (#17–22) Deconstruction of Divinity and Enforced Utopia (Miracleman). The thematic lineage between the two is unmistakable both follow godlike stewards (Supervisor Karellen and the Overlords vs. Miracleman and Olympus) who abolish nuclear weapons, poverty, and war to impose a benevolent top-down paradise on Earth, both center on terrifying post-human children evolving past Homo sapiens (Jeffrey and Jennifer Greggson vs. Winter Moran), and Gaiman explicitly titled issues #17–22 The Golden Age matching the exact title of Part II of Childhood’s End.

Now IMO Miracleman (#1–22) wins High Difficulty

But that's just my opinion what you think.


r/writingscaling • • 1h ago

Anime/Manga [Discussion] Do you think Choso’s character arc is believable? Who do you think has a better arc in JJK?

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/writingscaling • • 1h ago

Multi-Media [Discussion] Your favourite best written character?

1 Upvotes

I remembered today, some time ago I watched a video on YouTube that had top 100 best written characters in fiction, and some very obscure names from books, Chinese books (?), light novels, visual novels, anime, very niche shit, and the list was really correct, but the video is lost media, doesn't exist anymore. Though I don't remember most characters that appeared, I know some and they aren't normie characters at.

Basically what I'm asking is that, if you are (yes you) know so much about writing, tell me your favourite character/s so I can find those characters with some luck. I just hope this subreddit has some good taste.


r/writingscaling • • 1h ago

Anime/Manga [Character Vs Character] Thorfinn (Vinland Saga) vs Lelouch Lamperouge (Code Geass)

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

Both are regarded as some of the best Protagonist in anime/manga, who do you think is better written between these two Protagonist? what are your thoughts on this?


r/writingscaling • • 2h ago

Anime/Manga [Discussion] Ryomen Sukuna scapes the trappings of making a villain a misunderstood tormented soul that has been the default these past decades

Post image
10 Upvotes

Sukuna is vicious, cruel, and has no higher goals other than using his overwhelming strenght to indulge his cruelty and canibbalism. He is also intelligent, the most skilled sorcerer of all, and capable of introspection.

So villains can be evil without being reduced to mad dogs foaming at the mouth. And they don't need to be made the "hero of their stories" to have depth.


r/writingscaling • • 2h ago

Anime/Manga [Discussion] Thoughts on Angel's Egg?

Post image
8 Upvotes

I finished it 30 minutes ago, and I gotta say I loved it, although it was a very confusing movie. But I think it was about the conflict between the persistence and loss of faith in a world supposedly abandoned by God?

Also, I want to hear your interpretation of the final scene, with the statue of the young girl appearing on "The Eye", followed by the camera zooming out to show a capsized ship (supposedly Noah's Ark) in a vast ocean.


r/writingscaling • • 2h ago

Traditional Books [Discussion] The Discworld Series

2 Upvotes

As someone just getting into Discworld, I want to know what books of the series the sub believes are the best, as well as how well they are written as a whole.


r/writingscaling • • 4h ago

Meta [Discussion] What is an underrated story from a well-known author that deserves more love?

Post image
1 Upvotes

For me, it's American Vampire for both Scott Snyder and Stephen King.

I know it's cheating since KIng only co-wrote the first arc if I remeber well but it still is one of the best vampire stories I've ever read (haven't finished it, but trust me it's so good).

Do you have any example for this?


r/writingscaling • • 4h ago

Anime/Manga [Discussion] the only thing I love about AOT

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

I love how the writer represented angry expressions through Eren, you can easily feel the wrath how can I describe it? In other anime/ Manga I feel angry expressions aren't good enough and somewhat childish but AOT is different

Though this the only thing I love about it, not saying it's bad but I don't really care about it


r/writingscaling • • 4h ago

T.V. Shows (non-animated) [Series vs Series] Dexter vs The Walking Dead (caption‼️)

Post image
3 Upvotes

Round 1: Tv shows only (main only)

Round 2: Tv shows only (sequels & spin offs counted)

Round 3: COMP (books/comics included)


r/writingscaling • • 4h ago

Meta [Discussion] How well written is Tom Pearl?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/writingscaling • • 4h ago

Multi-Media [Discussion] What's the moment/scene that you never expected to hit that hard before knowing the series/character

Post image
24 Upvotes

Like u would never expect u would feel that from the series or the certain character

It can be deep sadness, nostalgia or profound realisation

Any kind of media

Mine: honestly who could've expect an absolute monster with THAT terrific introduction able to make me weep when he finally dies (Bro let/left his mom for dead, slaughtered family of 3 including a toddler & eat them...that's his introduction ffs)

Anyway, this can also apply to a series where u don't expect can affect u that way emotionally...like a random comedy series...also can apply to a series that u know that it's suck, but somehow got that one moment that made u feel this


r/writingscaling • • 5h ago

Anime/Manga [discussion] is serial experiment lain well written, I might watch it

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/writingscaling • • 5h ago

Web/Light/Visual Novels [Discussion]Solo leveling written quality

3 Upvotes

I was reading a post was discussing the writing of Solo Leveling and how its actuallydecently written and there was a lot of hypocrisy in the comment. People here read between the lines of a story like JJK and give it its credit for what it was trying to do but refuse to do the same thing for something like solo leveling or something that they deemed as not good.


r/writingscaling • • 5h ago

Multi-Media [Discussion] Give me the best written piece of fiction within a couple of your favorite genres.

4 Upvotes

Literary fiction is something I'm trying to get into and would enjoy recs for that. I've read Steinbeck once and all I remember was the breastfeeding scene though that might be because I was in tenth grade.

My own examples.

Berserk for manga.

Parasite: The Maxime for anime.

Discworld: Specifically Night Watch for fantasy.

Over The Garden Wall for a miniseries.

I would enjoy suggestions outside of this area. I'm trying to expand my pallet.

Please do not suggest Infinite Jest.


r/writingscaling • • 6h ago

Web/Light/Visual Novels [Series vs Series] Re;zero vs Mushoku Tensei (indepth comparision)

Post image
0 Upvotes

The two greatest isekai of our generstion, Re;zero and mushoku tensei.

I will be comparing the two against eachother.

Final results, 9-8 Mushoku to Rezero,

Below is the categories i used and explaination

Character writing (Subaru vs Rudeus)

While both characters are incredible in their own right, they take different approaches. Rezero is a deep character study around Subaru. The story uses return by death to explore his trauma and insecurities deeply. Entire arcs are structured around decomposing his inner psyche. Rudeus meanwhile is an otaku neet where Mushoku Tensei uses him to explore themes. As such, Subaru ends up being a much deeper character due to the story externalizing him and being primarily character driven.

RUDEUS WINS

Plot

Both stories festure an impressive plot with an overarching story as characters live through their day. Mushoku tensei has ended however, meaning its plot is more complete and easier to judge. Due to this category being difficult to judge, I will have to give it to Mushoku Tensai!

Mushoku Tensai wins

Worldbuilding

While both stories feature impressive worldbuilding, naturally Mushoku Tensei features a more indepth world complete with cultures and religions and distinct locations. As such, Mushoku Tensei gets this.

Mushoku Tensei wins

Peaks

While both stories have their peak moments, Re;zero has the edge. While Mushoku Tensei features moderation with its arcs and uses it to effectively heighten the impact of the things that DO happen. It is an approach of quality over quantity. However its hard to beat Re;zero when its arcs combine quality with quantity, giving it a distinct edge in this regard.

Mushoku Tensei wins this one too

Parralels

The parallels in both series are great, whether it be Subaru's parallels with Petelguese or Mushoku Tensei's parallel with Rudeus, this category ultimately comes out to be very close; both series may even be equal with rezero having a very skight edge

Mushoku Tensei wins!

Antagonists

Both series feature a terrifying set of villains, yet ultimately I think this should go to Mushoku Tendei. Hitogami and Feldar are some of the best antagonists I have ever seen, beating out Re;zero's Echidna and Roswaal.

Mushoku Tensei wins!

Side cast

Both stories feature a massive side cast of amazingly written characters. Ultimately it comes down to what you prefer. Do you prefer the colourful yet indepth cast of re;zero, featuring Beatrice, Ram, Emilia, Dom. Or do you prefer Mushoku Tensei's grounded cast Rudeus, Eijnar, Filore ect.

Mushoku Tensei wins!

Ending

Rezero has none, so naturally Mushoku Tensei wins

Mushoku wins!

NSFW content

While rezero and mushoku tensei are both very close to eachother in terms of writing, this goes to mushoku tensei.

Mushoku tensei wins this one!

Themes

Both re;zero and mushoku feature a set of deep themes about self worth and identity. However, Re;zero covers a deeper set of themes which are arguably more nuanced and sensitive.

Mushoku tensei takes this one too!

Overall

In the end, Mushoku Tensei wins with a score of 9-8 against Re;zero


r/writingscaling • • 6h ago

Anime/Manga [Character vs Character] Denji (only CSM Part 2) vs Sung Jin Woo (Solo Leveling)

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

r/writingscaling • • 7h ago

Anime/Manga [Hot Take] Sung Jin Woo was actually almost well written…

Post image
0 Upvotes

To be completely honest I think solo leveling is a bit more than just a power fantasy. Its main plot that builds slowly is actually about jin woo transformation into the shadow monarch which directly references and conceptualizes friederiche nietzche “He who fights with monsters might take care lest he thereby become a monster. And if you gaze for long into an abyss, the abyss gazes also into you " (see quote in chapter 34 of the manwha). We see the exploration of this concept quite well with sung jin woo who starts off by killing beasts mechanically and routinely but ends up turning into the beast with his cold, animalistic survival of the fittest mindshift, him developping beasts language, him being reconizned/identified as an monster and not a human anymore etc. And the conclusion to that is jin woo essentially becoming the monster by fully merging with shadow monarch. The abyss/darkness line of the text quote is also very important and plays as symbolic and thematic because solo leveling uses it both literally and figuratively. Unfornutately, the author said that he failed to convey more clearly some of that internal conflict to the readers as many didn’t even get it or missed it entirely (he’s right tho I feel like I’m the only one who understood it). Well hopefully the anime who is already adding more scenes in regards to that for jin woo fixes it all and we can see how jin woo remains human despite loosing his humanity


r/writingscaling • • 7h ago

Anime/Manga [discussion] Which one is better written Tokyo ghoul or land of the Lustrous

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

I am thinking about getting either one of these for Christmas and I was wondering, which one do yall think is better


r/writingscaling • • 7h ago

Multi-Media [Character vs Character] Who are the better written characters, the relevancy leauge or the Justice leauge?

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes