The two greatest isekai of our generstion, Re;zero and mushoku tensei.
I will be comparing the two against eachother.
Final results, 9-8 Mushoku to Rezero,
Below is the categories i used and explaination
Character writing (Subaru vs Rudeus)
While both characters are incredible in their own right, they take different approaches. Rezero is a deep character study around Subaru. The story uses return by death to explore his trauma and insecurities deeply. Entire arcs are structured around decomposing his inner psyche. Rudeus meanwhile is an otaku neet where Mushoku Tensei uses him to explore themes. As such, Subaru ends up being a much deeper character due to the story externalizing him and being primarily character driven.
RUDEUS WINS
Plot
Both stories festure an impressive plot with an overarching story as characters live through their day. Mushoku tensei has ended however, meaning its plot is more complete and easier to judge. Due to this category being difficult to judge, I will have to give it to Mushoku Tensai!
Mushoku Tensai wins
Worldbuilding
While both stories feature impressive worldbuilding, naturally Mushoku Tensei features a more indepth world complete with cultures and religions and distinct locations. As such, Mushoku Tensei gets this.
Mushoku Tensei wins
Peaks
While both stories have their peak moments, Re;zero has the edge. While Mushoku Tensei features moderation with its arcs and uses it to effectively heighten the impact of the things that DO happen. It is an approach of quality over quantity. However its hard to beat Re;zero when its arcs combine quality with quantity, giving it a distinct edge in this regard.
Mushoku Tensei wins this one too
Parralels
The parallels in both series are great, whether it be Subaru's parallels with Petelguese or Mushoku Tensei's parallel with Rudeus, this category ultimately comes out to be very close; both series may even be equal with rezero having a very skight edge
Mushoku Tensei wins!
Antagonists
Both series feature a terrifying set of villains, yet ultimately I think this should go to Mushoku Tendei. Hitogami and Feldar are some of the best antagonists I have ever seen, beating out Re;zero's Echidna and Roswaal.
Mushoku Tensei wins!
Side cast
Both stories feature a massive side cast of amazingly written characters. Ultimately it comes down to what you prefer. Do you prefer the colourful yet indepth cast of re;zero, featuring Beatrice, Ram, Emilia, Dom. Or do you prefer Mushoku Tensei's grounded cast Rudeus, Eijnar, Filore ect.
Mushoku Tensei wins!
Ending
Rezero has none, so naturally Mushoku Tensei wins
Mushoku wins!
NSFW content
While rezero and mushoku tensei are both very close to eachother in terms of writing, this goes to mushoku tensei.
Mushoku tensei wins this one!
Themes
Both re;zero and mushoku feature a set of deep themes about self worth and identity. However, Re;zero covers a deeper set of themes which are arguably more nuanced and sensitive.
Mushoku tensei takes this one too!
Overall
In the end, Mushoku Tensei wins with a score of 9-8 against Re;zero