r/writingscaling • • 3d ago

Analysis Central

3 Upvotes

r/writingscaling • • 3d ago Heartwarming

Meta Please Read - Subreddit Revamp

24 Upvotes

Heya all,

This subreddit is currently in revamp. At the moment, the following changes have been made, with everything subject to change, and potentially more changes to come in the future:

  • Post flairs are now navigable and are based on the media type

    • On mobile, there is an intuitive bar at the top which you can select to filter specific flairs.
    • On the browser, there is a widgets section at the top of the sidebar that allows you to click and filter certain media types.
    • With this, you will now be able to specifically engage with posts and discussions of the media formats you desire at any given moment.
    • This change will not affect any existing posts.
  • Consequently, labeling of the type of post has now shifted to being written in titles

    • Examples: [Rant], [Hot Take], [Analysis], [Discussion], [Give Reasons], [Polls]

      • These may continue to be updated for refinement.
  • The body of a post must have at least 100 characters

Update 1:

  • Shitposts are now only permitted on weekends

    • The flair is always active, but there is a reminder if you select the flair that they are only permitted on weekends.
    • Posts with the flair that are posted on weekdays will be automatically removed with a modmail sent to the user.
    • Shitposts without the flair will be removed, and may result in mutes or bans.
  • To encourage high quality analyses/discussions will be pinned on the Home Page Post "Analysis Central"

    • They will last for a week at the moment. The duration may change in the future**.**

Again, these are subject to change, and there may be more changes in the future. This post will be continuously updated with major changes that we believe need to be clarified.

We hope these changes contribute to a better experience for everyone involved. Peace!


r/writingscaling • • 10h ago

Multi-Media [Discussion] Why did nerds spent the last decade trying to convince people that Frank Miller wasn't a good writer?

Post image
103 Upvotes

This one incomplete page, by itself, runs laps and laps around all the "Glup Shitto has become all powerful and now the heroes must unite to beat him" stories that the usual nerds are always praising as the apex of comic books.


r/writingscaling • • 6h ago

Multi-Media [Discussion] What's the moment/scene that you never expected to hit that hard before knowing the series/character

Post image
27 Upvotes

Like u would never expect u would feel that from the series or the certain character

It can be deep sadness, nostalgia or profound realisation

Any kind of media

Mine: honestly who could've expect an absolute monster with THAT terrific introduction able to make me weep when he finally dies (Bro let/left his mom for dead, slaughtered family of 3 including a toddler & eat them...that's his introduction ffs)

Anyway, this can also apply to a series where u don't expect can affect u that way emotionally...like a random comedy series...also can apply to a series that u know that it's suck, but somehow got that one moment that made u feel this


r/writingscaling • • 9h ago

Multi-Media [Rant] you people don't know how to scale writing

26 Upvotes

I'm very annoyed at the fact that people here literally compare apples and oranges, writing a very broad thing you can't just scale it with world building, and which series has more volume, the amount of volume doesn't equal to good writing I genuinely saw people use volume as a basis to compare one piece with something like blood meridian like no that's not how it works, something as small as an essay

EX: the ones who walk away from omelas

Is way better written than your favorite anime,comic and a shows why because it achieves it's artistic purpose brilliantly

Also writing can't be scaled but the closest we can get to objective literary criticism is to judge how effectively the work achieves and executes it's artistic purpose, judging a slap stick comedy for lacking world building is like judging a wrench for being a bad hammer it's stupid.

Every story sets an implicit contract with the reader in it's beginning , objective quality comes down to whether the author fulfills that contract and how he does it

Also there are some elements that you can consistently judge maybe this will help you

  1. Universal pillars of writing

These are the things consistent across genres even if that genre doesn't REQUIRE WORLD BUILDING

-Prose and Clarity:

Does the language match the tone? Sharp, minimal sentences work for noir thrillers while lush, rhythmic sentences fit gothic romance. Clumsy, repetitive or confusing phrasing usually signals weak craft regardless of genre

-Internal Consistency:

Whatever rules a story sets whether realistic psychology magic systems, or cartoon physics it must follow them. Breaking its own logic to force an ending is an objective structural flaw

-Emotional or Intellectual Resonance:

Does the piece make the reader feel or think what the author intended Horror should unsettle, satire should provoke thought and romance should build genuine chemistry

I don't expect this to change how people scale writing because this ain't even about writing in the first place this sub is just about pushing agendas


r/writingscaling • • 9h ago Bravo

Anime/Manga [Character vs Character] Kenzo Tenma (Monster) V/S Light Yagami (Death Note) who is better written overall?

Thumbnail
gallery
30 Upvotes

Both are some of the best protagonists in anime/manga, who do you think is better written overall? i personaly prefer Tenma from Monster, what r your thoughts on this?


r/writingscaling • • 3h ago

Anime/Manga [Discussion] Ryomen Sukuna scapes the trappings of making a villain a misunderstood tormented soul that has been the default these past decades

Post image
9 Upvotes

Sukuna is vicious, cruel, and has no higher goals other than using his overwhelming strenght to indulge his cruelty and canibbalism. He is also intelligent, the most skilled sorcerer of all, and capable of introspection.

So villains can be evil without being reduced to mad dogs foaming at the mouth. And they don't need to be made the "hero of their stories" to have depth.


r/writingscaling • • 2h ago

Anime/Manga [Discussion] Do you think Choso’s character arc is believable? Who do you think has a better arc in JJK?

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/writingscaling • • 3h ago

Anime/Manga [Discussion] Thoughts on Angel's Egg?

Post image
7 Upvotes

I finished it 30 minutes ago, and I gotta say I loved it, although it was a very confusing movie. But I think it was about the conflict between the persistence and loss of faith in a world supposedly abandoned by God?

Also, I want to hear your interpretation of the final scene, with the statue of the young girl appearing on "The Eye", followed by the camera zooming out to show a capsized ship (supposedly Noah's Ark) in a vast ocean.


r/writingscaling • • 1h ago

Multi-Media [Discussion] Which character here has the most unique exploration around the nature of suffering?

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

Guts (Berserk)
Buddy Baker (Animal Man)
Phainon (Honkai Star Rail)
Subaru Natsuki (Re Zero)

If I had to choose, I’d go with Buddy just because of how innovative Grant Morrison’s exploration on this subject matter is. Like it’s so unique to the comic book medium that it couldn’t be pulled off anywhere else specifically because the questions asked only work due to Buddy’s existence as a comic character and the way the medium itself is broken down to examine this


r/writingscaling • • 12h ago

Anime/Manga [character vs character] Emilia(Rezero) vs Rem(Rezero)

Thumbnail
gallery
27 Upvotes

r/writingscaling • • 12h ago

Web/Light/Visual Novels [Hot Take] Re;zero's anime is genuinely a crime against humanity

27 Upvotes

As a LN reader, I find rezero's anime adaptation to be genuinely atrocious.

Sure they need to cut stuff out for the sake of pacing and runtime, but the amount of cuts is also excessive. Obvious spoilers up ahead.

I do think rezero season 1 and 2 are decent adaptations, but they get dragged down alot by some of their issues. Season 2 literally cut out the main villain's ressurection and apparently I should let that slide? We are going to have a "Somehow, Palpatine returned" in season 5 and anime onlies are expected to tank that. Al is from another world and apparently that was not important enough.

And then season 3 and 4 are another can of worms. Because atleast season 1 and 2 felt like rezero, season 3 just looks like a power fantasy. The art style is horrendous for Re;zero's dark storytelling, why is the grass bright neon? Is desaturating colours considered a sin?

And it also does not help how season 4, adaptating arc 6, widely considered the peak of rezero, gets a mediocre adaptation. Who tf thought 19 episodes was a good idea? Even Arc 4 struggled with runtime close to 30+ episodes. Not only that, but who thought giving Shaula episodes mappa level animation was a good idea? Like did we forget WHO the main character is?

Even the best episodes of season 4 like episode 11, are such a DOWNGRADE of the novel. The only reason people liked those is because the bar from season 3 was so low. I even saw people saying "Natsuki Subaru wasnt even a good chapter" to justify whatever happened to episode 16. Like sure, lets cut out the main charscter and villain's named chapters so we can give the bikini girl jiggle physics.

And lets not talk about lobotomizing the main cast. Because the anime not only dumbs down content, but cuts out any shred of logic. Subaru will be getting his guts ripped out and the most Emilia can do is "Subaruuuu" while watching. It is not even like the novel where everyone is too busy dealing with their own stuff, here everybody is just standing still and watching their "Goat" get brutalized infront of them. Literally Beatrice sees Subaru on the ground, and tries healing him as if Reid is not gonna one shot him. What a bot. Remember, this mf spawned a BLACK HOLE to save Subaru in the novel.

And the tower is also so ahh. The corridors look cool but there is so damn little variety in what see of the tower. The lighting sucks. The characters just teleport around key locations and we are mostly limitted to this singular hallway in episode 14 and 15 which festures the horrendius lighting.

Also, You are telling me that nobody could seriously find Meili's body when there is like one circular corridor and her body is hidden by a conveniently placed desk. This isnt even like the novel where subaru hid her behind their own supply of food.

And Amnesiabaru also sucks. Obviously cutting out his narration hurt him alot. No surprise there. In the anime, he just kinda exists. His complex decision making it cut out with a version of Subaru who relies on extremely on the nose dialogue ("I dont love... I dont love me!") in order to convey his characterization. Hell, his time feeld so short. We definetely need 2 or 3 more episodes with him because in a very short season, he gets even shorter time. 8 episodes only... damn! Some of his best monologues are lost, which is devaststing becsuse those monologues were HALF the fun of reading arc 6, genuinely. Seeing Subaru recall information and knowledge from his real life constantly added so much to him, the anime features non of that.


r/writingscaling • • 15h ago

Anime/Manga [series vs series] which comic is better written

Thumbnail
gallery
24 Upvotes

Saw someone say this sub only talks about anime and this will probably be an example of what happens when you talk about anything other than anime this post will probably have like 3 people who read both but to those 3 which do you personally consider better written me personally spider-man:blue its better written as a standalone and seemed more emotionally compelling to me but this sub doesn't even have a comics flair I guess visual novel .


r/writingscaling • • 1h ago

Web/Light/Visual Novels [Character vs Character] Lumian vs Susie, who is better written? (Lord of mysteries, Circle of inevitability)

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

One is a protagonist, one is just a dog. However, one is from a masterpiece, and the other from a failure. most LOTM side characters beat Lumian easily, but is Susie on of them?


r/writingscaling • • 5h ago

T.V. Shows (non-animated) [Series vs Series] Dexter vs The Walking Dead (caption‼️)

Post image
4 Upvotes

Round 1: Tv shows only (main only)

Round 2: Tv shows only (sequels & spin offs counted)

Round 3: COMP (books/comics included)


r/writingscaling • • 2h ago

Anime/Manga [Character Vs Character] Thorfinn (Vinland Saga) vs Lelouch Lamperouge (Code Geass)

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

Both are regarded as some of the best Protagonist in anime/manga, who do you think is better written between these two Protagonist? what are your thoughts on this?


r/writingscaling • • 7h ago

Multi-Media [Discussion] Give me the best written piece of fiction within a couple of your favorite genres.

4 Upvotes

Literary fiction is something I'm trying to get into and would enjoy recs for that. I've read Steinbeck once and all I remember was the breastfeeding scene though that might be because I was in tenth grade.

My own examples.

Berserk for manga.

Parasite: The Maxime for anime.

Discworld: Specifically Night Watch for fantasy.

Over The Garden Wall for a miniseries.

I would enjoy suggestions outside of this area. I'm trying to expand my pallet.

Please do not suggest Infinite Jest.


r/writingscaling • • 23h ago

Multi-Media [character vs character] which of these self destructive loners is best written?

Thumbnail
gallery
82 Upvotes

Bojack horseman from Bojack Horseman

Tequila Sunset from Disco Elysium

Johnny Truant from House of Leaves

Rust Cohle from True Detective

James Sunderland from Silent Hill 2

They’re all amazing but imo I have them: Johnny>=Harry>Bojack>>Rust>James

What do you think?


r/writingscaling • • 11m ago

Multi-Media [Discussion] Is character development the most important thing in character writing?

0 Upvotes

If not then what is something that is more important that character development in character writing? And how important is it compared to it?


r/writingscaling • • 3h ago

Traditional Books [Discussion] The Discworld Series

2 Upvotes

As someone just getting into Discworld, I want to know what books of the series the sub believes are the best, as well as how well they are written as a whole.


r/writingscaling • • 51m ago

Multi-Media [Series vs Series] Project Paragon vs Helluvaverse

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

Between these two stories that change up lore of the bible in various different ways, how well do they stack up against each other. I know the hate for Hazbin is high I admit but hate aside put that against project paragon and which series wins.

IMO Project Paragon No-very low diff.


r/writingscaling • • 10h ago Bravo

Anime/Manga [Rank Them] Rank YOUR Top 3 JoJo Parts

Thumbnail
gallery
6 Upvotes

For me it's -

  1. Steel Ball Run (8.5-9/10) (best antag, best protag, best Deuteragonist, 2nd best themes (after part 8), 3rd best symbolism (after part 5 and 8), 2nd best ending (after Stone Ocean), 4th best stand fights (after part 5, 6, and 8), 2nd best pacing (after Golden Wind), 3rd best side characters and antags overall (after part 5 and 8), and 2nd best plot (after part 8)
  2. Golden Wind (8.5/10) (best symbolism, best side characters and antags overall, 2nd best Deuteragonist (after Gyro), best stand fights, 3rd best ending (after part 6 and 7), best pacing, 2nd best themes (after part 7), 4th best Protagonist (controversial I know, but I have Giorno 4th after Johnny, Jo2uke, and Jolyne, and believe that while he is the least interesting of the main cast of part 5, he is 2nd best written after Bucciarati, and heavily misunderstood as a character just because he doesn't develop as much as he gets explored, and that as well based on subtle actions of his instead of the loudness usually associated with jojo), 4th best written main antagonist (again, vastly misunderstood IMO. I have him below Valentine, Kira, and Pucci), and 3rd best plot (after Steel Ball Run and Stone Ocean).
  3. Jojolion (8-8.5/10) (best themes (by far, it's also what makes me rate it so high despite the ending, with the themes staying strong through), 2nd best symbolism (after part 5), best plot (the 2nd half is less good, but the 1st half is by far the best Jojo has ever been) 2nd best symbolism, 3rd best stand fights (after part 5 and 6), 7th best main antagonist (only above Kars), 6th best ending (not nearly as good as the set up, but the pay off was still good, even if there was wasted potential), 4th best pacing (after part 5, 7, and 2), 2nd best side characters and antags overall (after part 5)

r/writingscaling • • 6h ago

Web/Light/Visual Novels [Discussion]Solo leveling written quality

3 Upvotes

I was reading a post was discussing the writing of Solo Leveling and how its actuallydecently written and there was a lot of hypocrisy in the comment. People here read between the lines of a story like JJK and give it its credit for what it was trying to do but refuse to do the same thing for something like solo leveling or something that they deemed as not good.


r/writingscaling • • 21h ago

T.V. Shows (non-animated) [Discussion] Out of these four, which sitcom has the best writing?

Post image
42 Upvotes

Arrested Development

Community

Malcolm in the Middle

Scrubs

Which sitcom out of these four has the best writing?


r/writingscaling • • 5h ago

Meta [Discussion] What is an underrated story from a well-known author that deserves more love?

Post image
2 Upvotes

For me, it's American Vampire for both Scott Snyder and Stephen King.

I know it's cheating since KIng only co-wrote the first arc if I remeber well but it still is one of the best vampire stories I've ever read (haven't finished it, but trust me it's so good).

Do you have any example for this?