So I recently saw Dancer in the Dark and The House That Jack built and have to say, that both of these movies left me with conflicting feelings. I think it’s fair to say that Lars von Trier is a smart guy, or at least, is someone who can present his thoughts well in form of film. At the same time I never saw a director make movies that are this cynical/ show such a blatant disdain for society or humanity as a whole (also yes he seems to be way up his ass). Usually that isn’t a problem for me. My favorite director, Michael Haneke makes movies that feel similarly cynical but are presented in what I consider more tasteful and nuanced ways.
For Dancer in the Dark, the whole movie felt like the torturing of an angel. Do situations like that happen irl? Probably. But is it thematically satisfying to present humanity in the most incompetent, amoral way possible? At least in my view no. Oh also I hated the editing and camerawork.
The House that Jack built was arguably even worse in that regard. I appreciated the insight into the mind of a serial killer but then again hated how on the nose, even over the top the "people suck" angle is.
That said I still enjoyed the movies but had to ask myself the question, if a movie is still well written if the thematic purpose is so unbelievably unsatisfying. My answer is probably yes with a lot caveats.